中国循环农业发展评估——政策回顾与对辽中县的调研案例
|
摘要
循环农业涉及农业废弃物的循环性利用和资源保护等方面,在中国获得了越来越多的关注。当前对循环农业的政府干预手段较多,但目的和手段都不尽相同。因此,有必要对这些政策系统化,并进行深入了解,提出具体建议,以促进循环农业发展。研究总结中国有关循环农业发展的现行政策,揭示影响其发展的关键因素,选择辽宁省沈阳市辽中县为案例,通过比较分析循环农业和非循环农业的农业管理方式差异,揭示农民培训的重要性。研究结果表明,循环农业生产者使用农家肥的比例(38%)明显高于非循环农业生产者(6%),使用化肥的比例(90%)低于非循环农业生产者(98%)。每种作物的U-STAT和模式都显示循环农业生产者比非循环农业生产者使用更少的农家肥和化肥。循环农业生产者玉米的产量明显高于非循环农业生产者。许多循环农业生产者使用化肥,其数量与非循环农业生产者使用的并没有很大的区别。因此,为了推动循环农业发展,传授循环农业技术,开展具体技术培训和信息服务比简单的宣传更为重要。
Circular agriculture(CA) refers to the circular use of agricultural waste and the conservation of resources,which has attracted increasing attention in China.In 2015,the Ministry of Agriculture(MOA) and relevant ministries issued the National Plan of Sustainable Agricultural Development 2015-2030.The plan aims to promote CA and achieve zero emissions from agricultural waste by 2030.The MOA also issued bills to target zero growth of chemical fertilizers and pesticides by 2020.Many researchers have studied CA,and in order to disseminate CA techniques to farmers,they recommended interventions such as advertisements to enhance the recognition of CA,technical training,expanding farmland,increasing farmers' income,and support for leading enterprises.However,it is not clear from these studies whether the government has implemented any of these interventions.This study summarized current policies that contributed to CA,and revealed the factors impacting the development of the CA.Then,taking a case of Liaozhong County,itdemonstrated the importance of the training for farmers through the comparison of agricultural management between the farmers who recognize their farming as being CA(hereafter,circular farmers) and those of other farmers(hereafter,non-circular farmers).The household data were collected from six out of the 15 towns in the county in 2014.The total number of surveyed households was 525,of which 495 were considered valid for the management analysis.Collected data indicated 281 of the total 495 farmers produced corn,followed by rice,whole vegetables,and tomato.Theresults showed that the proportion of circular farmers using manure(38%) was obviously higher than that of non-circular farmers(6%).The proportion of corn farmers using chemical fertilizer(90%) was smaller than that of non-circular farmers(98%).On the other hand,the proportion of circular farmers who use chemical fertilizer for rice,vegetables,and tomatoes was higher than that of non-circular farmers.The U-stat and mode of each commodity indicated that circular farmers used less manure and similar amounts of chemical fertilizer than non-circular farmers.Circular farmers' production value of corn was significantly higher than that of non-circular farmers.However,as mentioned above,chemical fertilizer was used by many circular farmers and its quantity was not significantly different from that used by non-circular farmers.This was not consistent with the goal of the government.Thus,to enhance CA,specific technical training or information services would be more important than simple advertisements.
Circular agriculture(CA) refers to the circular use of agricultural waste and the conservation of resources,which has attracted increasing attention in China.In 2015,the Ministry of Agriculture(MOA) and relevant ministries issued the National Plan of Sustainable Agricultural Development 2015-2030.The plan aims to promote CA and achieve zero emissions from agricultural waste by 2030.The MOA also issued bills to target zero growth of chemical fertilizers and pesticides by 2020.Many researchers have studied CA,and in order to disseminate CA techniques to farmers,they recommended interventions such as advertisements to enhance the recognition of CA,technical training,expanding farmland,increasing farmers' income,and support for leading enterprises.However,it is not clear from these studies whether the government has implemented any of these interventions.This study summarized current policies that contributed to CA,and revealed the factors impacting the development of the CA.Then,taking a case of Liaozhong County,itdemonstrated the importance of the training for farmers through the comparison of agricultural management between the farmers who recognize their farming as being CA(hereafter,circular farmers) and those of other farmers(hereafter,non-circular farmers).The household data were collected from six out of the 15 towns in the county in 2014.The total number of surveyed households was 525,of which 495 were considered valid for the management analysis.Collected data indicated 281 of the total 495 farmers produced corn,followed by rice,whole vegetables,and tomato.Theresults showed that the proportion of circular farmers using manure(38%) was obviously higher than that of non-circular farmers(6%).The proportion of corn farmers using chemical fertilizer(90%) was smaller than that of non-circular farmers(98%).On the other hand,the proportion of circular farmers who use chemical fertilizer for rice,vegetables,and tomatoes was higher than that of non-circular farmers.The U-stat and mode of each commodity indicated that circular farmers used less manure and similar amounts of chemical fertilizer than non-circular farmers.Circular farmers' production value of corn was significantly higher than that of non-circular farmers.However,as mentioned above,chemical fertilizer was used by many circular farmers and its quantity was not significantly different from that used by non-circular farmers.This was not consistent with the goal of the government.Thus,to enhance CA,specific technical training or information services would be more important than simple advertisements.
引文
[1]尹昌斌,周颖编.循环农业发展理论与模式.北京:中国农业出版社,2008
[2]韩玉,龙攀,陈源泉,等.中国循环农业评价体系研究进展.中国生态农业学报,2013,21(9):1039~1048
[3]徐卫涛,张俊飚,李树明.影响农户参与循环农业工程的因素分析.中国人口·资源与环境,2010,20(8):33~37
[4]腾英,王生林.定西市农户参与循环农业的影响因素分析.中国农学通报,2014,30(11):90~96
[5]Xiong Y.Economic ecology benefit research of Combined Circular Agriculture.Int.J.BIO Automation,2010,8(2):131~140
[6]Xu H,Huang X,Zhong T,et al.Chinese land policies and farmers'adoption of organic fertilizer for saline soils.land Use Policy,2014,38:541~549
[7]农业部信息中心.福建省农业厅办公室关于印发2010年福建省测土配方施肥实施方案的通知.中国农业信息网,http://www.agri.cn/province/fujian/zcfg/dffg/201411/t20141114_4149.htm,2010
[8]黑龙江省农业委员会.关于印发2015年测土配方施肥补贴项目实施方案的通知.黑龙江省土肥信息网,http://www.hljstfz.org.cn/a/zhongyaotongzhi/2015/1022/4710.html,2015
[9]黑龙江省农业委员会.关于印发2015年耕地保护与质量提升补贴项目实施方案的通知.黑龙江省农业委员会电子政务,http://dzzw.hljagri.gov.cn/zwgk/nwwj/whwj/201510/t20151020_646313.htm,2015
[10]玉林市博白县农业局.2015年博白县耕地保护与质量提升项目实施方案.博白县农业信息网,http://hzsagri.gov.cn/yulin/bobai/zwgk_4999/tzgg_5004/201507/t20150720_451194.html,2015
[11]农业部办公厅.农业部办公厅关于印发2015年畜禽养殖标准化示范创建活动工作方案的通知,http://www.hbxmfw.com/czhn/HTML/36589.html,2015
[12]天门市畜牧兽医局.天门市2015年畜牧养殖标准化示范创建活动实施法案.天门畜牧信息网,http://www.tmxm.gov.cn/nzcms_show_news.asp?id=5764,2015
[13]呼伦贝尔市农牧业局.关于2015年畜禽粪污等农业农村废弃物综合利用试点项目的公示,http://www.hlbenm.gov.cn/show.asp?id=3143,2015
[14]农业部.2013年国家支持粮食增产农民增收的政策措施,http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/zcfg/qnhnzc/201303/t20130320_3354.htm,2013
[15]农业部.2014年国家深化农村改革、支持粮食生产、促进农民增收政策措施,http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/zcfg/qnhnzc/201404/t20140425_3884.htm,2014
[16]农业部.2015年国家深化农村改革、发展现代农业、促进农民增收政策措施,http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/zcfg/qnhnzc/201504/t20150430_4570.htm,2015
[17]宝剑久俊.中国の农业构造调整と农业经营の变容.一桥大学大学院经济学研究科博士学位申请论文.2015
[18]日本总合研究所.第1章中国における农业生产者の所得补偿政策と价格支持政策、主要国の农业情报调查分析报告书(平成22年度).农林水产省大臣官房国际部国际政策课、海外农业情报调查分析(アジア)报告书.平成22年度海外农业情报调查分析·国际相互理解事业,2011
[19]倪洪兴.中国农业支持政策研究.国际贸易和可持续发展中心,2013,47
[20]高杨.测土配方施肥:政府“搭台”企业“唱戏”:访农业部测土配方施肥专家组组长张福锁教授.农民日报,2012-06-18
[21]农业部.2015年畜牧标准化规模养殖扶持政策,http://www.tuliu.com/read-9212.html,2015
[22]中华畜牧业信息网.山西省扶持肉牛肉羊标准化规模养殖,http://www.cnxmy.com/Article_51_141458.html,2011
[23]中央政府门户网站.黑龙江将发展标准化规模养殖支持龙头企业自建基地,http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2014-04/11/content_2657.htm,2014
[24]呼伦贝尔市农牧业局.关于2015年畜禽粪污等农业农村废弃物综合利用试点项目的公示,http://www.hlbenm.gov.cn/show.asp?id=3143,2015
[25]宋丹瑛.中国における绿色食品认証制度の展开及び地域农业.地域政策研究,2008,10(3):65~76
[26]Zhao H.The development and present situation of“three kinds of food”certification system in China:Non-polluted food,green food and organic food.Journal of food system research,2009,16(2):14~28
[27]中国绿色食品发展中心.2010,2014.http://www.greenfood.agri.cn/zl/tjnb/
[28]农业部.我国强力推进无公害农产品和农产品地理标志,http://www.moa.gov.cn/ztzl/nyjj/2011nian/201103/t20110319_1950.htm,2011
[29]农业部.2014年全国绿色食品继续保持良好发展态势,http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/zwdt/201501/t20150119_4341.htm,2015
[30]农业部.无公害食品产地认定规范(NY/T 5343—2006),http://www.greenfood.org.cn/Html/2013_12_20/11444_15488_2013_12_20_26225.html,2013
[31]中国绿色食品发展中心.国家发展改革委关于印发绿色食品认证及标志使用收费管理办法的通知,http://www.greenfood.org.cn/Html/2007-1-25/2_1886_2007-1-25_2812.html,2007
[32]辽宁省农村经济委员会.2012年辽宁省无公害农产品、绿色食品、有机食品公告.http://www.lnjn.gov.cn/government/notice/shengfa/2013/7/495042.shtml,2013
[33]辽宁省农村经济委员会.辽宁省无公害农产品、绿色食品、有机食品公告(2013),http://www.lnjn.gov.cn/government/notice/shengfa/2014/5/551376.shtml,2014
[34]辽宁省农村经济委员会.辽宁省无公害农产品、绿色食品、有机食品公告(2014),http://www.lnjn.gov.cn/government/notice/shengfa/2015/12/595087.shtml,2015
[35]丁长琴.我国有机农业发展模式及理论探讨.农业技术经济,2012,2:122~128
[36]忻州市民政局.忻州市人民政府办公厅关于印发忻州市促进现代农业发展扶持办法的通知.忻州阳光农廉网,http://www.xznlw.gov.cn/html/fwms/nwh/2821.html,2015
[37]中共庐江县委员会.关于印发2014年合肥市促进现代农业发展政策实施细则通知.中国庐江,http://www.lj.gov.cn/contents/88814.html,2014
[38]曹汪斌,杨岩.中国有机野菜の生产·流通课题と管理监督制度(海外情报).农畜产业振兴机构.野菜情报,2013,110:48~55
[39]汪卫民.中国生态农业理论与实践.环境导报.1998,2:5~8
[40]农业部.农业部举行新闻发布会,有关负责人解读浙江现代生态循环农业发展试点省建设等相关情况:推进现代生态循环农业加快农业发展方式转变.农业部信息中心,http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/zwdt/201501/t20150106_4324.htm,2015
[41]常家亮,刘玉祥,王玉峰.晋城市循环农业发展的实践与探索.农业工程技术·新能源产业,2009,7:17~18
[42]国务院第二次全国农业普查领导小组办公室.中国第二次全国农业普查资料滙编(农业卷).北京:中国统计出版社,2009
[43]柳杨.辽中县农村养殖污染问题研究.长春:吉林大学,2012
[44]中华人民共和国环境保护部.生态县、生态市、生态省建设指标(修订稿),http://sts.mep.gov.cn/stsfcj/ghyzb/200801/t20080115_116249.htm,2008
[45]辽中县.2013年种植业工作总结及2014年工作计划.2014
[46]辽宁省人民政府.2014年辽中县政府工作报告:2014年12月29日在辽中县第十七届人民代表大会第三次会议上.辽中县人民政府,http://www.ln.gov.cn/zfxx/zfgzbg/jgzbg/lzx/201401/t20140116_1256.html,2014
[47]Bickel D.R.Robust estimators of the mode and skewness of continuous data.Computational Statistics&Data Analysis,2002,39:153~163
[2]韩玉,龙攀,陈源泉,等.中国循环农业评价体系研究进展.中国生态农业学报,2013,21(9):1039~1048
[3]徐卫涛,张俊飚,李树明.影响农户参与循环农业工程的因素分析.中国人口·资源与环境,2010,20(8):33~37
[4]腾英,王生林.定西市农户参与循环农业的影响因素分析.中国农学通报,2014,30(11):90~96
[5]Xiong Y.Economic ecology benefit research of Combined Circular Agriculture.Int.J.BIO Automation,2010,8(2):131~140
[6]Xu H,Huang X,Zhong T,et al.Chinese land policies and farmers'adoption of organic fertilizer for saline soils.land Use Policy,2014,38:541~549
[7]农业部信息中心.福建省农业厅办公室关于印发2010年福建省测土配方施肥实施方案的通知.中国农业信息网,http://www.agri.cn/province/fujian/zcfg/dffg/201411/t20141114_4149.htm,2010
[8]黑龙江省农业委员会.关于印发2015年测土配方施肥补贴项目实施方案的通知.黑龙江省土肥信息网,http://www.hljstfz.org.cn/a/zhongyaotongzhi/2015/1022/4710.html,2015
[9]黑龙江省农业委员会.关于印发2015年耕地保护与质量提升补贴项目实施方案的通知.黑龙江省农业委员会电子政务,http://dzzw.hljagri.gov.cn/zwgk/nwwj/whwj/201510/t20151020_646313.htm,2015
[10]玉林市博白县农业局.2015年博白县耕地保护与质量提升项目实施方案.博白县农业信息网,http://hzsagri.gov.cn/yulin/bobai/zwgk_4999/tzgg_5004/201507/t20150720_451194.html,2015
[11]农业部办公厅.农业部办公厅关于印发2015年畜禽养殖标准化示范创建活动工作方案的通知,http://www.hbxmfw.com/czhn/HTML/36589.html,2015
[12]天门市畜牧兽医局.天门市2015年畜牧养殖标准化示范创建活动实施法案.天门畜牧信息网,http://www.tmxm.gov.cn/nzcms_show_news.asp?id=5764,2015
[13]呼伦贝尔市农牧业局.关于2015年畜禽粪污等农业农村废弃物综合利用试点项目的公示,http://www.hlbenm.gov.cn/show.asp?id=3143,2015
[14]农业部.2013年国家支持粮食增产农民增收的政策措施,http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/zcfg/qnhnzc/201303/t20130320_3354.htm,2013
[15]农业部.2014年国家深化农村改革、支持粮食生产、促进农民增收政策措施,http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/zcfg/qnhnzc/201404/t20140425_3884.htm,2014
[16]农业部.2015年国家深化农村改革、发展现代农业、促进农民增收政策措施,http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/zcfg/qnhnzc/201504/t20150430_4570.htm,2015
[17]宝剑久俊.中国の农业构造调整と农业经营の变容.一桥大学大学院经济学研究科博士学位申请论文.2015
[18]日本总合研究所.第1章中国における农业生产者の所得补偿政策と价格支持政策、主要国の农业情报调查分析报告书(平成22年度).农林水产省大臣官房国际部国际政策课、海外农业情报调查分析(アジア)报告书.平成22年度海外农业情报调查分析·国际相互理解事业,2011
[19]倪洪兴.中国农业支持政策研究.国际贸易和可持续发展中心,2013,47
[20]高杨.测土配方施肥:政府“搭台”企业“唱戏”:访农业部测土配方施肥专家组组长张福锁教授.农民日报,2012-06-18
[21]农业部.2015年畜牧标准化规模养殖扶持政策,http://www.tuliu.com/read-9212.html,2015
[22]中华畜牧业信息网.山西省扶持肉牛肉羊标准化规模养殖,http://www.cnxmy.com/Article_51_141458.html,2011
[23]中央政府门户网站.黑龙江将发展标准化规模养殖支持龙头企业自建基地,http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2014-04/11/content_2657.htm,2014
[24]呼伦贝尔市农牧业局.关于2015年畜禽粪污等农业农村废弃物综合利用试点项目的公示,http://www.hlbenm.gov.cn/show.asp?id=3143,2015
[25]宋丹瑛.中国における绿色食品认証制度の展开及び地域农业.地域政策研究,2008,10(3):65~76
[26]Zhao H.The development and present situation of“three kinds of food”certification system in China:Non-polluted food,green food and organic food.Journal of food system research,2009,16(2):14~28
[27]中国绿色食品发展中心.2010,2014.http://www.greenfood.agri.cn/zl/tjnb/
[28]农业部.我国强力推进无公害农产品和农产品地理标志,http://www.moa.gov.cn/ztzl/nyjj/2011nian/201103/t20110319_1950.htm,2011
[29]农业部.2014年全国绿色食品继续保持良好发展态势,http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/zwdt/201501/t20150119_4341.htm,2015
[30]农业部.无公害食品产地认定规范(NY/T 5343—2006),http://www.greenfood.org.cn/Html/2013_12_20/11444_15488_2013_12_20_26225.html,2013
[31]中国绿色食品发展中心.国家发展改革委关于印发绿色食品认证及标志使用收费管理办法的通知,http://www.greenfood.org.cn/Html/2007-1-25/2_1886_2007-1-25_2812.html,2007
[32]辽宁省农村经济委员会.2012年辽宁省无公害农产品、绿色食品、有机食品公告.http://www.lnjn.gov.cn/government/notice/shengfa/2013/7/495042.shtml,2013
[33]辽宁省农村经济委员会.辽宁省无公害农产品、绿色食品、有机食品公告(2013),http://www.lnjn.gov.cn/government/notice/shengfa/2014/5/551376.shtml,2014
[34]辽宁省农村经济委员会.辽宁省无公害农产品、绿色食品、有机食品公告(2014),http://www.lnjn.gov.cn/government/notice/shengfa/2015/12/595087.shtml,2015
[35]丁长琴.我国有机农业发展模式及理论探讨.农业技术经济,2012,2:122~128
[36]忻州市民政局.忻州市人民政府办公厅关于印发忻州市促进现代农业发展扶持办法的通知.忻州阳光农廉网,http://www.xznlw.gov.cn/html/fwms/nwh/2821.html,2015
[37]中共庐江县委员会.关于印发2014年合肥市促进现代农业发展政策实施细则通知.中国庐江,http://www.lj.gov.cn/contents/88814.html,2014
[38]曹汪斌,杨岩.中国有机野菜の生产·流通课题と管理监督制度(海外情报).农畜产业振兴机构.野菜情报,2013,110:48~55
[39]汪卫民.中国生态农业理论与实践.环境导报.1998,2:5~8
[40]农业部.农业部举行新闻发布会,有关负责人解读浙江现代生态循环农业发展试点省建设等相关情况:推进现代生态循环农业加快农业发展方式转变.农业部信息中心,http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/zwdt/201501/t20150106_4324.htm,2015
[41]常家亮,刘玉祥,王玉峰.晋城市循环农业发展的实践与探索.农业工程技术·新能源产业,2009,7:17~18
[42]国务院第二次全国农业普查领导小组办公室.中国第二次全国农业普查资料滙编(农业卷).北京:中国统计出版社,2009
[43]柳杨.辽中县农村养殖污染问题研究.长春:吉林大学,2012
[44]中华人民共和国环境保护部.生态县、生态市、生态省建设指标(修订稿),http://sts.mep.gov.cn/stsfcj/ghyzb/200801/t20080115_116249.htm,2008
[45]辽中县.2013年种植业工作总结及2014年工作计划.2014
[46]辽宁省人民政府.2014年辽中县政府工作报告:2014年12月29日在辽中县第十七届人民代表大会第三次会议上.辽中县人民政府,http://www.ln.gov.cn/zfxx/zfgzbg/jgzbg/lzx/201401/t20140116_1256.html,2014
[47]Bickel D.R.Robust estimators of the mode and skewness of continuous data.Computational Statistics&Data Analysis,2002,39:153~163