2008年以来地图学眼动与视觉认知研究新进展
|
摘要
地图是人类日常生活中不可或缺的工具。地图认知作为研究人对地图的感知、学习、记忆、推理和决策的科学,一直以来是地图学基础理论的重要内容。作为地图认知研究的核心,近年来地图视觉认知在相关学科(如心理学、认知科学和计算机视觉)和新的研究手段(如眼动跟踪、脑电和核磁)的促进下取得了一系列新的研究成果。尤其是眼动跟踪方法作为地图视觉认知研究的重要手段之一,越来越受到研究者的关注,为地图视觉认知研究的定量化、实用化提供了有力支撑。本文系统地梳理了2008年以来眼动跟踪方法在地图视觉认知研究中取得的新进展,并将其归纳为6个发展趋势,分别包括:①刺激材料:从静态地图到动态交互地图;②研究范围:从地图认知到地图空间认知;③实验环境:从实验室环境到真实环境;④地图维度:从二维地图到三维地图;⑤个体差异:从单一维度到多维度;⑥研究目的:从规律探究到实践应用。本文最后总结了未来研究面临的挑战、难点和可能的解决方法,期望能在地图视觉认知研究中起到抛砖引玉的作用。
Maps are a necessity in people's lives. Map cognition research, a science of investigating perception, learning, memory, reasoning and decision making of maps, has long been an important issue in the foundation of cartography. As a core part of map cognition research, studies on visual cognition of maps have made a series of achievements promoted by advancements of related fields(e.g., psychology, cognitive science and computer vision) and new techniques(e.g., eye tracking, EEG and functional magnetic resonance imaging).Particularly, eye tracking approach has gained much attention, which has been used as a crucial method to investigate map cognition. This paper reviews the new progress of eye tracking based visual cognition of maps which have been made since 2008. We summarized these progresses in six aspects:(1) stimulus: from static maps to dynamic and interactive maps;(2)research extent: from map cognition to map-based spatial cognition;(3) experiment environment: from lab environment to real environment;(4) map dimension: from 2 D to 3 D;(5) individual differences: from single dimension to multiple dimensions;(6) research purpose:from theory exploration to application. We also summarized future research challenges,difficulties and possible solutions. We hope this review can serve as an initial effort to open more endeavor for future eye tracking investigations into map cognition.
Maps are a necessity in people's lives. Map cognition research, a science of investigating perception, learning, memory, reasoning and decision making of maps, has long been an important issue in the foundation of cartography. As a core part of map cognition research, studies on visual cognition of maps have made a series of achievements promoted by advancements of related fields(e.g., psychology, cognitive science and computer vision) and new techniques(e.g., eye tracking, EEG and functional magnetic resonance imaging).Particularly, eye tracking approach has gained much attention, which has been used as a crucial method to investigate map cognition. This paper reviews the new progress of eye tracking based visual cognition of maps which have been made since 2008. We summarized these progresses in six aspects:(1) stimulus: from static maps to dynamic and interactive maps;(2)research extent: from map cognition to map-based spatial cognition;(3) experiment environment: from lab environment to real environment;(4) map dimension: from 2 D to 3 D;(5) individual differences: from single dimension to multiple dimensions;(6) research purpose:from theory exploration to application. We also summarized future research challenges,difficulties and possible solutions. We hope this review can serve as an initial effort to open more endeavor for future eye tracking investigations into map cognition.
引文
[1]Tolman E C.Cognitive maps in rats and men.Psychological Review,1948,55(4):189.
[2]Golledge R G.Human wayfinding and cognitive map//Golledge R G.Wayfinding Behavior:Cognitive Mapping and Other Spatial Processes.Baltimore,MD:The Johns Hopkins University Press,1999:5-45.
[3]Montello D R.Cognitive research in GIScience:Recent achievements and future prospects.Geography Compass,2009.3(5):1824-1840.
[4]Gao Jun,Gong Jianhua,Lu Xuejun,et al.Spatial cognition studies in geoscience.Journal of Remote Sensing,2008,12(2):338.[高俊,龚建华,鲁学军,等.地理信息科学的空间认知研究(专栏引言).遥感学报,2008,12(2):338.]
[5]MacEachren A M,Kraak M J.Research challenges in geovisualization.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2001,28(1):3-12.
[6]Slocum T A,Blok C,Jiang B,et al.Cognitive and usability issues in geovisualization.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2001,28(1):61-75.
[7]Zhu Guorui,Wang Jianhua.Discussions on related issues of modern cartographic analysis.Acta Geodaetica et Cartographica Sinica,1995,24(1):77-79.[祝国瑞,王建华.现代地图分析有关问题的探讨.测绘学报,1995,24(1):77-79.]
[8]Gao Jun.Spatial Cognition of maps and cognitive cartography//Chinese Yearbook of Cartography.Beijing:SinoMaps,1991:23.[高俊.地图的空间认知与认知地图学.中国地图学年鉴.北京:中国地图出版社,1991:23.]
[9]Bertin J.Semiology of Graphics:Diagrams,Networks,Maps.Madison:University of Wisconsin Press,1983.
[10]Kolá?nyA.Cartographic information:A fundamental concept and term in modern cartography.The Cartographic Journal,1969,6(1):47-49.
[11]Goldberg J H,Stimson M J,Lewenstein M M,et al.Eye tracking in web search tasks:Design implications//Proceedings of the 2002 Symposium on Eye Tracking Research&Applications.New Orleans,LA,USA:New York:ACM,2002.
[12]Cavanagh P.Visual cognition.Vision Research,2011,51(13):1538-1551.
[13]Yarbus A L,Haigh B,Rigss L A.Eye Movements and Vision.New York:Plenum Press,1967.
[14]Rayner K.Eye movements and attention in reading,scene perception,and visual search.The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,2009,62(8):1457-1506.
[15]Steinke T R.Eye movement studies in cartography and related fields.Cartographica:The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization,1987,24(2):40-73.
[16]Wang S,Chen Y,Yuan Y,et al.Visualizing the intellectual structure of eye movement research in cartography.ISPRSInternational Journal of Geo-Information,2016,5(10):1-22.
[17]Roth R E,??ltekin A,Delazari L,et al.User studies in cartography:Opportunities for empirical research on interactive maps and visualizations.International Journal of Cartography,2017:1-29.
[18]Franke C,Schweikart J.Mental representation of landmarks on maps:Investigating cartographic visualization methods with eye tracking technology.Spatial Cognition&Computation,2017,17(1/2):20-38.
[19]Wiener J M,H?lscher C,Büchner S,et al.Gaze behaviour during space perception and spatial decision making.Psychological Research,2012,76(6):713-729.
[20]Liao H,Wang X,Dong W,et al.Measuring the influence of map label density on perceived complexity:A user study using eye tracking.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2018:1-19.
[21]Gao Xueyuan,Dong Weihua,Tong Yiyi,et al.Study on the influence of field cognitive style,gender and spatial terminology on geographical spatial orientation ability:Based on experiments in virtual space.Journal of Geoinformation Science,2016,18(11):1513-1521.[高雪原,董卫华,童依依,等.场认知方式,性别和惯用空间语对地理空间定向能力影响的实验研究.地球信息科学学报,2016,18(11):1513-1521.]
[22]Nielsen J.Usability Engineering.San Francisco,CA:Morgan Kaufmann,1993.
[23]Manson S M,Kne L,Dyke K R,et al.Using eye-tracking and mouse metrics to test usability of web mapping navigation.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2012,39(1):48-60.
[24]Montello D,Sutton P.An Introduction to Scientific Research Methods in Geography and Environmental Studies.Thousand Oaks,CA:SAGE Publications,2012.
[25]Fabrikant S I,Hespanha S R,Hegarty M.Cognitively inspired and perceptually salient graphic displays for efficient spatial inference making.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,2010,100(1):13-29.
[26]Ooms K,De Maeyer P,Fack V.Study of the attentive behavior of novice and expert map users using eye tracking.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2014,41(1):37-54.
[27]Liao H,Dong W.An exploratory study investigating gender effects on using 3D maps for spatial orientation in wayfinding.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2017,6(3):1-19.
[28]Deng Yibo,Wang Yusheng,Wang Junchao,et al.Research on the location of the legend based on eye-movement tracking.Geomatics&Spatial Information Technology,2012,35(10):201-204.[邓毅博,王雨生,王俊超,等.地图图例位置的眼动实验研究.测绘与空间地理信息,2012,35(10):201-204.]
[29]Rayner K.Eye movements in reading and information processing:20 years of research.Psychological Bulletin,1998,124(3):372-422.
[30]Matin E.Saccadic suppression:A review and an analysis.Psychological Bulletin,1974,81(12):899.
[31]Chi C F,Lin Y H,Lan W S.Measurement of information processing load and visual load on a dynamic information processing task.Behaviour&Information Technology,2003,22(5):365-374.
[32]Goldberg J H,Kotval X P.Computer interface evaluation using eye movements:Methods and constructs.International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics,1999,24(6):631-645.
[33]Jacob R J,Karn K S.Eye tracking in human-computer interaction and usability research:Ready to deliver the promises.Mind,2003,2(3):573-605.
[34]Poole A,Ball L J.Eye tracking in HCI and usability research//Encyclopedia of Human Computer Interaction,2006:211-219.
[35]Li Wei,Chen Yufen,Cartography eye movements study and experimental parameter analysis.Bulletin of Surveying and Mapping,2012(10):16-20.[李伟,陈毓芬,地图学眼动研究及实验参数解析.测绘通报,2012(10):16-20.]
[36]Just M A,Carpenter P A.Eye fixations and cognitive processes.Cognitive Psychology,1976,8(4):441-480.
[37]Andrienko G,Andrienko N,Burch M,et al.Visual analytics methodology for eye movement studies.IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics,2012,18(12):2889-2898.
[38]Ooms K,Andrienko G,Andrienko N,et al.Analysing the spatial dimension of eye movement data using a visual analytic approach.Expert Systems with Applications,2012,39(1):1324-1332.
[39]H?gerstrand.Spatial Process.Chicago:University of Chicago,1967.
[40]Li X,C?ltekin A,Kraak M J.Visual exploration of eye movement data using the space-time-cube//Fabrikant S I.Geographic Information Science.Springer:Berlin Heidelberg,2010:295-309.
[41]Dong W,Liao H,Roth R E,et al.Eye tracking to explore the potential of enhanced imagery basemaps in web mapping.The Cartographic Journal,2014,51(4):313-329.
[42]Ooms K,Maeyer P D,Fack V,et al.Investigating the effectiveness of an efficient label placement method using eye movement data.The Cartographic Journal,2012,49(3):234-246.
[43]Brychtova A,Coltekin A.An empirical user study for measuring the influence of colour distance and font size in map reading using eye tracking.The Cartographic Journal,2016,43(3):202-212.
[44]Dong W,Wang S,Chen Y,et al.Using eye tracking to evaluate the usability of flow maps.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2018,7(7):281.
[45]??ltekin A,BrychtováA,Griffin A L,et al.Perceptual complexity of soil-landscape maps:A user evaluation of color organization in legend designs using eye tracking.International Journal of Digital Earth,2017,10(6):560-581.
[46]C?ltekin A,Heil B,Garlandini S,et al.Evaluating the effectiveness of interactive map interface designs:A case study integrating usability metrics with eye-movement analysis.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2009,36(1):5-17.
[47]Wolfe J M,Horowitz T S.What attributes guide the deployment of visual attention and how do they do it?Nature Reviews Neuroscience,2004,5(6):495-501.
[48]Garlandini S,Fabrikant S I.Evaluating the effectiveness and efficiency of visual variables for geographic information visualization//Hornsby K S,et al.Spatial Information Theory.Springer:Berlin Heidelberg,2009:195-211.
[49]Dong W,Liao H,Xu F,et al.Using eye tracking to evaluate the usability of animated maps.Science China Earth Sciences,2014,57(3):512-522.
[50]Dong W,Ran J,Wang J.Effectiveness and efficiency of map symbols for dynamic geographic information visualization.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2012,39(2):98-106.
[51]Ooms K,Coltekin A,De Maeyer P,et al.Combining user logging with eye tracking for interactive and dynamic applications.Behavior Research Methods,2015,47(4):977-993.
[52]G?bel F,Kiefer P,Raubal M.FeaturEyeTrack:A vector tile-based eye tracking framework for interactive maps//Societal Geo-Innovation:Short Papers,Posters and Poster Abstracts of the 20th AGILE Conference on Geographic Information Science.Wageningen,the Netherlands:Association of Geographic Information Laboratories for Europe(AGILE),2017.
[53]Kiefer P,Giannopoulos I,Raubal M,et al.Eye tracking for spatial research:Cognition,computation,challenges.Spatial Cognition&Computation,2017,17(1/2):1-19.
[54]Lobben A K.Tasks,strategies,and cognitive processes associated with navigational map reading:A review perspective.The Professional Geographer,2004,56(2):270-281.
[55]Montello D R.Navigation//Shah P,Miyake A.The Cambridge Handbook of Visuospatial Thinking.New York:Cambridge University Press,2005:257-294.
[56]Koletsis E,Elzakker C P J M,Kraak M J,et al.An investigation into challenges experienced when route planning,navigating and wayfinding.International Journal of Cartography,2017,3(1):4-18.
[57]Spiers H J,Maguire E A.The dynamic nature of cognition during wayfinding.Journal of Environmental Psychology,2008,28(3):232-249.
[58]Lin C T,Huang T Y,Lin W J,et al.Gender differences in wayfinding in virtual environments with global or local landmarks.Journal of Environmental Psychology,2012,32(32):89-96.
[59]Steck S D,Mallot H A.The role of global and local landmarks in virtual environment navigation.Presence:Teleoperators&Virtual Environments,2000,9(1):69-83.
[60]Liao H,Dong W,Peng C,et al.Exploring differences of visual attention in pedestrian navigation when using 2D maps and 3D geo-browsers.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2017,44(6):474-490.
[61]Richardson A E,Montello D R,Hegarty M.Spatial knowledge acquisition from maps and from navigation in real and virtual environments.Memory&Cognition,1999,27(4):741-750.
[62]Wenczel F,Hepperle L,von Stülpnagel R.Gaze behavior during incidental and intentional navigation in an outdoor environment.Spatial Cognition&Computation,2017,17(1/2):121-142.
[63]Emo B.Seeing the axial line:Evidence from wayfinding experiments.Behavioral Sciences,2014,4(3):167-180.
[64]Foulsham T,Walker E,Kingstone A.The where,what and when of gaze allocation in the lab and the natural environment.Vision Research,2011,51(17):1920-1931.
[65]Yang Feng,Li Shijian.Wearable computing.Bulletin of China Compute Federation,2014,10(1):76-81.[杨峰,李石坚,穿戴式计算.中国计算机学会通讯,2014,10(1):76-81.]
[66]Kiefer P,Giannopoulos I,Raubal M.Where am I?Investigating map matching during self‐localization with mobile eye tracking in an urban environment.Transactions in GIS,2014,18(5):660-686.
[67]Ohm C,Müller M,Ludwig B,Evaluating indoor pedestrian navigation interfaces using mobile eye tracking.Spatial Cognition&Computation,2017,17(1/2):89-120.
[68]Wang C,Chen Y,Zheng S,et al.Gender and age differences in using indoor maps for wayfinding in real environments.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2018,8(1):11.
[69]Evans K M,Jacobs R A,Tarduno J A,et al.Collecting and analyzing eye-tracking data in outdoor environments.Journal of Eye Movement Research,2012,5(2):1-19.
[70]Brügger A,Richter K F,Fabrikant S I.Which egocentric direction suffers from visual attention during aided wayfinding?//Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop Eye Tracking for Spatial Research.Zurich,Switzerland ETH Zurich,2018.
[71]SMI.BeGaze Manual Version 3.7.2017.Available from:www.humre.vu.lt/files/doc/Instrukcijos/SMI/BeGaze2.pdf.
[72]Beugher S D,Br?ne G,GoedeméT.Automatic analysis of in-the-wild mobile eye-tracking experiments using object,face and person detection//2014 International Conference on Computer Vision Theory and Applications(VISAPP).Lisbon,Portugal,2014.
[73]Anagnostopoulos V,Havlena M,Kiefer P,et al.Gaze-informed location-based services.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,2017,31(9):1770-1797.
[74]Robinson A H,Morrison J L,Muehrcke P C,et al.Elements of Cartography.6th ed.NJ,USA:John Wiley&Sons,1995:688.
[75]Shepherd I D.Travails in the third dimension:a critical evaluation of three-dimensional geographical visualization//Dodge M,McDerby M,Turner M.Geographic Visualization:Concepts,Tools and Applications.Chichester,UK:John Wiley&Sons,2008:199-222.
[76]H?berling C,B?r H,Hurni L.Proposed cartographic design principles for 3D maps:A contribution to an extended cartographic theory.Cartographica:The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization,2008,43(3):175-188.
[77]Xu Zhiyong,Ai Tinghua,Wei Yongjun,et al.On visual variables of 3D map symbol.Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University,2006,31(6):557-560.[徐智勇,艾廷华,危拥军,等.三维地图符号视觉参量研究.武汉大学学报:信息科学版,2006,31(6):557-560.]
[78]Yang Nai.Study on several issues of 3D map design based on spatial cognition[D].Wuhan:Wuhan University,2010.[杨乃.基于空间认知的三维地图设计若干问题的研究[D].武汉:武汉大学,2010.]
[79]Liu Bing,Dong Weihua,Wang Yanwen,et al.The Influence of FOV and viewing angle on the visual information processing of 3D maps.Journal of Geo-information Science,2015,17(12):1490-1496.[刘兵,董卫华,王彦文,等.视场角与观察角度对三维地图视觉信息加工的影响研究.地球信息科学学报,2015,17(12):1490-1496.]
[80]Liu B,Dong W,Meng L.Using eye tracking to explore the guidance and constancy of visual variables in 3Dvisualization.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2017,6(9):1-18.
[81]Popelka S,Dole?alováJ.Non-photorealistic 3D visualization in city maps:An eye-tracking study//Brus J,Vondrakova A,Vozenilek V.Modern Trends in Cartography.Berlin Heidelberg:Springer,2015:357-367.
[82]Lokka I E,??ltekin A.A virtual reality experiment for improving the navigational recall:What can we learn from eye movements of high-and low-performing individuals?//Eye Tracking for Spatial Research,Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop 2018.ETH Zurich.
[83]Lei T C,Wu S C,Chao C W,et al.Evaluating differences in spatial visual attention in wayfinding strategy when using2D and 3D electronic maps.GeoJournal,2016,81(2):153-167.
[84]Lokka I E,??ltekin A,Wiener J,et al.Virtual environments as memory training devices in navigational tasks for older adults.Scientific Reports,2018,8:1-15.
[85]JSTV.Yu Zhan:Super brain challenge of matching coutour maps to real mountain images[OL/EB].2017.Available from:http://v.jstv.com/a/20170113/1484317946746.shtml.[江苏卫视.于湛:挑战项目一眼辨山.2017.Available from:http://v.jstv.com/a/20170113/1484317946746.shtml.]
[86]Ooms K,De Maeyer P,Fack V,et al.Interpreting maps through the eyes of expert and novice users.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,2012,26(10):1773-1788.
[87]Lawton C A.Gender,spatial abilities,and wayfindin//Chrisler J C,McCreary D R.Handbook of Gender Research in Psychology.Berlin Heidelberg:Springer,2010:317-341.
[88]Coluccia E,Iosue G,Brandimonte M A.The relationship between map drawing and spatial orientation abilities:A study of gender differences.Journal of Environmental Psychology,2007,27(2):135-144.
[89]C?ltekin A,Fabrikant S I,Lacayo M.Exploring the efficiency of users'visual analytics strategies based on sequence analysis of eye movement recordings.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,2010,24(10):1559-1575.
[90]Dong W,Zheng L,Liu B,et al.Using eye tracking to explore differences in map-based spatial ability between geographers and non-geographers.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2018,7(9):337.
[91]Zheng Shulei,Yang Chunlei,Li Ying,et al.Research on map user cluster anslysis and discriminant analysis.Geomatics&Spatial Information Technology,2015,38(4):14-16.[郑束蕾,杨春雷,李瑛,等.基于聚类分析和判别分析的地图用户分类研究.测绘与空间地理信息,2015,38(4):14-16.]
[92]Zheng Shulei.Research on personalized map cognition mechanism[D].Zhengzhou:PLA Information Engineering Universit.[郑束蕾.个性化地图的认知机理研究[D].郑州:解放军信息工程大学,2015.]
[93]Dong W,Ying Q,Yang Y,et al.Using eye tracking to explore the impacts of geography courses on map-based spatial ability.Sustainability,2018,11(1):76.
[94]Dong W,Jiang Y,Zheng L,et al.Assessing map-reading skills using eye tracking and Bayesian structural equation modelling.Sustainability,2018,10(9):1-13.
[95]Giannopoulos I,Kiefer P,Raubal M.GazeNav:Gaze-based pedestrian navigation//Boring S,et al.Proceedings of the17th International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction with Mobile Devices and Services,New York:ACM:Copenhagen,Denmark,2015:337-346.
[96]Giannopoulos I,Kiefer P,Raubal M.GeoGazemarks:Providing gaze history for the orientation on small display maps//Morency L-P,Bohus D,Aghajan H.Proceedings of the 14th ACM International Conference on Multimodal Interaction.New York:ACM:SantaMonica,California,USA,2012:165-172.
[97]Kluge M,Asche H.Validating a smartphone-based pedestrian navigation system prototype//Computational Science and Its Applications-ICCSA 2012.Springer,2012:386-396.
[98]Gkonos C,Giannopoulos I,Raubal M.Maps,vibration or gaze?Comparison of novel navigation assistance in indoor and outdoor environments.Journal of Location Based Services,2017:1-21.
[99]Ohm C,Müller M,Ludwig B,et al.Where is the landmark?Eye tracking studies in large-scale indoor environments//Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Eye Tracking for Spatial Research(in conjunction with GIScience2014).Vienna,Austria,2014.
[100]Lander C,Wiehr F,Herbig N,et al.Inferring landmarks for pedestrian navigation from mobile eye-tracking data and Google street view//Proceedings of the 2017 CHI Conference Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems.Denver,CO,USA:New York:ACM,2017.
[101]Viaene P,Vansteenkiste P,Lenoir M,et al.Examining the validity of the total dwell time of eye fixations to identify landmarks in a building.Journal of Eye Movement Research,2016,9(3):1-11.
[102]Zhi Meixia.Landmark visual salience model based on eye tracking experiment[D].Zhengzhou:PLA Information Engineering University,2017.[智梅霞.基于眼动追踪的城市建筑物地标视觉显著度模型构建[D].郑州:解放军信息工程大学,2017.]
[103]Wang Chengshun,Chen Yufen,Zheng Shulei.User interest analysis method of web map point symbol considering eye movement data.Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University,2018(9):1429-1437.[王成舜,陈毓芬,郑束蕾.顾及眼动数据的网络地图点状符号用户兴趣分析方法.武汉大学学报:信息科学版,2018(9):1429-1437.]
[104]Burch M,Kurzhals K,Weiskopf D.Visual task solution strategies in public transport maps//Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Eye Tracking for Spatial Research(in conjunction with GIScience 2014).Vienna,Austria,2014.
[105]Kiefer P,Giannopoulos I,Raubal M.Using eye movements to recognize activities on cartographic maps//Acm Sigspatial International Conference on Advances in Geographic Information Systems.Orlando,FL,USA:New York:ACM,2013.
[106]Liao H,Dong W,Huang H,et al.Inferring user tasks in pedestrian navigation from eye movement data in real-world environments.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,2019,33(4):739-763.
[107]Krejtz K,Duchowski A T,??ltekin,Arzu.High-level gaze metrics from map viewing:Charting ambient/focal visual Attention//Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Eye Tracking for Spatial Research.Vienna,Austria,2014.
[108]Niedomysl T,Elldér E,Larsson A,et al.Learning benefits of using 2D versus 3D maps:Evidence from a randomized controlled experiment.Journal of Geography,2013,112(3):87-96.
[109]Sun Q,Xia J,Nadarajah N,et al.Assessing drivers'visual-motor coordination using eye tracking,GNSS and GIS:Aspatial turn in driving psychology.Journal of Spatial Science,2016,61(2):299-316.
[110]Maggi S,Fabrikant S I..Triangulating eye movement data of animated displays//Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Eye Tracking for Spatial Research(in conjunction with GIScience 2014).Vienna,Austria,2014.
[111]Wang Jiayao,Sun Linan,Cheng Yi.Innovative thinking changes cartography.Geospatial Information,2011,9(2):1-5.[王家耀,孙力楠,成毅.创新思维改变地图学.地理空间信息,2011,9(2):1-5.]
[2]Golledge R G.Human wayfinding and cognitive map//Golledge R G.Wayfinding Behavior:Cognitive Mapping and Other Spatial Processes.Baltimore,MD:The Johns Hopkins University Press,1999:5-45.
[3]Montello D R.Cognitive research in GIScience:Recent achievements and future prospects.Geography Compass,2009.3(5):1824-1840.
[4]Gao Jun,Gong Jianhua,Lu Xuejun,et al.Spatial cognition studies in geoscience.Journal of Remote Sensing,2008,12(2):338.[高俊,龚建华,鲁学军,等.地理信息科学的空间认知研究(专栏引言).遥感学报,2008,12(2):338.]
[5]MacEachren A M,Kraak M J.Research challenges in geovisualization.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2001,28(1):3-12.
[6]Slocum T A,Blok C,Jiang B,et al.Cognitive and usability issues in geovisualization.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2001,28(1):61-75.
[7]Zhu Guorui,Wang Jianhua.Discussions on related issues of modern cartographic analysis.Acta Geodaetica et Cartographica Sinica,1995,24(1):77-79.[祝国瑞,王建华.现代地图分析有关问题的探讨.测绘学报,1995,24(1):77-79.]
[8]Gao Jun.Spatial Cognition of maps and cognitive cartography//Chinese Yearbook of Cartography.Beijing:SinoMaps,1991:23.[高俊.地图的空间认知与认知地图学.中国地图学年鉴.北京:中国地图出版社,1991:23.]
[9]Bertin J.Semiology of Graphics:Diagrams,Networks,Maps.Madison:University of Wisconsin Press,1983.
[10]Kolá?nyA.Cartographic information:A fundamental concept and term in modern cartography.The Cartographic Journal,1969,6(1):47-49.
[11]Goldberg J H,Stimson M J,Lewenstein M M,et al.Eye tracking in web search tasks:Design implications//Proceedings of the 2002 Symposium on Eye Tracking Research&Applications.New Orleans,LA,USA:New York:ACM,2002.
[12]Cavanagh P.Visual cognition.Vision Research,2011,51(13):1538-1551.
[13]Yarbus A L,Haigh B,Rigss L A.Eye Movements and Vision.New York:Plenum Press,1967.
[14]Rayner K.Eye movements and attention in reading,scene perception,and visual search.The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology,2009,62(8):1457-1506.
[15]Steinke T R.Eye movement studies in cartography and related fields.Cartographica:The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization,1987,24(2):40-73.
[16]Wang S,Chen Y,Yuan Y,et al.Visualizing the intellectual structure of eye movement research in cartography.ISPRSInternational Journal of Geo-Information,2016,5(10):1-22.
[17]Roth R E,??ltekin A,Delazari L,et al.User studies in cartography:Opportunities for empirical research on interactive maps and visualizations.International Journal of Cartography,2017:1-29.
[18]Franke C,Schweikart J.Mental representation of landmarks on maps:Investigating cartographic visualization methods with eye tracking technology.Spatial Cognition&Computation,2017,17(1/2):20-38.
[19]Wiener J M,H?lscher C,Büchner S,et al.Gaze behaviour during space perception and spatial decision making.Psychological Research,2012,76(6):713-729.
[20]Liao H,Wang X,Dong W,et al.Measuring the influence of map label density on perceived complexity:A user study using eye tracking.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2018:1-19.
[21]Gao Xueyuan,Dong Weihua,Tong Yiyi,et al.Study on the influence of field cognitive style,gender and spatial terminology on geographical spatial orientation ability:Based on experiments in virtual space.Journal of Geoinformation Science,2016,18(11):1513-1521.[高雪原,董卫华,童依依,等.场认知方式,性别和惯用空间语对地理空间定向能力影响的实验研究.地球信息科学学报,2016,18(11):1513-1521.]
[22]Nielsen J.Usability Engineering.San Francisco,CA:Morgan Kaufmann,1993.
[23]Manson S M,Kne L,Dyke K R,et al.Using eye-tracking and mouse metrics to test usability of web mapping navigation.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2012,39(1):48-60.
[24]Montello D,Sutton P.An Introduction to Scientific Research Methods in Geography and Environmental Studies.Thousand Oaks,CA:SAGE Publications,2012.
[25]Fabrikant S I,Hespanha S R,Hegarty M.Cognitively inspired and perceptually salient graphic displays for efficient spatial inference making.Annals of the Association of American Geographers,2010,100(1):13-29.
[26]Ooms K,De Maeyer P,Fack V.Study of the attentive behavior of novice and expert map users using eye tracking.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2014,41(1):37-54.
[27]Liao H,Dong W.An exploratory study investigating gender effects on using 3D maps for spatial orientation in wayfinding.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2017,6(3):1-19.
[28]Deng Yibo,Wang Yusheng,Wang Junchao,et al.Research on the location of the legend based on eye-movement tracking.Geomatics&Spatial Information Technology,2012,35(10):201-204.[邓毅博,王雨生,王俊超,等.地图图例位置的眼动实验研究.测绘与空间地理信息,2012,35(10):201-204.]
[29]Rayner K.Eye movements in reading and information processing:20 years of research.Psychological Bulletin,1998,124(3):372-422.
[30]Matin E.Saccadic suppression:A review and an analysis.Psychological Bulletin,1974,81(12):899.
[31]Chi C F,Lin Y H,Lan W S.Measurement of information processing load and visual load on a dynamic information processing task.Behaviour&Information Technology,2003,22(5):365-374.
[32]Goldberg J H,Kotval X P.Computer interface evaluation using eye movements:Methods and constructs.International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics,1999,24(6):631-645.
[33]Jacob R J,Karn K S.Eye tracking in human-computer interaction and usability research:Ready to deliver the promises.Mind,2003,2(3):573-605.
[34]Poole A,Ball L J.Eye tracking in HCI and usability research//Encyclopedia of Human Computer Interaction,2006:211-219.
[35]Li Wei,Chen Yufen,Cartography eye movements study and experimental parameter analysis.Bulletin of Surveying and Mapping,2012(10):16-20.[李伟,陈毓芬,地图学眼动研究及实验参数解析.测绘通报,2012(10):16-20.]
[36]Just M A,Carpenter P A.Eye fixations and cognitive processes.Cognitive Psychology,1976,8(4):441-480.
[37]Andrienko G,Andrienko N,Burch M,et al.Visual analytics methodology for eye movement studies.IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics,2012,18(12):2889-2898.
[38]Ooms K,Andrienko G,Andrienko N,et al.Analysing the spatial dimension of eye movement data using a visual analytic approach.Expert Systems with Applications,2012,39(1):1324-1332.
[39]H?gerstrand.Spatial Process.Chicago:University of Chicago,1967.
[40]Li X,C?ltekin A,Kraak M J.Visual exploration of eye movement data using the space-time-cube//Fabrikant S I.Geographic Information Science.Springer:Berlin Heidelberg,2010:295-309.
[41]Dong W,Liao H,Roth R E,et al.Eye tracking to explore the potential of enhanced imagery basemaps in web mapping.The Cartographic Journal,2014,51(4):313-329.
[42]Ooms K,Maeyer P D,Fack V,et al.Investigating the effectiveness of an efficient label placement method using eye movement data.The Cartographic Journal,2012,49(3):234-246.
[43]Brychtova A,Coltekin A.An empirical user study for measuring the influence of colour distance and font size in map reading using eye tracking.The Cartographic Journal,2016,43(3):202-212.
[44]Dong W,Wang S,Chen Y,et al.Using eye tracking to evaluate the usability of flow maps.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2018,7(7):281.
[45]??ltekin A,BrychtováA,Griffin A L,et al.Perceptual complexity of soil-landscape maps:A user evaluation of color organization in legend designs using eye tracking.International Journal of Digital Earth,2017,10(6):560-581.
[46]C?ltekin A,Heil B,Garlandini S,et al.Evaluating the effectiveness of interactive map interface designs:A case study integrating usability metrics with eye-movement analysis.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2009,36(1):5-17.
[47]Wolfe J M,Horowitz T S.What attributes guide the deployment of visual attention and how do they do it?Nature Reviews Neuroscience,2004,5(6):495-501.
[48]Garlandini S,Fabrikant S I.Evaluating the effectiveness and efficiency of visual variables for geographic information visualization//Hornsby K S,et al.Spatial Information Theory.Springer:Berlin Heidelberg,2009:195-211.
[49]Dong W,Liao H,Xu F,et al.Using eye tracking to evaluate the usability of animated maps.Science China Earth Sciences,2014,57(3):512-522.
[50]Dong W,Ran J,Wang J.Effectiveness and efficiency of map symbols for dynamic geographic information visualization.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2012,39(2):98-106.
[51]Ooms K,Coltekin A,De Maeyer P,et al.Combining user logging with eye tracking for interactive and dynamic applications.Behavior Research Methods,2015,47(4):977-993.
[52]G?bel F,Kiefer P,Raubal M.FeaturEyeTrack:A vector tile-based eye tracking framework for interactive maps//Societal Geo-Innovation:Short Papers,Posters and Poster Abstracts of the 20th AGILE Conference on Geographic Information Science.Wageningen,the Netherlands:Association of Geographic Information Laboratories for Europe(AGILE),2017.
[53]Kiefer P,Giannopoulos I,Raubal M,et al.Eye tracking for spatial research:Cognition,computation,challenges.Spatial Cognition&Computation,2017,17(1/2):1-19.
[54]Lobben A K.Tasks,strategies,and cognitive processes associated with navigational map reading:A review perspective.The Professional Geographer,2004,56(2):270-281.
[55]Montello D R.Navigation//Shah P,Miyake A.The Cambridge Handbook of Visuospatial Thinking.New York:Cambridge University Press,2005:257-294.
[56]Koletsis E,Elzakker C P J M,Kraak M J,et al.An investigation into challenges experienced when route planning,navigating and wayfinding.International Journal of Cartography,2017,3(1):4-18.
[57]Spiers H J,Maguire E A.The dynamic nature of cognition during wayfinding.Journal of Environmental Psychology,2008,28(3):232-249.
[58]Lin C T,Huang T Y,Lin W J,et al.Gender differences in wayfinding in virtual environments with global or local landmarks.Journal of Environmental Psychology,2012,32(32):89-96.
[59]Steck S D,Mallot H A.The role of global and local landmarks in virtual environment navigation.Presence:Teleoperators&Virtual Environments,2000,9(1):69-83.
[60]Liao H,Dong W,Peng C,et al.Exploring differences of visual attention in pedestrian navigation when using 2D maps and 3D geo-browsers.Cartography and Geographic Information Science,2017,44(6):474-490.
[61]Richardson A E,Montello D R,Hegarty M.Spatial knowledge acquisition from maps and from navigation in real and virtual environments.Memory&Cognition,1999,27(4):741-750.
[62]Wenczel F,Hepperle L,von Stülpnagel R.Gaze behavior during incidental and intentional navigation in an outdoor environment.Spatial Cognition&Computation,2017,17(1/2):121-142.
[63]Emo B.Seeing the axial line:Evidence from wayfinding experiments.Behavioral Sciences,2014,4(3):167-180.
[64]Foulsham T,Walker E,Kingstone A.The where,what and when of gaze allocation in the lab and the natural environment.Vision Research,2011,51(17):1920-1931.
[65]Yang Feng,Li Shijian.Wearable computing.Bulletin of China Compute Federation,2014,10(1):76-81.[杨峰,李石坚,穿戴式计算.中国计算机学会通讯,2014,10(1):76-81.]
[66]Kiefer P,Giannopoulos I,Raubal M.Where am I?Investigating map matching during self‐localization with mobile eye tracking in an urban environment.Transactions in GIS,2014,18(5):660-686.
[67]Ohm C,Müller M,Ludwig B,Evaluating indoor pedestrian navigation interfaces using mobile eye tracking.Spatial Cognition&Computation,2017,17(1/2):89-120.
[68]Wang C,Chen Y,Zheng S,et al.Gender and age differences in using indoor maps for wayfinding in real environments.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2018,8(1):11.
[69]Evans K M,Jacobs R A,Tarduno J A,et al.Collecting and analyzing eye-tracking data in outdoor environments.Journal of Eye Movement Research,2012,5(2):1-19.
[70]Brügger A,Richter K F,Fabrikant S I.Which egocentric direction suffers from visual attention during aided wayfinding?//Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop Eye Tracking for Spatial Research.Zurich,Switzerland ETH Zurich,2018.
[71]SMI.BeGaze Manual Version 3.7.2017.Available from:www.humre.vu.lt/files/doc/Instrukcijos/SMI/BeGaze2.pdf.
[72]Beugher S D,Br?ne G,GoedeméT.Automatic analysis of in-the-wild mobile eye-tracking experiments using object,face and person detection//2014 International Conference on Computer Vision Theory and Applications(VISAPP).Lisbon,Portugal,2014.
[73]Anagnostopoulos V,Havlena M,Kiefer P,et al.Gaze-informed location-based services.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,2017,31(9):1770-1797.
[74]Robinson A H,Morrison J L,Muehrcke P C,et al.Elements of Cartography.6th ed.NJ,USA:John Wiley&Sons,1995:688.
[75]Shepherd I D.Travails in the third dimension:a critical evaluation of three-dimensional geographical visualization//Dodge M,McDerby M,Turner M.Geographic Visualization:Concepts,Tools and Applications.Chichester,UK:John Wiley&Sons,2008:199-222.
[76]H?berling C,B?r H,Hurni L.Proposed cartographic design principles for 3D maps:A contribution to an extended cartographic theory.Cartographica:The International Journal for Geographic Information and Geovisualization,2008,43(3):175-188.
[77]Xu Zhiyong,Ai Tinghua,Wei Yongjun,et al.On visual variables of 3D map symbol.Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University,2006,31(6):557-560.[徐智勇,艾廷华,危拥军,等.三维地图符号视觉参量研究.武汉大学学报:信息科学版,2006,31(6):557-560.]
[78]Yang Nai.Study on several issues of 3D map design based on spatial cognition[D].Wuhan:Wuhan University,2010.[杨乃.基于空间认知的三维地图设计若干问题的研究[D].武汉:武汉大学,2010.]
[79]Liu Bing,Dong Weihua,Wang Yanwen,et al.The Influence of FOV and viewing angle on the visual information processing of 3D maps.Journal of Geo-information Science,2015,17(12):1490-1496.[刘兵,董卫华,王彦文,等.视场角与观察角度对三维地图视觉信息加工的影响研究.地球信息科学学报,2015,17(12):1490-1496.]
[80]Liu B,Dong W,Meng L.Using eye tracking to explore the guidance and constancy of visual variables in 3Dvisualization.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2017,6(9):1-18.
[81]Popelka S,Dole?alováJ.Non-photorealistic 3D visualization in city maps:An eye-tracking study//Brus J,Vondrakova A,Vozenilek V.Modern Trends in Cartography.Berlin Heidelberg:Springer,2015:357-367.
[82]Lokka I E,??ltekin A.A virtual reality experiment for improving the navigational recall:What can we learn from eye movements of high-and low-performing individuals?//Eye Tracking for Spatial Research,Proceedings of the 3rd International Workshop 2018.ETH Zurich.
[83]Lei T C,Wu S C,Chao C W,et al.Evaluating differences in spatial visual attention in wayfinding strategy when using2D and 3D electronic maps.GeoJournal,2016,81(2):153-167.
[84]Lokka I E,??ltekin A,Wiener J,et al.Virtual environments as memory training devices in navigational tasks for older adults.Scientific Reports,2018,8:1-15.
[85]JSTV.Yu Zhan:Super brain challenge of matching coutour maps to real mountain images[OL/EB].2017.Available from:http://v.jstv.com/a/20170113/1484317946746.shtml.[江苏卫视.于湛:挑战项目一眼辨山.2017.Available from:http://v.jstv.com/a/20170113/1484317946746.shtml.]
[86]Ooms K,De Maeyer P,Fack V,et al.Interpreting maps through the eyes of expert and novice users.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,2012,26(10):1773-1788.
[87]Lawton C A.Gender,spatial abilities,and wayfindin//Chrisler J C,McCreary D R.Handbook of Gender Research in Psychology.Berlin Heidelberg:Springer,2010:317-341.
[88]Coluccia E,Iosue G,Brandimonte M A.The relationship between map drawing and spatial orientation abilities:A study of gender differences.Journal of Environmental Psychology,2007,27(2):135-144.
[89]C?ltekin A,Fabrikant S I,Lacayo M.Exploring the efficiency of users'visual analytics strategies based on sequence analysis of eye movement recordings.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,2010,24(10):1559-1575.
[90]Dong W,Zheng L,Liu B,et al.Using eye tracking to explore differences in map-based spatial ability between geographers and non-geographers.ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information,2018,7(9):337.
[91]Zheng Shulei,Yang Chunlei,Li Ying,et al.Research on map user cluster anslysis and discriminant analysis.Geomatics&Spatial Information Technology,2015,38(4):14-16.[郑束蕾,杨春雷,李瑛,等.基于聚类分析和判别分析的地图用户分类研究.测绘与空间地理信息,2015,38(4):14-16.]
[92]Zheng Shulei.Research on personalized map cognition mechanism[D].Zhengzhou:PLA Information Engineering Universit.[郑束蕾.个性化地图的认知机理研究[D].郑州:解放军信息工程大学,2015.]
[93]Dong W,Ying Q,Yang Y,et al.Using eye tracking to explore the impacts of geography courses on map-based spatial ability.Sustainability,2018,11(1):76.
[94]Dong W,Jiang Y,Zheng L,et al.Assessing map-reading skills using eye tracking and Bayesian structural equation modelling.Sustainability,2018,10(9):1-13.
[95]Giannopoulos I,Kiefer P,Raubal M.GazeNav:Gaze-based pedestrian navigation//Boring S,et al.Proceedings of the17th International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction with Mobile Devices and Services,New York:ACM:Copenhagen,Denmark,2015:337-346.
[96]Giannopoulos I,Kiefer P,Raubal M.GeoGazemarks:Providing gaze history for the orientation on small display maps//Morency L-P,Bohus D,Aghajan H.Proceedings of the 14th ACM International Conference on Multimodal Interaction.New York:ACM:SantaMonica,California,USA,2012:165-172.
[97]Kluge M,Asche H.Validating a smartphone-based pedestrian navigation system prototype//Computational Science and Its Applications-ICCSA 2012.Springer,2012:386-396.
[98]Gkonos C,Giannopoulos I,Raubal M.Maps,vibration or gaze?Comparison of novel navigation assistance in indoor and outdoor environments.Journal of Location Based Services,2017:1-21.
[99]Ohm C,Müller M,Ludwig B,et al.Where is the landmark?Eye tracking studies in large-scale indoor environments//Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Eye Tracking for Spatial Research(in conjunction with GIScience2014).Vienna,Austria,2014.
[100]Lander C,Wiehr F,Herbig N,et al.Inferring landmarks for pedestrian navigation from mobile eye-tracking data and Google street view//Proceedings of the 2017 CHI Conference Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems.Denver,CO,USA:New York:ACM,2017.
[101]Viaene P,Vansteenkiste P,Lenoir M,et al.Examining the validity of the total dwell time of eye fixations to identify landmarks in a building.Journal of Eye Movement Research,2016,9(3):1-11.
[102]Zhi Meixia.Landmark visual salience model based on eye tracking experiment[D].Zhengzhou:PLA Information Engineering University,2017.[智梅霞.基于眼动追踪的城市建筑物地标视觉显著度模型构建[D].郑州:解放军信息工程大学,2017.]
[103]Wang Chengshun,Chen Yufen,Zheng Shulei.User interest analysis method of web map point symbol considering eye movement data.Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University,2018(9):1429-1437.[王成舜,陈毓芬,郑束蕾.顾及眼动数据的网络地图点状符号用户兴趣分析方法.武汉大学学报:信息科学版,2018(9):1429-1437.]
[104]Burch M,Kurzhals K,Weiskopf D.Visual task solution strategies in public transport maps//Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Eye Tracking for Spatial Research(in conjunction with GIScience 2014).Vienna,Austria,2014.
[105]Kiefer P,Giannopoulos I,Raubal M.Using eye movements to recognize activities on cartographic maps//Acm Sigspatial International Conference on Advances in Geographic Information Systems.Orlando,FL,USA:New York:ACM,2013.
[106]Liao H,Dong W,Huang H,et al.Inferring user tasks in pedestrian navigation from eye movement data in real-world environments.International Journal of Geographical Information Science,2019,33(4):739-763.
[107]Krejtz K,Duchowski A T,??ltekin,Arzu.High-level gaze metrics from map viewing:Charting ambient/focal visual Attention//Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Eye Tracking for Spatial Research.Vienna,Austria,2014.
[108]Niedomysl T,Elldér E,Larsson A,et al.Learning benefits of using 2D versus 3D maps:Evidence from a randomized controlled experiment.Journal of Geography,2013,112(3):87-96.
[109]Sun Q,Xia J,Nadarajah N,et al.Assessing drivers'visual-motor coordination using eye tracking,GNSS and GIS:Aspatial turn in driving psychology.Journal of Spatial Science,2016,61(2):299-316.
[110]Maggi S,Fabrikant S I..Triangulating eye movement data of animated displays//Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop on Eye Tracking for Spatial Research(in conjunction with GIScience 2014).Vienna,Austria,2014.
[111]Wang Jiayao,Sun Linan,Cheng Yi.Innovative thinking changes cartography.Geospatial Information,2011,9(2):1-5.[王家耀,孙力楠,成毅.创新思维改变地图学.地理空间信息,2011,9(2):1-5.]