The reliability of the Glasgow Coma Scale: a systematic review

详细信息    查看全文

• 作者：Florence C. M. Reith ; Ruben Van den Brande ; Anneliese Synnot…
• 关键词：Glasgow Coma Scale ; Glasgow Coma Score ; Grading scales ; Reliability ; Reproducibility of results ; Systematic review
• 刊名：Intensive Care Medicine
• 出版年：2016
• 出版时间：January 2016
• 年：2016
• 卷：42
• 期：1
• 页码：3-15
• 全文大小：826 KB
• 参考文献：1.Teasdale G, Jennett B (1974) Assessment of coma and impaired consciousness. A practical scale. Lancet 2:81鈥?4CrossRef PubMed
  2.Koziol J, Hacke W (1990) Multivariate data reduction by principal components with application to neurological scoring instruments. J Neurol 237:461鈥?64CrossRef PubMed
  3.Knaus WA, Draper EA, Wagner DP, Zimmerman JE (1985) APACHE II: a severity of disease classification system. Crit Care Med 13:818鈥?29CrossRef PubMed
  4.Vincent JL, Moreno R, Takala J et al (1996) The SOFA (Sepsis-related Organ Failure Assessment) score to describe organ dysfunction/failure. On behalf of the Working Group on Sepsis-Related Problems of the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine. Intensive Care Med 22:707鈥?10CrossRef PubMed
  5.Le Gall JR, Lemeshow S, Saulnier F (1993) A new Simplified Acute Physiology Score (SAPS II) based on a European/North American multicenter study. JAMA 270:2957鈥?963CrossRef PubMed
  6.Teasdale G, Maas A, Lecky F et al (2014) The Glasgow Coma Scale at 40 years: standing the test of time. Lancet Neurol 13:844鈥?54. doi:10.鈥?016/鈥婼1474-4422(14)70120-6 CrossRef PubMed
  7.Murray GD, Butcher I, McHugh GS et al (2007) Multivariable prognostic analysis in traumatic brain injury: results from the IMPACT study. J Neurotrauma 24:329鈥?37CrossRef PubMed
  8.Mokkink LB, Terwee CB, Patrick DL et al (2010) The COSMIN study reached international consensus on taxonomy, terminology, and definitions of measurement properties for health-related patient-reported outcomes. J Clin Epidemiol 63:737鈥?45. doi:10.鈥?016/鈥媕.鈥媕clinepi.鈥?010.鈥?2.鈥?06 CrossRef PubMed
  9.Fava GA, Tomba E, Sonino N (2012) Clinimetrics: the science of clinical measurements. Int J Clin Pract 66:11鈥?5. doi:10.鈥?111/鈥媕.鈥?742-1241.鈥?011.鈥?2825.鈥媥 CrossRef PubMed
  10.Sun S (2011) Meta-analysis of Cohen鈥檚 kappa. Health Serv Outcomes Res Methodol 11:145鈥?63CrossRef
  11.Baker M (2008) Reviewing the application of the Glasgow Coma Scale: Does it have interrater reliability? Br J Neurosci Nurs 4:342鈥?47. doi:10.鈥?2968/鈥媌jnn.鈥?008.鈥?.鈥?.鈥?0674 CrossRef
  12.Green SM (2011) Cheerio, laddie! Bidding farewell to the Glasgow Coma Scale. Ann Emerg Med 58:427鈥?30CrossRef PubMed
  13.Lowry M (1998) Emergency nursing and the Glasgow Coma Scale. Accid Emerg Nurs 6:143鈥?48CrossRef PubMed
  14.Wijdicks EFM (2006) Clinical scales for comatose patients: the Glasgow Coma Scale in historical context and the new FOUR Score. Rev Neurol Dis 3:109鈥?17PubMed
  15.Zuercher M, Ummenhofer W, Baltussen A, Walder B (2009) The use of Glasgow Coma Scale in injury assessment: a critical review. Brain Inj 23:371鈥?84. doi:10.鈥?080/鈥?269905090292626鈥? CrossRef PubMed
  16.Prasad K (1996) The Glasgow Coma Scale: a critical appraisal of its clinimetric properties. J Clin Epidemiol 49:755鈥?63CrossRef PubMed
  17.Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG (2009) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med 6:e1000097. doi:10.鈥?371/鈥媕ournal.鈥媝med.鈥?000097 PubMedCentral CrossRef PubMed
  18.Landis JR, Koch GG (1977) The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics 33:159鈥?74CrossRef PubMed
  19.Terwee CB, Bot SDM, de Boer MR et al (2007) Quality criteria were proposed for measurement properties of health status questionnaires. J Clin Epidemiol 60:34鈥?2. doi:10.鈥?016/鈥媕.鈥媕clinepi.鈥?006.鈥?3.鈥?12 CrossRef PubMed
  20.Fleiss J (1986) The design and analysis of clinical experiments. Wiley, New York
  21.Teasdale G, Knill-Jones R, van der Sande J (1978) Observer variability in assessing impaired consciousness and coma. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 41:603鈥?10PubMedCentral CrossRef PubMed
  22.Heron R, Davie A, Gillies R, Courtney M (2001) Interrater reliability of the Glasgow Coma Scale scoring among nurses in sub-specialties of critical care. Aust Crit Care 14:100鈥?05CrossRef PubMed
  23.Nunnally JC, Bernstein IH (1994) Psychometric theory, 3rd edn. McGraw-Hill, New York
  24.Menegazzi JJ, Davis EA, Sucov AN, Paris PM (1993) Reliability of the Glasgow Coma Scale when used by emergency physicians and paramedics. J Trauma 34:46鈥?8CrossRef PubMed
  25.Hollander JE, Go S, Lowery DW et al (2003) Inter-rater reliability of criteria used in assessing blunt head injury patients for intracranial injuries. Acad Emerg Med 10:830鈥?35CrossRef PubMed
  26.Kho ME, McDonald E, Stratford PW, Cook DJ (2007) Interrater reliability of APACHE II scores for medical-surgical intensive care patients: a prospective blinded study. Am J Crit Care 16:378鈥?83PubMed
  27.Wenner JB, Norena M, Khan N et al (2009) Reliability of intensive care unit admitting and comorbid diagnoses, race, elements of Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II Score, and predicted probability of mortality in an electronic intensive care unit database. J Crit Care 24:401鈥?07CrossRef PubMed
  28.Chen LM, Martin CM, Morrison TL, Sibbald WJ (1999) Interobserver variability in data collection of the APACHE II score in teaching and community hospitals. Crit Care Med 27:1999鈥?004CrossRef PubMed
  29.Diringer MN, Edwards DF (1997) Does modification of the Innsbruck and the Glasgow Coma Scales improve their ability to predict functional outcome? Arch Neurol 54:606鈥?11CrossRef PubMed
  30.Sadaka F, Patel D, Lakshmanan R (2012) The FOUR score predicts outcome in patients after traumatic brain injury. Neurocrit Care 16:95鈥?01CrossRef PubMed
  31.Gill MR, Reiley DG, Green SM (2004) Inter-rater reliability of Glasgow Coma Scale scores in the emergency department. Ann Emerg Med 43:215鈥?23CrossRef PubMed
  32.Feldman A, Hart KW, Lindsell CJ, McMullan JT (2015) Randomized controlled trial of a scoring aid to improve Glasgow Coma Scale scoring by emergency medical services providers. Ann Emerg Med 65(325鈥?29):e2. doi:10.鈥?016/鈥媕.鈥媋nnemergmed.鈥?014.鈥?7.鈥?54 PubMed
  33.Juarez VJ, Lyons M (1995) Interrater reliability of the Glasgow Coma Scale. J Neurosci Nurs 27:283鈥?86CrossRef PubMed
  34.Rowley G, Fielding K (1991) Reliability and accuracy of the Glasgow Coma Scale with experienced and inexperienced users. Lancet 337:535鈥?38CrossRef PubMed
  35.Fielding K, Rowley G (1990) Reliability of assessments by skilled observers using the Glasgow Coma Scale. Aust J Adv Nurs 7:13鈥?7PubMed
  36.Gill M, Martens K, Lynch EL et al (2007) Inter-rater reliability of 3 simplified neurologic scales applied to adults presenting to the emergency department with altered levels of consciousness. Ann Emerg Med 49:403鈥?07CrossRef PubMed
  37.Koch D, Linn S (2000) The Glasgow Coma Scale and the challenge of clinimetrics. Int Med J 7:51鈥?0
  38.Sternbach GL (2000) The Glasgow coma scale. J Emerg Med 19:67鈥?1CrossRef PubMed
  39.McHugh ML (2012) Interrater reliability: the kappa statistic. Biochem Medica 22:276鈥?82CrossRef
  40.Heard K, Bebarta VS (2004) Reliability of the Glasgow Coma Scale for the emergency department evaluation of poisoned patients. Hum Exp Toxicol 23:197鈥?00CrossRef PubMed
  41.Le Roux P, Menon DK, Citerio G et al (2014) Consensus summary statement of the international multidisciplinary consensus conference on multimodality monitoring in neurocritical care : a statement for healthcare professionals from the Neurocritical Care Society and the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine. Intensive Care Med 40(9):1189鈥?209. doi:10.鈥?007/鈥媠00134-014-3369-6 CrossRef PubMed
  42.Livingston BM, Mackenzie SJ, MacKirdy FN, Howie JC (2000) Should the pre-sedation Glasgow Coma Scale value be used when calculating acute physiology and chronic health evaluation scores for sedated patients? Scottish Intensive Care Society Audit Group. Crit Care Med 28:389鈥?94CrossRef PubMed
  43.Rutledge R, Lentz CW, Fakhry S, Hunt J (1996) Appropriate use of the Glasgow Coma Scale in intubated patients: a linear regression prediction of the Glasgow Verbal Score from the Glasgow Eye and Motor scores. J Trauma 41:514鈥?22CrossRef PubMed
  44.Zuercher M, Ummenhofer W, Baltussen A, Walder B (2009) The use of Glasgow Coma Scale in injury assessment: a critical review. Brain Inj 23:371鈥?84. doi:10.鈥?080/鈥?269905090292626鈥? CrossRef PubMed
  45.Kottner J, Audige L, Brorson S et al (2011) Guidelines for reporting reliability and agreement studies (GRRAS) were proposed. J Clin Epidemiol 64:96鈥?06. doi:10.鈥?016/鈥媕.鈥媕clinepi.鈥?010.鈥?3.鈥?02 CrossRef PubMed
  46.Zhao X (2011) When to use Cohen鈥檚 k, if Ever?. International Communication Association 2011 Conference, Boston, pp 1鈥?0
  47.Braakman R, Avezaat CJ, Maas AI et al (1977) Inter observer agreement in the assessment of the motor response of the Glasgow coma scale. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 80:100鈥?06CrossRef PubMed
  48.Rimel RW, Jane JA, Edlich RF (1979) An injury severity scale for comprehensive management of central nervous system trauma. JACEP 8:64鈥?7CrossRef PubMed
  49.Lindsay KW, Teasdale GM, Knill-Jones RP (1983) Observer variability in assessing the clinical features of subarachnoid hemorrhage. J Neurosurg 58:57鈥?2CrossRef PubMed
  50.Stanczak DE, White JG 3rd, Gouview WD et al (1984) Assessment of level of consciousness following severe neurological insult. A comparison of the psychometric qualities of the Glasgow Coma Scale and the comprehensive level of Consciousness Scale. J Neurosurg 60:955鈥?60. doi:10.鈥?171/鈥媕ns.鈥?984.鈥?0.鈥?.鈥?955 CrossRef PubMed
  51.Starmark JE, Heath A (1988) Severity grading in self-poisoning. Hum Toxicol 7:551鈥?55CrossRef PubMed
  52.Starmark JE, Stalhammar D, Holmgren E, Rosander B (1988) A comparison of the Glasgow Coma Scale and the Reaction Level Scale (RLS85). J Neurosurg 69:699鈥?06CrossRef PubMed
  53.Tesseris J, Pantazidis N, Routsi C, Fragoulakis D (1991) A comparative study of the Reaction Level Scale (RLS85) with Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) and Edinburgh-2 Coma Scale (modified) (E2CS(M)). Acta Neurochir Wien 110:65鈥?6CrossRef PubMed
  54.Ellis A, Cavanagh SJ (1992) Aspects of neurosurgical assessment using the Glasgow Coma Scale. Intensive Crit Care Nurs 8:94鈥?9CrossRef PubMed
  55.Oshiro EM, Walter KA, Piantadosi S et al (1997) A new subarachnoid hemorrhage grading system based on the Glasgow Coma Scale: a comparison with the Hunt and Hess and World Federation of Neurological Surgeons Scales in a clinical series. Neurosurgery 41:140鈥?47CrossRef PubMed
  56.Crossman J, Bankes M, Bhan A, Crockard HA (1998) The Glasgow Coma Score: reliable evidence? Injury 29:435鈥?37CrossRef PubMed
  57.Wijdicks EF, Kokmen E, O鈥橞rien PC (1998) Measurement of impaired consciousness in the neurological intensive care unit: a new test. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 64:117鈥?19PubMedCentral CrossRef PubMed
  58.Lane PL, Baez AA, Brabson T et al (2002) Effectiveness of a Glasgow Coma Scale instructional video for EMS providers. Prehosp Disaster Med 17:142鈥?46PubMed
  59.Ely EW, Truman B, Shintani A et al (2003) Monitoring sedation status over time in ICU patients: reliability and validity of the Richmond Agitation-Sedation Scale (RASS). JAMA 289:2983鈥?991CrossRef PubMed
  60.Wijdicks EF, Bamlet WR, Maramattom BV et al (2005) Validation of a new Coma Scale: the FOUR score. Ann Neurol 58:585鈥?93CrossRef PubMed
  61.Holdgate A, Ching N, Angonese L (2006) Variability in agreement between physicians and nurses when measuring the Glasgow Coma Scale in the emergency department limits its clinical usefulness. Emerg Med Australas 18:379鈥?84CrossRef PubMed
  62.Baez AA, Giraldez EM, De Pena JM (2007) Precision and reliability of the Glasgow Coma Scale score among a cohort of Latin American prehospital emergency care providers. Prehosp Disaster Med 22:230鈥?32CrossRef PubMed
  63.Kerby JD, MacLennan PA, Burton JN et al (2007) Agreement between prehospital and emergency department Glasgow Coma Scores. J Trauma 63:1026鈥?031CrossRef PubMed
  64.Wolf CA, Wijdicks EF, Bamlet WR, McClelland RL (2007) Further validation of the FOUR Score Coma Scale by intensive care nurses. Mayo Clin Proc 82:435鈥?38CrossRef PubMed
  65.Nassar AP Jr, Neto RCP, de Figueiredo WB, Park M (2008) Validity, reliability and applicability of Portuguese versions of Sedation-Agitation Scales among critically ill patients. Sao Paulo Med J 126:215鈥?19CrossRef
  66.Akavipat P (2009) Endorsement of the FOUR Score for consciousness assessment in neurosurgical patients. Neurol Med Chir Tokyo 49:565鈥?71CrossRef PubMed
  67.Iyer VN, Mandrekar JN, Danielson RD et al (2009) Validity of the FOUR Score Coma Scale in the medical intensive care unit. Mayo Clin Proc 84:694鈥?01PubMedCentral CrossRef PubMed
  68.Ryu WHA, Feinstein A, Colantonio A et al (2009) Early identification and incidence of mild TBI in Ontario. Can J Neurol Sci 36:429鈥?35CrossRef PubMed
  69.Stead LG, Wijdicks EF, Bhagra A et al (2009) Validation of a new Coma Scale, the FOUR Score, in the emergency department. Neurocrit Care 10:50鈥?4CrossRef PubMed
  70.Fischer M, Ruegg S, Czaplinski A et al (2010) Inter-rater reliability of the Full Outline of Unresponsiveness Score and the Glasgow Coma Scale in critically ill patients: a prospective observational study. Crit Care 14:R64PubMedCentral CrossRef PubMed
  71.Idrovo L, Fuentes B, Medina J et al (2010) Validation of the FOUR Score (Spanish Version) in acute stroke: an interobserver variability study. Eur Neurol 63:364鈥?69CrossRef PubMed
  72.Necioglu Orken D, Kocaman Sagduyu A, Sirin H et al (2010) Reliability of the Turkish version of a new Coma Scale: FOUR Score. Balk Med J 27:28鈥?1
  73.Ashkenazy S, DeKeyser-Ganz F (2011) Assessment of the reliability and validity of the Comfort Scale for adult intensive care patients. Heart Lung 40:e44鈥揺51CrossRef PubMed
  74.Bruno MA, Ledoux D, Lambermont B et al (2011) Comparison of the FOUR and Glasgow Liege Scale/Glasgow Coma Scale in an intensive care unit population. Neurocrit Care 15:447鈥?53CrossRef PubMed
  75.Gujjar AR, Nandagopal R, Jacob PC et al (2011) FOUR Score鈥揳 new Coma Score: inter-observer reliability and relation to outcome in critically ill medical patients. Eur J Neurol 18:441
  76.Kevric J, Jelinek GA, Knott J, Weiland TJ (2011) Validation of the Full Outline of Unresponsiveness (FOUR) Scale for conscious state in the emergency department: comparison against the Glasgow Coma Scale. Emerg Med J 28:486鈥?90CrossRef PubMed
  77.Namiki J, Yamazaki M, Funabiki T, Hori S (2011) Inaccuracy and misjudged factors of Glasgow Coma Scale scores when assessed by inexperienced physicians. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 113:393鈥?98CrossRef PubMed
  78.Patel D, Sadaka F, Lakshmanan R (2011) The FOUR score predicts outcome in patients after traumatic brain injury. Neurocrit Care 15:S238
  79.Takahashi C, Okudera H, Origasa H et al (2011) A simple and useful coma scale for patients with neurologic emergencies: the Emergency Coma Scale. Am J Emerg Med 29:196鈥?02CrossRef PubMed
  80.Winship C, Williams B, Boyle M (2011) Assessment of the Glasgow Coma Scale: a pilot study examining the accuracy of paramedic undergraduates. Australas J Paramed 10:11
  81.Marcati E, Ricci S, Casalena A et al (2012) Validation of the Italian version of a new Coma Scale: the Four Score. Intern Emerg Med 7:145鈥?52CrossRef PubMed
  82.Winship C, Williams B, Boyle MJ (2012) Should an alternative to the Glasgow Coma Scale be taught to paramedic students? Emerg Med J 30:e19CrossRef PubMed
  83.Ben铆tez-Rosario MA, Castillo-Padr贸s M, Garrido-Bernet B et al (2013) Appropriateness and reliability testing of the modified richmond Agitation-Sedation Scale in Spanish patients with advanced cancer. J Pain Symptom Manag 45:1112鈥?119CrossRef
  84.Dinh MM, Oliver M, Bein K et al (2013) Level of agreement between prehospital and emergency department vital signs in trauma patients. Emerg Med Australas 25:457鈥?63PubMed
  85.Gujjar AR, Jacob PC, Nandhagopal R et al (2013) FOUR score and Glasgow Coma Scale in medical patients with altered sensorium: interrater reliability and relation to outcome. J Crit Care 28(316):e1鈥揺8PubMed
  
• 作者单位：Florence C. M. Reith (1) (2)
  Ruben Van den Brande (1) (2)
  Anneliese Synnot (3) (4) (7)
  Russell Gruen (5) (6) (8)
  Andrew I. R. Maas (1) (2)
  
  1. Department of Neurosurgery, Antwerp University Hospital, Wilrijkstraat 10, 2650, Edegem, Belgium
  2. University of Antwerp, Edegem, Belgium
  3. Australian & New Zealand Intensive Care Research Centre (ANZIC-RC), School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, Melbourne, Australia
  4. Cochrane Consumers and Communication Review Group, Centre for Health Communication and Participation, School of Psychology and Public Health, La Trobe University, Melbourne, Australia
  7. ANZIC-RC, Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, The Alfred Hospital, Level 6, 99 Commercial Road, Melbourne, VIC, 3004, Australia
  5. Central Clinical School, Monash University, Melbourne, Australia
  6. Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, Singapore
  8. Central Clinical School, Level 6, The Alfred Centre, 99 Commercial Road, Melbourne, VIC, 3004, Australia
  
• 刊物主题：Intensive / Critical Care Medicine; Anesthesiology; Emergency Medicine; Pneumology/Respiratory System; Pain Medicine; Pediatrics;
• 出版者：Springer Berlin Heidelberg
• ISSN：1432-1238

文摘

Introduction The Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) provides a structured method for assessment of the level of consciousness. Its derived sum score is applied in research and adopted in intensive care unit scoring systems. Controversy exists on the reliability of the GCS. The aim of this systematic review was to summarize evidence on the reliability of the GCS.