摘要
双酚A及其类似物双酚S、双酚F、双酚AF和卤代双酚A等双酚类化合物广泛用于生产聚碳酸酯塑料和环氧树脂,生产量大且目前在各种环境介质、食品及人体内均有检出。近年来,研究发现很多神经疾病的发生与双酚类化合物的暴露密切相关,有关双酚A及其类似物的神经毒性日益受到国内外研究者关注。本研究从对动物行为、神经发育、神经递质含量及神经递质代谢等方面综述了双酚类化合物的神经毒性效应及作用机制,为今后进一步探究双酚A类似物的神经毒性作用及其安全性评价提供更多的理论参考。
In recent years,more and more evidences have shown that development of certain neurological disorders such as autism spectrum disorder and schizophrenia are positively correlated with the exposure to bisphenol compounds,and thereby increasing concern has been focused on the neurotoxicity of these chemicals.Rodent and fish studies suggest that BPA and its analogs could induce abnormal behaviors and impair nervous system development by disturbing the development of neurons,inducing nerve cell apoptosis,and inhibiting differentiation of neural cells.In addition,BPA could affect certain neurons produce and release their neurotransmitters and neurotransmitter metabolism,and thereby induce disturbed neurotransmitter levels,which may finally lead to behavior disorders.However,fewer studies reported effects of its analogues on neurotransmitter levels or metabolism in animals.It has been reported that the bisphenols can also directly impair the nervous system and affect the generation and transmission of action potential by changing the concentration of intra and extra cellular calcium.Therefore,advances in studies of neurotoxic effects of BPA and its analogues were reviewed in this paper including effects on behavior,development of nerve cell,neurotransmitter levels and metabolism,with an emphasis on the underlying mechanisms of those effects.Finally,this review would help the comprehensive understanding for neurotoxicity of the bisphenol compounds and for evaluating the safety of bisphenol analogues.
引文
[1]Song S J,Song M Y,Zeng L Z,et al.Occurrence and profiles of bisphenol analogues in municipal sewage sludge in China[J].Environmental Pollution,2014,186(1):14-19.
[2]Liao C,Liu F,Kannan K.Bisphenol S,a new bisphenol analogue,in paper products and currency bills and its association with bisphenol a residues[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2012,46(12):6515-6522.
[3]Calafat A M,Ye X,Wong L-Y,et al.Exposure of the U S population to bisphenol A and 4-tertiary-octylphenol:2003-2004[J].Environmental Health Perspectives,2008,116(1):39-44.
[4]Song S,Ruan T,Wang T,et al.Distribution and preliminary exposure assessment of bisphenol AF(BPAF)in various environmental matrices around a manufacturing plant in China[J].Environmental Science&Technology,2012,46(24):13136-13143.
[5]Braun J M,Yolton K,Dietrich K N,et al.Prenatal bisphenol Aexposure and early childhood behavior[J].Environmental Health Perspectives,2009,117(12):1945-1952.
[6]Sathyanarayana S,Braun J M,Yolton K,et al.Case report:High prenatal bisphenol a exposure and infant neonatal neurobehavior[J].Environmental Health Perspectives,2011,119(8):1170-1175.
[7]Stein T P,Schluter M D,Steer R A,et al.Bisphenol A exposure in children with autism spectrum disorders[J].Autism Research,2015,8(3):272-283.
[8]Shingo M,Daisuke M,Daisuke I,et al.Effects of perinatal exposure to low dose of bisphenol A on anxiety like behavior and dopamine metabolites in brain[J].Neuro-Psychopharmacology and Biological Psychiatry,2012,39(2):273-279.
[9]Keiko N,Kyoko I,Kanji Y,et al.Prenatal and lactational exposure to low-doses of bisphenol A alters brain monoamine concentration in adult mice[J].Neuroscience Letters,2010,484(1):66-70.
[10]Wang J,Wang X,Xiong C,et al.Chronic bisphenol A exposure alters behaviors of zebrafish(Danio rerio)[J].Environmental Pollution,2015,206:275-281.
[11]高强,李昕,郝耀光,等.青春期双酚A结构类似物暴露对小鼠行为的影响[J].生态毒理学报,2016,11(3):140-144.Gao Q,Li X,Hao Y G,et al.Effects of exposure to analogues of bisphenol A on depressive-like behaviors in mice[J].Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology,2016,11(3):140-144.
[12]Shingo M,Daisuke M,Daisuke I,et al.Perinatal exposure to bisphenol A enhances contextual fear memory and affects the serotoninergic system in juvenile female mice[J].Hormones and Behavior,2013,63(5):709-716.
[13]Vom Saal F S,Hughes C.An extensive new literature concerning low-dose effects of bisphenol A shows the need for a new risk assessment[J].Environmental Health Perspectives,2005,113(8):926-933.
[14]Wolstenholme J T,Rissman E F,Connelly J J.The role of Bisphenol A in shaping the brain,epigenome and behavior[J].Hormones and Behavior,2011,59(3):296-305.
[15]Cox K H,Gatewood J D,Howeth C,et al.Gestational exposure to bisphenol A and cross-fostering affect behaviors in juvenile mice[J].Hormones and Behavior,2010,58(5):754-761.
[16]Matsuda S,Saika S,Amano K,et al.Changes in brain monoamine levels in neonatal rats exposed to bisphenol A at low doses[J].Chemosphere,2010,78(7):894-906.
[17]李璐.化妆品中抗氧化剂及化妆品塑料包装中双酚A的测定[D].吉林:吉林大学,2014.Li L.The Determination of Antioxidants in Cosmetics and Bisphenol A in Plastic Packaging of Cosmetics[D].Jilin:Jilin University,2014.
[18]Nam S H,Seo Y M,Kim M G.Bisphenol A migration from polycarbonate baby bottle with repeated use[J].Chemosphere,2010,79(9):949-952.
[19]Liao C,Kannan K.A survey of bisphenol A and other bisphenol analogues in foodstuffs from nine cities in China[J].Food Addit Contam Part A Chem Anal Control Expo Risk Assess,2014,31(2):319-329.
[20]Jin S,Yang F,Xu Y,et al.Risk assessment of xenoestrogens in a typical domestic sewage-holding lake in China[J].Chemosphere,2013,93(6):892-898.
[21]Eriko Y,Nobuyoshi Y,Sachi T,et al.Bisphenol A and other bisphenol analogues including BPS and BPF in surface water samples from Japan,China,Korea and India[J].Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety,2015,122:565-572.
[22]陈默,范湛蓝,高群,等.北京女性尿液中双酚A及氯代双酚A的浓度和风险评价[J].中国环境科学,2015,35(9):2853-2860.Chen M,Fan Z L,Gao Q,et al.Levels and risk assessment of bisphenol A and chlorinated BPAs in urine samples of Beijing women[J].China Environmental Science,2015,35(9):2853-2860.
[23]Yang Y,Guan J,Yin J,et al.Urinary levels of bisphenol analogues in residents living near a manufacturing plant in south China[J].Chemosphere,2014,112:481-486.
[24]Coiro P,Padmashri R,Suresh A,et al.Impaired synaptic development in a maternal immune activation mouse model of neurodevelopmental disorders[J].Brain Behavior and Immunity,2015,50:249-258.
[25]陈运华.孤独症大鼠发病机制中突触与神经免疫功能异常的初步研究[D].贵州:贵州医科大学,2016.Chen Y H.A Preliminary Study on the Dysfunction of Synaptic and Neural Immune Function in the Pathogenesis of Autism Rats[D].Guizhou:Guizhou Medical University,2016.
[26]Wang X C,Dong Q X,Chen Y H,et al.Bisphenol A affects axonal growth,musculature and motor behavior in developing zebrafish[J].Aquatic Toxicology,2013,142-143(4):104-113.
[27]叶银萍.双酚A对大鼠海马神经元树突发育的影响及其分子机制[D].浙江:浙江师范大学,2010.Ye Y P.Effects of Bisphenol-A on Cultured Hippocampal Dendritic Development and Its Molecular Mechanism[D].Zhejiang:Zhejiang Normal University,2010.
[28]Iwakura T,Iwafuchi M,Muraoka D,et al.In vitro effects of bisphenol A on developing hypothalamic neurons[J].Toxicology,2010,272(1-3):52-58.
[29]Lin Y,Zhang H,Wang W D,et al.Effects of perinatal exposure to bisphenol A inducing dopaminergic neuronal cell to apoptosis happening in midbrain of male rat offspring][J].Journal of Sichuan University(Medical Science Edition),2006,37(4):570-573.
[30]Huang B,Ning S,Zhang Q,et al.Bisphenol A represses dopaminergic neuron differentiation from human embryonic stem cells through downregulating the expression of insulin-like growth factor 1[J].Molecular Neurobiology,2017,54(5):3798-3812.
[31]Lee S,Kim Y K,Shin T Y,et al.Neurotoxic effects of bisphenol AF on calcium-induced ROS and MAPKs[J].Neurotoxicity Research,2013,23(3):249-259.
[32]白承连,郑易,李星驰,等.四溴双酚A对斑马鱼胚胎发育毒性和神经毒性研究[J].中国药事,2013,27(3):292-297.Bai C L,Zheng Y,Li X C,et al.Developmental and neurobehavioral toxicity of TBBPA in zebrafish embryos[J].Chinese Pharmaceutical Affairs,2013,27(3):292-297.
[33]Saili K S,Corvi M M,Weber D N,et al.Neurodevelopmental low-dose bisphenol A exposure leads to early life-stage hyperactivity and learning deficits in adult zebrafish[J].Toxicology,2012,291(1-3):83-92.
[34]Kinch C D,Ibhazehiebo K,Jeong J-H,et al.Low-dose exposure to bisphenol A and replacement bisphenol S induces precocious hypothalamic neurogenesis in embryonic zebrafish[J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,2015,112(5):1475-1480.
[35]Weber D N,Hoffmann R G,Hoke E S,et al.Bisphenol A exposure during early development induces sex-specific changes in adult zebrafish social interactions[J].Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health Part A,2015,78(1):50-66.
[36]朱小乔,唐天乐,彭翔,等.双酚AF暴露降低斑马鱼学习记忆能力并影响神经系统相关基因表达[J].生态毒理学报,2017,12(1):119-126.Zhu XQ,Tang T L,Peng X,et al.Bisphenol AF exposure reduces learning and memory ability and influences expression of nervous system genes in zebrafish[J].Asian Journal of Ecotoxicology,2017,12(1):119-126.
[37]Hyland K.Neurochemistry and defects of biogenic amine neurotransmitter metabolism[J].Journal of Inherited Metabolic Disease,1999,22(4):353-363.
[38]Honma T,Miyagawa M,Suda M,et al.Effects of perinatal exposure to bisphenol A on brain neurotransmitters in female rat offspring[J].Industrial Health,2006,44(3):510-524.
[39]Hyland K.Clinical utility of monoamine neurotransmitter metabolite analysis in cerebrospinal fluid[J].Clinical Chemistry,2008,54(4):633-641.
[40]刘蓓蓓,张蕴琨.运动与脑组织中5-羟色胺及其代谢物的研究现状[J].南京体育学院学报(自然科学版),2005,4(4):29-33.Liu B B,Zhang Y K.The research condition of training and serotonin and its products in brain tissues[J].Journal of Nanjing Institute of Physical Education(Natural Science),2005,4(4):29-33.
[41]Manar M E T,Samia S S,Ehab S R,et al.Neuroprotective role of Ginkgo biloba against cognitive deficits associated with Bisphenol A exposure:An animal model study[J].Neurochemistry International,2017,108:199-212.
[42]Ye G,Chen Y,Wang H,et al.Metabolomics approach reveals metabolic disorders and potential biomarkers associated with the developmental toxicity of tetrabromobisphenol A and tetrachlorobisphenol A[J].Scientific Reports,2016,6:35257.
[43]Ogi H,Itoh K,Ikegaya H,Fushiki S.Alterations of neurotransmitter norepinephrine and gamma-aminobutyric acid correlate with murine behavioral perturbations related to bisphenol A exposure[J].Brain&Development,2015,37(8):739-746.
[44]李雪玲.学习与记忆生理机制研究进展综述[J].楚雄师范学院学报,2003,18(3):67-70.Li X L.A literature review of learning and memory physiological mechanism researches[J].Journal of Chuxiong Normal University,2003,18(3):67-70.
[45]王文娟,王军,钱文溢等.双酚A对大鼠背根神经节神经元钙离子通道电流影响[J].中国公共卫生,2012,28(2):210-212.Wang W J,Wang J,Qian W Y,et al.Effects of bisphenol A on calcium channel currents in dorsal root ganglion neurons of rats[J].Chinese Journal of Public Health,2012,28(2):210-212.
[46]沈巧巧.双酚A快速影响海马神经元胞内钙离子水平[D].浙江:浙江师范大学,2016.Shen Q Q.Rapid Effect of Bisphenol A on Calcium Level in Hippocampal Neurons[D].Zhejiang:Zhejiang Normal University,2016.
[47]Qiu W,Zhao Y,Yang M,et al.Actions of bisphenol A and bisphenol S on the reproductive neuroendocrine system during early development in zebrafish[J].Endocrinology,2016,157(2):636-647.
[48]刘志华,汪惠丽.双酚A对脑发育及行为影响的神经毒性及可能机制[C].//中国食品科学技术学会、美国食品科技学会.中国食品科学技术学会、美国食品科技学会.中国食品科学技术学会第十二届年会暨第八届中美食品业高层论坛论文摘要集,2015.Liu Z H,Wang H L.Neurotoxicity and possible mechanism of bisphenol A on brain development and behavior[C].//Chinese Institute of Food Science and Technology Institute of Food Technologists.Chinese Institute of Food Science and Technology Institute of Food Technologists.Abstracts of Food Summit in China2015&12th Annual Meeting of CIFST,2015.
[49]Sengupta S,Obiorah I,Maximov P,et al.Molecular mechanism of action of bisphenol and bisphenol A mediated by oestrogen receptor alpha in growth and apoptosis of breast cancer cells[J].British Journal of Pharmacology,2013,169(1):167-178.
[50]Lee Y M,Seong M J,Lee J W,et al.Estrogen receptor independent neurotoxic mechanism of bisphenol A,an environmental estrogen[J].Journal of Veterinary Science,2007,8(1):27-38.
[51]Lee S,Suk K,Kim I K,et al.Signaling pathways of bisphenol A-induced apoptosis in hippocampal neuronal cells:role of calcium-induced reactive oxygen species,mitogen-activated protein kinases,and nuclear factor-kappa B[J].Journal of Neuroscience Research,2008,86(13):2932-2942.
[52]Xiong Y,Qi J G.Neurobiology[M].Beijing:Science Press,2013:16-39.
[53]Nowicki B A,Hamada M A,Robinson G Y,et al.Adverse effects of bisphenol A(BPA)on the dopamine system in two distinct cell models and corpus striatum of the Sprague-Dawley rat[J].Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health Part A,2016,79(20):912-924.
[54]Yoneda T,Hiroi T,Osada M,et al.Non-genomic modulation of dopamine release by bisphenol-A in PC12cells[J].Journal of Neurochemistry,2003,87(6):1499-1508.
[55]Beatriz C,Pilar S,Jesús M T,et al.Bisphenol A,bisphenol Fand bisphenol S affect differently 5α-reductase expression and dopamine-serotonin systems in the prefrontal cortex of juvenile female rats[J].Environmental Research,2015,142:281-287.
[56]范瑛.胆碱对双酚A所致成年大鼠空间记忆损害的改善作用[J].现代预防医学,2015,42(10):1830-1832.Fan Y.Choline supplementation ameliorates bisphenol A-induced spatial memory impairments in adult rats[J].Modern Preventive Medicine,2015,42(10):1830-1832.
[57]Zhou R,Chen F,Chang F,et al.Persistent overexpression of DNA methyltransferase 1attenuating GABAergic inhibition in basolateral amygdala accounts for anxiety in rat offspring exposed perinatally to low-dose bisphenol A[J].Journal of Psychiatric Research,2013,47(10):1535-1544.
[58]Zhou R,Chen F,Feng X,et al.Perinatal exposure to low-dose of bisphenol A causes anxiety-like alteration in adrenal axis regulation and behaviors of rat offspring:A potential role for metabotropic glutamate 2/3receptors[J].Journal of Psychiatric Research,2015,64:121-129.
[59]Xu X,Dong F,Yang Y,et al.Sex-specific effects of long-term exposure to bisphenol-A on anxiety-and depression-like behaviors in adult mice[J].Chemosphere,2015,120:258-266.
[60]Klenke U,Constantin S,Wray S.BPA directly decreases gnRHneuronal activity via noncanonical pathway[J].Endocrinology,2016,157(5):1980-1990.
[61]Rezg R,El-Fazaa S,Gharbi N,et al.Bisphenol a and human chronic diseases:Current evidences,possible mechanisms,and future perspectives[J].Environment International,2014,64(3):83-90.
[62]Inadera H.Neurological effects of bisphenol A and its analogues[J].International Journal of Medical Sciences,2015,12(12):926-936.
[63]周天舒,梁立韵,孙彦,等.四溴双酚A暴露下的神经毒性效应探讨[C].//中国化学会环境化学专业委员会.中国化学会环境化学专业委员会第五届全国环境化学大会摘要集,2009.Zhou T S,Liang L Y,Sun Y.et al.Neurotoxic effects of tetrabromobisphenol A exposure[C].//Environmental Chemistry professional committee of Chinese Chemical Society.Environmental Chemistry Professional Committee of Chinese Chemical Society,Abstracts of the 5th National Conference on Environmental Chemistry,2009.
[64]Garcia-Segura L M,et al.Aromatase expression by astrocytes after brain injury:Implications for local estrogen formation in brain repair[J].Journal of Neuroscience,1999,89(2):567-578.
[65]Wooten G F,Currie L J,Bovbjerg V E,et al.Are men at greater risk for Parkinson’s disease than women[J].Journal of Neurology Neurosurgery and Psychiatry,2004,75(4):637-639.
[66]Dluzen D E,McDermott J L,Liu B.Estrogen as a neuroprotectant against MPTP-Induced neurotoxicity in C57/B1mice[J].Neurotoxicology and Teratology,1996,18(5):603-606.
[67]Rochester J R,Bolden A L.Bisphenol S and F:A systematic review and comparison of the hormonal activity of bisphenol A substitutes[J].Environmental Health Perspectives,2015,123(7):643-650.
[68]European Food Safety Authority(EFSA),Workshop on bisphenol A(BPA)hazard assessment protocol[R].Brussels:EFSA,2017.
[69]Huang R P,Liu Z H,Yuan S F,et al.Worldwide human daily intakes of bisphenol A(BPA)estimated from global urinary concentration data(2000-2016)and its risk analysis[J].Environmental Pollution,2017,230:143-152.
[70]National Toxicology Program.Final Report of the Endocrine Disruptors Low Dose Peer Review Panel[R].Raleigh:N C,2001.
[71]Vom Saal,F S,Akingbemi,B T,Belcher S M,et al.Chapel hill bisphenol A expert panel consensus statement:Integration of mechanisms,effects in animals and potential to impact human health at current levels of exposure[J].Reproductive Toxicology,2007,24(2):131-138.
[72]Vandenberg L N,Maffini M V,Sonnenschein C.Bisphenol-Aand the great divide:A review of controversies in the field of endocrine disruption[J].Endocrine Reviews,2009,30(1):75-95.