基于WoS数据库的馆际互借与文献传递研究综述
|
摘要
[目的/意义]整体把握馆际互借和文献传递发展脉络,探索馆际互借和文献传递的未来发展趋势。[方法/过程]以Wo S核心合集作为统计源,采用文献计量学方法对国外馆际互借与文献传递研究文献的发文时间、国家与地区、机构与作者、发表刊物等进行统计分析;利用His Cite和Cite Space筛选出重要相关文献,在对其进行阅读归纳的基础上,进行馆际互借研究的发展脉胳与主题分析。[结果/结论]馆际互借可分为传统馆际互借时期(20世纪80年代以前)、馆际互借研究迅速发展期(1980-1990年)、文献传递快速上升期(1990-2000年)、动态发展期(2000-2016年)4个阶段,未来馆际互借员角色应更加多样化。
[Purpose/significance]This paper aims to explore the development and future of Interlibrary Loan.[Method/process]Based on the literature in Web of science core collection,this paper analyzed the distribution time,countries,institutions,authors,publications,research topics and cited reference using bibliometric method. On this basis,His Cite and Cite Space were used to filter important relevant papers as reading and inducing subject,to analyze the subjects and the development of interlibrary loan and document delivery. [Result/conclusion]The development of interlibrary loan can be divided into four periods: the traditional period of interlibrary loan( before the 1980 s),the rapid development of interlibrary loan research(1980-1990),the rapid rise of document delivery(1990-2000),the dynamic development(2000-2016). The role of future interlibrary loan librarians should be more diversified.
[Purpose/significance]This paper aims to explore the development and future of Interlibrary Loan.[Method/process]Based on the literature in Web of science core collection,this paper analyzed the distribution time,countries,institutions,authors,publications,research topics and cited reference using bibliometric method. On this basis,His Cite and Cite Space were used to filter important relevant papers as reading and inducing subject,to analyze the subjects and the development of interlibrary loan and document delivery. [Result/conclusion]The development of interlibrary loan can be divided into four periods: the traditional period of interlibrary loan( before the 1980 s),the rapid development of interlibrary loan research(1980-1990),the rapid rise of document delivery(1990-2000),the dynamic development(2000-2016). The role of future interlibrary loan librarians should be more diversified.
引文
[1]MCGRATH M.A farewell from the editor to Interlending and document supply[J].Interlending&document supply,2016,44(4):186-190.
[2]陈涛,顾红.国外文献传递研究综述[J].国外社会科学,2008(6):96-102.
[3]黄洁晶,高波.近10年国外馆际互借理论研究进展[J].中国图书馆学报,2008(2):87-92.
[4]高波,林婷.国外文献传递理论研究进展:2000-2008[J].图书情报工作,2010,54(9):9-13.
[5]夏磊.近十年国外馆际互借和文献传递研究的文献综述[J].图书馆杂志,2011,30(7):14-17.
[6]MAK C.Resource sharing among ARL libraries in the US.35years of growth[J].Interlending&document supply,2011,39(1):26-31.
[7]WALDHART T J.The growth of interlibrary loans among ARL university libraries[J].The journal of academic librarianship,1984,10(4):204-208.
[8]BUDD J.Interlibrary loan service:a study of turnaround time[J].RASD Update,1986,26(1):75-80.
[9]CORNISH G P.Copyright law and document supply:a world-wide review of development 1986-89[J].Interlending&document supply,1989,17(4):117-123.
[10]BARWICK M.Interlending and document supply:a review of recent literature-XXXII[J].Interlending&document supply,1997,25(3):126-132.
[11]KUROSMAN K,DURNIAK B A.Document delivery:a comparison of commercial document suppliers and interlibrary loan services[J].College&research libraries,1994,55(2):129-139.
[12]PEDERSEN W,GREGORY D.Interlibrary loan and commercial document supply:finding the right fit[J].The journal of academic librarianship,1994,20(5/6):263-272.
[13]KINNUCAN M T.Demand for document delivery and interlibrary loan in academic settings[J].Library and information science research,1993,15(4):355-374.
[14]GOULD S.Interlending and document supply:a review of recent literature.XXX1[J].Interlending&document supply,1997,25(1):27-35.
[15]CORNISH G P.Copyright and document delivery in the electronic environment[J].Interlending&document supply,1998,26(3):123-129.
[16]BRASSIL J T,LOW S,MAXEMCHUK N F.Copyright protection for the electronic distribution of text documents[J].Proceedings of the IEEE,1999,87(7):1181-1196.
[17]DOBSON C,PEDERSEN W A.Document delivery to developing countries[J].Interlending&document supply,1998,26(1):3-9.
[18]MCGRATH M.Interlending and document supply:a review of the recent literature;94[J].Interlending&document supply,2016,44(4):182-185.
[19]DE JONG C J,FREDERIKSEN L J.CARL Libraries-a Canadian resource-sharing experience[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(1):22-33.
[20]BERNARDINI E,MANGIARACINA S.The relationship between ILL/document supply and journal subscriptions[J].Interlending&document supply,2011,39(1):9-25.
[21]GAVEL Y.Bringing the national interlending system into the local document supply process-a Swedish case study[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(2):104-109.
[22]ECHEVERERRIA M,BARREDO P.Online journals:their impact on document delivery[J].Interlending&document supply,2005,33(3):145-149.
[23]KIDD T.Does electronic journal access affect document delivery requests?some data from Glasgow University library[J].Interlending&document supply,2003,31(4):264-269.
[24]NISONGER T E,GUZI G.Approaches,techniques,and criteria for serials evaluation in the electronic environment[J].The serials librarian,2001,40(3-4):393-407.
[25]JACKSON M E.Will electronic journals eliminate the need for ILL?[J].Interlending&document supply,2004,32(3):192-193.
[26]GARROD P.E-books:are they the interlibrary lending model of the future?[J].Interlending&document supply,2004,32(4):227-233.
[27]WARD S M,WRAY T,DEBUS-LOPEZ K E.Collection development based on patron requests:collaboration between interlibrary loan and acquisitions[J].Library collections,acquisitions,and technical services,2003,27(2):203-213.
[28]MCGEE D.Assessing the borrow direct engineering e-book pilot[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(4):174-178.
[29]WALTERS W H.E-books in academic libraries:challenges for sharing and use[J].Journal of librarianship and information science,2014,46(2):85-95.
[30]孙维莲,曾丽军.《STM文献传递声明》及其对图书馆馆际互借服务的影响[J].中国图书馆学报,2014,40(1):118-122.
[31]CORNISH G P.Reform of UK copyright law and its benefits for libraries[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(1):14-17.
[32]TIESSEN R.How copyright affects interlibrary loan and electronic resources in Canada[J].Interlending&document supply,2012,40(1):49-54.
[33]DOAJ.Directory of open access journals[EB/OL].[2017-11-07].https://doaj.org/.
[34]ROAR.Registry of open access repositories[EB/OL].[2017-11-07].http://roar.eprints.org/.
[35]PIKE G H.Elsevier Buys SSRN.com:what it means for scholarly publication[EB/OL].[2018-04-23].http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2963709
[36]MCGRATH M.Interlending and document supply:a review of the recent literature:90[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(3):160-166.
[37]BOUKACEM-ZEGHMOURI C,SCHOPFEL J.Document supply and open access:an international survey on grey literature[J].Interlending&document supply,2006,34(3):96-104.
[38]BAICH T.Opening interlibrary loan to open access[J].Interlending&document supply,2012,40(1):55-60.
[39]BAICH T.Open access:help or hindrance to resource sharing?[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(2):68-75.
[40]SCHOPFEL J.Open access and document supply[J].Interlending&document supply,2014,42(4):187-195.
[41]郑建程,赵艳,肖曼,等.学术期刊从订阅模式向开放获取模式转化的经费可行性研究:OA2020的启示[J].图书情报工作,2016,60(12):75-80.
[42]GARDNER C C,GARDNER G J.Fast and furious(at publishers):the motivations behind crowdsourced research sharing[J].College&research libraries,2017,78(2):131-149.
[43]ZHAO L L.Riding the wave of open access:providing library research support for scholarly publishing literacy[J].Australian academic&research libraries,2014,45(1):3-18.
[2]陈涛,顾红.国外文献传递研究综述[J].国外社会科学,2008(6):96-102.
[3]黄洁晶,高波.近10年国外馆际互借理论研究进展[J].中国图书馆学报,2008(2):87-92.
[4]高波,林婷.国外文献传递理论研究进展:2000-2008[J].图书情报工作,2010,54(9):9-13.
[5]夏磊.近十年国外馆际互借和文献传递研究的文献综述[J].图书馆杂志,2011,30(7):14-17.
[6]MAK C.Resource sharing among ARL libraries in the US.35years of growth[J].Interlending&document supply,2011,39(1):26-31.
[7]WALDHART T J.The growth of interlibrary loans among ARL university libraries[J].The journal of academic librarianship,1984,10(4):204-208.
[8]BUDD J.Interlibrary loan service:a study of turnaround time[J].RASD Update,1986,26(1):75-80.
[9]CORNISH G P.Copyright law and document supply:a world-wide review of development 1986-89[J].Interlending&document supply,1989,17(4):117-123.
[10]BARWICK M.Interlending and document supply:a review of recent literature-XXXII[J].Interlending&document supply,1997,25(3):126-132.
[11]KUROSMAN K,DURNIAK B A.Document delivery:a comparison of commercial document suppliers and interlibrary loan services[J].College&research libraries,1994,55(2):129-139.
[12]PEDERSEN W,GREGORY D.Interlibrary loan and commercial document supply:finding the right fit[J].The journal of academic librarianship,1994,20(5/6):263-272.
[13]KINNUCAN M T.Demand for document delivery and interlibrary loan in academic settings[J].Library and information science research,1993,15(4):355-374.
[14]GOULD S.Interlending and document supply:a review of recent literature.XXX1[J].Interlending&document supply,1997,25(1):27-35.
[15]CORNISH G P.Copyright and document delivery in the electronic environment[J].Interlending&document supply,1998,26(3):123-129.
[16]BRASSIL J T,LOW S,MAXEMCHUK N F.Copyright protection for the electronic distribution of text documents[J].Proceedings of the IEEE,1999,87(7):1181-1196.
[17]DOBSON C,PEDERSEN W A.Document delivery to developing countries[J].Interlending&document supply,1998,26(1):3-9.
[18]MCGRATH M.Interlending and document supply:a review of the recent literature;94[J].Interlending&document supply,2016,44(4):182-185.
[19]DE JONG C J,FREDERIKSEN L J.CARL Libraries-a Canadian resource-sharing experience[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(1):22-33.
[20]BERNARDINI E,MANGIARACINA S.The relationship between ILL/document supply and journal subscriptions[J].Interlending&document supply,2011,39(1):9-25.
[21]GAVEL Y.Bringing the national interlending system into the local document supply process-a Swedish case study[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(2):104-109.
[22]ECHEVERERRIA M,BARREDO P.Online journals:their impact on document delivery[J].Interlending&document supply,2005,33(3):145-149.
[23]KIDD T.Does electronic journal access affect document delivery requests?some data from Glasgow University library[J].Interlending&document supply,2003,31(4):264-269.
[24]NISONGER T E,GUZI G.Approaches,techniques,and criteria for serials evaluation in the electronic environment[J].The serials librarian,2001,40(3-4):393-407.
[25]JACKSON M E.Will electronic journals eliminate the need for ILL?[J].Interlending&document supply,2004,32(3):192-193.
[26]GARROD P.E-books:are they the interlibrary lending model of the future?[J].Interlending&document supply,2004,32(4):227-233.
[27]WARD S M,WRAY T,DEBUS-LOPEZ K E.Collection development based on patron requests:collaboration between interlibrary loan and acquisitions[J].Library collections,acquisitions,and technical services,2003,27(2):203-213.
[28]MCGEE D.Assessing the borrow direct engineering e-book pilot[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(4):174-178.
[29]WALTERS W H.E-books in academic libraries:challenges for sharing and use[J].Journal of librarianship and information science,2014,46(2):85-95.
[30]孙维莲,曾丽军.《STM文献传递声明》及其对图书馆馆际互借服务的影响[J].中国图书馆学报,2014,40(1):118-122.
[31]CORNISH G P.Reform of UK copyright law and its benefits for libraries[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(1):14-17.
[32]TIESSEN R.How copyright affects interlibrary loan and electronic resources in Canada[J].Interlending&document supply,2012,40(1):49-54.
[33]DOAJ.Directory of open access journals[EB/OL].[2017-11-07].https://doaj.org/.
[34]ROAR.Registry of open access repositories[EB/OL].[2017-11-07].http://roar.eprints.org/.
[35]PIKE G H.Elsevier Buys SSRN.com:what it means for scholarly publication[EB/OL].[2018-04-23].http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2963709
[36]MCGRATH M.Interlending and document supply:a review of the recent literature:90[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(3):160-166.
[37]BOUKACEM-ZEGHMOURI C,SCHOPFEL J.Document supply and open access:an international survey on grey literature[J].Interlending&document supply,2006,34(3):96-104.
[38]BAICH T.Opening interlibrary loan to open access[J].Interlending&document supply,2012,40(1):55-60.
[39]BAICH T.Open access:help or hindrance to resource sharing?[J].Interlending&document supply,2015,43(2):68-75.
[40]SCHOPFEL J.Open access and document supply[J].Interlending&document supply,2014,42(4):187-195.
[41]郑建程,赵艳,肖曼,等.学术期刊从订阅模式向开放获取模式转化的经费可行性研究:OA2020的启示[J].图书情报工作,2016,60(12):75-80.
[42]GARDNER C C,GARDNER G J.Fast and furious(at publishers):the motivations behind crowdsourced research sharing[J].College&research libraries,2017,78(2):131-149.
[43]ZHAO L L.Riding the wave of open access:providing library research support for scholarly publishing literacy[J].Australian academic&research libraries,2014,45(1):3-18.