基于三角模糊数层次分析法的工程造价司法鉴定人综合素质评估研究
|
摘要
全面科学地评估工程造价司法鉴定人的综合素质,优化鉴定人员队伍结构,可以提高工程造价鉴定的效率。采用文献调查法对鉴定人素质要求进行整合提炼,通过德尔菲法筛选并确定素质评价指标。结合现有的素质理论,构建了由4个一级指标和14个二级指标组成的工程造价司法鉴定人综合素质评价指标体系,并运用三角模糊数层次分析法确定各评价指标的相对重要性,为更准确地评估工程造价司法鉴定人的综合素质提供参考。研究发现,职业道德是评估工程造价司法鉴定人综合素质最重要的指标,主要体现在鉴定人是否故意出具虚假鉴定结果及是否收受贿赂。
In order to evaluate the comprehensive quality of judicial appraiser in a scientific manner,this study uses the method of literature review to integrate and refine the quality requirements of appraisers. Quality evaluation index is screened and determined by Delphi method. Combining with the existing theory of quality,this study constructs the comprehensive quality evaluation index system of project cost judicial appraiser including 4 first level indicators and 14 second level indicators. Triangle fuzzy number analytic hierarchy process is used to determine the weight of each evaluation index and provide a reference for the accurate evaluation of the comprehensive quality of project cost judicial appraisers. Finally,it is found that the professional ethics of judicial appraisers is an important index to evaluate their comprehensive quality, which is mainly reflected in whether the appraiser intentionally produces false identification results and whether he accepts bribes.
In order to evaluate the comprehensive quality of judicial appraiser in a scientific manner,this study uses the method of literature review to integrate and refine the quality requirements of appraisers. Quality evaluation index is screened and determined by Delphi method. Combining with the existing theory of quality,this study constructs the comprehensive quality evaluation index system of project cost judicial appraiser including 4 first level indicators and 14 second level indicators. Triangle fuzzy number analytic hierarchy process is used to determine the weight of each evaluation index and provide a reference for the accurate evaluation of the comprehensive quality of project cost judicial appraisers. Finally,it is found that the professional ethics of judicial appraisers is an important index to evaluate their comprehensive quality, which is mainly reflected in whether the appraiser intentionally produces false identification results and whether he accepts bribes.
引文
[1]朱化武,高长春,陈建永.工程造价司法鉴定实务[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2014:6.
[2]王芳.全科医生综合素质评价指标体系的构建研究[D].青岛:青岛大学,2017:8.
[3]陈晨,吴超仲.基于三角模糊数层次分析法的驾驶人综合素质评估研究[J].武汉理工大学学报,2012,6(3):479-483.
[4]周月萍.工程造价司法鉴定应注意哪些问题[N].建筑时报,2016-8-4(7).
[5]郭兆碧.工程造价司法鉴定存在问题的思考[J].中国住宅设施,2017(4):105-106.
[6]邱林.工程造价咨询执业风险与控制探讨[J].建筑经济,2016,37(12):73-76.
[7]陈兰芳.建设工程施工合同纠纷案中造价鉴定问题研究[J].中国住宅设施,2017(3):88-89.
[8]侯芳芳.司法实务中建设工程造价鉴定注意事项[J].门窗,2016(12):74-75.
[9]陈垠亭.浅谈工程造价咨询机构如何做好司法鉴定业务[J].科技创新导报,2014(17):217.
[10]何丽琴.浅谈工程造价鉴定的主体[J].建设管理,2014(12):34-35.
[11]曹淑萍,张建军.如何做好工程造价司法鉴定[J].建设管理,2014(12):36-39.
[12]林文学.工程造价鉴定司法实务研究[J].北京仲裁,2015(90):45-54.
[13]孙凌志,孙丽伟,孟尚臻.建设工程造价咨询规范研究[J].工程管理学报,2016,30(1):26-31.
[2]王芳.全科医生综合素质评价指标体系的构建研究[D].青岛:青岛大学,2017:8.
[3]陈晨,吴超仲.基于三角模糊数层次分析法的驾驶人综合素质评估研究[J].武汉理工大学学报,2012,6(3):479-483.
[4]周月萍.工程造价司法鉴定应注意哪些问题[N].建筑时报,2016-8-4(7).
[5]郭兆碧.工程造价司法鉴定存在问题的思考[J].中国住宅设施,2017(4):105-106.
[6]邱林.工程造价咨询执业风险与控制探讨[J].建筑经济,2016,37(12):73-76.
[7]陈兰芳.建设工程施工合同纠纷案中造价鉴定问题研究[J].中国住宅设施,2017(3):88-89.
[8]侯芳芳.司法实务中建设工程造价鉴定注意事项[J].门窗,2016(12):74-75.
[9]陈垠亭.浅谈工程造价咨询机构如何做好司法鉴定业务[J].科技创新导报,2014(17):217.
[10]何丽琴.浅谈工程造价鉴定的主体[J].建设管理,2014(12):34-35.
[11]曹淑萍,张建军.如何做好工程造价司法鉴定[J].建设管理,2014(12):36-39.
[12]林文学.工程造价鉴定司法实务研究[J].北京仲裁,2015(90):45-54.
[13]孙凌志,孙丽伟,孟尚臻.建设工程造价咨询规范研究[J].工程管理学报,2016,30(1):26-31.