高分辨率卫星影像提取DEM技术在活动构造定量研究中的应用——以库米什盆地南缘断裂陡坎为例
详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |
  • 英文篇名:APPLICATION OF DEM GENERATION TECHNOLOGY FROM HIGH RESOLUTION SATELLITE IMAGE IN QUANTITATIVE ACTIVE TECTONICS STUDY: A CASE STUDY OF FAULT SCARPS IN THE SOUTHERN MARGIN OF KUMISHI BASIN
  • 作者:汪思妤 ; 艾明 ; 吴传勇 ; 雷启云 ; 张会平 ; 任光雪 ; 李传友 ; 任治坤
  • 英文作者:WANG Si-yu;AI Ming;WU Chuan-yong;LEI Qi-yun;ZHANG Hui-ping;REN Guang-xue;LI Chuan-you;REN Zhi-kun;Key Laboratory of Active Tectonics and Volcano,Institute of Geology,China Earthquake Administration;Earthquake Agency of Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region;Earthquake Agency of Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region;
  • 关键词:立体像对 ; DEM ; 逆断层 ; 活动构造 ; 精度分析
  • 英文关键词:stereo images;;DEM;;thrust faults;;active tectonics;;accuracy analysis
  • 中文刊名:DZDZ
  • 英文刊名:Seismology and Geology
  • 机构:中国地震局地质研究所活动构造与火山重点实验室;新疆维吾尔自治区地震局;宁夏回族自治区地震局;
  • 出版日期:2018-10-15
  • 出版单位:地震地质
  • 年:2018
  • 期:v.40
  • 基金:中国地震局地质研究所基本科研业务专项(IGCEA1607);; 地震动力学国家重点实验室自主课题(LED2014A03);; 国家自然科学基金(41472201,41761144071)共同资助
  • 语种:中文;
  • 页:DZDZ201805005
  • 页数:19
  • CN:05
  • ISSN:11-2192/P
  • 分类号:60-78
摘要
通过数字化地形图和野外地形测量获取数字高程模型(DEM)的传统方法存在时效性差、获取周期长、范围小等缺点,高分辨率卫星影像提取DEM技术的出现为快速获取断裂带大范围的地形地貌数据提供了全新的解决方案,极大地提高了野外地形地貌数据获取的效率,该方法与激光雷达扫描技术(Li DAR,Light Detection and Ranging)相比成本低,与Sf M(Structure from Motion)摄影测量方法相比覆盖范围大。然而,国内外目前尚缺乏针对用该方法获取的DEM精度是否满足活动构造定量研究要求的报道。文中以LPS(Leica Photogrammetry Suit)为软件平台,以Worldview-2全色波段立体像对为数据源,选择植被覆盖稀疏的东天山库米什盆地南缘最新发现的地表破裂带作为研究区,提取了0. 5m分辨率DEM,基于该DEM数据测量了不同期次洪积扇上的断层陡坎高度,并与后差分GPS(DGPS,differential GPS)野外实测的地形剖面进行了对比分析与精度评价。研究结果表明:由该方法获取的DEM高程与野外DGPS实测高程相差约-2. 82~4. 87m,经高程校正后与DGPS测线的吻合度很高,形态差异为0. 30m,能够精细刻画陡坎形态;对断层陡坎高度的测量精度可以达到0. 22m,能够满足活动构造定量研究中高精度地形地貌数据获取的需要,为快速获取断裂精细几何结构、断层剖面形态以及断层垂直位错带来了极大的便利,为后续野外工作中选择探槽开挖点、典型断错地貌点以及年代样品采集点提供了重要参考,在活动构造研究中具有广阔的应用前景。
        Traditional method to generate Digital Elevation Model( DEM) through topographic map and topographic measurement has weak points such as low efficiency,long operating time and small range.The emergence of DEM-generation technology from high resolution satellite image provides a new method for rapid acquisition of large terrain and geomorphic data, which greatly improves the efficiency of data acquisition. This method costs lower compared with Li DAR( Light Detection and Ranging),has large coverage compared with SfM( Structure from Motion). However,there is still lack of report on whether the accuracy of DEM generated from stereo-imagery satisfies the quantitative research of active tectonics. This research is based on LPS( Leica Photogrammetry Suit) software platform,using Worldview-2 panchromatic stereo-imagery as data source,selecting Kumishi Basin in eastern Tianshan Mountains with little vegetation as study area. We generated 0. 5 m resolution DEM of5-km swath along the newly discovered rupture zone at the south of Kumishi Basin,measured the height of fault scarps on different levels of alluvial fans based on the DEM,then compared with the scarp height measured by differential GPS survey in the field to analyze the accuracy of the extracted DEM. The results show that the elevation difference between the topographic profiles derived from the extracted DEM and surveyed by differential GPS ranges from-2. 82 to 4. 87 m. The shape of the fault scarp can be finely depicted and the deviation is 0. 30 m after elevation correction. The accuracy of measuring the height of fault scarps can reach 0. 22 m,which meets the need of high-precision quantitative research of active tectonics. It provides great convenience for rapidly obtaining fine geometry,profiles morphology,vertical dislocations of fault and important reference for sites selection for trench excavation,slip rate,and samples. This method has broad prospects in the study of active tectonics.
引文
毕海芸,郑文俊,曾江源,等.2017.Sf M摄影测量方法在活动构造定量研究中的应用[J].地震地质,39(4):656-674.doi:10.3969/j.issn.0253-4967.2017.04.003.BI Hai-yun,ZHENG Wen-jun,ZENG Jiang-yuan,et al.2017.Application of Sf M photogrammetry method to the quantitative study of active tectonics[J].Seismology and Geology,39(4):656-674(in Chinese).
    蔡庆空,蒋金豹,张玲,等.2014.ALOS-PRISM立体像对提取DEM的应用研究[J].测绘科学,39(1):70-73.CAI Qing-kong,JIANG Jin-bao,ZHANG Ling,et al.2014.Study on DEM extraction by ALOS-PRISM stereo pair[J].Science of Surveying and Mapping,39(1):70-73(in Chinese).
    陈桂华,徐锡伟,闻学泽,等.2006.数字航空摄影测量学方法在活动构造中的应用[J].地球科学,31(3):405-410.CHEN Gui-hua,XU Xi-wei,WEN Xue-ze,et al.2006.Application of digital aerophotogrammetry in active tectonics[J].Earth Science,31(3):405-410(in Chinese).
    陈杰,曲国胜,尹金辉,等.2001.中国西南天山山前的晚新生代构造与地震活动[J].中国地震,17(2):134-135.CHEN Jie,QU Guo-sheng,YIN Jin-hui,et al.2001.Late Cenozoic tectonics and seismicity in the southwestern Tianshan[J].Earthquake Research in China,17(2):134-135(in Chinese).
    邓起东,冯先岳,张培震,等.1999.乌鲁木齐山前坳陷逆断裂-褶皱带及其形成机制[J].地学前缘,6(4):191-201.DENG Qi-dong,FENG Xian-yue,ZHANG Pei-zhen,et al.1999.Reverse fault and fold zone in the Urumqi rangefront depression of the northern Tianshan and its genetic mechanism[J].Earth Science Frontiers,6(4):191-201(in Chinese).
    邓起东,冯先岳,张培震,等.2000.天山活动构造[M].北京:地震出版社.DENG Qi-dong,FENG Xian-yue,ZHANG Pei-zhen,et al.2000.Active Tectonics in Tianshan Mountains[M].Seismological Press,Beijing(in Chinese).
    邓起东,张培震,冉勇康,等.2002.中国活动构造基本特征[J].中国科学(D辑),32(12):1020-1030.DENG Qi-dong,ZHANG Pei-zhen,RAN Yong-kang,et al.2002.Basic characteristics of active tectonics of China[J].Science in China(Ser D),32(12):1020-1030(in Chinese).
    丁辉,姚安强.2012.利用IKONOS立体像对提取DEM精度的实验[J].测绘科学,37(1):182-184.DING Hui,YAO An-qiang.2012.DEM generation and analysis using IKONOS stereo pairs[J].Science of Surveying and Mapping,37(1):182-184(in Chinese).
    范兴旺,翁永玲,胡伍生,等.2010.IRS-P5立体像对提取DEM及精度评价[J].遥感技术与应用,25(4):547-551.FAN Xing-wang,WENG Yong-ling,HU Wu-sheng,et al.2010.DEM extraction and accuracy assessment based on IRS-P5 stereo images[J].Remote Sensing Technology and Application,25(4):547-551(in Chinese).
    高阳,何建国,李建中,等.2010.东天山阿其克库都克断裂新构造运动特征[J].新疆地质,28(3):247-249.GAO Yang,HE Jian-guo,LI Jian-zhong,et al.2010.Neotectonic activate features of Aqikekuduk Fault in eastern Tianshan area[J].Xinjiang Geology,28(3):247-249(in Chinese).
    管树巍,李本亮,何登发,等.2007.晚新生代以来天山南、北麓冲断作用的定量分析[J].地质学报,81(6):725-744.GUAN Shu-wei,LI Ben-liang,HE Deng-fa,et al.2007.Late Cenozoic active fold-and-thrust belts in the southern and northern flanks of Tianshan[J].Acta Geologica Sinica,81(6):725-744(in Chinese).
    郭召杰,张志诚,廖国辉,等.2002.天山东段隆升过程的裂变径迹年龄证据及构造意义[J].新疆地质,20(4):331-334.GUO Zhao-jie,ZHANG Zhi-cheng,LIAO Guo-hui,et al.2002.Uplifting process of eastern Tianshan Mountains:Evidence from fission-track age and its tectonic significance[J].Xinjiang Geology,20(4):331-334(in Chinese).
    贾秀鹏,焦伟利,李丹.2006.基于SPOT5异轨立体像对提取DEM试验与精度评估[J].测绘地理信息,31(2):32-34.JIA Xiu-peng,JIAO Wei-li,LI Dan.2006.DEM extraction and accuracy evaluation based on SPOT 5 across-track stereo images[J].Journal of Geomatics,31(2):32-34(in Chinese).
    李安,杨晓平,黄伟亮,等.2012.焉耆盆地北缘和静逆断裂-褶皱带第四纪变形[J].地震地质,34(2):240-253.doi:10.3969/j.issn.0253-4967.2012.02.004.LI An,YANG Xiao-ping,HUANG Wei-liang,et al.2012.Quaternary deformation of the Hejing thrust-fold belt on northern margin of the Yanqi Basin,southern Tianshan[J].Seismology and Geology,34(2):240-253(in Chinese).
    林爱明,傅碧宏,狩野谦一,等.2003.焉耆盆地活动断层的晚第四纪右行走滑[J].新疆地质,21(1):103-115.LIN Ai-ming,FU Bi-hong,KANO Keni-ichi,et al.2003.Late Quaternary dextral shearing of the active faults in Yanqi Basin[J].Xinjiang Geology,21(1):103-115(in Chinese).
    刘和甫,梁慧社,蔡立国,等.1994.天山两侧前陆冲断系构造样式与前陆盆地演化[J].地球科学,19(6):727-741.LIU He-fu,LIANG Hui-she,CAI Li-guo,et al.1994.Evolution and structural style of Tianshan and adjacent basins,northwestern China[J].Earth Science,19(6):727-741(in Chinese).
    刘静,陈涛,张培震,等.2013.机载激光雷达扫描揭示海原断裂带微地貌的精细结构[J].科学通报,58(1):41-45.LIU Jing,CHEN Tao,ZHANG Pei-zhen,et al.2013.Illuminating the active Haiyuan Fault,China by airborne light detection and ranging[J].Chinese Science Bulletin,58(1):41-45(in Chinese).
    马保东,吴立新,许志华.2013.利用资源三号测绘卫星立体像对提取DEM及精度评价:以神东矿区大柳塔矿为例[J].测绘通报(11):68-70.MA Bao-dong,WU Li-xin,XU Zhi-hua.2013.DEM extraction and accuracy assessment based on ZY-3 stereo images:Daliuta Mine being a case[J].Bulletin of Surveying and Mapping,(11):68-70(in Chinese).
    马素颜.2009.基于高分辨率卫星遥感数据提取DEM方法研究[D].上海:华东师范大学.MA Su-yan.2009.Research on the extraction of DEM based on high resolution remotely-sensed data[D].East China Normal University,Shanghai(in Chinese).
    任治坤,陈涛,张会平,等.2014.Li DAR技术在活动构造研究中的应用[J].地质学报,88(6):1196-1207.REN Zhi-kun,CHEN Tao,ZHANG Hui-ping,et al.2014.Li DAR survey in active tectonics studies:An introduction and overview[J].Acta Geologica Sinica,88(6):1196-1207(in Chinese).
    沈强,鄂栋臣,周春霞.2008.利用ASTER立体像对提取Grove山地区相对DEM及精度分析[J].测绘通报,(1):22-25.SHEN Qiang,E Dong-chen,ZHOU Chun-xia.2008.Extraction and evaluation of DEM generated from Aster stereo data in Grove Mountains[J].Bulletin of Surveying and Mapping,(1):22-25(in Chinese).
    王广杰,何政伟,仇文侠,等.2009.ASTER立体像对提取玛尔挡坝区DEM及精度评价[J].测绘科学,34(3):94-96.WANG Guang-jie,HE Zheng-wei,QIU Wen-xia,et al.2009.Extraction and accuracy assessment of DEM on Maerdang dam area from ASTER stereo image data[J].Science of Surveying and Mapping,34(3):94-96(in Chinese).
    王红平,刘修国,罗红霞,等.2010.基于RPC模型的IRS-P5影像正射校正[J].地球科学,35(3):485-489.WANG Hong-ping,LIU Xiu-guo,LUO Hong-xia,et al.2010.IRS-P5 satellite image ortho corrections using RPCmodel[J].Earth Science,35(3):485-489(in Chinese).
    王蕾.2016.高原地区高分辨率卫星立体像对提取DEM及精度分析[D].成都:成都理工大学.WANG Lei.2016.DEM extraction by stereo images of high resolution satellite and accuracy analysis in plateau[D].Chengdu University of Technology,Chengdu(in Chinese).
    汪一鹏,沈军.2000.天山北麓活动构造基本特征[J].新疆地质,18(3):203-210.WANG Yi-peng,SHEN Jun.2000.Basic features of active structures at the northern foothill of Tianshan Mountains,China[J].Xinjiang Geology,18(3):203-210(in Chinese).
    魏占玉,Arrowsmith Ramon,何宏林,等.2015.基于Sf M方法的高密度点云数据生成及精度分析[J].地震地质,37(2):636-648.doi:10.3969/j.issn.0253-4967.2015.02.024.WEI Zhan-yu,Arrowsmith Ramon,HE Hong-lin,et al.2015.Accuracy analysis of terrain point cloud acquired by“Structure from Motion”using aerial photos[J].Seismology and Geology,37(2):636-648(in Chinese).
    吴传勇.2016.西南天山北东东走向断裂的晚第四纪活动特征及在天山构造变形中的作用[D].北京:中国地震局地质研究所.WU Chuan-yong.2016.Late Quaternary activity of the east-northeastern trending faults in the southwestern Tianshan and their role in the tectonic deformation of the Tianshan Mountains[D].Institute of Geology,China Earthquake Administration,Beijing(in Chinese).
    徐岳仁,张军龙,陈长云.2012.DGPS和SPOT-5异轨立体像对在岷江源构造地貌研究中的应用[J].北京大学学报(自然科学版),48(4):574-582.XU Yue-ren,ZHANG Jun-long,CHEN Chang-yun.2012.Application of DGPS method and SPOT-5 across-track stereo images on tectonic geomorphology research in origin of Minjiang River[J].Acta Scientiarum Naturalium Universitatis Pekinensis,48(4):574-582(in Chinese).
    杨国荣.2007.IKONOS立体像对提取DEM及正射纠正的实验研究[J].现代测绘,30(5):26,29.YANG Guo-rong.2007.Research on extraction DEM and ortho rectifying based on IKONOS stereopair[J].Modern Surveying and Mapping,30(5):26,29(in Chinese).
    杨海波,杨晓平,黄雄南,等.2016.移动摄影测量数据与差分GPS数据的对比分析:以祁连山北麓洪水坝河东岸断层陡坎为例[J].地震地质,38(4):1030-1046.doi:10.3969/j.issn.0253-4967.2016.04.018.YANG Hai-bo,YANG Xiao-ping,HUANG Xiong-nan,et al.2016.Data comparative analysis between Sf M data and DGPS data:A case study from fault scarp in the east bank of Hongshuiba River,northern margin of the Qilian Shan[J].Seismology and Geology,38(4):1030-1046(in Chinese).
    杨晓平,邓起东,张培震,等.2008.天山山前主要推覆构造区的地壳缩短[J].地震地质,30(1):111-131.YANG Xiao-ping,DENG Qi-dong,ZHANG Pei-zhen,et al.2008.Crustal shortening of major nappe structures on the front margins of the Tianshan[J].Seismology and Geology,30(1):111-131(in Chinese).
    俞晶星.2013.雅布赖山前断裂晚第四纪滑动速率与古地震[D].北京:中国地震局地质研究所.YU Jing-xing.2013.Late Quaternary slip rate and paleoearthquake of Yabrai Hill piedmont fault[D].Institute of Geology,China Earthquake Administration,Beijing(in Chinese).
    张会平,杨农,刘少峰,等.2006.数字高程模型(DEM)在构造地貌研究中的应用新进展[J].地质通报,25(6):660-669.ZHANG Hui-ping,YANG Nong,LIU Shao-feng,et al.2006.Recent progress in the DEM-based tectonogeomorphic study[J].Geological Bulletin of China,25(6):660-669(in Chinese).
    张永生,刘军,巩丹超.2014.高分辨率遥感卫星应用:成像模型、处理算法及应用技术[M].北京:科学出版社.ZHANG Yong-sheng,LIU Jun,GONG Dan-chao.2014.Applications of High Resolution Remote Sensing Satellites:Imaging Models,Processing Algorithms and Application Technologies[M].Science Press,Beijing(in Chinese).
    张祖勋,张剑清.2012.数字摄影测量学[M].武汉:武汉大学出版社.ZHANG Zu-xun,ZHANG Jian-qing.2012.Digital Photogrammetry[M].Wuhan University Press,Wuhan(in Chinese).
    邹小波,袁道阳,邵延秀,等.2017.采用立体像对和差分GPS揭示民乐-永昌隐伏断裂地表变形特征[J].地震地质,39(6):1198-1212.doi:10.3969/j.issn.0253-4967.2017.06.008.ZOU Xiao-bo,YUAN Dao-yang,SHAO Yan-xiu,et al.2017.Using stereo-pair and differential GPS to reveal surface deformation characteristics of the Minle-Yongchong Fault[J].Seismology and Geology,39(6):1198-1212(in Chinese).
    Allen M B,Windley B F,Zhang C,et al.1993.Evolution of the Turfan Basin,Chinese central Asia[J].Tectonics,12(4):889-896.
    Avouac J P,Tapponnier P T,Bai M,et al.1993.Active thrusting and folding along the northern Tienshan,and Late Cenozoic rotation of the Tarim relative to Dzhungaria and Kazakhstan[J].Journal of Geophysical Research,98:6755-6840.
    Bi H,Zheng W,Ren Z,et al.2017.Using an unmanned aerial vehicle for topography mapping of the fault zone based on structure from motion photogrammetry[J].International Journal of Remote Sensing,38(8-10):2495-2510.
    Bi H,Zheng W,Ge W,et al.2018.Constraining the distribution of vertical slip on the South Heli Shan Fault(northeastern Tibet)from high-resolution topographic data[J].Journal of Geophysical Research Solid Earth,123(3):2484-2501.
    Binet R,Bollinger L.2005.Horizontal coseismic deformation of the 2003 Bam(Iran)earthquake measured from SPOT-5 THR satellite imagery[J].Geophysical Research Letters,32(2):287-294.
    Burchfiel B C,Brown E T,Deng Q D,et al.1999.Crustal shortening on the margins of the Tien Shan,Xinjiang,China[J].International Geology Review,41(8):665-700.
    D'Oleireoltmanns S,Marzolff I,Peter K D,et al.2012.Unmanned aerial vehicle(UAV)for monitoring soil erosion in Morocco[J].Remote Sensing,4(11):3390-3416.
    Dolloff J T,Theiss H J.2012.Temporal correlation of metadata errors for commercial satellite images:Representation and effects on stereo extraction accuracy[R].ISPRS-International Archives of the Photogrammetry,Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences,39:215-223.
    Fabris M,Pesci A.2005.Automated DEM extraction in digital aerial photogrammetry:Precisions and validation for mass movement monitoring[J].Annals of Geophysics,48(6):57-72.
    Fisher P F,Tate N J.2006.Causes and consequences of error in digital elevation models[J].Progress in Physical Geography,30(4):467-489.
    Fonstad M A,Dietrich J T,Courville B C,et al.2013.Topographic structure from motion:A new development in photogrammetric measurement[J].Earth Surface Processes&Landforms,38(4):421-430.
    Fu B,Lin A,Kano K I,et al.2003.Quaternary folding of the eastern Tian Shan,northwest China[J].Tectonophysics,369(1):79-101.
    Hetzel R,Tao M,Stokes S,et al.2004.Late Pleistocene/Holocene slip rate of the Zhangye thrust(Qilian Shan,China)and implications for the active growth of the northeastern Tibetan plateau[J].Tectonics,23(6):TC6006.
    Hooper D M,Bursik M I,Webb F H.2003.Application of high-resolution,interferometric DEMs to geomorphic studies of fault scarps,Fish Lake Valley,Nevada-California,USA[J].Remote Sensing of Environment,84(2):255-267.
    Huang W L,Yang X P,Li A,et al.2015.Late Pleistocene shortening rate on the northern margin of the Yanqi Basin,southeastern Tian Shan,NW China[J].Journal of Asian Earth Sciences,112:11-24.
    James M R,Robson S.2012.Straightforward reconstruction of 3D surfaces and topography with a camera:Accuracy and geoscience application[J].Journal of Geophysical Research:Earth Surface,117(F3),F03017.
    Jawak S D,Luis A J.2011.Applications of World View-2 satellite data for extraction,of polar spatial information and DEM of Larsemann Hills[R].East Antarctica.International Conference on Earth Sciences&Engineering.
    Johnson K,Nissen E,Saripalli S,et al.2014.Rapid mapping of ultrafine fault zone topography with structure from motion[J].Geosphere,10(5):969-986.
    Kondo H,Toda S,Okumura K,et al.2008.A fault scarp in an urban area identified by Li DAR survey:A case study on the Itoigawa-Shizuoka Tectonic Line,central Japan[J].Geomorphology,101(4):731-739.
    Massonnet D,Rossi M,Carmona C,et al.1993.The displacement field of the Landers earthquake mapped by radar interferometry[J].Nature,364(6433):138-142.
    Ren Z K,Zhang Z Q,Chen T,et al.2016.Clustering of offsets on the Haiyuan Fault and their relationship to paleoearthquakes[J].Geological Society of America Bulletin,128(1-2):3-18
    Ren Z K,Zhang Z Q,Zhang P Z.2018.Different earthquake patterns for two neighboring fault segments within the Haiyuan fault zone[J].Earth and Planetary Physics,2(1):1-7.
    Smith W H F,Wessel P.1990.Gridding with continuous curvature splines in tension[J].Geophysics,55(3):293-305.
    Toutin T,Schmitt C V,Wang H.2012.Impact of no GCP on elevation extraction from World View stereo data[J].ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry&Remote Sensing,72(2):73-79.
    Wang C Y,Yang Z E,Luo H,et al.2004.Crustal structure of the northern margin of the eastern Tien Shan,China,and its tectonic implications for the 1906 M~7.7 Manas earthquake[J].Earth&Planetary Science Letters,223(1-2):187-202.
    Wright T J,Parsons B E,Lu Z.2004.Toward mapping surface deformation in three dimensions using In SAR[J].Geophysical Research Letters,31(1):169-178.
    Yin A,Nie S,Craig P,et al.1998.Late Cenozoic tectonic evolution of the southern Chinese Tian Shan[J].Tectonics,17(1):1-27.
    Zebker H A,Rosen P.2002.On the derivation of coseismic displacement fields using differential radar interferometry:The Landers earthquake[C].Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium,1994.IGARSS'94.Surface and Atmospheric Remote Sensing:Technologies,Data Analysis and Interpretation.International:IEEE,19617-19634.
    Zhou L,Heitaro K,Sakae M,et al.2013.Detection of subtle tectonic-geomorphic features in densely forested mountains by very high-resolution airborne Li DAR survey[J].Geomorphology,182(2):104-115.
    Zhou Y,Parsons B,Elliott J R,et al.2015.Assessing the ability of Pleiades stereo imagery to determine height changes in earthquakes:A case study for the El Mayor-Cucapah epicentral area[J].Journal of Geophysical Research:Solid Earth,120(12):8793-8808.
    Zielke O,Arrowsmith J R,Grant L L,et al.2010.Slip in the 1857 and earlier large earthquakes along the Carrizo Plain,San Andreas Fault[J].Science,327(5969):1119-1122.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700