International comparison of prehospital trauma care systems

详细信息	查看全文 | 推荐本文 |

• 作者：Bahman S. Roudsari ; Avery B. Nathens ; Peter Cameron ; Ian Civil ; Russel L. Gruen ; Thomas D. Koepsell ; Fiona E. Lecky ; Rolf L. Lefering ; Moishe Liberman ; Charles N. Mock ; Hans-Jö ; rg Oestern ; Thomas
• 关键词：Emergency medical services (EMS) ; Trauma ; Injury ; International ; Mortality ; Clustered study ; Shock rate ; Intracluster correlation coefficient (ICC)
• 刊名：Injury
• 出版年：2007
• 期刊代码：120_00201383
• 类别：med
• 出版时间：September 2007
• 卷：38
• 期：9
• 页码：993-1000
• 文件大小：228 K

摘要

Given the recent emphasis on developing prehospital trauma care globally, we embarked upon a multicentre study to compare trauma patients’ outcome within and between countries with technician-operated advanced life support (ALS) and physician-operated (Doc-ALS) emergency medical service (EMS) systems. These environments represent the continuum of prehospital care in high income countries with more advanced prehospital trauma care systems.

Methods

Five countries with ALS-EMS system and four countries with Doc-ALS EMS system provided us with de-identified patient-level data from their national or local trauma registries. Generalised linear latent and mixed models was used in order to compare emergency department (ED) shock rate (systolic blood pressure (SBP) <90 mmHg) and early trauma fatality rate (i.e. death during the first 24 h after hospital arrival) between ALS and Doc-ALS EMS systems. Logistic regression was used to compare outcomes of interest among different countries, accounting for within-system correlation in patient outcomes.

Results

After adjustment for patient age, sex, type and mechanism of injury, injury severity score and SBP at scene, the ED shock rate did not vary significantly between Doc-ALS and ALS systems (OR: 1.16, 95%CI: 0.73–1.91). However, the early trauma fatality rate was significantly lower in Doc-ALS EMS systems compared with ALS EMS systems (OR: 0.70, 95%CI: 0.54–0.91). Furthermore, we found a considerable heterogeneity in patient outcomes among countries even with similar type of EMS systems.

Conclusion

These findings suggest that prehospital trauma care systems that dispatch a physician to the scene may be associated with lower early trauma fatality rates, but not necessarily with significantly better outcomes on other clinical measures. The reasons for these findings deserve further studies.