国家级贫困县旅游发展与多维贫困的脱钩关系研究——以西南地区为例
|
摘要
发展旅游业被认为是贫困地区缓解贫困的重要方式之一,为探讨国家级贫困县的旅游扶贫发展现状,本文基于Tapio脱钩模型,以西南地区136个国家级贫困县为例,对旅游发展分别与综合贫困以及、教育、医疗、社会福利等不同维度贫困间的脱钩关系进行研究。研究结果表明:①随着旅游的发展,西南地区贫困县的综合贫困状况得到改善,但改善程度表现出不稳定性并逐渐放缓;②随着旅游发展,西南地区贫困县经济和社会福利贫困某种程度上得到改善,医疗贫困得到较大改善,教育贫困基本未得到改变;③西南地区不同省份贫困县的旅游扶贫发展存在空间差异性,贵州贫困县表现最好。本研究对于深度了解旅游扶贫现状,进一步发挥旅游的多维扶贫作用具有重要意义。
Poverty has always been the focus of people's attention. The ways to alleviate poverty have become one of the hot topics of discussion. The report of the 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China pointed out that China's strong fight against poverty has made decisive progress. Nevertheless, at the end of 2017, China's rural impoverished population still had 30.46 million. The task of poverty alleviation is still arduous in China. For the sake of complete eradication of poverty in rural areas by 2020, China's poverty alleviation work needs to be further advanced. Due to the high spatial consistency of China's tourism resource-rich areas and poverty-stricken areas, and tourism industry's characteristics of less investment, rapid effect, low threshold and high industry related degree,the development of tourism is considered as an important way to get rid of poverty in poor areas. Thus, tourism poverty alleviation has gradually received attention from governments at all levels and academic circles. From the current poverty situation, the country is transiting from widespread poverty to small-scale poverty. Poverty-stricken counties are the vital targets and crucial organizational units of poverty alleviation in rural China. In order to explore the status quo of tourism poverty alleviation, this paper takes 136 national-level poor counties in Southwest China as an example to study the decoupling relationship between tourism development and multidimensional poverty based on Tapio decoupling model. We got three research results. First, with the development of tourism, comprehensive poverty has been improved, but has shown instability and gradually slowed down. Second, with the development of tourism, economic poverty and social welfare poverty have been partly improved, medical poverty has been improved greatly, and education poverty has almost remained unchanged.Third, there are spatial differences in tourism poverty alleviation for different provinces, with the best performance in Guizhou province. This study is meaningful for understanding current situations about tourism poverty alleviation deeply and exerting the effect of multidimensional tourism poverty alleviation thoroughly.
Poverty has always been the focus of people's attention. The ways to alleviate poverty have become one of the hot topics of discussion. The report of the 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China pointed out that China's strong fight against poverty has made decisive progress. Nevertheless, at the end of 2017, China's rural impoverished population still had 30.46 million. The task of poverty alleviation is still arduous in China. For the sake of complete eradication of poverty in rural areas by 2020, China's poverty alleviation work needs to be further advanced. Due to the high spatial consistency of China's tourism resource-rich areas and poverty-stricken areas, and tourism industry's characteristics of less investment, rapid effect, low threshold and high industry related degree,the development of tourism is considered as an important way to get rid of poverty in poor areas. Thus, tourism poverty alleviation has gradually received attention from governments at all levels and academic circles. From the current poverty situation, the country is transiting from widespread poverty to small-scale poverty. Poverty-stricken counties are the vital targets and crucial organizational units of poverty alleviation in rural China. In order to explore the status quo of tourism poverty alleviation, this paper takes 136 national-level poor counties in Southwest China as an example to study the decoupling relationship between tourism development and multidimensional poverty based on Tapio decoupling model. We got three research results. First, with the development of tourism, comprehensive poverty has been improved, but has shown instability and gradually slowed down. Second, with the development of tourism, economic poverty and social welfare poverty have been partly improved, medical poverty has been improved greatly, and education poverty has almost remained unchanged.Third, there are spatial differences in tourism poverty alleviation for different provinces, with the best performance in Guizhou province. This study is meaningful for understanding current situations about tourism poverty alleviation deeply and exerting the effect of multidimensional tourism poverty alleviation thoroughly.
引文
[1]Sen A.Poverty:An ordinal approach to measurement.Econometrica,1976,44(2):219-231.
[2]Foster J,Greer J,Thorbecke E.A class of decomposable poverty measures.Econometrica,1984,52(3):761-766.
[3]Alkire S,Foster J.Counting and multidimensional poverty measurement.Journal of Public Economics,2011,95(7):476-487.
[4]Bader C,Bieri S,Wiesmann U,et al.A different perspective on poverty in Lao PDR:Multidimensional poverty in Lao PDR for the years 2002/2003 and 2007/2008.Social Indicators Research,2015,126(2):1-20.
[5]Dehury B,Mohanty S K.Regional estimates of multidimensional poverty in India.Economics:The Open Access,OpenAssessment E-Journal,2015,9:1-35.
[6]王小林,Alkire S.中国多维贫困测量:估计和政策含义.中国农村经济,2009,(12):4-10.[Wang Xiaolin,Alkire S.Chinese multidimensional poverty measurement:Estimation and policy implications.Chinese Rural Economy,2009,(12):4-10.]
[7]刘艳华,徐勇.中国农村多维贫困地理识别及类型划分.地理学报,2015,70(6):993-1007.[Liu Yanhua,Xu Yong.Geographical identification and classification of multi-dimensional poverty in rural China.Acta Geographica Sinica,2015,70(6):993-1007.]
[8]王艳慧,钱乐毅,段福洲.县级多维贫困度量及其空间分布格局研究:以连片特困区扶贫重点县为例.地理科学,2013,33(12):1489-1497.[Wang Yanhui,Qian Leyi,Duan Fuzhou.Multidimensional poverty measurement and spatial distribution pattern at the country scale:A case study on key country from national contiguous special poverty-stricken areas.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2013,33(12):1489-1497.]
[9]李佳,成升魁,马金刚,等.基于县域要素的三江源地区旅游扶贫模式探讨.资源科学,2009,31(11):1818-1824.[Li Jia,Cheng Shengkui,Ma Jingang,et.al.Investigating modes for poverty elimination through developing tourism resources at county levels in the Sanjiangyuan region.Resources Science,2009,31(11):1818-1824.]
[10]郭鲁芳,李如友.旅游减贫效应的门槛特征分析及实证检验:基于中国省际面板数据的研究.商业经济与管理,2016,(6):81-91.[Guo Lufang,Li Ruyou.Aanlysis on the threshold effect of tourism development on poverty alleviation and relevant empirical test:Based on the province panel data in China.Journal of Business Economics,2016,(6):81-91.]
[11]Aref F.Tourism industry for poverty reduction in Iran.African Journal of Business Management,2011,5(11):4191-4195.
[12]Zeng B,Ryan C.Assisting the poor in China through tourism development:A review of research.Tourism Management,2012,33(2):239-248.
[13]Njoya E T,Seetaram N.Tourism contribution to poverty alleviation in Kenya:A dynamic computable general equilibrium analysis.Journal of Travel Research,2018,57(4):513-524.
[14]Kim N,Song H J,Pyun J H.The relationship among tourism,poverty,and economic development in developing countries:A panel data regression analysis.Tourism Economics,2016,22(6):1174-1190.
[15]Truong V D,Hall C M,Garry T.Tourism and poverty alleviation:Perceptions and experiences of poor people in Sapa,Vietnam.Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2014,22(7):1071-1089.
[16]龙祖坤,杜倩文,周婷.武陵山区旅游扶贫效率的时间演进与空间分异.经济地理,2015,35(10):210-217.[Long Zukun,Du Qianwen,Zhou Ting.The evolution of time and space differentiation of Wuling mountain area tourism poverty alleviation efficiency.Economic Geography,2015,35(10):210-217.]
[17]李会琴,杨树旺,侯林春,等.农户参与视角的旅游扶贫生态效率研究:基于陕西省延安市4村89户的调研.陕西师范大学学报(自科版),2017,45(4):98-104.[Li huiqin,Yang shuwang,Hou linchun,et al.Eco-efficiency of pro-poor tourism from the perspective of farmer’s participation:Based on survey of 89 households in four villages,Yanan,Shaanxi province.Journal of Shaanxi Normal University(Natural Science Edition),2017,45(4):98-104.]
[18]Butler,R,Curran R,O’Gorman K D.Pro-poor tourism in a first world urban setting:Case study of Glasgow Govan.International Journal of Tourism Research,2013,15(5),443-457.
[19]Manwa H,Manwa F.Poverty alleviation through pro-poor tourism:The role of Botswana forest reserves.Sustainability,2014,6(9):5697-5713.
[20]Manyara G,Jones E.Community-based tourism enterprises development in Kenya:An exploration of their potential as avenues of poverty reduction.Journal of Sustainable tourism,2007,15(6):628-644.
[21]Mutana S,Chipfuva T,Muchenje B.Is tourism in Zimbabwe developing with the poor in mind?Assessing the pro-poor involvement of tourism operators located near rural areas in Zimbabwe.Asian Social Science,2013,9(5):154.
[22]刘长生.旅游产业发展、价格效应及其社会福利影响.旅游科学,2013,27(6):25-38.[Liu Changsheng.On the impact of tourism industry development,price effect and its social welfare.Tourism Science,2013,27(6):25-38.]
[23]王艳慧,钱乐毅,陈烨烽,等.生态贫困视角下的贫困县多维贫困综合度量.应用生态学报,2017,28(8):2677-2686.[Wang Yanhui,Qian Leyi,Chen Yefeng,et al.Multidimensional and comprehensive poverty measurement of povertystricken counties from the perspective of ecological poverty.Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2017,28(8):2677-2686.]
[24]袁媛,王仰麟,马晶,等.河北省县域贫困度多维评估.地理科学进展,2014,33(1):124-133.[Yuan Yuan,Wang Yanglin,Ma Jing,et al.Multidimensional evaluation of county poverty degree in Hebei province.Progress in Geography,2014,33(1):124-133.]
[25]杨建春,肖小虹.贵州旅游扶贫效应动态分析.商业研究,2011,(7):212-216.[Yang Jianchun,Xiao Xiaohong.Dynamic analysis on the poverty alleviation effect of tourism in Guizhou.Commercial Research,2011,(7):212-216.]
[26]柳建平,刘咪咪.甘肃省贫困地区女性多维贫困测度及影响因素分析:基于14个贫困村的调查资料.西北人口,2018,39(2):112-120.[Liu Jianping,Liu Mimi.An analysis on multidimensional poverty measurement of women and recognition of its causes:Based on the survey data of 14 poverty villages in Gansu.Northwest Population,2018,39(2):112-120.]
[27]丁建军.中国11个集中连片特困区贫困程度比较研究:基于综合发展指数计算的视角.地理科学,2014,34(12):1418-1427.[Din Jianjun.Comparative analysis on poverty degree of China’s 11 contiguous destitute areas:With view of comprehensive development index.Scientia Geographica Sinica.2014,34(12):1414-1427.]
[28]陈烨烽,王艳慧,王小林.中国贫困村测度与空间分布特征分析.地理研究,2016,35(12):2298-2308.[Che Yefeng,Wang Yanhui,Wang Xiaolin.Measurement and spatial analysis of poverty-stricken villages in China.Geographical Research,2016,35(12):2298-2308.]
[29]向延平.旅游发展与经济增长空间自相关分析:基于武陵山区的经验数据.经济地理,2012,32(8):172-175.[Xiang Yanping.The analysis on the spatial autocorrelation of the tourism development and economic growth based on the empirical data of Wuling Mountain areas.Economic Geography,2012,32(8):172-175.]
[30]郑长德,单德朋.集中连片特困地区多维贫困测度与时空演进.南开学报:哲学社会科学版,2016,(3):135-146.[Zheng Changde,Shan Depeng.The multidimensional measurement of poverty and its spatial-temporal evolution in contiguous destitute areas.Nankai Journal:Philosophy,Literature and Social Science Edition,2016,(3):135-146.]
[31]罗晓珊,蔡广鹏,韩会庆,等.喀斯特山区多维贫困度时空变化特征分析:以毕节市为例.贵州师范大学学报(自然科学版),2017,35(1):8-14.[Luo Xiaoshan,Cai Guangpeng,Han Huiqing,et al.Temporal variation characteristics analysis of multidimensional poverty in karst mountain areas:A case study of Bijie.Journal of Guizhou Normal University(Natural Sciences),2017,35(1):8-14.]
[32]杨帆,陈凌珠,庄天慧,等.可持续生计视阈下县域多维贫困测度与时空演化研究:以四川藏区行政区划县为例.软科学,2017,31(10):38-42.[Yan Fan,Chen Lingzhu,Zhuang Tianhui,et al.Study on multidimensional poverty measurement and spatio-temporal evolution based on the sustainable livelihood framework.Soft Science,2017,31(10):38-42.]
[33]Battiston D,Cruces G,Lopez-Calva L F,et al.Income and beyond:Multidimensional poverty in six Latin American countries.Social Indicators Research,2013,112(2):291-314.
[34]周礼,蒋金亮.长三角城市旅游竞争力综合评价及其空间分异.经济地理,2015,35(1):173-179.[Zhou Li,Jiang Jinliang.Comprehensive evaluation of urban tourism competitiveness in the Yangtze River Delta and its spatial patterns analysis.Economic Geography,2015,35(1):173-179.]
[35]Zhou Z H,Sun J N,Ren G P.Study and application on the entropy method for determination of weight of evaluating indicators in fuzzy synthetic evaluation far water quality assessment.Acta Scientiae Circucnstantide,2005,25(4):552-555.
[36]杜挺,谢贤健,梁海艳,等.基于熵权TOPSIS和GIS的重庆市县域经济综合评价及空间分析.经济地理,2014,34(6):40-47.[Du Ting,Xie Xianjian,Liang Haiyan,et al.County economy comprehensive evaluation and spatial analysis in chongqing city based on entropy weight-TOPSIS and GIS.Economic Geography,2014,34(6):40-47.]
[37]方硕,程道品,段文军,等.基于熵权法的河池县域旅游扶贫产业竞争力研究.旅游研究,2015,7(2):40-44.[Fang Shuo,Cheng Daopin,Duan Wenjun,et al.On counties’tourism poverty-alleviating competitiveness in Hechi based on entropy weight theory.Tourism Research,2015,7(2):40-44.]
[38]贾艳红,赵军,南忠仁,等.熵权法在草原生态安全评价研究中的应用:以甘肃牧区为例.干旱区资源与环境,2007,21(1):17-21.[Jia Yan hong,Zhao Jun,Nan Zhongren,et al.The application of entropy-right method to thstudy of ecological security evaluation of grassland:A case study at the ecological security evaluation of grassland to pastoral area of Gansu.Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment,2007,21(1):17-21.]
[39]OECD.Decoupling:A conceptual overview.Pairs:OECD,2000:5.
[40]齐绍洲,林屾,王班班.中部六省经济增长方式对区域碳排放的影响:基于Tapio脱钩模型、面板数据的滞后期工具变量法的研究.中国人口·资源与环境,2015,25(5):59-66.[Qi Shaozhou,Lin Shen,Wang Banban.Impact of economic growth pattern of the six provinces of central China on regional carbon emission:Based on the Tapio model and lag instrumental variable analysis of panel data.China Population,Resources and Environment,2015,25(5):59-66.]
[41]刘爱东,曾辉祥,刘文静.中国碳排放与出口贸易间脱钩关系实证.中国人口资源与环境,2014,24(7):73-81.[Liu Aidong,Zeng Huixiang,Liu Wenjing.Empirical study of decoupling relationship between carbon emissions and export trade in China.China Population,Resources and Environment,2014,24(7):73-81.]
[42]迟瑶,王艳慧,房娜.连片特困区贫困县农村基本公共服务与县域经济时空格局演变关系研究.地理研究,2016,35(7):1243-1258.[Chi Yao,Wang Yanhui,Fang Na.Spatio-temporal pattern of rural basic public services and county economy in poverty-stricken contiguous destitute areas of China.Geographical Research,2016,35(7):1243-1258.]
[43]钟太洋,黄贤金,韩立,等.资源环境领域脱钩分析研究进展.自然资源学报,2010,25(8):1400-1412.[Zhong Taiyang,Huang Xianjin,Han Li,et al.Review on the research of decoupling analysis in the field of environments and resource.Journal of Natural Resources,2010,25(8):1400-1412.]
[44]Tapio P.Towards a theory of decoupling:degrees of decoupling in the EU and the case of road traffic in Finland between1970 and 2001.Transport Policy,2005,12(2):137-151.
[45]周银香.交通碳排放与行业经济增长脱钩及耦合关系研究:基于Tapio脱钩模型和协整理论.经济问题探索,2016,(6):41-48.[Zhou Yinxiang.Study on the decoupling and coupling relationship of traffic carbon sequestration and industrial economic growth:Based on Tapio decoupling model and cointegration theory.Inquiry Into Economic Issues,2016,(6):41-48.]
[46]Llorca-Rodríguez C M,Casas-Jurado A C,García-Fernández R M.Tourism and poverty alleviation:An empirical analysis using panel data on Peru's departments.International Journal of Tourism Research,2017,19(6):746-756.
[47]赵磊.旅游发展与经济增长:来自中国的经验证据.旅游学刊,2015,30(4):33-49.[Zhao Lei.Tourism development and economic growth:Empirical evidence from China.Tourism Tribune,2015,30(4):33-49.]
[48]程晓丽,王逢春.安徽省旅游产业发展与经济增长相关性分析.经济地理,2014,34(3):182-186.[Cheng Xiaoli,Wang Fengchun.The correlation analysis of tourism industry development and economic growth of Anhui.Economic Geography,2014,34(3):33-49.]
[49]陆林,刘莹莹.旅游教育与旅游业发展时空相关性分析.高等农业教育,2009,(8):17-21.[Lu Lin,Liu Yingying.Spatio-temporal correlation analysis between tourism education and tourism development.Higher Agricultural Education,2009,(8):17-21.]
[50]张广海,刘真真,李盈昌.中国沿海省份旅游产业发展水平综合评价及时空格局演变.地域研究与开发,2013,32(4):22-27.[Zhang Guanghai,Liuzhenzhen,Li Yingchang.Comprehensive evaluation and temporal-spatial evolution of the development level of tourism in China’s coastal provinces.Areal Research and Development,2013,32(4):22-27.]
[2]Foster J,Greer J,Thorbecke E.A class of decomposable poverty measures.Econometrica,1984,52(3):761-766.
[3]Alkire S,Foster J.Counting and multidimensional poverty measurement.Journal of Public Economics,2011,95(7):476-487.
[4]Bader C,Bieri S,Wiesmann U,et al.A different perspective on poverty in Lao PDR:Multidimensional poverty in Lao PDR for the years 2002/2003 and 2007/2008.Social Indicators Research,2015,126(2):1-20.
[5]Dehury B,Mohanty S K.Regional estimates of multidimensional poverty in India.Economics:The Open Access,OpenAssessment E-Journal,2015,9:1-35.
[6]王小林,Alkire S.中国多维贫困测量:估计和政策含义.中国农村经济,2009,(12):4-10.[Wang Xiaolin,Alkire S.Chinese multidimensional poverty measurement:Estimation and policy implications.Chinese Rural Economy,2009,(12):4-10.]
[7]刘艳华,徐勇.中国农村多维贫困地理识别及类型划分.地理学报,2015,70(6):993-1007.[Liu Yanhua,Xu Yong.Geographical identification and classification of multi-dimensional poverty in rural China.Acta Geographica Sinica,2015,70(6):993-1007.]
[8]王艳慧,钱乐毅,段福洲.县级多维贫困度量及其空间分布格局研究:以连片特困区扶贫重点县为例.地理科学,2013,33(12):1489-1497.[Wang Yanhui,Qian Leyi,Duan Fuzhou.Multidimensional poverty measurement and spatial distribution pattern at the country scale:A case study on key country from national contiguous special poverty-stricken areas.Scientia Geographica Sinica,2013,33(12):1489-1497.]
[9]李佳,成升魁,马金刚,等.基于县域要素的三江源地区旅游扶贫模式探讨.资源科学,2009,31(11):1818-1824.[Li Jia,Cheng Shengkui,Ma Jingang,et.al.Investigating modes for poverty elimination through developing tourism resources at county levels in the Sanjiangyuan region.Resources Science,2009,31(11):1818-1824.]
[10]郭鲁芳,李如友.旅游减贫效应的门槛特征分析及实证检验:基于中国省际面板数据的研究.商业经济与管理,2016,(6):81-91.[Guo Lufang,Li Ruyou.Aanlysis on the threshold effect of tourism development on poverty alleviation and relevant empirical test:Based on the province panel data in China.Journal of Business Economics,2016,(6):81-91.]
[11]Aref F.Tourism industry for poverty reduction in Iran.African Journal of Business Management,2011,5(11):4191-4195.
[12]Zeng B,Ryan C.Assisting the poor in China through tourism development:A review of research.Tourism Management,2012,33(2):239-248.
[13]Njoya E T,Seetaram N.Tourism contribution to poverty alleviation in Kenya:A dynamic computable general equilibrium analysis.Journal of Travel Research,2018,57(4):513-524.
[14]Kim N,Song H J,Pyun J H.The relationship among tourism,poverty,and economic development in developing countries:A panel data regression analysis.Tourism Economics,2016,22(6):1174-1190.
[15]Truong V D,Hall C M,Garry T.Tourism and poverty alleviation:Perceptions and experiences of poor people in Sapa,Vietnam.Journal of Sustainable Tourism,2014,22(7):1071-1089.
[16]龙祖坤,杜倩文,周婷.武陵山区旅游扶贫效率的时间演进与空间分异.经济地理,2015,35(10):210-217.[Long Zukun,Du Qianwen,Zhou Ting.The evolution of time and space differentiation of Wuling mountain area tourism poverty alleviation efficiency.Economic Geography,2015,35(10):210-217.]
[17]李会琴,杨树旺,侯林春,等.农户参与视角的旅游扶贫生态效率研究:基于陕西省延安市4村89户的调研.陕西师范大学学报(自科版),2017,45(4):98-104.[Li huiqin,Yang shuwang,Hou linchun,et al.Eco-efficiency of pro-poor tourism from the perspective of farmer’s participation:Based on survey of 89 households in four villages,Yanan,Shaanxi province.Journal of Shaanxi Normal University(Natural Science Edition),2017,45(4):98-104.]
[18]Butler,R,Curran R,O’Gorman K D.Pro-poor tourism in a first world urban setting:Case study of Glasgow Govan.International Journal of Tourism Research,2013,15(5),443-457.
[19]Manwa H,Manwa F.Poverty alleviation through pro-poor tourism:The role of Botswana forest reserves.Sustainability,2014,6(9):5697-5713.
[20]Manyara G,Jones E.Community-based tourism enterprises development in Kenya:An exploration of their potential as avenues of poverty reduction.Journal of Sustainable tourism,2007,15(6):628-644.
[21]Mutana S,Chipfuva T,Muchenje B.Is tourism in Zimbabwe developing with the poor in mind?Assessing the pro-poor involvement of tourism operators located near rural areas in Zimbabwe.Asian Social Science,2013,9(5):154.
[22]刘长生.旅游产业发展、价格效应及其社会福利影响.旅游科学,2013,27(6):25-38.[Liu Changsheng.On the impact of tourism industry development,price effect and its social welfare.Tourism Science,2013,27(6):25-38.]
[23]王艳慧,钱乐毅,陈烨烽,等.生态贫困视角下的贫困县多维贫困综合度量.应用生态学报,2017,28(8):2677-2686.[Wang Yanhui,Qian Leyi,Chen Yefeng,et al.Multidimensional and comprehensive poverty measurement of povertystricken counties from the perspective of ecological poverty.Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology,2017,28(8):2677-2686.]
[24]袁媛,王仰麟,马晶,等.河北省县域贫困度多维评估.地理科学进展,2014,33(1):124-133.[Yuan Yuan,Wang Yanglin,Ma Jing,et al.Multidimensional evaluation of county poverty degree in Hebei province.Progress in Geography,2014,33(1):124-133.]
[25]杨建春,肖小虹.贵州旅游扶贫效应动态分析.商业研究,2011,(7):212-216.[Yang Jianchun,Xiao Xiaohong.Dynamic analysis on the poverty alleviation effect of tourism in Guizhou.Commercial Research,2011,(7):212-216.]
[26]柳建平,刘咪咪.甘肃省贫困地区女性多维贫困测度及影响因素分析:基于14个贫困村的调查资料.西北人口,2018,39(2):112-120.[Liu Jianping,Liu Mimi.An analysis on multidimensional poverty measurement of women and recognition of its causes:Based on the survey data of 14 poverty villages in Gansu.Northwest Population,2018,39(2):112-120.]
[27]丁建军.中国11个集中连片特困区贫困程度比较研究:基于综合发展指数计算的视角.地理科学,2014,34(12):1418-1427.[Din Jianjun.Comparative analysis on poverty degree of China’s 11 contiguous destitute areas:With view of comprehensive development index.Scientia Geographica Sinica.2014,34(12):1414-1427.]
[28]陈烨烽,王艳慧,王小林.中国贫困村测度与空间分布特征分析.地理研究,2016,35(12):2298-2308.[Che Yefeng,Wang Yanhui,Wang Xiaolin.Measurement and spatial analysis of poverty-stricken villages in China.Geographical Research,2016,35(12):2298-2308.]
[29]向延平.旅游发展与经济增长空间自相关分析:基于武陵山区的经验数据.经济地理,2012,32(8):172-175.[Xiang Yanping.The analysis on the spatial autocorrelation of the tourism development and economic growth based on the empirical data of Wuling Mountain areas.Economic Geography,2012,32(8):172-175.]
[30]郑长德,单德朋.集中连片特困地区多维贫困测度与时空演进.南开学报:哲学社会科学版,2016,(3):135-146.[Zheng Changde,Shan Depeng.The multidimensional measurement of poverty and its spatial-temporal evolution in contiguous destitute areas.Nankai Journal:Philosophy,Literature and Social Science Edition,2016,(3):135-146.]
[31]罗晓珊,蔡广鹏,韩会庆,等.喀斯特山区多维贫困度时空变化特征分析:以毕节市为例.贵州师范大学学报(自然科学版),2017,35(1):8-14.[Luo Xiaoshan,Cai Guangpeng,Han Huiqing,et al.Temporal variation characteristics analysis of multidimensional poverty in karst mountain areas:A case study of Bijie.Journal of Guizhou Normal University(Natural Sciences),2017,35(1):8-14.]
[32]杨帆,陈凌珠,庄天慧,等.可持续生计视阈下县域多维贫困测度与时空演化研究:以四川藏区行政区划县为例.软科学,2017,31(10):38-42.[Yan Fan,Chen Lingzhu,Zhuang Tianhui,et al.Study on multidimensional poverty measurement and spatio-temporal evolution based on the sustainable livelihood framework.Soft Science,2017,31(10):38-42.]
[33]Battiston D,Cruces G,Lopez-Calva L F,et al.Income and beyond:Multidimensional poverty in six Latin American countries.Social Indicators Research,2013,112(2):291-314.
[34]周礼,蒋金亮.长三角城市旅游竞争力综合评价及其空间分异.经济地理,2015,35(1):173-179.[Zhou Li,Jiang Jinliang.Comprehensive evaluation of urban tourism competitiveness in the Yangtze River Delta and its spatial patterns analysis.Economic Geography,2015,35(1):173-179.]
[35]Zhou Z H,Sun J N,Ren G P.Study and application on the entropy method for determination of weight of evaluating indicators in fuzzy synthetic evaluation far water quality assessment.Acta Scientiae Circucnstantide,2005,25(4):552-555.
[36]杜挺,谢贤健,梁海艳,等.基于熵权TOPSIS和GIS的重庆市县域经济综合评价及空间分析.经济地理,2014,34(6):40-47.[Du Ting,Xie Xianjian,Liang Haiyan,et al.County economy comprehensive evaluation and spatial analysis in chongqing city based on entropy weight-TOPSIS and GIS.Economic Geography,2014,34(6):40-47.]
[37]方硕,程道品,段文军,等.基于熵权法的河池县域旅游扶贫产业竞争力研究.旅游研究,2015,7(2):40-44.[Fang Shuo,Cheng Daopin,Duan Wenjun,et al.On counties’tourism poverty-alleviating competitiveness in Hechi based on entropy weight theory.Tourism Research,2015,7(2):40-44.]
[38]贾艳红,赵军,南忠仁,等.熵权法在草原生态安全评价研究中的应用:以甘肃牧区为例.干旱区资源与环境,2007,21(1):17-21.[Jia Yan hong,Zhao Jun,Nan Zhongren,et al.The application of entropy-right method to thstudy of ecological security evaluation of grassland:A case study at the ecological security evaluation of grassland to pastoral area of Gansu.Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment,2007,21(1):17-21.]
[39]OECD.Decoupling:A conceptual overview.Pairs:OECD,2000:5.
[40]齐绍洲,林屾,王班班.中部六省经济增长方式对区域碳排放的影响:基于Tapio脱钩模型、面板数据的滞后期工具变量法的研究.中国人口·资源与环境,2015,25(5):59-66.[Qi Shaozhou,Lin Shen,Wang Banban.Impact of economic growth pattern of the six provinces of central China on regional carbon emission:Based on the Tapio model and lag instrumental variable analysis of panel data.China Population,Resources and Environment,2015,25(5):59-66.]
[41]刘爱东,曾辉祥,刘文静.中国碳排放与出口贸易间脱钩关系实证.中国人口资源与环境,2014,24(7):73-81.[Liu Aidong,Zeng Huixiang,Liu Wenjing.Empirical study of decoupling relationship between carbon emissions and export trade in China.China Population,Resources and Environment,2014,24(7):73-81.]
[42]迟瑶,王艳慧,房娜.连片特困区贫困县农村基本公共服务与县域经济时空格局演变关系研究.地理研究,2016,35(7):1243-1258.[Chi Yao,Wang Yanhui,Fang Na.Spatio-temporal pattern of rural basic public services and county economy in poverty-stricken contiguous destitute areas of China.Geographical Research,2016,35(7):1243-1258.]
[43]钟太洋,黄贤金,韩立,等.资源环境领域脱钩分析研究进展.自然资源学报,2010,25(8):1400-1412.[Zhong Taiyang,Huang Xianjin,Han Li,et al.Review on the research of decoupling analysis in the field of environments and resource.Journal of Natural Resources,2010,25(8):1400-1412.]
[44]Tapio P.Towards a theory of decoupling:degrees of decoupling in the EU and the case of road traffic in Finland between1970 and 2001.Transport Policy,2005,12(2):137-151.
[45]周银香.交通碳排放与行业经济增长脱钩及耦合关系研究:基于Tapio脱钩模型和协整理论.经济问题探索,2016,(6):41-48.[Zhou Yinxiang.Study on the decoupling and coupling relationship of traffic carbon sequestration and industrial economic growth:Based on Tapio decoupling model and cointegration theory.Inquiry Into Economic Issues,2016,(6):41-48.]
[46]Llorca-Rodríguez C M,Casas-Jurado A C,García-Fernández R M.Tourism and poverty alleviation:An empirical analysis using panel data on Peru's departments.International Journal of Tourism Research,2017,19(6):746-756.
[47]赵磊.旅游发展与经济增长:来自中国的经验证据.旅游学刊,2015,30(4):33-49.[Zhao Lei.Tourism development and economic growth:Empirical evidence from China.Tourism Tribune,2015,30(4):33-49.]
[48]程晓丽,王逢春.安徽省旅游产业发展与经济增长相关性分析.经济地理,2014,34(3):182-186.[Cheng Xiaoli,Wang Fengchun.The correlation analysis of tourism industry development and economic growth of Anhui.Economic Geography,2014,34(3):33-49.]
[49]陆林,刘莹莹.旅游教育与旅游业发展时空相关性分析.高等农业教育,2009,(8):17-21.[Lu Lin,Liu Yingying.Spatio-temporal correlation analysis between tourism education and tourism development.Higher Agricultural Education,2009,(8):17-21.]
[50]张广海,刘真真,李盈昌.中国沿海省份旅游产业发展水平综合评价及时空格局演变.地域研究与开发,2013,32(4):22-27.[Zhang Guanghai,Liuzhenzhen,Li Yingchang.Comprehensive evaluation and temporal-spatial evolution of the development level of tourism in China’s coastal provinces.Areal Research and Development,2013,32(4):22-27.]