摘要
信任是经济交换的润滑剂,也是社会资本的重要内容之一。高信任社会的交易成本更低,人们的合作倾向更高,这都有利于经济发展。实证研究的结果也表明,更高水平的信任带来更高的投资水平和经济增长,国家也有更高的收入水平。信任对经济发展的促进机制是:信任可以促进合作,促进金融发展,促进创新,提高政府效率,改进劳动力市场,提高人们的幸福感。我国在市场化转型后,不诚信事件频发,导致人际信任降低。建议加强法制建设、建立声誉机制、加强道德教育重建社会诚信和信任,以促进经济社会发展。
Trust is the lubricant of economic exchange and an important part of social capital. The transaction cost of a high-trust society is lower and people tend to cooperate more, which is conducive to economic development. The results of empirical research also show that a higher level of trust leads to a higher level of investment and economic growth, and a higher income level in countries. The promotion mechanisms of trust on economic development are: trust can promote cooperation,financial development and innovation, and can improve government efficiency, the labor market and people's well-being as well. In China's transition towards market economy, the frequent discredit incidents lead to the decline of mutual trust. The foremost measures of improving the level of trust are to advance the legislation, establish a creditability mechanism, and underline education on ethics to reinstate social integrity and trust.
引文
[1]霍布斯.利维坦[M].北京:商务印书馆,1985.
[2]Coleman J.Foundations of Social Theory[M].Harvard University Press,1990.
[3]Dasgupta,Partha,Economic Progress and the Idea of Social Capital[J].Social Capital:A Multifaceted Perspective,2000,Washington DC:World Bank.
[4]Fukuyama F.Trust:The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity[M].New York:Free Press,1995.
[5]Putnam R,Bowling Alone:The Collapse and Revival of American Community[M].New York:Simon and SchusteR,2000.
[6]Guiso L,Sapienza P,Zingales L.Civic Capital as the Missing Link[J].Handbook of Social Economics,2011,Volume 1A,Jess Benhabib,Alberto Bisin,and Matthew O Jackson,eds.
[7]North D.Institutions,Institutional Change and Economic Performance[M].New York:Cambridge University Press,1990.
[8]Williamson O E.The Economic Institutions of Capitalism[M].New York:The Free Press,1985.
[9]Almond G,Verba S.The Civic Culture:Political Attitudes and Democracy in Five Nations[M].London:Sage Publications,1963.
[10]Algan Y,Cahuc P.Trust and Human Development:Overview and Policy[J].Handbook of Economic Growth,2013,P Aghion and S Durlauf(ed),North Holland,Elsevier.
[11]Berg J,Dickhaut J,McCabe K.Trust,Reciprocity and Social History[J].Games and Economic Behavior,1995,10:122-42.
[12]西美尔.货币哲学[M].北京:华夏出版社,2002.
[13]Luhmann N.Trust and Power[M].NewYork:John Wiley,1979.
[14]Uslaner E.Producing and Consuming Trust[J].Political Science Quarterly,2000,115,(4),569-590.
[15]Arrow K.Gifts and Exchange[J].Philosophy and Public Affairs,1972,Vol 1(4),343-362.
[16]Acemoglu D,Robinson J,Johnson S.The Colonial Origins of Comparative Development:An Empirical Investigation[J].American Economic Review,2001,91:1369-1401.
[17]Platteau J P.Behind the Market Stage Where Real Societies Exist[J].Journal of Development Studies,1994,30(3),533-577,753-817.
[18]Amartya K Sen.Development as Freedom[M].New York:Anchor Books,1999.
[19]Knack S.Social Capital,Growth and Poverty:A Survey of Cross-country Evidence[R].World Bank Social Capital Initiative Working Paper NO 7,1999.
[20]Schmidt K.Is Trust Important for Economic Development and Growth?[R].Working paper,2003.
[21]Putnam R,Leonardi R,Nanetti RY.Making Democracy Work[M].Princeton,NJ:Princeton University Press,1993.
[22]La Porta,Rafael,Lopez-de-Silanes F,Shleifer A,Vishny R.Trust in Large Organizations[J].American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings,1997,87(2):333-8.
[23]Tabellini,G.Institutions and Culture[J].Journal of the European Economic,2008b.6:255-294.
[24]Alesina A and La Ferrara E.Who Trust Others?[J].Journal of Public Economics,2002,Vol(85)2,pp 207-234.
[25]Zak P J,Knack S.Trust and growth[J].Economic Journal,2001,Vol 111,295-321.
[26]Knack S,Keefer P.Does Social Capital Have an Economic Payoff?A Cross-Country Investigation[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1997,Vol 112(4),1252-88.
[27]Dincer O and Uslaner E.Trust and Growth[J].Public Choice,2010,Vol 142(1),pages 59-67.
[28]Beugelsdijk S,H L F de Groot,and A B T M van SchaiK.Trust and Economic Growth:A Robustness Analysis[J].Oxford Economic Papers,2004,56,118-134.
[29]Kasmaoui K,Mughal M,Bouoiyour J.Does Trust Influence Economic Growth?Evidence from the Arab World[J].Economics Bulletin,2018,Vol 38,Issue 2,pages 880-891.
[30]Ahmad M and Hall S G.Trust-based Social Capital,Economic Growth and Property Rights:Explaining the Relationship[J].International Journal of Social Economics,2017,Vol 44 NO 1,pp 21-52.
[31]崔巍,陈琨.社会信任对经济增长的影响——基于经济收敛模型的视角[J].经济与管理研究,2016(8):14-22
[32]崔巍.社会信任及其经济意义[J].社会科学辑刊,2010(6):61-65.
[33]齐春宇,孙力军,李修彪.信任与经济增长1949—2014——基于1934年中国21省民间借贷利率测度信任[J].现代经济探讨,2018(5):6-13.
[34]Bisin A,Verdier T.The Economics of Cultural Transmission and the Dynamics of Preferences[J].Journal of Economic Theory,2001,97,298-319.
[35]Guiso L,Sapienza P,Zingales L.Alfred Marshall Lecture:Social Capital as Good Culture[J].Journal of the European Economic Association,2008c,6(2-3):295-320.
[36]Tabellini G.Culture and Institutions:Economic Development in the Regions of Europe[J].Journal of the European Economic Association,2010,8(4),pP 677-716.
[37]Guiso L.,Sapienza,P.,Zingales,L.Long Term Persistence[R].Working Paper 14278,National Bureau of Economic Research August 2008.
[38]Algan Y,Cahuc P.Inherited Trust and Growth[J].American Economic Review,2010,100:2060-2092.
[39]Guiso L,Sapienza P,Zingales L.Does Culture Affect Economic Outcomes?[J].Journal of Economic Perspectives,2006,Vol 20(2),pp 23-48.
[40]Ljunge M.Inherited Trust and Economic Success of second generation immigrants[R].IFN Working paper,2012.
[41]Butler J,Paola G,Guiso L.The Right Amount of Trust[R].NBER Working paper 15344,2009.
[42]Blau P.Exchange and Power in Social Life[M].New York:Wiley,1964.
[43]Ledyard J.Public Goods:A Survey of Experimental Research[J].Handbook of Experimental Economics,1995.
[44]Lawler E E.The Ultimate Advantage:Creating the High-inVolvement Organization[M].San Francisco:Jossey-Bass,1992,
[45]Nooteboom B.Social Capital,Institutions and Trust[J].Review of Social Economy,2007,65,29-53.
[46]Anderson L R,Jennifer M M and Jeffrey M.“Social Capital and Contributions in a Public Goods Experiment”[J].American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings,2004,94(2),pP 373-376.
[47]Karlan D.Using Experimental Economics to Measure Social Capital and Predict Financial Aprisions[J].American Economic Review,2005,95(5),pP 1688-1699.
[48]Barr A,Serneels P.Reciprocity in the workplace[J].Experimental Economics,2009,12(1),pP 99-112.
[49]陈叶烽,叶航,汪丁丁.信任水平的测度及其对合作的影响——来自一组实验微观数据的证据[J].管理世界,2010(4):54-64.
[50]Bennett R,Gabriel H.Image building for charitable organizations[J].Social Marketing Quarterly,2000,6,77-80.
[51]Brown E,Ferris J M.Social capital and philanthropy:An analysis of the impact of social capital on individual giving and Volunteering[J].Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly,2007,36,85-99.
[52]Wang L,Graddy E.Social capital,Volunteering,and charitable giving[J].Voluntas:International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations,2008,19,23-42.
[53]Greif A.Contract Enforceability and Economic Institutions in Early Trade:The Maghribi Traders’ Coalition[J].American Economic Review,1993,83 525-48.
[54]Milgrom P,North D,Weingast B.The Role of Institutions in the Revival of Trade:The Law Mechant,Private Judges,and the Champagne Fairs[J].Economics and Politics,1990,2:1-23.
[55]狄亚哥·甘贝塔.西西里黑手党.社会信任解体的代价[J].犯罪研究,2014(1):93-103.
[56]李明贤,周蓉.社会信任、关系网络与合作社社员资金互助行为——基于一个典型案例研究[J].农业经济问题,2018(5):103-113.
[57]蔡起华,朱玉春.社会信任、关系网络与农户参与农村公共产品供给[J].中国农村经济,2015(7):57-69.
[58]杨柳,朱玉春.社会信任、合作能力与农户参与小农水供给行为——基于黄河灌区五省数据的验证[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2016(3):163-170.
[59]Guiso L,Sapienza P,Zingales L.The Role of Social Capital in Financial Development[J].American Economic Review,2004,Vol 94,N 3,pP 526-56.
[60]Guiso L,Sapienza P,Zingales L.Trusting the Stock Market[J].Journal of Finance,2008a,63(6),pages 2557-2600.
[61]Guiso,L and Jappelli,T,2005,Awarness and Stock Market Participation[J].Review of Finance,9(4),537-567.
[62]Cole S,Gine X,Tobacman J,Townsend R,Vickery J.Barriers to HouseholdRisk Management:Evidence from India[J].American Economic Journal:Applied Economics,2013,VOL 5,NO 1,pP 104-35.
[63]Lins K V,Servaes H,Tamayo A.Social Capital,Trust,and Firm Performance:The Value of Corporate Social Responsibility during the Financial Crisis[J].The Journal of Finance,August 2017.
[64]Bottazzi L,Rin M D,Hellmann T.The Importance of Trust for Investment:Evidence from Venture Capital[J].The Review of Financial Studies,2016,Vol 29 NO 9.
[65]陈颐.儒家文化、社会信任与普惠金融[J].财贸经济,2017(4):5-20.
[66]李俊青,李双建,赵旭霞.社会信任、收益率波动与银行风险[J].财贸经济,2017(11):55-69.
[67]马红鸽.个人禀赋、社会信任与新农保参与研究——基于新农保参与过程选择的视角[J].统计与信息论坛,2016(3):44-51.
[68]Cingano F,Pinotti P.Trust,Firm Organization,and the Structure of Production[R].Working paper,2012.
[69]Bloom N,Sadun R,J Van Reenen.The Organization of Firms Across Countries[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,2012,127(4):1663-1705.
[70]王伟.社会信任、政治关系与民营企业商业信用模式[J].广东财经大学学报,2015(2):22-35.
[71]李晓梅.社会信任与文化价值观对于国家创新绩效的作用研究——基于65个样本国家的实证研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理,2013(8):93-101.
[72]Volken T.Elements of Trust:The Cultural Dimension of Internet Diffusion Revisited[J].Electronic Journal of Sociology,2002.
[73]Bornschier V,Volken T.Trust and the Disposition to Change in Cross-National Perspective:A Research Note[J].Electronic Journal of Sociology,2005,7:1-27.
[74]Knack S.Social Capital and the Quality of Government:Evidence from the United StateS Policy[R].Research Working Paper;NO 2504,2000,World Bank,Washington,DC.
[75]Uslaner E M.Trust and Corruption Revisited:How and Why Trust and Corruption Shape Each Other[J].Quality and Quantity,2013,47(6)pp 3603-3608.
[76]Uslaner E M.Corruption,Inequality,and the Rule of Law[M].New York,Cambridge University Press,2008.
[77]Uslaner E M.The Moral Foundations of Trust[M].New York,Cambridge University Press,2002.
[78]Messner SF,Baumer EP,Rosenfeld R.Dimensions of Social Capital and Rates of Criminal Homicide[J].American Sociological Review,2004,69:882-903.
[79]Wike R,Holzwart K,Where Trust is High,Crime and Corruption are Low[R].Pew Global Attitudes Project,2008,http://www pewglobal org.
[80]陈捷,呼和·那日松,卢春龙.社会信任与基层社区治理效应的因果机制[J].社会,2011(6):22-40.
[81]Coleman J.Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital[J].American Journal of Sociology,1988,94:S95-S120.
[82]Goldin,Claudia,Lawrence F Katz.Human Capital and Social Capital:The Rise of Secondary Schooling in America,1910 to 1940[R].NBER Working Paper,1998,NO 6439,Cambridge,MA.
[83]Barefoot J C,Maynard K E,Beckham J C,Brummett B H,Hooker K,Siegler I C.Trust,Health,and Longevity[J].Journal of Behavioral Medicine,1998,21,517-526.
[84]Kawachi I,Kennedy B P,Glass R.Social Capital and Self-rated Health:A Contextual Analysis[J].American Journal of Public Health,1999,89,1187-1193.
[85]Subramanian S V,Kim D J,and Kawachi I.Social Trust and Self-Rated Health in US Communities:A Multilevel Analysis[J].Journal of Urban Health:Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine,2002,Vol 79,NO 4,S21-S34.
[86]Kawachi I,Kennedy B P,Lochner K,Prothrow-Stith D.Social Capital,Income Inequality,and Mortality[J].American Journal of Public Health,1997,87:1491-8.
[87]朱慧劼,姚兆余.社会信任对城市居民健康状况的影响[J].城市问题,2015(9):94-98.
[88]Aghion P,Algan Y,Cahuc P.Can Policy Affect Culture?Minimum Wage and the Quality of Labor Relations[J].Journal of the European Economic Association,2011,Vol 9(1):3-42.
[89]Algan Y,Cahuc P.Civic Virtue and Labor Market Institutions[J].American Economic Journal:Macroeconomics,2009,1(1):111-145.
[90]霍鹏,张静宜,彭楚乔,等.社会互动与信任对农民参与“新农保”行为的影响研究[J].农业技术经济,2016(6):68-76.
[91]高虹,陆铭.社会信任对劳动力流动的影响——中国农村整合型社会资本的作用及其地区差异[J].中国农村经济,2010(3):12-24,34.
[92]王宇,王士权.社会信任与农村劳动力代际职业流动[J].农业技术经济,2017(11):92-103.
[93]金枭枭,侯志阳.社会信任、社会认同与社会距离研究——以农民工为视角的实证分析[J].武汉理工大学学报,2017(2):88-96.
[94]Christian Bj?rnskov.The Happy Few:Cross——Country Evidence on Social Capital and Life Satisfaction[J].Kyklos,Wiley Blackwell,2003,Vol 56(1),pages 3-16.
[95]Helliwell J F,Wang S.Trust and Well-Being[J].International Journal of Wellbeing,2011,Vol 1,NO 1,pp 42-78.
[96]Helliwell J F.Well-Being and Social Capital:Does Suicide Pose a Puzzle?[J].Social Indicators Research,2007,81:455-96.
[97]Calvo R,Zheng Y,Kumar S,Olgiati A,Berkman L.Well-Being and Social Capital on Planet Earth:Cross-National Evidence from 142 Countries[J].2012,PLOS ONE 7(8):e42793.
[98]Rodriguez-Pose A,von Berlepsch,V.Social Capital and Individual Happiness in Europe[J].Journal of Happiness Studies,2014,15,357-386.
[99]Elgar F J,Davis C G,Wohl M J,Trites S J,Zelenski J M,Martin M S.Social Capital,Health and Life Satisfaction in 50 Countries[J].Health & Place,2011,17,1044-1053.
[100]Veljko JovanoviTrust and Subjective Well-being:The Case of S erbia[J].Personality and Individual Differences,Volume 98,August 2016,Pages 284-288.
[101]Siedlecki K L,Salthouse T A,Oishi S,Jeswani S.The Relationship Between Social Support and Subjective Wellbeing Across Age[J].Social Indicators Research,2014,117,561-576.
[102]Helliwell J F,Layard R,Sachs J.World Happiness Report[R].New York:Earth Institute,Columbia University,2015.
[103]Tay L,Herian M N,Diener E.Detrimental Effects of Corruption and Subjective Well-being:Whether,How,and When[J].Social Psychological and Personality Science,2014,5,751-759.
[104]Helliwell J F,Huang H,Wang S.Social Capital and Well-being in Times of Crisis[J].Journal of Happiness Studies,2014,15,145162.
[105]Habibov N,Afandi E.Pre- and Post-crisis Life Satisfaction and Social Trust Intransitional Countries:An initial Assessment[J].Social Indicators Research,2015,121,503-524.
[106]Hamilton K,Helliwell J,Woolcock M.Social Capital,Trust,and Well-being in the Evaluation of Wealth[R].Policy Research Working Paper 7707,2016,Poverty and Inequality Team,Development Research Group,World Bank.
[107]袁正,夏波.信任与幸福:基于WVS 的中国微观数据[J].中国经济问题,2012(6):163-170.
[108]金明,杨炳成.城市居民主观幸福感驱动因素——基于吉林省长春市的调查与分析[J].税务与经济,2018(6):104-110.
[109]孟德斯鸠.论法的精神[M].北京:北京出版社,2007.
[110]Smith A H.Chinese Characteristics[M].New York:Fleming H .Revell,1894.
[111]Weber M.The Religion of China :Confucianism and Taoism[M].New York :The Free Press,1951.
[112]Redding G.The Spirit of Chinese Capitalis[M].Berlin:Walter de Gruyter,1990.
[113]Greif A,Tabellini G.Cultural and Institutional Bifurcation:China and Europe Compared[J].American Economic Review,2010,VOL 100,NO 2,135-40.
[114]中共中央宣传部.习近平总书记系列重要讲话读本[M].北京:学习出版社/人民出版社,2016.
[115]论语[M].北京:中华书局,2016.
(1)国外学者和民众感觉我国缺乏普遍的信任,但调查数据显示我国是高信任度社会。
(2)张维迎:《重建信任》,中国经济50人论坛,2002年。
(3)刘伟:《关于我国市场主体失信的原因思考》,中国经济50人论坛,2006年。
(4)全球态度调查(Pew Global Attitudes survey)2007年结果显示,中国排在第一位,79%的中国人同意大部分人是值得信任的。