Sixty-four archival biopsies were selected from patients who presented to the surgeon with an indication for biopsy to “rule out” dysplasia. Histologically, all biopsies showed nonspecific atypia that was difficult to discriminate from dysplasia. Twenty-three of the patients progressed to squamous carcinoma and the rest remained benign over five years follow-up. Cases stained with ProExC by IHC methods showed a significant pattern of expression (p = 0.026). The staining was greatest in patients without a history of prior head and neck cancer but was not significant. Our results show that ProExC, used in conjunction with the H&E slide, can enhance the predictive power of a mucosal biopsy in a cohort of patients.