水痘减毒活疫苗在小学生及学龄前儿童中保护效力相关文献的Meta分析
|
摘要
目的评价水痘减毒活疫苗(varicella vaccine,VarV)在小学生及学龄前儿童中的保护效力(vaccine effectiveness,VE)。方法检索中国知网、万方和维普中文期刊、PubMed和Embase等文献数据库,收集中国2017年以前所有国内病例对照研究和回顾性队列研究中VarV的VE文献,并应用RevMan 5. 1软件进行Meta分析。结果共纳入34篇文献,其中病例对照研究19篇,回顾性队列研究15篇。34篇文献VarV合并VE为69%(95%CI:64%～73%);接种2剂次VarV的VE(92%,95%CI:80%～97%)明显高于接种1剂次(60%,95%CI:42%～73%),差异有统计学意义(P <0. 000 01);学龄前儿童接种VarV的VE(78%,95%CI:60%～87%)明显高于小学(33%,95%CI:4%～54%),差异有统计学意义(P <0. 000 01);5岁以下儿童接种VarV的VE最高,为94%(95%CI:69%～99%),9岁及9岁以上儿童接种VarV的VE最低,为41%(95%CI:23%～54%)。结论 VarV具有一定的保护效力,随着接种年龄的增加而降低。建议全面推广VarV的2剂次免疫程序。
Objective To evaluate the vaccine effectiveness(VE) of live attenuated varicella vaccine(VarV) in pupils and preschoolers. Methods The literatures of case-control or cohort studies on VE of VarV in China before 2017 were collected from data bases such as CNKI,Wanfang,PubMed and Embase for Meta-analysis by using RevMan 5. 1 software.Results A total of 34 literatures were collected,of which 19 were those of case-control studies and 15 of retrospective cohort studies. The overall VE of VarV was 69%(95% CI: 64% ～ 73%),while that of two doses of VarV(92%,95%CI: 80% ～ 97%)was significantly higher than that of one dose(60%,95% CI: 42% ～ 73%)(P < 0. 000 01). The VE of VarV in preschoolers(78%,95% CI: 60% ～ 87%)was significantly higher than that in pupils(33%,95% CI: 4% ～54%)(P < 0. 000 01). The VE was the highest in children at ages of less than 5 years(94%,95% CI: 69% ～ 99%)while was the lowest in those at not less than 9 years(41%,95% CI: 23% ～ 54%). Conclusion VarV showed a certain VE which decreased with the increasing age for vaccination. The authors propose to popularize the two-dose immunization schedule of VarV.
Objective To evaluate the vaccine effectiveness(VE) of live attenuated varicella vaccine(VarV) in pupils and preschoolers. Methods The literatures of case-control or cohort studies on VE of VarV in China before 2017 were collected from data bases such as CNKI,Wanfang,PubMed and Embase for Meta-analysis by using RevMan 5. 1 software.Results A total of 34 literatures were collected,of which 19 were those of case-control studies and 15 of retrospective cohort studies. The overall VE of VarV was 69%(95% CI: 64% ～ 73%),while that of two doses of VarV(92%,95%CI: 80% ～ 97%)was significantly higher than that of one dose(60%,95% CI: 42% ～ 73%)(P < 0. 000 01). The VE of VarV in preschoolers(78%,95% CI: 60% ～ 87%)was significantly higher than that in pupils(33%,95% CI: 4% ～54%)(P < 0. 000 01). The VE was the highest in children at ages of less than 5 years(94%,95% CI: 69% ～ 99%)while was the lowest in those at not less than 9 years(41%,95% CI: 23% ～ 54%). Conclusion VarV showed a certain VE which decreased with the increasing age for vaccination. The authors propose to popularize the two-dose immunization schedule of VarV.
引文
[1]MAIB,CHEN S H,HUANG J M,et al.A retrospective cohort study on the effectiveness of varicella vaccine against vari cella outbreak in school[J].Prog in Microbiol Immunol,2013,41(1):20-22.(in Chinese)麦冰,陈抒豪,黄劲梅,等.水痘疫苗在学校暴发疫情中保护效果的回顾性队列研究[J].微生物学免疫学进展,2013,41(1):20-22.
[2]TOYAMA N,SHIRAKI K.Universal varicella vaccination increased the incidence of herpes zoster in the child-rearing generation as its short-term effect[J].J Dermatol Sci,2018,92(1):89-96.
[3]KIM J,KIM J E,BAE J M.Incidence of varicella in children in Jeju-do,Korea,2005-2016:age-period-cohort analysis[J].Epidemiol Health,2018,40:e2018054.
[4]LOPEZ A S,ZHANG J,MARIN M.Epidemiology of varicella during the 2-dose varicella vaccination program United States,2005-2014[J].MMWR,2016,65(34):902-905.
[5]HIROSE M,GILIO A E,FERRONATO A E,et al.The impact of varicella vaccination on varicella-related hospitalization rates:global data review[J].Rev Paul Pediatr,2016,34(3):359-366.
[6]HU H,CHAO W Q,SHEN T H,et al.Meta-analysis of the effectiveness of varicella vaccine in outbreaks[J].Chin J Vacc Immun,2017,23(3):331-336.(in Chinese)胡宏,曹文群,沈天寒,等.水痘疫苗在聚集性疫情中保护效果的Meta分析[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2017(3):331-336.
[7]LEE Y H,CHOE Y J,CHO S L,et al.Effects of one-dose varicella vaccination on disease severity in children during outbreaks in Seoul,Korea[J].J Korean Med Sci,2019,34(10):e83.
[8]MARIN M,MARTI M,KAMBHAMPATI A,et al.Global varicella vaccine effectiveness:a meta-analysis[J].Pediatrics,2016,137(3):e20153741.
[9]HAN K,ZHENG H,HUANG Z,et al.Vaccination coverage and its determinants among migrant children in Guangdong,China[J].BMC Public Health,2014,14:203.
[10]LEUNG J,BRODER K R,MARIN M,et al.Severe varicella in persons vaccinated with varicella vaccine(breakthrough varicella):a systematic literature review[J].Expert Rev Vacc,2017,16(4):391-400.
[11]HAGEMANN C,STRENG A,KRAEMER A,et al.Heterogeneity in coverage for measles and varicella vaccination in toddlers-analysis of factors influencing parental acceptance[J].BMC Public Health,2017,17(1):724.
[12]HARPAZ R,HOEK A J.Point-counterpoint:The hope-simpson hypothesis and its implications regarding an effect of routine varicella vaccination on herpes zoster incidence[J].J Infect Dis,2018,218(Suppl 2):S57-S62.
[13]ZHONG W J.Study on the charateristics and risk factors of varicella among children in kindergartens and primary schools,Qingpu District[D].Shanghai:Fudan University,2014.(in Chinese)仲文江.青浦区托幼机构儿童与小学生水痘发病特征及危险因素研究[D].上海:复旦大学,2014.
[14]ZHANG L P,DU Y,JING B F,et al.Analysis on immunization of live attenuated varicella vaccine in A school student in Minhang,Shanghai[J].Chinese Primary Health Care,2012,26(5):81-83.(in Chinese)张莉萍,杜艳,金宝芳,等.上海市闵行区某学校学生水痘疫苗免疫效果分析[J].中国初级卫生保健,2012,26(5):81-83.
[15]YU W B,AN X D,LI Y C,et al.Investigation on the protective effect of two varicella outbreaks[J].Chin Trop Med,2010,10(6):684,686.(in Chinese)于文博,安向东,李艳春,等.两起水痘暴发疫情的疫苗保护效果调查[J].中国热带医学,2010,10(6):684,686.
[16]WU L P,LIU G,ZHANG H,et al.Effect of time after vaccination and varicella attack rate on effectiveness of a single dose of varicella vaccine[J].Chin J Biologicals,2013,26(9):1304-1308.(in Chinese)吴莉萍,刘刚,张宏,等.免疫后时间及流行强度对1剂次水痘疫苗效力的影响[J].中国生物制品学杂志,2013,26(9):1304-1308.
[17]WANG Z.A case-control study on varicella vaccine effectiveness[D].Beijing:Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention,2011.(in Chinese)王哲.水痘疫苗保护效果的病例对照研究[D].北京:中国疾病预防控制中心,2011.
[18]SUN Y,WANG D M,CUI W H,et al.An outbreak of varicella among students in an urban primary school in Yantai city of Shandong province,2016[J].Chin J Vacc Immun,2017,23(4):425-428,435.(in Chinese)孙源,王冬梅,崔伟红,等.山东省烟台市2016年一起城区小学水痘暴发的流行病学调查分析[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2017,23(4):425-428,435.
[19]RUAN J R,ZHONG C Y,HUANG J F.A case-control study on protective effect of varicella vaccine during outbreaks in schools and kindergartens[J].J Lanzhou Univ(Med Sci),2015,41(6):25-28.(in Chinese)阮菁如,钟春燕,黄佳峰.水痘聚集性疫情中水痘疫苗保护效果的病例对照研究[J].兰州大学学报(医学版),2015,41(6):25-28.
[20]PENG Z,YING Y,JIANG L L,et al.A case-control study of the efficacy of 1-dose of varicella vaccine in Putuo district of Shanghai[J].Chin J Vacc Immun,2017,23(1):34-37.(in Chinese)彭臻,应颖,蒋丽丽,等.上海市普陀区1剂次水痘疫苗保护效果病例对照研究[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2017,23(1):34-37.
[21]PAN X Q,MA R,XU G Z,et al.A case control study on the efficacy of varicella vaccine[J].Zhejiang Prevent Med,2013,25(5):37-38.(in Chinese)潘兴强,马瑞,许国章.水痘疫苗免疫效果的病例对照研究[J].浙江预防医学,2013,25(5):37-38.
[22]MAO L F,HE C Q.Effectiveness of varicella vaccine:a casecontrol study[J].Chin J School Health,2014,35(5):720-722.(in Chinese)毛龙飞,何茶清.水痘减毒活疫苗保护效果的配对病例对照研究[J].中国学校卫生,2014(5):720-722.
[23]LUO L C,LI G,LI Y.Epidemic factors of varicella outbreak in a school and investigation of its protective efficacy[J].Chin J Biologicals,2013,26(8):1158-1160.(in Chinese)罗念慈,李刚,李苑.一起学校水痘暴发的流行因素及其疫苗保护效率调查[J].中国生物制品学杂志,2013(8):1158-1160.
[24]LIU H.A case-control study on chickenpox outbreak in school[J].J Prevent Med Inform,2017,33(2):144-147.(in Chinese)刘惠.一起学校水痘暴发疫情的病例对照调查[J].预防医学情报杂志,2017,33(2):144-147.
[25]LIANG J,FANG Q,ZHONG J M,et al.Effectiveness of varicella vaccination:a case-control study on varicella outbreaks in school[J].J Trop Med,2016,16(11):1441-1444.(in Chinese)梁静,方琼,钟剑明,等.儿童水痘暴发疫情的水痘疫苗保护效果病例对照研究[J].热带医学杂志,2016,16(11):1441-1444.
[26]LIANG F Q,HE B X,YANG G,et al.Analysis onecase-control study of varicella outbreak[J].J Trop Med,2006,6(5):575-576.(in Chinese)梁飞琼,何炳欣,杨国,等.水痘爆发病例的接种效率分析[J].热带医学杂志,2006(5):575-576.
[27]LI K,DIAO X B.A case control study on the efficacy of varicella vaccine in Changtu County of Liaoning Province[J].Contemporary Med,2016,22(6):163-164.(in Chinese)李凯,刁勋波.辽宁省昌图县水痘疫苗免疫效果的病例对照研究[J].当代医学,2016,22(6):163-164.
[28]JU Z R,LI Y M,DENG L Q.A investigation of chicken pox outbreak among students in a school,Hunchun[J].Med J Chin People’s Health,2016,28(19):64-66.(in Chinese)鞠志人,李亚明,邓立权.珲春市某校学生水痘暴发疫情调查[J].中国民康医学,2016,28(19):64-66.
[29]HE W Y,LIANG J H,WU L P,et al.A case-control study on the effectiveness of varicella vaccination on varicella outbreaks in schools and children's institutions[J].J Trop Med,2012,12(5):617-619.(in Chinese)何蔚云,梁建华,吴丽萍,等.儿童集体单位水痘暴发与水痘疫苗接种效果的病例对照研究[J].热带医学杂志,2012(5):617-619.
[30]FU C X,LIANG J H,WANG D H,et al.Effectiveness of varicella vaccine:a 1:1 matched case-control study[J].Chin Maternal Child Health,2008,23(10):1353-1355.(in Chinese)傅传喜,梁建华,王大虎,等.社区水痘疫苗保护效果1∶1配对病例对照研究[J].中国妇幼保健,2008,23(10):1353-1355.
[31]FU C X,LIANG J H,WANG D H,et al.A matched case-control study on varicella vaccine protection[J].Modern Prevent Med,2007,34(20):3813-3814.(in Chinese)傅传喜,梁建华,王大虎,等.水痘疫苗对学校水痘集中发病保护效果的配对病例对照研究[J].现代预防医学,2007,34(20):3813-3814.
[32]ZHU Q,WANG X X,SU W C,et al.Effectiveness of varicella vaccine based on several varicella outbreaks in Guangdong Province[J].South Chin J Prevent Med,2016,42(2):129-133.(in Chinese)朱琦,王小溪,苏伟成,等.基于广东省多个水痘疫情暴发现场的水痘疫苗保护效果研究[J].华南预防医学,2016,42(2):129-133.
[33]ZHOU Q,LUO X H,YUAN J,et al.Analysis of an out break of chickenpox in primary schools[J].Chin J School Health,2013,34(5):617-618.(in Chinese)周荃,罗小华,袁俊,等.一起小学水痘暴发疫情分析[J].中国学校卫生,2013,34(5):617-618.
[34]XU M G,HUANG J,WU Y S,et al.An epidemiological study on the outbreak of chickenpox in elementary school in Shanghai in 2007[J].Chin J Vacc Immun,2008,14(6):516-520.(in Chinese)徐敏钢,黄瑾,吴益生,等.2007年上海市某小学水痘爆发的流行病学调查[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2008,14(6):516-520.
[35]WU H Y,ZHANG A X,REN H,et al.An epidemiological investigation on varicella vaccination among children in some areas of shanghai[J].Shanghai J Prevent Med,2006,18(9):437-439.(in Chinese)吴寰宇,张爱香,任宏,等.上海市部分地区儿童水痘疫苗免疫后流行病学效果观察[J].上海预防医学杂志,2006,18(9):437-439.
[36]WANG C L,LU H Y,ZHOU H,et al.A retrospective cohort study on the efficacy of varicella vaccine against varicella out break in school and kindergarten[J].Chin J Dis Control&Prevent,2016,20(7):741-743.(in Chinese)王翠玲,吕海英,周海,等.水痘疫苗在学校和幼儿园水痘暴发疫情中保护效力的回顾性队列研究[J].中华疾病控制杂志,2016,20(7):741-743.
[37]SUN L Y,YUAN Y R,FANG J,et al.Analysis on the protective effects of varicella vaccination in varicella emergency in a district of Ningboin,Zhejiang province from 2010-2012[J].Inter J Epidemiol Infect Dis,2013,40(6):411-413.(in Chinese)孙灵英,袁月荣,方建,等.浙江省宁波市某区2010-2012年水痘突发疫情中疫苗保护效果分析[J].国际流行病学传染病学杂志,2013,40(6):411-413.
[38]SUI H T,YAO J Y,LIN Q H,et al.Field investigation of a varicella outbreak in a primary school of Zhangpu County,Fujian Province,2015[J].Chin J Vacc Immun,2016,22(6):642-645,615.(in Chinese)随海田,姚建有,林权恵,等.福建省漳浦县2015年一起小学水痘暴发的现场调查[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2016,22(6):642-645,615.
[39]PANG H,WANG C,JIANG Y,et al.Comparison of varicella vaccine effectiveness during outbreak in a primary school[J].Chin J Biologicals,2015,28(1):68-71.(in Chinese)庞红,王晨,江燕,等.学校水痘暴发中水痘疫苗保护率的比较[J].中国生物制品学杂志,2015,28(1):68-71.
[40]KUANG C P,LIN X L,ZHUANG H Y,et al.Epidemic factors and protective efficacy of vaccine in an outbreak of varicella in a school[J].Prac Prevent Med,2017,24(6):699-701.(in Chinese)旷翠萍,林喜乐,庄辉元,等.一起学校水痘暴发疫情的流行因素及疫苗保护效果调查[J].实用预防医学,2017,24(6):699-701.
[41]HUANG M,LIAO Q X,WU X L,et al.A investigation of the cluster outbreak of chicken pox in a primary school,Luohu District[J].Prac Prevent Med,2014,21(3):328-329.(in Chinese)黄敏,廖庆祥,吴晓亮,等.罗湖一起小学水痘聚集性疫情的流行病学调查[J].实用预防医学,2014,21(3):328-329.
[42]HUANG M,LIAO Q X,HE L,et al.Epidemic investigation of chickenpox clustering epidemic situation in a primary school in Shenzhen[J].Heilongjiang Med J,2013,37(10):1015-1017.(in Chinese)黄敏,廖庆祥,何林,等.深圳某小学水痘聚集性疫情的流行病学调查[J].黑龙江医学,2013,37(10):1015-1017.
[43]HAN Z M.A study on the epidemic characteristics and immunity level of varicella in Yuecheng District[D].Hangzhou:Zhejiang University,2012.(in Chinese)韩宗梅.越城区水痘疫情特征分析及免疫水平调查[D].浙江杭州:浙江大学,2012.
[44]GAN L Q,XU Y C,ZHONG J M,et al.Epidemiological investigation of a varicella outbreak in school[J].Chin J School Doctor,2017,31(2):112-114.(in Chinese)甘立勤,许玉成,钟剑明,等.1起水痘爆发疫情的现场流行病学调查[J].中国校医,2017,31(2):112-114.
[45]DEN H Y,ZHENG L,LIU D J,et al.Epidemiological a nalysis of varicella outbreak in Baoan District[J].Contemporary Med,2009,16(23):146-147.(in Chinese)邓惠云,郑磊,刘德坚,等.宝安区一起水痘突发公共卫生事件的流行病学调查分析[J].中国当代医药,2009,16(23):146-147.
[46]THOMAS C A,SHWE T,BIXLER D,et al.Two-dose varicella vaccine effectiveness and rash severity in outbreaks of varicella among public school students[J].Pediatr Infect Dis J,2014,33(11):1164-1168.
[47]OH S H,CHOI E,SHIN H,et al.Varicella and varicella vaccination in South Korea[J].Clin Vaccine Immunol,2014,21(5):762-768.
[48]LIESE J G,COHEN C,RACK A,et al.The effectiveness of varicella vaccination in children in Germany:a case-control study[J].Pediatr Infect Dis J,2013,32(9):998-1004.
[49]LI L,SUO L D,LI J,et al.A varicella outbreak in a school with high one-dose vaccination coverage,Beijing,China[J].Vaccine,2012.30(34):5094-5098.
[50]SUO L,LI J,ZHAO D,et al.Effect evaluation of a 2 dose varicella vaccine immunization strategy implemented to control outbreaks in school and kindergarten settings[J].Chin J Prevent Med,2015,49(6):485-489.
[51]LEUNG J,BRODER K R,MARIN M,et al.Impact of the UStwo-dose varicella vaccination program on the epidemiology of varicella outbreaks:data from nine states,2005-2012[J].Pediatr Infect Dis J,2015,34(10):1105-1109.
[2]TOYAMA N,SHIRAKI K.Universal varicella vaccination increased the incidence of herpes zoster in the child-rearing generation as its short-term effect[J].J Dermatol Sci,2018,92(1):89-96.
[3]KIM J,KIM J E,BAE J M.Incidence of varicella in children in Jeju-do,Korea,2005-2016:age-period-cohort analysis[J].Epidemiol Health,2018,40:e2018054.
[4]LOPEZ A S,ZHANG J,MARIN M.Epidemiology of varicella during the 2-dose varicella vaccination program United States,2005-2014[J].MMWR,2016,65(34):902-905.
[5]HIROSE M,GILIO A E,FERRONATO A E,et al.The impact of varicella vaccination on varicella-related hospitalization rates:global data review[J].Rev Paul Pediatr,2016,34(3):359-366.
[6]HU H,CHAO W Q,SHEN T H,et al.Meta-analysis of the effectiveness of varicella vaccine in outbreaks[J].Chin J Vacc Immun,2017,23(3):331-336.(in Chinese)胡宏,曹文群,沈天寒,等.水痘疫苗在聚集性疫情中保护效果的Meta分析[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2017(3):331-336.
[7]LEE Y H,CHOE Y J,CHO S L,et al.Effects of one-dose varicella vaccination on disease severity in children during outbreaks in Seoul,Korea[J].J Korean Med Sci,2019,34(10):e83.
[8]MARIN M,MARTI M,KAMBHAMPATI A,et al.Global varicella vaccine effectiveness:a meta-analysis[J].Pediatrics,2016,137(3):e20153741.
[9]HAN K,ZHENG H,HUANG Z,et al.Vaccination coverage and its determinants among migrant children in Guangdong,China[J].BMC Public Health,2014,14:203.
[10]LEUNG J,BRODER K R,MARIN M,et al.Severe varicella in persons vaccinated with varicella vaccine(breakthrough varicella):a systematic literature review[J].Expert Rev Vacc,2017,16(4):391-400.
[11]HAGEMANN C,STRENG A,KRAEMER A,et al.Heterogeneity in coverage for measles and varicella vaccination in toddlers-analysis of factors influencing parental acceptance[J].BMC Public Health,2017,17(1):724.
[12]HARPAZ R,HOEK A J.Point-counterpoint:The hope-simpson hypothesis and its implications regarding an effect of routine varicella vaccination on herpes zoster incidence[J].J Infect Dis,2018,218(Suppl 2):S57-S62.
[13]ZHONG W J.Study on the charateristics and risk factors of varicella among children in kindergartens and primary schools,Qingpu District[D].Shanghai:Fudan University,2014.(in Chinese)仲文江.青浦区托幼机构儿童与小学生水痘发病特征及危险因素研究[D].上海:复旦大学,2014.
[14]ZHANG L P,DU Y,JING B F,et al.Analysis on immunization of live attenuated varicella vaccine in A school student in Minhang,Shanghai[J].Chinese Primary Health Care,2012,26(5):81-83.(in Chinese)张莉萍,杜艳,金宝芳,等.上海市闵行区某学校学生水痘疫苗免疫效果分析[J].中国初级卫生保健,2012,26(5):81-83.
[15]YU W B,AN X D,LI Y C,et al.Investigation on the protective effect of two varicella outbreaks[J].Chin Trop Med,2010,10(6):684,686.(in Chinese)于文博,安向东,李艳春,等.两起水痘暴发疫情的疫苗保护效果调查[J].中国热带医学,2010,10(6):684,686.
[16]WU L P,LIU G,ZHANG H,et al.Effect of time after vaccination and varicella attack rate on effectiveness of a single dose of varicella vaccine[J].Chin J Biologicals,2013,26(9):1304-1308.(in Chinese)吴莉萍,刘刚,张宏,等.免疫后时间及流行强度对1剂次水痘疫苗效力的影响[J].中国生物制品学杂志,2013,26(9):1304-1308.
[17]WANG Z.A case-control study on varicella vaccine effectiveness[D].Beijing:Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention,2011.(in Chinese)王哲.水痘疫苗保护效果的病例对照研究[D].北京:中国疾病预防控制中心,2011.
[18]SUN Y,WANG D M,CUI W H,et al.An outbreak of varicella among students in an urban primary school in Yantai city of Shandong province,2016[J].Chin J Vacc Immun,2017,23(4):425-428,435.(in Chinese)孙源,王冬梅,崔伟红,等.山东省烟台市2016年一起城区小学水痘暴发的流行病学调查分析[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2017,23(4):425-428,435.
[19]RUAN J R,ZHONG C Y,HUANG J F.A case-control study on protective effect of varicella vaccine during outbreaks in schools and kindergartens[J].J Lanzhou Univ(Med Sci),2015,41(6):25-28.(in Chinese)阮菁如,钟春燕,黄佳峰.水痘聚集性疫情中水痘疫苗保护效果的病例对照研究[J].兰州大学学报(医学版),2015,41(6):25-28.
[20]PENG Z,YING Y,JIANG L L,et al.A case-control study of the efficacy of 1-dose of varicella vaccine in Putuo district of Shanghai[J].Chin J Vacc Immun,2017,23(1):34-37.(in Chinese)彭臻,应颖,蒋丽丽,等.上海市普陀区1剂次水痘疫苗保护效果病例对照研究[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2017,23(1):34-37.
[21]PAN X Q,MA R,XU G Z,et al.A case control study on the efficacy of varicella vaccine[J].Zhejiang Prevent Med,2013,25(5):37-38.(in Chinese)潘兴强,马瑞,许国章.水痘疫苗免疫效果的病例对照研究[J].浙江预防医学,2013,25(5):37-38.
[22]MAO L F,HE C Q.Effectiveness of varicella vaccine:a casecontrol study[J].Chin J School Health,2014,35(5):720-722.(in Chinese)毛龙飞,何茶清.水痘减毒活疫苗保护效果的配对病例对照研究[J].中国学校卫生,2014(5):720-722.
[23]LUO L C,LI G,LI Y.Epidemic factors of varicella outbreak in a school and investigation of its protective efficacy[J].Chin J Biologicals,2013,26(8):1158-1160.(in Chinese)罗念慈,李刚,李苑.一起学校水痘暴发的流行因素及其疫苗保护效率调查[J].中国生物制品学杂志,2013(8):1158-1160.
[24]LIU H.A case-control study on chickenpox outbreak in school[J].J Prevent Med Inform,2017,33(2):144-147.(in Chinese)刘惠.一起学校水痘暴发疫情的病例对照调查[J].预防医学情报杂志,2017,33(2):144-147.
[25]LIANG J,FANG Q,ZHONG J M,et al.Effectiveness of varicella vaccination:a case-control study on varicella outbreaks in school[J].J Trop Med,2016,16(11):1441-1444.(in Chinese)梁静,方琼,钟剑明,等.儿童水痘暴发疫情的水痘疫苗保护效果病例对照研究[J].热带医学杂志,2016,16(11):1441-1444.
[26]LIANG F Q,HE B X,YANG G,et al.Analysis onecase-control study of varicella outbreak[J].J Trop Med,2006,6(5):575-576.(in Chinese)梁飞琼,何炳欣,杨国,等.水痘爆发病例的接种效率分析[J].热带医学杂志,2006(5):575-576.
[27]LI K,DIAO X B.A case control study on the efficacy of varicella vaccine in Changtu County of Liaoning Province[J].Contemporary Med,2016,22(6):163-164.(in Chinese)李凯,刁勋波.辽宁省昌图县水痘疫苗免疫效果的病例对照研究[J].当代医学,2016,22(6):163-164.
[28]JU Z R,LI Y M,DENG L Q.A investigation of chicken pox outbreak among students in a school,Hunchun[J].Med J Chin People’s Health,2016,28(19):64-66.(in Chinese)鞠志人,李亚明,邓立权.珲春市某校学生水痘暴发疫情调查[J].中国民康医学,2016,28(19):64-66.
[29]HE W Y,LIANG J H,WU L P,et al.A case-control study on the effectiveness of varicella vaccination on varicella outbreaks in schools and children's institutions[J].J Trop Med,2012,12(5):617-619.(in Chinese)何蔚云,梁建华,吴丽萍,等.儿童集体单位水痘暴发与水痘疫苗接种效果的病例对照研究[J].热带医学杂志,2012(5):617-619.
[30]FU C X,LIANG J H,WANG D H,et al.Effectiveness of varicella vaccine:a 1:1 matched case-control study[J].Chin Maternal Child Health,2008,23(10):1353-1355.(in Chinese)傅传喜,梁建华,王大虎,等.社区水痘疫苗保护效果1∶1配对病例对照研究[J].中国妇幼保健,2008,23(10):1353-1355.
[31]FU C X,LIANG J H,WANG D H,et al.A matched case-control study on varicella vaccine protection[J].Modern Prevent Med,2007,34(20):3813-3814.(in Chinese)傅传喜,梁建华,王大虎,等.水痘疫苗对学校水痘集中发病保护效果的配对病例对照研究[J].现代预防医学,2007,34(20):3813-3814.
[32]ZHU Q,WANG X X,SU W C,et al.Effectiveness of varicella vaccine based on several varicella outbreaks in Guangdong Province[J].South Chin J Prevent Med,2016,42(2):129-133.(in Chinese)朱琦,王小溪,苏伟成,等.基于广东省多个水痘疫情暴发现场的水痘疫苗保护效果研究[J].华南预防医学,2016,42(2):129-133.
[33]ZHOU Q,LUO X H,YUAN J,et al.Analysis of an out break of chickenpox in primary schools[J].Chin J School Health,2013,34(5):617-618.(in Chinese)周荃,罗小华,袁俊,等.一起小学水痘暴发疫情分析[J].中国学校卫生,2013,34(5):617-618.
[34]XU M G,HUANG J,WU Y S,et al.An epidemiological study on the outbreak of chickenpox in elementary school in Shanghai in 2007[J].Chin J Vacc Immun,2008,14(6):516-520.(in Chinese)徐敏钢,黄瑾,吴益生,等.2007年上海市某小学水痘爆发的流行病学调查[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2008,14(6):516-520.
[35]WU H Y,ZHANG A X,REN H,et al.An epidemiological investigation on varicella vaccination among children in some areas of shanghai[J].Shanghai J Prevent Med,2006,18(9):437-439.(in Chinese)吴寰宇,张爱香,任宏,等.上海市部分地区儿童水痘疫苗免疫后流行病学效果观察[J].上海预防医学杂志,2006,18(9):437-439.
[36]WANG C L,LU H Y,ZHOU H,et al.A retrospective cohort study on the efficacy of varicella vaccine against varicella out break in school and kindergarten[J].Chin J Dis Control&Prevent,2016,20(7):741-743.(in Chinese)王翠玲,吕海英,周海,等.水痘疫苗在学校和幼儿园水痘暴发疫情中保护效力的回顾性队列研究[J].中华疾病控制杂志,2016,20(7):741-743.
[37]SUN L Y,YUAN Y R,FANG J,et al.Analysis on the protective effects of varicella vaccination in varicella emergency in a district of Ningboin,Zhejiang province from 2010-2012[J].Inter J Epidemiol Infect Dis,2013,40(6):411-413.(in Chinese)孙灵英,袁月荣,方建,等.浙江省宁波市某区2010-2012年水痘突发疫情中疫苗保护效果分析[J].国际流行病学传染病学杂志,2013,40(6):411-413.
[38]SUI H T,YAO J Y,LIN Q H,et al.Field investigation of a varicella outbreak in a primary school of Zhangpu County,Fujian Province,2015[J].Chin J Vacc Immun,2016,22(6):642-645,615.(in Chinese)随海田,姚建有,林权恵,等.福建省漳浦县2015年一起小学水痘暴发的现场调查[J].中国疫苗和免疫,2016,22(6):642-645,615.
[39]PANG H,WANG C,JIANG Y,et al.Comparison of varicella vaccine effectiveness during outbreak in a primary school[J].Chin J Biologicals,2015,28(1):68-71.(in Chinese)庞红,王晨,江燕,等.学校水痘暴发中水痘疫苗保护率的比较[J].中国生物制品学杂志,2015,28(1):68-71.
[40]KUANG C P,LIN X L,ZHUANG H Y,et al.Epidemic factors and protective efficacy of vaccine in an outbreak of varicella in a school[J].Prac Prevent Med,2017,24(6):699-701.(in Chinese)旷翠萍,林喜乐,庄辉元,等.一起学校水痘暴发疫情的流行因素及疫苗保护效果调查[J].实用预防医学,2017,24(6):699-701.
[41]HUANG M,LIAO Q X,WU X L,et al.A investigation of the cluster outbreak of chicken pox in a primary school,Luohu District[J].Prac Prevent Med,2014,21(3):328-329.(in Chinese)黄敏,廖庆祥,吴晓亮,等.罗湖一起小学水痘聚集性疫情的流行病学调查[J].实用预防医学,2014,21(3):328-329.
[42]HUANG M,LIAO Q X,HE L,et al.Epidemic investigation of chickenpox clustering epidemic situation in a primary school in Shenzhen[J].Heilongjiang Med J,2013,37(10):1015-1017.(in Chinese)黄敏,廖庆祥,何林,等.深圳某小学水痘聚集性疫情的流行病学调查[J].黑龙江医学,2013,37(10):1015-1017.
[43]HAN Z M.A study on the epidemic characteristics and immunity level of varicella in Yuecheng District[D].Hangzhou:Zhejiang University,2012.(in Chinese)韩宗梅.越城区水痘疫情特征分析及免疫水平调查[D].浙江杭州:浙江大学,2012.
[44]GAN L Q,XU Y C,ZHONG J M,et al.Epidemiological investigation of a varicella outbreak in school[J].Chin J School Doctor,2017,31(2):112-114.(in Chinese)甘立勤,许玉成,钟剑明,等.1起水痘爆发疫情的现场流行病学调查[J].中国校医,2017,31(2):112-114.
[45]DEN H Y,ZHENG L,LIU D J,et al.Epidemiological a nalysis of varicella outbreak in Baoan District[J].Contemporary Med,2009,16(23):146-147.(in Chinese)邓惠云,郑磊,刘德坚,等.宝安区一起水痘突发公共卫生事件的流行病学调查分析[J].中国当代医药,2009,16(23):146-147.
[46]THOMAS C A,SHWE T,BIXLER D,et al.Two-dose varicella vaccine effectiveness and rash severity in outbreaks of varicella among public school students[J].Pediatr Infect Dis J,2014,33(11):1164-1168.
[47]OH S H,CHOI E,SHIN H,et al.Varicella and varicella vaccination in South Korea[J].Clin Vaccine Immunol,2014,21(5):762-768.
[48]LIESE J G,COHEN C,RACK A,et al.The effectiveness of varicella vaccination in children in Germany:a case-control study[J].Pediatr Infect Dis J,2013,32(9):998-1004.
[49]LI L,SUO L D,LI J,et al.A varicella outbreak in a school with high one-dose vaccination coverage,Beijing,China[J].Vaccine,2012.30(34):5094-5098.
[50]SUO L,LI J,ZHAO D,et al.Effect evaluation of a 2 dose varicella vaccine immunization strategy implemented to control outbreaks in school and kindergarten settings[J].Chin J Prevent Med,2015,49(6):485-489.
[51]LEUNG J,BRODER K R,MARIN M,et al.Impact of the UStwo-dose varicella vaccination program on the epidemiology of varicella outbreaks:data from nine states,2005-2012[J].Pediatr Infect Dis J,2015,34(10):1105-1109.