烟剂对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊防效及经济效益与安全性评价
详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |
  • 英文篇名:Efficiency, economic benefit, and safety, of fumigation to control Bradysia odoriphaga (Yang et Zhang) (Diptera: Sciaridae)
  • 作者:徐蕾 ; 赵彤华 ; 许国庆 ; 刘培斌
  • 英文作者:XU Lei;ZHAO Tong-Hua;XU Guo-Qing;LIU Pei-Bin;Institute of Plant Protection, Liaoning Academy of Agricultural Sciences;
  • 关键词:韭菜迟眼蕈蚊 ; 烟剂 ; 温室防效 ; 药剂残留 ; 绿色防控
  • 英文关键词:Bradysia odoriphaga;;smoke agent;;greenhouse control effect;;insecticide residues;;green management
  • 中文刊名:KCZS
  • 英文刊名:Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology
  • 机构:辽宁省农业科学院植物保护研究所;
  • 出版日期:2018-03-26
  • 出版单位:应用昆虫学报
  • 年:2018
  • 期:v.55
  • 基金:国家公益性行业(农业)科研专项(201303027-09)
  • 语种:中文;
  • 页:KCZS201802016
  • 页数:8
  • CN:02
  • ISSN:11-6020/Q
  • 分类号:118-125
摘要
【目的】通过室内与温室试验相结合,综合评价了烟剂对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊Bradysia odoriphaga(Yang et Zhang)的控制效果,为韭蛆的绿色防控提供技术支持。【方法】采用玻璃方箱法测定了敌敌畏烟剂和异丙威烟剂对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊成虫的熏蒸毒力;在温室比较了2种烟剂与生产中普遍使用的毒·辛乳油灌根方法的药效,通过测产并结合投入成本分析了各自取得的经济效益,最后进行药剂的残留检测。【结果】敌敌畏烟剂对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊成虫的熏蒸毒力较强;中剂量敌敌畏烟剂和高剂量异丙威烟剂对成虫的防效分别为96.21%和86.05%,对幼虫的防效分别为97.08%和90.00%,极显著高于毒·辛乳油灌根处理(77.36%,P<0.01),分别实现增产41.71%和30.75%,新增总收益分别达到20 507.94元/hm~2和15 118.28元/hm~2,投入产出比分别为1∶16.28和1∶10.33。经检测,韭菜样本在检出限内无敌敌畏残留,而用药15 d后异丙威残留量为0.186 mg/kg,低于最大残留限量标准。【结论】烟剂熏蒸是比较理想的韭菜迟眼蕈蚊绿色防控手段,生产上可选用敌敌畏烟剂和异丙威烟剂。
        [Objectives] To provide a practical method for controlling the Chinese chive maggot, Bradysia odoriphaga. [Methods] The efficiency of using fumigation to control the Chinese chive maggot, Bradysia odoriphaga, was evaluated comprehensively in laboratory bioassays and greenhouse experiments. The toxicity of dichlorvos FU and isoprocarb FU to B. odoriphaga adults was measured in a glass chamber. The control efficiency of these two kinds of fumigants and chlorpyrifos-phoxim EC were compared using plot tests in a greenhouse, and the relative economic benefit of the three fumigants was analyzed by estimating yield in relation to cost. Finally, residues of the various fumigants used were measured and compared. [Results] Dichlorvos FU was the most toxic of the fumigants tested to B. odoriphaga adults. The results of greenhouse experiments show that the control efficiency of a medium dosage of 15% dichlorvos FU and a high dosage of 10% isoprocarb FU was up to 96.21% and 86.05%, respectively. The control efficiency of these pesticides against larvae was up to 97.08% and 90.00%, respectively, significantly higher than that of 20% chlorpyrifos-phoxim EC(P<0.01). Moreover, 15% dichlorvos FU and 10% isoprocarb FU increased yield by 41.71% and 30.75%, respectively, gave financial returns of 20 507.94 Yuan/hm~2 and 15 118.28 Yuan/hm~2, respectively, and had input-output ratios of 1︰ 16.28 and 1︰10.33, respectively. Rigorous monitoring found that any dichlorvos residues in Chinese chive samples were below the limit of detection. The isoprocarb residue after 15 days was 0.186 mg/kg, which is below the MRL standard. [Conclusion] Fumigation was an effective, environmentally friendly way of controlling B. odoriphaga. Dichlorvos FU and isoprocarb FU are recommended for controlling this pest in Chinese chive crops.
引文
Abbott WS,1925.A method of computing the effectiveness of an insecticide.Journal of Economic Entomology,3(2):302-303.
    An LN,Zhao X,Dong LX,Lu WY,Dong JZ,Wei GS,2014.Bioactivity and safety evaluation of veratrine 0.5%SL against Bradysia odoriphaga.Agrochemicals,53(12):924-926.[安立娜,赵鑫,董立新,路文雅,董建臻,魏国树,2014.0.5%藜芦碱可溶液剂对韭蛆的生物活性及安全性评价.农药,53(12):924-926.]
    Bezemer TM,Jones TH,1998.Plant-insect herbivore interactions in elevated atmospheric CO2:quantitative analyses and guild effects.Oikos,82(2):212-222.
    Bryant JP,Chapin FS,Klein DR,1983.Carbon/nutrient balance of boreal plants in relation to vertebrate herbivory.Oikos,40(3):357-368.
    Cui XQ,Zhang Q,Jiang H,Lin RH,Wang KY,2012.Acute toxicity evaluation of neonicotinoid insecticides to Bombyx mori and observation of toxic symptoms.Science of Sericulture,38(2):288-291.[崔新倩,张骞,姜辉,林荣华,王开运,2012.新烟碱类杀虫剂对家蚕的急性毒性评价与中毒症状观察.蚕业科学,38(2):288-291.]
    Ding XH,Liu FH,Xie YM,Li CM,He J,Fu KY,Tuerxun,Abdurahman H,Abdureyim A,Xu JJ,Guo WC,2016.Studies on control effect of Asia corn borer,Pyrausta nubilalis Guenee in fields and economic benefit evaluation in Xinjiang desert and oasis ecological zone.Xinjiang Agricultural Sciences,53(4):663-672.[丁新华,刘芳慧,解玉梅,李翠梅,何江,付开赟,吐尔逊,阿不都热合曼·胡吉,阿卜杜热伊木·阿卜杜热西提,许建军,郭文超,2016.新疆荒漠绿洲生态区玉米螟田间药效研究及经济效益评价.新疆农业科学,53(4):663-672.]
    Dong LY,Li SG,Xia W,Liu BC,Zhu ZY,2004.Controlling effect of chlorpyrifos 40%EC against Chinese chive maggot.Northern Horticulture,(3):84-85.[董立元,李顺高,夏伟,刘宝传,朱志英,2004.40%毒死蜱乳油防治韭菜韭蛆药效试验.北方园艺,(3):84-85.]
    Fairbrother A,Purdy J,Anderson T,Fell R,2014.Risks of neonicotinoid insecticides to honeybees.Environmental Toxicology&Chemistry,33(4):719-731.
    Finney DJ,1971.Probit Analysis(3nd edition).Cambridge,England:Cambridge University Press.9-158.
    Hassani AKE,Dacher M,Gary V,Lambin M,Gauthier M,Armengaud C,2008.Effects of sublethal doses of acetamiprid and thiamethoxam on the behavior of the honeybee(Apis mellifera).Archives Environment Contamination Toxicology,54(4):653-661.
    Li H,Zhao YH,Wang QH,Liu F,Mu W,2016.Toxic characters and toxicity of hexaflumuron against Bradysia odoriphaga Yang et Zhang(Diptera:Sciaridae)at different developmental stages.Journal of Plant Protection,43(4):670-676.[李慧,赵云贺,王秋红,刘峰,慕卫,2016.氟铃脲对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊不同虫态的致毒特点及毒力.植物保护学报,43(4):670-676.]
    Li NN,Yang JP,2012.Toxicity determination of botanical pesticide to larvae of Bradysia odoriphaga Yang et Zhang in laboratory and its control effect in fields.Shandong Agricultural Sciences,44(7):101-103.[李娜娜,杨建平,2012.植物源农药对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊幼虫的室内毒力测定和田间防治效果.山东农业科学,44(7):101-103.]
    Li PC,Sun GW,1989.Development and application of forestry smoke agent in China.Forestry Science&Technology,(1):23-25.[李谱超,孙国文,1989.我国林用烟剂的研制及应用.林业科技,(1):23-25.]
    Li XX,Ma XD,Xue M,Zhao HP,Li ZX,2014.Toxic effects of clothianidin and other five kinds of insecticides to Bradysia odoriphaga.Acta Phytophylacica Sinica,41(2):225-229.[李贤贤,马晓丹,薛明,赵海鹏,李朝霞,2014.噻虫胺等药剂对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊的致毒效应.植物保护学报,41(2):225-229.]
    Ma XD,Xue M,Li ZX,Zhao HP,Ji GX,2015.Toxic effects of five insect growth regulators on chive gnat Bradysia odoriphaga.Journal of Plant Protection,42(2):271-277.[马晓丹,薛明,李朝霞,赵海朋,纪桂霞,2015.五种昆虫生长调节剂对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊的致毒作用.植物保护学报,42(2):271-277.]
    Penuelas J,Castells E,Joffre R,Tognetti R,2002.Carbon-based secondary and structural compounds in mediterranean shrubs growing near a natural CO2 spring.Global Change Biology,8(3):281-288.
    Song D,Li CR,Jia CH,Zhu XD,He M,2016.Pesticide residues and food safety of five organophosphorus pesticides used on chinese chives.Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology,53(6):1255-1260.[宋丹,李传仁,贾春虹,朱晓丹,贺敏,2016.韭菜上五种有机磷农药的残留监测与安全性评价.应用昆虫学报,53(6):1255-1260.]
    Wang HT,Liu XQ,Wang LL,Wang YZ,2014.Control efficacy of chlorpyrifos 0.5%mixed preparation of pesticide and fertilizer on Bradysia odoriphaga in field.Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences,42(17):5463-5464,5536.[王洪涛,刘学卿,王丽丽,王英姿,2014.0.5%毒死蜱药肥混剂对韭蛆的田间防治效果.安徽农业科学,42(17):5463-5464,5536.]
    Wang P,Qin YC,Pan PL,Li PY,2011.The analysis of the volatile component from the sugar-acetic acid-ethanol water solutions and their trapping effects on Bradysia odoriphaga.Acta Phytophylacica Sinica,38(6):513-520.[王萍,秦玉川,潘鹏亮,李鹏燕,2011.糖醋酒液对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊的诱杀效果及其挥发物活性成分分析.植物保护学报,38(6):513-520.]
    Wang ZX,Fan F,Wang ZY,Han YH,Yang XF,Wei GS,2015.Effects of environmental color on biological characteristics of Bradysia odoriphaga(Diptera:Sciaridae).Acta Entomologica Sinica,58(5):553-558.[王占霞,范凡,王忠燕,韩艳华,杨小凡,魏国树,2015.环境颜色对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊生物学特性的影响.昆虫学报,58(5):553-558.]
    Wu QJ,Yu Y,Gu XS,Liu F,Song DL,Wer GS,He M,Liu CZ,Xu GQ,Zhang YJ,2016.The occurrence of,and damage caused by,root maggots on Chinese chives and integrated management techniques to control these pests.Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology,53(6):1165-1173.[吴青君,于毅,谷希树,刘峰,宋敦伦,魏国树,贺敏,刘长仲,许国庆,张友军,2016.韭菜根蛆的发生危害及综合防治技术研究.应用昆虫学报,53(6):1165-1173.]
    Xu L,Zhao JQ,Xu GQ,Zhong T,Zhao TH,2015.Artificial induction of sexuales in Aphis glycines(Hemiptera:Aphididae).Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology,52(6):1429-1437.[徐蕾,赵季秋,许国庆,钟涛,赵彤华,2015.室内人工诱导大豆蚜产生有性世代的研究.应用昆虫学报,52(6):1429-1437.]
    Xu L,Zhao TH,Liu PB,Zhong T,Wang Z,Xu GQ,2016a.Olfactory behavioral responses of Bradysia odoriphaga.Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology,53(6):1329-1337.[徐蕾,赵彤华,刘培斌,钟涛,王哲,许国庆,2016a.韭菜迟眼蕈蚊Bradysia odoriphaga嗅觉行为反应.应用昆虫学报,53(6):1329-1337.]
    Xu L,Zhao TH,Liu PB,Zhong T,Wang Z,Xu GQ,2016b.Effects of temperature on development of Bradysia odoriphaga(Yang et Zhang).Liaoning Agricultural Sciences,(5):84-85.[徐蕾,赵彤华,刘培斌,钟涛,王哲,许国庆,2016b.温度对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊发育的影响.辽宁农业科学,(5):84-85.]
    Yang TT,2004.The application technique of smoke generator in greenhouse vegetables.Journal of Changjiang Vegetables,(2):30-31.[杨田堂,2004.烟剂农药在棚室蔬菜上的应用技术.长江蔬菜,(2):30-31.]
    Yao HR,1963.Prevention and control of agricultural diseases and insect pests by using smoke agents.Scientia Agricultura Sinica,4(3):32-35.[姚浩然,1963.利用烟剂防治农业病虫害的问题.中国农业科学,4(3):32-35.]
    Zhang JT,Xiong GH,He JG,Xu Y,Wei LX,Peng YH,2016.Fumigation activities of three essential oils against adult Musca domestica(Diptera:Muscidae).Acta Entomologica Sinica,59(6):641-646.[张俊天,熊国红,何建国,徐颖,魏丽秀,彭映辉,2016.三种植物精油对家蝇成虫的熏蒸活性.昆虫学报,59(6):641-646.]
    Zhang M,Lv AQ,Chen ZF,Li JJ,Ma PF,Li XX,Wang HP,2016.The current situation and strategies of chive germplasm development research in China.Journal of Plant Genetic Resources,17(3):503-506.[张明,吕爱琴,陈中府,李纪军,马培芳,李锡香,王海平,2016.我国韭菜资源研究现状和种质创新研究建议.植物遗传资源学报,17(3):503-506.]
    Zhang P,Liu F,Mu W,Wang QH,Li H,Chen CY,2014.Life table study of the effects of sublethal concentrations of thiamethoxam on Bradysia odoriphaga Yang and Zhang.Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology,111(1):31-37.
    Zhang P,Mu W,Liu F,He M,Luo MM,2015a.Adsorption and leaching of thiamethoxam in soil.Environmental Chemistry,34(4):705-711.[张鹏,慕卫,刘峰,贺敏,罗梅梅,2015a.噻虫嗪在土壤中的吸附和淋溶特性.环境化学,34(4):705-711.]
    Zhang P,Zhao YH,Han JK,Zhai YB,Mu W,Liu F,2015b.Control effects of thiamethoxam and clothianidin against Bradysia odoriphaga with different application methods.Journal of Plant Protection,42(4):645-650.[张鹏,赵云贺,韩京坤,翟永彪,幕卫,刘峰,2015b.不同施药方式下噻虫嗪和噻虫胺对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊的防治效果.植物保护学报,42(4):645-650.]
    Zhou FY,Zhu GD,Zhao HP,Wang Z,Xue M,Li XX,Xu HQ,Ma XD,Liu YY,2016.Sterilization effects of adult-targeted baits containing insect growth regulators on Delia antiqua.Scientific Reports,(6):32855.
    Zhu GD,Ma XD,Xue M,Ji GX,Luo Y,Sun X,2016.Toxicity of botanic insecticide to Bradysia odoriphaga larvae and application value assessment.Northern Horticulture,(22):135-139.[祝国栋,马晓丹,薛明,纪桂霞,罗茵,孙夏,2016.植物源杀虫剂对韭菜迟眼蕈蚊幼虫毒力及应用价值评价.北方园艺,(22):135-139.]
    Zhuang QY,Zhang SC,Zhai YF,Yu Y,Zhou XH,2015.Control efficiency of different types and formulation of insecticide against Bradysia odoriphaga Yang et Zhang.China Plant Protection,35(3):78-80.[庄乾营,张思聪,翟一凡,于毅,周仙红,2015.不同农药种类及剂型防治韭菜迟眼蕈蚊效果比较.中国植保导刊,35(3):78-80.]

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700