水稻纹枯病生物防控研究进展
|
摘要
由立枯丝核菌(Rhizoctonia solani)侵染引起的纹枯病是水稻三大病害之一,也是一种危害遍布全球的水稻病害。鉴于水稻抗纹枯病育种至今尚未发现免疫或高抗品种,目前水稻纹枯病的防治主要依赖化学药物,从环境与人体安全的角度考虑,纹枯病的生物防控将是今后的发展方向。为此,本综述概述了目前对水稻纹枯病具有生物防控作用的真菌类拮抗微生物,如青霉和木霉,以及细菌类拮抗微生物,芽孢杆菌,假单胞菌和放线菌等;此外,本综述进一步探讨了如何提高水稻纹枯病生物防治效果以及新型生物防治的手段,如利用通过稻鸭共养模式和基因工程改造来进行生物防治。
Sheath blight caused by Rhizoctonia solani infection is one of the three major diseases of rice, and it is also a rice disease that is harmful all over the world. In view of the fact that no immune or high resistant varieties have been found in rice breeding for resistance to sheath blight, the prevention and control of rice sheath blight mainly depends on chemicals at present. From the point of view of environment and human safety, biological control of sheath blight will be the development direction in the future. Therefore, this study summarized the fungi antagonistic microbes, Penicillium and Trichoderma, bacteria antagonistic microbes, Bacillus spp., Pseudomonas pseudomonas and Actinomycetes, which have biological control effect on rice sheath blight so far. Besides, this review further discussed how to improve the biological control effect of rice sheath blight, as well as the new biological control methods, such as biological control by using rice-duck co-culture model and genetic engineering modification.
Sheath blight caused by Rhizoctonia solani infection is one of the three major diseases of rice, and it is also a rice disease that is harmful all over the world. In view of the fact that no immune or high resistant varieties have been found in rice breeding for resistance to sheath blight, the prevention and control of rice sheath blight mainly depends on chemicals at present. From the point of view of environment and human safety, biological control of sheath blight will be the development direction in the future. Therefore, this study summarized the fungi antagonistic microbes, Penicillium and Trichoderma, bacteria antagonistic microbes, Bacillus spp., Pseudomonas pseudomonas and Actinomycetes, which have biological control effect on rice sheath blight so far. Besides, this review further discussed how to improve the biological control effect of rice sheath blight, as well as the new biological control methods, such as biological control by using rice-duck co-culture model and genetic engineering modification.
引文
Cao Q.Q.,Zhou D.B.,and Zheng L.,2013,Screening,identification and cultivation conditions of microbes antagonistic to rice sheath blight fungus Rhizoctonia solani,Zhongguo Shengwu Fangzhi Xuebao(Chinese Journal of Biological Control),29(2):270-276(曹琦琦,周登博,郑丽,2013,水稻纹枯病菌拮抗菌的筛选、鉴定及培养条件探索,中国生物防治学报,29(2):270-276)
Chen D.,Ye B.,Liu Y.J.,Zhou X.Y.,Lei X.H.,Duan Y.M.,and Zhu H.J.,2015,Screening,identification and optimization of fermentation conditions of the antagonistic strain CZB40against Rhizoctonia solani,Zhiwu Baohu(Plant Protection),41(5):46-53(陈丹,叶波,刘燕娟,周鑫钰,雷湘华,段雍明,朱宏建,2015,水稻纹枯病菌拮抗菌CZB40的筛选、鉴定及其发酵条件优化,植物保护,41(5):46-53)
Chen L.J.,Yu Y.Y.,Wang C.,Ke H.J.,Liu H.X.,and Guo J.H.,2014,Preliminary research of mechanisms underlying Bacillus cereus AR156-mediated resistance to Rhizoctonia solani in rice,Zhongguo Shengwu Fangzhi Xuebao(Chinese J-ournal of Biological Control),30(1):107-112(陈刘军,俞仪阳,王超,柯红娇,刘红霞,郭坚华,2014,蜡质芽孢杆菌AR156防治水稻纹枯病机理初探,中国生物防治学报,30(1):107-112)
Chen Z.Y.,Xu Z.G.,Lu F.,Liu Y.F.,and Chen Y.L.,2000,Evaluation and utilization of antagonistic bacteria against rice sheath blight,Jiangsu Nongye Xuebao(Chinese Journal of Rice Science),16(3):148-152(陈志谊,许志刚,陆凡,刘永锋,陈毓苓,2000,拮抗细菌B-916培养液对水稻纹枯病菌的抗生活性及其抗菌物质的研究,江苏农业学报,16(3):148-152)
Harikrishnan H.,Shanmugaiah V.,Balasubramanian N.,Sharma M.P.,and Kotchoni S.O.,2014,Antagonistic potential of native strain Streptomyces aurantio griseus VSMGT1014 against sheath blight of rice disease,World J.Microbiol.Biotechnol.,30(12):3149-3161
Li S.S.,Cui L.L.,Cheng J.S.,Chen T.,Fu Y.P.,and Xie J.T.,2018,Assessment of two Trichoderma harzianum strains for biocontrol against rice sheath blight and growth promotion of rice,Zhiwu Bingli Xuebao(Acat Phytopathologica Sini ca),48(1):98-107(李松鹏,崔琳琳,程家森,陈桃,付艳苹,谢甲涛,2018,两株哈茨木霉菌株防治水稻纹枯病及促进水稻生长的潜力研究,植物病理学报,48(1):98-107)
Mathivanan N.,Prabavathy V.R.,and Vijayanandraj V.R.,2005,Application of talc formulations of Pseudomonas fluorescens Migula and Trichoderma viride Pers.ex S.F.Gray decrease the sheath blight disease and enhance the plant growth and yield in rice,J.Phytopathol.,153(12):697-701
Meng Q.Z.,Liu Z.H.,Wang H.Y.,Zhang S.S.,and Wei S.H.,2001,Research progress in rice sheath blight,Shenyang Nongye Daxue Xuebao(Journal of Shenyang Agricultural University),32(5):376-381(孟庆忠,刘志恒,王鹤影,张书绅,魏松红,2001,水稻纹枯病研究进展,沈阳农业大学学报,32(5):376-381)
Molla K.A.,Karmakar S.,Chanda P.K.,Ghosh S.,Sarkar S.N.,Datta S.K.,and Datta K.,2013,Rice oxalate oxidase gene driven by green tissue-specific promoter increases tolerance to sheath blight pathogen(Rhizoctonia solani)in transgenic rice,Mol.Plant Pathol.,14(9):910-922
Nagarajkumar M.,Jayaraj J.,Muthukrishnan S.,Bhaskaran R.,and Velazhahan R.,2005,Detoxification of oxalic acid by Pseudomonas fluorescens strain Pf MDU2:Implications for the biological control of rice sheath blight caused by Rhizoctonia solani,Microbiol Res.,160(3):291-298
Nie Y.F.,Liu Y.F.,Li D.Q.,Liu Y.Z.,Luo C.P.,and Chen Z.Y.,2007,Marine bacteria with antimicrobial activity against rice sheath blight,Jiangsu Nongye Xuebao(Jiangsu Journal of Agricultural Sciences),23(5):420-427(聂亚锋,刘永锋,李德全,刘邮洲,罗楚平,陈志谊,2007,海洋源拮抗细菌对水稻纹枯病的防治,江苏农业学报,23(5):420-427)
Padaria J.C.,Tarafdar A.,Raipuria R.,Lone S.A.,Gahlot P.,Shakil N.A.,and Kumar J.,2016,Identification of phenazine-1-carboxylic acid gene(phc CD)from Bacillus pumilus M-TCC7615 and its role in antagonism against Rhizoctonia solani,J.Basic Microbiol.,56(9):999-1008
Peng W.F.,Wu Z.M.,Chen W.,Zeng Y.J.,and Li K.T.,2016,Isolation and identification of Streptomyces triostinicus C2antagonizing on a variety of plant pathogenic fungi,Shengwu Jishu Tongbao(Biotechnology Bulletin),32(7):106-111(彭卫福,吴志明,陈未,曾勇军,李昆太,2016,拮抗多种植物病原真菌Streptomyces triostinicus C2的分离与鉴定,生物技术通报,32(7):106-111)
Peng D.,Li S.,Wang J.,Chen C.,and Zhou M.,2014,Integrated biological and chemical control of rice sheath blight by Bacillus subtilis NJ-18 and jinggangmycin,Pest Manag.Sci.,70(2):258-263
Qian Y.J.,Liao S.L.,Ma C.R.,Ba X.L.,and Wu Q.,2018,Effect of diazinomycin on rice sheath blight control and yield increase,Hubei Zhibao(Hubei Plant Protection),(3):5-6(钱艳杰,廖少龙,马呈瑞,巴晓林,武巧,2018,申嗪霉素对水稻纹枯病的防病增产效果,湖北植保,(3):5-6)
Ren X.P.,Xie G.L.,and Zhao L.H.,2005,Screening and utilization of antagonistic bacteria against rice sheath blight,Zhiwu Baohu Xuebao(Journal of Plant Protection),32(4):337-342(任小平,谢关林,赵丽涵,2005,水稻纹枯病拮抗细菌的筛选与利用,植物保护学报,32(4):337-342)
Sripriya R.,Parameswari C.,and Veluthambi K.,2017,Enhancement of sheath blight tolerance in transgenic rice by combined expression of tobacco osmotin(ap24)and rice chitinase(chi11)genes,In Vitro Cell.Dev-Pl.,53(1):12-21
Shanmugaiah V.,Mathivanan N.,and Varghese B.,2010,Purification,crystal structure and antimicrobial activity of phenazine-1-carboxamide produced by a growth-promoting biocontrol bacterium,Pseudomonas aeruginosa MML2212,J.Appl.Microbiol.,108(2):703-711
Shanmugam V.,Sriram S.,Babu S.,Nandakumar R.,Raguchander T.,Balasubramanian P.,and Samiyappan R.,2001,Purification and characterization of an extracellular alpha-glucosidase protein from Trichoderma viride which degrades a phytotoxin associated with sheath blight disease in rice,J.Appl.Microbiol.,90(3):320-329
Sriram S.,Raguchand er T.,Babu S.,Nandakumar R.,Shanmugam V.,Vidhyasekaran P.,Balasubramanian P.,and Samiyappan R.,2000,Inactivation of phytotoxin produced by the rice sheath blight pathogen Rhizoctonia solani,Can.J.Microbiol.,46(6):520-524
Sha S.,Liu L.,Pan S.,and Wang W.M.,2013,Isolation and purification of antifungal components from Trichoderma harzianum ferment broth by high-speed counter-current chromatography,Zhongguo Shengwu Fangzhi Xuebao(Chinese Journal of Biological Control),29(1):83-88(沙莎,刘雷,潘顺,王为民,2013,高速逆流色谱法从哈茨木霉发酵液中分离纯化抑菌活性成分,中国生物防治学报,29(1):83-88)
Wan M.G.,2008,Chracterization of the identity and biocontrol potential of a strain of Streptomyces F-1 isolated from rice,Dissertation for Ph.D.,Huazhong Agricultural University,Supervisor:Li G.Q.,pp.1(万明国,2008,源于水稻的链霉菌菌株F-1的鉴定及其防病潜力和防病机制研究,博士学位论文,华中农业大学,导师:李国庆,pp.1)
Wang Y.L.,Liu S.Y.,Mao X.Q.,Zhang Z.,Jiang H.,Chai R.Y.,Qiu H.P.,Wang J.Y.,Du X.F.,Li B.,and Sun G.C.,2013,Identification and characterization of rhizosphere fungal strain MF-91 antagonistic to rice blast and sheath blight pathogens,J.Appl.Microbiol.,114(5):1480-1490
Yang D.,Wang B.,Wang J.,Chen Y.,and Zhou M.,2009,Activity and efficacy of Bacillus subtillis strain NJ-18 against rice sheath blight and Sclerotinia stem rot of rape,Biol.Control,51(1):61-65
Zeng J.F.,1995,Antibiosis of the blue mold strain Z88on Rhizoctonia solani,Fujian Nongye Daxue Xuebao(Journal of Fujian Agricultural University),24(2):180-183(曾金凤,1995,青霉Z88菌株对水稻纹枯病菌的抗生作用,福建农业大学学报,24(2):180-183)
Zhang Y.X.,Wang D.B.,and Peng Y.F.,1996,Studies on the colonization of the biocontrol agent D93 strain on wheat roots,Journal Huazhong Agricultural University,15(1):18-23
Zheng A.P.,Li P.,Wang S.Q.,Wang L.X.,and Ma B.T.,2002,Screening,taxonomy of antagonistic strain B34 against Rhizoctonia solani and acquirement of the antiseptic protein,Zhongguo Shuidao Kexue(Chinese Journal of Rice Science),16(4):356-360(郑爱萍,李平,王世全,王玲霞,马炳田,2002,水稻纹枯病菌拮抗菌B34分离鉴定及杀菌蛋白的获得,中国水稻科学,16(4):356-360)
Zhu L.H.,Wan J.M.,and Shao Q.M.,1990,Breeding of resistant lines in indica rice and their genetic analysis of resisitance to bacterial blight,Nanjing Nongye Daxue Xuebao(Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University),13(1):13-18(朱立宏,万建民,邵启明,1990,籼稻抗白叶枯病衍生抗源选育及其遗传分析,南京农业大学学报,13(1):13-18)
Chen D.,Ye B.,Liu Y.J.,Zhou X.Y.,Lei X.H.,Duan Y.M.,and Zhu H.J.,2015,Screening,identification and optimization of fermentation conditions of the antagonistic strain CZB40against Rhizoctonia solani,Zhiwu Baohu(Plant Protection),41(5):46-53(陈丹,叶波,刘燕娟,周鑫钰,雷湘华,段雍明,朱宏建,2015,水稻纹枯病菌拮抗菌CZB40的筛选、鉴定及其发酵条件优化,植物保护,41(5):46-53)
Chen L.J.,Yu Y.Y.,Wang C.,Ke H.J.,Liu H.X.,and Guo J.H.,2014,Preliminary research of mechanisms underlying Bacillus cereus AR156-mediated resistance to Rhizoctonia solani in rice,Zhongguo Shengwu Fangzhi Xuebao(Chinese J-ournal of Biological Control),30(1):107-112(陈刘军,俞仪阳,王超,柯红娇,刘红霞,郭坚华,2014,蜡质芽孢杆菌AR156防治水稻纹枯病机理初探,中国生物防治学报,30(1):107-112)
Chen Z.Y.,Xu Z.G.,Lu F.,Liu Y.F.,and Chen Y.L.,2000,Evaluation and utilization of antagonistic bacteria against rice sheath blight,Jiangsu Nongye Xuebao(Chinese Journal of Rice Science),16(3):148-152(陈志谊,许志刚,陆凡,刘永锋,陈毓苓,2000,拮抗细菌B-916培养液对水稻纹枯病菌的抗生活性及其抗菌物质的研究,江苏农业学报,16(3):148-152)
Harikrishnan H.,Shanmugaiah V.,Balasubramanian N.,Sharma M.P.,and Kotchoni S.O.,2014,Antagonistic potential of native strain Streptomyces aurantio griseus VSMGT1014 against sheath blight of rice disease,World J.Microbiol.Biotechnol.,30(12):3149-3161
Li S.S.,Cui L.L.,Cheng J.S.,Chen T.,Fu Y.P.,and Xie J.T.,2018,Assessment of two Trichoderma harzianum strains for biocontrol against rice sheath blight and growth promotion of rice,Zhiwu Bingli Xuebao(Acat Phytopathologica Sini ca),48(1):98-107(李松鹏,崔琳琳,程家森,陈桃,付艳苹,谢甲涛,2018,两株哈茨木霉菌株防治水稻纹枯病及促进水稻生长的潜力研究,植物病理学报,48(1):98-107)
Mathivanan N.,Prabavathy V.R.,and Vijayanandraj V.R.,2005,Application of talc formulations of Pseudomonas fluorescens Migula and Trichoderma viride Pers.ex S.F.Gray decrease the sheath blight disease and enhance the plant growth and yield in rice,J.Phytopathol.,153(12):697-701
Meng Q.Z.,Liu Z.H.,Wang H.Y.,Zhang S.S.,and Wei S.H.,2001,Research progress in rice sheath blight,Shenyang Nongye Daxue Xuebao(Journal of Shenyang Agricultural University),32(5):376-381(孟庆忠,刘志恒,王鹤影,张书绅,魏松红,2001,水稻纹枯病研究进展,沈阳农业大学学报,32(5):376-381)
Molla K.A.,Karmakar S.,Chanda P.K.,Ghosh S.,Sarkar S.N.,Datta S.K.,and Datta K.,2013,Rice oxalate oxidase gene driven by green tissue-specific promoter increases tolerance to sheath blight pathogen(Rhizoctonia solani)in transgenic rice,Mol.Plant Pathol.,14(9):910-922
Nagarajkumar M.,Jayaraj J.,Muthukrishnan S.,Bhaskaran R.,and Velazhahan R.,2005,Detoxification of oxalic acid by Pseudomonas fluorescens strain Pf MDU2:Implications for the biological control of rice sheath blight caused by Rhizoctonia solani,Microbiol Res.,160(3):291-298
Nie Y.F.,Liu Y.F.,Li D.Q.,Liu Y.Z.,Luo C.P.,and Chen Z.Y.,2007,Marine bacteria with antimicrobial activity against rice sheath blight,Jiangsu Nongye Xuebao(Jiangsu Journal of Agricultural Sciences),23(5):420-427(聂亚锋,刘永锋,李德全,刘邮洲,罗楚平,陈志谊,2007,海洋源拮抗细菌对水稻纹枯病的防治,江苏农业学报,23(5):420-427)
Padaria J.C.,Tarafdar A.,Raipuria R.,Lone S.A.,Gahlot P.,Shakil N.A.,and Kumar J.,2016,Identification of phenazine-1-carboxylic acid gene(phc CD)from Bacillus pumilus M-TCC7615 and its role in antagonism against Rhizoctonia solani,J.Basic Microbiol.,56(9):999-1008
Peng W.F.,Wu Z.M.,Chen W.,Zeng Y.J.,and Li K.T.,2016,Isolation and identification of Streptomyces triostinicus C2antagonizing on a variety of plant pathogenic fungi,Shengwu Jishu Tongbao(Biotechnology Bulletin),32(7):106-111(彭卫福,吴志明,陈未,曾勇军,李昆太,2016,拮抗多种植物病原真菌Streptomyces triostinicus C2的分离与鉴定,生物技术通报,32(7):106-111)
Peng D.,Li S.,Wang J.,Chen C.,and Zhou M.,2014,Integrated biological and chemical control of rice sheath blight by Bacillus subtilis NJ-18 and jinggangmycin,Pest Manag.Sci.,70(2):258-263
Qian Y.J.,Liao S.L.,Ma C.R.,Ba X.L.,and Wu Q.,2018,Effect of diazinomycin on rice sheath blight control and yield increase,Hubei Zhibao(Hubei Plant Protection),(3):5-6(钱艳杰,廖少龙,马呈瑞,巴晓林,武巧,2018,申嗪霉素对水稻纹枯病的防病增产效果,湖北植保,(3):5-6)
Ren X.P.,Xie G.L.,and Zhao L.H.,2005,Screening and utilization of antagonistic bacteria against rice sheath blight,Zhiwu Baohu Xuebao(Journal of Plant Protection),32(4):337-342(任小平,谢关林,赵丽涵,2005,水稻纹枯病拮抗细菌的筛选与利用,植物保护学报,32(4):337-342)
Sripriya R.,Parameswari C.,and Veluthambi K.,2017,Enhancement of sheath blight tolerance in transgenic rice by combined expression of tobacco osmotin(ap24)and rice chitinase(chi11)genes,In Vitro Cell.Dev-Pl.,53(1):12-21
Shanmugaiah V.,Mathivanan N.,and Varghese B.,2010,Purification,crystal structure and antimicrobial activity of phenazine-1-carboxamide produced by a growth-promoting biocontrol bacterium,Pseudomonas aeruginosa MML2212,J.Appl.Microbiol.,108(2):703-711
Shanmugam V.,Sriram S.,Babu S.,Nandakumar R.,Raguchander T.,Balasubramanian P.,and Samiyappan R.,2001,Purification and characterization of an extracellular alpha-glucosidase protein from Trichoderma viride which degrades a phytotoxin associated with sheath blight disease in rice,J.Appl.Microbiol.,90(3):320-329
Sriram S.,Raguchand er T.,Babu S.,Nandakumar R.,Shanmugam V.,Vidhyasekaran P.,Balasubramanian P.,and Samiyappan R.,2000,Inactivation of phytotoxin produced by the rice sheath blight pathogen Rhizoctonia solani,Can.J.Microbiol.,46(6):520-524
Sha S.,Liu L.,Pan S.,and Wang W.M.,2013,Isolation and purification of antifungal components from Trichoderma harzianum ferment broth by high-speed counter-current chromatography,Zhongguo Shengwu Fangzhi Xuebao(Chinese Journal of Biological Control),29(1):83-88(沙莎,刘雷,潘顺,王为民,2013,高速逆流色谱法从哈茨木霉发酵液中分离纯化抑菌活性成分,中国生物防治学报,29(1):83-88)
Wan M.G.,2008,Chracterization of the identity and biocontrol potential of a strain of Streptomyces F-1 isolated from rice,Dissertation for Ph.D.,Huazhong Agricultural University,Supervisor:Li G.Q.,pp.1(万明国,2008,源于水稻的链霉菌菌株F-1的鉴定及其防病潜力和防病机制研究,博士学位论文,华中农业大学,导师:李国庆,pp.1)
Wang Y.L.,Liu S.Y.,Mao X.Q.,Zhang Z.,Jiang H.,Chai R.Y.,Qiu H.P.,Wang J.Y.,Du X.F.,Li B.,and Sun G.C.,2013,Identification and characterization of rhizosphere fungal strain MF-91 antagonistic to rice blast and sheath blight pathogens,J.Appl.Microbiol.,114(5):1480-1490
Yang D.,Wang B.,Wang J.,Chen Y.,and Zhou M.,2009,Activity and efficacy of Bacillus subtillis strain NJ-18 against rice sheath blight and Sclerotinia stem rot of rape,Biol.Control,51(1):61-65
Zeng J.F.,1995,Antibiosis of the blue mold strain Z88on Rhizoctonia solani,Fujian Nongye Daxue Xuebao(Journal of Fujian Agricultural University),24(2):180-183(曾金凤,1995,青霉Z88菌株对水稻纹枯病菌的抗生作用,福建农业大学学报,24(2):180-183)
Zhang Y.X.,Wang D.B.,and Peng Y.F.,1996,Studies on the colonization of the biocontrol agent D93 strain on wheat roots,Journal Huazhong Agricultural University,15(1):18-23
Zheng A.P.,Li P.,Wang S.Q.,Wang L.X.,and Ma B.T.,2002,Screening,taxonomy of antagonistic strain B34 against Rhizoctonia solani and acquirement of the antiseptic protein,Zhongguo Shuidao Kexue(Chinese Journal of Rice Science),16(4):356-360(郑爱萍,李平,王世全,王玲霞,马炳田,2002,水稻纹枯病菌拮抗菌B34分离鉴定及杀菌蛋白的获得,中国水稻科学,16(4):356-360)
Zhu L.H.,Wan J.M.,and Shao Q.M.,1990,Breeding of resistant lines in indica rice and their genetic analysis of resisitance to bacterial blight,Nanjing Nongye Daxue Xuebao(Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University),13(1):13-18(朱立宏,万建民,邵启明,1990,籼稻抗白叶枯病衍生抗源选育及其遗传分析,南京农业大学学报,13(1):13-18)