家庭环境对中学生阅读能力的影响:阅读投入、阅读兴趣的中介作用
详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |
  • 英文篇名:Effect of family environment on reading ability: The mediating effects of reading engagement and reading interest among junior high school students
  • 作者:温红博 ; 凯丽 ; 刘先伟
  • 英文作者:WEN Hongbo;LIANG Kaili;LIU Xianwei;Institute of education statistics and measurement, Beijing Normal University;
  • 关键词:家庭环境 ; 阅读兴趣 ; 阅读投入 ; 阅读能力 ; 中介效应 ; 结构方程模型
  • 英文关键词:family environment;;reading interest;;reading engagement;;reading ability;;mediating effect;;structural equational modeling
  • 中文刊名:XLXB
  • 英文刊名:Acta Psychologica Sinica
  • 机构:北京师范大学教育统计与测量研究所;
  • 出版日期:2016-03-15
  • 出版单位:心理学报
  • 年:2016
  • 期:v.48
  • 语种:中文;
  • 页:XLXB201603004
  • 页数:10
  • CN:03
  • ISSN:11-1911/B
  • 分类号:32-41
摘要
采用学生阅读能力测试卷和学生阅读状况调查问卷,对随机选取的559名中学生进行调查,并运用结构方程模型探讨了家庭环境影响阅读能力的内在机制。结果发现,家庭环境影响阅读投入的路径系数为0.18,阅读投入影响阅读兴趣的路径系数为0.51,阅读兴趣影响阅读投入的路径系数为0.80,阅读投入影响阅读能力的路径系数为0.46,各路径系数均达到显著水平(p<0.05)。结果表明,(1)家庭环境通过阅读投入的完全中介作用影响阅读兴趣;阅读兴趣通过阅读投入的完全中介作用影响阅读成绩;(2)家庭环境对阅读能力的影响是通过阅读投入和阅读兴趣的循环互动作用实现的。
        Several studies found that family factors were important to students' reading ability. However, there are few studies discussing the internal mechanism. As students' individual characteristic, reading interest is one of the mediating factors between family environment and reading ability. Nowadays, investigators have paid more attention to the reading engagement, and some studies show that it is reasonable to believe the mediating effect of reading engagement. Therefore, it's important to discuss the mediating effect of reading interest and reading engagement on reading ability. The first study we explored was whether reading interest and reading engagement were the single-step multiple mediating variables between family environment and reading ability. The hypothese1: reading interest and reading engagement were single-step multiple mediators between family environment and reading ability. Furthermore, studies show that reading interest had significant influence on reading engagement. The second study was whether reading interest and reading engagement were the multiple-step multiple mediating variables between family environment and reading ability. The hypothese2: the relationship between family environment and reading ability via the influence of reading interest on reading engagement. However, some researchers suggest that there is the interaction between reading interest and reading engagement so the third study was whether the interaction between reading interest and reading engagement could be the mediating effect between family environment and reading ability. The hypothese3: The relationship between family environment and reading ability was in nature through the interaction between reading interest and reading engagement. Participants were 574 8th students from two medium counties. In each county, there were 3 common junior high schools selected which were categorized as better, general, poor on the basis of school conditions respectively. And two classes were selected randomly from each school. All students Participated in the reading ability test and reading questionnaire test. After testing, 15 students were excluded from the analyses because of incomplete data in reading ability test and same answers in reading questionnaire test. The final samples included 273(48.84%) male students and 286(51.16%) female students. The population was distributed widely. There were 301(53.85%) students from towns, and 258(46.15%) students from villages. Participants completed two measures: reading questionnaire(32 items) and reading ability test(24 items). Reading questionnaire included personal information, family environment questionnaire, reading interest questionnaire, reading engagement questionnaire. Reading ability test included four passages which were categorized as narrative(2 passages) and expository(2 passages).Preliminary and descriptive analyses showed: The internal consistency for reading questionnaire(family environment, reading interest, reading engagement) was measured by Cronbach's alpha,they were 0.72, 0.84, 0.79. The internal consistency for reading ability test was.870. In study 1, reading engagement could be a mediator of the relationship between family environment and reading ability. Model fit indices in SEM were χ2 = 575.95, df = 128, χ2/df = 4.50(p < 0.001), TLI = 0.82, CFI = 0.85, RMSEA = 0.08. In study 2, the relationship between family environment and reading ability was through the effect of reading interest on reading engagement. Model fit indices in SEM were χ2 = 334.70, df = 128, χ2/df = 2.62(p < 0.001), TLI = 0.92, CFI = 0.93, RMSEA = 0.05. In study 3, The relationship between family environment and reading ability was in nature through the interactive cycle between reading interest and reading engagement. Model fit indices in SEM were χ2 = 334.75, df = 129, χ2/df = 2.60(p < 0.001), TLI = 0.92, CFI = 0.93, RMSEA = 0.05. SEM results are different from previous studies:(1) reading engagement is the mediating variable between family environment and reading interest, reading engagement is the mediating variable between family reading interest and reading performance;(2) The relationship between family environment and reading ability is in nature through the interactive cycle between reading interest and reading engagement. Reading engagement plays a critical role in internal mechanism between family environment and reading ability.
引文
Fan,N.(2010).The effect of non-cognitive factors on reading ability:Emotional.Journal of Adult Education of Hebei University,12,98-99.[范宁.(2010).影响阅读能力的非认知因素:情绪.河北大学成人教育学院学报,12,98-99.]
    Fang,J.,Wen,Z.L.,Zhang,M.Q.,&Sun,P.Z.(2014).The analyses of multiple mediation effects based on structural equation modeling.Journal of Psychological Science,37,735-741.[方杰,温忠麟,张敏强,孙配贞.(2014).基于结构方程模型的多重中介效应分析.心理科学,37,735-741.]
    Freedman,J.L.,Sears,D.O.,&Carlsmith,J.M.(1984).Social psychology(D.Gao,&J.Gao,Trans.).Harbin:Heilongjiang People’s Press.[弗里德曼,西尔斯,卡尔史密斯.(1984).社会心理学(高地,高佳译).哈尔滨:黑龙江人民出版社.]
    He,X.M.,&Chen,X.M.(2008).The effect of students’learning engagement on learning interest.Global Education,37,46-51.[何旭明,陈向明.(2008).学生的学习投入对学习兴趣的影响研究.全球教育展望,37,46-51.]
    Huang,C.G.(2009).The main factors effecting children’s reading ability.Journal of Library Science,31,53-56.[黄春光.(2009).影响儿童阅读能力的主要环境因素.图书馆学刊,31,53-56.]
    Huang,X.R.(2009).The influence of family finances and the overall results of the class on children’s reading performance:Longitudinal studies.In Chinese Psychological Society(Ed.),Selected papers on twelfth national academic conference of psychology(pp.53-56).Ji’nan:Shandong Normal University.[黄小瑞.(2009).家庭经济状况及班级的整体成绩对儿童阅读成绩的影响:纵向研究.见中国心理学会(编),第十二届全国心理学学术大会论文摘要集(pp.53-56).济南:山东师范大学.]
    Lei,H.,Liu,Y.L.,&Tian,L.(2012).The relationship among family environment,class environment,and the academic of high school students:The mediating effect of learning diligence.Shanghai Jiaoyu Keyan,(4),17-20.[雷浩,刘衍玲,田澜.(2012).家庭环境、班级环境与高中生学业成绩的关系:学业勤奋度的中介作用.上海教育科研,(4),17-20.]
    Lin,C.D.(1985).Psychological issues of intellectual development.Beijing:Knowledge Press.[林传鼎.(1985).智力开发的心理学问题.北京:知识出版社.]
    Lu,J.(2012).The influence of engagement in reading and learning strategy on reading performance:Evidence-based research with Shanghai PISA 2009 data.Educational Development and Research,(18),17-24.[陆璟.(2012).阅读参与度和学习策略对阅读成绩的影响-基于上海PISA2009数据的实证研究.教育研究发展,(18),17-24.]
    Ren,C.R.,&Xin,T.(2013).Longitudinal study on predicting effect of social economic status on students'performance.Education Research,(3),79-87.[任春荣,辛涛.(2013).家庭社会经济地位对小学生成绩预测效应的追踪研究.教育研究,(3),79-87.]
    Shi,L.S.,Chen,Y.M.,Hou,X.,&Gao,F.Q.(2013).Social economic status and study engagement:The mediating effects of academic self-efficacy among junior high school students.Psychological Development and Education,29,71-77.[石雷山,陈英敏,侯秀,高峰强.(2013).家庭社会经济地位与学习投入的关系:学业自我效能的中介作用.心理发展与教育,29,71-77.]
    Shu,H.,Li,W.L.,Gu,Y.M.,Anderson,R.,Wu,X.C.,Zhang,H.C.,&Xuan,Y.(2002).The role of home literacy environment in children’s reading development.Psychological Science,25,136-139.[舒华,李文玲,辜玉旻,Anderson,R.,伍新春,张厚粲,轩月.(2002).家庭文化背景在儿童阅读发展中的作用.心理科学,25,136-139.]
    Tang,J.M.(2005).Study on development assessment of middle school students'reading ability(Unpublished master’s thesis).Dongbei Normal University,Jiling.[唐吉民.(2005).中学生阅读能力的发展性评价研究(硕士学位论文).东北师范大学,吉林.]
    Tang,W.J.,Wen,H.B.,Liu,X.W.,&Su,M.(in press).The causal model study among family,school environment and students’reading ability in primary school.The Journal of Education.[唐文君,温红博,刘先伟,苏梅.(印刷中).家庭、学校环境与小学生阅读能力的因果模型研究.教育学报.]
    Wang,J.C.,Wang,X.Q.,&Jiang,B.F.(2012).Structural equation models:Methods and applications.Beijing:Higher Education Press.[王济川,王小倩,姜宝法.(2012).结构方程模型:方法与应用.北京:高等教育出版社.]
    Wen,H.B.,&Xin,T.(2011-03-17).Reading literacy:The basic ability of children for the future.China Education Daily,p1-6.[温红博,辛涛.(2011-03-17).阅读素养:孩子面向未来的基础能力.中国教育报,p1-6.]
    Wen,H.B.(2005).Primary scholar Chinese reading ability scales:Development,validity,and reliability(Unpublished master’s thesis).Huanan Normal University,Guangdong.[温鸿博.(2005).小学语文阅读能力测评量表的编制(硕士学位论文).华南师范大学,广东.]
    Wen,Z.L.,Zhang,L.,Hou,J.T.,&Liu,H.Y.(2004).Testing and application of the mediating effects.Acta Psychologica Sinica,36,614-620.[温忠麟,张雷,侯杰泰,刘红云.(2004).中介效应检验程序及其应用.心理学报,36,614-620.]
    Wen,C.,Zhang,W.,Li,D.P.,Yu,C.F.,&Dai,W.Z.(2010).Relationship between junior students’gratitude and academic achievement:With academic engagement as the mediator.Psychological Development and Education,26,598-605.[文超,张卫,李董平,喻承甫,代维祝.(2010).初中生感恩与学业成就的关系:学习投入的中介作用.心理发展与教育,26,598-605.]
    Yu,Z.Z.(2009).The revelation of PISA test to reading teaching in primary school.Zhejiang Education Science,(5),19-22.[虞哲中.(2009).PISA测试对我国小学阅读教学的启示.浙江教育科学,(5),19-22.]
    Zhang,B.Y.(2004).Reading psychology.Beijing:Beijing Normal University Press.[张必隐.(2004).阅读心理学.北京:北京师范大学出版社.]
    Zhang,S.,Su,M.,Wang,L.L.,&Wen,H.B.(2014).The effect of teachers on students’reading ability:The mediating effect of reading engagement.Chinese Journal of Special Education,(9),84-89.[张生,苏梅,王丽丽,温红博.(2014).教师对学生阅读能力的影响研究:阅读投入的中介效应.中国特殊教育,(9),84-89.]
    Zhang,W.J.,&Xin,T.(2012).A cross-culture comparison study of the impact of reading engagement on reading literacy:Based on PISA 2009.Psychological Development and Education,28,175-183.[张文静,辛涛.(2012).阅读投入对阅读素养影响的跨文化比较研究-以PISA 2009为例.心理发展与教育,28,175-183.]
    Zhang,K.(2000).Interest and learning:A resurgent research.Journal of Ningbo University(Educational Science),22,27-30,33.[章凯.(2000).兴趣与学习:一个正在复兴的研究领域.宁波大学学报(教育科学版),22,27-30,33.]
    Babi?,D.P.,&Baucal,A.(2011).The big improvement in PISA 2009 reading achievements in Serbia:Improvement of the quality of education or something else?CEPSJournal:Center for Educational Policy Students Journal,1,53-74.
    Bandura,A.(1997).Self-efficacy:The exercise of control.New York:W.H.Freeman and Company.
    Bentler,P.M.(1990).Comparative fit indexes in structural models.Psychological Bulletin,107,238-246.
    Bradley,R.H.,&Corwyn,R.F.(2002).Socioeconomic status and child development.Annual Review of Psychology,53,371-399.
    Briggs,C.,&Elkind,D.(1977).Characteristics of early readers.Perceptual and Motor Skills,44,1231-1237.
    Campbell,J.R.,Voelkl,K.E.,&Donahue,P.L.(1997).NAEP1996 trends in academic progress(NCES Publication No.97985r).Washington,DC:U.S.Department of Education.
    Davis-Kean,P.E.(2005).The influence of parent education and family income on child achievement:The indirect role of parental expectations and the home environment.Journal of Family Psychology,19,294-304.
    Eseryel,D.,Law,V.,Ifenthaler,D.,Ge,X.,&Miller,R.(2014).An investigation of the interrelationships between motivation,engagement,and complex problem solving in game-based learning.Educational Technology&Society,17,42-53.
    Finn,J.D.(1993).School engagement and students at risk.Washington,DC:National Center for Education Statistics.
    Flowerday,T.,Schraw,G.,&Stevens,J.(2004).The role of choice and interest in reader engagement.The Journal of Experimental Education,72,93-114.
    Fredricks,J.A.,Blumenfeld,P.C.,&Paris,A.H.(2004).School engagement:Potential of the concept,state of the evidence.Review of Educational Research,74,59-109.
    Furrer,C.J.,&Skinner,E.A.(2003).Sense of relatedness as a factor in children’s academic engagement and performance.Journal of Educational Psychology,95,148-162.
    Guthrie,J.T.,&Wigfield,A.(2000).Engagement and motivation in reading.In M.L.Kamil,P.B.Mosenthal,P.D.Pearson,&R.Barr(Eds.),Handbook of reading research:Volume III(pp.403-422).New York:Erlbaum.
    Hart,B.,&Risley,T.R.(1995).Meaningful differences in the everyday experience of young American children.Baltimore:Brookes.
    Hayes,A.F.(2009).Beyond Baron and Kenny:Statistical mediation analysis in the new millennium.Communication Monographs,76,408-420.
    Hidi,S.(1990).Interest and its contribution as a mental resource for learning.Review of Educational Research,60,549-571.
    Hidi,S.(2001).Interest,reading,and learning:Theoretical and practical considerations.Educational Psychology Review,13,191-209.
    Hoff-Ginsberg,E.,&Tardif,T.(1995).Socioeconomic status and parenting.In M.H.Bornstein(Ed.),Handbook of parenting(Vol.4,pp.161-187).Mahwah,NJ:Erlbaum.
    Kirsch,I.,de Jong,J.,Lafontaine,D.,McQ ueen,J.,Mendelovits,J.,&Monseur,C.(2002).Reading for change:Performance and engagement across countries(pp.1-263).Paris:Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.
    Mackinnon,D.P.(2008).Introduction to statistical mediation analysis.Mahwah,N.J.:Earlbaum.
    Matthews,K.A.,&Gallo,L.C.(2011).Psychological perspectives on pathways linking socioeconomic status and physical health.Annual Review of Psychology,62,501-530.
    Means,T.B.,Jonassen,D.H.,&Dwyer,F.M.(1997).Enhancing relevance:Embedded ARCS strategies vs.purpose.Educational Technology Research and Development,45,5-17.
    Narvaez,D.,van den Broek,P.,&Buiz,A.B.(1999).The influence of reading purpose on inference generation and comprehension in reading.Journal of Educational Psychology,91,488-496.
    OECD.(2010).PISA 2009 results:What students know and can do:Student performance in reading,mathematics and science(p.6-19).Paris:Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.
    Patrick,B.C.,Skinner,E.A.,&Connell,J.P.(1993).What motivates children’s behavior and emotion?Joint effects of perceived control and autonomy in the academic domain.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,65,781-791.
    Preacher,K.J.,Curran,P.J.,&Bauer,D.J.(2006).Computational tools for probing interactions in multiple linear regression,multilevel modeling,and latent curve analysis.Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics,31,437-448.
    Randolph,K.A.,Fraser,M.W.,&Orthner,D.K.(2006).Astrategy for assessing the impact of time-varying family risk factors on high school dropout.Journal of Family Issues,27,933-950.
    Reger,Z.(1990).Mothers’speech in different social groups in Hungary.In G.Conti-Ramsden&C.E.Snow(Eds.),Children’s language(Volume 7).Hillsdale,NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,Inc.
    Scarbrough,H.S.,&Dobrich,W.(1994).On the efficacy of reading to preschoolers.Developmental Review,14,245-302.
    Schraw,G.,&Dennison,R.S.(1994).The effect of reader purpose on interest and recall.Journal of Literacy Research,26(1),1-18.
    Terenzini,P.T.,Cabrera,A.F.,&Bernal,E.M.(2001).Swimming against the tide:The poor in American higher education.Paper presented at the meeting the College Board Research Report.New York:The College Board.
    Wigfield,A.,Guthrie,J.T.,Perencevich,K.C.,Taboada,A.,Klauda,S.L.,Mc Rae,A.,&Barbosa,P.(2008).Role of reading engagement in mediating effects of reading comprehension instruction on reading outcomes.Psychology in the Schools,45,432-445.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700