湖泊生态系统稳态转换理论与驱动因子研究进展
|
摘要
湖泊生态系统会在长期的人为胁迫和短期的强扰动下发生稳态转换,稳态转换前后湖泊生态系统的结构和关键过程会发生明显的变化,探求浅水湖泊稳态转换驱动因子是科学合理确定湖泊管理策略的关键所在。对湖泊生态系统稳态转换的理论内涵、驱动机制进行了总结和探讨。湖泊生态系统稳态转换的概念主要含有发生的突然性和难以预知性、系统的结构与功能发生明显变化以及存在多稳态现象等内涵;具有非线性、多阈值、多稳态,以及修复过程中的迟滞效应等特征。湖泊生态系统稳态转换的驱动因子可分为外部驱动和内部驱动两种类型。外部驱动包括外源性氮磷负荷、气候变化、风浪、湖泊水位等因子;外源性氮磷负荷和气候变化的影响具有长期性和累积性,通过逐步削弱湖泊生态系统恢复力进而引发稳态转换;风浪、湖泊水位等为突发性因子,往往表现为稳态转换的直接诱因。内部驱动包括鱼类、水生植物等因子;鱼类主要通过对水生植物、湖泊底质、浮游动物等生态组分的影响引发湖泊生态系统稳态转换;水生植物对湖泊清水稳态可能不仅存在正反馈作用,也会在一定条件下存在负反馈作用。今后应加强沉水植物生长消亡的主要环境与生物要素综合作用机理、湖泊稳态类型与主控因素等方面的研究。
The lake ecosystem can undergo regime shifts triggered by long-term human threats and short-term strong disturbance. Before and after regime shifts, the ecosystem structure and key processes will change dramatically. For scientific management and decision making on lakes, it is therefore essential to reveal the mechanism and explore the driving factors of regime shifts. We concluded and discussed the concept and driving factors of regime shifts. Changing dramatically and difficult to forecast, ecosystem structure and key processes change, alternative stable state are main connotations of the concept of regime shifts. The characteristics of regime shifts include non-linear, alternative stable state, multiple thresholds, and hysteresis during restoration. There are external and internal factors in driving shifts between alternative states. The external driving factors include external nutrient loadings, climate change, storm, and water level. The influence of external nutrient loadings and climate change on lake ecosystem are long-term and accumulative. They can weaken the ecological resilience of lake to trigger regime shifts. Storm and water level are short-term factors and can trigger regime shifts shortly. The internal driving factors include fish, macrophyte. Fish can impose influence on macrophyte, lake sediment and zooplankton to trigger regime shifts. There is not only positive feedback effect of macrophyte on clear state of lake, also under certain conditions there is negative feedback effect. Some potential research focus was proposed based on the intensive literature review, including:(a) integrated influence of environmental and biological factors on macrophyte,(b) dominated states and key processes controlling the state based on large scale lake survey.
The lake ecosystem can undergo regime shifts triggered by long-term human threats and short-term strong disturbance. Before and after regime shifts, the ecosystem structure and key processes will change dramatically. For scientific management and decision making on lakes, it is therefore essential to reveal the mechanism and explore the driving factors of regime shifts. We concluded and discussed the concept and driving factors of regime shifts. Changing dramatically and difficult to forecast, ecosystem structure and key processes change, alternative stable state are main connotations of the concept of regime shifts. The characteristics of regime shifts include non-linear, alternative stable state, multiple thresholds, and hysteresis during restoration. There are external and internal factors in driving shifts between alternative states. The external driving factors include external nutrient loadings, climate change, storm, and water level. The influence of external nutrient loadings and climate change on lake ecosystem are long-term and accumulative. They can weaken the ecological resilience of lake to trigger regime shifts. Storm and water level are short-term factors and can trigger regime shifts shortly. The internal driving factors include fish, macrophyte. Fish can impose influence on macrophyte, lake sediment and zooplankton to trigger regime shifts. There is not only positive feedback effect of macrophyte on clear state of lake, also under certain conditions there is negative feedback effect. Some potential research focus was proposed based on the intensive literature review, including:(a) integrated influence of environmental and biological factors on macrophyte,(b) dominated states and key processes controlling the state based on large scale lake survey.
引文
ALDRIDGE F J,SCHELSKE C L,CARRICK H J.1993.Nutient limitationin a hypereutrophic Floride lake[J].Archives of Hydrobiology,127:21-37.
ANTON Hough R,FORNWALL M D,NEGELE B J,et al.1989.Plantcommunity dynamics in a chain of lakes:principal factors in thedecline of rooted with eutrophication[J].Hydrobiologia,173:199-217.
BACHMANN R W,HORSBURGH C A,HOYER M V,et al.2002.Relations betweent trophic state indicators and plant biomas in Floridalakes[J].Hydrobiologia,470:219-234.
BACHMANN R W,HOYER M V,CANFIELD D E.1999.The restorationof Lake Apopka in relation to alternative stable states[J].Hydrobiologia,394:219-232.
BATES B C,KUNDZEWICZ Z W,WU S,et al.2008.Climate Change andWater[R].Technical Paper of the Intergovernmental Panel on ClimateChange,IPCC Secretariat,Geneva,210.
BAYLEY S E,PRATHER C M.2003.DO wetland lakes exhibit alternativestable states?Submersed aquatic vegetation and chlorophy11 inwestern boreal shallow lakes[J].Limnology and Oceanography,48(6):2335-2345.
BILOTTA G S,BRAZIER R E.2008.Understanding the influence ofsuspended solids on water quality and aquatic[j].Water Research,42:2849-2861.
BLENCKNER T,OMSTEDT A,RUMMUKAINEN M.2002.A Swedishcase study of contemporary and possible future consequences ofclimate change on lake function[J].Aquatic Science,64:1-14.
BOLL T,JOHANSSON L S,LAURIDSEN T L,et al.2012.Changes inbenthic macroinvertebrate abundance and lake isotope(C,N)signalsfollowing biomanipulation:an 18-year study in shallow Lake Vaeng,Denmark[J].Hydrobiologia,686:135-145.
BOURAOUI F,GRIZZETTI B,GRANLUND K,et al.2004.Impact ofclimate change on the water cycle and nutrient losses in a Finnishcatchment[J].Climatic Change,66:109-126.
CARPENTER S R,BROCK W A.2006.Rising variance:a leadingindicator of ecological transition[J].Ecology Letters,9:311-318.
CARPENTER S R,COLE J J,PACE,M L et al.2011.Early warnings ofregime shifts:a wholeecosystem experiment[J].Science,332:1079-1082.
CARPENTER S R,LATHROP R C.2008.Probabilistic estimate of athreshold for eutrophication[J].Ecosystems,11:601-613.
CARPENTER S R.1988.Complex interactions in Lake communities[M].Speringer-Verlag,New York,283.缺项
CARPENTER S R.2003.Regime Shifts in Lake Ecosystems:Pattern andVariation[M].Volume 15 in the Excellence in Ecology Series.EcologyInstitute,Oldendorf/Luhe,Germany.
CARPENTER S R.2005.Eutrophication of aquatic cosystems:bistabilityand soil phosphorus[J].Proc Natl Acad Sci USA,102:10002-10005.
CARVALHO L,KIRIKA A.2003.Changes in shallow lake functioning:response to climate change and nutrient reduction[J].Hydrobiologia,506-509,789-796.
CHAO P T,HOBBS B F,VENKATESH B N.1999.How climateuncertainty should be included in Great Lakes management:Modelingworkshop results[J].Journal of The American Water ResourcesAssociation,35(6):1485-1497.
CHOI J S.1998.Lake ecosystem responses to rapid climate change[J].Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,49:281-290.
CLAIR T A.1998.Canadian freshwater wetlands and climate change:guesteditorial[J].Climate Change,20:163-165.
COLLIE J S,RICHARDSON K,STEELE J H.2004.Regime shifts:canecological theory illuminate the mechanisms[J].?Progress inOceanography,60(2/4):281-302.
CONLEY D J,PAERL H W,HOWARTH R W,et al.2009a.Controllingeutrophication:nitrogen and phosphorus[J].Science,323:1014-1015.
CONLEY D J,PAERL H W,HOWARTH R W,et al.2009b.Eutrophication:Time to adjust expectations response[J].Science,324:724-725.
CURY P,SHANNON L.2004.Regime shifts in upwelling ecosystems:observed changes and possible mechanisms in the northern andsouthern Benguela[J].Progress in Oceanography,60:223-243.
Ellen van Donk,Ramesh D.Gulati,Arjen Iedema,et al.1993.Macrophyte-related shifts in the nitrogen and phosphorus contents ofthe different trophic levels in a biomanipulated shallow lakes[J].Hydrobiologia,251:19-26.
FOLKE C,CARPENTER S,WALKER B,et al.2004.Regime shifts,resilience,and biodiversity in ecosystem management[J].AnnualReview of Ecology and Systematics,35:557-581.
GONZALEZ SMA,JAPPESEN E,GOMA J,et al.2005.Does highnitrogen loading prevent clear water conditions in shallow lakes atmoderately high phosphorous concentrations[J].?Freshwater Biology,50:27-41.
Great Lakes Water Quality Board.2003.Climate Change and Water Qualityin the Great Lakes Basin:Report of the Great Lakes Water QualityBoard to the International Joint Commission[R].Canada:Great LakesWater Quality Board,135.
GROISMAN P Y,KNIGHT R W,KARL T R.2001.Heavy precipitationand high streamflow in the contiguous United States:Trends in thetwentieth century[J].Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society,82:219-246.
HARGEBY A,BLINDOW I,ANDERSSON G.2007.Long-term patterns ofshifts between clear and turbid states in lake Krankej?n and lakeT?kern[J].Ecosystems,10:28-35.
HAVENS K E,AUMEN N G.2000.Hypothesis driven experimentalresearch is necessary for natural resource management[J].Environmental Management,25:1-7.
HAVENS K E,JIN K R,RODUSKY A J,et al.2001.Hurricane effects on ashallow lake ecosystems and its response to a controlled manipulationof wate level[J].The Scientific World,1:44-70.
HOLLING C S.1973.Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems[J].Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics,4:1-2.
IBELINGS B W,PORTIELJE R,LAMMENS E,et al.2007.Resilience ofalternative stable states during the recovery of shallow lakes fromeutrophication:Lake Veluwe as a case study[J].Ecosystems,10:4-16.
JEPPESEN E,JENSEN J P,BRANCO C W C.2007.Restoration of shallowlakes by nutrient contrlo and biomanipulation-the successful strategyvaries with lake size and climate[J].Hydrobiologia,581:269-285.
JEPPESEN E,JENSEN J P,KRISTENSEN P,et al.1990.Fish manipulationas s lake restoration tool in shallow,eutrophic,temperate lakes 2:threshold levels,long-term stability and conclusions[J].Hydrobiologia,(200/201):219-227.
JEPPESEN E,S?NDERGAARD M,JENSEN J P,et al.2005.Lakeresponses to reduced nutrient loading–an analysis of contemporarylong-term data from 35 case studies[J].Freshwter Biology,50:1747-1771.
JEPPOESEN E,JENSEN J P,KRISTENSEN P,et al.1990.Fishmanipulation as a lake restoration tool in shallow,eutrophic,temperatelakes 2:threshold levedl,long-term stability and conclusions[J].Hydrobilologia,(200/201):21-227.
JOHN D I,GERALD L W,PAUL F T.1977.The Motion of a Small Spherein a Rotating Velocity Field:A Possible Mechanism for SuspendingParticles in Turbulence[J].Journal of geophysical research,82(15):2096-2100.
JONES J I,SAYER C D.2003.Does the fish-invertebrate-periphytoncascade precipitate plant loss in shallow[J]?Ecology,84(8):2155-2167.
KAMENIR Y,WINDER M,DUBINSKY Z,et al.2008.Lake Tahoe vs.Kinneret phytoplankton:comparison of long-term taxonomic sizestructure consistency[J].Aquatic Sciences,70:195-203.
KARL E.Havens,R.Thomas James,THERESE L.East,et al.2003.N∶Pratios,light limitation,and cyanobacterial dominance in a subtropicallake impacted by non-point source nutrient pollution[J].EnvironmentalPollution,122:379-390.
KOMATSU E,FUKUSHIMA T,HARASAWA H.2007.A modelingapproach to forecast the effect of long-term climate change on lakewater quality[J].Ecological Modelling,209(2/4):351-366.
KOSTEN S,LACEROT G,JEPPESEN E,et al.209.Effects of submergedvegetation on water clarity across climates[J].Ecosystems,12:1117-1129.
KUMAGAI M,ISHIKAWA K,CHUNMENG J.2003.Dynamics andbiogeochemical significance of the physical environment in LakeBiwa[J].Lakes Reserviors Research and Management,7:345-348.
KUZNETSOV Y A.1995.Elements of applied bifurcation theory[M].Springer-Verlag
LAMMENS E,VAN NES E H,MEIJER M L,et al.2004.Effects ofcommercial fishery on the bream population and the expansion ofChara aspera in Lake Veluwe[J].Ecological Modelling,177:233-244.
MALMAEUSA J M,BLENCKNERA T,MARKENSTENB H,et al.2006.Lake phosphorus dynamics and climate warming:a mechanistic modelapproach[J].Ecological Modelling,190(1/2):1-14.
MARSDEN S.1989.Lake restoration by reducing external phosphorusloading:the influence of sediment phosphorus release[J].FreshwaterBiology,21:139-162.
MARTIN R.Perrow,Brian Moss,Julia Stansfield.1994.Trophicinteractions in a shallow lake following a reduction in nutrient loading:a long-term study[J].Hydrobiologia,(275/276):43-52.
MAY R M.1977.Thresholds and breakpoints in ecosystems with amultiplicity of stable states[J].Nature,269:471-477.
NAJJAR R G.1999.The water balance of the Susquehanna River basin andits response to climate change[J].Journal of Hydrology,219:7-19.
NICHOLLS K H.1999.Effects of temperature and other factors on summerphosphorus in the inner Bay of Quinte,Lake Ontario:implications forclimate warming[J].Journal of Great Lakes Research,25(5):250-262.
PERROW M R,MOSS B,STANSFIELD J.1994.Trophic interactions in ashallow lake following a reduction in nutrient loading:a long-termstudy[J].Hydrobiologia,(275/276):43-52.
Roger W.Bachmann,Mark V.Hoyer,Daniel E.Canfield.1999.Therestoration of Lake Apopka in relation to alternative stable states[J].Hydrobiologia,394:219-232.
SCHEFFER M,BAKEMA A H,WORTELBOER F G.1993.MEGAPLANT-a simulation model for the dynamics of submergedplants[J].Aquatic Botany,45:341-356.
SCHEFFER M,BAKEMA A H,WORTELBOER F G.2000.MEGAPLANT-Calado G,Duarte P.Modelling growth of Ruppiacirrhosa[J].Aquatic Botany,68:29-44.
SCHEFFER M,CARPENTER S R.2003.Catastrophic regime shifts inecosystems:linking theory to observation[J].TRENDS in Ecology andEvolution,18(12):648-656.
SCHEFFER M,CARPENTER S R.2003.Catastrophic regime shifts inecosystems:linking theory to observation[J].Trends in ecology andevolution,18(12):648-656.
SCHEFFER M,CARPENTER S,JONATHAN A F,et al.2001.Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems[J].Nature,413:591-596.
SCHEFFER M,EGBERT H.van Nes.2007.Shallow lakes theory revisited:various alternative regimes driven by climate,nutrients,depth and lakesize[J].Hydrobiologia,584:455-466.
SCHEFFER M,HOSPER S H,MEIJER M-L,et al.1993.Alternativeequilibria in shallow lakes[J].Trends in Ecology and Evolution,8:275-279.
SCHEFFER M,SZABóS,GRAGNANI A,et al.2003.Floating plantdominance as a stable state[J].PNAS,100(7):4040-4045.
SCHEFFER M.1990.Multiplicity of stable states in a freshwater system[J].Hydrobiologia,(200/201):475-486.
SCHINDLER D W,HECHY R E.2009.Eutrophication:more nitrogen dataneeded[J].Science,324:721-722.
SCHINDLER D W,HECKY R E,FINDLAY D L,et al.2008.Eutrophication of lakes cannot be controlled by reducing nitrogeninput:Results of a 37-year whole-ecosystem experiment[J].PNAS,105:11254-11258.
SOLHEIM A L,REKOLAINEN S,MOE S J,et al.2008.Ecologicalthreshold responses in European lakes and their application for WaterFramework Directive(WFD)implementation:synthesis of lakesresults from the REBECCA project[J].Aquatic Ecology,42:317-334.
S?NDERGAARD M,JEPPESEN E,MORTENSEN E,et al.1990.Phytoplankton biomass reduction after planktivorous fish reduction ina shallow,eutrophic lake:a combined effect of reduced internalP-loading and increased zooplankton grazing[J].Hydrobillogia,(200/201):229-240.
VAN DEN BERG M S,SCHEFFER M,VAN NES E,et al.1999.Dynamicsand stability of Chara sp.and Potanmogeton petinatus in a shallowlake changing in eutrophication level[J].Hydrobiologia,(408/409):335-342.
VAN NES E H,RIP W J,SCHEFFER M.2007.A theory for cyclic shiftsbetween alternative states in shallow lakes[J].Ecosystems,10:17-27.
VAN NES E H,SCHEFFER M,VAN DEN BERG M S,et al.2002.Dominance of charophytes in eutriphic shallow lakes-when should weexpect it to be an alternative stable state[J].?Aquatic Botany,72:275-296.
VITOUSEK P M,MOONEY H A,LUBCHENCO J,et al.1997.Humandomination of earth’s ecosystems[J].Science,277:494-499.
WALLSTEN M,FORSGEN P.1989.The effects of increased water level onaquatic macrophytes[J].J.Aquat.Plant Manage,27:32-37.
WALTER K D,WILLIAM H C,KEITH G,et al.2010.Thresholds,breakpoints,and nonlinearity in freshwaters as related tomanagement[J].North American Benthological Society,29(3):988-997.
WINNIE J Rip,MAARTEN Ouboter,EGBERT H.van Nes,et al.2005.Oscillation of a shallow lake ecosystem upon redunction in externalphosphorus load[J].Archives of Hydrobiology,164(3):387-409.
YACOBI Y Z.2006.Temporal and vertical variation of chlorophyⅡaconcentration,phytoplankton photosynthetic activity and lightattenuation in Lake Kinneret:possibilities and limitations forsimulation by remote sensing[J].Jouranl of Plankton Research,28(8):725-736.
ZIMMER K D,HANSON M A,HERWIG B R,et al.2009.Thresholds andstability of alternative regimes in shallow Prairie-Parkland Lakes ofcentral North America[J].Ecosystems,12:843-852.
ZIMMER K D,HERVIG B R,LAURICH L M.2006.Nutrient excretion byfish in wetland ecosystems and its potential to support algalproduction[J].Limnology and Oceanography,51(1):197-207.
陈开宁,包先明,史龙新,等.2006.太湖五里湖重建示范工程-大型围隔实验[J].湖泊科学,18(2):139-149.
冯剑丰,王洪礼,朱琳.2009.生态系统多稳态研究进展[J].生态环境学报,18(4):1553-1559.
刘永定,常毅峰,潘晓洁,等.2007.淡水生态系统稳态转换理论及其指导意义[D].中国海洋湖沼学会藻类分会第七届会员大会暨第十四次学术讨论会论文摘要集.
秦伯强,宋玉芝,高光.2006.附着生物在浅水富营养化湖泊藻-草型生态系统转化过程中的作用[J].中国科学C辑:生命科学,36(3):283-288.
秦伯强.2002.长江中下游湖泊富营养化发生机制与控制途径初探[J].湖泊科学,14(3):193-201.
秦伯强.2007.湖泊生态恢复的基本原理与实现[J].生态学报,27(11):4848-4858.
舒庆.2008.“十一五”环境规划汇编[M].北京:红旗出版社.
张运林,秦伯强,胡维平,等.2006.太湖典型湖区真光层深度的时空变化及其生态意义[J].中国科学D辑:地球科学,36(3):287-296.
ANTON Hough R,FORNWALL M D,NEGELE B J,et al.1989.Plantcommunity dynamics in a chain of lakes:principal factors in thedecline of rooted with eutrophication[J].Hydrobiologia,173:199-217.
BACHMANN R W,HORSBURGH C A,HOYER M V,et al.2002.Relations betweent trophic state indicators and plant biomas in Floridalakes[J].Hydrobiologia,470:219-234.
BACHMANN R W,HOYER M V,CANFIELD D E.1999.The restorationof Lake Apopka in relation to alternative stable states[J].Hydrobiologia,394:219-232.
BATES B C,KUNDZEWICZ Z W,WU S,et al.2008.Climate Change andWater[R].Technical Paper of the Intergovernmental Panel on ClimateChange,IPCC Secretariat,Geneva,210.
BAYLEY S E,PRATHER C M.2003.DO wetland lakes exhibit alternativestable states?Submersed aquatic vegetation and chlorophy11 inwestern boreal shallow lakes[J].Limnology and Oceanography,48(6):2335-2345.
BILOTTA G S,BRAZIER R E.2008.Understanding the influence ofsuspended solids on water quality and aquatic[j].Water Research,42:2849-2861.
BLENCKNER T,OMSTEDT A,RUMMUKAINEN M.2002.A Swedishcase study of contemporary and possible future consequences ofclimate change on lake function[J].Aquatic Science,64:1-14.
BOLL T,JOHANSSON L S,LAURIDSEN T L,et al.2012.Changes inbenthic macroinvertebrate abundance and lake isotope(C,N)signalsfollowing biomanipulation:an 18-year study in shallow Lake Vaeng,Denmark[J].Hydrobiologia,686:135-145.
BOURAOUI F,GRIZZETTI B,GRANLUND K,et al.2004.Impact ofclimate change on the water cycle and nutrient losses in a Finnishcatchment[J].Climatic Change,66:109-126.
CARPENTER S R,BROCK W A.2006.Rising variance:a leadingindicator of ecological transition[J].Ecology Letters,9:311-318.
CARPENTER S R,COLE J J,PACE,M L et al.2011.Early warnings ofregime shifts:a wholeecosystem experiment[J].Science,332:1079-1082.
CARPENTER S R,LATHROP R C.2008.Probabilistic estimate of athreshold for eutrophication[J].Ecosystems,11:601-613.
CARPENTER S R.1988.Complex interactions in Lake communities[M].Speringer-Verlag,New York,283.缺项
CARPENTER S R.2003.Regime Shifts in Lake Ecosystems:Pattern andVariation[M].Volume 15 in the Excellence in Ecology Series.EcologyInstitute,Oldendorf/Luhe,Germany.
CARPENTER S R.2005.Eutrophication of aquatic cosystems:bistabilityand soil phosphorus[J].Proc Natl Acad Sci USA,102:10002-10005.
CARVALHO L,KIRIKA A.2003.Changes in shallow lake functioning:response to climate change and nutrient reduction[J].Hydrobiologia,506-509,789-796.
CHAO P T,HOBBS B F,VENKATESH B N.1999.How climateuncertainty should be included in Great Lakes management:Modelingworkshop results[J].Journal of The American Water ResourcesAssociation,35(6):1485-1497.
CHOI J S.1998.Lake ecosystem responses to rapid climate change[J].Environmental Monitoring and Assessment,49:281-290.
CLAIR T A.1998.Canadian freshwater wetlands and climate change:guesteditorial[J].Climate Change,20:163-165.
COLLIE J S,RICHARDSON K,STEELE J H.2004.Regime shifts:canecological theory illuminate the mechanisms[J].?Progress inOceanography,60(2/4):281-302.
CONLEY D J,PAERL H W,HOWARTH R W,et al.2009a.Controllingeutrophication:nitrogen and phosphorus[J].Science,323:1014-1015.
CONLEY D J,PAERL H W,HOWARTH R W,et al.2009b.Eutrophication:Time to adjust expectations response[J].Science,324:724-725.
CURY P,SHANNON L.2004.Regime shifts in upwelling ecosystems:observed changes and possible mechanisms in the northern andsouthern Benguela[J].Progress in Oceanography,60:223-243.
Ellen van Donk,Ramesh D.Gulati,Arjen Iedema,et al.1993.Macrophyte-related shifts in the nitrogen and phosphorus contents ofthe different trophic levels in a biomanipulated shallow lakes[J].Hydrobiologia,251:19-26.
FOLKE C,CARPENTER S,WALKER B,et al.2004.Regime shifts,resilience,and biodiversity in ecosystem management[J].AnnualReview of Ecology and Systematics,35:557-581.
GONZALEZ SMA,JAPPESEN E,GOMA J,et al.2005.Does highnitrogen loading prevent clear water conditions in shallow lakes atmoderately high phosphorous concentrations[J].?Freshwater Biology,50:27-41.
Great Lakes Water Quality Board.2003.Climate Change and Water Qualityin the Great Lakes Basin:Report of the Great Lakes Water QualityBoard to the International Joint Commission[R].Canada:Great LakesWater Quality Board,135.
GROISMAN P Y,KNIGHT R W,KARL T R.2001.Heavy precipitationand high streamflow in the contiguous United States:Trends in thetwentieth century[J].Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society,82:219-246.
HARGEBY A,BLINDOW I,ANDERSSON G.2007.Long-term patterns ofshifts between clear and turbid states in lake Krankej?n and lakeT?kern[J].Ecosystems,10:28-35.
HAVENS K E,AUMEN N G.2000.Hypothesis driven experimentalresearch is necessary for natural resource management[J].Environmental Management,25:1-7.
HAVENS K E,JIN K R,RODUSKY A J,et al.2001.Hurricane effects on ashallow lake ecosystems and its response to a controlled manipulationof wate level[J].The Scientific World,1:44-70.
HOLLING C S.1973.Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems[J].Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics,4:1-2.
IBELINGS B W,PORTIELJE R,LAMMENS E,et al.2007.Resilience ofalternative stable states during the recovery of shallow lakes fromeutrophication:Lake Veluwe as a case study[J].Ecosystems,10:4-16.
JEPPESEN E,JENSEN J P,BRANCO C W C.2007.Restoration of shallowlakes by nutrient contrlo and biomanipulation-the successful strategyvaries with lake size and climate[J].Hydrobiologia,581:269-285.
JEPPESEN E,JENSEN J P,KRISTENSEN P,et al.1990.Fish manipulationas s lake restoration tool in shallow,eutrophic,temperate lakes 2:threshold levels,long-term stability and conclusions[J].Hydrobiologia,(200/201):219-227.
JEPPESEN E,S?NDERGAARD M,JENSEN J P,et al.2005.Lakeresponses to reduced nutrient loading–an analysis of contemporarylong-term data from 35 case studies[J].Freshwter Biology,50:1747-1771.
JEPPOESEN E,JENSEN J P,KRISTENSEN P,et al.1990.Fishmanipulation as a lake restoration tool in shallow,eutrophic,temperatelakes 2:threshold levedl,long-term stability and conclusions[J].Hydrobilologia,(200/201):21-227.
JOHN D I,GERALD L W,PAUL F T.1977.The Motion of a Small Spherein a Rotating Velocity Field:A Possible Mechanism for SuspendingParticles in Turbulence[J].Journal of geophysical research,82(15):2096-2100.
JONES J I,SAYER C D.2003.Does the fish-invertebrate-periphytoncascade precipitate plant loss in shallow[J]?Ecology,84(8):2155-2167.
KAMENIR Y,WINDER M,DUBINSKY Z,et al.2008.Lake Tahoe vs.Kinneret phytoplankton:comparison of long-term taxonomic sizestructure consistency[J].Aquatic Sciences,70:195-203.
KARL E.Havens,R.Thomas James,THERESE L.East,et al.2003.N∶Pratios,light limitation,and cyanobacterial dominance in a subtropicallake impacted by non-point source nutrient pollution[J].EnvironmentalPollution,122:379-390.
KOMATSU E,FUKUSHIMA T,HARASAWA H.2007.A modelingapproach to forecast the effect of long-term climate change on lakewater quality[J].Ecological Modelling,209(2/4):351-366.
KOSTEN S,LACEROT G,JEPPESEN E,et al.209.Effects of submergedvegetation on water clarity across climates[J].Ecosystems,12:1117-1129.
KUMAGAI M,ISHIKAWA K,CHUNMENG J.2003.Dynamics andbiogeochemical significance of the physical environment in LakeBiwa[J].Lakes Reserviors Research and Management,7:345-348.
KUZNETSOV Y A.1995.Elements of applied bifurcation theory[M].Springer-Verlag
LAMMENS E,VAN NES E H,MEIJER M L,et al.2004.Effects ofcommercial fishery on the bream population and the expansion ofChara aspera in Lake Veluwe[J].Ecological Modelling,177:233-244.
MALMAEUSA J M,BLENCKNERA T,MARKENSTENB H,et al.2006.Lake phosphorus dynamics and climate warming:a mechanistic modelapproach[J].Ecological Modelling,190(1/2):1-14.
MARSDEN S.1989.Lake restoration by reducing external phosphorusloading:the influence of sediment phosphorus release[J].FreshwaterBiology,21:139-162.
MARTIN R.Perrow,Brian Moss,Julia Stansfield.1994.Trophicinteractions in a shallow lake following a reduction in nutrient loading:a long-term study[J].Hydrobiologia,(275/276):43-52.
MAY R M.1977.Thresholds and breakpoints in ecosystems with amultiplicity of stable states[J].Nature,269:471-477.
NAJJAR R G.1999.The water balance of the Susquehanna River basin andits response to climate change[J].Journal of Hydrology,219:7-19.
NICHOLLS K H.1999.Effects of temperature and other factors on summerphosphorus in the inner Bay of Quinte,Lake Ontario:implications forclimate warming[J].Journal of Great Lakes Research,25(5):250-262.
PERROW M R,MOSS B,STANSFIELD J.1994.Trophic interactions in ashallow lake following a reduction in nutrient loading:a long-termstudy[J].Hydrobiologia,(275/276):43-52.
Roger W.Bachmann,Mark V.Hoyer,Daniel E.Canfield.1999.Therestoration of Lake Apopka in relation to alternative stable states[J].Hydrobiologia,394:219-232.
SCHEFFER M,BAKEMA A H,WORTELBOER F G.1993.MEGAPLANT-a simulation model for the dynamics of submergedplants[J].Aquatic Botany,45:341-356.
SCHEFFER M,BAKEMA A H,WORTELBOER F G.2000.MEGAPLANT-Calado G,Duarte P.Modelling growth of Ruppiacirrhosa[J].Aquatic Botany,68:29-44.
SCHEFFER M,CARPENTER S R.2003.Catastrophic regime shifts inecosystems:linking theory to observation[J].TRENDS in Ecology andEvolution,18(12):648-656.
SCHEFFER M,CARPENTER S R.2003.Catastrophic regime shifts inecosystems:linking theory to observation[J].Trends in ecology andevolution,18(12):648-656.
SCHEFFER M,CARPENTER S,JONATHAN A F,et al.2001.Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems[J].Nature,413:591-596.
SCHEFFER M,EGBERT H.van Nes.2007.Shallow lakes theory revisited:various alternative regimes driven by climate,nutrients,depth and lakesize[J].Hydrobiologia,584:455-466.
SCHEFFER M,HOSPER S H,MEIJER M-L,et al.1993.Alternativeequilibria in shallow lakes[J].Trends in Ecology and Evolution,8:275-279.
SCHEFFER M,SZABóS,GRAGNANI A,et al.2003.Floating plantdominance as a stable state[J].PNAS,100(7):4040-4045.
SCHEFFER M.1990.Multiplicity of stable states in a freshwater system[J].Hydrobiologia,(200/201):475-486.
SCHINDLER D W,HECHY R E.2009.Eutrophication:more nitrogen dataneeded[J].Science,324:721-722.
SCHINDLER D W,HECKY R E,FINDLAY D L,et al.2008.Eutrophication of lakes cannot be controlled by reducing nitrogeninput:Results of a 37-year whole-ecosystem experiment[J].PNAS,105:11254-11258.
SOLHEIM A L,REKOLAINEN S,MOE S J,et al.2008.Ecologicalthreshold responses in European lakes and their application for WaterFramework Directive(WFD)implementation:synthesis of lakesresults from the REBECCA project[J].Aquatic Ecology,42:317-334.
S?NDERGAARD M,JEPPESEN E,MORTENSEN E,et al.1990.Phytoplankton biomass reduction after planktivorous fish reduction ina shallow,eutrophic lake:a combined effect of reduced internalP-loading and increased zooplankton grazing[J].Hydrobillogia,(200/201):229-240.
VAN DEN BERG M S,SCHEFFER M,VAN NES E,et al.1999.Dynamicsand stability of Chara sp.and Potanmogeton petinatus in a shallowlake changing in eutrophication level[J].Hydrobiologia,(408/409):335-342.
VAN NES E H,RIP W J,SCHEFFER M.2007.A theory for cyclic shiftsbetween alternative states in shallow lakes[J].Ecosystems,10:17-27.
VAN NES E H,SCHEFFER M,VAN DEN BERG M S,et al.2002.Dominance of charophytes in eutriphic shallow lakes-when should weexpect it to be an alternative stable state[J].?Aquatic Botany,72:275-296.
VITOUSEK P M,MOONEY H A,LUBCHENCO J,et al.1997.Humandomination of earth’s ecosystems[J].Science,277:494-499.
WALLSTEN M,FORSGEN P.1989.The effects of increased water level onaquatic macrophytes[J].J.Aquat.Plant Manage,27:32-37.
WALTER K D,WILLIAM H C,KEITH G,et al.2010.Thresholds,breakpoints,and nonlinearity in freshwaters as related tomanagement[J].North American Benthological Society,29(3):988-997.
WINNIE J Rip,MAARTEN Ouboter,EGBERT H.van Nes,et al.2005.Oscillation of a shallow lake ecosystem upon redunction in externalphosphorus load[J].Archives of Hydrobiology,164(3):387-409.
YACOBI Y Z.2006.Temporal and vertical variation of chlorophyⅡaconcentration,phytoplankton photosynthetic activity and lightattenuation in Lake Kinneret:possibilities and limitations forsimulation by remote sensing[J].Jouranl of Plankton Research,28(8):725-736.
ZIMMER K D,HANSON M A,HERWIG B R,et al.2009.Thresholds andstability of alternative regimes in shallow Prairie-Parkland Lakes ofcentral North America[J].Ecosystems,12:843-852.
ZIMMER K D,HERVIG B R,LAURICH L M.2006.Nutrient excretion byfish in wetland ecosystems and its potential to support algalproduction[J].Limnology and Oceanography,51(1):197-207.
陈开宁,包先明,史龙新,等.2006.太湖五里湖重建示范工程-大型围隔实验[J].湖泊科学,18(2):139-149.
冯剑丰,王洪礼,朱琳.2009.生态系统多稳态研究进展[J].生态环境学报,18(4):1553-1559.
刘永定,常毅峰,潘晓洁,等.2007.淡水生态系统稳态转换理论及其指导意义[D].中国海洋湖沼学会藻类分会第七届会员大会暨第十四次学术讨论会论文摘要集.
秦伯强,宋玉芝,高光.2006.附着生物在浅水富营养化湖泊藻-草型生态系统转化过程中的作用[J].中国科学C辑:生命科学,36(3):283-288.
秦伯强.2002.长江中下游湖泊富营养化发生机制与控制途径初探[J].湖泊科学,14(3):193-201.
秦伯强.2007.湖泊生态恢复的基本原理与实现[J].生态学报,27(11):4848-4858.
舒庆.2008.“十一五”环境规划汇编[M].北京:红旗出版社.
张运林,秦伯强,胡维平,等.2006.太湖典型湖区真光层深度的时空变化及其生态意义[J].中国科学D辑:地球科学,36(3):287-296.