双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液的研究进展
|
摘要
压裂技术是提高低渗透油气藏生产能力和油气井采收率的重要手段,而压裂液是影响压裂效果的关键因素。相较于水基植物胶压裂液和以单链表面活性剂为稠化剂的传统清洁压裂液,双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液在耐温、携砂和保护油气层等使用性能上更具优势,是新一代清洁压裂液发展重点。本文综述了双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液制备、性能及应用的研究进展,分析比较了阳离子双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液、阴离子双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液、两性双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液等的优缺点,讨论了双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液在油田领域的应用现状:阳离子双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液的制备方法成熟,耐温性能较好,可以应用于中高温油田,但是其生产成本较高;阴离子双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液能有效减少表面活性剂在地层的吸附损失,降低储层渗透率伤害,但是其合成条件苛刻,耐温性不高,适用于中低温油田;两性双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂溶液的耐温性好,但是其制备过程繁琐、成本高,难以大规模推广应用。对双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液的研究前景进行了展望:发展低成本的合成方法及耐高温双子表面活性剂类清洁压裂液的制备及应用。
Fracturing technology is very important for improving the production capacity of the low permeability reservoir, and the recovery of oil and gas wells. The fracturing fluids are the key factors to affect the fracturing effect.Gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids have become the key items in the development of new generation clean fracturing fluids, for its excellent utilization property compared with the water base plant fracturing fluid and traditional clean fracturing fluids with single-tailed surfactant as viscosifier. The recent advances in the preparation, performance and application of gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids were reviewed in this paper. Different gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids, including cationic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids, anionic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids, zwitterionic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids are compared, and the applications of gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids in oilfield are also discussed. Cationic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids could be applied in medium-high temperature oilfields with the advantage of mature preparation methods and good anti-temperature property, the disadvantage of cationic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids is high cost. Anionic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids has the advantage of lower damage to reservoir permeability and stratum adsorption amount of surfactant, the disadvantage of anionic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids is harsh reactionconditions and medium anti-temperature property, so it could be applied in medium-low temperature oilfields. The zwitterionic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids has high anti-temperature property, but it is difficult to apply because of the complex preparation process and high cost. From the view of preparation, performance and practical applications, the research perspective of gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids was outlined in the end of this paper, which are the development of low-cost methods and the preparation and application of gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids with high anti-temperature.
Fracturing technology is very important for improving the production capacity of the low permeability reservoir, and the recovery of oil and gas wells. The fracturing fluids are the key factors to affect the fracturing effect.Gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids have become the key items in the development of new generation clean fracturing fluids, for its excellent utilization property compared with the water base plant fracturing fluid and traditional clean fracturing fluids with single-tailed surfactant as viscosifier. The recent advances in the preparation, performance and application of gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids were reviewed in this paper. Different gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids, including cationic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids, anionic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids, zwitterionic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids are compared, and the applications of gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids in oilfield are also discussed. Cationic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids could be applied in medium-high temperature oilfields with the advantage of mature preparation methods and good anti-temperature property, the disadvantage of cationic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids is high cost. Anionic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids has the advantage of lower damage to reservoir permeability and stratum adsorption amount of surfactant, the disadvantage of anionic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids is harsh reactionconditions and medium anti-temperature property, so it could be applied in medium-low temperature oilfields. The zwitterionic gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids has high anti-temperature property, but it is difficult to apply because of the complex preparation process and high cost. From the view of preparation, performance and practical applications, the research perspective of gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids was outlined in the end of this paper, which are the development of low-cost methods and the preparation and application of gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluids with high anti-temperature.
引文
[1]王所良,李勇,吴增智.高温油藏用海水基压裂液研究进展[J].石油化工应用,2016,35(10):5-9.WANG S L,LI Y,WU Z Z.Review on aerwater based fracturing fluids for high temperature reservoirs[J].Petrochemical Industry Application,2016,35(10):5-9.
[2]张磊.清洁压裂液研究进展及应用现状[J].精细石油化工进展,2012,13(8):12-15.ZHANG L.Status quo of research and application of clean fracturing fluid[J].Advances in Fine Petrochemicals,2012,13(8):12-15.
[3]刘刚之,崔景海,谭博.清洁压裂液研究进展[J].中国石油和化工,2013(6):48-50.LIU G Z,CUI J H,TAN B.The research progress of clean fracturing fluid[J].Petroleum Engineering Technology,2013(6):48-50.
[4]严志虎,戴彩丽,赵明伟,等.清洁压裂液的研究与应用进展[J].油田化学,2015,32(1):141-145.YAN Z H,DAI C L,ZHAO M W,et al.Progress in research and application of clean fracturing fluids[J].Oilfield Chemistry,2015,32(1):141-145.
[5]魏静,钟汉斌.清洁压裂液的最新研究进展[J].广东化工,2015,42(17):121-121,126.WEI J,ZHONG H B.Latest development on clean fracturing fluid[J].Guangdong Chemical Industry,2015,42(17):121-121,126.
[6]刘明书,唐善法,方飞飞,等.清洁压裂液用离子型表面活性剂体系的研究进展[J].精细石油化工进展,2012,13(6):1390-1392.LIU M S,TANF S F,FANG F F,et al.Progress of research on ionic surfactant system for use in clean fracturing fluids[J].Advances in Fine Petrochemicals,2012,13(6):1390-1392.
[7]黄嵘,唐善法.中高温清洁压裂液研究及应用进展[J].化工生产与技术,2012,19(3):28-32.HUANG R,TANF S F.The research progress of medium-high temperature clean fracturing fluid[J].Chemical Production and Tachnology,2012,19(3):28-32.
[8]WANG B M,WEN S C,ZHOU M.Study and evaluation on clean fracturing fluid performance[J].International Journal of Science,2014,1(5):24-27.
[9]余海棠,刘彦锋,王迪东.黏弹性清洁压裂液的性能评价与应用[J].应用化工,2013,42(9):1641-1647.YU H T,LIU Y F,WANG D D.Performance evaluation and application of viscoelastic surfactant-based fracturing fluid[J].Applied Chemicalindustry,2013,42(9):1641-1647.
[10]TYAGI P,TYAGI R.Synthesis,structural properties and applications of gemini surfactants:a review[J].Tenside Surfactants Detergents,2009,46(6):373-382.
[11]KAMAL M S.A review of gemini surfactants:potential application in enhanced oil recovery[J].Journal of Surfactants&Detergents,2016,19(2):223-236.
[12]赵永,丁国华,刘峥.双子表面活性剂的合成与应用研究进展[J].精细石油化工,2015,32(2):75-79.ZHAO Y,DING G H,LIU Z.Synthesis and application of gemini surfactant[J].Speciality Petrochemicals,2015,32(2):75-79.
[13]陈文杰,邵波,刘勇,等.双子表面活性剂在油气田开发中的应用研究[J].长江大学学报(自科版),2016,13(34):66-70.CHEN W J,SHAO B,LIU Y,et al.The application of gemini surfactant in the development of oil and gas fields[J].Journal of Yangtze University(Natural Science Edition),2016,13(34):66-70.
[14]李谦定,孟凡宁,杨添麒,等.N,N'-双(十八烷基二甲基)-1,2-二溴化己二铵盐双子表面活性剂的合成及应用研究[J].精细化工,2014,31(12):1452-1456.LI Q D,MENG F N,YANG T L,et al.Synthesis and application research of N,N'-bis(octadecyl dimethyl)-1,2-dibromide-dihexyl ammonium salt[J].Fine Chemicals,2014,31(12):1452-1456.
[15]穆瑞花,狄育慧,余丽丽,等.阳离子清洁压裂液的室内性能评价[J].现代化工,2016,36(7):114-117.MU R H,DI Y H,YU L L,et al.Laboratory performance analysis of cationic cleaning fracturing fluid[J].Modern Chemical Industry,2016,36(7):114-117.
[16]张福铭,李学军,陈小华,等.中高温清洁压裂液体系PA-VES120的研发[J].中国海上油气,2014,26(5):86-91.ZHANG F M,LI X J,CHEN X H,et al.Development of medium-high temperature clean fracturing fluid PA-VES120[J].China Offshore Oil and Gas,2014,26(5):86-91.
[17]沈一丁,马少云,王磊,等.一种中高温清洁压裂液及其制备方法:CN101775276A[P].2010-02-02.SHEN Y D,MA S Y,WANG L,et al.Medium high temperature clean fracturing fluid and its preparation method:CN101775276A[P].2010-02-02.
[18]李超群,王增宝,李宏,等.油气层保护用清洁压裂液的性能评价[J].精细石油化工进展,2011,12(12):11-14.LI C Q,WANG Z B,LI H,et al.Evaluation on performance of a clean fracturing fluid for oil and gas reservoir protection[J].Advances in Fine Petrochemicals,2011,12(12):11-14.
[19]鲁红升,郑存川,黄志宇,等.一种含酯基的阳离子双子表面活性剂及其制备方法和应用:CN106540631A[P].2016-07-13.LU H S,ZHENG C C,HUANG Z Y,et al.Cationic gemini surfactant containing esterfunction and its preparation method and application:CN106540631A[P].2016-07-13.
[20]余瀚森,杨海洋,彭康,等.一种双子阳离子表面活性剂及其制备方法:CN106946743 A[P].2017-05-02.YU H S,YANG H Y,PENG K,et al.Cationic gemini surfactant and its preparation method:CN106946743 A[P].2017-05-02.
[21]贾振福,钟静霞,牛红彬,等.新型清洁压裂液的实验室合成[J].钻井液与完井液,2006,23(6):42-46.JIA Z F,ZHONG J X,NIU H B,et al.Laboratory synthesis of a new clear fracturing fluid[J].Drilling Fluid&Completion Fluid,2006,23(6):42-46.
[22]杨志远,王晓华,杨伏生,等.一种煤层气清洁压裂液:CN104312572 A[P].2014-09-25.YANG Z Y,WANG X H,YANG F S,et al.Clean fracturing fluid for coalbed methane:CN104312572 A[P].2014-09-25.
[23]YANG C P,SONG Z Z,ZHAO J J.Self-assembly properties of ultra-long-chain gemini surfactants bearing multiple amide groups with high performance in fracturing fluid application[J].Colloids and Surfaces A:Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects,2017,523:62-70.
[24]MAO J C,YANG X J,WANG D L,et al.A novel gemini viscoelastic surfactant(VES)for fracturing fluids with good temperature stability[J].RSC Advances,2016,6:88426-88432.
[25]CHEN F,WU Y,WANG M,et al.Self-assembly networks of wormlike micelles and hydrophobically modified polyacrylamide with high performance in fracturing fluid application[J].Colloid and Polymer Science,2015,293(3):687-697.
[26]张艳,张士诚,张劲,等.耐高温酸性清洁压裂液性能研究及适用性探讨[J].油田化学,2014,31(2):199-202.ZHANG Y,ZHANG S C,ZHANG J,et al.Research and discussion on applicability of high temperature resistant acidic clean fracturing fluid[J].Oilfield Chemistry,2014,31(2):199-202.
[27]虞建业.一种无盐型清洁压裂液表面活性稠化剂合成方法:CN103951599 A[P].2014-05-14.YU J Y.The synthetic method of clean fracturing fluid viscoelastic surfactant without salt:CN103951599 A[P].2014-05-14.
[28]朱红军,牛华,娄平均,等.含双子表面活性剂酸性清洁压裂液的合成与性能[J].精细石油化工进展,2011,12(10):4-8.ZHU H J,NIU H,LOU P J,et al.Synthesis and performance of gemini surfactant-containing acidic clean fracturing fluid[J].Advances in Fine Petrochemicals,2011,12(10):4-8.
[29]娄平均,牛华,朱红军,等.新型吉米奇季铵盐在VES清洁压裂液中的应用研究[J].油气田开发,2011,29(1):45-47.LOU P J,NIU H,ZHU H J,et al.The application of new gemini quaternary ammonium salt in VES clean fracturing fluid[J].Oil and Gas Field Development,2011,29(1):45-47.
[30]牛华,娄平均,丁徽,等.新型吉米奇(Gemini)季铵盐(NGA)的研制及其在VES清洁压裂液中的应用[J].石油化工应用,2010,29(7):13-16.NIU H,LOU P J,DING W,et al.Preparation of a new gemini quaternary ammonium salt(NGA)and application in VES clean fracturing fluid[J].Petrochemical Industry Application,2010,29(7):13-16.
[31]唐善法,胡小冬,欧阳向南,等.阴离子双子表面活性剂提高采收率技术研究[C]//第四届全国油气田开发技术大会.北海,2011.TANG S F,HU X D,OUYANG X N,et al.Research on the enhancing oil recovery technologies of anionic gemini surfactant[C]//4th National Conference on Oil and Gas Field Development Technology.Beihai,2011.
[32]唐善法,崔云海,熊萧,等.阴离子双子表面活性剂(GA-16)溶液黏度及影响因素研究[J].石油天然气学报,2014,36(8):146-149.TANG S F,CUI Y H,XIONG X,et al.Research on the solution viscosity and influencing factors of anionic gemini surfactant(GA-16)[J].Journal of Oil and Gas Technology,2014,36(8):146-149.
[33]雷小洋,唐善法,余吉良,等.GA 16复合清洁压裂液的制备及其性能研究[J].长江大学学报,2015,12(31):34-36.LEI X Y,TANG S F,YU J L,et al.Preparation of GA-16 complex clean fracturing fluid and its properties[J].Journal of Yangtze University(Natural Science Edition),2015,12(31):34-36.
[34]唐善法,赵成洋,田磊,等.羧酸盐双子表面活性剂耐温清洁压裂液-以在塔里木盆地致密砂岩气藏应用为例[J].天然气工业,2016,36(6):45-51.TANG S F,ZHAO C Y,TIAN L,et al.Temperature-resistance clean fracturing fluid with carboxylate gemini surfactant:a case study of tight sandstone gas reservoirs in the Tarim Basin[J].Natural Gas Industry,2016,36(6):45-51.
[35]宋有胜,赵文娜,王宇宾,等.一种清洁压裂液:CN104371700A[P].2014-11-06.SONG Y S,ZHAO W N,WANG Y B,et al.Clean fracturing fluid:CN104371700A[P].2014-11-06.
[36]毛金成,杨小江,张恒,等.一种双子两性黏弹性表面活性剂及其制备方法和以其为稠化剂的清洁压裂液:CN201610578298.3[P].2016-07-21.MAO J C,YANG X J,ZHANG H,et al.Gemini amphoteric viscoelastic surfactant and its preparation method and clean fracturing fluid using it as viscosifier:CN201610578298.3[P].2016-07-21.
[37]张玄,张鹏,张聪忠,等.耐高温清洁压裂液及其制备方法:CN03525391 A[P].2013-10-11.ZHANG X,ZHANG P,ZHANG C Z,et al.High temperature-resistance clean fracturing fluid and its preparation method:CN103525391 A[P].2013-10-11.
[38]虞建业,卢敏晖,袁萍,等.一种双子表面活性剂的合成方法及其应用:CN103936634[P].2014-05-14.YU J Y,LU M H,YU P,et al.Synthetic method and application of one gemini surfactant:CN103936634[P].2014-05-14.
[39]刘明书,唐善法,方飞飞,等.阴阳离子双子表面活性剂在清洁压裂液中的应用[J].断块油气田,2012,19(5):651-653.LIU M S,TANG S F,FANG F F,et al.Application of anioniccationic gemini surfactant in clean fracturing fluid[J].Fault-Block Oil&Gas Field,2012,19(5):651-653.
[40]梁策.CTJ清洁压裂液室内性能评价[J].中国石油和化工标准与质量,2013(6):112.LIANG C.Laboratory performance analysis of CTJ clean fracturing fluid[J].China Petroleum and Chemical Standard and Quality,2013(6):112.
[41]王满学,何静,吴安明.一种清洁压裂液及其制备方法:CN104194766 A[P].2014-09-12.WANG M X,HE J,WU A M.One clean fracturing fluid and its preparation method:CN104194766 A[P].2014-09-12.
[42]陈亚联,张冕,王祖文.一种油井双子表面活性剂压裂液及其制备方法:CN103965859 A[P].2014-04-23.CHEN Y L,ZHANG M,WANG Z W.One gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluid and its preparation method:CN103965859A[P].2014-04-23.
[2]张磊.清洁压裂液研究进展及应用现状[J].精细石油化工进展,2012,13(8):12-15.ZHANG L.Status quo of research and application of clean fracturing fluid[J].Advances in Fine Petrochemicals,2012,13(8):12-15.
[3]刘刚之,崔景海,谭博.清洁压裂液研究进展[J].中国石油和化工,2013(6):48-50.LIU G Z,CUI J H,TAN B.The research progress of clean fracturing fluid[J].Petroleum Engineering Technology,2013(6):48-50.
[4]严志虎,戴彩丽,赵明伟,等.清洁压裂液的研究与应用进展[J].油田化学,2015,32(1):141-145.YAN Z H,DAI C L,ZHAO M W,et al.Progress in research and application of clean fracturing fluids[J].Oilfield Chemistry,2015,32(1):141-145.
[5]魏静,钟汉斌.清洁压裂液的最新研究进展[J].广东化工,2015,42(17):121-121,126.WEI J,ZHONG H B.Latest development on clean fracturing fluid[J].Guangdong Chemical Industry,2015,42(17):121-121,126.
[6]刘明书,唐善法,方飞飞,等.清洁压裂液用离子型表面活性剂体系的研究进展[J].精细石油化工进展,2012,13(6):1390-1392.LIU M S,TANF S F,FANG F F,et al.Progress of research on ionic surfactant system for use in clean fracturing fluids[J].Advances in Fine Petrochemicals,2012,13(6):1390-1392.
[7]黄嵘,唐善法.中高温清洁压裂液研究及应用进展[J].化工生产与技术,2012,19(3):28-32.HUANG R,TANF S F.The research progress of medium-high temperature clean fracturing fluid[J].Chemical Production and Tachnology,2012,19(3):28-32.
[8]WANG B M,WEN S C,ZHOU M.Study and evaluation on clean fracturing fluid performance[J].International Journal of Science,2014,1(5):24-27.
[9]余海棠,刘彦锋,王迪东.黏弹性清洁压裂液的性能评价与应用[J].应用化工,2013,42(9):1641-1647.YU H T,LIU Y F,WANG D D.Performance evaluation and application of viscoelastic surfactant-based fracturing fluid[J].Applied Chemicalindustry,2013,42(9):1641-1647.
[10]TYAGI P,TYAGI R.Synthesis,structural properties and applications of gemini surfactants:a review[J].Tenside Surfactants Detergents,2009,46(6):373-382.
[11]KAMAL M S.A review of gemini surfactants:potential application in enhanced oil recovery[J].Journal of Surfactants&Detergents,2016,19(2):223-236.
[12]赵永,丁国华,刘峥.双子表面活性剂的合成与应用研究进展[J].精细石油化工,2015,32(2):75-79.ZHAO Y,DING G H,LIU Z.Synthesis and application of gemini surfactant[J].Speciality Petrochemicals,2015,32(2):75-79.
[13]陈文杰,邵波,刘勇,等.双子表面活性剂在油气田开发中的应用研究[J].长江大学学报(自科版),2016,13(34):66-70.CHEN W J,SHAO B,LIU Y,et al.The application of gemini surfactant in the development of oil and gas fields[J].Journal of Yangtze University(Natural Science Edition),2016,13(34):66-70.
[14]李谦定,孟凡宁,杨添麒,等.N,N'-双(十八烷基二甲基)-1,2-二溴化己二铵盐双子表面活性剂的合成及应用研究[J].精细化工,2014,31(12):1452-1456.LI Q D,MENG F N,YANG T L,et al.Synthesis and application research of N,N'-bis(octadecyl dimethyl)-1,2-dibromide-dihexyl ammonium salt[J].Fine Chemicals,2014,31(12):1452-1456.
[15]穆瑞花,狄育慧,余丽丽,等.阳离子清洁压裂液的室内性能评价[J].现代化工,2016,36(7):114-117.MU R H,DI Y H,YU L L,et al.Laboratory performance analysis of cationic cleaning fracturing fluid[J].Modern Chemical Industry,2016,36(7):114-117.
[16]张福铭,李学军,陈小华,等.中高温清洁压裂液体系PA-VES120的研发[J].中国海上油气,2014,26(5):86-91.ZHANG F M,LI X J,CHEN X H,et al.Development of medium-high temperature clean fracturing fluid PA-VES120[J].China Offshore Oil and Gas,2014,26(5):86-91.
[17]沈一丁,马少云,王磊,等.一种中高温清洁压裂液及其制备方法:CN101775276A[P].2010-02-02.SHEN Y D,MA S Y,WANG L,et al.Medium high temperature clean fracturing fluid and its preparation method:CN101775276A[P].2010-02-02.
[18]李超群,王增宝,李宏,等.油气层保护用清洁压裂液的性能评价[J].精细石油化工进展,2011,12(12):11-14.LI C Q,WANG Z B,LI H,et al.Evaluation on performance of a clean fracturing fluid for oil and gas reservoir protection[J].Advances in Fine Petrochemicals,2011,12(12):11-14.
[19]鲁红升,郑存川,黄志宇,等.一种含酯基的阳离子双子表面活性剂及其制备方法和应用:CN106540631A[P].2016-07-13.LU H S,ZHENG C C,HUANG Z Y,et al.Cationic gemini surfactant containing esterfunction and its preparation method and application:CN106540631A[P].2016-07-13.
[20]余瀚森,杨海洋,彭康,等.一种双子阳离子表面活性剂及其制备方法:CN106946743 A[P].2017-05-02.YU H S,YANG H Y,PENG K,et al.Cationic gemini surfactant and its preparation method:CN106946743 A[P].2017-05-02.
[21]贾振福,钟静霞,牛红彬,等.新型清洁压裂液的实验室合成[J].钻井液与完井液,2006,23(6):42-46.JIA Z F,ZHONG J X,NIU H B,et al.Laboratory synthesis of a new clear fracturing fluid[J].Drilling Fluid&Completion Fluid,2006,23(6):42-46.
[22]杨志远,王晓华,杨伏生,等.一种煤层气清洁压裂液:CN104312572 A[P].2014-09-25.YANG Z Y,WANG X H,YANG F S,et al.Clean fracturing fluid for coalbed methane:CN104312572 A[P].2014-09-25.
[23]YANG C P,SONG Z Z,ZHAO J J.Self-assembly properties of ultra-long-chain gemini surfactants bearing multiple amide groups with high performance in fracturing fluid application[J].Colloids and Surfaces A:Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects,2017,523:62-70.
[24]MAO J C,YANG X J,WANG D L,et al.A novel gemini viscoelastic surfactant(VES)for fracturing fluids with good temperature stability[J].RSC Advances,2016,6:88426-88432.
[25]CHEN F,WU Y,WANG M,et al.Self-assembly networks of wormlike micelles and hydrophobically modified polyacrylamide with high performance in fracturing fluid application[J].Colloid and Polymer Science,2015,293(3):687-697.
[26]张艳,张士诚,张劲,等.耐高温酸性清洁压裂液性能研究及适用性探讨[J].油田化学,2014,31(2):199-202.ZHANG Y,ZHANG S C,ZHANG J,et al.Research and discussion on applicability of high temperature resistant acidic clean fracturing fluid[J].Oilfield Chemistry,2014,31(2):199-202.
[27]虞建业.一种无盐型清洁压裂液表面活性稠化剂合成方法:CN103951599 A[P].2014-05-14.YU J Y.The synthetic method of clean fracturing fluid viscoelastic surfactant without salt:CN103951599 A[P].2014-05-14.
[28]朱红军,牛华,娄平均,等.含双子表面活性剂酸性清洁压裂液的合成与性能[J].精细石油化工进展,2011,12(10):4-8.ZHU H J,NIU H,LOU P J,et al.Synthesis and performance of gemini surfactant-containing acidic clean fracturing fluid[J].Advances in Fine Petrochemicals,2011,12(10):4-8.
[29]娄平均,牛华,朱红军,等.新型吉米奇季铵盐在VES清洁压裂液中的应用研究[J].油气田开发,2011,29(1):45-47.LOU P J,NIU H,ZHU H J,et al.The application of new gemini quaternary ammonium salt in VES clean fracturing fluid[J].Oil and Gas Field Development,2011,29(1):45-47.
[30]牛华,娄平均,丁徽,等.新型吉米奇(Gemini)季铵盐(NGA)的研制及其在VES清洁压裂液中的应用[J].石油化工应用,2010,29(7):13-16.NIU H,LOU P J,DING W,et al.Preparation of a new gemini quaternary ammonium salt(NGA)and application in VES clean fracturing fluid[J].Petrochemical Industry Application,2010,29(7):13-16.
[31]唐善法,胡小冬,欧阳向南,等.阴离子双子表面活性剂提高采收率技术研究[C]//第四届全国油气田开发技术大会.北海,2011.TANG S F,HU X D,OUYANG X N,et al.Research on the enhancing oil recovery technologies of anionic gemini surfactant[C]//4th National Conference on Oil and Gas Field Development Technology.Beihai,2011.
[32]唐善法,崔云海,熊萧,等.阴离子双子表面活性剂(GA-16)溶液黏度及影响因素研究[J].石油天然气学报,2014,36(8):146-149.TANG S F,CUI Y H,XIONG X,et al.Research on the solution viscosity and influencing factors of anionic gemini surfactant(GA-16)[J].Journal of Oil and Gas Technology,2014,36(8):146-149.
[33]雷小洋,唐善法,余吉良,等.GA 16复合清洁压裂液的制备及其性能研究[J].长江大学学报,2015,12(31):34-36.LEI X Y,TANG S F,YU J L,et al.Preparation of GA-16 complex clean fracturing fluid and its properties[J].Journal of Yangtze University(Natural Science Edition),2015,12(31):34-36.
[34]唐善法,赵成洋,田磊,等.羧酸盐双子表面活性剂耐温清洁压裂液-以在塔里木盆地致密砂岩气藏应用为例[J].天然气工业,2016,36(6):45-51.TANG S F,ZHAO C Y,TIAN L,et al.Temperature-resistance clean fracturing fluid with carboxylate gemini surfactant:a case study of tight sandstone gas reservoirs in the Tarim Basin[J].Natural Gas Industry,2016,36(6):45-51.
[35]宋有胜,赵文娜,王宇宾,等.一种清洁压裂液:CN104371700A[P].2014-11-06.SONG Y S,ZHAO W N,WANG Y B,et al.Clean fracturing fluid:CN104371700A[P].2014-11-06.
[36]毛金成,杨小江,张恒,等.一种双子两性黏弹性表面活性剂及其制备方法和以其为稠化剂的清洁压裂液:CN201610578298.3[P].2016-07-21.MAO J C,YANG X J,ZHANG H,et al.Gemini amphoteric viscoelastic surfactant and its preparation method and clean fracturing fluid using it as viscosifier:CN201610578298.3[P].2016-07-21.
[37]张玄,张鹏,张聪忠,等.耐高温清洁压裂液及其制备方法:CN03525391 A[P].2013-10-11.ZHANG X,ZHANG P,ZHANG C Z,et al.High temperature-resistance clean fracturing fluid and its preparation method:CN103525391 A[P].2013-10-11.
[38]虞建业,卢敏晖,袁萍,等.一种双子表面活性剂的合成方法及其应用:CN103936634[P].2014-05-14.YU J Y,LU M H,YU P,et al.Synthetic method and application of one gemini surfactant:CN103936634[P].2014-05-14.
[39]刘明书,唐善法,方飞飞,等.阴阳离子双子表面活性剂在清洁压裂液中的应用[J].断块油气田,2012,19(5):651-653.LIU M S,TANG S F,FANG F F,et al.Application of anioniccationic gemini surfactant in clean fracturing fluid[J].Fault-Block Oil&Gas Field,2012,19(5):651-653.
[40]梁策.CTJ清洁压裂液室内性能评价[J].中国石油和化工标准与质量,2013(6):112.LIANG C.Laboratory performance analysis of CTJ clean fracturing fluid[J].China Petroleum and Chemical Standard and Quality,2013(6):112.
[41]王满学,何静,吴安明.一种清洁压裂液及其制备方法:CN104194766 A[P].2014-09-12.WANG M X,HE J,WU A M.One clean fracturing fluid and its preparation method:CN104194766 A[P].2014-09-12.
[42]陈亚联,张冕,王祖文.一种油井双子表面活性剂压裂液及其制备方法:CN103965859 A[P].2014-04-23.CHEN Y L,ZHANG M,WANG Z W.One gemini surfactant clean fracturing fluid and its preparation method:CN103965859A[P].2014-04-23.