华北恒山—宣化—兴和地区基性岩墙是赞岐岩吗?
详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |
  • 英文篇名:Are Those Mafic Dikes in Hengshan-Xuanhua-Xinghe Area of North China Sanukitoids?
  • 作者:张继 ; 程素华
  • 英文作者:ZHANG Ji;CHENG Su-hua;School of Earth Sciences and Resources,China University of Geosciences;
  • 关键词:赞岐岩 ; 基性岩墙 ; 热俯冲 ; 板内裂解 ; 结晶分离作用 ; 地壳混染作用 ; 高铁玄武岩 ; 华北
  • 英文关键词:sanukitoid;;mafic dike;;hot subduction;;intraplate rifting;;fractional crystallization;;crustal contamination;;ferrobasalt;;North China
  • 中文刊名:XAGX
  • 英文刊名:Journal of Earth Sciences and Environment
  • 机构:中国地质大学(北京)地球科学与资源学院;
  • 出版日期:2017-01-15
  • 出版单位:地球科学与环境学报
  • 年:2017
  • 期:v.39;No.152
  • 基金:国家自然科学基金项目(41102122,40972125)
  • 语种:中文;
  • 页:XAGX201701005
  • 页数:18
  • CN:01
  • ISSN:61-1423/P
  • 分类号:69-86
摘要
在以往的研究中,华北恒山—宣化—兴和地区基性岩墙所代表的是一种裂解伸展构造背景,但近年来有研究提出这些基性岩墙可能为赞岐岩,代表了俯冲汇聚构造背景,因此,广泛出露于恒山—宣化—兴和地区的大量元古代基性岩墙是否为赞岐岩,对于明确该地区在古元古代是汇聚还是伸展构造背景具有重要科学意义。恒山—兴和—宣化地区岩石手标本可见典型的辉绿结构。恒山地区岩墙岩石主要由具角闪石后成合晶的辉石、自形的斜长石和石榴石组成;兴和地区岩墙岩石主要由角闪石和中性斜长石组成,角闪石填充在斜长石组成的三角形"骨架"中;宣化地区样品岩石薄片镜下无明显的辉绿结构,由石榴石、斜长石、单斜辉石、斜方辉石、角闪石组成。恒山、宣化地区样品岩石主量元素特征为高铁高镁富钛,略富集相容元素和不相容元素,且轻稀土元素较重稀土元素富集,与赞岐岩的地球化学标准不尽相似。兴和地区样品Mg#值偏低,但同样富铁富钛,更富集不相容元素,未见明显富集相容元素,与赞岐岩的地球化学标准相差较大。因此,华北恒山—宣化—兴和地区基性岩墙不属于赞岐岩,而为高铁玄武岩,且经历了一定程度的结晶分离作用和地壳混染作用,很可能属于板内裂解的产物。
        In previous study,the mafic dikes in Hengshan-Xuanhua-Xinghe area of North China have been thought as the production of rifting and extension;some papers have already claimed that those mafic dikes may be sanukitouids.Therefore,the definition of those mafic dikes is of important significance to distinguish the tectonic background of subduction or extensional tectonic background.The hand specimens of rocks in Hengshan-Xuanhua-Xinghe area have typical ophitic texture.The mafic dikes in Hengshan area are made up of pyroxene with amphibole-symplektite,idiomorphic plagioclase and garnet;the mafic dikes in Xinghe area consist of andesine,amphibole and the amphibole fills into the triangle"skeleton"which is made up of plagioclase;and the mafic dikes in Xuanhua area without obvious ophitic texture consist of garnet, plagioclase,clinopyroxene,orthopyroxene and amphibole.Compared with the geochemistry standard of sanukitoids,the samples in Hengshan and Xuanhua areas are rich in FeOT,MgO and TiO_2,lightly rich in both compatible and incompatible elements,and whats more,the contents of lightrare earth elements are much more than those of heavy rare earth elements.However,the samples in Xinghe area,which are very different from sanukitoids,are also rich in FeOT and TiO_2,and richer in incompatible elements,but with lower Mg#,and the compatible elements are not that rich.Therefore,those mafic dikes in Hengshan-Xuanhua-Xinghe area of North China are not typical sanukitoids,but belong to the ferrobasalts.They have experienced a degree of fractional crystallization and crustal contamination,and may be the production of intraplate rifting.
引文
[1]张旗,钱青,翟明国,等.Sanukite(赞岐岩)的地球化学特征、成因及其地球动力学意义[J].岩石矿物学杂志,2005,24(2):117-125.ZHANG Qi,QIAN Qing,ZHAI Ming-guo,et al.Geochemistry,Petrogenesis and Geodynamic Implications of Sanukite[J].Acta Petrologica et Mineralogica,2005,24(2):117-125.
    [2]SHIREY S B,HANSON G N.Mantle-derived Archaean Monozodiorites and Trachyandesites[J].Nature,1984,310:222-224.
    [3]LOBACH-ZHUCHENKO S B,ROLLINSON H R,CHEKULAEV V P,et al.The Archaean Sanukitoid Series of the Baltic Shield:Geological Setting,Geochemical Characteristics and Implications for Their Origin[J].Lithos,2005,79(1/2):107-128.
    [4]王仁民,刘璐璐.正确识别GMM岩套体系[C]∥中国地质学会.2012年全国岩石学与地球动力学研讨会论文集.北京:地质出版社,2012:540-541.WANG Ren-min,LIU Lu-lu.How to Identify GMM Rock Suits[C]∥Geological Society of China.Proceedings of the National Petrology and Geodynamics Conference in 2012.Beijing:Geological Publishing House,2012:540-541.
    [5]TATSUMI Y,ISHIZAKA K.Origin of High-magnesian Andesites in the Setouchi Volcanic Belt,Southwest Japan:I.Petrographical and Chemical Characteristics[J].Earth and Planetary Science Letters,1982,60(2):293-304.
    [6]LAURENT O,MARTIN H,MOYEN J F,et al.The Diversity and Evolution of Late-Archean Granitoids:Evidence for the Onset of“Modern-style”Plate Tectonics Between 3.0and 2.5Ga[J].Lithos,2014,205:208-235.
    [7]MARTIN H,SMITHIES R H,RAPP R,et al.An Overview of Adakite,Tonalite-trondhjemite-granodiorite(TTG),and Sanukitoid:Relationships and Some Implications for Crustal Evolution[J].Lithos,2005,79(1/2):1-24.
    [8]MARTIN H,MOYEN J F,RAPP R.The Sanukitoid Series:Magmatism at the Archaean-proterozoic Transition[J].Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh,2009,100(1/2):15-33.
    [9]SMITHIES R H,CHAMPION D C.High-Mg Diorite from the Archaean Pilbara Craton;Anorogenic Magmas Derived from a Subduction-modified Mantle[J].Geological Survey of Western Australia,Annual Review,1998,99:45-59.
    [10]STEVENSON R,HENRY P,GARIEPY C,et al.Assimilation-fractional Crystallization Origin of Archean Sanukitoid Suites:Western Superior Province,Canada[J].Precambrian Research,1999,96(1/2):83-99.
    [11]MOYEN J F,MARTIN H,JAYANANDA M.Origin of the Late-Archean Granite of Closepet,South India:Information from Geochemical Modeling of Trace Element Behaviour[J].SeriesⅡA:Earth and Planetary Science,1997,325(9):659-664.
    [12]STERN R A,HANSON G N.Archean High-Mg Granodiorite:A Derivative of Light Rare Earth Element-enriched Monzodiorite of Mantle Origin[J].Journal of Petrology,1991,32(1):201-238.
    [13]RAPP R P,SHIMIZU N,NORMAN M D,et al.Reaction Between Slab-derived Melts and Peridotite in the Mantle Wedge:Experimental Constraints at 3.8GPa[J].Chemical Geology,1999,160(4):335-356.
    [14]HALLA J.Late Archean High-Mg Granitoids(Sanukitoids)in the Southern Karelian Domain,Eastern Finland:Pb and Nd Isotopic Constraints on Crustmantle Interactions[J].Lithos,2005,79(1/2):161-178.
    [15]SHIMODA G,TATSUMI Y,NOHDA S,et al.Setouchi High-Mg Andesites Revisited:Geochemical Evidence for Melting of Subducting Sediments[J].Earth and Planetary Science Letters,1998,160(3/4):479-492.
    [16]KOVALENKO A,CLEMENS J D,SAVATENKOV V.Petrogenetic Constraints for the Genesis of Archaean Sanukitoid Suites:Geochemistry and Isotopic Evidence from Karelia,Baltic Shield[J].Lithos,2005,79(1/2):147-160.
    [17]KOVALENKO A V.Sm-Nd Data as a Key to the Origin of the Archean Sanukitoids of Karelia,Baltic Shield[J].Geochemistry International,2008,46(4):367-377.
    [18]OLIVEIRA M A D,DALLAGNOL R,ALTHOFF F J,et al.Mesoarchean Sanukitoid Rocks of the Rio Maria Granite-greenstone Terrane,Amazonian Craton,Brazil[J].Journal of South American Earth Sciences,2009,27(2/3):146-160.
    [19]MOYEN J F,MARTIN H,JAYANANDA M,et al.Late Archaean Granites:A Typology Based on the Dharwar Craton(India)[J].Precambrian Research,2003,127(1/2/3):103-123.
    [20]王仁民,刘永顺,倪志耀,等.古洋求索录[M].北京:地质出版社,2014.WANG Ren-min,LIU Yong-shun,NI Zhi-yao,et al.The Research of Archean Oceanic Crust[M].Beijing:Geological Publishing House,2014.
    [21]陈红杰,王仁民,刘永顺,等.怀安瓦窑口赞岐岩(Sanukitoid)的特征和成因研究[C]∥中国地质学会.2013年全国岩石学与地球动力学研讨会论文集.北京:地质出版社,2013:76-77.CHEN Hong-jie,WANG Ren-min,LIU Yong-shun,et al.The Research on the Feature and Genesis of Wayaokou Sanukitoids in Huaian[C]∥Geological Society of China.Proceedings of the National Petrology and Geodynamics Conference in 2013.Beijing:Geological Publishing House,2013:76-77.
    [22]刘璐璐,王仁民,陈红杰,等.双庙富钾高铬花岗岩的成因探讨[C]∥中国地质学会.2013年全国岩石学与地球动力学研讨会论文集.北京:地质出版社,2013:97.LIU Lu-lu,WANG Ren-min,CHEN Hong-jie,et al.The Discussion on Genesis of K-riched High-Cr Granite in Shuangmiao[C]∥Geological Society of China.Proceedings of the National Petrology and Geodynamics Conference Proceedings in 2013.Beijing:Geological Publishing House,2013:97.
    [23]陈红杰.冀西北晚太古代赞岐岩类及其构造意义研究[D].北京:首都师范大学,2014.CHEN Hong-jie.The Research of Late Archean Sanukitoids in the Northwest Hebei Province and Its Implication for the Tectonic Evolution[D].Bejing:Capital Normal University,2014.
    [24]张旗,王焰,钱青,等.晚太古代Sanukite(赞岐岩)与地球早期演化[J].岩石学报,2004,20(6):1355-1362.ZHANG Qi,WANG Yan,QIAN Qing,et al.Sanukite of Late Archaean and Early Earth Evolution[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,2004,20(6):1355-1362.
    [25]边红业,吉峰,表尚虎.大兴安岭富西里地区赞岐岩-(石英)二长闪长岩LA-ICP-MS锆石U-Pb定年及其地质意义[J].世界地质,2014,33(4):768-779.BIAN Hong-ye,JI Feng,BIAO Shang-hu.LA-ICPMS Zircon U-Pb Dating of Sanukite-(Quartz)Monzodiorite in Fuxili Area,Daxinganling and Its Geological Significance[J].Global Geology,2014,33(4):768-779.
    [26]张旗,金惟俊,王元龙,等.晚中生代中国东部高原北界探讨[J].岩石学报,2007,23(4):689-700.ZHANG Qi,JIN Wei-jun,WANG Yuan-long,et al.Discussion of North Boundary of the East China Plateau During Late Mesozoic Era[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,2007,23(4):689-700.
    [27]彭松柏,刘松峰,林木森,等.华夏早古生代俯冲作用(Ⅱ):大爽高镁-镁质安山岩新证据[J].地球科学,2016,41(6):931-947.PENG Song-bai,LIU Song-feng,LIN Mu-sen,et al.Early Paleozoic Subduction in Cathaysia(Ⅱ):New Evidence from the Dashuang High Magnesian-magnesian Andesite[J].Earth Science,2016,41(6):931-947.
    [28]袁玲玲,张晓晖,翟明国,等.富闪深成岩的成因及其地球动力学意义[J].岩石学报,2016,32(5):1556-1570.YUAN Ling-ling,ZHANG Xiao-hui,ZHAI Mingguo,et al.Petrogenesis and Geodynamic Implications of Appinite Suite[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,2016,32(5):1556-1570.
    [29]孙勇,李永军,杨高学,等.西准噶尔谢米斯台山西缘火山岩岩石地球化学特征及其地质意义[J].矿物岩石地球化学通报,2015,34(2):387-394.SUN Yong,LI Yong-jun,YANG Gao-xue,et al.Geochemical and Geological Significance of the Volcanic Rocks in the West of the Xiemisitai Mountain,West Junggar[J].Bulletin of Mineralogy,Petrology and Geochemistry,2015,34(2):387-394.
    [30]简平,张旗,刘敦一,等.内蒙古固阳晚太古代赞岐岩(Sanukite):角闪花岗岩的SHRIMP定年及其意义[J].岩石学报,2005,21(1):151-157.JIAN Ping,ZHANG Qi,LIU Dun-yi,et al.SHRIMP Dating and Geological Significance of Late Archean High-Mg Diorite(Sanukite)and Hornblende-granite at Guyang of Inner Mongolia[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,2005,21(1):151-157.
    [31]钟长汀,毛德宝,刘丽萍,等.内蒙古大青山新太古代—古元古代赞岐状岩和富Nb辉长岩的特征及其对成矿作用的制约[C]∥中国地质学会.第八届全国矿床会议论文集.北京:地质出版社,2006:305-310.ZHONG Chang-ting,MAO De-bao,LIU Li-ping,et al.The Features of Neoarchean-Paleoproterozoic Sanukitevlike Rocks and Nb-enriched Gabbro in Daqingshan of Inner Mongolia and Its Influence on Mineralization[C]∥Geological Society of China.Proceedings of the Eighth National Conference on Mineral Deposits.Beijing:Geological Publishing House,2006:305-310.
    [32]钟长汀,席忠,赵维宽,等.内蒙古大青山地区金矿床类型、控矿规律及找矿方向[J].地质调查与研究,2005,28(4):240-249.ZHONG Chang-ting,XI Zhong,ZHAO Wei-kuan,et al.Types,Metallotects and Exploration Direction of the Gold Deposit in Daqingshan,Inner Mongolia[J].Geological Survey and Research,2005,28(4):240-249.
    [33]钟长汀,邓晋福,万渝生,等.内蒙古大青山地区古元古代花岗岩:地球化学、锆石SHRIMP定年及其地质意义[J].岩石学报,2014,30(11):3172-3188.ZHONG Chang-ting,DENG Jin-fu,WAN Yu-sheng,et al.Paleoproterozoic Granitoids in the Daqingshan Mountain Area,Inner Mongolia:Geochemistry,SHRIMP Zircon Dating and Geological Significance[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,2014,30(11):3172-3188.
    [34]HEILIMO E,HALLA J,HUHMA H.Single-grain Zircon U-Pb Age Constraints of the Western and Eastern Sanukitoid Zones in the Finnish Part of the Karelian Province[J].Lithos,2011,121(1/2/3/4):87-99.
    [35]WANG Y J,ZHANG Y Z,ZHAO G C,et al.Zircon U-Pb Geochronological and Geochemical Constraints on the Petrogenesis of the Taishan Sanukitoids(Shandong):Implications for Neoarchean Subduction in the Eastern Block,North China Craton[J].Precambrian Research,2009,174(3/4):273-286.
    [36]OBRIEN P J,WALTE N,LI J.The Petrology of Two Distinct Granulite Types in the Hengshan Mts,China,and Tectonic Implications[J].Journal of Asian Earth Sciences,2005,24(5):615-627.
    [37]侯贵廷,李江海,钱祥麟,等.华北克拉通中部中元古代岩墙群的古地磁学研究及其地质意义[J].中国科学:D辑,地球科学,2000,30(6):602-608.HOU Gui-ting,LI Jiang-hai,QIAN Xiang-lin,et al.The Paleomagnetism and Geological Significance of Meso-Proterozoic Dyke Swarms in the Central North China Craton[J].Science in China:Series D,Earth Sciences,2000,30(6):602-608.
    [38]侯贵廷,钱祥麟,李江海.华北克拉通中元古代岩墙群形成的构造应力场数值模拟[J].北京大学学报:自然科学版,2002,38(4):492-496.HOU Gui-ting,QIAN Xiang-lin,LI Jiang-hai.The Simulation of Mesoproterzoic Tectonic Stress Field Forming Mafic Dyke Swarms in the Central North China Craton[J].Acta Scientiarum Naturalium Universitatis Pekinensis,2002,38(4):492-496.
    [39]李江海,侯贵廷,钱祥麟,等.恒山中元古代早期基性岩墙群的单颗粒锆石U-Pb年龄及其克拉通构造演化意义[J].地质论评,2001,47(3):234-238.LI Jiang-hai,HOU Gui-ting,QIAN Xiang-lin,et al.Single Zircon U-Pb Age of the Initial Mesoproterozoic Basic Dike Swarms in Hengshan Mountain and Its Implication for the Tectonic Evolution of the North China Craton[J].Geological Review,2001,47(3):234-238.
    [40]邵济安,张履桥,李大明.华北克拉通元古代的三次伸展事件[J].岩石学报,2002,18(2):152-160.SHAO Ji-an,ZHANG Lu-qiao,LI Da-ming.Three Proterozoic Extensional Events in North China Craton[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,2002,18(2):152-160.
    [41]张臣,吴泰然.内蒙古苏左旗南部华北板块北缘中新元古代—古生代裂解-汇聚事件的地质记录[J].岩石学报,2001,17(2):199-205.ZHANG Chen,WU Tai-ran.Crack and Assembly Events of Meso-Neoproterozoic-Palaeozoic Continental Blocks in the Sourthern Area of Suzuoqi,Inner Mongolia[J].Acta Petrologica Sinica,2001,17(2):199-205.
    [42]彭澎,翟明国,郭敬辉,等.华北克拉通1.8Ga镁铁质岩墙群的成因和构造背景[C]∥中国地质学会.2004年全国岩石学与地球动力学研讨会论文集.北京:地质出版社,2004:179-180.PENG Peng,ZHAI Ming-guo,GUO Jing-hui,et al.The Genesis and Tectonic Background of 1.8Ga Mafic Dikes Swarm in North China Craton[C]∥Geological Society of China.Proceedings of the National Petrology and Geodynamics Conference in 2004.Beijing:Geological Publishing House,2004:179-180.
    [43]李江海,KRONER A,黄雄南,等.恒山地区变基性岩墙群的发现及“五台群”绿岩地层的解体[J].中国科学:D辑,地球科学,2001,31(11):902-910.LI Jiang-hai,KRONER A,HUANG Xiong-nan,et al.The Discovery of the Neoarchean Mafic Dyke Swarm in Hengshan and Reinterpretation of the Previous“Wutai Greenstone Belt”[J].Science in China:Series D,Earth Sciences,2001,31(11):902-910.
    [44]PENG P,GUO J H,ZHAI M G,et al.Genesis of the Hengling Magmatic Belt in the North China Craton:Implications for Paleoproterozoic Tectonics[J].Lithos,2012,148(3):27-44.
    [45]PENG P,ZHAI M G,ZHANG H F,et al.Geochronological Constraints on the Paleoproterozoic Evolution of the North China Craton:SHRIMP Zircon Ages of Different Types of Mafic Dikes[J].International Geology Review,2010,47(5):492-508.
    [46]王仁民,赖兴运,董卫东,等.冀西北晚太古宙古缝合带的一些证据[M]∥钱祥麟,王仁民.华北北部麻粒岩带地质演化.北京:地震出版社,1994:7-20.WANG Ren-min,LAI Xing-yun,DONG Wei-dong,et al.Some Evidences of the Late Archean Collision Zone in Northwest Hebei Province[M]∥QIAN Xiang-lin,WANG Ren-min.The Geological Evolution of Granulite Bands in the North Part of North China.Beijing:Seismological Press,1994:7-20.
    [47]ZHANG H F,WANG H Z,SANTOSH M,et al.Zircon U-Pb Ages of Paleoproterozoic Mafic Granulites from the Huaian Terrane,North China Craton(NCC):Implications for Timing of Cratonization and Crustal Evolution History[J].Precambrian Research,2015,272:244-263.
    [48]尹继元,袁超,孙敏,等.新疆西准噶尔地区赞岐岩(Sanukite)的地球化学特征、成因机制及其与铜金矿化的关系[J].地球化学,2009,38(5):413-423.YIN Ji-yuan,YUAN Chao,SUN Min,et al.Sanukitic Dykes in West Junggar,Xinjiang:Geochemical Features,Petrogenesis and Links to Cu-Au Mineralization[J].Geochimica,2009,38(5):413-423.
    [49]TAYLOR S R,MCLENNAN S M.The Continental Crust:Its Composition and Evolution[M].Oxford:Blackwell,1985.
    [50]SUN S S,MCDONOUGH W F.Chemical and Isotopic Systematics of Oceanic Basalts:Implications for Mantle Composition and Processes[J].Geological Society,London,Special Publications,1989,42:313-345.
    [51]FENNER C N.The Crystallization of Basalt[J].American Journal of Science,1929,18(5):223-253.
    [52]彭头平,王岳军,彭冰霞,等.一种罕见的岩石:富铁玄武岩/富铁苦橄岩研究进展[J].地球科学进展,2005,20(5):525-532.PENG Tou-ping,WANG Yue-jun,PENG Bing-xia,et al.The Summary on a Kind of Rare Rock-ferrobasalts/Ferropicrites[J].Advances in Earth Science,2005,20(5):525-532.
    [53]LEYBOURME M L,WAGONER N V,AYRES L.Partial Melting of a Refractory Subducted Slab in a Paleoproterozoic Island Arc:Implications for Global Chemical Cycles[J].Geology,1999,27(8):731-734.
    [54]HALLS H C,LI J H,DAVIS D,et al.A Precisely Dated Proterozoic Palaeomagnetic Pole from the North China Craton,and Its Relevance to Palaeocontinental Reconstruction[J].Geophysical Journal International,2000,143(1):185-203.
    [55]侯贵廷.华北基性岩墙群[M].北京:科学出版社,2012.HOU Gui-ting.The Mafic Dyke Swarms in North China[M].Beijing:Science Press,2012.
    [56]WANG Y J,FAN W M,ZHANG Y,et al.Structural Evolution and 40 Ar/39 Ar Dating of the Zanhuang Metamorphic Domain in the North China Craton:Constraints on Paleoproterozoic Tectonothermal Overprinting[J].Precambrian Research,2003,122(1/2/3/4):159-182.
    [57]彭澎,翟明国,张华锋,等.华北克拉通1.8Ga镁铁质岩墙群的地球化学特征及其地质意义:以晋冀蒙交界地区为例[J].岩石学报,2004,20(3):439-456.PENG Peng,ZHAI Ming-guo,ZHANG Hua-feng,et al.Geochemistry and Geological Significance of the 1.8Ga Mafic Dyke Swarms in the North China Craton:An Example from the Juncture of Shanxi,Hebei and Inner Mongolia[J].Acta Petrologica Sinca,2004,20(3):439-456.
    [58]HERGT J M,PEATE D W,HAWKESWORTH C J.The Petrogenesis of Mesozoic Gondwana Low-Ti Flood Basalt[J].Earth and Planetary Science Letters,1991,105(1/2/3):134-148.
    [59]夏林圻,夏祖春,徐学义,等.利用地球化学方法判别大陆玄武岩和岛弧玄武岩[J].岩石矿物学杂志,2007,26(1):77-89.XIA Lin-qi,XIA Zu-chun,XU Xue-yi,et al.The Discrimination Between Continental Basalt and Island Arc Basalt Based on Geochemical Method[J].Acta Petrologica et Mineralogica,2007,26(1):77-89.
    [60]赵振华.关于岩石微量元素构造环境判别图解使用的有关问题[J].大地构造与成矿学,2007,31(1):92-103.ZHAO Zhen-hua.How to Use the Trace Element Diagrams to Discriminate Tectonic Settings[J].Geotectonica et Metallogenia,2007,31(1):92-103.
    [61]武莉娜,王志畅,汪云亮.微量元素La、Nb、Zr在判别大地构造环境方面的应用[J].华东地质学院学报,2003,26(4):343-348.WU Li-na,WANG Zhi-chang,WANG Yun-liang.On the Application of La,Nb,and Zr in Identifying the Tectonic Settings[J].Journal of East China Geological Institute,2003,26(4):343-348.
    [62]李昌年.构造岩浆判别的地球化学方法及其讨论[J].地质科技情报,1992,11(3):73-78.LI Chang-nian.A Geochemical Method for Tectonomagmatic Discrimination[J].Geological Science and Technology Information,1992,11(3):73-78.
    [63]孙书勤,汪云亮,张成江.玄武岩类岩石大地构造环境的Th、Nb、Zr判别[J].地质论评,2003,49(1):40-47.SUN Shu-qin,WANG Yun-liang,ZHANG Chengjiang.Discrimination of the Tectonic Settings of Basalts by Th,Nb and Zr[J].Geological Review,2003,49(1):40-47.
    [64]PEARCE J A,NORRY M J.Petrogenetic Implications of Ti,Zr,Y,and Nb Variations in Volcanic Rocks[J].Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology,1979,69(1):33-47.
    [65]李永军,李甘雨,佟丽莉,等.玄武岩类形成的大地构造环境Ta、Hf、Th、La、Zr、Nb比值对比判别[J].地球科学与环境学报,2015,37(2):14-21.LI Yong-jun,LI Gan-yu,TONG Li-li,et al.Discrimination of Ratios of Ta,Hf,Th,La,Zr and Nb for Tectonic Settings in Basalts[J].Journal of Earth Sciences and Environment,2015,37(2):14-21.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700