Emerging chemical and genetic evidence suggests that separatebiochemical solutions have evolved tosynthesize the four kno
wn classes of
![](/images/gifchars/beta2.gif)
-lactam antibiotics. Oneof these classes contains clavulanic acid (
1) andafamily of structurally related but antipodal clavam metabolites
2-
5,
7, and
8 which lacka carboxylate at C-3, havea different oxidation state, and exhibit stereochemical features atC-2. Previous
work has demonstrated theincorporation of ornithine/arginine in the identical regiochemicalsense in all of these natural products, and hasestablished the common intermediacy of the monocyclic
![](/images/gifchars/beta2.gif)
-lactamproclavaminic acid (
12) as
well. In this paperthequite advanced bicyclic intermediate clavaminic acid (
14)has been synthesized in doubly
13C-labeled formbypreparative incubation of recombinant clavaminate synthase. Theintact and equally efficient incorporation of
14into valclavam (
7) and 2-(2-hydroxyethyl)clavam(
8), together
with
18O
2-incorporation experiments, has beeninterpretedto define clavaminic acid as the final intermediate shared in thebiosynthesis of clavulanic acid and the antipodalclavams. A mechanistic rationale of this interrelationship and thelate stages of the respective biosyntheses is proposed.