循证口腔医学25年:从理念迈向实践
|
摘要
自Cochrane口腔健康组于1994年成立以来,循证口腔医学已历经25年的发展。相关理念及方法逐渐得到了国内外口腔医学领域专家学者及医护人员的广泛认同,并已成为口腔诊疗、教学、研究和政策制订中不可或缺的重要组成部分。本文将简要介绍循证口腔医学过去25年的主要发展历程,并对其未来发展方向作一展望,以帮助国内同行更好地理解循证口腔医学的本质及价值,推动循证口腔医学研究与实践在我国的进一步发展。
Since the establishment of Cochrane Oral Health Group in 1994,evidence-based dentistry(EBD)has been developed for 25 years.EBD-related concepts and methods have gradually gained recognition from dental experts and healthcare providers,and have become an integral component of dental care,education,research and policy-making.In order to help Chinese colleagues to achieve a better understanding of the essence and value of EBD,and to facilitate the further development of evidence-based dental research and practice in China,this article will briefly introduce the progress of EBD during the past 25 years and discuss its future prospect.
Since the establishment of Cochrane Oral Health Group in 1994,evidence-based dentistry(EBD)has been developed for 25 years.EBD-related concepts and methods have gradually gained recognition from dental experts and healthcare providers,and have become an integral component of dental care,education,research and policy-making.In order to help Chinese colleagues to achieve a better understanding of the essence and value of EBD,and to facilitate the further development of evidence-based dental research and practice in China,this article will briefly introduce the progress of EBD during the past 25 years and discuss its future prospect.
引文
[1] Djulbegovic B,Guyatt G.Progress in evidence-based medicine:aquarter century on[J].Lancet,2017,390(10092)∶415-423
[2] Guyatt G.Evidence-based medicine[J].ACP J Club,1991,A-16∶114
[3] British Medical Journal Publishing Group.Iain Chalmers:Guilty,obsessional,and frustrated[J].BMJ,2013,347∶f6152
[4] Sackett DL,Rosenberg WM,Gray JA,et al.Evidence based medicine:what it is and what it isn't[J].BMJ,1996,312(7023)∶71-72
[5] Antczak-Bouckoms A,Shaw WC.The cochrane collaboration:oral health group[J].J Dent Res,1994,73(11)∶1674-1676
[6] Tavender EJ,Glenny AM.The cochrane collaboration:the oral health group[J].J Dent Educ,2002,66(5)∶612-616
[7] Richards D.Twenty years of the Centre for Evidence-based Dentistry[J].Evid Based Dent,2015,16(2)∶34
[8] Richards D,Lawrence A.Evidence based dentistry[J].Br Dent J,1995,179(7)∶270-273
[9]Hutter J.The history of evidence-based dentistry in the ADA[J].J Evid Based Dent Pract,2004,4(1)∶8-11
[10] EBD.Scotland launches clinical effectiveness initiative[J].J Evid Based Dent Pract,2005,6(2)∶51-52
[11] Newman MG,Baudendistel CL.A letter from the editorin-chief and the publisher[J].J Evid Based Dent Pract,2001,1(1)∶1-2
[12] Marinho VC,Richards D,Niederman R.Variation,certainty,evidence,and change in dental education:employing evidence-based dentistry in dental education[J].J Dent Educ,2001,65(5)∶449-455
[13] Kersten HW,Vervoorn JM,Zijlstra AE,et al.Development and implementation of new educational concepts in a dental curriculum[J].Eur J Dent Educ,2007,11(1)∶2-9
[14] Levine AE,Bebermeyer RD,Chen JW,et al.Development of an interdisciplinary course in information resources and evidence-based dentistry[J].J Dent Educ,2008,72(9)∶1067-1076
[15] Maggio LA,Jeffery KM.Helping a dental school put the“e”in evidence-based dentistry[J].Journal of the Medical Library Association,2008,96(2)∶152-155
[16] Winning T,Needleman I,Rohlin M,et al.Evidence-based care and the curriculum[J].Eur J Dent Educ,2008,12Suppl 1∶48-63
[17] Harrison JE.Evidence-based orthodontics:Where do I find the evidence?[J].J Orthod,2000,27(1)∶71-78
[18] Needleman I,Moles DR,Worthington H.Evidence-based periodontology,systematic reviews and research quality[J].Periodontol 2000,2005,37∶12-28
[19]郑家伟.循证牙医学[J].上海口腔医学,2001,10(1)∶96
[20]周正炎.循证医学--21世纪医学的新模式[J].口腔颌面外科杂志,2001,11(1)∶1-3
[21]章魁华,刘宏伟,陈永.关于循证医学[J].中华口腔医学杂志,2001,36(5)∶394-395
[22]史宗道.循证医学与口腔医学[J].上海口腔医学,2001,10(4)∶289-291
[23]徐琼,樊明文.循证医学及其在口腔医学中的应用[J].国外医学口腔医学分册,2003,30(2)∶85-87
[24]徐凌,柴枫,巢永烈.循证口腔医学的发展现状及展望[J].国外医学口腔医学分册,2003,30(2)∶88-90
[25]史宗道,石冰,陈娥,郭春岚.我国口腔医学领域应用临床流行病学与循证医学的现状[J].中华口腔医学杂志,2002,37(6)∶472-474
[26]邱蔚六.重视循证医学、学习循证医学、应用循证医学[J].中国口腔颌面外科杂志,2003,1(2)∶65
[27]史宗道.循证口腔医学[J].口腔正畸学,2002,9(4)∶181-185
[28]史宗道.循证口腔医学(第2版)[M].北京:人民卫生出版社,2008
[29] Shi Z,Guo C,Awad M.Hyaluronate for temporomandibular joint disorders[J].Cochrane Database Syst Rev,2003,(1)∶CD002970
[30] Del Fabbro M,Corbella S,Tsesis I,et al.The trend of quality of publications in endodontic surgery:a 10-year systematic survey of the literature[J].J Evid Based Dent Pract,2015,15(1)∶2-7
[31] Gibson R,Harrison J.What are we reading?An analysis of the orthodontic literature 1999to 2008[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2011,139(5)∶e471-e484
[32] Livas C,Pandis N,Ren Y.Time relevance,citation of reporting guidelines,and breadth of literature search in systematic reviews in orthodontics[J].Eur J Orthod,2015,37(2)∶183-187
[33] Agnihotry A,Fedorowicz Z,Worthington HV,et al.Systematic reviews in oral health:aquality imperative[J].J Evid Based Med,2016,9(2)∶47-52
[34]Mubeen S,Patel K,Cunningham Z,et al.Assessing the quality of dental clinical practice guidelines[J].J Dent,2017,67∶102-106
[35]曾宪涛,吴凡,邬兰,等.中国口腔医学领域临床实践指南的循证评价[J].中国循证医学杂志,2015,15(3)∶264-269
[36]陈薇,刘建平.循证临床实践指南的制订和评价Ⅰ.循证临床实践指南编制的方法[J].中华口腔医学杂志,2013,48(2)∶109-111
[37] Fleming PS,Koletsi D,O'Brien K,et al.Are dental researchers asking patient-important questions?A scoping review[J].J Dent,2016,49∶9-13
[38] Saltaji H,Armijo-Olivo S,Cummings GG,et al.Randomized clinical trials in dentistry:Risks of bias,risks of random errors,reporting quality,and methodologic quality over the years 1955-2013[J].PLoS One,2017,12(12)∶e0190089
[39] Tsichlaki A,O'Brien K.Do orthodontic research outcomes reflect patient values?A systematic review of randomized controlled trials involving children[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2014,146(3)∶279-285
[40] Hua F,Deng L,Kau CH,et al.Reporting quality of randomized controlled trial abstracts:survey of leading general dental journals[J].J Am Dent Assoc,2015,146(9)∶669-678
[41] Koletsi D,Pandis N,Polychronopoulou A,et al.What's in a title?An assessment of whether randomized controlled trial in a title means that it is one[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2012,141(6)∶679-685
[42] Fleming PS,Koletsi D,Polychronopoulou A,et al.Are clustering effects accounted for in statistical analysis in leading dental specialty journals?[J].J Dent,2013,41(3)∶265-270
[43] Chalmers I,Glasziou P.Avoidable waste in the production and reporting of research evidence[J].Lancet,2009,374(9683)∶86-89
[44] Fleming PS,Lynch CD,Pandis N.Randomized controlled trials in dentistry:Common pitfalls and how to avoid them[J].J Dent,2014,42(8)∶908-914
[45]花放,贺红.个体内临床试验报告规范(CONSORT for WPT)解读[J].中国循证医学杂志,2018,18(9)∶1001-1006
[46] Pandis N,Fleming PS,Hopewell S,et al.The CONSORT statement:application within and adaptations for orthodontic trials[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2015,147(6)∶663-679
[47] Hua F,Walsh T,Glenny AM,et al.Surveys on reporting guideline usage in dental journals[J].J Dent Res,2016,95(11)∶1207-1213
[48] Pandis N,Shamseer L,Kokich VG,et al.Active implementation strategy of CONSORT adherence by a dental specialty journal improved randomized clinical trial reporting[J].J Clin Epidemiol,2014,67(9)∶1044-1048
[49] Clarkson JE,Turner S,Grimshaw JM,et al.Changing clinicians'behavior:a randomized controlled trial of fees and education[J].J Dent Res,2008,87(7)∶640-644
[50] Clarkson JE,Ramsay CR,Eccles MP,et al.The translation research in a dental setting(TRiaDS)programme protocol[J].Implement Sci,2010,5:57
[51]杨智荣,孙凤,詹思延.偏倚风险评估系列:(二)平行设计随机对照试验偏倚评估工具2.0介绍[J].中华流行病学杂志,2017,38(9)∶1285-1291
[52] Taylor J,Walsh T,Worthington H,et al.Cochrane and the COMET initiative:developing the evidence base in oral medicine[J].Br Dent J,2017,223(9)∶729-732
[53]孙鑫,谭婧,唐立,等.重新认识真实世界研究[J].中国循证医学杂志,2017,17(2)∶126-130
[54] Hua F,Sun H,Walsh T,et al.Open access to journal articles in dentistry:Prevalence and citation impact[J].J Dent,2016,47∶41-48
[55]林伟青,田然,赵晨,等.促进临床试验数据共享,提高临床试验的透明化[J].中国循证医学杂志,2018,18(6)∶540-542
[56] Kwag KH,Gonzalez-Lorenzo M,Banzi R,et al.Providing doctors with high-quality information:an updated evaluation of web-based point-of-care information summaries[J].J Med Internet Res,2016,18(1)∶e15
[57]唐金陵,李立明.关于循证医学、精准医学和大数据研究的几点看法[J].中华流行病学杂志,2018,39(1)∶1-7
[2] Guyatt G.Evidence-based medicine[J].ACP J Club,1991,A-16∶114
[3] British Medical Journal Publishing Group.Iain Chalmers:Guilty,obsessional,and frustrated[J].BMJ,2013,347∶f6152
[4] Sackett DL,Rosenberg WM,Gray JA,et al.Evidence based medicine:what it is and what it isn't[J].BMJ,1996,312(7023)∶71-72
[5] Antczak-Bouckoms A,Shaw WC.The cochrane collaboration:oral health group[J].J Dent Res,1994,73(11)∶1674-1676
[6] Tavender EJ,Glenny AM.The cochrane collaboration:the oral health group[J].J Dent Educ,2002,66(5)∶612-616
[7] Richards D.Twenty years of the Centre for Evidence-based Dentistry[J].Evid Based Dent,2015,16(2)∶34
[8] Richards D,Lawrence A.Evidence based dentistry[J].Br Dent J,1995,179(7)∶270-273
[9]Hutter J.The history of evidence-based dentistry in the ADA[J].J Evid Based Dent Pract,2004,4(1)∶8-11
[10] EBD.Scotland launches clinical effectiveness initiative[J].J Evid Based Dent Pract,2005,6(2)∶51-52
[11] Newman MG,Baudendistel CL.A letter from the editorin-chief and the publisher[J].J Evid Based Dent Pract,2001,1(1)∶1-2
[12] Marinho VC,Richards D,Niederman R.Variation,certainty,evidence,and change in dental education:employing evidence-based dentistry in dental education[J].J Dent Educ,2001,65(5)∶449-455
[13] Kersten HW,Vervoorn JM,Zijlstra AE,et al.Development and implementation of new educational concepts in a dental curriculum[J].Eur J Dent Educ,2007,11(1)∶2-9
[14] Levine AE,Bebermeyer RD,Chen JW,et al.Development of an interdisciplinary course in information resources and evidence-based dentistry[J].J Dent Educ,2008,72(9)∶1067-1076
[15] Maggio LA,Jeffery KM.Helping a dental school put the“e”in evidence-based dentistry[J].Journal of the Medical Library Association,2008,96(2)∶152-155
[16] Winning T,Needleman I,Rohlin M,et al.Evidence-based care and the curriculum[J].Eur J Dent Educ,2008,12Suppl 1∶48-63
[17] Harrison JE.Evidence-based orthodontics:Where do I find the evidence?[J].J Orthod,2000,27(1)∶71-78
[18] Needleman I,Moles DR,Worthington H.Evidence-based periodontology,systematic reviews and research quality[J].Periodontol 2000,2005,37∶12-28
[19]郑家伟.循证牙医学[J].上海口腔医学,2001,10(1)∶96
[20]周正炎.循证医学--21世纪医学的新模式[J].口腔颌面外科杂志,2001,11(1)∶1-3
[21]章魁华,刘宏伟,陈永.关于循证医学[J].中华口腔医学杂志,2001,36(5)∶394-395
[22]史宗道.循证医学与口腔医学[J].上海口腔医学,2001,10(4)∶289-291
[23]徐琼,樊明文.循证医学及其在口腔医学中的应用[J].国外医学口腔医学分册,2003,30(2)∶85-87
[24]徐凌,柴枫,巢永烈.循证口腔医学的发展现状及展望[J].国外医学口腔医学分册,2003,30(2)∶88-90
[25]史宗道,石冰,陈娥,郭春岚.我国口腔医学领域应用临床流行病学与循证医学的现状[J].中华口腔医学杂志,2002,37(6)∶472-474
[26]邱蔚六.重视循证医学、学习循证医学、应用循证医学[J].中国口腔颌面外科杂志,2003,1(2)∶65
[27]史宗道.循证口腔医学[J].口腔正畸学,2002,9(4)∶181-185
[28]史宗道.循证口腔医学(第2版)[M].北京:人民卫生出版社,2008
[29] Shi Z,Guo C,Awad M.Hyaluronate for temporomandibular joint disorders[J].Cochrane Database Syst Rev,2003,(1)∶CD002970
[30] Del Fabbro M,Corbella S,Tsesis I,et al.The trend of quality of publications in endodontic surgery:a 10-year systematic survey of the literature[J].J Evid Based Dent Pract,2015,15(1)∶2-7
[31] Gibson R,Harrison J.What are we reading?An analysis of the orthodontic literature 1999to 2008[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2011,139(5)∶e471-e484
[32] Livas C,Pandis N,Ren Y.Time relevance,citation of reporting guidelines,and breadth of literature search in systematic reviews in orthodontics[J].Eur J Orthod,2015,37(2)∶183-187
[33] Agnihotry A,Fedorowicz Z,Worthington HV,et al.Systematic reviews in oral health:aquality imperative[J].J Evid Based Med,2016,9(2)∶47-52
[34]Mubeen S,Patel K,Cunningham Z,et al.Assessing the quality of dental clinical practice guidelines[J].J Dent,2017,67∶102-106
[35]曾宪涛,吴凡,邬兰,等.中国口腔医学领域临床实践指南的循证评价[J].中国循证医学杂志,2015,15(3)∶264-269
[36]陈薇,刘建平.循证临床实践指南的制订和评价Ⅰ.循证临床实践指南编制的方法[J].中华口腔医学杂志,2013,48(2)∶109-111
[37] Fleming PS,Koletsi D,O'Brien K,et al.Are dental researchers asking patient-important questions?A scoping review[J].J Dent,2016,49∶9-13
[38] Saltaji H,Armijo-Olivo S,Cummings GG,et al.Randomized clinical trials in dentistry:Risks of bias,risks of random errors,reporting quality,and methodologic quality over the years 1955-2013[J].PLoS One,2017,12(12)∶e0190089
[39] Tsichlaki A,O'Brien K.Do orthodontic research outcomes reflect patient values?A systematic review of randomized controlled trials involving children[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2014,146(3)∶279-285
[40] Hua F,Deng L,Kau CH,et al.Reporting quality of randomized controlled trial abstracts:survey of leading general dental journals[J].J Am Dent Assoc,2015,146(9)∶669-678
[41] Koletsi D,Pandis N,Polychronopoulou A,et al.What's in a title?An assessment of whether randomized controlled trial in a title means that it is one[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2012,141(6)∶679-685
[42] Fleming PS,Koletsi D,Polychronopoulou A,et al.Are clustering effects accounted for in statistical analysis in leading dental specialty journals?[J].J Dent,2013,41(3)∶265-270
[43] Chalmers I,Glasziou P.Avoidable waste in the production and reporting of research evidence[J].Lancet,2009,374(9683)∶86-89
[44] Fleming PS,Lynch CD,Pandis N.Randomized controlled trials in dentistry:Common pitfalls and how to avoid them[J].J Dent,2014,42(8)∶908-914
[45]花放,贺红.个体内临床试验报告规范(CONSORT for WPT)解读[J].中国循证医学杂志,2018,18(9)∶1001-1006
[46] Pandis N,Fleming PS,Hopewell S,et al.The CONSORT statement:application within and adaptations for orthodontic trials[J].Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop,2015,147(6)∶663-679
[47] Hua F,Walsh T,Glenny AM,et al.Surveys on reporting guideline usage in dental journals[J].J Dent Res,2016,95(11)∶1207-1213
[48] Pandis N,Shamseer L,Kokich VG,et al.Active implementation strategy of CONSORT adherence by a dental specialty journal improved randomized clinical trial reporting[J].J Clin Epidemiol,2014,67(9)∶1044-1048
[49] Clarkson JE,Turner S,Grimshaw JM,et al.Changing clinicians'behavior:a randomized controlled trial of fees and education[J].J Dent Res,2008,87(7)∶640-644
[50] Clarkson JE,Ramsay CR,Eccles MP,et al.The translation research in a dental setting(TRiaDS)programme protocol[J].Implement Sci,2010,5:57
[51]杨智荣,孙凤,詹思延.偏倚风险评估系列:(二)平行设计随机对照试验偏倚评估工具2.0介绍[J].中华流行病学杂志,2017,38(9)∶1285-1291
[52] Taylor J,Walsh T,Worthington H,et al.Cochrane and the COMET initiative:developing the evidence base in oral medicine[J].Br Dent J,2017,223(9)∶729-732
[53]孙鑫,谭婧,唐立,等.重新认识真实世界研究[J].中国循证医学杂志,2017,17(2)∶126-130
[54] Hua F,Sun H,Walsh T,et al.Open access to journal articles in dentistry:Prevalence and citation impact[J].J Dent,2016,47∶41-48
[55]林伟青,田然,赵晨,等.促进临床试验数据共享,提高临床试验的透明化[J].中国循证医学杂志,2018,18(6)∶540-542
[56] Kwag KH,Gonzalez-Lorenzo M,Banzi R,et al.Providing doctors with high-quality information:an updated evaluation of web-based point-of-care information summaries[J].J Med Internet Res,2016,18(1)∶e15
[57]唐金陵,李立明.关于循证医学、精准医学和大数据研究的几点看法[J].中华流行病学杂志,2018,39(1)∶1-7