汪楫的钓鱼岛诗歌及相关问题考略
|
摘要
罗时进先生的论文《明清钓鱼岛诗歌及其相关文献考述》是近年钓鱼岛诗歌研究的力作,考证细密、意蕴深远,但其间可补遗处有二:一是其文所列清代册封琉球正使汪楫的钓鱼岛诗歌有《中流》诗二首,实则其《神飙》诗也关涉钓鱼岛;其二,罗文称朱彝尊所作《题汪检讨楫乘风破浪图》诗"似未流传",实则该诗收在朱氏早年刊刻的《腾笑集》中。汪楫等人的钓鱼岛诗歌不仅具有纪行抒怀的文学价值,且对论定钓鱼岛的中国归属权也有重要支撑作用,于此可见"钓鱼岛文学文献"的整理与研究的必要性和迫切性。
Imperial Chinese messengers to Ryukyu Kingdom had written many poems about the Diaoyu Islands, including Wang Ji's two poems named Zhongliu. Mr. Luo Shijin referred to it in his paper Diaoyu Islands Poetry and Related Literature in the Ming and Qing Dynasties.In fact, Wang Ji's another poem named Magic Hurricane related to the Diaoyu Islands. Mr. Luo Shijin also supposed that the poem An Inscription for Wang Ji's Painting of Ride the Wind and Waves by Zhu Yizun was lost. As a matter of fact, this poem was recorded in Zhu Yizu's Tengxiao Collection of Peoms. In a word, Wang Ji 's poem, Magic Hurricane shows how necessary and urgent to collate and study literary documents about the Diaoyu Islands.
Imperial Chinese messengers to Ryukyu Kingdom had written many poems about the Diaoyu Islands, including Wang Ji's two poems named Zhongliu. Mr. Luo Shijin referred to it in his paper Diaoyu Islands Poetry and Related Literature in the Ming and Qing Dynasties.In fact, Wang Ji's another poem named Magic Hurricane related to the Diaoyu Islands. Mr. Luo Shijin also supposed that the poem An Inscription for Wang Ji's Painting of Ride the Wind and Waves by Zhu Yizun was lost. As a matter of fact, this poem was recorded in Zhu Yizu's Tengxiao Collection of Peoms. In a word, Wang Ji 's poem, Magic Hurricane shows how necessary and urgent to collate and study literary documents about the Diaoyu Islands.
引文
[1]刘江永.钓鱼岛列岛归属考:事实与法理[M].北京:人民出版社,2016.
[2]汪楫.观海集[M]//《清代诗文集汇编》编纂委员会.清代诗文集汇编(140册).上海:上海古籍出版社,2010.
[3]汪楫.使琉球杂录[M]//黄润华.国家图书馆藏琉球资料汇编(上册),北京:北京图书馆出版社,2000:872-873.
[4]井上清.钓鱼岛的历史与主权[M].贾俊琪,译.北京:新星出版社,2013:44-45.
[5]范成大.范成大诗集[M]//北京大学古文献研究所.全宋诗(第41册).北京:北京大学出版社,1998:25935-25936.
[6]陈铁民.王维集校注[M].北京:中华书局,1997:174-175.
[7]罗时进.明清钓鱼岛诗歌及其相关文献考述[J].文学遗产,2014(1):1-16.
[8]朱彝尊.腾笑集[M].上海:上海古籍出版社,1979:55-58.
[9]阮元.广陵诗事[M]//王云五.丛书集成初编(第2605册).北京:中华书局,1985:2.
[10]夏敏.中琉邦交语境中的涉琉文学境中的涉琉文学[N].中国社会科学报,2014-3-12(B05).
[11]韩结根.钓鱼岛历史真相[M].上海:复旦大学出版社,北京:海豚出版社,2014.
[12]姜鹏,罗时进.清嘉庆赵文楷钓鱼岛诗歌写作考述——以赵朴初先生二通书札为中心的讨论[J].苏州大学学报,2013(4):158-162.
[13]李鼎元.使琉球记[M]//沈云龙.近代中国史料丛刊(第472册).台北:文海出版社,1966:112-113.
[2]汪楫.观海集[M]//《清代诗文集汇编》编纂委员会.清代诗文集汇编(140册).上海:上海古籍出版社,2010.
[3]汪楫.使琉球杂录[M]//黄润华.国家图书馆藏琉球资料汇编(上册),北京:北京图书馆出版社,2000:872-873.
[4]井上清.钓鱼岛的历史与主权[M].贾俊琪,译.北京:新星出版社,2013:44-45.
[5]范成大.范成大诗集[M]//北京大学古文献研究所.全宋诗(第41册).北京:北京大学出版社,1998:25935-25936.
[6]陈铁民.王维集校注[M].北京:中华书局,1997:174-175.
[7]罗时进.明清钓鱼岛诗歌及其相关文献考述[J].文学遗产,2014(1):1-16.
[8]朱彝尊.腾笑集[M].上海:上海古籍出版社,1979:55-58.
[9]阮元.广陵诗事[M]//王云五.丛书集成初编(第2605册).北京:中华书局,1985:2.
[10]夏敏.中琉邦交语境中的涉琉文学境中的涉琉文学[N].中国社会科学报,2014-3-12(B05).
[11]韩结根.钓鱼岛历史真相[M].上海:复旦大学出版社,北京:海豚出版社,2014.
[12]姜鹏,罗时进.清嘉庆赵文楷钓鱼岛诗歌写作考述——以赵朴初先生二通书札为中心的讨论[J].苏州大学学报,2013(4):158-162.
[13]李鼎元.使琉球记[M]//沈云龙.近代中国史料丛刊(第472册).台北:文海出版社,1966:112-113.