基于对称性指标预测拓扑材料
|
摘要
拓扑材料是凝聚态物理和材料科学领域的前沿课题。随着理论方法的发展,最近人们在大规模筛选拓扑材料方向取得了多个进展。文章着重介绍作者基于对称性指标理论发展的根据在原子绝缘体基组展开系数高效判断材料拓扑性质的方法,以及相关的典型材料。人们预言的数千个新的拓扑体系为进一步深入研究拓扑材料提供了基础。
Over the past decade, topological materials——in which the topology of electron bands in the bulk material leads to robust, unconventional surface states and electromagnetism——have attracted much attention. With the development of the theoretical methods,recently there have been many advancements on searching for topological materials in a large scale. Very recently, based on symmetry-indicator theory and using so-called atomic insulator basis, we develop a theoretical method for systematically discovering topological materials. In this paper, we introduce our algorithm, and we also discuss several typical topological materials.The predicted thousands of topological materials provide a platform for further study on topological materials next step.
Over the past decade, topological materials——in which the topology of electron bands in the bulk material leads to robust, unconventional surface states and electromagnetism——have attracted much attention. With the development of the theoretical methods,recently there have been many advancements on searching for topological materials in a large scale. Very recently, based on symmetry-indicator theory and using so-called atomic insulator basis, we develop a theoretical method for systematically discovering topological materials. In this paper, we introduce our algorithm, and we also discuss several typical topological materials.The predicted thousands of topological materials provide a platform for further study on topological materials next step.
引文
[1]v Klitzing K,Dorda G,Pepper M.Phys.Rev.Lett.,1980,45:494
[2]Thouless D J,Kohmoto M,Nightingale M P et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,1982,49:405
[3]Haldane F D M.Phys.Rev.Lett.,1988,61:2015
[4]Hasan M Z,Kane C L.Rev.Mod.Phys.,2010,82:3045
[5]Qi X L,Zhang S C.Rev.Mod.Phys.,2011,83:1057
[6]Kane C L,Mele E J.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2005,95:226801
[7]Kane C L,Mele E J.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2005,95:146802
[8]Bernevig B A,Hughes T,Zhang S C.Science,2006,314:1757
[9]Fu L,Kane C L,Kane E J.Phy.Rev.Lett.,2007,98:106803
[10]Moore J E,Balents L.Phys.Rev.B,2007,75:121306(R)
[11]Roy R.Phys.Rev.B,2009,79:195322
[12]Schnyder A P,Ryu S,Furusaki A et al.Phys.Rev.B,2008,78:195125
[13]Ryu S,Schnyder A P,Furusaki A et al.New Journal of Physics,2010,12:065010
[14]Kitaev A.AIP Conference Proceedings,2009,1134:22
[15]Chiu C K,Teo J C Y,Schnyder A P et al.Rev.Mod.Phys.,2016,88:035005
[16]Fu L.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2011,106:106802
[17]Hsieh T H,Lin H,Liu J et al.Nature Commun.,2012,3:982
[18]Wang Z,Alexandradinata A,Cava R J et al.Nature,2016,532:189
[19]Wieder B J et al.Science,2018,361:246
[20]Schindler F et al.Science Advances,2018,4:eaat0346
[21]Benalcazar W A,Bernevig B A,Hughes T L.Science,2017,357:61
[22]Benalcazar W A,Bernevig B A,Hughes T L.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:245115
[23]Song Z,Fang Z,Fang C.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2017,119:246402
[24]Langbehn J,Peng Y,Trifunovic L et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2017,119:246401
[25]Slager R J,Mesarosm A,Juric?ic V et al.Nature Physics,2013,9:98
[26]Ando Y,Fu L.Annu.Rev.Condens.Matter Phys.,2015,6:361
[27]Wan X,Turner A M,Vishwanath A et al.Phys.Rev.B,2011,83:205101;万贤纲.物理,2015,44:427
[28]Young S M,Zaheer S,Teo J C Y et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2012,108:140405
[29]Wang Z et al.Phys.Rev.B,2012,85:195320
[30]Wang Z,Weng H,Wu Q et al.Phys.Rev.B,2013,88:125427
[31]Burkov A A,Hook M D,Balents L.Phys.Rev.B,2011,84:235126
[32]Weng H,Liang Y,Xu Q et al.Phys.Rev.B,2015,92:045108;Fang C,Chen Y,Kee H Y et al.Phys.Rev.B,2015,92:081201
[33]Bzdusek T,Wu Q S,Ruegg A et al.Nature,2016,538:75
[34]Chen W,Lu H Z,Hou J M.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:041102(R);Sun X Q,Lian B,Zhang S C.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2017,119:147001;Yan Z,Bi R,Shen H et al.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:041103(R)
[35]Chang P Y,Yee C H.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:081114(R)
[36]Ezawa M.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:041202(R)
[37]Wang L,Jian S K,Yao H.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:075110
[38]Bradlyn B et al.Science,2016,353:aaf5037;Weng H,Fang C,Fang Z et al.Phys.Rev.B,2016,93:241202(R);Weng H,Fang C,Fang Z et al.Phys.Rev.B,2016,94:165201
[39]Zhang T et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2009,103:266803
[40]Fu L,Kane C L.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2008,100:096407;Akhmerov A R,Nilsson J,Beenakker C W J.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2009,102:216404
[41]Qi X L,Hughes T L,Zhang S C.Phys.Rev.B,2008,78:195424;Essin A,Moore J E,Vanderbilt D.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2009,102:146805
[42]Son D T,Spivak B Z.Phys.Rev.B,2013,88:104412
[43]Potter A C,Kimchi I,Vishwanath A.Nature Commun.,2014,5:5161'
[44]Wang C M,Sun H P,Lu H Z et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2017,119:136806
[45]Zhang C et al.Nature,2019,565:331
[46]Yang K Y,Lu Y M,Ran Y.Phys.Rev.B,2011,84:075129
[47]Hosur P,Dai X,Fang Z et al.Phys.Rev.B,2014,90:045130
[48]Wu L et al.Nature Physics,2017,13:350
[49]Katsnelson M I,Novoselov K S,Geim A K.Nature Physics,2006,2:620
[50]Kopnin N B,Heikkila T T,Volovik G E.Phys.Rev.B,2011,83:220503(R)
[51]Zhang H,Liu C X,Qi X L et al.Nature Physics,2009,5:438
[52]Weng H,Fang C,Fang Z et al.Phys.Rev.X,2015,5:011029;Huang S M et al.Nature Commun.,2015,6:7373
[53]Xu G,Weng H,Wang Z et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2011,107:186806
[54]Yu R,Weng H,Fang Z et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2015,115:036807;Kim Y,Wieder B J,Kane C L et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2015,115:036806
[55]Yu R,Zhang W,Zhang H J et al.Science,2010,329:61
[56]Du Y,Wan B,Wang D et al.Scientific Reports,2015,5:14423;Du Y et al.npj Quantum Materials,2017,2:3
[57]Liu C C,Feng W,Yao Y.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2011,107:076802
[58]Zhang H J et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2011,106:156402
[59]Qian X,Liu J,Fu L et al.Science,2014,346:1344
[60]Zhang W et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2011,106:156808
[61]Neupane M et al.Phys.Rev.B,2012,85:235406
[62]Kuroda K et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2012,108:206803
[63]Yan B et al.Europhys.Lett.,2010,90:37002
[64]Sato T et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2010,105:136802
[65]Xu Y et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2013,111:136804
[66]Bansil A,Lin H,Das T.Rev.Mod.Phys.,2016,88:021004
[67]Tang P,Zhou Q,Zhang S C.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2017,119:206402
[68]Schindler F et al.Nature Physics,2018,14:918
[69]Hsieh D et al.Nature,2009,460:1101;Chen Y et al.Science,2009,325:178;Xia Y et al.Nature Physics,2009,5:398
[70]Liu Z K et al.Science,2014,343:864;Liu Z K et al.Nature Materials,2014,13:677
[71]Lv B Q et al.Phys.Rev.X,2015,5:031013;Xu S Y et al.Science,2015,349:613;Lv B Q et al.Nature,2017,546:627
[72]Zhang C L et al.Nature Commun.,2016,7:10735;Huang Xet al.Phys.Rev.X,2015,5:031023
[73]Fei Z et al.Nature Physics,2017,13:677;Tang S et al.Nature Physics,2017,13:683
[74]Zhu F F et al.Nature Materials,2015,14:1020
[75]Chang C Z et al.Science,2013,340:167
[76]Takane D et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2019,122:076402
[77]Rao Z et al.Nature,2019,567:496
[78]Sanchez D S et al.Nature,2019,567:500
[79]Ando Y.J.Phys.Soc.Jpn.,2013,82:102001
[80]Armitage N P,Mele E J,Vishwanath A.Rev.Mod.Phys.,2018,90:015001
[81]Feng W,Wen J,Zhou J et al.Computer Physics Communications,2012,183:1849
[82]Scanlon D O et al.Adv.Mater.,2012,24:2154
[83]Wang N et al.Phys.Rev.B,2014,89:045142
[84]Fu L,Kane C L.Phys.Rev.B,2007,76:045302
[85]Fang C,Gilbert M J,Bernevig B A.Phys.Rev.B,2012,86:115112
[86]Bradlyn B,Elcoro L,Cano J et al.Nature,2017,547:298
[87]Po H C,Vishwanath A,Watanabe H.Nature Commun.,2017,8:50
[88]Tang F,Po H C,Vishwanath A et al.Nature Physics,2019,15:470
[89]Bradley C J,Cracknell A P.The Mathematical Theory of Symmetry in Solids:Representation Theory for Point Groups and Space Groups.Oxford University Press,1972
[90]Tang F,Po H C,Vishwanath A et al.Nature,2019,566:486
[91]Tang F,Po H C,Vishwanath A et al.Science Advances,2019,5:eaau8725
[92]Khalaf E,Po H C,Vishwanath A et al.Phys.Rev.X,2018,8:031070
[93]Song Z,Zhang T,Fang Z et al.Nature Commun.,2018,9:3530
[94]Hellenbrandt M.Crystallogr.Rev.,2004,10:17
[95]Brixner L H.J.Inorg.Nucl.Chem.,1962,24:257
[96]Brown B E.Acta Crystallogr.,1966,20:268
[97]Clarke R,Marseglia E,Hughes H P.Philos.Mag.B,1978,38:121
[98]Deng K et al.Nature Physics,2016,12:1105
[99]Tamai A et al.Phys.Rev.X,2016,6:031021
[100]Huang L et al.Nat.Mater.,2016,15:1155;Jiang J et al.Nat.Commun.,2017,8:13973
[101]Wang Z,Wieder B J,Li J et al.arXiv 1806.11116(2018)
[102]Fang C,Fu L.arXiv 1709.01929(2017)
[103]Hsu C H et al.2D Mater.,2019,6:031004
[104]Tang F,Wan X.Frontiers of Physics,2019,14:4
[105]Zhang T,Jiang Y,Song Z et al.Nature,2019,566:475
[106]Vergniory M G,Elcoro L,Felser C et al.Nature,2019,566:480
[107]Song Z,Zhang T,Fang C.Phys.Rev.X,2018,8:031069
[108]Wang D et al.arXiv 1906.01283(2019)
[109]Watanabe H,Po H C,Vishwanath A.Science Advances,2018,4:eaat8685
[110]Po H C,Watanabe H,Vishwanath A.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2018,121:126402
[111]Watanabe H,Lu L.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2018,121:263903
[112]de Paz M B,Vergniory M G,Bercioux D et al.arXiv 1903.02562(2019)
[113]Ono S,Yanase Y,Watanabe H.arXiv 1811.08712(2018)
[114]Blaha P,Schwarz K,Madsen G K H et al.WIEN2k:An Augmented Plane Wave+Local Orbitals Program for Calculating Crystal Properties.Karlheinz Schwarz,Technische Univ.Wien,Autria,2001
[115]Perdew J P,Burke K,Ernzerhof M.Phys.Rev.Lett.,1996,77:3865
[116]Koller D,Tran F,Blaha P.Phys.Rev.B,2001,83:195134
[2]Thouless D J,Kohmoto M,Nightingale M P et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,1982,49:405
[3]Haldane F D M.Phys.Rev.Lett.,1988,61:2015
[4]Hasan M Z,Kane C L.Rev.Mod.Phys.,2010,82:3045
[5]Qi X L,Zhang S C.Rev.Mod.Phys.,2011,83:1057
[6]Kane C L,Mele E J.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2005,95:226801
[7]Kane C L,Mele E J.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2005,95:146802
[8]Bernevig B A,Hughes T,Zhang S C.Science,2006,314:1757
[9]Fu L,Kane C L,Kane E J.Phy.Rev.Lett.,2007,98:106803
[10]Moore J E,Balents L.Phys.Rev.B,2007,75:121306(R)
[11]Roy R.Phys.Rev.B,2009,79:195322
[12]Schnyder A P,Ryu S,Furusaki A et al.Phys.Rev.B,2008,78:195125
[13]Ryu S,Schnyder A P,Furusaki A et al.New Journal of Physics,2010,12:065010
[14]Kitaev A.AIP Conference Proceedings,2009,1134:22
[15]Chiu C K,Teo J C Y,Schnyder A P et al.Rev.Mod.Phys.,2016,88:035005
[16]Fu L.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2011,106:106802
[17]Hsieh T H,Lin H,Liu J et al.Nature Commun.,2012,3:982
[18]Wang Z,Alexandradinata A,Cava R J et al.Nature,2016,532:189
[19]Wieder B J et al.Science,2018,361:246
[20]Schindler F et al.Science Advances,2018,4:eaat0346
[21]Benalcazar W A,Bernevig B A,Hughes T L.Science,2017,357:61
[22]Benalcazar W A,Bernevig B A,Hughes T L.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:245115
[23]Song Z,Fang Z,Fang C.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2017,119:246402
[24]Langbehn J,Peng Y,Trifunovic L et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2017,119:246401
[25]Slager R J,Mesarosm A,Juric?ic V et al.Nature Physics,2013,9:98
[26]Ando Y,Fu L.Annu.Rev.Condens.Matter Phys.,2015,6:361
[27]Wan X,Turner A M,Vishwanath A et al.Phys.Rev.B,2011,83:205101;万贤纲.物理,2015,44:427
[28]Young S M,Zaheer S,Teo J C Y et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2012,108:140405
[29]Wang Z et al.Phys.Rev.B,2012,85:195320
[30]Wang Z,Weng H,Wu Q et al.Phys.Rev.B,2013,88:125427
[31]Burkov A A,Hook M D,Balents L.Phys.Rev.B,2011,84:235126
[32]Weng H,Liang Y,Xu Q et al.Phys.Rev.B,2015,92:045108;Fang C,Chen Y,Kee H Y et al.Phys.Rev.B,2015,92:081201
[33]Bzdusek T,Wu Q S,Ruegg A et al.Nature,2016,538:75
[34]Chen W,Lu H Z,Hou J M.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:041102(R);Sun X Q,Lian B,Zhang S C.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2017,119:147001;Yan Z,Bi R,Shen H et al.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:041103(R)
[35]Chang P Y,Yee C H.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:081114(R)
[36]Ezawa M.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:041202(R)
[37]Wang L,Jian S K,Yao H.Phys.Rev.B,2017,96:075110
[38]Bradlyn B et al.Science,2016,353:aaf5037;Weng H,Fang C,Fang Z et al.Phys.Rev.B,2016,93:241202(R);Weng H,Fang C,Fang Z et al.Phys.Rev.B,2016,94:165201
[39]Zhang T et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2009,103:266803
[40]Fu L,Kane C L.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2008,100:096407;Akhmerov A R,Nilsson J,Beenakker C W J.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2009,102:216404
[41]Qi X L,Hughes T L,Zhang S C.Phys.Rev.B,2008,78:195424;Essin A,Moore J E,Vanderbilt D.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2009,102:146805
[42]Son D T,Spivak B Z.Phys.Rev.B,2013,88:104412
[43]Potter A C,Kimchi I,Vishwanath A.Nature Commun.,2014,5:5161'
[44]Wang C M,Sun H P,Lu H Z et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2017,119:136806
[45]Zhang C et al.Nature,2019,565:331
[46]Yang K Y,Lu Y M,Ran Y.Phys.Rev.B,2011,84:075129
[47]Hosur P,Dai X,Fang Z et al.Phys.Rev.B,2014,90:045130
[48]Wu L et al.Nature Physics,2017,13:350
[49]Katsnelson M I,Novoselov K S,Geim A K.Nature Physics,2006,2:620
[50]Kopnin N B,Heikkila T T,Volovik G E.Phys.Rev.B,2011,83:220503(R)
[51]Zhang H,Liu C X,Qi X L et al.Nature Physics,2009,5:438
[52]Weng H,Fang C,Fang Z et al.Phys.Rev.X,2015,5:011029;Huang S M et al.Nature Commun.,2015,6:7373
[53]Xu G,Weng H,Wang Z et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2011,107:186806
[54]Yu R,Weng H,Fang Z et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2015,115:036807;Kim Y,Wieder B J,Kane C L et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2015,115:036806
[55]Yu R,Zhang W,Zhang H J et al.Science,2010,329:61
[56]Du Y,Wan B,Wang D et al.Scientific Reports,2015,5:14423;Du Y et al.npj Quantum Materials,2017,2:3
[57]Liu C C,Feng W,Yao Y.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2011,107:076802
[58]Zhang H J et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2011,106:156402
[59]Qian X,Liu J,Fu L et al.Science,2014,346:1344
[60]Zhang W et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2011,106:156808
[61]Neupane M et al.Phys.Rev.B,2012,85:235406
[62]Kuroda K et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2012,108:206803
[63]Yan B et al.Europhys.Lett.,2010,90:37002
[64]Sato T et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2010,105:136802
[65]Xu Y et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2013,111:136804
[66]Bansil A,Lin H,Das T.Rev.Mod.Phys.,2016,88:021004
[67]Tang P,Zhou Q,Zhang S C.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2017,119:206402
[68]Schindler F et al.Nature Physics,2018,14:918
[69]Hsieh D et al.Nature,2009,460:1101;Chen Y et al.Science,2009,325:178;Xia Y et al.Nature Physics,2009,5:398
[70]Liu Z K et al.Science,2014,343:864;Liu Z K et al.Nature Materials,2014,13:677
[71]Lv B Q et al.Phys.Rev.X,2015,5:031013;Xu S Y et al.Science,2015,349:613;Lv B Q et al.Nature,2017,546:627
[72]Zhang C L et al.Nature Commun.,2016,7:10735;Huang Xet al.Phys.Rev.X,2015,5:031023
[73]Fei Z et al.Nature Physics,2017,13:677;Tang S et al.Nature Physics,2017,13:683
[74]Zhu F F et al.Nature Materials,2015,14:1020
[75]Chang C Z et al.Science,2013,340:167
[76]Takane D et al.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2019,122:076402
[77]Rao Z et al.Nature,2019,567:496
[78]Sanchez D S et al.Nature,2019,567:500
[79]Ando Y.J.Phys.Soc.Jpn.,2013,82:102001
[80]Armitage N P,Mele E J,Vishwanath A.Rev.Mod.Phys.,2018,90:015001
[81]Feng W,Wen J,Zhou J et al.Computer Physics Communications,2012,183:1849
[82]Scanlon D O et al.Adv.Mater.,2012,24:2154
[83]Wang N et al.Phys.Rev.B,2014,89:045142
[84]Fu L,Kane C L.Phys.Rev.B,2007,76:045302
[85]Fang C,Gilbert M J,Bernevig B A.Phys.Rev.B,2012,86:115112
[86]Bradlyn B,Elcoro L,Cano J et al.Nature,2017,547:298
[87]Po H C,Vishwanath A,Watanabe H.Nature Commun.,2017,8:50
[88]Tang F,Po H C,Vishwanath A et al.Nature Physics,2019,15:470
[89]Bradley C J,Cracknell A P.The Mathematical Theory of Symmetry in Solids:Representation Theory for Point Groups and Space Groups.Oxford University Press,1972
[90]Tang F,Po H C,Vishwanath A et al.Nature,2019,566:486
[91]Tang F,Po H C,Vishwanath A et al.Science Advances,2019,5:eaau8725
[92]Khalaf E,Po H C,Vishwanath A et al.Phys.Rev.X,2018,8:031070
[93]Song Z,Zhang T,Fang Z et al.Nature Commun.,2018,9:3530
[94]Hellenbrandt M.Crystallogr.Rev.,2004,10:17
[95]Brixner L H.J.Inorg.Nucl.Chem.,1962,24:257
[96]Brown B E.Acta Crystallogr.,1966,20:268
[97]Clarke R,Marseglia E,Hughes H P.Philos.Mag.B,1978,38:121
[98]Deng K et al.Nature Physics,2016,12:1105
[99]Tamai A et al.Phys.Rev.X,2016,6:031021
[100]Huang L et al.Nat.Mater.,2016,15:1155;Jiang J et al.Nat.Commun.,2017,8:13973
[101]Wang Z,Wieder B J,Li J et al.arXiv 1806.11116(2018)
[102]Fang C,Fu L.arXiv 1709.01929(2017)
[103]Hsu C H et al.2D Mater.,2019,6:031004
[104]Tang F,Wan X.Frontiers of Physics,2019,14:4
[105]Zhang T,Jiang Y,Song Z et al.Nature,2019,566:475
[106]Vergniory M G,Elcoro L,Felser C et al.Nature,2019,566:480
[107]Song Z,Zhang T,Fang C.Phys.Rev.X,2018,8:031069
[108]Wang D et al.arXiv 1906.01283(2019)
[109]Watanabe H,Po H C,Vishwanath A.Science Advances,2018,4:eaat8685
[110]Po H C,Watanabe H,Vishwanath A.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2018,121:126402
[111]Watanabe H,Lu L.Phys.Rev.Lett.,2018,121:263903
[112]de Paz M B,Vergniory M G,Bercioux D et al.arXiv 1903.02562(2019)
[113]Ono S,Yanase Y,Watanabe H.arXiv 1811.08712(2018)
[114]Blaha P,Schwarz K,Madsen G K H et al.WIEN2k:An Augmented Plane Wave+Local Orbitals Program for Calculating Crystal Properties.Karlheinz Schwarz,Technische Univ.Wien,Autria,2001
[115]Perdew J P,Burke K,Ernzerhof M.Phys.Rev.Lett.,1996,77:3865
[116]Koller D,Tran F,Blaha P.Phys.Rev.B,2001,83:195134