储能技术经济性评估方法综述
|
摘要
对储能技术经济性的评估方法进行了较全面的综述。阐述储能技术经济性评估的必要意义,分析经济性对于储能发展的影响,较全面地介绍储能效益评估软件(energy storage valuation tool,ESVT)、储能经济测算指数λ、基于储能平准化成本的经济测算模型,并在此基础上分析了当前储能在国内外应用的成本效益。最后根据国内外储能经济性分析的情况,指出了储能技术在经济性方面目前存在的问题和未来的发展趋势。
This paper comprehensively reviews on evaluation methods for economy of energy storage technologies.It states necessity of economy evaluation for the energy storage technology and analyzes influence of economy on development of energy storage.It also introduces the energy storage valuation tool(ESVT),the YCC index of energy storage economy and the economic calculation model based on energy storage leveling cost,and then analyzes application cost effectiveness of current energy storage at home and abroad.Finally according to economy analysis of domestic and international energy storage situations,it points out current existing problems and future development trend of the energy storage technology in economy aspect.
This paper comprehensively reviews on evaluation methods for economy of energy storage technologies.It states necessity of economy evaluation for the energy storage technology and analyzes influence of economy on development of energy storage.It also introduces the energy storage valuation tool(ESVT),the YCC index of energy storage economy and the economic calculation model based on energy storage leveling cost,and then analyzes application cost effectiveness of current energy storage at home and abroad.Finally according to economy analysis of domestic and international energy storage situations,it points out current existing problems and future development trend of the energy storage technology in economy aspect.
引文
[1]张文亮,丘明,来小康.储能技术在电力系统中的应用[J].电网技术,2008,32(7):1-9.ZHANG Wenliang,QIU Ming,LAI Xiaokang.Application of energy storage technologies in power grids[J].Power System Technology,2008,32(7):1-9.
[2]钟迪,李启明,周贤,等.多能互补能源综合利用关键技术研究现状及发展趋势[J].热力发电,2018(2):1-5.ZHONG Di,LI Qiming,ZHOU Xian,et al.Research status and development trends for key technologies of multi-energy complementary comprehensive utilization system[J].Thermal Power Generation,2018(2):1-5.
[3]魏增福,郑金.应用于智能电网的储能技术[J].广东电力,2010,23(11):22-27.WEI Zengfu,ZHENG Jin.Energy storage techniques applied in smart grid[J].Guangdong Electric Power,2010,23(11):22-27.
[4]刘大贺,韩晓娟,李建林.基于光伏电站场景下的梯次电池储能经济性分析[J].电力工程技术,2017,36(6):27-31,77.LIU Dahe,HAN Xiaojuan,LI Jianlin.Economic analysis of echelon battery energy storage based on artificial fish swarm algorithm[J].Electric Power Engineering Teachnology,2017,36(6):27-31,77.
[5]牛赛.储能技术研究及其在智能电网中的应用[D].郑州:郑州大学,2011.
[6]严干贵,谢国强,李军徽,等.储能系统在电力系统中的应用综述[J].东北电力大学学报,2011,31(3):7-12.YAN Gangui,XIE Guoqiang,LI Junhui,et al.Review of energy storage system in electric power system[J].Journal of Northeast Dianli University,2011,31(3):7-12.
[7]程时杰,余文辉,文劲宇,等.储能技术及其在电力系统稳定控制中的应用[J].电网技术,2007,31(20):97-108.CHENG Shijie,YU Wenhui,WEN Jinyu,et al.Energy storage and its application in power system stability enhancement[J].Power System Technology,2007,31(20):97-108.
[8]吴峰,张涵.用户光伏发电储能优化配置研究[J].智慧电力,2018,46(7):1-6.WU Feng,ZHANG Han.Study on optimized configuration of energy storage for photovoltaic power generation[J].Smart Power,2018,46(7):1-6.
[9]宁阳天,李相俊,董德华,等.储能系统平抑风光发电出力波动的研究方法综述[J].供用电,2017,34(4):2-11.NING Yangtian,LI Xiangjun,DONG Dehua,et al.A review of the research methods of smoothing wind/PV Power output with energy storage systems[J].Distribution&Utilization,2017,34(4):2-11.
[10]李姚旺,苗世洪,刘君瑶,等.考虑需求响应不确定性的光伏微电网储能系统优化配置[J].电力系统保护与控制,2018,46(20):69-77.LI Yaowang,MIAO Shihong,LIU Junyao,et al.Optimal allocation of energy storage system in PV micro grid considering uncertainty of demand response[J].Power System Protection and Control,2018,46(20):69-77.
[11]张远,曾杰,李庆生,等.微电网中光伏-储能协调控制策略的研究[J].广东电力,2014,27(8):10-14.ZHANG Yuan,ZENG Jie,LI Qingsheng,et al.Photovoltaic-energy storage coordination control strategy for micro grid[J].Guangdong Electric Power,2014,27(8):10-14.
[12]彭政,崔雪,王恒,等.考虑储能和需求侧响应的微网光伏消纳能力研究[J].电力系统保护与控制,2017,45(22):63-69.PENG Zheng,CUI Xue,WANG Heng,et al.Research on the accommodation of photovoltaic power considering storage system and demand response in microgrid[J].Power System Protection and Control,2017,45(22):63-69.
[13]廖强强,陆宇东,王栋,等.发电侧备用电池储能系统的技术经济分析[J].电力建设,2014,35(1):118-121.LIAO Qiangqiang,LU Yudong,WANG Dong,et al.Technical and economic analysis on energy storage system of standby battery for thermal power plants[J].Electric Power Construction,2014,35(1):118-121.
[14]叶季蕾,陶琼,薛金花,等.风电并网集成应用中的储能经济性进展分析[J].化工进展,2016,35(增刊2):137-143.YE Jilei,TAO Qiong,XUE Jinhua,et al.Economic progress analysis of energy storage in the application of wind power integration[J].Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress,2016,35(S2):137-143.
[15]肖立业.超导电力技术的现状和发展趋势[J].电网技术,2004,28(9):33-37.XIAO Liye.Present station and development trend of superconducting power technology[J].Power System Technology,2004,28(9):33-37.
[16]王超,苏伟,钟国彬,等.超级电容器及其在新能源领域的应用[J].广东电力,2015,28(12):46-52.WANG Chao,SU Wei,ZHONG Guobin,et al.Supercapacitor and its applications in the field of new energy[J].Guangdong Electric Power,2015,28(12):46-52.
[17]杨德志,沈佳妮,杨晓伟,等.石墨烯基超级电容器研究进展[J].储能科学与技术,2014,3(1):1-8.YANG Dezhi,SHEN Jiani,YANG Xiaowei,et al.Progress in graphene based supercapacitors[J].Energy Storage Science and Technology,2014,3(1):1-8.
[18]王江波,赵国亮,蒋晓春,等.飞轮储能技术在电网中的应用综述[J].电力电子技术,2013,47(7):28-30.WANG Jiangbo,ZHAO Guoliang,JIANG Xiaochun,et al.Overview on application of flywheel energy storage technology in power grid[J].Power Electronics,2013,47(7):28-30.
[19]王超,戴兴建,汪勇,等.储能复合材料飞轮研究进展[J].储能科学与技术,2017,6(5):1076-1083.WANG Chao,DAI Xingjian,WANG Yong,et al.Research progress of energy storage composite flywheel[J].Energy Storage Science and Technology,2017,6(5):1076-1083.
[20]孙振新,刘汉强,赵喆,等.储能经济性研究[J].中国电机工程学报,2013,33(增刊1):54-58.SUN Zhenxin,LIU Hanqiang,ZHAO Zhe,et al.Research on economical efficiency of energy storage[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2013,33(S1):54-58.
[21]纪律,刘畅,胡珊,等.中国电力储能应用的挑战与对策[J].高科技与产业化,2016(4):54-58.JI Lü,LIU Chang,HU Shan,et al.Challenge and countermeasures of electric energy storage application in China[J].High-Technology&Industrialization,2016(4):54-58.
[22]薛金花,叶季蕾,陶琼,等.采用全寿命周期成本模型的用户侧电池储能经济可行性研究[J].电网技术,2016,40(8):2471-2476.XUE Jinhua,YE Jilei,TAO Qiong,et al.Economic feasibility of user-side battery energy storage based on whole-life-cycle cost model[J].Power System Technology,2016,40(8):2471-2476.
[23]杨裕生,程杰,曹高萍.规模储能装置经济效益的判据[J].电池,2011,41(1):19-21.YANG Yusheng,CHENG Jie,CAO Gaoping.A gauge for direct economic benefits of energy storage devices[J].Battery Bimonthly,2011,41(1):19-21.
[24]刘坚.储能技术经济性现状及商业化运行障碍[J].中国能源,2017,39(7):36-40.LIU Jian.Economic status of energy storage technologies and business model barriers[J].Energy of China,2017,39(7):36-40.
[25]李娜,刘喜梅,白恺,等.梯次利用电池储能电站经济性评估方法研究[J].可再生能源,2017,35(6):926-932.LI Na,LIU Ximei,BAI Kai,et al.Research on the economic evaluation method of secondary battery energy storage[J].Renewable Energy Resources,2017,35(6):926-932.
[26]邢洁,曹哲,张怡,等.储能系统应用于用户侧的技术经济分析[J].电气应用,2017,36(1):26-30.XING Jie,CAO Zhe,ZHANG Yi,et al.[J].Technical and economic analysis on user-side energy storage system[J].Electrotechnical Application,2017,36(1):26-30.
[27]DARLING S B,YOU F,VESELKA T,et al.Assumptions and the levelized cost of energy for photovoltaics[J].Energy&Environmental Science,2011,4(9):3133-3139.
[28]UECKERDT F,HIRTH L,LUDERER G,et al.System lcoe:what are the costs of variable renewables[J].Energy,2013,63(1):61-75.
[29]刘喜梅,白恺,邓春,等.大型风电项目平准化成本模型研究[J].可再生能源,2016,34(12):1853-1858.LIU Ximei,BAI Kai,DENG Chun,et al.Research on levelized cost of energy model of large-scale wind power projects[J].Renewable Energy Resources,2016,34(12):1853-1858.
[30]陈大宇,张粒子,王澍,等.储能在美国调频市场中的发展及启示[J].电力系统自动化,2013,37(1):9-13.CHEN Dayu,ZHANG Lizi,WANG Shu,et al.Development of energy storage in frequency regulation market of U-nited States and its enlightenment[J].Automation of Electric Power Systems,2013,37(1):9-13.
[2]钟迪,李启明,周贤,等.多能互补能源综合利用关键技术研究现状及发展趋势[J].热力发电,2018(2):1-5.ZHONG Di,LI Qiming,ZHOU Xian,et al.Research status and development trends for key technologies of multi-energy complementary comprehensive utilization system[J].Thermal Power Generation,2018(2):1-5.
[3]魏增福,郑金.应用于智能电网的储能技术[J].广东电力,2010,23(11):22-27.WEI Zengfu,ZHENG Jin.Energy storage techniques applied in smart grid[J].Guangdong Electric Power,2010,23(11):22-27.
[4]刘大贺,韩晓娟,李建林.基于光伏电站场景下的梯次电池储能经济性分析[J].电力工程技术,2017,36(6):27-31,77.LIU Dahe,HAN Xiaojuan,LI Jianlin.Economic analysis of echelon battery energy storage based on artificial fish swarm algorithm[J].Electric Power Engineering Teachnology,2017,36(6):27-31,77.
[5]牛赛.储能技术研究及其在智能电网中的应用[D].郑州:郑州大学,2011.
[6]严干贵,谢国强,李军徽,等.储能系统在电力系统中的应用综述[J].东北电力大学学报,2011,31(3):7-12.YAN Gangui,XIE Guoqiang,LI Junhui,et al.Review of energy storage system in electric power system[J].Journal of Northeast Dianli University,2011,31(3):7-12.
[7]程时杰,余文辉,文劲宇,等.储能技术及其在电力系统稳定控制中的应用[J].电网技术,2007,31(20):97-108.CHENG Shijie,YU Wenhui,WEN Jinyu,et al.Energy storage and its application in power system stability enhancement[J].Power System Technology,2007,31(20):97-108.
[8]吴峰,张涵.用户光伏发电储能优化配置研究[J].智慧电力,2018,46(7):1-6.WU Feng,ZHANG Han.Study on optimized configuration of energy storage for photovoltaic power generation[J].Smart Power,2018,46(7):1-6.
[9]宁阳天,李相俊,董德华,等.储能系统平抑风光发电出力波动的研究方法综述[J].供用电,2017,34(4):2-11.NING Yangtian,LI Xiangjun,DONG Dehua,et al.A review of the research methods of smoothing wind/PV Power output with energy storage systems[J].Distribution&Utilization,2017,34(4):2-11.
[10]李姚旺,苗世洪,刘君瑶,等.考虑需求响应不确定性的光伏微电网储能系统优化配置[J].电力系统保护与控制,2018,46(20):69-77.LI Yaowang,MIAO Shihong,LIU Junyao,et al.Optimal allocation of energy storage system in PV micro grid considering uncertainty of demand response[J].Power System Protection and Control,2018,46(20):69-77.
[11]张远,曾杰,李庆生,等.微电网中光伏-储能协调控制策略的研究[J].广东电力,2014,27(8):10-14.ZHANG Yuan,ZENG Jie,LI Qingsheng,et al.Photovoltaic-energy storage coordination control strategy for micro grid[J].Guangdong Electric Power,2014,27(8):10-14.
[12]彭政,崔雪,王恒,等.考虑储能和需求侧响应的微网光伏消纳能力研究[J].电力系统保护与控制,2017,45(22):63-69.PENG Zheng,CUI Xue,WANG Heng,et al.Research on the accommodation of photovoltaic power considering storage system and demand response in microgrid[J].Power System Protection and Control,2017,45(22):63-69.
[13]廖强强,陆宇东,王栋,等.发电侧备用电池储能系统的技术经济分析[J].电力建设,2014,35(1):118-121.LIAO Qiangqiang,LU Yudong,WANG Dong,et al.Technical and economic analysis on energy storage system of standby battery for thermal power plants[J].Electric Power Construction,2014,35(1):118-121.
[14]叶季蕾,陶琼,薛金花,等.风电并网集成应用中的储能经济性进展分析[J].化工进展,2016,35(增刊2):137-143.YE Jilei,TAO Qiong,XUE Jinhua,et al.Economic progress analysis of energy storage in the application of wind power integration[J].Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress,2016,35(S2):137-143.
[15]肖立业.超导电力技术的现状和发展趋势[J].电网技术,2004,28(9):33-37.XIAO Liye.Present station and development trend of superconducting power technology[J].Power System Technology,2004,28(9):33-37.
[16]王超,苏伟,钟国彬,等.超级电容器及其在新能源领域的应用[J].广东电力,2015,28(12):46-52.WANG Chao,SU Wei,ZHONG Guobin,et al.Supercapacitor and its applications in the field of new energy[J].Guangdong Electric Power,2015,28(12):46-52.
[17]杨德志,沈佳妮,杨晓伟,等.石墨烯基超级电容器研究进展[J].储能科学与技术,2014,3(1):1-8.YANG Dezhi,SHEN Jiani,YANG Xiaowei,et al.Progress in graphene based supercapacitors[J].Energy Storage Science and Technology,2014,3(1):1-8.
[18]王江波,赵国亮,蒋晓春,等.飞轮储能技术在电网中的应用综述[J].电力电子技术,2013,47(7):28-30.WANG Jiangbo,ZHAO Guoliang,JIANG Xiaochun,et al.Overview on application of flywheel energy storage technology in power grid[J].Power Electronics,2013,47(7):28-30.
[19]王超,戴兴建,汪勇,等.储能复合材料飞轮研究进展[J].储能科学与技术,2017,6(5):1076-1083.WANG Chao,DAI Xingjian,WANG Yong,et al.Research progress of energy storage composite flywheel[J].Energy Storage Science and Technology,2017,6(5):1076-1083.
[20]孙振新,刘汉强,赵喆,等.储能经济性研究[J].中国电机工程学报,2013,33(增刊1):54-58.SUN Zhenxin,LIU Hanqiang,ZHAO Zhe,et al.Research on economical efficiency of energy storage[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2013,33(S1):54-58.
[21]纪律,刘畅,胡珊,等.中国电力储能应用的挑战与对策[J].高科技与产业化,2016(4):54-58.JI Lü,LIU Chang,HU Shan,et al.Challenge and countermeasures of electric energy storage application in China[J].High-Technology&Industrialization,2016(4):54-58.
[22]薛金花,叶季蕾,陶琼,等.采用全寿命周期成本模型的用户侧电池储能经济可行性研究[J].电网技术,2016,40(8):2471-2476.XUE Jinhua,YE Jilei,TAO Qiong,et al.Economic feasibility of user-side battery energy storage based on whole-life-cycle cost model[J].Power System Technology,2016,40(8):2471-2476.
[23]杨裕生,程杰,曹高萍.规模储能装置经济效益的判据[J].电池,2011,41(1):19-21.YANG Yusheng,CHENG Jie,CAO Gaoping.A gauge for direct economic benefits of energy storage devices[J].Battery Bimonthly,2011,41(1):19-21.
[24]刘坚.储能技术经济性现状及商业化运行障碍[J].中国能源,2017,39(7):36-40.LIU Jian.Economic status of energy storage technologies and business model barriers[J].Energy of China,2017,39(7):36-40.
[25]李娜,刘喜梅,白恺,等.梯次利用电池储能电站经济性评估方法研究[J].可再生能源,2017,35(6):926-932.LI Na,LIU Ximei,BAI Kai,et al.Research on the economic evaluation method of secondary battery energy storage[J].Renewable Energy Resources,2017,35(6):926-932.
[26]邢洁,曹哲,张怡,等.储能系统应用于用户侧的技术经济分析[J].电气应用,2017,36(1):26-30.XING Jie,CAO Zhe,ZHANG Yi,et al.[J].Technical and economic analysis on user-side energy storage system[J].Electrotechnical Application,2017,36(1):26-30.
[27]DARLING S B,YOU F,VESELKA T,et al.Assumptions and the levelized cost of energy for photovoltaics[J].Energy&Environmental Science,2011,4(9):3133-3139.
[28]UECKERDT F,HIRTH L,LUDERER G,et al.System lcoe:what are the costs of variable renewables[J].Energy,2013,63(1):61-75.
[29]刘喜梅,白恺,邓春,等.大型风电项目平准化成本模型研究[J].可再生能源,2016,34(12):1853-1858.LIU Ximei,BAI Kai,DENG Chun,et al.Research on levelized cost of energy model of large-scale wind power projects[J].Renewable Energy Resources,2016,34(12):1853-1858.
[30]陈大宇,张粒子,王澍,等.储能在美国调频市场中的发展及启示[J].电力系统自动化,2013,37(1):9-13.CHEN Dayu,ZHANG Lizi,WANG Shu,et al.Development of energy storage in frequency regulation market of U-nited States and its enlightenment[J].Automation of Electric Power Systems,2013,37(1):9-13.