摘要
侗语精知庄章组中古层汉借词的读音较为特殊:精组为s,知庄章组合并,读为。这与侗语自身音系有关,也与借源汉语有关。另外,个别侗语方言还有精知庄章组塞化现象和精组弱化为h的现象。
The pronunciation of the initials of the Jing(精),Zhi(知),Zhuang(庄),Zhang(章)groups in the Middle Chinese loanwords in Kam is special:The pronunciation of the initial in the Jing group is/s/,with the initials of the Jing,Zhi,Zhuang,Zhang groups merging into a group,reading as//.These phenomena have resulted from the influence of the Kam phonology and the phonology of the Middle Chinese loan words.Additionally,in some Kam dialects,the initials of the Jing,Zhi,Zhuang,Zhang groups have changed into stops and that of the Jing group has been weakened as/h/.
引文
Bi,Qianqi(毕谦琦).2015.Dong-Han shanggu guanxici de yuyin tedian侗汉上古关系词的语音特点[The phonological features of old Kam-Chinese corresponding words].Yuyan Yanjiu Jikan(dishiwu ji)语言研究集刊(第十五辑)[Bulletin of Linguistic(15)],250-268.Shanghai:Shanghai Cishu Chubanshe上海:上海辞书出版社[Shanghai:Shanghai Lexicographical Press].
Bi,Qianqi(毕谦琦).2017.Yongcong dongyu hanjieci de lishi cengci ji jige xiangguan wenti de taolun永从侗语汉借词的历史层次及几个相关问题的讨论[The historical layers of the Yongcong Dong language and the relating problems].Yuyan Yanjiu Jikan(dishiba ji)语言研究集刊(第十八辑)[Bulletin of Linguistic(18)],259-276.Shanghai:Shanghai Cishu Chubanshe上海:上海辞书出版社[Shanghai:Shanghai Lexicographical Press].
Bo,Wenze(薄文泽).1997.Yanghuangyu佯僙语[Yanghuang Language].Shanghai:Shanghai Yuandong Chubanshe上海:上海远东出版社[Shanghai:Shanghai Far East Press].
Cao,Zhiyun(曹志耘).2014.Tongdao dongyu shengmu de busongqihua xianxiang:Jianyu ganyu bijiao通道侗语声母的不送气化现象---兼与赣语比较[Deaspiration of initials in Tongdao Kam language:With reference to parallel phenomenon in the Gan dialect].Minzu Yuwen民族语文[Minority Languages of China]2014.3:37-44.
Chen,Zhongmin(陈忠敏).2015.Lun 160nian qian Shanghaihua shengmu[dz][z]bianyi:Jianlun beibu wuyu cong Xie Cheng Chong Chuan Chan Dengmu duyin bianyi xianxiang论160年前上海话声母[dz][z]变异---兼论北部吴语从邪澄崇船禅等母读音变异现象[On the variation of the initial[dz][z]in Shanghai dialect 160years ago].Fangyan方言[Dialect]2015.4:340-345.
Du,Jialun(杜佳伦).2014.Minyu Lishi Cengci Fenxi yu Xiangguan Yinbian Tantao闽语历史层次分析与相关音变探讨[The Historical Levels Analysis of Min Dialect and Some Related Discussion].Shanghai:Zhongxi Shuju上海:中西书局[Shanghai:Zhongxi Book Company].
Gong,Qunhu(龚群虎).2002.Han-Tai Guanxici de Shijian Cengci汉泰关系词的时间层次[A Study of Sino-Thai Chronological Strata].Shanghai:Fudan Daxue Chubanshe上海:复旦大学出版社[Shanghai:The Fudan University Press].
Guizhou Provincial Ethnic Language Steering Committee(贵州省民族语文指导委员会).(ed.)1959.Dongzu Yuyan Wenzi Wenti Kexue Taolunhui Huikan侗族语言文字问题科学讨论会汇刊[The Scientific Symposium Essays of Dong Language and Characters].
Jacques,Guillaume(向柏霖),&Qingyuan Lan(蓝庆元).2013.Zhongguo Shaoshu Minzu Yuyan Hanyu Jieci de Lishi Cengci中国少数民族语言汉语借词的历史层次[Chinese Loanwords in Minority Languages].Beijing:Shangwu Yinshuguan北京:商务印书馆[Beijing:The Commercial Press].
Lan,Qingyuan(蓝庆元).2001.Zhuangyu zhonggu hanyu jieci ji hanyueyu yu pinghua de guanxi壮语中古汉语借词及汉越语与平话的关系[Middle ancient times Chinese Loanwords in Zhuang language and original relationship between Chinese Loanwords in Vietnamese and Ping dialect of Chinese].Minzu Yuwen民族语文[Minority Languages of China]2001.3:48-61.
Lan,Qingyuan(蓝庆元).2005.Han-Zhuang Tongyuanci Jieci Yanjiu汉壮同源词借词研究[A Study of Cognate Words and Loanwords in Zhuang and Chinese].Beijing:Zhongyang Minzu Daxue Chubanshe北京:中央民族大学出版社[Beijing:Minzu University of China Press].
Lan,Qingyuan(蓝庆元).2011.Lajiayu Yanjiu拉珈语研究[A Study of Lajia Language].Guilin:Guangxi Shifan Daxue Chubanshe桂林:广西师范大学出版社[Guilin:Guangxi Normal University Press].
Laurent,Sagart(沙加尔),&Shixuan Xu(徐世璇).2002.Haniyu zhong hanyu jieci de lishi cengci哈尼语中汉语借词的历史层次[The historical layers of loanwords in Hani].Zhongguo Yuwen中国语文[Studies of the Chinese Language]2002.1:55-65.
Li,Lianjin(李连进).2000.Pinghua Yinyun Yanjiu平话音韵研究[A Study of the Phonology of the Ping Dialect].Nanning:Guangxi Renmin Chubanshe南宁:广西人民出版社[Nanning:Guangxi People’s Publishing House].
Li,Lianjin(李连进).2002.Zhuangyu laojieci,hanyueyu he pinghua de lishi yuanliu guanxi壮语老借词、汉越语和平话的历史源流关系[Historical source relations of Zhuang language’s old loanwords Han-Viet phonetics Pinghua group and Yue group].Guangxi Shiyuan Xuebao广西师院学报[Journal of Guangxi Theachers College]2002.4:87-91.
Liang,Min(梁敏),&Junru Zhang(张均如).1996.Dongtai Yuzu Gailun侗台语族概论[The Introduction of Kamdai Language].Beijing:Zhongguo Shehui Kexue Chubanshe北京:中国社会科学出版社[Beijing:The China Social Science Press].
Liu,Xiangyou(刘祥友).2009.Xiangnan tuhua zhong“t”、“th”teshu yindu de laiyuan湘南土话中t、th特殊音读的来源[On the origins of special sounds:“t”and“th”in South Hunan Dialects].Anqing Shifan Xueyuan Xuebao(shehui kexue ban)安庆师范学院学报(社会科学版)[Journal of Anqing Teachers College(social science edition)]2009.8:125-128.
Mai,Yun(麦耘).1997.Zhonggu jingzuzi zai yueyu zhu cifangyan de butong dufa jiqi lishi hanyi中古精组字在粤语诸次方言的不同读法及其历史涵义[The different froms pronunciation of the initials of Jing group in Cantonese dialects its historical meaning].Zhongguo Yuyan Xuebao中国语言学报[Journal of Chinese Linguistics]1997.2:211-226.
Sun,Lixin(孙立新).1994.Shaanxi Chengcheng fangyan Xinmu feng Hongyin duzuo[t]shengmu陕西澄城方言心母逢洪音读作[t]声母[The s-initial was prounaced[t]before broad vowels].Zhongguo Yuwen中国语文[Studies of the Chinese Language]1994.5:392-392.
Wan,Bo(万波).2009.Ganyu Shengmu de Lishi Cengci Yanjiu赣语声母的历史层次研究[The Studies of the Historical Layers of Gan Dialect Initials].Beijing:Shangwu Yinshuguan北京:商务印书馆[Beijing:The Commercial Press].
Wei,Shuguan(韦树关).2001.Lun Yuenanyu zhong de Hanyueyin yu hanyu Pinghua fangyan de guanxi论越南语中的汉越音与汉语平话方言的关系[On the relationship between the Sino-Vietnamese sound and Pingua dialect].Guangxi Minzu Xueyuan Xuebao广西民族学院学报[Journal of Guangxi College for Nationalities]2001.2:127-130.
Wei,Shuguan(韦树关).2002.Gu Bang,Duan,Xinmu zai Guangxi hanyu fangyan zhongde teshu yindu古帮、端、心母在广西汉语方言中的特殊音读[The special pronunciations of ancient Bang,Duan,Xin in the Chinese dialects of Guangxi].Guangxi Minzu Xueyuan Xuebao广西民族学院学报[Journal of Guangxi College for Nationalities]2002.1:149-151.
Xin,Shibiao(辛世彪).2005.Hainan Minyu Jing Zhuang Zhang shengmu de sehua yu diceng yuyan de yingxiang海南闽语精庄章声母的塞化与底层语言的影响[The stopping of initals about Jing Zhuang Zhang of Minnan dialect in Hainan and the influence from underlying language].Minzu Yuwen民族语文[Minority Languages of China]2005.1:15-20.
Xin,Shibiao(辛世彪).2006.Lingaoyu shengmu de teshu yinbian ji yuqi tongzu yuyan de guanxi临高语声母的特殊音变及与其同族语言的关系[The special sound changes in the initials of Lingao language and the relationship between the these phenomena and cognate languages].Dongfang Yuyanxue东方语言学[Oriental Linguistics]2006.1:213-245.
Xin,Shibiao(辛世彪).2013.Hainan Minyu Bijiao Yanjiu海南闽语比较研究[A Comparative Study of Hainan Min Dialect].Beijing:Shangwu Yinshuguan北京:商务印书馆[Beijing:The Commercial Press].
Yue,Jing(岳静).2006.Huangjinzhen Mulaoyu zhonggu Jing Zhangzu hanjieci de duyin黄金镇仫佬语中古精章组汉借词的读音[The pronunciation of the Jing Zhang groups initials in huangjin town Mulao language middle Chinese Loanwords].Minzu Yuwen民族语文[Minority Languages of China]2006.1:35-44.
Zeng,Xiaoyu(曾晓渝).2002.Lun Shuiyu shengmu s->h-de lishi yinbian论水语声母s->h-的历史音变[On the historical sound change s->h-in Shui language].Minzu Yuwen民族语文[Minority Languages of China]2002.1:1-9.
Zeng,Xiaoyu(曾晓渝).2004.Hanyu Shuiyu Guanxi Lun汉语水语关系论[On the Linguistic Relationships between Sino and Sui].Beijing:Shangwu Yinshuguan北京:商务印书馆[Beijing:The Commercial Press].
Zhang,Junru(张均如).1983.Zhuangdong yuzu secayin de chansheng he fazhan壮侗语族塞擦音的产生和发展[The emergence and development of the affricate in Zhuang Dong languages].Minzu Yuwen民族语文[Minority Languages of China]1983.1:19-29.
Zhang,Junru(张均如).1999.Zhuangyu Fangyan Yanjiu壮语方言研究[The Study of the Dilects of Zhuang Language].Chengdu:Sichuan Minzu Chubanshe成都:四川民族出版社[Chengdu:Sichuan Nationalities publishing house].
Zhang,Yuansheng(张元生).1985.Hainan Lingaohua海南临高话[Lingao Languege in Hainan Province].Nanning:Guangxi Minzu Chubanshe南宁:广西民族出版社[Nanning:Guangxi Nationalities Publishing House].
Zhou,Yaowen(周耀文),&Meizhen Luo(罗美珍).2001.Daiyu Fangyan Yanjiu傣语方言研究[The Study of the Dilects of Dai Language].Beijing:Minzu Chubanshe北京:民族出版社[Beijing:The Ethnic Publishing House].
Zhu,Xiaonong(朱晓农).2007.Zheng zaoqi shangsheng dai jiasheng证早期上声带假声[Falsetto:The phonetic nature of rising tone in early times].Zhongguo Yuwen中国语文[Studies of the Chinese Language]2007.2:160-168.
Zhu,Xiaonong(朱晓农).2009.Shengdiao qiyin yu fasheng:Jianlun hanyu sisheng de faming声调起因于发声---兼论汉语四声的发明[Phonation as the phonetic cause of tonogenesis:With special reference to Chinese].Yuyan Yanjiu Jikan(diliüji)语言研究集刊(第六辑)[Bulletin of Linguistic(6)],1-29.Shanghai:Shanghai Cishu Chubanshe上海:上海辞书出版社[Shanghai:Shanghai Lexicographical Press].
Zhu,Xiaonong(朱晓农).2010.Yuyinxue语音学[Phonetics].Beijing:Shangwu Yinshuguan北京:商务印书馆[Beijing:The Commercial Press].
[1]关于民族语汉借词分层的理论和具体操作方法,沙加尔和徐世璇(2002)、龚群虎(2002)、曾晓渝(2002,2004)、蓝庆元(2005)等学者已经有过详细的论述,本文即是按照上述学者的理论和方法进行分层。
[2]本文所用侗语材料来源说明如下:榕江县车江侗语,本人2013年暑假调查,发音人吴永谊(1986年生),以及中央民族学院少数民族语言研究所第五研究室编写的《壮侗语族语言词汇集》(1985)所收的车江侗语材料;天柱县石洞侗语,本人2013年暑假调查,发音人龙启益(1958年生);锦屏县高坝侗语,本人2013年暑假调查,发音人石林(1945年生);永从侗语,本人2013年暑假和2015年暑假调查,发音人石锦宏(1963年生)、龙全佑(1990年生);从江县平江侗语,本人2013年暑假调查,发音人潘永乐(1974年生);榕江县乐里侗语,本人2013年暑假调查,发音人姜才晖(1972年生);镇远报京侗语,本人2015年暑假调查,发音人邰通祥(1966年生)、邰光文(1961年生)。本文通道陈团、三江和里、从江贯洞、龙胜平等、黎平水口、大苗山寨怀等地的侗语材料来自上世纪50年代中国科学院少数民族语言调查第一工作队的调查卡片,由贵州民族大学龙耀宏教授整理并提供给笔者,在此表示感谢!
[3]关于六世纪南方汉语的这一现象可参看陈忠敏(2015),该文指出,从《颜氏家训》材料本身不能说明从邪两母在六世纪南方汉语中归并为浊擦音还是浊塞擦音。但是结合《可洪音义》等材料来看,应该是读浊擦音。古江东方言从邪澄崇禅船六母的情况都是如此,只是《颜氏家训》仅举从邪而已。
[4]临高语的例词见本文表9,仫佬语的例词见本文表4。