基于科学知识图谱分析的国际园林景观史研究动态——以《园林与设计景观史(1998—2017)》杂志刊载论文为对象
|
摘要
以国际园林景观史学界的重要期刊《园林与设计景观史》(Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes)为研究对象,运用VOSviewer和CiteSpace这2种科学知识图谱软件并结合传统研究方法,系统分析该期刊1998—2017年间刊载的508篇论文,揭示近20年来国际园林与设计景观史的研究动态、发展趋势、主题演进与学术脉络,为国内风景园林历史理论的研究和发展提供重要借鉴。
Taking the important academic journal of the international landscape architecture history-Studies in the History of Gardens & Designed Landscapes-as the research object,and by using VOSviewer and CiteSpace these two Bibliometric softwares and meanwhile combining traditional research methods,this paper systematically analyzes the 508 papers published on the journal during 1998-2017,and reveals its research dynamics,development trends,theme evolution and academic context in the last two decades.This research will provide important enlightenments for the vigorous development of the landscape architecture history and theory in China.
Taking the important academic journal of the international landscape architecture history-Studies in the History of Gardens & Designed Landscapes-as the research object,and by using VOSviewer and CiteSpace these two Bibliometric softwares and meanwhile combining traditional research methods,this paper systematically analyzes the 508 papers published on the journal during 1998-2017,and reveals its research dynamics,development trends,theme evolution and academic context in the last two decades.This research will provide important enlightenments for the vigorous development of the landscape architecture history and theory in China.
引文
[1]孟兆祯.奠基人之奠基作:赞汪菊渊院士遗著《中国古代园林史》[J].中国园林,2007,23(6):3-4.
[2]金云峰,陶楠.环境史景观史园林史[J].中国园林,2014,30(8):85-88.
[3]Fortunato S,Bergstrom C T,B?rner K,et al.Science of science[J].Science,2018,359(6379):eaao0185.
[4]Chen C.Science Mapping:A Systematic Review of the Literature[J].Journal of Data and Information Science,2017,2(2):1-40.
[5]李志明,樊荣甜.国外开放空间研究演进与前沿热点的可视化分析[J].国际城市规划,2017,32(6):34-41.
[6]袁媛,柳叶,林静.国外社区规划近十五年研究进展:基于Citespace软件的可视化分析[J].上海城市规划,2015(4):26-33.
[7]王俊帝,刘志强,邵大伟,等.基于Cite Space的国外城市绿地研究进展的知识图谱分析[J].中国园林,2018,34(4):5-11.
[8]严若谷,周素红,闫小培.西方城市更新研究的知识图谱演化[J].人文地理,2011,26(6):83-88.
[9]朱轶佳,李慧,王伟.城市更新研究的演进特征与趋势[J].城市问题,2015(9):30-35.
[10]Tang M,Liao H,Wan Z,et al.Ten Years of Sustainability(2009 to 2018):A Bibliometric Overview[J].Sustainability,2018,10(5):1655.
[11]Yu D,Xu Z,Pedrycz W,et al.Information sciences 1968-2016:A retrospective analysis with text mining and bibliometric[J].Information Sciences,2017,418-419:619-634.
[12]李杰,郭晓宏,姜亢,等.安全科学知识图谱的初步研究:以《Safety Science》期刊数据为例[J].中国安全科学学报,2013,23(4):152-158.
[13]张彦南,李全,陈工,等.基于《E c o n o m i c Geography》的经济地理学知识图谱分析[J].人文地理,2017,32(3):138-145.
[14]奚雪松,俞孔坚,胡佳文,等.从Landscape and Urban Planning 20年来的论文看国际景观规划研究动态[J].北京大学学报:自然科学版,2008(4):651-660.
[15]金荷仙,常晓菲,吴沁甜.国内外9本代表性风景园林期刊2008-2012年载文统计分析与研究[J].中国园林,2014,30(7):57-66.
[16]金荷仙,汪辉,苗诗麒,等.1985-2014年《中国园林》载文统计分析与研究[J].中国园林,2015,31(10):37-50.
[17]汪辉,刘小凤.2004-2013年《中国园林》论文、作者及研究动态分析[J].中国园林,2015,31(4):119-124.
[18]B?rner K,Chen C,Boyack K W.Visualizing knowledge domains[J].Annual Review of Information Science&Technology,2003,37(1):179-255.
[19]Chen C.Searching for intellectual turning points:progressive knowledge domain visualization[J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,2004,101(suppl):5303-5310.
[20]Eck N J V,Waltman L,Dekker R,et al.Acomparison of two techniques for bibliometric mapping:Multidimensional scaling and VOS[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,2010,61(12):2405-2416.
[21]Clunas C.Superfluous things:material culture and social status in early modern China[M].Hawaii:University of Hawaii Press,1991.
[22]Clunas C.Fruitful Sites:Garden Culture in Ming Dynasty China[M].Durham:Duke University Press,1996.
[23]van Eck N J,Waltman L.Text mining and visualization using VOSviewer[J].Eprint Arxiv,2011,7(3):50-54.
[24]Ingold T.The temporality of the landscape[J].World Archaeology,2010,25:152-174.
[25]Beattie J J,Holmes K.Reflections on the history of Australasian gardens and landscapes[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2011,31(2):75-82.
[26]Fahey C.The free selector's landscape:Moulding the Victorian farming districts,1870-1915[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2011,31(2):97-108.
[27]Fagiolo M.The garden of the Gamberaia in the Seicento:the mysteries of the waters,the elements and earthquakes[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2002,22(1):17-33.
[28]Bevilacqua M.Towards a history of the Villa Gamberaia:tssues of patronage[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2002,22(1):4-16.
[29]汤姆林逊,汪洋.二十世纪的园林设计:始于艺术[J].中国园林,1988,4(2):48-49;18.
[30]De Lorenzo C,Van Der Plaat D.'Our Australian Switzerland':Lindt,Humboldt and the Victorian landscape[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2004,24(2):133-149.
[31]Wellington R.Lines of sight:Isra?l Silvestre and the axial symbolism of Louis XIV's gardens at Versailles[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2017,37(2):120-133.
[32]Se?kin Y?.Gardens of the nineteenth-century imperial palaces in Istanbul[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2003,23(1):72-86.
[33]Bowe P.The evolution of the ancient Greek garden[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2010,30(3):208-223.
[34]Bowe P.The origin and development of the ancient Greek fountain[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2012,32(3):201-213.
[35]Han C.The aesthetics of wandering in the Chinese literati garden[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2012,32(4):297-301.
[36]Song N.Imagined territory:Paektusan in late Chos?n maps and writings[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2017,37(2):157-173.
[37]Atik M,Danaci H M,Erdo?an R.Perception of Plants in Ancient Times and Their Use as Motifs Revealing Aspects of the Cultural Landscape in Side,Turkey[J].Landscape Research,2010,35(3):281-297.
[38]Loeb R E,Garthwaite P M,Transue M R.None in common,many unique:species selection for gardens of the American South from 1734to 1825[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2015,35(2):144-171.
[39]Woudstra J.From bosquet a l'angloise to jardin a l'angloise The progression of the mingled manner of planting from its inception to its decline and survival[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2013,33(2):71-95.
[40]Robin N.The influence of scientific theories on the design of botanical gardens around 1800[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2008,28(3-4):382-399.
[41]Cole C A,Urban C A,Russo P,et al.Herbaceous plant community composition in created wetlands over seven years in northern New York,USA[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2013,33(3):235-247.
[42]Kullmann K.Red loops,green links:Park Rabet and urban decline in East Leipzig[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2014,34(4):259-274.
[43]Kullmann K.Concave worlds,artificial horizons:reframing the urban public garden[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2017,37(1):15-32.
[44]Davis T.The American motor parkway[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2005,25(4):219-249.
[45]Beattie J.Environmental History and Garden History in China and the West:Problems,Methods and Responses[J].Environment&History,2018,24(1):5-22.
[46]夏丽森.计成《园冶》在欧美的传播及影响[J].中国园林,2012,28(12):43-47.
[47]Fung S.Here and there in Yuan ye[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,1999,19(1):36-45.
[48]Jie L,Xin Z.Influences of Literati painting on garden-making:a comparative study of Yuan ye(The Craft of Gardens)and Fu sheng liu ji(Six Chapters of a Floating Life)[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2017,37(4):336-341.
[49]Xiao J,Xue C Q L.Architecture in Ji Cheng's The Craft of Gardens:a visual study of the role of representation in counteracting the influence of the pictorial idea in Chinese scholar gardens of the Ming period[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2015,35(3):218-234.
[50]林箐,王向荣.风景园林与文化[J].中国园林,2009,25(9):19-23.
[51]Tian Y,Fang H.Research on the historic appearance of the Lion Grove from the Yuan dynasty to the Republic of China[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2017,37(1):1-14.
[52]Lu A.Deciphering the reclusive landscape:a study of Wen Zheng-Ming's 1533 album of the Garden of the Unsuccessful Politician[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2011,31(1):40-59.
[53]Yinong X.Interplay of image and fact:the Pavilion of Surging Waves)Suzhou[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,1999,19(3-4):288-301.
[54]Watson P.Famous Gardens of Luoyang,by LIGefei[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2004,24(1):38-54.
[55]Liu X,Hardie A.The Garden of Perfect Brightness(Yuanmingyuan)at the height of its splendour:Translated from Wang Wei(2002)[The Yuanmingyuan Ruins][J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2005,25(1):1-22.
[56]Siu V M.China and Europe intertwined:a new view of the European sector of the Chang Chun Yuan[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,1999,19(3-4):376-393.
[57]Hu P K.The Shao Garden of Mi Wanzhong(1570-1628):revisiting a late Ming landscape through visual and literary sources1[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,1999,19(3-4):314-342.
[58]Hammond K J.Wang Shizhen's Yan Shan Garden essays:narrating a literati landscape[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,1999,19(3-4):276-287.
[59]Duempelmann S.Taking Turns:Landscape and Environmental History at the Crossroads[J].Landscape Research,2011,36(6):625-640.
(1)作者共被引网络,即研究对象为期刊所有论文的参考文献。通过分析共被引网络图谱中的关键节点,可以揭示出某个研究邻域的代表性作者和知识结构。
(2)引用突现是指引用量突然上升或下降,通常代表该领域研究方向的转变。在图上表现为节点发生突变的圈层被红色标注出来。
(3)平均引用影响关系是指期刊中的主题词被引用的频率大小,其图上的颜色从蓝色(最低引用影响)到红色(最高引用影响),能够揭示出一定时期研究的热点趋势。
(4)鉴于软件分析过程中的参数设置不同,VOSviewer的聚类分析结果可能会略有差异。
[2]金云峰,陶楠.环境史景观史园林史[J].中国园林,2014,30(8):85-88.
[3]Fortunato S,Bergstrom C T,B?rner K,et al.Science of science[J].Science,2018,359(6379):eaao0185.
[4]Chen C.Science Mapping:A Systematic Review of the Literature[J].Journal of Data and Information Science,2017,2(2):1-40.
[5]李志明,樊荣甜.国外开放空间研究演进与前沿热点的可视化分析[J].国际城市规划,2017,32(6):34-41.
[6]袁媛,柳叶,林静.国外社区规划近十五年研究进展:基于Citespace软件的可视化分析[J].上海城市规划,2015(4):26-33.
[7]王俊帝,刘志强,邵大伟,等.基于Cite Space的国外城市绿地研究进展的知识图谱分析[J].中国园林,2018,34(4):5-11.
[8]严若谷,周素红,闫小培.西方城市更新研究的知识图谱演化[J].人文地理,2011,26(6):83-88.
[9]朱轶佳,李慧,王伟.城市更新研究的演进特征与趋势[J].城市问题,2015(9):30-35.
[10]Tang M,Liao H,Wan Z,et al.Ten Years of Sustainability(2009 to 2018):A Bibliometric Overview[J].Sustainability,2018,10(5):1655.
[11]Yu D,Xu Z,Pedrycz W,et al.Information sciences 1968-2016:A retrospective analysis with text mining and bibliometric[J].Information Sciences,2017,418-419:619-634.
[12]李杰,郭晓宏,姜亢,等.安全科学知识图谱的初步研究:以《Safety Science》期刊数据为例[J].中国安全科学学报,2013,23(4):152-158.
[13]张彦南,李全,陈工,等.基于《E c o n o m i c Geography》的经济地理学知识图谱分析[J].人文地理,2017,32(3):138-145.
[14]奚雪松,俞孔坚,胡佳文,等.从Landscape and Urban Planning 20年来的论文看国际景观规划研究动态[J].北京大学学报:自然科学版,2008(4):651-660.
[15]金荷仙,常晓菲,吴沁甜.国内外9本代表性风景园林期刊2008-2012年载文统计分析与研究[J].中国园林,2014,30(7):57-66.
[16]金荷仙,汪辉,苗诗麒,等.1985-2014年《中国园林》载文统计分析与研究[J].中国园林,2015,31(10):37-50.
[17]汪辉,刘小凤.2004-2013年《中国园林》论文、作者及研究动态分析[J].中国园林,2015,31(4):119-124.
[18]B?rner K,Chen C,Boyack K W.Visualizing knowledge domains[J].Annual Review of Information Science&Technology,2003,37(1):179-255.
[19]Chen C.Searching for intellectual turning points:progressive knowledge domain visualization[J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,2004,101(suppl):5303-5310.
[20]Eck N J V,Waltman L,Dekker R,et al.Acomparison of two techniques for bibliometric mapping:Multidimensional scaling and VOS[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science&Technology,2010,61(12):2405-2416.
[21]Clunas C.Superfluous things:material culture and social status in early modern China[M].Hawaii:University of Hawaii Press,1991.
[22]Clunas C.Fruitful Sites:Garden Culture in Ming Dynasty China[M].Durham:Duke University Press,1996.
[23]van Eck N J,Waltman L.Text mining and visualization using VOSviewer[J].Eprint Arxiv,2011,7(3):50-54.
[24]Ingold T.The temporality of the landscape[J].World Archaeology,2010,25:152-174.
[25]Beattie J J,Holmes K.Reflections on the history of Australasian gardens and landscapes[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2011,31(2):75-82.
[26]Fahey C.The free selector's landscape:Moulding the Victorian farming districts,1870-1915[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2011,31(2):97-108.
[27]Fagiolo M.The garden of the Gamberaia in the Seicento:the mysteries of the waters,the elements and earthquakes[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2002,22(1):17-33.
[28]Bevilacqua M.Towards a history of the Villa Gamberaia:tssues of patronage[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2002,22(1):4-16.
[29]汤姆林逊,汪洋.二十世纪的园林设计:始于艺术[J].中国园林,1988,4(2):48-49;18.
[30]De Lorenzo C,Van Der Plaat D.'Our Australian Switzerland':Lindt,Humboldt and the Victorian landscape[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2004,24(2):133-149.
[31]Wellington R.Lines of sight:Isra?l Silvestre and the axial symbolism of Louis XIV's gardens at Versailles[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2017,37(2):120-133.
[32]Se?kin Y?.Gardens of the nineteenth-century imperial palaces in Istanbul[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2003,23(1):72-86.
[33]Bowe P.The evolution of the ancient Greek garden[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2010,30(3):208-223.
[34]Bowe P.The origin and development of the ancient Greek fountain[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2012,32(3):201-213.
[35]Han C.The aesthetics of wandering in the Chinese literati garden[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2012,32(4):297-301.
[36]Song N.Imagined territory:Paektusan in late Chos?n maps and writings[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2017,37(2):157-173.
[37]Atik M,Danaci H M,Erdo?an R.Perception of Plants in Ancient Times and Their Use as Motifs Revealing Aspects of the Cultural Landscape in Side,Turkey[J].Landscape Research,2010,35(3):281-297.
[38]Loeb R E,Garthwaite P M,Transue M R.None in common,many unique:species selection for gardens of the American South from 1734to 1825[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2015,35(2):144-171.
[39]Woudstra J.From bosquet a l'angloise to jardin a l'angloise The progression of the mingled manner of planting from its inception to its decline and survival[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2013,33(2):71-95.
[40]Robin N.The influence of scientific theories on the design of botanical gardens around 1800[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2008,28(3-4):382-399.
[41]Cole C A,Urban C A,Russo P,et al.Herbaceous plant community composition in created wetlands over seven years in northern New York,USA[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2013,33(3):235-247.
[42]Kullmann K.Red loops,green links:Park Rabet and urban decline in East Leipzig[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2014,34(4):259-274.
[43]Kullmann K.Concave worlds,artificial horizons:reframing the urban public garden[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2017,37(1):15-32.
[44]Davis T.The American motor parkway[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2005,25(4):219-249.
[45]Beattie J.Environmental History and Garden History in China and the West:Problems,Methods and Responses[J].Environment&History,2018,24(1):5-22.
[46]夏丽森.计成《园冶》在欧美的传播及影响[J].中国园林,2012,28(12):43-47.
[47]Fung S.Here and there in Yuan ye[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,1999,19(1):36-45.
[48]Jie L,Xin Z.Influences of Literati painting on garden-making:a comparative study of Yuan ye(The Craft of Gardens)and Fu sheng liu ji(Six Chapters of a Floating Life)[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2017,37(4):336-341.
[49]Xiao J,Xue C Q L.Architecture in Ji Cheng's The Craft of Gardens:a visual study of the role of representation in counteracting the influence of the pictorial idea in Chinese scholar gardens of the Ming period[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2015,35(3):218-234.
[50]林箐,王向荣.风景园林与文化[J].中国园林,2009,25(9):19-23.
[51]Tian Y,Fang H.Research on the historic appearance of the Lion Grove from the Yuan dynasty to the Republic of China[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2017,37(1):1-14.
[52]Lu A.Deciphering the reclusive landscape:a study of Wen Zheng-Ming's 1533 album of the Garden of the Unsuccessful Politician[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2011,31(1):40-59.
[53]Yinong X.Interplay of image and fact:the Pavilion of Surging Waves)Suzhou[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,1999,19(3-4):288-301.
[54]Watson P.Famous Gardens of Luoyang,by LIGefei[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2004,24(1):38-54.
[55]Liu X,Hardie A.The Garden of Perfect Brightness(Yuanmingyuan)at the height of its splendour:Translated from Wang Wei(2002)[The Yuanmingyuan Ruins][J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,2005,25(1):1-22.
[56]Siu V M.China and Europe intertwined:a new view of the European sector of the Chang Chun Yuan[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,1999,19(3-4):376-393.
[57]Hu P K.The Shao Garden of Mi Wanzhong(1570-1628):revisiting a late Ming landscape through visual and literary sources1[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,1999,19(3-4):314-342.
[58]Hammond K J.Wang Shizhen's Yan Shan Garden essays:narrating a literati landscape[J].Studies in the History of Gardens&Designed Landscapes,1999,19(3-4):276-287.
[59]Duempelmann S.Taking Turns:Landscape and Environmental History at the Crossroads[J].Landscape Research,2011,36(6):625-640.
(1)作者共被引网络,即研究对象为期刊所有论文的参考文献。通过分析共被引网络图谱中的关键节点,可以揭示出某个研究邻域的代表性作者和知识结构。
(2)引用突现是指引用量突然上升或下降,通常代表该领域研究方向的转变。在图上表现为节点发生突变的圈层被红色标注出来。
(3)平均引用影响关系是指期刊中的主题词被引用的频率大小,其图上的颜色从蓝色(最低引用影响)到红色(最高引用影响),能够揭示出一定时期研究的热点趋势。
(4)鉴于软件分析过程中的参数设置不同,VOSviewer的聚类分析结果可能会略有差异。