“净身出户”协议的效力探讨及裁判策略
|
摘要
"净身出户"协议是夫妻双方基于物权对夫妻共同财产分割的约定。"净身出户"协议不是一般民事协议,而是离婚协议的一种类型,不具有单独可诉性。司法裁判时,应当依据婚姻法、民法、合同法、侵权法的相关规定综合判断其效力是否存在,应当作为离婚诉讼附带的财产分割争议一并审理,坚持个案裁判结果公平,尤其注重保护婚姻弱势一方和平衡夫妻双方的正当利益。
The agreement of "clearing out with nothing" is a joint agreement on property rights between husband and wife.Instead of a general civil agreement,the agreement of "clearing out with nothing" is a kind of divorce agreement that is not separately actionable.In judicial adjudication,we should comprehensively judge whether this kind of agreement is valid or not according to the relevant provisions of marriage law,civil law,contract law and tort law,and try it as an incidental property division dispute in divorce proceedings,guaranteeing the fair result of the case adjudication,with particular emphasis on protecting the weak party in marriage and balancing the legitimate interests of both husband and wife.
The agreement of "clearing out with nothing" is a joint agreement on property rights between husband and wife.Instead of a general civil agreement,the agreement of "clearing out with nothing" is a kind of divorce agreement that is not separately actionable.In judicial adjudication,we should comprehensively judge whether this kind of agreement is valid or not according to the relevant provisions of marriage law,civil law,contract law and tort law,and try it as an incidental property division dispute in divorce proceedings,guaranteeing the fair result of the case adjudication,with particular emphasis on protecting the weak party in marriage and balancing the legitimate interests of both husband and wife.
引文
[1]陈保君.“忠诚协议”的合同性质及效力——以出轨方净身出户案为例[J].信阳农业高等专科学校学报,2011(2).
[2]梁淘淘,李建普.“净身出户”妈妈也应付孩子抚养费[J].农家参谋,2010(10).
[3]徐旭,李源.限制婚姻自由的协议自始无效[N].中国妇女报,2011-10-13-(A03).
[4]夏阳.农村妇女离婚遭遇“净身出户”[N].北京日报,2011-09-21(018).
[5]郭鹏.夫妻忠诚协议效力的再探讨——基于学说理论与实证案例的反思[J].劳动保障世界,2017(24).
[6]王彬.司法裁决中的“顺推法”与“逆推法”[J].法制与社会发展,2014(1).
[7]景春兰.夫妻“忠实协议”的裁判规则解释[J].政治与法律,2017(8).
[2]梁淘淘,李建普.“净身出户”妈妈也应付孩子抚养费[J].农家参谋,2010(10).
[3]徐旭,李源.限制婚姻自由的协议自始无效[N].中国妇女报,2011-10-13-(A03).
[4]夏阳.农村妇女离婚遭遇“净身出户”[N].北京日报,2011-09-21(018).
[5]郭鹏.夫妻忠诚协议效力的再探讨——基于学说理论与实证案例的反思[J].劳动保障世界,2017(24).
[6]王彬.司法裁决中的“顺推法”与“逆推法”[J].法制与社会发展,2014(1).
[7]景春兰.夫妻“忠实协议”的裁判规则解释[J].政治与法律,2017(8).