基于亚波长人工微结构的电磁波减反增透研究进展
|
摘要
电磁波抗反射技术在太阳能电池、光学透镜、红外传感、探测器等众多应用场景中至关重要,长久以来一直是先进光学系统、光电器件研究领域热点方向之一.本文简略回顾了传统的减反的理论与方法;侧重介绍了近几年来基于亚波长人工微结构材料的电磁波减反增透相关研究进展,主要内容包括局域表面等离激元抑制光反射增强光耦合,传播表面等离激元局域共振模式诱导高透隧穿,超构材料诱导金属透明,人工微结构超表面红外、太赫兹减反等若干典型工作;探讨了亚波长人工微结构光学减反领域未来的发展方向与其所可能遇到的问题挑战.
When light passes through an interface between two media with different refractive indices, part of light energy is reflected and thus causes an inevitable optical reflection. Optical anti-reflection is of great importance for applications in a wide range such as solar cells, optical lenses, infrared sensors, and photo-detectors, which has long been a research topic in the fields of optical systems and optoelectronic devices. In this article, the recent research progress of the optical anti-reflection based on subwavelength artificial engineering materials is reviewed. Having made a brief review of conventional anti-reflection methods, we focus on the overview of the newly developed techniques for optical anti-reflection, such as eliminating reflection by exciting the localized surface plasmons, the enhancement of transmission induced by the excitation of propagating surface plasmons,making metals transparent by the help of metamaterials, and the reduction of anti-reflection in long wavelength infrared and terahertz spectral ranges by using metasurfaces. Compared with the conventional anti-reflection methods, the new technique usually does not suffer the limitation of material, and it benefits from enhanced light absorption and wide incidence angle response. The new technique also enables the design of anti-reflection over wide or a multiple wavelength band. Finally, the future opportunities and challenges for further developing the subwavelength artificial engineering microstructures in optical anti-reflection are also predicted.
When light passes through an interface between two media with different refractive indices, part of light energy is reflected and thus causes an inevitable optical reflection. Optical anti-reflection is of great importance for applications in a wide range such as solar cells, optical lenses, infrared sensors, and photo-detectors, which has long been a research topic in the fields of optical systems and optoelectronic devices. In this article, the recent research progress of the optical anti-reflection based on subwavelength artificial engineering materials is reviewed. Having made a brief review of conventional anti-reflection methods, we focus on the overview of the newly developed techniques for optical anti-reflection, such as eliminating reflection by exciting the localized surface plasmons, the enhancement of transmission induced by the excitation of propagating surface plasmons,making metals transparent by the help of metamaterials, and the reduction of anti-reflection in long wavelength infrared and terahertz spectral ranges by using metasurfaces. Compared with the conventional anti-reflection methods, the new technique usually does not suffer the limitation of material, and it benefits from enhanced light absorption and wide incidence angle response. The new technique also enables the design of anti-reflection over wide or a multiple wavelength band. Finally, the future opportunities and challenges for further developing the subwavelength artificial engineering microstructures in optical anti-reflection are also predicted.
引文
[1]Born M,Wolf E 1999 Principles of Optics(Cambridge:Cambridge University Press)pp38-49
[2]Chattopadhyay S,Huang Y F,Jen Y J,Ganguly A,Chen K H,Chen L C 2010 Mat.Sci.Eng.69 1
[3]Raut H K,Ganesh V A,Nair A S,Ramakrishna S 2011Energy Environ.Sci.4 3779
[4]Hedayati M K,Elbahri M 2016 Materials 9 497
[5]Ebbesen T W,Lezec H J,Ghaemi H F,Thio T,Wolff P A1998 Nature 391 667
[6]Barnes W L,Dereux A,Ebbesen T W 2003 Nature 424 824
[7]Genet C,Ebbesen T W 2007 Nature 445 39
[8]Hutter E,Fendler J H 2004 Adv.Mater.16 1685
[9]Ozbay E 2006 Science 311 189
[10]Pendry J B,Holden A J,Stewart W J,Youngs I 1996 Phys.Rev.Lett.76 4773
[11]Pendry J B,Holden A J,Robbins D J,Stewart W J 1999IEEE Trans.Microwave Theory Tech.47 2075
[12]Smith D R,Padilla W J,Vier D C,Nemat-Nasser S C,Schultz S 2000 Phys.Rev.Lett.84 4184
[13]Shelby R A,Smith D R,Schultz S 2001 Science 292 77
[14]Ramakrishna S A 2005 Rep.Prog.Phys.68 449
[15]Smith D R,Pendry J B,Wiltshire M C K 2004 Science 305788
[16]Stetter F,Esselborn R,Harder N,Friz N,Tolles P 1976Appl Opt 15 2315
[17]Dobrowolski J S,Piotrowski H C 1982 Appl. Opt. 21 1502
[18]Liu Y S,Yang W H,Zhu Y Y,Chen J,Yang Z L,Yang J H2009 Acta Phys.Sin.58 584992(in Chinese)[刘永生,杨文华,朱艳燕,陈静,杨正龙,杨金焕2009物理学报58 584992]
[19]Epstein L V 1952 J.Opt.Soc.Am.42 806
[20]Dobrowolski J A,Poitras D,Ma P H,Vakil H,Acree M2002 Appl. Opt. 41 3075
[21]Poitras D,Dobrowolski J A 2004 Appl. Opt.43 1286
[22]Dobrowolski J A,Guo Y,Tiwald T,Ma P H,Poitras D2006 Appl. Opt. 45 1555
[23]Berning P H 1962 J.Opt. Soc.Am.42 806
[24]Minot M J 1976 J.Opt.Soc.Am.66 515
[25]Raguin D H,Morris G M 1993 Appl. Opt. 32 1154
[26]Branz H M,Yost V E,Ward S,Jones K M,To B,Stradins P 2009 Appl. Phys.Lett. 94 231121
[27]Zhou W D,Tao M,Chen L,Yang H J 2007 J.Appl. Phys.102 103105
[28]Moharam M G,Gaylord T K 1983 J.Opt.Soc.Am.73 1105
[29]Abe M 1994 J.Opt.Soc.Am.11 2038
[30]Moharam M G,Gaylord T K 1982 J.Opt. Soc.Am.72 1385
[31]Sheldon B,Haggerty J S 1982 J.Opt. Soc.Am.72 1049
[32]Moharam M G,Gaylord T K 1981 J.Opt. Soc.Am.71 811
[33]Motamedi M E,Southwell W H,Gunning W J 1992 Appl.Opt. 31 4371
[34]Brauer R,Bryngdahl O 1994 Appl. Opt. 33 7875
[35]Aspnes D E,Theeten J B 1979 Phys.Rev.B 20 3292
[36]Chhajed S,Schubert M F,Kim J K,Schubert E F 2008Appl. Phys.Lett. 93 251108
[37]Sai H S,Fujii H,Arafune K,Ohshita Y,Yamaguchi M 2006Appl. Phys.Lett. 88 201116
[38]Southwell W H 1990 J.Opt. Soc.Am.8 549
[39]Kanamori Y,Roy E,Chen Y 2005 Microelectron.Eng.78287
[40]Bruckner C,Pradarutti B,Stenzel O,Steinkopf R,Riehemann S,Notni G,Tiinnermann A 2007 Opt.Express15 779
[41]Chen H L,Chuang S Y,Lin C H,Lin Y H 2007 Opt.Express 15 14793
[42]Fan P X,Bai B F,Long J Y,Jiang D F,Jin G F,Zhang H J,Zhong M L 2015 Nano Lett. 15 5988
[43]Liang L,Xu Q F,Hu M L,Sun H,Xiang G H,Zhou L B2013 Acta Phys.Sin.62 037301(in Chinese)[梁磊,徐琴芳,忽满利,孙浩,向光华,周利斌2013物理学报62 037301]
[44]Mendoza-Galvan A,Jarrendahl K,Arwin H,Huang Y F,Chen L C Y,Chen K H 2009 Appl. Opt. 48 4996
[45]Lee C,Bae S Y,Mobasser S,Manohara H 2005 Nano Lett.52438
[46]Hu L,Chen G 2007 Nano Lett.7 3249
[47]Lohmuller T,Helgert M,Sundermann M,Brunner R,Spatz J P 2008 Nano Lett. 8 1429
[48]Muskens O L,Rivas J G,Algra R E,Bakkers E P A M,Lagendijk A 2008 Nano Lett.8 2638
[49]Lee Y J,Ruby D S,Peters D W,McKenzie B B,Hsu J W P2008 Nano Lett.8 1505
[50]Yang Z P,Ci L J,Bur J A,Lin S Y,Ajayan P M 2008Nano Lett. 8 446
[51]Zhu J,Yu Z F,Burkhard G F,Hsu C M,Connor S T,Xu Y Q,Wang Q,McGehee M,Fan S H,Cui Y 2009 Nano Lett.9279
[52]Xie G Y,Zhang G M,Lin F,Zhang J,Liu Z F,Mu S C2008 Nanotechnology 19 095605
[53]Huang Y F,Chattopadhyay S,Jen Y J,Peng C Y,Liu T A,Hsu Y K,Pan C L,LoH C,Hsu C H,Chang Y H,Lee C S,Chen K H,Chen L C Y 2007 Nat.Nanotechnol.2 770
[54]Vukusic P,Sambles J R 2003 Nature 424 852
[55]Kanamori Y,Sasaki M,Hane K 1998 Opt.Lett.24 1422
[56]Stavenga D G,Foletti S,Palasantzas G,Arikawa K 2006Proc.R.Soc.B 273 661
[57]Zhang G M,Zhang J,Xie G Y,Liu Z F,Shao H B 2006Small 2 1440
[58]Sun C H,Jiang P,Jiang B 2008 Appl. Phys.Lett. 92 061112
[59]Bodena S A,Bagnall DM 2008 Appl. Phys.Lett.93 133108
[60]Clapham P B,Hutley M C 1973 Nature 244 281
[61]Wilson S J,Hutley M C 2010 Opt.Acta 29 993
[62]Walheim S,Schaffer E,Mlynek J,Steiner U 1999 Science283 520
[63]Rayleigh L 1879 Proc.London Math.Soc.11 51
[64]Jacobsson R 1966 in Wolf E Ed.Progress in Optics(Vol.5)(Amsterdam:North-Holland)p247
[65]Bernard C G 1967 Endeavour 26 79
[66]Southwell W H 1983 Opt.Lett.8 584
[67]Xi J Q,Schubert M F,Kim J K,Schubert E F,Chen M F,Lin S Y,Liu W,Smart J A 2007 Nat.Photon.1 176
[68]Juan M L,Righini M,Quidant R 2011 Nat.Photon.5 349
[69]Stenzel O,Stendal A,Voigtsberger K,Borczyskowski C 1995Sol Energy Mater.Sol. Cells 37 337
[70]Stuart H R,Hall D G 1996 Appl.Phys.Lett.69 2327
[71]Stuart H R,Hall D G 1998 Appl. Phys.Lett. 73 3815
[72]Schaadt D M,Feng B,Yu E T 2005 Appl.Phys.Lett.86063106
[73]Derkacs D,Lim S H,Matheu P,Mar W,Yu E T 2006 Appl.Phys.Lett. 89 093103
[74]Matheu P,Lim S H,Derkacs D,McPheeters C,Yu E T2008 Appl. Phys.Lett. 93 113108
[75]Derkacs D,Chen W V,Matheu P M,Lim S H,Yu P K L,Yu E T 2008 Appl.Phys.Lett. 93 091107
[76]Nakayama K,Tanabe K,Atwater H A 2008 Appl. Phys.Le.tt.93 121904
[77]Atwater H A,Polman A 2010 Nat.Mater.9 205
[78]Chen X,Fang J,Zhang X D,Zhao Y,Gu M 2017 ACS Photon.4 2102
[79]Basch A,Beck F J,Soderstrom T,Varlamov S,Catchpole K R 2012 Appl. Phys.Lett. 100 243903
[80]Catchpole K R,Polman A 2008 Appl. Phys.Lett.93 191113
[81]Starowicz Z,Lipinski M,Berent K,Socha R,Szczepanowicz K,Kruk T 2013 Plasmonics 8 41
[82]Tan H R,Santbergen R,Smets A H M,Zeman M 2012Nano Lett.12 4070
[83]Zhang Y N,Cai B Y,Jia B H 2016 Nano Mater.6 95
[84]Ho W J,Liu J H J,Yang Y C,Ho C H 2018 Nano Lett. 81003
[85]Akimov Y A,Koh W S 2010 Nanotechnology 21 235201
[86]Winans J D,Hungerford C,Shome K,Rothberg L J,Fauchet P M 2015 Opt.Express 23 A92
[87]Han T,Meng F Y,Zhang S,Wang J Q,Cheng X M 2011Acta Phys.Sin.60 60027303(in Chinese)[韩涛,孟凡英,张松,汪建强,程雪梅2011物理学报60 60027303]
[88]Beck F J,Mokkapati S,Catchpole K R 2010 Prog.Photovolt.Res.Appl. 18 500
[89]Lim S H,Mar W,Matheu P,Derkacs D,Yu E T 2007 J.Appl Phys.101 104309
[90]Pillai S,Catchpole K R,Trupke T,Green M A 2007 J.Appl. Phys.101 093105
[91]Spinelli P,Polman A 2012 Opt.Express 20 A642
[92]Ren X G,Cheng J Q,Zhang S Q,Li X C,Rao T K,Huo L J,Hou J H,Choy W C H 2016 Small 12 5200
[93]Pala R A,White J,Barnard E,Liu J,Brongersma M L 2009Adv.Mater.21 3504
[94]Fu Y Q,Ng S P,Qiu G Y,Hung T F,Wu C L,Lee C S2017 Nanoscale 9 10940
[95]Wan D H,Chen H L,Tseng T C,Fang C Y,Lai Y S,Yeh F Y 2010 Adv.Funct.Mater.20 3064
[96]Ferry V E,Sweatlock L A,Pacifici D,Atwater H A 2008Nano Lett.8 4391
[97]Munday J N,Atwater H A 2011 Nano Lett. 11 2195
[98]Zhou L,Tan Y L,Wang J Y,Xu W C,Yuan Y,Cai W S,Zhu S N,Zhu J 2016 Nat.Photon.10 393
[99]Green M A,Pillai S 2012 Nat.Photon.6 130
[100]Fan R H,Peng R W,Huang X R,Li J,Liu Y,Hu Q,Wang M,Zhang X 2012 Adv.Mater.24 1980
[101]Wen W J,Yang Z,Xu G,Chen Y H,Zhou L,Ge W K,Chan C T,Sheng P 2003 Appl. Phys.Lett.83 2106
[102]Wen W J,Zhou L,Hou B,Chan C T,Sheng P 2005 Phys.Rev.B 72 153406
[103]Akozbek N,Mattiucci N,Ceglia D,Trimm R,Alu A,D'Aguanno G,Vincenti M A,Scalora M,Bloemer M J 2012Phys.Rev.B 85 205430
[104]Lee J W,Seo M A,Kang D H,Khim K S,Jeoung S C,Kim D S 2007 Phys.Rev.Lett. 99 137401
[105]Huang X R,Peng R W,Fan R H 2010 Phys.Rev.Lett.105243901
[106]Weiner J 2009 Rep.Prog.Phys.72 064401
[107]Ghaemi H F,Thio T,Grupp D E,Ebbesen T W,Lezec H J1998 Phys.Rev.B 58 6779
[108]Barnes W L,Murray W A,Dintinger J,Devaux E,Ebbesen T W 2004 Phys.Rev.Lett.92 107401
[109]Liu H T,Lalanne P 2008 Nature 452 728
[110]Porto J A,Garcia-Vidal F J,Pendry J B 1999 Phys.Rev.Lett.83 2845
[111]Went H E,Hibbins A P,Sambles J R 2000 Appl. Phys.Lett.77 2789
[112]Ruan Z C,Qiu M 2006 Phys.Rev.Lett.96 233901
[113]Alu A,D'Aguanno G,Mattiucci N,Bloemer M J 2011 Phys.Rev.Lett.106 123902
[114]Fan R H,Zhu L H,Peng R W,Huang X R,Qi D X,Ren X P,Hu Q,Wang M 2013 Phys.Rev.B 87 195444
[115]Pacheco Jr J,Grzegorczyk T M,Wu BI,Zhang Y,Kong J A2002 Phys.Rev.Lett. 89 257401
[116]Pendry J B 2003 Nature 423 22
[117]Foteinopoulou S,Economou E N,Soukoulis C M 2003 Phys.Rev.Lett.90 107402
[118]Cubukcu E,Aydin K,Ozbay E,Foteinopoulou S,Soukoulis C M 2003 Nature 423 604
[119]Parimi P V,Lu W T,Vodo P,Sridhar S 2003 Nature 426404
[120]Berrier A,Mulot M,Swillo M,Qiu M,Thylen L,Talneau A,Anand S 2004 Phys.Rev.Lett. 93 073902
[121]Pendry J B 2004 Science 306 1353
[122]Chena H S,Ran L X,Huangfu J,Zhang X M,Chen K S2005 Appl. Phys.Lett. 86 151909
[123]Shin H,Fan S H 2006 Phys.Rev.Lett.96 239903
[124]Lezec H J,Dionne J A,Atwater H A 2007 Science 316 430
[125]Khorasaninejad M,Chen W T,Devlin R C,Oh J,Zhu A Y,Capasso F 2016 Science 352 1190
[126]Khorasaninejad M,Capasso F 2017 Science 358 6367
[127]Pendry J B 2000 Phys.Rev.Lett. 85 3966
[128]Pendry J B,Ramakrishna S A 2003 Physica B 338 329
[129]Ramakrishna S A 2005 Rep.Prog.Phys.338 329
[130]Pendry J B,Schurig D,Smith D R 2006 Science 312 1780
[131]Cummer S A,Popa BI,Schurig D,Smith D R,Pendry J B2006 Phys.Rev.E 74 036621
[132]Schurig D,Mock J J,Justice B J,Cummer S A,Pendry J B,Starr A F,Smith D R 2006 Science 314 977
[133]Chen H S,Wu B-I,Zhang B,Kong J A 2007 Phys.Rev.Lett. 99 063903
[134]Li J S,Pendry J B 2008 Phys.Rev.Lett. 101 203901
[135]Hao J M,Yuan Y,Ran L X,Jiang T,Kong J A,Chan C T,Zhou L 2007 Phys.Rev.Lett.99 063908
[136]Chin J Y,Lu M Z,Cui T J 2008 Appl. Phys.Lett. 93 251903
[137]Zhu B,Feng Y J,Zhao J M,Huang C,Wang Z B,Jiang T2010 Opt.Express 18 23196
[138]Wei Z,Cao Y,Fan Y C,Yu X,Li H Q 2011 Appl. Phys.Lett. 99 221907
[139]Alici K B,Turhan A B,Soukoulis C M,Ozbay E 2011 Opt.Express 19 14260
[140]Zhang B X,Zhao Y H,Hao Q Z,Kiraly B,Khoo I C,Chen S F,Huang T J 2011 Opt.Express 19 15221
[141]Shrestha S,Wang Yu,Overvig A C,Lu M,Stein A,Negro L D,Yu N F 2018 A CS Photon.5 3526
[142]Hao J M,Wang J,Liu X L,Padilla W J,Zhou L,Qiu M2010 Appl. Phys.Lett. 96 251104
[143]Bhattarai K,Ku Z Y,Silva S,Jeon J Y,Kim J O,Lee S J,Urbas A,Zhou J F 2015 Adv.Opt.Mater.3 1779
[144]Aydin K,Ferry V E,Briggs R M,Atwater H A 2011 Nat.Commun.2 517
[145]Hao J M,Qiu C W,Qiu M,Zouhdi S 2012 Opt. Lett. 374955
[146]Landy N I,Sajuyigbe S,Mock J J,Smith D R,Padilla W J2008 Phys.Rev.Lett. 100 207402
[147]Zou Y H,Jiang L,Wena S C,Shu W X,Qing Y J,Tang ZX,Luo H L,Fan D Y 2008 Appl. Phys.Lett. 93 26115
[148]Wena Q Y,Zhang H W,Xie Y S,Yang Q H,Liu Y L 2009Appl. Phys.Lett.95 241111
[149]Yang J,Hu X H,Li X,Liu Z,Liang Z X,Jiang X Y,Zi J2009 Phys.Rev.B 80 125103
[150]Liu N,Mesch M,Weiss T,Hentschel M,Giessen H 2010Nano Lett.10 2342
[151]Lu J L,Yu W W,Zhang X D,Xu H,Hao J M,Sun Y,Chen X,Meng X J,Dai N,Chu J H 2018 J.Infrared Millim Waves 37 740
[152]Pan X H,Xu H,Yu W W,Shen H,Hao J M,Sun Y,Shen Y,Meng X J,Dai N 2019 J.Infrared Millim Waves 38 50(in Chinese)[潘晓航,许昊,俞伟伟,沈宏,郝加明,孙艳,沈悦,孟祥建,戴宁2019红外与毫米波学报38 50]
[153]Zhou L,Wen W J,Chan C T,Sheng P 2005 Phys.Rev.Lett. 94 243905
[154]Song Z Y,He Q,Xiao S Y,Zhou L 2012 Appl. Phys.Lett.101 181110
[155]Korobkin D,Urzhumov Y,Shvets G 2006 J.Opt.Soc.Am.B 23 468
[156]Hooper I R,Priest T W,Sambles J R 2006 Phys.Rev.Lett.97 053902
[157]Malureanu R,Zalkovskij M,Song Z Y,Gritti C,Andryieuski A,He Q,Zhou L,Jepsen P U,Lavrinenko A V 2012 Opt.Express 20 22770
[158]Sun W J,He Q,Hao J M,Zhou L 2011 Opt.Lett. 36 927
[159]Thoman A,Kern A,Helm H,Walther M 2008 Phys.Rev.B77 195405
[160]Ding L,Wu Q Y S,Song J F,Serita K,Tonouchi M,Teng J H 2013 Adv.Opt.Mater.1 910
[161]Ding L,Wu Q Y S,Teng J H 2014 Laser Photon.Rev.8941
[162]Zhang J,Ade P A R,Mauskopf P,Moncelsi L,Savini G,Whitehouse N 2009 Appl. Opt.48 6635
[163]Chen H T,Zhou J F,O'Hara J F,Chen F,Azad A K,Taylor A J 2010 Phys.Rev.Lett. 105 073901
[164]Chen H T,Zhou J F,O'Hara J F,Taylor A J 2010 THz Sci.Tech.3 66
[165]Park M S,Bhattarai K,Kim D K,Kang S W,Kim J O,Zhou J F,Jang W Y,Noyola M,Urbas A,Ku Z Y,Lee S J2014 Opt.Express 22 30161
[166]Hedayati M K,Abdelaziz M,Etrich C,Homaeigohar S,Rockstuhlm C,Elbahri M 2016 Materials 9 636
[167]Jeon J Y,Bhattarai K,Kim D K,Kim J O,Urbas A,Lee S J,Ku Z Y,Zhou J F 2016 Sci.Rep.6 36190
[168]Cordaro A,Groep J V D,Raza S,Pecora E F,Priolo F,Brongersma M L 2019 A CS Photon.6 453
[169]Jeon J Y,Hwang J W,Bhattarai K,Kim D K,Kim O J,Urbas A,Zhou J F,Ku Z Y,Lee S J 2019 Opt.Mat. Express9 1290
[170]Kabiri A,Girgis E,Capasso F 2013 Nan.o Lett.13 6040
[171]Zhang B Y,Hendrickson J,Nader N,Chen H T,Guo J P2014 Appl. Phys.Lett. 105 241113
[172]Huang L,Chang C C,Zeng B B,Nogan J,Luo S N,Taylor A J,Azad A K,Chen H T 2017 A CS Photon.4 2111
[173]Zhao J,Zhang C,Cheng Q,Yang J,Cui T J 2018 Appl.Phys.Lett. 112 073504
[2]Chattopadhyay S,Huang Y F,Jen Y J,Ganguly A,Chen K H,Chen L C 2010 Mat.Sci.Eng.69 1
[3]Raut H K,Ganesh V A,Nair A S,Ramakrishna S 2011Energy Environ.Sci.4 3779
[4]Hedayati M K,Elbahri M 2016 Materials 9 497
[5]Ebbesen T W,Lezec H J,Ghaemi H F,Thio T,Wolff P A1998 Nature 391 667
[6]Barnes W L,Dereux A,Ebbesen T W 2003 Nature 424 824
[7]Genet C,Ebbesen T W 2007 Nature 445 39
[8]Hutter E,Fendler J H 2004 Adv.Mater.16 1685
[9]Ozbay E 2006 Science 311 189
[10]Pendry J B,Holden A J,Stewart W J,Youngs I 1996 Phys.Rev.Lett.76 4773
[11]Pendry J B,Holden A J,Robbins D J,Stewart W J 1999IEEE Trans.Microwave Theory Tech.47 2075
[12]Smith D R,Padilla W J,Vier D C,Nemat-Nasser S C,Schultz S 2000 Phys.Rev.Lett.84 4184
[13]Shelby R A,Smith D R,Schultz S 2001 Science 292 77
[14]Ramakrishna S A 2005 Rep.Prog.Phys.68 449
[15]Smith D R,Pendry J B,Wiltshire M C K 2004 Science 305788
[16]Stetter F,Esselborn R,Harder N,Friz N,Tolles P 1976Appl Opt 15 2315
[17]Dobrowolski J S,Piotrowski H C 1982 Appl. Opt. 21 1502
[18]Liu Y S,Yang W H,Zhu Y Y,Chen J,Yang Z L,Yang J H2009 Acta Phys.Sin.58 584992(in Chinese)[刘永生,杨文华,朱艳燕,陈静,杨正龙,杨金焕2009物理学报58 584992]
[19]Epstein L V 1952 J.Opt.Soc.Am.42 806
[20]Dobrowolski J A,Poitras D,Ma P H,Vakil H,Acree M2002 Appl. Opt. 41 3075
[21]Poitras D,Dobrowolski J A 2004 Appl. Opt.43 1286
[22]Dobrowolski J A,Guo Y,Tiwald T,Ma P H,Poitras D2006 Appl. Opt. 45 1555
[23]Berning P H 1962 J.Opt. Soc.Am.42 806
[24]Minot M J 1976 J.Opt.Soc.Am.66 515
[25]Raguin D H,Morris G M 1993 Appl. Opt. 32 1154
[26]Branz H M,Yost V E,Ward S,Jones K M,To B,Stradins P 2009 Appl. Phys.Lett. 94 231121
[27]Zhou W D,Tao M,Chen L,Yang H J 2007 J.Appl. Phys.102 103105
[28]Moharam M G,Gaylord T K 1983 J.Opt.Soc.Am.73 1105
[29]Abe M 1994 J.Opt.Soc.Am.11 2038
[30]Moharam M G,Gaylord T K 1982 J.Opt. Soc.Am.72 1385
[31]Sheldon B,Haggerty J S 1982 J.Opt. Soc.Am.72 1049
[32]Moharam M G,Gaylord T K 1981 J.Opt. Soc.Am.71 811
[33]Motamedi M E,Southwell W H,Gunning W J 1992 Appl.Opt. 31 4371
[34]Brauer R,Bryngdahl O 1994 Appl. Opt. 33 7875
[35]Aspnes D E,Theeten J B 1979 Phys.Rev.B 20 3292
[36]Chhajed S,Schubert M F,Kim J K,Schubert E F 2008Appl. Phys.Lett. 93 251108
[37]Sai H S,Fujii H,Arafune K,Ohshita Y,Yamaguchi M 2006Appl. Phys.Lett. 88 201116
[38]Southwell W H 1990 J.Opt. Soc.Am.8 549
[39]Kanamori Y,Roy E,Chen Y 2005 Microelectron.Eng.78287
[40]Bruckner C,Pradarutti B,Stenzel O,Steinkopf R,Riehemann S,Notni G,Tiinnermann A 2007 Opt.Express15 779
[41]Chen H L,Chuang S Y,Lin C H,Lin Y H 2007 Opt.Express 15 14793
[42]Fan P X,Bai B F,Long J Y,Jiang D F,Jin G F,Zhang H J,Zhong M L 2015 Nano Lett. 15 5988
[43]Liang L,Xu Q F,Hu M L,Sun H,Xiang G H,Zhou L B2013 Acta Phys.Sin.62 037301(in Chinese)[梁磊,徐琴芳,忽满利,孙浩,向光华,周利斌2013物理学报62 037301]
[44]Mendoza-Galvan A,Jarrendahl K,Arwin H,Huang Y F,Chen L C Y,Chen K H 2009 Appl. Opt. 48 4996
[45]Lee C,Bae S Y,Mobasser S,Manohara H 2005 Nano Lett.52438
[46]Hu L,Chen G 2007 Nano Lett.7 3249
[47]Lohmuller T,Helgert M,Sundermann M,Brunner R,Spatz J P 2008 Nano Lett. 8 1429
[48]Muskens O L,Rivas J G,Algra R E,Bakkers E P A M,Lagendijk A 2008 Nano Lett.8 2638
[49]Lee Y J,Ruby D S,Peters D W,McKenzie B B,Hsu J W P2008 Nano Lett.8 1505
[50]Yang Z P,Ci L J,Bur J A,Lin S Y,Ajayan P M 2008Nano Lett. 8 446
[51]Zhu J,Yu Z F,Burkhard G F,Hsu C M,Connor S T,Xu Y Q,Wang Q,McGehee M,Fan S H,Cui Y 2009 Nano Lett.9279
[52]Xie G Y,Zhang G M,Lin F,Zhang J,Liu Z F,Mu S C2008 Nanotechnology 19 095605
[53]Huang Y F,Chattopadhyay S,Jen Y J,Peng C Y,Liu T A,Hsu Y K,Pan C L,LoH C,Hsu C H,Chang Y H,Lee C S,Chen K H,Chen L C Y 2007 Nat.Nanotechnol.2 770
[54]Vukusic P,Sambles J R 2003 Nature 424 852
[55]Kanamori Y,Sasaki M,Hane K 1998 Opt.Lett.24 1422
[56]Stavenga D G,Foletti S,Palasantzas G,Arikawa K 2006Proc.R.Soc.B 273 661
[57]Zhang G M,Zhang J,Xie G Y,Liu Z F,Shao H B 2006Small 2 1440
[58]Sun C H,Jiang P,Jiang B 2008 Appl. Phys.Lett. 92 061112
[59]Bodena S A,Bagnall DM 2008 Appl. Phys.Lett.93 133108
[60]Clapham P B,Hutley M C 1973 Nature 244 281
[61]Wilson S J,Hutley M C 2010 Opt.Acta 29 993
[62]Walheim S,Schaffer E,Mlynek J,Steiner U 1999 Science283 520
[63]Rayleigh L 1879 Proc.London Math.Soc.11 51
[64]Jacobsson R 1966 in Wolf E Ed.Progress in Optics(Vol.5)(Amsterdam:North-Holland)p247
[65]Bernard C G 1967 Endeavour 26 79
[66]Southwell W H 1983 Opt.Lett.8 584
[67]Xi J Q,Schubert M F,Kim J K,Schubert E F,Chen M F,Lin S Y,Liu W,Smart J A 2007 Nat.Photon.1 176
[68]Juan M L,Righini M,Quidant R 2011 Nat.Photon.5 349
[69]Stenzel O,Stendal A,Voigtsberger K,Borczyskowski C 1995Sol Energy Mater.Sol. Cells 37 337
[70]Stuart H R,Hall D G 1996 Appl.Phys.Lett.69 2327
[71]Stuart H R,Hall D G 1998 Appl. Phys.Lett. 73 3815
[72]Schaadt D M,Feng B,Yu E T 2005 Appl.Phys.Lett.86063106
[73]Derkacs D,Lim S H,Matheu P,Mar W,Yu E T 2006 Appl.Phys.Lett. 89 093103
[74]Matheu P,Lim S H,Derkacs D,McPheeters C,Yu E T2008 Appl. Phys.Lett. 93 113108
[75]Derkacs D,Chen W V,Matheu P M,Lim S H,Yu P K L,Yu E T 2008 Appl.Phys.Lett. 93 091107
[76]Nakayama K,Tanabe K,Atwater H A 2008 Appl. Phys.Le.tt.93 121904
[77]Atwater H A,Polman A 2010 Nat.Mater.9 205
[78]Chen X,Fang J,Zhang X D,Zhao Y,Gu M 2017 ACS Photon.4 2102
[79]Basch A,Beck F J,Soderstrom T,Varlamov S,Catchpole K R 2012 Appl. Phys.Lett. 100 243903
[80]Catchpole K R,Polman A 2008 Appl. Phys.Lett.93 191113
[81]Starowicz Z,Lipinski M,Berent K,Socha R,Szczepanowicz K,Kruk T 2013 Plasmonics 8 41
[82]Tan H R,Santbergen R,Smets A H M,Zeman M 2012Nano Lett.12 4070
[83]Zhang Y N,Cai B Y,Jia B H 2016 Nano Mater.6 95
[84]Ho W J,Liu J H J,Yang Y C,Ho C H 2018 Nano Lett. 81003
[85]Akimov Y A,Koh W S 2010 Nanotechnology 21 235201
[86]Winans J D,Hungerford C,Shome K,Rothberg L J,Fauchet P M 2015 Opt.Express 23 A92
[87]Han T,Meng F Y,Zhang S,Wang J Q,Cheng X M 2011Acta Phys.Sin.60 60027303(in Chinese)[韩涛,孟凡英,张松,汪建强,程雪梅2011物理学报60 60027303]
[88]Beck F J,Mokkapati S,Catchpole K R 2010 Prog.Photovolt.Res.Appl. 18 500
[89]Lim S H,Mar W,Matheu P,Derkacs D,Yu E T 2007 J.Appl Phys.101 104309
[90]Pillai S,Catchpole K R,Trupke T,Green M A 2007 J.Appl. Phys.101 093105
[91]Spinelli P,Polman A 2012 Opt.Express 20 A642
[92]Ren X G,Cheng J Q,Zhang S Q,Li X C,Rao T K,Huo L J,Hou J H,Choy W C H 2016 Small 12 5200
[93]Pala R A,White J,Barnard E,Liu J,Brongersma M L 2009Adv.Mater.21 3504
[94]Fu Y Q,Ng S P,Qiu G Y,Hung T F,Wu C L,Lee C S2017 Nanoscale 9 10940
[95]Wan D H,Chen H L,Tseng T C,Fang C Y,Lai Y S,Yeh F Y 2010 Adv.Funct.Mater.20 3064
[96]Ferry V E,Sweatlock L A,Pacifici D,Atwater H A 2008Nano Lett.8 4391
[97]Munday J N,Atwater H A 2011 Nano Lett. 11 2195
[98]Zhou L,Tan Y L,Wang J Y,Xu W C,Yuan Y,Cai W S,Zhu S N,Zhu J 2016 Nat.Photon.10 393
[99]Green M A,Pillai S 2012 Nat.Photon.6 130
[100]Fan R H,Peng R W,Huang X R,Li J,Liu Y,Hu Q,Wang M,Zhang X 2012 Adv.Mater.24 1980
[101]Wen W J,Yang Z,Xu G,Chen Y H,Zhou L,Ge W K,Chan C T,Sheng P 2003 Appl. Phys.Lett.83 2106
[102]Wen W J,Zhou L,Hou B,Chan C T,Sheng P 2005 Phys.Rev.B 72 153406
[103]Akozbek N,Mattiucci N,Ceglia D,Trimm R,Alu A,D'Aguanno G,Vincenti M A,Scalora M,Bloemer M J 2012Phys.Rev.B 85 205430
[104]Lee J W,Seo M A,Kang D H,Khim K S,Jeoung S C,Kim D S 2007 Phys.Rev.Lett. 99 137401
[105]Huang X R,Peng R W,Fan R H 2010 Phys.Rev.Lett.105243901
[106]Weiner J 2009 Rep.Prog.Phys.72 064401
[107]Ghaemi H F,Thio T,Grupp D E,Ebbesen T W,Lezec H J1998 Phys.Rev.B 58 6779
[108]Barnes W L,Murray W A,Dintinger J,Devaux E,Ebbesen T W 2004 Phys.Rev.Lett.92 107401
[109]Liu H T,Lalanne P 2008 Nature 452 728
[110]Porto J A,Garcia-Vidal F J,Pendry J B 1999 Phys.Rev.Lett.83 2845
[111]Went H E,Hibbins A P,Sambles J R 2000 Appl. Phys.Lett.77 2789
[112]Ruan Z C,Qiu M 2006 Phys.Rev.Lett.96 233901
[113]Alu A,D'Aguanno G,Mattiucci N,Bloemer M J 2011 Phys.Rev.Lett.106 123902
[114]Fan R H,Zhu L H,Peng R W,Huang X R,Qi D X,Ren X P,Hu Q,Wang M 2013 Phys.Rev.B 87 195444
[115]Pacheco Jr J,Grzegorczyk T M,Wu BI,Zhang Y,Kong J A2002 Phys.Rev.Lett. 89 257401
[116]Pendry J B 2003 Nature 423 22
[117]Foteinopoulou S,Economou E N,Soukoulis C M 2003 Phys.Rev.Lett.90 107402
[118]Cubukcu E,Aydin K,Ozbay E,Foteinopoulou S,Soukoulis C M 2003 Nature 423 604
[119]Parimi P V,Lu W T,Vodo P,Sridhar S 2003 Nature 426404
[120]Berrier A,Mulot M,Swillo M,Qiu M,Thylen L,Talneau A,Anand S 2004 Phys.Rev.Lett. 93 073902
[121]Pendry J B 2004 Science 306 1353
[122]Chena H S,Ran L X,Huangfu J,Zhang X M,Chen K S2005 Appl. Phys.Lett. 86 151909
[123]Shin H,Fan S H 2006 Phys.Rev.Lett.96 239903
[124]Lezec H J,Dionne J A,Atwater H A 2007 Science 316 430
[125]Khorasaninejad M,Chen W T,Devlin R C,Oh J,Zhu A Y,Capasso F 2016 Science 352 1190
[126]Khorasaninejad M,Capasso F 2017 Science 358 6367
[127]Pendry J B 2000 Phys.Rev.Lett. 85 3966
[128]Pendry J B,Ramakrishna S A 2003 Physica B 338 329
[129]Ramakrishna S A 2005 Rep.Prog.Phys.338 329
[130]Pendry J B,Schurig D,Smith D R 2006 Science 312 1780
[131]Cummer S A,Popa BI,Schurig D,Smith D R,Pendry J B2006 Phys.Rev.E 74 036621
[132]Schurig D,Mock J J,Justice B J,Cummer S A,Pendry J B,Starr A F,Smith D R 2006 Science 314 977
[133]Chen H S,Wu B-I,Zhang B,Kong J A 2007 Phys.Rev.Lett. 99 063903
[134]Li J S,Pendry J B 2008 Phys.Rev.Lett. 101 203901
[135]Hao J M,Yuan Y,Ran L X,Jiang T,Kong J A,Chan C T,Zhou L 2007 Phys.Rev.Lett.99 063908
[136]Chin J Y,Lu M Z,Cui T J 2008 Appl. Phys.Lett. 93 251903
[137]Zhu B,Feng Y J,Zhao J M,Huang C,Wang Z B,Jiang T2010 Opt.Express 18 23196
[138]Wei Z,Cao Y,Fan Y C,Yu X,Li H Q 2011 Appl. Phys.Lett. 99 221907
[139]Alici K B,Turhan A B,Soukoulis C M,Ozbay E 2011 Opt.Express 19 14260
[140]Zhang B X,Zhao Y H,Hao Q Z,Kiraly B,Khoo I C,Chen S F,Huang T J 2011 Opt.Express 19 15221
[141]Shrestha S,Wang Yu,Overvig A C,Lu M,Stein A,Negro L D,Yu N F 2018 A CS Photon.5 3526
[142]Hao J M,Wang J,Liu X L,Padilla W J,Zhou L,Qiu M2010 Appl. Phys.Lett. 96 251104
[143]Bhattarai K,Ku Z Y,Silva S,Jeon J Y,Kim J O,Lee S J,Urbas A,Zhou J F 2015 Adv.Opt.Mater.3 1779
[144]Aydin K,Ferry V E,Briggs R M,Atwater H A 2011 Nat.Commun.2 517
[145]Hao J M,Qiu C W,Qiu M,Zouhdi S 2012 Opt. Lett. 374955
[146]Landy N I,Sajuyigbe S,Mock J J,Smith D R,Padilla W J2008 Phys.Rev.Lett. 100 207402
[147]Zou Y H,Jiang L,Wena S C,Shu W X,Qing Y J,Tang ZX,Luo H L,Fan D Y 2008 Appl. Phys.Lett. 93 26115
[148]Wena Q Y,Zhang H W,Xie Y S,Yang Q H,Liu Y L 2009Appl. Phys.Lett.95 241111
[149]Yang J,Hu X H,Li X,Liu Z,Liang Z X,Jiang X Y,Zi J2009 Phys.Rev.B 80 125103
[150]Liu N,Mesch M,Weiss T,Hentschel M,Giessen H 2010Nano Lett.10 2342
[151]Lu J L,Yu W W,Zhang X D,Xu H,Hao J M,Sun Y,Chen X,Meng X J,Dai N,Chu J H 2018 J.Infrared Millim Waves 37 740
[152]Pan X H,Xu H,Yu W W,Shen H,Hao J M,Sun Y,Shen Y,Meng X J,Dai N 2019 J.Infrared Millim Waves 38 50(in Chinese)[潘晓航,许昊,俞伟伟,沈宏,郝加明,孙艳,沈悦,孟祥建,戴宁2019红外与毫米波学报38 50]
[153]Zhou L,Wen W J,Chan C T,Sheng P 2005 Phys.Rev.Lett. 94 243905
[154]Song Z Y,He Q,Xiao S Y,Zhou L 2012 Appl. Phys.Lett.101 181110
[155]Korobkin D,Urzhumov Y,Shvets G 2006 J.Opt.Soc.Am.B 23 468
[156]Hooper I R,Priest T W,Sambles J R 2006 Phys.Rev.Lett.97 053902
[157]Malureanu R,Zalkovskij M,Song Z Y,Gritti C,Andryieuski A,He Q,Zhou L,Jepsen P U,Lavrinenko A V 2012 Opt.Express 20 22770
[158]Sun W J,He Q,Hao J M,Zhou L 2011 Opt.Lett. 36 927
[159]Thoman A,Kern A,Helm H,Walther M 2008 Phys.Rev.B77 195405
[160]Ding L,Wu Q Y S,Song J F,Serita K,Tonouchi M,Teng J H 2013 Adv.Opt.Mater.1 910
[161]Ding L,Wu Q Y S,Teng J H 2014 Laser Photon.Rev.8941
[162]Zhang J,Ade P A R,Mauskopf P,Moncelsi L,Savini G,Whitehouse N 2009 Appl. Opt.48 6635
[163]Chen H T,Zhou J F,O'Hara J F,Chen F,Azad A K,Taylor A J 2010 Phys.Rev.Lett. 105 073901
[164]Chen H T,Zhou J F,O'Hara J F,Taylor A J 2010 THz Sci.Tech.3 66
[165]Park M S,Bhattarai K,Kim D K,Kang S W,Kim J O,Zhou J F,Jang W Y,Noyola M,Urbas A,Ku Z Y,Lee S J2014 Opt.Express 22 30161
[166]Hedayati M K,Abdelaziz M,Etrich C,Homaeigohar S,Rockstuhlm C,Elbahri M 2016 Materials 9 636
[167]Jeon J Y,Bhattarai K,Kim D K,Kim J O,Urbas A,Lee S J,Ku Z Y,Zhou J F 2016 Sci.Rep.6 36190
[168]Cordaro A,Groep J V D,Raza S,Pecora E F,Priolo F,Brongersma M L 2019 A CS Photon.6 453
[169]Jeon J Y,Hwang J W,Bhattarai K,Kim D K,Kim O J,Urbas A,Zhou J F,Ku Z Y,Lee S J 2019 Opt.Mat. Express9 1290
[170]Kabiri A,Girgis E,Capasso F 2013 Nan.o Lett.13 6040
[171]Zhang B Y,Hendrickson J,Nader N,Chen H T,Guo J P2014 Appl. Phys.Lett. 105 241113
[172]Huang L,Chang C C,Zeng B B,Nogan J,Luo S N,Taylor A J,Azad A K,Chen H T 2017 A CS Photon.4 2111
[173]Zhao J,Zhang C,Cheng Q,Yang J,Cui T J 2018 Appl.Phys.Lett. 112 073504