摘要
碳纳米材料因独特的物理化学性质,而成为纳米产品中使用最多的纳米材料之一.这些纳米材料不可避免地通过各种途径进入环境,其生物安全性研究是碳纳米科技健康发展亟待解决的关键科学问题.寻找和建立针对环境生物体系中碳纳米材料高灵敏、本征的定量检测方法,获得与环境生物体系相关的数据,是推动其环境纳米生物效应和安全性研究的关键.在纳米毒理学研究中,同位素标记分析方法是一种不可替代的定量分析方法,尤其对碳纳米材料,具有独特的优势.结合现代分析技术,可本征、快速、准确、高灵敏地对其纳米生物效应与毒理学进行研究.本文综述了典型碳纳米材料的放射性同位素和稳定性同位素标记技术和方法、检测方法及其在碳纳米材料结构形成、生物体内定量吸收、分布、转化和排泄等纳米生物效应与毒理学分析研究的相关应用,并展望了同位素标记技术在碳纳米材料的毒理学研究和环境健康效应研究中的应用.
Carbon nanomaterials,due to their unique physical and chemical properties,have been widely applied in many consumer products. Carbon nanomaterials have become one kind of the most used commercialized nanomaterials in world. Subsequently,the release of substantial amount of nanomaterials into the environment is inevitable. Understanding the safety,environmental and human health impacts of nanotechnology-based products is of worldwide importance. Therefore,researches on the biological effects of carbon nanomaterials and nanosafety in environment are urgently significant issues during the healthy and sustained development of carbon nanomaterials in our country and around world. Sensitive,intrinsic and quantitative detection of carbon nanomaterials in environment is a key technique for studying their nanosafety and environmental risk. Isotope labeling,including radioactive isotope labeling and stable isotope labeling,have the advantages of high sensitivity and good accuracy,which was an alternative nuclear analysis method to be applied for the study of nanotoxicology. In this review,we summarized the recent advances in the radioactive and stable isotopelabeling of carbon nanomaterials and their applications in nanotoxicology. Carbon isotopes were able to labeled intrinsically to the fullerene,carbon nanotubes and graphene,etc.,as tracers,which can easily distinguish the endogenous and exogenous sources of carbon elements of interest samples,be used to investigate quantitatively the absorption,distribution,metabolism and transformation of carbon nanomaterials in ecological system,and will provide a standard detection method and the key data for the risk evaluation of carbon nanomaterials in environment and health system in future.
引文
1 http://www.nanotechproject.org/cpi/about/analysis/,accessed on 2015-07-10
2 Nel AE,Zhao YL,M?dler L.Accounts Chem Res,2013,46:605–606
3 Westerhoff P,Nowack B.Accounts Chem Res,2012,46:844–853
4 Oberd?rster G,Oberd?rster E,Oberd?rster J.Environ Health Persp,2005,113:823–839
5 Wang J,Hu Z,Xu J,Zhao Y.NPG Asia Mater,2014,6:e84
6 Klaine SJ,Alvarez PJJ,Batley GE,Fernandes TF,Handy RD,Lyon DY,Mahendra S,Mclaughlin MJ,Lead JR.Environ Toxicol Chem,2008,27:1825–1851
7 Vedam H.Nanosafety policy overview.In:2011 International Conference on Nanoscience,Technology and Societal Implications(NSTSI).Bhubaneswar,India,2011.1–6
8 Zhao YL,Xing GM,Chai ZF.Nat Nanotechnol,2008,3:191–192
9 Zhao F,Zhao Y,Liu Y,Chang XL,Chen CY,Zhao YL.Small,2011,7:1322–1337
10 Wu HC,Chang XL,Liu L,Zhao F,Zhao YL.J Mater Chem,2010,20:1036–1052
11 Yan L,Zhao F,Li SF,Hu ZB,Zhao YL.Nanoscale,2011,3:362–382
12 Wang B,He X,Zhang ZY,Zhao YL,Feng WY.Accounts Chem Res,2013,46:761–769
13 Zhu MT,Nie G,Meng H,Xia T,Nel A,Zhao YL.Accounts Chem Res,2013,46:622–631
14 Ma XW,Zhao YL,Liang XJ.Accounts Chem Res,2011,44:1114–1122
15 Liu Y,Zhao YL,Sun BY,Chen CY.Accounts Chem Res,2013,46:702–713
16 Chang XL,Yang ST,Xing G.J Biomed Nanotechnol,2014,10:2828–2851
17 丁艳萍,季天骄,宋晓,聂广军.科学通报,2013,58:2436–2448
18 王越,王鹏,陈春英,赵宇亮.科学通报,2013,58:2007–2020
19 徐莺莺,林晓影,陈春英.科学通报,2013,58:2466–2478
20 常雪灵,祖艳,赵宇亮.科学通报,2010,56:108–118
21 Zhao F,Meng H,Yan L,Wang B,Zhao Y.Sci Bull,2015,60:3–20
22 汪冰,丰伟悦,赵宇亮,邢更妹,柴之芳.中国科学B辑:化学,2005,35:1–10
23 Nel AE,Madler L,Velegol D,Xia T,Hoek EMV,Somasundaran P,Klaessig F,Castranova V,Thompson M.Nat Mater,2009,8:543–557
24 Hagens WI,Oomen AG,De Jong WH,Cassee FR,Sips AJa M.Regul Toxicol Pharm,2007,49:217–229
25 Wang HF,Yang S-T,Cao A,Liu Y.Accounts Chem Res,2012,46:750–760
26 He X,Zhang ZY,Liu JS,Ma YH,Zhang P,Li YY,Wu ZQ,Zhao YL,Chai ZF.Nat Nanotechnol,2011,6:755
27 He X,Ma YH,Li M,Zhang P,Li YY,Zhang ZY.Small,2013,9:1482–1491
28 张智勇,赵宇亮,柴之芳.化学进展,2011,23:1527–1532
29 Astefanei A,Nú?ez O,Galceran MT.Anal Chim Acta,2015,882:1–21
30 Scida K,Stege PW,Haby G,Messina GA,García CD.Anal Chim Acta,2011,691:6–17
31 Isaacson CW,Kleber M,Field JA.Environ Sci Technol,2009,43:6463–6474
32 Williams PM.Nature,1968,219:152–153
33 Lyon TDB,Baxter MS.Nature,1978,273:750–751
34 Martinelli LA,Devol AH,Victoria RL,Richey JE.Nature,1991,353:57–59
35 Benson S,Lennard C,Maynard P,Roux C.Forensic Sci Int,2006,157:1–22
36 Gregoricka LA.Am J Phys Anthropol,2013,152:353–369
37 Ong S-E,Mann M.Nat Protocols,2007,1:2650–2660
38 Mann M,Jensen ON.Nat Biotechnol,2003,21:255–261
39 Gulson B,Wong H.Environ Health Persp,2006,114:1486–1488
40 Berezin AA.Nanotechnol Percept,2009,5:27–36
41 Mutlib AE.Chem Res Toxicol,2008,21:1672–1689
42 Chen CY,Li YF,Qu Y,Chai ZF,Zhao YL.Chem Soc Rev,2013,42:8266–8303
43 Ji ZQ,Sun H,Wang H,Xie Q,Liu Y,Wang Z.J Nanopart Res,2006,8:53–63
44 Wang HF,Wang J,Deng XY,Sun HF,Shi ZJ,Gu ZN,Liu YF,Zhao YL.J Nanosci Nanotechnol,2004,4:1019–1024
45 Deng XY,Yang ST,Nie HY,Wang HF,Liu YF.Nanotechnology,2008,19:075101
46 Liu J-H,Yang S-T,Wang HF,Chang YL,Cao AN,Liu YF.Nanomedicine-UK,2012,7:1801–1812
47 Tao H,Yang K,Ma Z,Wan J,Zhang Y,Kang Z,Liu Z.Small,2012,8:281–290
48 Yuan Y,Chen Y,Liu JH,Wang HF,Liu YF.Diam Relat Mater,2009,18:95–100
49 王海芳,邓小勇,王竞,高兴发,邢更妹,施祖进,顾镇南,刘元方,赵宇亮.物理化学学报,2004,20:673–675
50 Nikolic N,Vranjes-Duric S,Jankovic D,Dokic D,Mirkovic M,Bibic N,Trajkovic V.Nanotechnology,2009,20:385102
51 Hong SY,Tobias G,Al-Jamal KT,Ballesteros B,Ali-Boucetta H,Lozano-Perez S,Nellist PD,Sim RB,Finucane C,Mather SJ,Green MLH,Kostarelos K,Davis BG.Nat Mater,2010,9:485–490
52 Bullard-Dillard R,Creek KE,Scrivens WA,Tour JM.Bioorg Chem,1996,24:376–385
53 Scrivens WA,Tour JM,Creek KE,Pirisi L.J Am Chem Soc,1994,116:4517–4518
54 Petersen EJ,Akkanen J,Kukkonen JVK,Weber WJ Jr.Environ Sci Technol,2009,43:2969–2975
55 Petersen EJ,Huang Q,Weber WJ Jr.Environ Sci Technol,2008,42:3090–3095
56 Petersen EJ,Huang Q,Weber WJ.Environ Health Perspect,2008,116:496–500
57 Petersen EJ,Huang Q,Weber WJ Jr.Environ Toxicol Chem,2010,29:1106–1112
58 Petersen EJ,Pinto RA,Mai DJ,Landrum PF,Weber WJ Jr.Environ Sci Technol,2011,45:1133–1138
59 Petersen EJ,Pinto RA,Zhang L,Huang Q,Landrum PF,Weber WJ Jr.Environ Sci Technol,2011,45:3718–3724
60 Czarny B,Georgin D,Berthon F,Plastow G,Pinault M,Patriarche G,Thuleau A,L’hermite MM,Taran F,Dive V.ACS Nano,2014,8:5715–5724
61 Guo X,Dong S,Petersen EJ,Gao S,Huang Q,Mao L.Environ Sci Technol,2013,47:12524–12531
62 Yamago S,Tokuyama H,Nakamura E,Kikuchi K,Kananishi S,Sueki K,Nakahara H,Enomoto S,Ambe F.Chem Biol,1995,2:385–389
63 Deng X,Jia G,Wang H,Sun H,Wang X,Yang S,Wang T,Liu Y.Carbon,2007,45:1419–1424
64 Georgin D,Czarny B,Botquin M,Mayne-L’hermite M,Pinault M,Bouchet-Fabre B,Carriere M,Poncy JL,Chau Q,Maximilien R,Dive V,Taran F.J Am Chem Soc,2009,131:14658–14659
65 Singh R,Pantarotto D,Lacerda L,Pastorin G,Klumpp C,Prato M,Bianco A,Kostarelos K.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA,2006,103:3357–3362
66 Liu Z,Cai W,He L,Nakayama N,Chen K,Sun X,Chen X,Dai H.Nat Nanotechnol,2007,2:47–52
67 Hong H,Yang K,Zhang Y,Engle JW,Feng L,Yang Y,Nayak TR,Goel S,Bean J,Theuer CP,Barnhart TE,Liu Z,Cai W.ACS Nano,2012,6:2361–2370
68 Wang JTW,Cabana L,Bourgognon M,Kafa H,Protti A,Venner K,Shah AM,Sosabowski JK,Mather SJ,Roig A,Ke X,Van Tendeloo G,De Rosales RTM,Tobias G,Al-Jamal KT.Adv Funct Mater,2014,24:1880–1894
69 Zhang X,Yin J,Peng C,Hu W,Zhu Z,Li W,Fan C,Huang Q.Carbon,2011,49:986–995
70 Song H,Luo S,Wei H,Song H,Yang Y,Zhao W.J Radioanal Nucl Ch,2010,285:635–639
71 Li YG,Huang X,Liu RL,Li QN,Zhang XD,Li WX.J Radioanal Nucl Ch,2005,265:127–131
72 M?ller W,Felten K,Sommerer K,Scheuch G,Meyer G,Meyer P,H?ussinger K,Kreyling WG.Am J Resp Crit Care,2008,177:426–432
73 Nemmar A,Hoet PHM,Vanquickenborne B,Dinsdale D,Thomeer M,Hoylaerts MF,Vanbilloen H,Mortelmans L,Nemery B.Circulation,2002,105:411–414
74 Cagle DW,Kennel SJ,Mirzadeh S,Alford JM,Wilson LJ.Proc Natl Acad Sci USA,1999,96:5182–5187
75 吴胜伟,郭金学,李玉兰,黄旋,李文新.核技术,2003,26:723–724
76 Liu Z,Chen K,Davis C,Sherlock S,Cao Q,Chen X,Dai H.Cancer Res,2008,68:6652–6660
77 Rojas S,Gispert JD,Martin R,Abad S,Menchon C,Pareto D,Victor VM,Alvaro M,Garcia H,Raul Herance J.ACS Nano,2011,5:5552–5559
78 Mcdevitt MR,Chattopadhyay D,Jaggi JS,Finn RD,Zanzonico PB,Villa C,Rey D,Mendenhall J,Batt CA,Njardarson JT,Scheinberg DA.Plos One,2007,2:e907
79 Mcdevitt MR,Chattopadhyay D,Kappel BJ,Jaggi JS,Schiffman SR,Antczak C,Njardarson JT,Brentjens R,Scheinberg DA.J Nucl Med,2007,48:1180–1189
80 Wang J,Deng X,Yang S,Wang H,Zhao Y,Liu Y.Nanotoxicology,2008,2:28–32
81 Yang ST,Guo W,Lin Y,Deng XY,Wang HF,Sun HF,Liu YF,Wang X,Wang W,Chen M,Huang YP,Sun YP.J Phys Chem C,2007,111:17761–17764
82 Yang ST,Fernando Ka S,Liu JH,Wang J,Sun HF,Liu YF,Chen M,Huang YP,Wang X,Wang HF,Sun YP.Small,2008,4:940–944
83 Yang ST,Wang X,Wang H,Lu F,Luo PG,Cao L,Meziani MJ,Liu J-H,Liu Y,Chen M,Huang Y,Sun YP.J Phys Chem C,2009,113:18110–18114
84 Kitaygorodskiy A,Wang W,Xie SY,Lin Y,Fernando Ka S,Wang X,Qu LW,Chen B,Sun YP.J Am Chem Soc,2005,127:7517–7520
85 阮龙飞,常雪灵,孙宝云,郭翠彬,董金泉,杨胜韬,高兴发,赵宇亮,杨敏.科学通报,2014,59:905–912
86 Wang CL,Ruan LF,Chang X-L,Zhang X,Yang S-T,Guo XH,Yuan H,Guo CB,Shi WQ,Sun BY,Zhao YL.Rsc Adv,2015,5:76949–76956
87 Tian LL,Wang X,Cao L,Meziani MJ,Kong CY,Lu FS,Sun YP.J Nanomater,2010,2010:742167
88 Liu JH,Yang ST,Wang X,Wang H,Liu Y,Luo PG,Liu Y,Sun YP.ACS Appl Mater Interf,2014,6:14672–14678
89 Liu L,Fan S.J Am Chem Soc,2001,123:11502–11503
90 Liu Z,Li X,Tabakman SM,Jiang K,Fan S,Dai H.J Am Chem Soc,2008,130:13540–13541
91 Chen Z,Tabakman SM,Goodwin AP,Kattah MG,Daranciang D,Wang X,Zhang G,Li X,Liu Z,Utz PJ,Jiang K,Fan S,Dai H.Nat Biotechnol,2008,26:1285–1292
92 Meijer G,Bethune DS.J Chem Phys,1990,93:7800–7802
93 Johnson RD,Meijer G,Salem JR,Bethune DS.J Am Chem Soc,1991,113:3619–3621
94 Yannoni CS,Bernier PP,Bethune DS,Meijer G,Salem JR.J Am Chem Soc,1991,113:3190–3192
95 Johnson RD,Bethune DS,Yannoni CS.Accounts Chem Res,1992,25:169–175
96 Kr?tschmer W,Fostiropoulos K,Huffman DR.Chem Phys Lett,1990,170:167–170
97 Ebbesen TW,Tabuchi J,Tanigaki K.Chem Phys Lett,1992,191:336–338
98 Ebbesen TW,Tsai JS,Tanigaki K,Tabuchi J,Shimakawa Y,Kubo Y,Hirosawa I,Mizuki J.Nature,1992,355:620–622
99 Ramirez AP,Kortan AR,Rosseinsky MJ,Duclos SJ,Mujsce AM,Haddon RC,Murphy DW,Makhija AV,Zahurak SM,Lyons KB.Phys Rev Lett,1992,68:1058–1060
100 Chakravarty S,Kivelson SA,Salkola MI,Tewari S.Science,1992,256:1306–1308
101 Hawkins JM,Meyer A,Loren S,Nunlist R.J Am Chem Soc,1991,113:9394–9395
102 Hawkins JM.Accounts Chem Res,1992,25:150–156
103 Chen CC,Lieber CM.J Am Chem Soc,1992,114:3141–3142
104 Martin MC,Fabian J,Godard J,Bernier P,Lambert JM,Mihaly L.Phys Rev B,1995,51:2844–2847
105 Horoyski PJ,Thewalt MLW,Anthony TR.Phys Rev B,1996,54:920–929
106 Dunk PW,Kaiser NK,Hendrickson CL,Quinn JP,Ewels CP,Nakanishi Y,Sasaki Y,Shinohara H,Marshall AG,Kroto HW.Nat Commun,2012,3:855
107 Cai WW,Piner RD,Stadermann FJ,Park S,Shaibat MA,Ishii Y,Yang DX,Velamakanni A,An SJ,Stoller M,An JH,Chen DM,Ruoff RS.Science,2008,321:1815–1817
108 Chang XL,Ruan LF,Yang ST,Sun BY,Guo CB,Zhou LJ,Dong JQ,Yuan H,Xing GM,Zhao YL,Yang M.Environ Sci:Nano,2014,1:64–70
109 阮龙飞,汪称龙,常雪灵,杨胜韬,赵宇亮,杨敏.分析测试学报,2014:583–587
110 Wang Z,Chang X,Lu Z,Gu M,Zhao Y,Gao X.Chem Sci,2014,5:2940–2948
111 Hou W-C,Kong L,Wepasnick KA,Zepp RG,Fairbrother DH,Jafvert CT.Environ Sci Technol,2010,44:8121–8127
112 Plata DL,Gschwend PM,Reddy CM.Nanotechnology,2008,19:185706
113 Hanna SK,Miller RJ,Lenihan HS.J Hazard Mater,2014,279:32–37
114 Chen S,Wu Q,Mishra C,Kang J,Zhang H,Cho K,Cai W,Balandin AA,Ruoff RS.Nat Mater,2012,11:203–207
115 Casabianca LB,Shaibat MA,Cai WW,Park S,Piner R,Ruoff RS,Ishii Y.J Am Chem Soc,2010,132:5672–5676
116 Kalbac M,Farhat H,Kong J,Janda P,Kavan L,Dresselhaus MS.Nano Lett,2011,11:1957–1963
117 Kalbac M,Frank O,Kong J,Sanchez-Yamagishi J,Watanabe K,Taniguchi T,Jarillo-Herrero P,Dresselhaus MS.J Phys Chem Lett,2012,3:796–799
118 Kalbac M,Kong J,Dresselhaus MS.J Phys Chem C,2012,116:19046–19050
119 Fang W,Hsu AL,Caudillo R,Song Y,Birdwell AG,Zakar E,Kalbac M,Dubey M,Palacios T,Dresselhaus MS,Araujo PT,Kong J.Nano Lett,2013,13:1541–1548
120 Ek-Weis J,Costa S,Frank O,Kalbac M.J Phys Chem Lett,2014,5:549–554
121 Yang K,Wan J,Zhang S,Zhang Y,Lee ST,Liu Z.ACS Nano,2011,5:516–522
122 Lin Y,Allard LF,Sun YP.J Phys Chem B,2004,108:3760–3764
123 Xu JY,Li QN,Li JG,Ran TC,Wu SW,Song WM,Chen SL,Li WX.Carbon,2007,45:1865–1870
124 Zhang X,Yin J,Kang C,Li J,Zhu Y,Li W,Huang Q,Zhu Z.Toxicol Lett,2010,198:237–243
125 Liang G,Zhang T,Liu R,Ye B,Yin L,Pu Y.J Nanosci Nanotechno,2010,10:8508–8515
126 Guo J,Zhang X,Li Q,Li W.Nucl Med Biol,2007,34:579–583
127 Yang ST,Luo J,Zhou Q,Wang H.Theranostics,2012,2:271–282
128 Lacerda L,Soundararajan A,Singh R,Pastorin G,Al-Jamal KT,Turton J,Frederik P,Herrero MA,Bao SLA,Emfietzoglou D,Mather S,Phillips WT,Prato M,Bianco A,Goins B,Kostarelos K.Adv Mater,2008,20:225
129 Wang JTW,Fabbro C,Venturelli E,Menard-Moyon C,Chaloin O,Da Ros T,Methven L,Nunes A,Sosabowski JK,Mather SJ,Robinson MK,Amadou J,Prato M,Bianco A,Kostarelos K,Al-Jamal KT.Biomaterials,2014,35:9517–9528
130 Yang ST,Wang YW,Liu JH,Wang H.J Radioanal Nucl Ch,2013,295:1181–1186
131 Yuan Y,Wang X,Jia G,Liu JH,Wang T,Gu Y,Yang ST,Zhen S,Wang H,Liu Y.Diam Relat Mater,2010,19:291–299
132 Nakamura M,Tahara Y,Murakami T,Iijima S,Yudasaka M.Carbon,2014,69:409–416
133 Yang ST,Cao L,Luo PG,Lu F,Wang X,Wang H,Meziani MJ,Liu Y,Qi G,Sun YP.J Am Chem Soc,2009,131:11308–11309