MXene材料用于放射性元素及重金属离子去除的研究进展
|
摘要
二维过渡金属碳/氮化物(MXene)是2011年发现的一类结构新颖、性质独特的层状纳米材料,目前已被广泛应用于能源存储以及环境治理等领域. MXene材料拥有较大的比表面积、丰富的活性吸附位点、良好的亲水性以及可控的层间距,并且这类纯无机材料表现出优异的抗辐照性能以及良好的导热性能,因此是容纳放射性元素与重金属离子的理想载体.本文归纳总结了近年来MXene材料的可控制备及其对放射性元素和重金属离子的去除研究进展,对相关的实验技术手段、吸附行为与相互作用机理进行了系统梳理,此外还对该领域的发展趋势进行了展望.
Two-dimensional transition metal carbide/nitride(MXene) is a class of new layered nanomaterial discovered in 2011. Due to the novel structure and unique characteristics, MXene-based materials have been widely explored in the applications of energy storage and environmental remediation fields. MXene materials have the advantages of large specific surface areas, abundant active adsorption sites, good hydrophilicity and controllable layer space, and such purely inorganic materials also exhibit excellent radiation resistance and thermal conductivity, thus can be considered as ideal candidates for the sequestration of radioactive element and heavy metal ions. Herein we review the research progress in the controllable preparation of MXene materials and their removal performance for radionuclides and heavy metal ions in the past five years. The related experimental techniques, adsorption behaviors and interaction mechanisms have been systematically summarized. The prospective investigation trends and possible directions in this field are also proposed and discussed.
Two-dimensional transition metal carbide/nitride(MXene) is a class of new layered nanomaterial discovered in 2011. Due to the novel structure and unique characteristics, MXene-based materials have been widely explored in the applications of energy storage and environmental remediation fields. MXene materials have the advantages of large specific surface areas, abundant active adsorption sites, good hydrophilicity and controllable layer space, and such purely inorganic materials also exhibit excellent radiation resistance and thermal conductivity, thus can be considered as ideal candidates for the sequestration of radioactive element and heavy metal ions. Herein we review the research progress in the controllable preparation of MXene materials and their removal performance for radionuclides and heavy metal ions in the past five years. The related experimental techniques, adsorption behaviors and interaction mechanisms have been systematically summarized. The prospective investigation trends and possible directions in this field are also proposed and discussed.
引文
1 Dincer I,Acar C.Int J Energy Res,2015,39:585-606
2 Bundt M,Albrecht A,Froidevaux P,Blaser P,Flühler H.Environ Sci Technol,2000,34:3895-3899
3 Fujita Y,Taylor JL,Gresham TLT,Delwiche ME,Colwell FS,McLing TL,Petzke LM,Smith RW.Environ Sci Technol,2008,42:3025-3032
4 Latta DE,Mishra B,Cook RE,Kemner KM,Boyanov MI.Environ Sci Technol,2014,48:1683-1691
5 Li J,Wang X,Zhao G,Chen C,Chai Z,Alsaedi A,Hayat T,Wang X.Chem Soc Rev,2018,47:2322-2356
6 Sun Y,Yang S,Chen Y,Ding C,Cheng W,Wang X.Environ Sci Technol,2015,49:4255-4262
7 Carboni M,Abney CW,Liu S,Lin W.Chem Sci,2013,4:2396-2402
8 Yue Y,Mayes RT,Kim J,Fulvio PF,Sun XG,Tsouris C,Chen J,Brown S,Dai S.Angew Chem Int Ed,2013,52:13458-13462
9 Camacho LM,Deng S,Parra RR.J Hazard Mater,2010,175:393-398
10 Korichi S,Bensmaili A.J Hazard Mater,2009,169:780-793
11 Lee SS,Li W,Kim C,Cho M,Lafferty BJ,Fortner JD.J Mater Chem A,2015,3:21930-21939
12 Naguib M,Gogotsi Y.Acc Chem Res,2015,48:128-135
13 Naguib M,Halim J,Lu J,Cook KM,Hultman L,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW.J Am Chem Soc,2013,135:15966-15969
14 Naguib M,Mashtalir O,Carle J,Presser V,Lu J,Hultman L,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW.ACS Nano,2012,6:1322-1331
15 Alhabeb M,Maleski K,Anasori B,Lelyukh P,Clark L,Sin S,Gogotsi Y.Chem Mater,2017,29:7633-7644
16 Barsoum MW.Prog Solid State Chem,2000,28:201-281
17 Naguib M,Kurtoglu M,Presser V,Lu J,Niu J,Heon M,Hultman L,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW.Adv Mater,2011,23:4248-4253
18 Ghidiu M,Lukatskaya MR,Zhao M-Q,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW.Nature,2014,516:78-81
19 Liang X,Garsuch A,Nazar LF.Angew Chem Int Ed,2015,54:3907-3911
20 Lukatskaya MR,Mashtalir O,Ren CE,Dall'Agnese Y,Rozier P,Taberna PL,Naguib M,Simon P,Barsoum MW,Gogotsi Y.Science,2013,341:1502-1505
21 Wang X,Kajiyama S,Iinuma H,Hosono E,Oro S,Moriguchi I,Okubo M,Yamada A.Nat Commun,2015,6:6544
22 Ren CE,Hatzell KB,Alhabeb M,Ling Z,Mahmoud KA,Gogotsi Y.J Phys Chem Lett,2015,6:4026-4031
23 Seh ZW,Fredrickson KD,Anasori B,Kibsgaard J,Strickler AL,Lukatskaya MR,Gogotsi Y,Jaramillo TF,Vojvodic A.ACS Energy Lett,2016,1:589-594
24 Shahzad F,Alhabeb M,Hatter CB,Anasori B,Man Hong S,Koo CM,Gogotsi Y.Science,2016,353:1137-1140
25 Dillon AD,Ghidiu MJ,Krick AL,Griggs J,May SJ,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW,Fafarman AT.Adv Funct Mater,2016,26:4162-4168
26 Halim J,Lukatskaya MR,Cook KM,Lu J,Smith CR,N?slund L?,May SJ,Hultman L,Gogotsi Y,Eklund P,Barsoum MW.Chem Mater,2014,26:2374-2381
27 Hantanasirisakul K,Zhao MQ,Urbankowski P,Halim J,Anasori B,Kota S,Ren CE,Barsoum MW,Gogotsi Y.Adv Electron Mater,2016,2:1600050
28 Guo J,Peng Q,Fu H,Zou G,Zhang Q.J Phys Chem C,2015,119:20923-20930
29 Lorencova L,Bertok T,Dosekova E,Holazova A,Paprckova D,Vikartovska A,Sasinkova V,Filip J,Kasak P,Jerigova M,Velic D,Mahmoud KA,Tkac J.Electrochim Acta,2017,235:471-479
30 Hoffman EN,Vinson DW,Sindelar RL,Tallman DJ,Kohse G,Barsoum MW.Nucl Eng Des,2012,244:17-24
31 Yang T,Wang C,Taylor CA,Huang X,Huang Q,Li F,Shen L,Zhou X,Xue J,Yan S,Wang Y.Acta Mater,2014,65:351-359
32 Zhang H,Su R,Shi L,O’Connor DJ,King BV,Kisi EH.J Eur Ceramic Soc,2018,38:1253-1264
33 Ghidiu M,Naguib M,Shi C,Mashtalir O,Pan LM,Zhang B,Yang J,Gogotsi Y,Billinge SJL,Barsoum MW.Chem Commun,2014,50:9517-9520
34 Alhabeb M,Maleski K,Mathis TS,Sarycheva A,Hatter CB,Uzun S,Levitt A,Gogotsi Y.Angew Chem Int Ed,2018,57:5444-5448
35 Urbankowski P,Anasori B,Makaryan T,Er D,Kota S,Walsh PL,Zhao M,Shenoy VB,Barsoum MW,Gogotsi Y.Nanoscale,2016,8:11385-11391
36 Li T,Yao L,Liu Q,Gu J,Luo R,Li J,Yan X,Wang W,Liu P,Chen B,Zhang W,Abbas W,Naz R,Zhang D.Angew Chem,2018,130:6223-6227
37 Zhou J,Zha X,Chen FY,Ye Q,Eklund P,Du S,Huang Q.Angew Chem,2016,128:5092-5097
38 Zhou J,Zha X,Zhou X,Chen F,Gao G,Wang S,Shen C,Chen T,Zhi C,Eklund P,Du S,Xue J,Shi W,Chai Z,Huang Q.ACS Nano,2017,11:3841-3850
39 Mashtalir O,Cook KM,Mochalin VN,Crowe M,Barsoum MW,Gogotsi Y.J Mater Chem A,2014,2:14334-14338
40 Kajiyama S,Szabova L,Iinuma H,Sugahara A,Gotoh K,Sodeyama K,Tateyama Y,Okubo M,Yamada A.Adv Energy Mater,2017,7:1601873
41 Ghidiu M,Halim J,Kota S,Bish D,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW.Chem Mater,2016,28:3507-3514
42 Peng Q,Guo J,Zhang Q,Xiang J,Liu B,Zhou A,Liu R,Tian Y.J Am Chem Soc,2014,136:4113-4116
43 Mashtalir O,Naguib M,Mochalin VN,Dall’Agnese Y,Heon M,Barsoum MW,Gogotsi Y.Nat Commun,2013,4:1716
44 Li L,Zhang M,Zhang X,Zhang Z.J Power Sources,2017,364:234-241
45 Shahzad A,Rasool K,Miran W,Nawaz M,Jang J,Mahmoud KA,Lee DS.ACS Sustain Chem Eng,2017,5:11481-11488
46 Guo J,Fu H,Zou G,Zhang Q,Zhang Z,Peng Q.J Alloys Compd,2016,684:504-509
47 Guo X,Zhang X,Zhao S,Huang Q,Xue J.Phys Chem Chem Phys,2016,18:228-233
48 Zhang YJ,Zhou ZJ,Lan JH,Ge CC,Chai ZF,Zhang P,Shi WQ.Appl Surf Sci,2017,426:572-578
49 Berdiyorov GR,Madjet ME,Mahmoud KA.Appl Phys Lett,2016,108:113110
50 Zhang YJ,Lan JH,Wang L,Wu QY,Wang CZ,Bo T,Chai ZF,Shi WQ.J Hazard Mater,2016,308:402-410
51 Ladeira ACQ,Ciminelli VST,Duarte HA,Alves MCM,Ramos AY.Geochim Cosmochim Acta,2001,65:1211-1217
52 Wang L,Tao W,Yuan L,Liu Z,Huang Q,Chai Z,Gibson JK,Shi W.Chem Commun,2017,53:12084-12087
53 Wang L,Yuan L,Chen K,Zhang Y,Deng Q,Du S,Huang Q,Zheng L,Zhang J,Chai Z,Barsoum MW,Wang X,Shi W.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces,2016,8:16396-16403
54 Gu P,Xing J,Wen T,Zhang R,Wang J,Zhao G,Hayat T,Ai Y,Lin Z,Wang X.Environ Sci-Nano,2018,5:946-955
55 Fard AK,Mckay G,Chamoun R,Rhadfi T,Preud’Homme H,Atieh MA.Chem Eng J,2017,317:331-342
56 Zou G,Guo J,Peng Q,Zhou A,Zhang Q,Liu B.J Mater Chem A,2016,4:489-499
57 Shahzad A,Rasool K,Miran W,Nawaz M,Jang J,Mahmoud KA,Lee DS.J Hazard Mater,2018,344:811-818
58 Jian M,Liu B,Zhang G,Liu R,Zhang X.Colloids Surfs A-Physicochem Eng Aspects,2015,465:67-76
59 Aksoyoglu S.J Radioanal Nucl Chem,1989,134:393-403
60 Saeed MM,Ahmed M,Chaudary MH,Gaffar A.Solvent Extr Ion Exch,2003,21:881-898
61 Xu N,Hochella Jr MF,Brown Jr GE,Parks GA.Geochim Cosmochim Acta,1996,60:2801-2815
62 Ying Y,Liu Y,Wang X,Mao Y,Cao W,Hu P,Peng X.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces,2015,7:1795-1803
63 Santos JS,Teixeira LSG,dos Santos WNL,Lemos VA,Godoy JM,Ferreira SLC.Anal Chim Acta,2010,674:143-156
64 Chen H,Huang S,Zhang Z,Liu Y,Wang X.Acta Chim Sin,2017,75:560-574(in Chinese)陈海军,黄舒怡,张志宾,刘云海,王祥科.化学学报,2017,75:560-574
65 Liang Y,Gu P,Yao W,Yu S,Wang J,Wang X.Prog Chem,2017,29:1062-1071(in Chinese)[梁宇,顾鹏程,姚文,于淑君,王建,王祥科.化学进展,2017,29:1062-1071]
66 Pang H,Wang X,Yao W,Yu S,Wang X.Sci Sin Chim,2018,48:58-73(in Chinese)庞宏伟,王祥学,姚文,于淑君,王祥科.中国科学:化学,2018,1:006
67 Yang S,Wang X,Chen Z,Li Q,Wei B,Wang X.Prog Chem,2017,30:225-242(in Chinese)[杨姗也,王祥学,陈中山,李倩,韦犇犇,王祥科.化学进展,2017,30:225-242]
68 Zong P,Wang S,Zhao Y,Wang H,Pan H,He C.Chem Eng J,2013,220:45-52
69 Li Z,Chen F,Yuan L,Liu Y,Zhao Y,Chai Z,Shi W.Chem Eng J,2012,210:539-546
70 Ding C,Cheng W,Sun Y,Wang X.J Hazard Mater,2015,295:127-137
71 Luo BC,Yuan LY,Chai ZF,Shi WQ,Tang Q.J Radioanal Nucl Chem,2016,307:269-276
72 Gao L,Yang Z,Shi K,Wang X,Guo Z,Wu W.J Radioanal Nucl Chem,2010,284:519-526
73 Mu W,Du S,Yu Q,Li X,Wei H,Yang Y.Dalton Trans,2018,47:8375-8381
74 Celebi O,Kilikli A,Erten HN.J Hazard Mater,2009,168:695-703
75 Gingele F,Dahmke A.Paleoceanography,1994,9:151-168
76 Owlad M,Aroua MK,Daud WAW,Baroutian S.Water Air Soil Pollut,2009,200:59-77
77 Kimbrough DE,Cohen Y,Winer AM,Creelman L,Mabuni C.Critical Rev Environ Sci Tech,1999,29:1-46
2 Bundt M,Albrecht A,Froidevaux P,Blaser P,Flühler H.Environ Sci Technol,2000,34:3895-3899
3 Fujita Y,Taylor JL,Gresham TLT,Delwiche ME,Colwell FS,McLing TL,Petzke LM,Smith RW.Environ Sci Technol,2008,42:3025-3032
4 Latta DE,Mishra B,Cook RE,Kemner KM,Boyanov MI.Environ Sci Technol,2014,48:1683-1691
5 Li J,Wang X,Zhao G,Chen C,Chai Z,Alsaedi A,Hayat T,Wang X.Chem Soc Rev,2018,47:2322-2356
6 Sun Y,Yang S,Chen Y,Ding C,Cheng W,Wang X.Environ Sci Technol,2015,49:4255-4262
7 Carboni M,Abney CW,Liu S,Lin W.Chem Sci,2013,4:2396-2402
8 Yue Y,Mayes RT,Kim J,Fulvio PF,Sun XG,Tsouris C,Chen J,Brown S,Dai S.Angew Chem Int Ed,2013,52:13458-13462
9 Camacho LM,Deng S,Parra RR.J Hazard Mater,2010,175:393-398
10 Korichi S,Bensmaili A.J Hazard Mater,2009,169:780-793
11 Lee SS,Li W,Kim C,Cho M,Lafferty BJ,Fortner JD.J Mater Chem A,2015,3:21930-21939
12 Naguib M,Gogotsi Y.Acc Chem Res,2015,48:128-135
13 Naguib M,Halim J,Lu J,Cook KM,Hultman L,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW.J Am Chem Soc,2013,135:15966-15969
14 Naguib M,Mashtalir O,Carle J,Presser V,Lu J,Hultman L,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW.ACS Nano,2012,6:1322-1331
15 Alhabeb M,Maleski K,Anasori B,Lelyukh P,Clark L,Sin S,Gogotsi Y.Chem Mater,2017,29:7633-7644
16 Barsoum MW.Prog Solid State Chem,2000,28:201-281
17 Naguib M,Kurtoglu M,Presser V,Lu J,Niu J,Heon M,Hultman L,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW.Adv Mater,2011,23:4248-4253
18 Ghidiu M,Lukatskaya MR,Zhao M-Q,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW.Nature,2014,516:78-81
19 Liang X,Garsuch A,Nazar LF.Angew Chem Int Ed,2015,54:3907-3911
20 Lukatskaya MR,Mashtalir O,Ren CE,Dall'Agnese Y,Rozier P,Taberna PL,Naguib M,Simon P,Barsoum MW,Gogotsi Y.Science,2013,341:1502-1505
21 Wang X,Kajiyama S,Iinuma H,Hosono E,Oro S,Moriguchi I,Okubo M,Yamada A.Nat Commun,2015,6:6544
22 Ren CE,Hatzell KB,Alhabeb M,Ling Z,Mahmoud KA,Gogotsi Y.J Phys Chem Lett,2015,6:4026-4031
23 Seh ZW,Fredrickson KD,Anasori B,Kibsgaard J,Strickler AL,Lukatskaya MR,Gogotsi Y,Jaramillo TF,Vojvodic A.ACS Energy Lett,2016,1:589-594
24 Shahzad F,Alhabeb M,Hatter CB,Anasori B,Man Hong S,Koo CM,Gogotsi Y.Science,2016,353:1137-1140
25 Dillon AD,Ghidiu MJ,Krick AL,Griggs J,May SJ,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW,Fafarman AT.Adv Funct Mater,2016,26:4162-4168
26 Halim J,Lukatskaya MR,Cook KM,Lu J,Smith CR,N?slund L?,May SJ,Hultman L,Gogotsi Y,Eklund P,Barsoum MW.Chem Mater,2014,26:2374-2381
27 Hantanasirisakul K,Zhao MQ,Urbankowski P,Halim J,Anasori B,Kota S,Ren CE,Barsoum MW,Gogotsi Y.Adv Electron Mater,2016,2:1600050
28 Guo J,Peng Q,Fu H,Zou G,Zhang Q.J Phys Chem C,2015,119:20923-20930
29 Lorencova L,Bertok T,Dosekova E,Holazova A,Paprckova D,Vikartovska A,Sasinkova V,Filip J,Kasak P,Jerigova M,Velic D,Mahmoud KA,Tkac J.Electrochim Acta,2017,235:471-479
30 Hoffman EN,Vinson DW,Sindelar RL,Tallman DJ,Kohse G,Barsoum MW.Nucl Eng Des,2012,244:17-24
31 Yang T,Wang C,Taylor CA,Huang X,Huang Q,Li F,Shen L,Zhou X,Xue J,Yan S,Wang Y.Acta Mater,2014,65:351-359
32 Zhang H,Su R,Shi L,O’Connor DJ,King BV,Kisi EH.J Eur Ceramic Soc,2018,38:1253-1264
33 Ghidiu M,Naguib M,Shi C,Mashtalir O,Pan LM,Zhang B,Yang J,Gogotsi Y,Billinge SJL,Barsoum MW.Chem Commun,2014,50:9517-9520
34 Alhabeb M,Maleski K,Mathis TS,Sarycheva A,Hatter CB,Uzun S,Levitt A,Gogotsi Y.Angew Chem Int Ed,2018,57:5444-5448
35 Urbankowski P,Anasori B,Makaryan T,Er D,Kota S,Walsh PL,Zhao M,Shenoy VB,Barsoum MW,Gogotsi Y.Nanoscale,2016,8:11385-11391
36 Li T,Yao L,Liu Q,Gu J,Luo R,Li J,Yan X,Wang W,Liu P,Chen B,Zhang W,Abbas W,Naz R,Zhang D.Angew Chem,2018,130:6223-6227
37 Zhou J,Zha X,Chen FY,Ye Q,Eklund P,Du S,Huang Q.Angew Chem,2016,128:5092-5097
38 Zhou J,Zha X,Zhou X,Chen F,Gao G,Wang S,Shen C,Chen T,Zhi C,Eklund P,Du S,Xue J,Shi W,Chai Z,Huang Q.ACS Nano,2017,11:3841-3850
39 Mashtalir O,Cook KM,Mochalin VN,Crowe M,Barsoum MW,Gogotsi Y.J Mater Chem A,2014,2:14334-14338
40 Kajiyama S,Szabova L,Iinuma H,Sugahara A,Gotoh K,Sodeyama K,Tateyama Y,Okubo M,Yamada A.Adv Energy Mater,2017,7:1601873
41 Ghidiu M,Halim J,Kota S,Bish D,Gogotsi Y,Barsoum MW.Chem Mater,2016,28:3507-3514
42 Peng Q,Guo J,Zhang Q,Xiang J,Liu B,Zhou A,Liu R,Tian Y.J Am Chem Soc,2014,136:4113-4116
43 Mashtalir O,Naguib M,Mochalin VN,Dall’Agnese Y,Heon M,Barsoum MW,Gogotsi Y.Nat Commun,2013,4:1716
44 Li L,Zhang M,Zhang X,Zhang Z.J Power Sources,2017,364:234-241
45 Shahzad A,Rasool K,Miran W,Nawaz M,Jang J,Mahmoud KA,Lee DS.ACS Sustain Chem Eng,2017,5:11481-11488
46 Guo J,Fu H,Zou G,Zhang Q,Zhang Z,Peng Q.J Alloys Compd,2016,684:504-509
47 Guo X,Zhang X,Zhao S,Huang Q,Xue J.Phys Chem Chem Phys,2016,18:228-233
48 Zhang YJ,Zhou ZJ,Lan JH,Ge CC,Chai ZF,Zhang P,Shi WQ.Appl Surf Sci,2017,426:572-578
49 Berdiyorov GR,Madjet ME,Mahmoud KA.Appl Phys Lett,2016,108:113110
50 Zhang YJ,Lan JH,Wang L,Wu QY,Wang CZ,Bo T,Chai ZF,Shi WQ.J Hazard Mater,2016,308:402-410
51 Ladeira ACQ,Ciminelli VST,Duarte HA,Alves MCM,Ramos AY.Geochim Cosmochim Acta,2001,65:1211-1217
52 Wang L,Tao W,Yuan L,Liu Z,Huang Q,Chai Z,Gibson JK,Shi W.Chem Commun,2017,53:12084-12087
53 Wang L,Yuan L,Chen K,Zhang Y,Deng Q,Du S,Huang Q,Zheng L,Zhang J,Chai Z,Barsoum MW,Wang X,Shi W.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces,2016,8:16396-16403
54 Gu P,Xing J,Wen T,Zhang R,Wang J,Zhao G,Hayat T,Ai Y,Lin Z,Wang X.Environ Sci-Nano,2018,5:946-955
55 Fard AK,Mckay G,Chamoun R,Rhadfi T,Preud’Homme H,Atieh MA.Chem Eng J,2017,317:331-342
56 Zou G,Guo J,Peng Q,Zhou A,Zhang Q,Liu B.J Mater Chem A,2016,4:489-499
57 Shahzad A,Rasool K,Miran W,Nawaz M,Jang J,Mahmoud KA,Lee DS.J Hazard Mater,2018,344:811-818
58 Jian M,Liu B,Zhang G,Liu R,Zhang X.Colloids Surfs A-Physicochem Eng Aspects,2015,465:67-76
59 Aksoyoglu S.J Radioanal Nucl Chem,1989,134:393-403
60 Saeed MM,Ahmed M,Chaudary MH,Gaffar A.Solvent Extr Ion Exch,2003,21:881-898
61 Xu N,Hochella Jr MF,Brown Jr GE,Parks GA.Geochim Cosmochim Acta,1996,60:2801-2815
62 Ying Y,Liu Y,Wang X,Mao Y,Cao W,Hu P,Peng X.ACS Appl Mater Interfaces,2015,7:1795-1803
63 Santos JS,Teixeira LSG,dos Santos WNL,Lemos VA,Godoy JM,Ferreira SLC.Anal Chim Acta,2010,674:143-156
64 Chen H,Huang S,Zhang Z,Liu Y,Wang X.Acta Chim Sin,2017,75:560-574(in Chinese)陈海军,黄舒怡,张志宾,刘云海,王祥科.化学学报,2017,75:560-574
65 Liang Y,Gu P,Yao W,Yu S,Wang J,Wang X.Prog Chem,2017,29:1062-1071(in Chinese)[梁宇,顾鹏程,姚文,于淑君,王建,王祥科.化学进展,2017,29:1062-1071]
66 Pang H,Wang X,Yao W,Yu S,Wang X.Sci Sin Chim,2018,48:58-73(in Chinese)庞宏伟,王祥学,姚文,于淑君,王祥科.中国科学:化学,2018,1:006
67 Yang S,Wang X,Chen Z,Li Q,Wei B,Wang X.Prog Chem,2017,30:225-242(in Chinese)[杨姗也,王祥学,陈中山,李倩,韦犇犇,王祥科.化学进展,2017,30:225-242]
68 Zong P,Wang S,Zhao Y,Wang H,Pan H,He C.Chem Eng J,2013,220:45-52
69 Li Z,Chen F,Yuan L,Liu Y,Zhao Y,Chai Z,Shi W.Chem Eng J,2012,210:539-546
70 Ding C,Cheng W,Sun Y,Wang X.J Hazard Mater,2015,295:127-137
71 Luo BC,Yuan LY,Chai ZF,Shi WQ,Tang Q.J Radioanal Nucl Chem,2016,307:269-276
72 Gao L,Yang Z,Shi K,Wang X,Guo Z,Wu W.J Radioanal Nucl Chem,2010,284:519-526
73 Mu W,Du S,Yu Q,Li X,Wei H,Yang Y.Dalton Trans,2018,47:8375-8381
74 Celebi O,Kilikli A,Erten HN.J Hazard Mater,2009,168:695-703
75 Gingele F,Dahmke A.Paleoceanography,1994,9:151-168
76 Owlad M,Aroua MK,Daud WAW,Baroutian S.Water Air Soil Pollut,2009,200:59-77
77 Kimbrough DE,Cohen Y,Winer AM,Creelman L,Mabuni C.Critical Rev Environ Sci Tech,1999,29:1-46