南海军事化问题论析
|
摘要
军事化的概念既表现为一个国家在某些内政外交等事务上增强军事属性的过程,也体现为军事要素影响国家间关系的作用在增强的过程。军事化与军国主义、安全化和武器化等概念存在着联系,但也具有较大区别,反映出国家为应对安全困境而增强软硬基础设施的态势与趋势,存在着全球性、地区性和国家性3个层次。由于在理论假定和概念阐释上存在着一定的局限性和灰色区域,军事化如何以及能否在实践操作中被正确和准确使用会存在较大困难。近年来,中美关于南海军事化问题在概念界定、责任归属、程度强弱与合法性等方面存在着巨大分歧,并在行动中具有爆发低烈度冲突的风险。从趋势上看,南海军事化问题还存在着主动性与被动性、防御性与进攻性、建设性与破坏性以及适度与过度等方面的争议,体现了相关国家之间在法律和战略上的博弈进程。对此,中国有必要采取更加积极主动的政策和措施,减弱其他方推进南海军事化问题的法律和战略基础,增强在南海地区进行必要建设的可能性。
The concept of militarization is not only a process in which a country enhances its military attributes in some internal or external affairs,but also a process of the enhanced role of military elements affecting relations between countries.The concept of militarization,with global,regional and national level,reflects the situation and trend of a country to strengthen its soft and hard infrastructures in response to security dilemmas. It has convergences and divergences with militarism,securitization and weaponization. Due to certain limitations and grey area in theoretical assumptions and conceptual interpretations,there are some difficulties of militarization to be correctly and accurately implemented in practice. In recent years,there have been great differences between China and the United States about the militarization of the South China Sea issue in terms of definition,responsibility,intensity and legitimacy,and there is a risk of a low-intensity conflict in action.Judging from the past,there're other disputes on the South China Sea issue,such as initiative and passivity,defensiveness and offensiveness,constructiveness and destructiveness,and moderation and excessiveness,which reflects the legal and strategic competition between the countries concerned. In this regard,it is necessary for China to adopt more proactive policies and measures to weaken the legal and strategic basis of the other parties to promote the militarization of the South China Sea issue,and enhance the possibility of carrying out the necessary construction in the South China Sea.
The concept of militarization is not only a process in which a country enhances its military attributes in some internal or external affairs,but also a process of the enhanced role of military elements affecting relations between countries.The concept of militarization,with global,regional and national level,reflects the situation and trend of a country to strengthen its soft and hard infrastructures in response to security dilemmas. It has convergences and divergences with militarism,securitization and weaponization. Due to certain limitations and grey area in theoretical assumptions and conceptual interpretations,there are some difficulties of militarization to be correctly and accurately implemented in practice. In recent years,there have been great differences between China and the United States about the militarization of the South China Sea issue in terms of definition,responsibility,intensity and legitimacy,and there is a risk of a low-intensity conflict in action.Judging from the past,there're other disputes on the South China Sea issue,such as initiative and passivity,defensiveness and offensiveness,constructiveness and destructiveness,and moderation and excessiveness,which reflects the legal and strategic competition between the countries concerned. In this regard,it is necessary for China to adopt more proactive policies and measures to weaken the legal and strategic basis of the other parties to promote the militarization of the South China Sea issue,and enhance the possibility of carrying out the necessary construction in the South China Sea.
引文
[1]Statement of Admiral Harry B.Harris Jr.,U.S.Navy Commander,U.S.Pacific Command before the Senate Armed Services Committee on U.S.Pacific Command Posture,February 23,2016,https://www.armed-services.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Harris_02-23-16.pdf.
[2]The Habibie Center,“Militarisation of the South China Sea Implications on ASEAN”,ASEAN Briefs,Vol.3,No.1(October 2015),p.3.
[3]《王毅:中国在南海岛礁部署防卫设施正当合法》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月24日,http://www.mfa.gov.cn/web/wjbzhd/t1561994.shtml;Remarks with Chinese Foreign Minister and State Councilor Wang Yi at a Press Availability,U.S.Department of State,May 23,2018,https://www.state.gov/secretary/remarks/2018/05/282469.htm.
[4]Greg Austin,“Xi Jinping and Maritime Militarization”,Diplomat,March 23,2016,https://thediplomat.com/2016/03/xi-jinping-and-maritime-militarization/.
[5]Anton Grizold,“Contemporary National Security in the Light of Militarization and Militarism”,Politi^cka misao,Vol.XXXVII,No.5(2000),pp.128-143.
[6][96]Emma Dailey,Security Council Question of Militarization of the Spratly and Paracel Islands,p.4,p.11,https://www.ofs.edu.sg/resources/munofs/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2014/05/SC-2.pdf.
[7]Chloe Aung,Militarization of the Arctic,Yangon Model United Nations,2016,p.2,https://yangonmodelunitednations.weebly.com/uploads/6/3/5/3/63535265/edited_unsc_militarization_of_the_arctic.pdf.
[8]Cynthia Enloe,Bananas,Beaches and Bases;Making Feminist Sense of International Politics,Berkeley:University of California Press,2000,pp.219-220;Jennifer Rycenga,Marguerite R.Wallter,Frontline Feminisms:Women,War and Resistance,London:Routledge,2001,p.121.
[9]Andrew L.Ross,“Dimensions of Militarization in the Third World”,Armed Forces and Society,Vol.13,No.4(Summer 1987),p.564.
[10]Geyer,Michael,“The Militarization of Europe,1914-1945”,in John R.Gillis,The Militarization of the Western World,New Brunswick,NJ:Rutgers University Press,1989,p.79.
[11]Lutz,Catherine,“Making War at Home in the United States:Militarization and the Current Crisis”,American Anthropologist,Vol.104,No.3(2002),p.723.
[12]Victoria M.Basham,Aaron Belkin and Jess Gifkins,“What is Critical Military Studies?”Critical Military Studies,Vol.1,No.1(2015),pp.1-2.
[13]Aaron Belkin,“Researching Normativity and Non-normativity in Military Organisations”,in Alison J.Williams,Neil Jenkings,Rachel Woodward,Matthew F.Rech,The Research Companion to Military Research Methods,London:Routledge,2016,pp.196-204.
[14]Kosta Gouliamos and Christos Kassimeris,The Marketing of War in the Age of Neomilitarism,London:Routledge,2012.
[15]Steven Flusty,Jason Dittmer,Emily Gilbert,Merje Kuus,“Interventions in Banal Imperialism”,Political Geography,Vol.27,No.6(2008),p.625;Merje Kuus,“Cosmopolitan militarism:Space of NATO Expansion”,Environment and Planning,Vol.41,No.3(2009),p.546.
[16]Rachel Woodward,K.Neil Jenkings,Alison J.Williams,“Militarisation,Universities and the University Armed Service Units”,Political Geography,Vol.60(September 2017),pp.203-212.
[17]Beatrice Jauregui,“World Fitness:US Army Family Humanism and the Positive Science of Persistent War”,Public Culture,Vol.27,No.3(2015),p.457.
[18]Eric Carlton,Militarism-Rule without Law,Ashgate:Aldershot,2001.
[19]“Introduction”,in Annica Kronsell and Erika Svedberg,Making Gender,Making War:Violence,Military and Peacekeeping Practices,Routledge Advances in Feminist Studies and Intersectionality,2011,p.17.
[20]巴瑞·布赞、奥利·维夫、D.怀尔德著:《新安全论》,朱宁译,杭州:浙江人民出版社,2003年,第一章;朱宁:《安全与非安全化---哥本哈根学派安全研究》,《世界经济与政治》2003年第10期,第22-23页;Albert Palazzo,“Strategy and Securitisation:Conflict or Complement in Australian Operations in Afghanistan”,Australian Army Journal,Vol.XIV,No 1(Autumn 2018),p.42.
[21]Robert L.Pfaltzgraff,Jr.,Weapons in Space,Presentation to the Boston Council on Foreign Relations,June 18,2007,p.3,http://www.ifpa.org/pdf/BCFR_061807.pdf.
[22]Ruth Leger Sivard,World Military and Social Expenditures,Leesburg,Va.:WMSE Publications,1985,pp.10-11;Kaniz Subarna,“Militarization-Is it a Threat to the National Security of Bangladesh”,International Journal for Excogitation Education and Research,Vol.1,No.2(June 2017),pp.13-14.
[23]Todor Mirkovic,“The World’s Globalization and Global Militarization”,VOJNO DELO,Vol.67,Br.6(January2015),p.5,http://www.odbrana.mod.gov.rs/odbrana-stari/vojni_casopisi/arhiva/VD_6-2015/67-2015-6-03-Mirkovic.pdf.
[24][27][37]Richard Tanter,Intelligence Agencies and Third World Militarization:A Case Study of Indonesia,1966-1989,with Special Reference to South Korea,1961-1989,A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy,Department of Politics,Faculty of Economic and Politics,Monash University,February 1991,p.23,p.40,p.25.
[25]David Kinsella,“The Global Arms Trade and the Diffusion of Militarism”,in Anna Stavrianakis and Jan Selby,Militarism and International Relations:Political Economy,Security,Theory,London:Routledge,2013,p.107.
[26]Amit Sharma,“Cyber Wars:A Paradigm Shift from Means to Ends”,Strategic Analysis,Vol.34,No.1(2010),pp.62-73;Martin C.Libicki,“Sub Rosa Cyber War”,in Christian Czosseck and Kenneth Geers,The Virtual Battlefield:Perspectives on Cyber Warfare,Amsterdam:IOS Press,2009,pp.55-65;Adam P.Liff,“Cyberwar:A New‘Absolute Weapon’?The Proliferation of Cyberwarfare Capabilities and Interstate War”,Journal of Strategic Studies,Vol.35,No.3(2012a),pp.401-428;Ilai Saltzman,“Cyber Posturing and the Offense-Defense Balance,”Contemporary Security Policy,Vol.34,No.1(2013),pp.40-63;Miguel Alberto N.Gomez,“Arming Cyberspace:The Militarization of a Virtual Domain”,Global Security and Intelligence Studies,Vol.1,No.2(Spring 2016),p.43.
[28]Miguel Alberto N.Gomez,“Arming Cyberspace:The Militarization of a Virtual Domain”,Global Security and Intelligence Studies,Vol.1,No.2(Spring 2016),p.44.
[29]Steve Chan,China’s Troubled Waters:Maritime Disputes in Theoretical Perspective,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2016,p.xii.
[30]Charles S.Gochman and Maoz Zeev,“Militarized Interstate Disputes,1816-1976:Procedures,Patterns,and Insights,”Journal of Conflict Resolution,Vol.28,No.4(1984),p.587.
[31]Gordon Adams and Shoon Murray,Mission Creep:The Militarization of U.S.Foreign Policy?,Washington,DC:Georgetown University Press,2014,Cited from Nina M.Serafino,“Security Assistance and Cooperation Shared Responsibility of the Departments of State and Defense”,Congressional Research Service,R44444,May 26,2016,p.3.
[32]张家栋:《美国政治演变柯南到达临界点》,《环球时报》2018年9月5日,第14版。
[33]Andrew Bacevich,American Empire:The Realities and Consequences of U.S.Diplomacy,Massachusetts:Harvard University Press,2002;Chalmers Johnson,The Sorrows of Empire,New York:Henry Holt and Company,LLC,2004;程群:《奥巴马政府与美国外交政策军事化趋势》,《现代国际关系》2009年第10期,第7页。
[34]The White House,National Security Strategy,May 2010,http://nssarchive.us/NSSR/2010.pdf.
[35]The White House,National Security Strategy,December 2017,https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/NSS-Final-12-18-2017-0905.pdf.
[36]Christopher J.Coyne,“The Political Economy of the Creeping Militarization of U.S.Foreign Policy”,Peace Economics,Peace Science and Public Policy,Vol.17,Iss.1(2011),pp.3-20.
[38]Eliav Lieblich and Adam Shinar,“The Case against Police Militarization”,Michigan Journal of Race and Law,Vol.23,No.1,p.4.
[39]Paul R.Hensel,Sara McLaughlin Mitchell,Thomas E.Sowers II,and Clayton L.Thyne,“Bones of Contention:Comparing Territorial,Maritime,and River Issues.”Journal of Conflict Resolution,Vol.52,No.1(2008),pp.117-43;Paul R.Hensel and Sara McLaughlin Mitchell,“From Territorial Claims to Identity Claims:The Issue Correlates of War(Icow)Project”,Conflict Management and Peace Science,Vol.34,No.2(2017),pp.126-140.
[40]Remarks by President Obama and President Xi of the People’s Republic of China in Joint Press Conference,The White House,September 25,2015,https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2015/09/25/remarks-president-obama-and-president-xi-peoples-republic-china-joint.
[41][78]Michael E.O’Hanlon,A Glass Half Full:The Rebalance,Reassurance,and Resolve in the U.S.-China Strategic Relationship,The Brookings Institution,October 2016,p.13,p.15,https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/201610_us_china_strategic_relationship_ohanlon.pdf.
[42]President Donald J.Trump’s State Visit to China,The White House,November 10,2017,https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/president-donald-j-trumps-state-visit-china/.
[43]John Chen and Bonnie Glaser,“What China’s‘Militarization’of the South China Sea Would Actually Look Like”,The Diplomat,November 5,2015,http://thediplomat.com/2015/11/what-chinas-militarization-of-the-south-china-sea-would-actually-look-like/;Malcolm Davis,China’s Great South China Sea Challenge:What Next and How to Respond,The National Interest,November 11,2015,http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/chinas-greatsouth-china-sea-challenge-what-next-how-respond-14317.
[44]蓝雅歌:《范长龙赴南沙视察岛礁》,《环球时报》2016年4月16日,第1版。
[45]李岩、张伟:《中国战机拦截美侦察机为何要在机头上翻跟头》,中华网,2017年5月21日,https://military.china.com/important/gundong/11065468/20170521/30549194_all.html。
[46]《空军轰6K战机开展岛礁起降训练提升海上实战能力》,《解放军报》2018年5月19日,第1版。
[47]Letter from Senators John McCain and Jack Reed,March 19,2015,http://www.freedom-now.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/6.2.15-Joint-letter-to-Carter-and-Kerry-re-Maldives.pdf.
[48]黎萌:《军事观察:美军战机抵近黄岩岛飞行应是次有限试探》,环球在线,2016年4月25日,http://mil.cri.cn/20160425/ca6aa852-537c-c44a-d151-6296fc46e44e.html。
[49]《外交部发言人陆慷就美国军舰擅自进入中国西沙群岛领海答记者问》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月27日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1562830.htm。
[50]《国防部就美B-52轰炸机进入中国南沙群岛有关岛礁邻近空域答记者问》,新华网,2015年12月19日,http://www.xinhuanet.com/world/2015-12/19/c_1117515043.htm;《2018年10月16日外交部发言人陆慷主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年10月16日,https://www.mfa.gov.cn/web/fyrbt_673021/t1604446.shtml。
[51]《2018年4月20日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年4月20日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1552853.htm;《2017年2月21日外交部发言人耿爽主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年2月21日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1440257.htm。
[52]《2017年1月24日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年1月24日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1433377.htm。
[53]《2018年4月20日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年4月20日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1552853.htm。
[54]《2018年4月24日外交部发言人陆慷主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年4月24日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1553842.htm。
[55]《2017年2月13日外交部发言人耿爽主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年2月13日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1438003.htm。
[56]钟声:《并不高明的造谣术---评美国领导人诬蔑中国的种种奇谈怪论》,《人民日报》2018年10月6日,第3版。
[57]《2018年5月24日外交部发言人陆慷主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月24日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1562195.htm。
[58]凌朔:《述评:南沙两座新机场为南海公益服务再添新支点》,新华社,2016年7月13日,http://www.xinhuanet.com/world/2016-07/13/c_129143129.htm。
[59]《国防部:南海诸岛自古以来就是中国领土》,中华人民共和国国防部网站,2018年8月30日,http://www.mod.gov.cn/reports/201412/zb/2018-08/30/content_4823635.htm。
[60]《2017年3月28日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年3月28日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1449431.htm。
[61]《2018年5月9日外交部发言人耿爽主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月9日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1558029.htm。
[62]《2018年5月21日外交部发言人陆慷主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月21日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1561060.htm。
[63]《2018年5月3日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月3日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1556448.htm。
[64]《2017年3月27日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年3月27日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1449007.htm。
[65]Richard Javad Heydarian,“The End of U.S.Primacy in Asia”,The National Interest,March 3,2016,https://nationalinterest.org/print/feature/the-end-us-primacy-asia-15383.
[66]《2017年2月22日外交部发言人耿爽主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年2月22日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1440587.htm;《2018年5月31日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月31日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1564367.htm。
[67][89]Michael Swaine,America’s Security Role in the South China Sea,Carnegie Endowment for International Peace,July 23,2015,http://carnegieendowment.org/2015/07/23/america-s-security-rolein-south-china-sea-pub-60826.
[68]Mel Goodma,“The Militarization of U.S.Foreign Policy”,Policy Brief,Vol.9,No.1(February 2004),p.3.
[69]Jan Voral,Strategic Naval Thinking of the United States of America and its Application on the Current Challenges of the U.S.Pacific Fleet,Master’s Thesis of Charles University,Prague,2016,p.76,https://dspace.cuni.cz/bitstream/handle/20.500.11956/53134/DPTX_2010_2_11230_0_322293_0_110511.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y.
[70]Ren Xiao,“U.S.Rebalance to Asia and China’s Responses”,in The Asia Foundation,America’s Role in Asia:The Implications of America’s Rebalancing Policy to Asia,Korean American Association,2015,p.66.
[71]Evans J.R.Revere,“U.S.Policy and East Asian Security:Challenge and Response”,in T.J.Pempel,Building a Regional Order in East Asia:Community,Competition,Conflict,The National Committee on American Foreign Policy,March 2016,p.8,https://www.ncafp.org/2016/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/E.-Asia-Regional-Order_3-16.pdf.
[72][84][86]You Ji,Spratly Militarization:Confusion in Concept and in Action,Paper for the 5th MIMA International Conference on South China Sea Conflicts,August 29-30,2016,p.11,p.7,p.9,http://www.mima.gov.my/v2/data/img/content/Paper2-Dr.YouJi.pdf.
[73]Matthew Lee and Eileen Ng,“US,China Bicker over Territorial Claims in South China Sea”,The Courier,Associated Press,August 5,2015,https://www.abqjournal.com/623581/us-china-bicker-over-territorial-claims-in-south-china-sea.html;“China’s Construction on South China Sea islands Should not be Mistaken for Militarization:Vice FM”,Xinhua,November 22,2015,http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2015-11/22/c_134842603.htm.
[74]“China Accuses US of Militarizing South China Sea”,Voice of America News,July 30,2015,http://www.voanews.com/content/chinaaccuses-us-of-militarizing-south-china-sea/2886799.html;Jim Sciutto,“Behind the Scenes:ASecret Navy Flight over China’s Military Buildup”,CNN International,May 26,2015,http://edition.cnn.com/2015/05/26/politics/south-china-sea-navy-surveillance-plane-jim-sciutto/;Carlyle Thayer,“Managing security tensions in the South China Sea the role of ASEAN”,in David Brewster,Indo-Pacific Maritime Security Challenges and Cooperation,The Australian National University,July 2016,pp.25-26,https://nsc.crawford.anu.edu.au/sites/default/files/publication/nsc_crawford_anu_edu_au/2017-05/indo-pacific_maritime_security_-_challenges_cooperation_-_final.pdf.
[75]Veronica F.Azzi,“Security for Show:The Militarisation of Public Space in Light of the 2016 Rio Olympic Games”,Contexto Internacional,Vol.39,No.3(September/December 2017),pp.601-602.
[76]王悠然:《美国警察军事化执法负面效应大》,《中国社会科学报》2018年9月10日,第3版。
[77]HPS Sodhi,“Military Implications of China’s Reclamation Drive in South China Sea”,Defence and Diplomacy Journal,Vol.5,No.2(January-March 2016),p.62.
[79]Lynn Kuok,The US FON Program in the South China Sea,Brookings Institution,June 7,2016,p.III.
[80]Andreas Bje Forsby,The South China Sea-A Breeding Ground for Geopolitical Rivalry?,Danish Institute for International Studies,2016,p.54.
[81]Josh Rogin,“The Obama Administration is Failing to Stop China’s Pacific Aggression”,The Washington Post,June24,2016,https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/global-opinions/the-obama-administration-is-failing-to-stop-chinas-pacific-aggression/2016/06/23/fce65f98-396c-11e6-8f7c-d4c723a2becb_story.html.
[82]郭至君、臧涵:《姚云竹答中评:到底谁在南海挑衅?很明确》,中评社,2018年6月2日,http://bj.crntt.com/doc/1050/8/9/4/105089453.html?coluid=308&kindid=19173&docid=105089453。
[83]Merriam-Webster Dictionary,http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/militarize;The Free Dictionary,http://www.thefreedictionary.com/militarization.
[85]Carlyle Thayer,“Managing security tensions in the South China Sea the role of ASEAN”,in David Brewster,IndoPacific Maritime Security Challenges and Cooperation,The Australian National University,July 2016,pp.25-26,https://nsc.crawford.anu.edu.au/sites/default/files/publication/nsc_crawford_anu_edu_au/2017-05/indo-pacific_maritime_security_-_challenges_cooperation_-_final.pdf.
[87]Mark J.Valencia,“Who Is Militarizing the South China Sea?”The Diplomat,December 20,2015,http://thediplomat.com/2015/12/who-is-militarizing-the-south-china-sea/.
[88]Joseph Chinyong Liow,What does the South China Sea ruling mean,and what’s next?,Brookings Institution,July12,2016,https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2016/07/12/what-does-the-south-china-sea-ruling-mean-and-whats-next/.
[90]韩旭东:《“不战不和”威胁不亚于战争》,《环球时报》2016年7月30日,第7版。
[91][97]You Ji,“De-combatising the Spratly Disputes”,Maritime Issues Working Papers,December 31,2016,p.11,pp.4-5,http://www.maritimeissues.com/uploaded/6_2_%20decombatising.pdf.
[92]Renato Cruz De Castro,“The Challenge of Conflict Resolution in the South China Sea Dispute:Examining the Prospect of a Stable Peace in East Asia”,International Journal of China Studies,Vol.7,No.1(April 2016),p.40.
[93]Andromeda Windra Ciptadi,Sailing the calm and rough seas the influence of wealth and sovereignty in Southeast Asian maritime disputes,Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS IN SECU-RITY STUDIES(FAR EAST,SOUTHEAST ASIA,THE PACIFIC)from the NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL,March 2016,p.2,https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/36740575.pdf.
[94]Jessica Chen Weiss,Reviewing President Xi’s State Visit,Testimony before the House Committee on Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on Asia and the Pacific,October 7,2015.
[95]Sukjoon Yoon,“Why is China Militarising the South China Sea”,RSIS Commentary,No.113,May 11,2015.
[98]Hugh White,China’s Island-building Project a Bid for Power,not Popularity,November 10,2015,http://www.theage.com.au/comment/chinas-islandbuilding-project-a-bid-for-power-not-popularity-20151108-gku0kr.html.
[99]Sam Bateman,“Brinkmanship in the South China Sea helps nobody”,East Asia Forum,June 7,2016.
[2]The Habibie Center,“Militarisation of the South China Sea Implications on ASEAN”,ASEAN Briefs,Vol.3,No.1(October 2015),p.3.
[3]《王毅:中国在南海岛礁部署防卫设施正当合法》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月24日,http://www.mfa.gov.cn/web/wjbzhd/t1561994.shtml;Remarks with Chinese Foreign Minister and State Councilor Wang Yi at a Press Availability,U.S.Department of State,May 23,2018,https://www.state.gov/secretary/remarks/2018/05/282469.htm.
[4]Greg Austin,“Xi Jinping and Maritime Militarization”,Diplomat,March 23,2016,https://thediplomat.com/2016/03/xi-jinping-and-maritime-militarization/.
[5]Anton Grizold,“Contemporary National Security in the Light of Militarization and Militarism”,Politi^cka misao,Vol.XXXVII,No.5(2000),pp.128-143.
[6][96]Emma Dailey,Security Council Question of Militarization of the Spratly and Paracel Islands,p.4,p.11,https://www.ofs.edu.sg/resources/munofs/wp-content/uploads/sites/18/2014/05/SC-2.pdf.
[7]Chloe Aung,Militarization of the Arctic,Yangon Model United Nations,2016,p.2,https://yangonmodelunitednations.weebly.com/uploads/6/3/5/3/63535265/edited_unsc_militarization_of_the_arctic.pdf.
[8]Cynthia Enloe,Bananas,Beaches and Bases;Making Feminist Sense of International Politics,Berkeley:University of California Press,2000,pp.219-220;Jennifer Rycenga,Marguerite R.Wallter,Frontline Feminisms:Women,War and Resistance,London:Routledge,2001,p.121.
[9]Andrew L.Ross,“Dimensions of Militarization in the Third World”,Armed Forces and Society,Vol.13,No.4(Summer 1987),p.564.
[10]Geyer,Michael,“The Militarization of Europe,1914-1945”,in John R.Gillis,The Militarization of the Western World,New Brunswick,NJ:Rutgers University Press,1989,p.79.
[11]Lutz,Catherine,“Making War at Home in the United States:Militarization and the Current Crisis”,American Anthropologist,Vol.104,No.3(2002),p.723.
[12]Victoria M.Basham,Aaron Belkin and Jess Gifkins,“What is Critical Military Studies?”Critical Military Studies,Vol.1,No.1(2015),pp.1-2.
[13]Aaron Belkin,“Researching Normativity and Non-normativity in Military Organisations”,in Alison J.Williams,Neil Jenkings,Rachel Woodward,Matthew F.Rech,The Research Companion to Military Research Methods,London:Routledge,2016,pp.196-204.
[14]Kosta Gouliamos and Christos Kassimeris,The Marketing of War in the Age of Neomilitarism,London:Routledge,2012.
[15]Steven Flusty,Jason Dittmer,Emily Gilbert,Merje Kuus,“Interventions in Banal Imperialism”,Political Geography,Vol.27,No.6(2008),p.625;Merje Kuus,“Cosmopolitan militarism:Space of NATO Expansion”,Environment and Planning,Vol.41,No.3(2009),p.546.
[16]Rachel Woodward,K.Neil Jenkings,Alison J.Williams,“Militarisation,Universities and the University Armed Service Units”,Political Geography,Vol.60(September 2017),pp.203-212.
[17]Beatrice Jauregui,“World Fitness:US Army Family Humanism and the Positive Science of Persistent War”,Public Culture,Vol.27,No.3(2015),p.457.
[18]Eric Carlton,Militarism-Rule without Law,Ashgate:Aldershot,2001.
[19]“Introduction”,in Annica Kronsell and Erika Svedberg,Making Gender,Making War:Violence,Military and Peacekeeping Practices,Routledge Advances in Feminist Studies and Intersectionality,2011,p.17.
[20]巴瑞·布赞、奥利·维夫、D.怀尔德著:《新安全论》,朱宁译,杭州:浙江人民出版社,2003年,第一章;朱宁:《安全与非安全化---哥本哈根学派安全研究》,《世界经济与政治》2003年第10期,第22-23页;Albert Palazzo,“Strategy and Securitisation:Conflict or Complement in Australian Operations in Afghanistan”,Australian Army Journal,Vol.XIV,No 1(Autumn 2018),p.42.
[21]Robert L.Pfaltzgraff,Jr.,Weapons in Space,Presentation to the Boston Council on Foreign Relations,June 18,2007,p.3,http://www.ifpa.org/pdf/BCFR_061807.pdf.
[22]Ruth Leger Sivard,World Military and Social Expenditures,Leesburg,Va.:WMSE Publications,1985,pp.10-11;Kaniz Subarna,“Militarization-Is it a Threat to the National Security of Bangladesh”,International Journal for Excogitation Education and Research,Vol.1,No.2(June 2017),pp.13-14.
[23]Todor Mirkovic,“The World’s Globalization and Global Militarization”,VOJNO DELO,Vol.67,Br.6(January2015),p.5,http://www.odbrana.mod.gov.rs/odbrana-stari/vojni_casopisi/arhiva/VD_6-2015/67-2015-6-03-Mirkovic.pdf.
[24][27][37]Richard Tanter,Intelligence Agencies and Third World Militarization:A Case Study of Indonesia,1966-1989,with Special Reference to South Korea,1961-1989,A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy,Department of Politics,Faculty of Economic and Politics,Monash University,February 1991,p.23,p.40,p.25.
[25]David Kinsella,“The Global Arms Trade and the Diffusion of Militarism”,in Anna Stavrianakis and Jan Selby,Militarism and International Relations:Political Economy,Security,Theory,London:Routledge,2013,p.107.
[26]Amit Sharma,“Cyber Wars:A Paradigm Shift from Means to Ends”,Strategic Analysis,Vol.34,No.1(2010),pp.62-73;Martin C.Libicki,“Sub Rosa Cyber War”,in Christian Czosseck and Kenneth Geers,The Virtual Battlefield:Perspectives on Cyber Warfare,Amsterdam:IOS Press,2009,pp.55-65;Adam P.Liff,“Cyberwar:A New‘Absolute Weapon’?The Proliferation of Cyberwarfare Capabilities and Interstate War”,Journal of Strategic Studies,Vol.35,No.3(2012a),pp.401-428;Ilai Saltzman,“Cyber Posturing and the Offense-Defense Balance,”Contemporary Security Policy,Vol.34,No.1(2013),pp.40-63;Miguel Alberto N.Gomez,“Arming Cyberspace:The Militarization of a Virtual Domain”,Global Security and Intelligence Studies,Vol.1,No.2(Spring 2016),p.43.
[28]Miguel Alberto N.Gomez,“Arming Cyberspace:The Militarization of a Virtual Domain”,Global Security and Intelligence Studies,Vol.1,No.2(Spring 2016),p.44.
[29]Steve Chan,China’s Troubled Waters:Maritime Disputes in Theoretical Perspective,Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2016,p.xii.
[30]Charles S.Gochman and Maoz Zeev,“Militarized Interstate Disputes,1816-1976:Procedures,Patterns,and Insights,”Journal of Conflict Resolution,Vol.28,No.4(1984),p.587.
[31]Gordon Adams and Shoon Murray,Mission Creep:The Militarization of U.S.Foreign Policy?,Washington,DC:Georgetown University Press,2014,Cited from Nina M.Serafino,“Security Assistance and Cooperation Shared Responsibility of the Departments of State and Defense”,Congressional Research Service,R44444,May 26,2016,p.3.
[32]张家栋:《美国政治演变柯南到达临界点》,《环球时报》2018年9月5日,第14版。
[33]Andrew Bacevich,American Empire:The Realities and Consequences of U.S.Diplomacy,Massachusetts:Harvard University Press,2002;Chalmers Johnson,The Sorrows of Empire,New York:Henry Holt and Company,LLC,2004;程群:《奥巴马政府与美国外交政策军事化趋势》,《现代国际关系》2009年第10期,第7页。
[34]The White House,National Security Strategy,May 2010,http://nssarchive.us/NSSR/2010.pdf.
[35]The White House,National Security Strategy,December 2017,https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/NSS-Final-12-18-2017-0905.pdf.
[36]Christopher J.Coyne,“The Political Economy of the Creeping Militarization of U.S.Foreign Policy”,Peace Economics,Peace Science and Public Policy,Vol.17,Iss.1(2011),pp.3-20.
[38]Eliav Lieblich and Adam Shinar,“The Case against Police Militarization”,Michigan Journal of Race and Law,Vol.23,No.1,p.4.
[39]Paul R.Hensel,Sara McLaughlin Mitchell,Thomas E.Sowers II,and Clayton L.Thyne,“Bones of Contention:Comparing Territorial,Maritime,and River Issues.”Journal of Conflict Resolution,Vol.52,No.1(2008),pp.117-43;Paul R.Hensel and Sara McLaughlin Mitchell,“From Territorial Claims to Identity Claims:The Issue Correlates of War(Icow)Project”,Conflict Management and Peace Science,Vol.34,No.2(2017),pp.126-140.
[40]Remarks by President Obama and President Xi of the People’s Republic of China in Joint Press Conference,The White House,September 25,2015,https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2015/09/25/remarks-president-obama-and-president-xi-peoples-republic-china-joint.
[41][78]Michael E.O’Hanlon,A Glass Half Full:The Rebalance,Reassurance,and Resolve in the U.S.-China Strategic Relationship,The Brookings Institution,October 2016,p.13,p.15,https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/201610_us_china_strategic_relationship_ohanlon.pdf.
[42]President Donald J.Trump’s State Visit to China,The White House,November 10,2017,https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/president-donald-j-trumps-state-visit-china/.
[43]John Chen and Bonnie Glaser,“What China’s‘Militarization’of the South China Sea Would Actually Look Like”,The Diplomat,November 5,2015,http://thediplomat.com/2015/11/what-chinas-militarization-of-the-south-china-sea-would-actually-look-like/;Malcolm Davis,China’s Great South China Sea Challenge:What Next and How to Respond,The National Interest,November 11,2015,http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/chinas-greatsouth-china-sea-challenge-what-next-how-respond-14317.
[44]蓝雅歌:《范长龙赴南沙视察岛礁》,《环球时报》2016年4月16日,第1版。
[45]李岩、张伟:《中国战机拦截美侦察机为何要在机头上翻跟头》,中华网,2017年5月21日,https://military.china.com/important/gundong/11065468/20170521/30549194_all.html。
[46]《空军轰6K战机开展岛礁起降训练提升海上实战能力》,《解放军报》2018年5月19日,第1版。
[47]Letter from Senators John McCain and Jack Reed,March 19,2015,http://www.freedom-now.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/6.2.15-Joint-letter-to-Carter-and-Kerry-re-Maldives.pdf.
[48]黎萌:《军事观察:美军战机抵近黄岩岛飞行应是次有限试探》,环球在线,2016年4月25日,http://mil.cri.cn/20160425/ca6aa852-537c-c44a-d151-6296fc46e44e.html。
[49]《外交部发言人陆慷就美国军舰擅自进入中国西沙群岛领海答记者问》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月27日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1562830.htm。
[50]《国防部就美B-52轰炸机进入中国南沙群岛有关岛礁邻近空域答记者问》,新华网,2015年12月19日,http://www.xinhuanet.com/world/2015-12/19/c_1117515043.htm;《2018年10月16日外交部发言人陆慷主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年10月16日,https://www.mfa.gov.cn/web/fyrbt_673021/t1604446.shtml。
[51]《2018年4月20日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年4月20日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1552853.htm;《2017年2月21日外交部发言人耿爽主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年2月21日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1440257.htm。
[52]《2017年1月24日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年1月24日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1433377.htm。
[53]《2018年4月20日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年4月20日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1552853.htm。
[54]《2018年4月24日外交部发言人陆慷主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年4月24日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1553842.htm。
[55]《2017年2月13日外交部发言人耿爽主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年2月13日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1438003.htm。
[56]钟声:《并不高明的造谣术---评美国领导人诬蔑中国的种种奇谈怪论》,《人民日报》2018年10月6日,第3版。
[57]《2018年5月24日外交部发言人陆慷主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月24日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1562195.htm。
[58]凌朔:《述评:南沙两座新机场为南海公益服务再添新支点》,新华社,2016年7月13日,http://www.xinhuanet.com/world/2016-07/13/c_129143129.htm。
[59]《国防部:南海诸岛自古以来就是中国领土》,中华人民共和国国防部网站,2018年8月30日,http://www.mod.gov.cn/reports/201412/zb/2018-08/30/content_4823635.htm。
[60]《2017年3月28日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年3月28日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1449431.htm。
[61]《2018年5月9日外交部发言人耿爽主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月9日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1558029.htm。
[62]《2018年5月21日外交部发言人陆慷主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月21日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1561060.htm。
[63]《2018年5月3日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月3日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1556448.htm。
[64]《2017年3月27日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年3月27日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1449007.htm。
[65]Richard Javad Heydarian,“The End of U.S.Primacy in Asia”,The National Interest,March 3,2016,https://nationalinterest.org/print/feature/the-end-us-primacy-asia-15383.
[66]《2017年2月22日外交部发言人耿爽主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2017年2月22日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1440587.htm;《2018年5月31日外交部发言人华春莹主持例行记者会》,中华人民共和国外交部网站,2018年5月31日,http://www.fmprc.gov.cn/nanhai/chn/fyrbt/t1564367.htm。
[67][89]Michael Swaine,America’s Security Role in the South China Sea,Carnegie Endowment for International Peace,July 23,2015,http://carnegieendowment.org/2015/07/23/america-s-security-rolein-south-china-sea-pub-60826.
[68]Mel Goodma,“The Militarization of U.S.Foreign Policy”,Policy Brief,Vol.9,No.1(February 2004),p.3.
[69]Jan Voral,Strategic Naval Thinking of the United States of America and its Application on the Current Challenges of the U.S.Pacific Fleet,Master’s Thesis of Charles University,Prague,2016,p.76,https://dspace.cuni.cz/bitstream/handle/20.500.11956/53134/DPTX_2010_2_11230_0_322293_0_110511.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y.
[70]Ren Xiao,“U.S.Rebalance to Asia and China’s Responses”,in The Asia Foundation,America’s Role in Asia:The Implications of America’s Rebalancing Policy to Asia,Korean American Association,2015,p.66.
[71]Evans J.R.Revere,“U.S.Policy and East Asian Security:Challenge and Response”,in T.J.Pempel,Building a Regional Order in East Asia:Community,Competition,Conflict,The National Committee on American Foreign Policy,March 2016,p.8,https://www.ncafp.org/2016/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/E.-Asia-Regional-Order_3-16.pdf.
[72][84][86]You Ji,Spratly Militarization:Confusion in Concept and in Action,Paper for the 5th MIMA International Conference on South China Sea Conflicts,August 29-30,2016,p.11,p.7,p.9,http://www.mima.gov.my/v2/data/img/content/Paper2-Dr.YouJi.pdf.
[73]Matthew Lee and Eileen Ng,“US,China Bicker over Territorial Claims in South China Sea”,The Courier,Associated Press,August 5,2015,https://www.abqjournal.com/623581/us-china-bicker-over-territorial-claims-in-south-china-sea.html;“China’s Construction on South China Sea islands Should not be Mistaken for Militarization:Vice FM”,Xinhua,November 22,2015,http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2015-11/22/c_134842603.htm.
[74]“China Accuses US of Militarizing South China Sea”,Voice of America News,July 30,2015,http://www.voanews.com/content/chinaaccuses-us-of-militarizing-south-china-sea/2886799.html;Jim Sciutto,“Behind the Scenes:ASecret Navy Flight over China’s Military Buildup”,CNN International,May 26,2015,http://edition.cnn.com/2015/05/26/politics/south-china-sea-navy-surveillance-plane-jim-sciutto/;Carlyle Thayer,“Managing security tensions in the South China Sea the role of ASEAN”,in David Brewster,Indo-Pacific Maritime Security Challenges and Cooperation,The Australian National University,July 2016,pp.25-26,https://nsc.crawford.anu.edu.au/sites/default/files/publication/nsc_crawford_anu_edu_au/2017-05/indo-pacific_maritime_security_-_challenges_cooperation_-_final.pdf.
[75]Veronica F.Azzi,“Security for Show:The Militarisation of Public Space in Light of the 2016 Rio Olympic Games”,Contexto Internacional,Vol.39,No.3(September/December 2017),pp.601-602.
[76]王悠然:《美国警察军事化执法负面效应大》,《中国社会科学报》2018年9月10日,第3版。
[77]HPS Sodhi,“Military Implications of China’s Reclamation Drive in South China Sea”,Defence and Diplomacy Journal,Vol.5,No.2(January-March 2016),p.62.
[79]Lynn Kuok,The US FON Program in the South China Sea,Brookings Institution,June 7,2016,p.III.
[80]Andreas Bje Forsby,The South China Sea-A Breeding Ground for Geopolitical Rivalry?,Danish Institute for International Studies,2016,p.54.
[81]Josh Rogin,“The Obama Administration is Failing to Stop China’s Pacific Aggression”,The Washington Post,June24,2016,https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/global-opinions/the-obama-administration-is-failing-to-stop-chinas-pacific-aggression/2016/06/23/fce65f98-396c-11e6-8f7c-d4c723a2becb_story.html.
[82]郭至君、臧涵:《姚云竹答中评:到底谁在南海挑衅?很明确》,中评社,2018年6月2日,http://bj.crntt.com/doc/1050/8/9/4/105089453.html?coluid=308&kindid=19173&docid=105089453。
[83]Merriam-Webster Dictionary,http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/militarize;The Free Dictionary,http://www.thefreedictionary.com/militarization.
[85]Carlyle Thayer,“Managing security tensions in the South China Sea the role of ASEAN”,in David Brewster,IndoPacific Maritime Security Challenges and Cooperation,The Australian National University,July 2016,pp.25-26,https://nsc.crawford.anu.edu.au/sites/default/files/publication/nsc_crawford_anu_edu_au/2017-05/indo-pacific_maritime_security_-_challenges_cooperation_-_final.pdf.
[87]Mark J.Valencia,“Who Is Militarizing the South China Sea?”The Diplomat,December 20,2015,http://thediplomat.com/2015/12/who-is-militarizing-the-south-china-sea/.
[88]Joseph Chinyong Liow,What does the South China Sea ruling mean,and what’s next?,Brookings Institution,July12,2016,https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2016/07/12/what-does-the-south-china-sea-ruling-mean-and-whats-next/.
[90]韩旭东:《“不战不和”威胁不亚于战争》,《环球时报》2016年7月30日,第7版。
[91][97]You Ji,“De-combatising the Spratly Disputes”,Maritime Issues Working Papers,December 31,2016,p.11,pp.4-5,http://www.maritimeissues.com/uploaded/6_2_%20decombatising.pdf.
[92]Renato Cruz De Castro,“The Challenge of Conflict Resolution in the South China Sea Dispute:Examining the Prospect of a Stable Peace in East Asia”,International Journal of China Studies,Vol.7,No.1(April 2016),p.40.
[93]Andromeda Windra Ciptadi,Sailing the calm and rough seas the influence of wealth and sovereignty in Southeast Asian maritime disputes,Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS IN SECU-RITY STUDIES(FAR EAST,SOUTHEAST ASIA,THE PACIFIC)from the NAVAL POSTGRADUATE SCHOOL,March 2016,p.2,https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/36740575.pdf.
[94]Jessica Chen Weiss,Reviewing President Xi’s State Visit,Testimony before the House Committee on Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on Asia and the Pacific,October 7,2015.
[95]Sukjoon Yoon,“Why is China Militarising the South China Sea”,RSIS Commentary,No.113,May 11,2015.
[98]Hugh White,China’s Island-building Project a Bid for Power,not Popularity,November 10,2015,http://www.theage.com.au/comment/chinas-islandbuilding-project-a-bid-for-power-not-popularity-20151108-gku0kr.html.
[99]Sam Bateman,“Brinkmanship in the South China Sea helps nobody”,East Asia Forum,June 7,2016.