开放存取期刊质量评价研究述评
|
摘要
开放存取期刊已逐渐成为科学研究免费共享的重要学术性资源之一。通过网络调查法和文献内容分析方法,从评价视角、评价方法与评价体系三方面对国内外有关开放存取期刊质量评价的文献进行梳理和比较分析。国内外开放存取期刊质量评价的研究视角主要集中在其学术影响力和期刊本身质量的评价;研究方法主要有引文分析法、网络计量法、同行评审法和综合评价法;评价指标体系的研究主要在兼顾传统的评价和开放存取期刊自身网络特征的综合评价。
Open access journals have gradually become one of the important academic resources for free sharing of scientific research.Through network survey method and literature content analysis method,the literature on quality evaluation of open-access journals at home and abroad are sorted out and compared from the perspective of evaluation,evaluation method and evaluation system.The evaluation of the quality of open-access journals at home and abroad mainly focuses on its academic influence and the evaluation of the quality of journals themselves.The research methods include citation analysis,network measurement,peer review and comprehensive evaluation.The research of evaluation index system is mainly concerned with the traditional evaluation and the comprehensive evaluation of the network characteristics of open access journals.
Open access journals have gradually become one of the important academic resources for free sharing of scientific research.Through network survey method and literature content analysis method,the literature on quality evaluation of open-access journals at home and abroad are sorted out and compared from the perspective of evaluation,evaluation method and evaluation system.The evaluation of the quality of open-access journals at home and abroad mainly focuses on its academic influence and the evaluation of the quality of journals themselves.The research methods include citation analysis,network measurement,peer review and comprehensive evaluation.The research of evaluation index system is mainly concerned with the traditional evaluation and the comprehensive evaluation of the network characteristics of open access journals.
引文
[1]胡明明.高校图书馆开放存取资源建设概述[J].当代经济,2017(9):138-139.
[2]黄如花.数字信息资源开放存取[M].武汉:武汉大学出版社,2017:15.
[3]AGYEI EAO,Pullen C.Open Access Initiative and Its Effect on the Quality of Scholarly Communication[J].Ghana Library Journal,2011(21):1-2.
[4]傅蓉.开放存取期刊及其影响分析[J].图书馆论坛,2007,27(4):122-125.
[5]潘琳.开放存取期刊的来源、分布与质量分析研究[J].山东图书馆学刊,2006(2):104-108.
[6]SOLOMO D J.The Role of Peer Review for Scholarly Journals in the information Age[J].Journal of Electronic Publishing,2007,10(1):62-77.
[7]DOAJ.Directory of open access journals[EB/OL].[2018-10-01].http://doaj.org/.
[8]马景娣.社会科学开放访问期刊及其学术影响力研究[J].情报资料工作,2005(2):47-49.
[9]胡德华.生物医学类OA期刊学术影响力评价研究[J].数字图书馆论坛,2009(6):19-25.
[10]INGWERSEN P.The calculation of Web Impact Factors[J],Journal of Documentation,1998,5(2):236-243.
[11]KURTZ M J,et al.Worldwide use and impact of the NASA Astrophysics Data System Digital Library[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2005,56(1):36-45.
[12]董文鸳,陈清文.图情领域开放存取期刊学术影响力评价[J].图书馆建设,2009(5):104-107.
[13]PIWOWAR,HEATHER,PRIEMU JASON.Introduction altmertrics:What,why and where?[J].Bulletin of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2013,39(4):8-13.
[14]孙晓菲,张婷,陈蕾.从开放存取到开放知识环境一一高校图书馆数字馆藏发展政策研究与实践[J].数字图书馆论坛,2015(12):45-46.
[15]陈铭.期刊利用统计与Altmetrics的兴起[J].图书与情报,2014(1):12-17.
[16]夏莉霞,方卿.国外开放存取期刊的质量评价与控制研究综述[J].信息资源管理学报,2011(2):49-54.
[17]XIA J F,MYERS R L,WILHOITE S K.Multiple open access availability and citation impact[J].Journal of Information Science,2011,37(1):19-29.
[18]XIA J F.Positioning Open Access Journals In a LISJournal Ranking[J].College&Research Libraries,2012,73(2):134-145.
[19]KOEHLER W,AGUILAR P,FINARELLI S,et al.A bibliometric analysis of select Information science print and electronic journals in the 1990s[J].Information Research,2000,6(1):88.
[20]赵清霞.开放存取期刊质量评价的相关问题思考[J].教育教学论坛,2012(3):123.
[21]SMITH A G.Citations and links as a measure of effectiveness of online LIS Journals[J],International Federation of Library Association Institution IFLIAJournal,2005,31(1):76-84.
[22]VAUGHAN L,SHAW D.Comparison of citation from ISI,Google,and Google Scholar:seeking Web indicators of impact[J].Scientometrics,2008,74(2):317-330.
[23]顾立平.开放数据计量研究综述:计算网络用户行为和科学社群影响力的Altmetrics计量[J].数字图书馆,2013(6):1-8.
[24]刘菊红,黄凯文.开放存取资源评价模式的研究:基于单篇论文质量评价[J].新世纪图书馆,2015(5):91-96.
[25]SUBER P.Open access overview:Focusing on open access to peer-reviewed research articles and their preprints[EB/OL].[2018-11-30].http://ww w.earlham.edu/-peters/fos/overview.html.
[26]徐芳.开放存取学术期刊质量评价方法的比较分析[J].图书馆杂志,2012,31(5):26-31.
[27]王秀成.科技期刊质量的层次分析综合评价法[J].文献学与文献工作,1989(5):14-19.
[28]陶雯,胡德华,曲艳吉.开放存取期刊质量评价方法研究[J].图书情报工作,2006(10):72-75.
[29]黄如花.数字信息资源开放存取[M]武汉:武汉大学出版社,2017:151-152.
[30]BORNMANN L,Daniel H D.The state of h index research is the h index the ideal way to measure research performance.Science and Society[J].EMBO reports,2009,10(1):2-6.
[31]夏莉霞,方卿.国外开放存取期刊的质量评价与控制研究综述[J].信息资源管理学报,2011(2):49-54.
[32]CHO S R.New evaluation indexes for articles and authors academic achievements based on Open Access Resources[J].Scienttometrics,2008,77(1):91-112.
[33]张红芹.开放获取期刊质量评价指标体系研究[D].南京农业大学,2007:6.
[34]叶继元,陈铭.开放存取期刊学术质量控制“全评价”体系研究---以“中国科技论文在线优秀期刊”为例[J].图书与情报,2013(2):81-87.
[35]MCCABE M J,SNYDER C M.A model of academic journal quality with applications to open access journals[EB/OL].[2018-11-20].http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/.
[36]黄如花.数字信息资源开放存取[M].武汉:武汉大学出版社,2017:160-161.
[37]ELBECK MATTHEW,MANDERNACH JEAN.Expanding the Value of Scholarly,Open Access E-journals[J].Library&Information Science Research,2008,30(4):237-241.
[2]黄如花.数字信息资源开放存取[M].武汉:武汉大学出版社,2017:15.
[3]AGYEI EAO,Pullen C.Open Access Initiative and Its Effect on the Quality of Scholarly Communication[J].Ghana Library Journal,2011(21):1-2.
[4]傅蓉.开放存取期刊及其影响分析[J].图书馆论坛,2007,27(4):122-125.
[5]潘琳.开放存取期刊的来源、分布与质量分析研究[J].山东图书馆学刊,2006(2):104-108.
[6]SOLOMO D J.The Role of Peer Review for Scholarly Journals in the information Age[J].Journal of Electronic Publishing,2007,10(1):62-77.
[7]DOAJ.Directory of open access journals[EB/OL].[2018-10-01].http://doaj.org/.
[8]马景娣.社会科学开放访问期刊及其学术影响力研究[J].情报资料工作,2005(2):47-49.
[9]胡德华.生物医学类OA期刊学术影响力评价研究[J].数字图书馆论坛,2009(6):19-25.
[10]INGWERSEN P.The calculation of Web Impact Factors[J],Journal of Documentation,1998,5(2):236-243.
[11]KURTZ M J,et al.Worldwide use and impact of the NASA Astrophysics Data System Digital Library[J].Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2005,56(1):36-45.
[12]董文鸳,陈清文.图情领域开放存取期刊学术影响力评价[J].图书馆建设,2009(5):104-107.
[13]PIWOWAR,HEATHER,PRIEMU JASON.Introduction altmertrics:What,why and where?[J].Bulletin of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2013,39(4):8-13.
[14]孙晓菲,张婷,陈蕾.从开放存取到开放知识环境一一高校图书馆数字馆藏发展政策研究与实践[J].数字图书馆论坛,2015(12):45-46.
[15]陈铭.期刊利用统计与Altmetrics的兴起[J].图书与情报,2014(1):12-17.
[16]夏莉霞,方卿.国外开放存取期刊的质量评价与控制研究综述[J].信息资源管理学报,2011(2):49-54.
[17]XIA J F,MYERS R L,WILHOITE S K.Multiple open access availability and citation impact[J].Journal of Information Science,2011,37(1):19-29.
[18]XIA J F.Positioning Open Access Journals In a LISJournal Ranking[J].College&Research Libraries,2012,73(2):134-145.
[19]KOEHLER W,AGUILAR P,FINARELLI S,et al.A bibliometric analysis of select Information science print and electronic journals in the 1990s[J].Information Research,2000,6(1):88.
[20]赵清霞.开放存取期刊质量评价的相关问题思考[J].教育教学论坛,2012(3):123.
[21]SMITH A G.Citations and links as a measure of effectiveness of online LIS Journals[J],International Federation of Library Association Institution IFLIAJournal,2005,31(1):76-84.
[22]VAUGHAN L,SHAW D.Comparison of citation from ISI,Google,and Google Scholar:seeking Web indicators of impact[J].Scientometrics,2008,74(2):317-330.
[23]顾立平.开放数据计量研究综述:计算网络用户行为和科学社群影响力的Altmetrics计量[J].数字图书馆,2013(6):1-8.
[24]刘菊红,黄凯文.开放存取资源评价模式的研究:基于单篇论文质量评价[J].新世纪图书馆,2015(5):91-96.
[25]SUBER P.Open access overview:Focusing on open access to peer-reviewed research articles and their preprints[EB/OL].[2018-11-30].http://ww w.earlham.edu/-peters/fos/overview.html.
[26]徐芳.开放存取学术期刊质量评价方法的比较分析[J].图书馆杂志,2012,31(5):26-31.
[27]王秀成.科技期刊质量的层次分析综合评价法[J].文献学与文献工作,1989(5):14-19.
[28]陶雯,胡德华,曲艳吉.开放存取期刊质量评价方法研究[J].图书情报工作,2006(10):72-75.
[29]黄如花.数字信息资源开放存取[M]武汉:武汉大学出版社,2017:151-152.
[30]BORNMANN L,Daniel H D.The state of h index research is the h index the ideal way to measure research performance.Science and Society[J].EMBO reports,2009,10(1):2-6.
[31]夏莉霞,方卿.国外开放存取期刊的质量评价与控制研究综述[J].信息资源管理学报,2011(2):49-54.
[32]CHO S R.New evaluation indexes for articles and authors academic achievements based on Open Access Resources[J].Scienttometrics,2008,77(1):91-112.
[33]张红芹.开放获取期刊质量评价指标体系研究[D].南京农业大学,2007:6.
[34]叶继元,陈铭.开放存取期刊学术质量控制“全评价”体系研究---以“中国科技论文在线优秀期刊”为例[J].图书与情报,2013(2):81-87.
[35]MCCABE M J,SNYDER C M.A model of academic journal quality with applications to open access journals[EB/OL].[2018-11-20].http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/.
[36]黄如花.数字信息资源开放存取[M].武汉:武汉大学出版社,2017:160-161.
[37]ELBECK MATTHEW,MANDERNACH JEAN.Expanding the Value of Scholarly,Open Access E-journals[J].Library&Information Science Research,2008,30(4):237-241.