摘要
化学指纹图谱是民族药质量评价体系的重要组成部分,其发展与药材质量可控、安全有效关系紧密。目前薄层色谱法、高效液相色谱法、气相色谱法、红外光谱法、紫外光谱法、拉曼光谱法、X射线衍射技术、核磁共振等多种方法已被用于民族药的化学指纹图谱研究。该文对近年国内外相关文献进行总结,探讨化学指纹图谱在民族药真伪鉴别、产地区分、质量评价等方面的应用前景,以期为民族药的资源评价、质量控制和创新发展提供有益参考。
Chemical fingerprint technology is one of the most important parts of quality evaluation system for Chinese ethnomedinins,which development has close relationships with quality control,safety and effectiveness of ethnomedinins. In the present study, many analysis technologies such as TCL,HPLC,GC,IR,UV,Raman spectra,XRD and NMR have been widely used in the quality control on ethnomedinins. In this review,the current status and progress in the applications of chemical fingerprint in the studies of species identification,productions region decimation and quality evaluation of ethnomedinins made by both domestic and foreign scholars have been summarized. This review may provide references for the resources evaluation,quality control and innovation and development of Chinese ethnomedinins.
引文
[1]Yang Y,Zhang Y,Huang Y,Lai X R,Fan G,You J L.Chin.J.Chin.Mater.Med.(杨洋,张艺,黄宇,赖先荣,范刚,游佳莉.中国中药杂志),2013,38(17):2878-2881.
[2]Wang Q L.Chin.J.Exp.Tradit.Med.Formulae(王庆林.中国实验方剂学杂志),2013,19(12):345-347.
[3]Jia M R,Lu X L,Ma Y Y.Chin.J.Chin.Mater.Med.(贾敏如,卢晓琳,马逾英.中国中药杂志),2015,40(23):4693-4702.
[4]Zhu Z Y,Wang T,Fu D H,Gui Y L,Wang J K,Cui T.Front.Med.,2016,10(2):166-177.
[5]Han L W.Chin.J.Chin.Mater.Med.(韩立炜.中国中药杂志),2015,40(17):3379-3384.
[6]Jia M R.J.Med.Pharm.Chin.Minorities(贾敏如.中国民族医药杂志),2011,17(7):38-41.
[7]Liu B,Guo Z Y,Bussmann R,Li F F,Li J Q,Hong L Y,Long C L.J.Ethnopharmacol.,2016,186:343-350.
[8]Zhang Y,Geng Y F,Zhang L L,Wang L,He L J,Wang C,Chai Z Z,Fan R Y,Li S,Wang Y H.J.Ethnopharmacol.,2015,169:413-425.
[9]Li Z Y,Yang Y Q,Li L S,Li Y W,Lin L,Cheng Y Y.Chin.J.Chin.Mater.Med.(李志勇,杨永强,李林森,李彦文,林灵,程阳阳.中国中药杂志),2016,41(12):2356-2361.
[10]Chinese Pharmacopoeia Commission.Chinese Pharmacopoeia.Beijing:China Medical Science Press(国家药典委员会.中华人民共和国药典.北京:中国医药科技出版社),2015.
[11]Zheng H,Su Z H.Lishizhen Med.Mater.Med.Res.(郑华,苏志恒.时珍国医国药),2015,26(10):2487-2489.
[12]Liu D F,Zhao L N,Li Y F,Jin C D.Chin.Tradit.Herbal Drugs(刘东方,赵丽娜,李银峰,靳朝东.中草药),2016,47(22):4085-4094.
[13]Liu B Q,Li C B,Quan C S,Fan S D,Hu W Z.J.Dalian Natl.Univ.(刘宝全,李春斌,权春善,范圣第,胡文忠.大连民族学院学报),2016,18(3):203-206.
[14]Song P P,Xia J F,Rezeng C,Li T,Wei T.Biosci.Trends,2016,10(3):163-170.
[15]Di Z,Zhao Y L,Zhang J,Wang Y Z,Li P.Chin.J.Exp.Tradit.Med.Formulae(狄准,赵艳丽,张霁,王元忠,李鹂.中国实验方剂学杂志),2016,22(18):21-26.
[16]Yang N N,Zhang J,Zhao Y L,Wang Y Z,Zhao Y H.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(杨妮娜,张霁,赵艳丽,王元忠,赵应红.光谱学与光谱分析),2016,36(12):4021-4027.
[17]Pan Y,Zhang J,Shen T,Zhao Y L,Zuo Z T,Wang Y Z,Li W Y.Biomed.Chromatogr.,2016,30(2):232-240.
[18]Liu Z H,Wang D M,Li D W,Zhang S.Front Pharmacol.,2017,8:198.
[19]Jiang X H,LüS H,Wang G L,Zhu Y W,He Z N.Chin.J.Forensic Med.(姜先华,吕世惠,王国林,朱郁文,和中年.中国法医学杂志),1990,5(1):65-68.
[20]Wang Y N,Wang J H,Chen J,Guo H Z,Fu X T,Chen Y G.Chin.J.Pharm.Anal.(王亚妮,王京辉,陈晶,郭洪祝,傅欣彤,陈有根.药物分析杂志),2016,36(5):847-855.
[21]Gong D D,Dong J J,Sun G X,Zhang J,Zhang Y J,Sun W Y.Chin.J.Chromatogr.(巩丹丹,董嘉俊,孙国祥,张晶,张玉静,孙万阳.色谱),2017,35(6):643-649.
[22]Zheng H,Wei R B.Chin.J.Hosp.Pharm.(郑恒,魏日胞.中国医院药学杂志),2003,23(2):112-113.
[23]Xu Y T,Zhang Z N.Henan.Tradit.Chin.Med.(徐玉田,张状年.河南中医药),2007,27(6):81-83.
[24]Yi Y K,Chen Z L,Deng H Z.Chin.Tradit.Pat.Med.(易廷逵,陈志良,邓红珠.中成药),2006,28(8):1192-1197.
[25]World Health Organization.Guidelines for the Assessment of Herbal Medicines,1991.
[26]Lin J M.Sci.Sin.Chim.(林金明.中国科学化学),2009,39(8):669.
[27]Upadhya V,Ankad G M,Pai S R,Hedge H S.Plant Sci.Today,2015,2(1):7-10.
[28]Fang N,Wu W X,Ming Q Z,Liu Y,Wang C G,Wang X Y,Shi J L.Chin.J.Pharm.Anal.(房楠,吴玟萱,明全忠,刘勇,王春国,王学勇,石晋丽.药物分析杂志),2015,35(2):344-350.
[29]Teng H L,Guo L C,Zhao X P.J.Guangxi Acad.Sci.(滕红丽,郭力城,赵湘培.广西科学院学报),2015,31(4):302-304.
[30]Guan M,Wang F L,Chen J.Chin.J.Pharm.Anal.(关明,王凤琳,陈坚.药物分析杂志),2011,31(10):1924-1929.
[31]Xie P S,Yan Y Z.J.Sep.Sci.,1987,10(11):607-613.
[32]Ristivojevi c'P,Andric'F L,Trifkovic'J,Irena V,Ljubi2a6 S,ivoslav L T,Du2anka M M O.J.Chemometr.,2014,28(4):301-310.
[33]Qing J,Zhang L Y,Pan W T,Xie Y.Stud.Trace Elem.Health(卿娟,张丽艳,潘文婷,谢宇.微量元素与健康研究),2014,31(2):62-63.
[34]Elangovan N M,Dhanarajan M S,Elangovan I.Int.Res.J.Pharm.Biosci.,2015,2(2):32-40.
[35]Shao Y H,Liu M T,Yang Y F,Yu X K,Ding P.Chin.J.Chin.Mater.Med.(邵艳华,刘美廷,杨一帆,于现阔,丁平.中国药学杂志),2017,52(3):188-192.
[36]Sudhakaran M V.Eur.J.Med.Plants,2014,4(9):1113-1124.
[37]Liu S,Ding P,Ying G,Dai L.West Chin.J.Pharm.Sci.(刘硕,丁平,应鸽,代蕾.华西药学杂志),2012,27(4):434-435.
[38]Cui M Y,Fu K C.Chin.J.Ethnomed.Ethnopharm.(崔明筠,付开聪.中国民族民间医药),2016,25(4):15-16.
[39]Chen W J,Liang W Y,Li S,Wu L F,Cui Y P,Qi Q,Yuan Y B,Zhang L Z.Chin.Tradit.Herbal Drugs(陈文静,梁文仪,李师,吴玲芳,崔雅萍,亓旗,袁永兵,张兰珍.中草药),2017,48(6):1210-1215.
[40]Ma X D,Fan Y X,Jin C C,Wang F,Xin G Z,Li P,Li H J.J.Chromatogr.A,2016,1450:53-63.
[41]Chen Q L,Zhu L,Tang Y N,Kwan H Y,Zhao Z Z,Chen H B,Yi T.Drug Test Anal.,2016,9(8):1105-1115.
[42]Cheng J,Yang P F,He K,Chen Q,Liu C.Chin.J.Pharm.Anal.(成杰,杨鹏飞,何康,陈曲,刘冲.药物分析杂志),2016,36(2):285-290.
[43]Zhong S H,Gu R,Liao Y F,Wang L X,Zheng H,Zheng X H,Huang M G.Chin.J.Pharm.Anal.(钟世红,古锐,廖艳凤,王铃鑫,郑欢,郑小华,黄明贵.药物分析杂志),2015,35(9):1578-1584.
[44]Dong H J,Chen X H,Zeng R.Chin.Tradit.Herbal Drugs(董红娇,陈晓虎,曾锐.中草药),2016,47(14):2428-2435.
[45]He D D,Fan J T,You R R,Chen X Q,Li Z L,Ju J M,Zeng B L.J.Chin.Mass Spectr.Soc.(何丹丹,范君婷,尤蓉蓉,陈雪晴,李振麟,鞠建明,曾白林.质谱学报),2017,38(1):138-145.
[46]You J L,Wang Y J,Zhang Y,Yang Y,Su Y W,Fan G.Chin.J.Chin.Mater.Med.(游佳莉,王毓杰,张艺,杨洋,苏永文,范刚.中国中药杂志),2015,40(2):362-366.
[47]Yang W,Laaksonen O,Kallio H,Yang B R.Food Chem.,2017,216:87-96.
[48]Zheng J,Kallio H P T,Yang B R.J.Agric.Food Chem.,2016,64(24):5031-5044.
[49]Wang D M,He F Y,Lv Z J,Li D W.PLo S ONE,2014,9(5):e96329.
[50]Zhang S S,Liu X,Wang J F,Yu M J,Huang Z J,Liu Y,Zhang H.Chin.Tradit.Herbal Drugs(张绍山,刘璇,王景富,余孟杰,黄钟杰,刘圆,张浩.中草药),2016,47(23):4257-4263.
[51]Zhang Y X,Li C Y,Liu C,Xu J,Xiang L,Fan G,Zhang Y.Chin.J.Chin.Mater.Med.(张雨欣,李聪颖,刘川,徐江,向丽,范刚,张艺.中国中药杂志),2016,41(4):572-577.
[52]Yun Q,Liu Q W,He C Y,He C Y,Ma X H,Gao X L,Talbi A,Zhou J P.Anal.Methods-UK,2014,6(13):4845-4852.
[53]Yang N N,Zhao Y H.J.Med.Pharm.China Minorities(杨妮娜,赵应红.中国民族医药杂志),2016,22(7):41-44.
[54]Deng X K,Gao K L,Chen L Y,Jiang J,Cai S,Lin Q X,Guan X H,Ma Y X.J.South-Central Univ.Natl.(邓旭坤,高康丽,陈旅翼,蒋捷,蔡爽,林亲雄,关祥会,马玉雪.中南民族大学学报),2016,35(1):55-58.
[55]Wang M,Avula B,Wang Y H,Zhao J,Avonto C,Parcher J F,Raman V,Zweigenbaum J A,Wylie P L,Khan I A.Food Chem.,2014,152(2):391-398.
[56]Lukas B,Schmiderer C,Novak J.Phytochemistry,2015,119:32-40.
[57]Han F,Chen Q,Shu J C,Zhao Z D,Huang Y,Xu H L,Yang M.Chin.Tradit.Herbal Drugs(韩飞,陈泣,舒积成,赵志冬,黄艺,许汉林,杨明.中草药),2015,46(13):1887-1891.
[58]Zhang J P,Wang Z J,Wang D,Liang J.J.Med.Pharm.Chin.Minorities(张建平,王志君,王栋,梁敬.中国民族医药杂志),2015,21(5):49-50.
[59]Liu B,Liu G L,Li Y W,Mou L L,Fang H,Zhang N,Liu H Y.Chin.J.Exp.Tradit.Med.Formulae(刘斌,刘国良,李艳薇,牟璐璐,方衡,张宁,刘海洋.中国实验方剂学杂志),2016,22(13):59-62.
[60]Deepalakshmi P D,Odgerel K,Thirugnanasambantham P,Yungeree O,Khorolragchaa A,Senthil K.Chromatographia,2016,79(19):1359-1371.
[61]Wang S,Sheng P,Yao L,Du B J.Chin.Tradit.Herbal Drugs(王飒,盛萍,姚蓝,杜冰洁.中草药),2015,46(19):2874-2879.
[62]Tang D P,Sheng P,Miao L J,Wang S.Chin.J.Exp.Tradit.Med.(唐代萍,盛萍,苗莉娟,王飒.中国实验方剂学杂志),2016,22(8):41-46.
[63]Kumar R,Sharma S,Sharma S,Kumar N.J.Appl.Res.Med.Aromat.Plants,2016,3(3):136-141.
[64]Bao X M,Ju A H,Bu R,Wang Y H.Chin.J.Tradit.Chin.Med.Pharm.(包小妹,鞠爱华,布仁,王玉华.中华中医药杂志),2017,32(2):810-813.
[65]Wang N,Liu J,Li S W,Pang Z R,Cui J,Shen G Y.Amino.Acid.Biotic.Resour.(王宁,刘佳,李书文,庞宗然,崔箭,申刚义.氨基酸和生物资源),2015,37(2):1-5.
[66]Wu T N,Yu C Z,Li R,Sun X M,Li J.Chin.Tradit.Herbal Drugs(吴婷妮,余长柱,李荣,孙晓梅,李俊.中草药),2013,44(17):2404-2409.
[67]Chen N D,Meng Y F,Yao H J,Cao C Y,Chen C,Li J.J.Chin.Med.Mater.(陈乃东,孟云飞,姚厚军,曹彩芸,陈辰,李俊.中药材),2015,38(8):1607-1610.
[68]Sun Y,Guo T,Sui Y,Li F M.J.Chromatogr.B,2003,792(2):147-152.
[69]Chen K.Chin.J.Ethnomed.Ethnopharm.(陈凯.中国民族民间医药),2014,23(1):9.
[70]Ma L J,Chen Q X,Han L,Liu X H,Zhou Y Z,Li J S,Cai B C.Nei Mongol.J.Tradit.Chin.Med.(马丽娟,陈巧霞,韩乐,刘训红,周逸芝,李俊松,蔡宝昌.内蒙古中医药),2016,35(15):140-144.
[71]Zhang F S,Chen F,Fu X S,Liu X H,Yang N Y,Cai B C,Xia M Y.Chin.J.Tradit.Chin.Med.Pharm.(张奉苏,陈菲,傅兴圣,刘训红,杨念云,蔡宝昌,夏敏媛.中华中医药杂志),2015,30(7):2349-2352.
[72]Chen W W,Lin J,Feng S Y,Huang H,Chen G N,Yu Y,Lin D,Chen R.Acta Laser Biol.Sin.(陈伟炜,林佳,冯尚源,黄浩,陈冠楠,俞允,林多,陈荣.激光生物学报),2015,24(1):25-30.
[73]Liu Y,Liu S H,Wang J Q,Sun S Q.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(刘岩,刘顺航,王俊全,孙素琴.光谱学与光谱分析),2007,27(6):1093-1097.
[74]Yang H X,Ma F,Du Y Z,Sun S Q,Wei L X.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(杨红霞,马芳,杜玉枝,孙素琴,魏立新.光谱学与光谱分析),2014,34(11):2973-2977.
[75]Kong M H,Wu D X,Chen X B.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(孔梦红,吴杜轩,陈相柏.光谱学与光谱分析),2017,37(3):778-782.
[76]Kortesniemi M,Sinkkonen J,Yang B R,Kallio H.Food Chem.,2017,219:139-147.
[77]Ning Y C.Spectral Identification and Organic Spectroscopy of Organic Compounds.Beijing:Science Press(宁永成.有机化合物波谱鉴定与有机波谱学.北京:科学出版社),2012.
[78]Liu F,Wang Y Z,Yang C Y,Jin H.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(刘飞,王元忠,杨春艳,金航.光谱学与光谱分析),2014,34(11):2968-2972.
[79]Zhao Q S,Zhou Y B,Sun S N,Lu X F,Ye R R,Peng M.Nat.Prod.Res.Dev.(赵庆帅,周玉碧,孙胜男,卢学峰,叶润蓉,彭敏.天然产物研究与开发),2015,27(6):1052-1055.
[80]Di Z,Zhao Y L,Zuo Z T,Long H,Zhang X,Wang Y Z,Li L.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(狄准,赵艳丽,左智天,龙华,张雪,王元忠,李鹂.光谱学与光谱分析),2016,36(2):388-393.
[81]Li Y H,Zou X B,Shen T T,Shi J Y,Zhao J W,Holmes M.Food Anal.Method,2017,10(4):1034-1044.
[82]LüL J,Guo Y H,Zhao Y C,Zhao D D,Li M H.Chin.J.Chin.Mater.Med.(吕丽娟,郭永辉,赵雅婵,赵冬冬,李旻辉.中国中药杂志),2015,40(5):799-803.
[83]Liu Y,Li J Y,Fan G,Sun S Q,Zhang Y X,Zhang Y,Tu Y.J.Mol.Struct.,2016,1124:180-187.
[84]Wang C L,Wen J M,Cheng C,Jiang W K,Sun S Q,Tu Y.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(王朝鲁,温建民,程程,蒋科卫,孙素琴,图雅.光谱学与光谱分析),2009,29(6):1498-1501.
[85]Shen Y X,Zhao Y L,Zhang J,Wang Y Z,Zhang Q Z.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(申云霞,赵艳丽,张霁,王元忠,张庆芝.光谱学与光谱分析),2016,36(5):1369-1373.
[86]Li T,He X.Chem.Pharm.Bull.,2016,64(4):289-296.
[87]Ying X H,Pei Y,Liu M Y,Ding G Y,Jiang M,Liang Q L,Wang Y M,Bai G,Luo G A.Anal.Methods-UK,2014,6(12):4212-4218.
[88]Yan L F,Ma X K.Chin.J.Ethnomed.Ethnopharm.(阎立峰,马小科.中国民族民间医药),2010,19(9):1-2.
[89]Wang W N,Chen D L,Zhu M F,Zhang H M.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(王文娜,陈地灵,朱梅芳,张鹤鸣.光谱学与光谱分析),2013,33(8):2109-2111.
[90]Wei C H,Chen J,Xu M L,Qi X Y.J.Jiangsu Univ.(Med.Ed.)(卫程华,陈娟,许曼翎,戚雪勇.江苏大学学报医学版),2015,25(3):263-267.
[91]Gao J M,Zhang Z M,Li G K.J.Instrum.Anal.(高嘉敏,张卓旻,李攻科.分析测试学报),2016,35(12):1647-1653.
[92]Li D,LüD Y,Chen H,Lu F,Chen Q,Chu K D.Chin.J.Pharm.Anal.(李丹,吕狄亚,陈辉,陆峰,陈强,褚克丹.药物分析杂志),2015,35(8):1466-1470.
[93]Han S Q G W,Ha S W L J,Lin X,Lin S,Yang F,Lou X T,LüZ W.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(韩斯琴高娃,哈斯乌力吉,林翔,林爽,杨芳,娄秀涛,吕志伟.光谱学与光谱分析),2015,35(10):2773-2775.
[94]Bu R B T,Han S Q G W,Ha S W L J,Lin X,Lin S,Lou X T,LüZ W.Chin.J.Pharm.Anal.(布仁巴图,韩斯琴高娃,哈斯乌力吉,林翔,林爽,娄秀涛,吕志伟.药物分析杂志),2015,35(7):1279-1282.
[95]Jin P C,Zhang J,Shen T,Wang Y Z.J.Instrum.Anal.(金鹏程,张霁,沈涛,王元忠.分析测试学报),2015,34(10):1113-1118.
[96]Zhong G,Zhang J,Zhang J Y,Li T,Wang Y Z.J.Henan Agric.Sci.(钟贵,张霁,张金渝,李涛,王元忠.河南农业科学),2015,44(9):91-94.
[97]Di Z,Zhao Y L,Zhang J,Wang Y Z,Li L.Chin.J.Exp.Tradit.Med.Formulae(狄准,赵艳丽,张霁,王元忠,李鹂.中国实验方剂学杂志),2016,22(18):21-26.
[98]Zhang J Y,Wang Y Z,Zhao Y L,Yang S B,Zhang J,Yuan T J,Wang J J,Jin H.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(张金渝,王元忠,赵艳丽,杨绍兵,张霁,袁天军,王家俊,金航.光谱学与光谱分析),2012,32(8):2176-2180.
[99]Liu C L,Meng Q G.Rock Miner.Anal.(刘昌岭,孟庆国.岩矿测试),2014,33(4):468-479.
[100]Duan X W,Liu Y,Sun H.J.Inner Mongol.Univ.(段新文,刘远,孙浩.内蒙古大学学报),2015,46(1):48-54.
[101]Gong N B,Huang R S,Wu Y S,Liang Q C,LüY.Chin.Tradit.Pat.Med.(龚宁波,黄瑞松,吴云山,梁启成,吕扬.中成药),2009,31(11):1729-1731.
[102]Zhu L Y,Xie J F,Kong Z M,Li G P,Han Y P.Chin.J.Chin.Mater.Med.(朱林燕,谢建锋,孔子铭,李高平,韩泳平.中国中药杂志),2015,40(10):1948-1952.
[103]Li C,Suo L,Ze G,Wang Z,Du Y Z,Wei L X.Chin.J.Pharm.Anal.(李岑,索朗,泽戈,王章,杜玉枝,魏立新.药物分析杂志),2011,31(12):2220-2224.
[104]Li C,Sang L,Leng B C R,Xia Z J,Du Y Z,Wei L X.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(李岑,桑老,楞本才让,夏振江,杜玉枝,魏立新.光谱学与光谱分析),2012,32(6):1671-1673.
[105]Li C,Yang H X,Du Y Z,Xiao Y C,Dui Z,Lao S,Wang Z,Ladan D J,Bi H T,Wei L X.Bioinorg.Chem.Appl.,2016,2016:1-11.
[106]Lei W,Song Y L,Guo X Y,Tu P F,Jiang Y.Food Res.Int.,2015,67:155-162.
[107]Su Y W,Tan E,Zhang J,You J L,Liu Y,Liu C,Zhou X D,Zhang Y.Chin.J.Chin.Mater.Med.(苏永文,谭尔,张静,游佳莉,刘悦,刘川,周向东,张艺.中国中药杂志),2014,39(21):4234-4239.
[108]Liu Y,Fan G,Zhang J,Zhang Y,Li J J,Xiong C,Zhang Q,Li X D,Lai X R.Sci.Rep.,2017,7:1585.
[109]Kortesniemi M,Sinkkonen J,Yang B R,Kallio H.Food Chem.,2014,147:138-146.
[110]Pan Z,Fan G,Yang R P,Luo W Z,Zhou X D,Zhang Y.Phytochem.Anal.,2015,26(4):247-252.
[111]Pan Z,Mao Q,Jiang S,Fan G,Zhang Y.Chin.Tradit.Pat.Med.(潘正,毛庆,江生,范刚,张艺.中成药),2015,37(3):567-570.
[112]Pan Y,Zhang J,Zhao Y L,Wang Y Z,Jin H.Phytochem.Anal.,2016,27(3/4):158-167.
[113]Wang Y Z,Liu E,Li P.J.Pharmaceut.Biomed.,2017,140:20-30.
[114]Rout G R,Swain D.J.Med.Plants,2016,4(6):274-278.
[115]Yang N N,Zhang J,Zhao Y L,Wang Y Z,Zhao Y H.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(杨妮娜,张霁,赵艳丽,王元忠,赵应红.光谱学与光谱分析),2016,36(12):4021-4027.
[116]Yang N N,Yang C Y,Wang Y Z,Zhao Y H.Spectrosc.Spect.Anal.(杨妮娜,杨春勇,王元忠,赵应红.光谱学与光谱分析),2017,37(1):58-64.
[117]Yang Y G,Jin H,Zhang J,Zhang J Y,Wang Y Z.J.Nat.Med.,2017,71(1):148-157.
[118]Chu B W,Zhang J,Li Z M,Zhao Y L,Zuo Z T,Wang Y Z,Li W Y.J.Nat.Med.,2016,70(4):803-810.
[119]Li Y,Zhang J,Li T,Liu H G,Li J Q,Wang Y Z.Spectrochim.Acta A,2017,177:20-27.
[120]Obisesan K A,Jiménez-Carvelo A M,Cuadros-Rodriguez L,Ruisánchez I,Callao M P.Talanta,2017,170:413-418.
[121]Sun W J,Zhang X,Zhang Z Y,Zhu R H.Spectrochim.Acta A,2017,171:72-79.