This study compared these two approaches in a particular case (door closure sounds). In this specific case, it was observed that dissimilarities obtained from the two procedures can be different, the more so as sounds are dissimilar and these differences can lead to slightly different perceptual spaces. Nevertheless, a free sorting experiment is a reliable way of reducing the number of stimuli in a large set of sounds. It allows selecting some representative sounds and narrowing the set of sounds while keeping in the subset most of the timbre features. This provides a useful preliminary step to a paired-comparison experiment.