社会资本影响个人健康水平吗?——基于CGSS2008的中国经验证据
详细信息    查看全文 | 推荐本文 |
  • 英文篇名:Does Social Capital Affect Personal Health Level?——Empirical Evidence from the Chinese General Social Survey in 2008
  • 作者:潘泽泉
  • 英文作者:Pan Zequan;School of Public Administration, Central South University;
  • 关键词:中国社会 ; 社会资本 ; 健康水平 ; 多元回归模型
  • 英文关键词:Chinese society;;social capital;;health level;;multivariate regression model
  • 中文刊名:ZJSH
  • 英文刊名:Zhejiang Social Sciences
  • 机构:中南大学社会学系;
  • 出版日期:2019-01-14
  • 出版单位:浙江社会科学
  • 年:2019
  • 期:No.269
  • 基金:2014年教育部哲学社会科学研究重大课题攻关项目“有序推进农业转移人口市民化的理论与政策研究”(项目编号:14JZD015)的阶段性成果
  • 语种:中文;
  • 页:ZJSH201901008
  • 页数:15
  • CN:01
  • ISSN:33-1149/C
  • 分类号:67-79+158-159
摘要
对于以关系取向、伦理本位为特征的中国社会,研究社会资本对健康的影响更具重要的理论价值与实践意义。基于中国综合社会调查(CGSS)2008年度的调查数据,通过建立多元回归模型研究中国居民个人社会资本对其健康水平的影响,并具体分析了这种影响的性别、年龄和城乡差异。现有数据为社会资本影响个人的健康水平提供了中国经验证据,体现了西方社会原有解释命题的有效性和中国社会的普遍适用性,即个人社会资本对健康发生学解释具有较强的解释效度和信度,同时也体现了中国经验的特殊性。研究结果显示,中国居民的个人社会资本对健康具有显著影响;个人社会资本的构成性成分对于健康的影响具有差异性;个人社会资本,尤其是网络规模与熟人单位类型,是决定健康水平的重要因素;个人社会资本对健康影响存在着明显的性别年龄、教育水平、社会地位和城乡差异,具有较明显的群际差异性和空间属性。
        For Chinese society characterized by relationship orientation and ethical standard, studying the impact of social capital on health has more important theoretical value and practical significance. Based on the survey data of Chinese General Social Survey(CGSS) in 2008, a multivariate regression model was established to study the impact of Chinese residents' individual social capital on their health level, and the gender, age and urban-rural differences of this impact were particularly analyzed. The available data provide evidence of Chinese experience that social capital affects an individual's health level, reflecting the validity of the original interpretation propositions from Western society and its universal applicability in Chinese society, that is, personal social capital has a strong explanatory validity and reliability for the health occurrence interpretation, which also reflects the particularity of Chinese experience. The findings show that the personal social capital of Chinese residents has a significant impact on health; the constituents of individual social capital have different effects on health; personal social capital, especially the size of the network and the type of acquaintance unit, are important factors to determine the level of health; the impact of personal social capital on health has obvious differences in gender, age, educational level, social status and urban-rural, with obvious inter-group and spatial attributes.
引文
(1)M Kamrul Islam,Juan Merlo,Ichiro Kawachi,Martin Lindstrom,Ulf-G Gerdtham.Social capital and health:Does egalitarianism matter?A literature review,International Journal for Equity in Health,2006,5.
    (2)Putnam R.Making Democracy Work:Civic Traditions in Modern Italy[M].Princeton:Princeton University Press,1993.
    (3)Brown,Thomas Ford,“Theoretical Perspectives on Social Capital.”Working paper located in http://hal.lamar.edu/-BBOWNTF/SOCCAP.HTML
    (4)Porter,Alejandro 1998,“Social Capital:Its Origins and Applications in Modern Sociology.”Annual Review of Sociology,1998,24.Lin,Nan 2001b,Social Capital:A Theory of Social Structure and Action.N Y:Cambridge University Press,2001.张文宏:《中国的社会资本研究:概念、操作化测量和经验研究》,《江苏社会科学》2007年第3期。
    (5)Bourdieu,Pierre 1986,“The Forms of Capital.”In John G.Richardson(ed.),Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education.Westport,CT.:Greenwood Press,1986.
    (6)Portes,Alejandro.“Social Capital:Its Origins and Applications in Modern Sociology”,Annual Review Sociology,1998.
    (7)Putnam,Robert.Making Democracy Work:Civic Traditions in Modern Italy,Princeton,NJ:Princeton UniversityPress,1993.
    (8)Coleman J.Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital.American Journal of Sociology,1988,(94):95~120.
    (9)PIU.Social Capital:A Discussion Paper,Performance and Innovation Unit(UK),April 2002.
    (10)Uphoff N,Wijayaratna C M.Demonstrated Benefits from Social Capital:the Productivity of Farmer Organizations in Gal Oya,Sri Lanka.World Development,2000,28(11):1875~1890.
    (11)Gittell R,Vidal A.Community Organizing:Building Social Capital as a Development Strategy.Thousand Oaks,CA:Sage,1998.Woolcock M.Social Capital and Economic Development:Towards a Theoretical Synthesis and Policy Framework.Theory and Society,1998,(27):151~208.Porter A.Social Capital:Its Origins and Applications in Modern Sociology.Annual Review of Sociology,1998,(24):1~24.Colletta NJ,Cullen M L.The Nexus between Violent Conflict,Social Capital and Social Cohesion:Case Studies from Cambodia and Rwanda[R].Social Capital Initiative Working Paper,No.23.Washington,DC:World Bank,2000.
    (12)Bourdieu,Pierre,”The Forms of Capital.”In John G.Richardson(ed.),Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education.Westport,CT.:Greenwood Press,1986.Coleman,James,Foundations of Social Theory.Cambridge:The Belknap Press,1990.Lin,Nan.“Building A Network Theory of Social Capital”.In Nan Lin,Karen Cook&Ronald Burt beds.),Social Capital:Theory and Research.NY:Aldine De Gruyter,2001.
    (13)Halpern D.Social Capital.Cambridge:Polity Press,2005.
    (14)Wellman,B.“The Community Question:The Intimate Networks of Last Yorkers.”American Journal of Sociology,1979,84.
    (15)Campbell K.E&B.A.Lee,“Name Generators in Surveys of Personal Networks.”Social Networks,1991,13.
    (16)Lin,Nan&Mary Dumin,“Access to Occupations through Social Ties.”Social Networks,1986,8.Hsung,R.M.&Hwang,“Job Mobility in Taiwan:Job Search Methods and Contacts Status.”Paper presented at Sunbelt XII International Conference on Social Networks,San Diego,the United States,1992.傅仰止:《社会资本的概念化与运作:论家人重迭网络中的“时间投资”机制》,《台湾社会学》2005年第9期。Lin,Nan&Bonnie Erickson,Social Capital:An International Research Program.Oxford:Oxford University Press,2008.
    (17)Van Der Gagg,Martin 2005,“Measurement of Individual Social Capital”http://dissertations.ub.rug.nl/faculties/ppsw/2005/m.p.j.der.gaag/(2009/04/01);Van Der Gagg,Martin&Snijders,Tom A.B.2005,“The Resource generator:Social Capital Quantification with Concrete Items.”Social Networks,27:pp.1~29;Flap,H.,Snijders,T.,Volker,B&Van Der Gagg,Martin 2003,“Measurement Instruments for Social Capital of Individuals”http://www.xs4all.nl/~gaag/work/SSND.pdf(2009/04/01)
    (18)吕涛:《社会资本的网络测量---关系、位置与资源》,《广东社会科学》2012年第1期。
    (19)Sabatini F.Social Capital as Social Networks:A New Framework for Measurement and an Empirical Analysis of Its Determinants and Consequences.the Journal of Socio-economics,2009,38:429~442.
    (20)Grootaert C,van Bastlaer T.Understand and Measuring Social Capital.Washington D C:World Bank,2002.
    (21)桂勇、黄荣贵:《社区社会资本测量:一项基于经验数据的研究》,《社会学研究》2008年第3期。
    (22)Harpham,T.,Grant,E.,&Thomas,E.Measuring social capital within health surveys:Key issues.Health Policy and Planning,2002,17(1),106~111.
    (23)Putnam R.Bowling Alone:America's Declining Social Capital in America.Journal of Democracy,1995,6(1):65~78.
    (24)Paxton P.Is Social Capital Declining in the United States?A Multiple Indicator Assessment.American Journal of Sociology,1999,105(1):88~127.
    (25)Narayan D,Cassidy M F.A Dimensional Approach to Measuring Social Capital:Development and Validation of a Social Capital Inventory.Current Sociology,2001,(49):59~102.
    (26)赵延东:《测量酉部城乡居民的社会资本》,《华中师范大学学报》2006年第45期。
    (27)裴志军:《村域社会资本:界定、维度及测量---基于浙江西部37个村落的实证研究》,《农村经济》2010年第6期。
    (28)胡涤非:《农村社会资本的结构及其测量---对帕特南社会资本理论的经验研究》,《武汉大学学报(哲学社会科学版)》2011年第4期。
    (29)边燕杰:《城市居民社会资本的来源及作用:网络观点与调查发现》,《中国社会科》2004年第3期。
    (30)赵延东、罗家德:《如何测量社会资本:一个经验研究综述》,《国外社会科学》2005年第2期。
    (31)Grossman,M.,On the Concept of Health Capital and Demand for Health.Journal of Political Economy,Vol.80,No.2.1972:223.
    (32)Putnam R.Bowling Alone:America’s Declining Social Capital in America[J].Journal of Democracy,1995,6(1):65~78.
    (33)Idler,E.L.,&Benyamini,Y.Self-rated health and mortality:A review of twenty-seven community studies.Journal of Health and Social Behavior,1997,38(1),21~37.
    (34)Mossey JM,Shapiro E.Self-rated health:a predictor of mortality among the elderly[J].Am J Public Health,1982,72(8):800~808.Idler E L,Angel R J.Self-rated Health and Mortality in the NHANES-1 Epidemiologic Follow-up Study[J].Journal of American Public Health,1990,80(4):446~452.I-dler E L,Kasl S V.Self-ratings of Health:Do They Also Predict Change in Functional Ability[J].Journal of Gerontology,1995,50(6):344~353.Marmot M,Feeney A,Shipley M,et al.Sickness Absence as a Measure of Health Status and Functioning From the UK Whitehall II Study[J].Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health,1995,49(2):124~130.
    (35)Yip,W.,Subramanian,S.V.,Mitchell,A.D.,Lee,D.T.S.,Wang,J.and Kawachi,I.,Does social capital enhance health and well-being?Evidence From rural China.Social Science&Medicine,No.64,2007,pp.35~49.
    (36)Durkheim E:Suicide:a study in sociology Edited by:Simpson G,Spaulding J A,Simpson G 1951.New York:Free Press,1897.
    (37)Wilkinson,Richard G.Class and Health,London:Tavistock Publications,1986.
    (38)Lin,Nan.“Building a Network Theory of Social Capital”,Connections,1999,22(1).
    (39)Lin,Nan,Ensel,Walter M..“Life Stress and Health:Stressors and Resources”,American Sociological Review,1989,54(3);Lin,Nan,Lai,Gina.1995,“Urban Stress in China”,Social Science and Medicine,1995,41(8);Wellman,Barry,Wortley,Scott.“Different Strokes from Different Folks:Community Ties and Social Support”,American Journal of Sociology,1990,96(3).
    (40)Kawachi,Ichiro,Berkman,Lisa F.Neighbourhoods and Health,Oxford:Oxford University Press,2003.
    (41)Harpham,Trudy,Grant,Emma,Thomas,Elizabeth.“Measuring Social Capital within Health Surveys:Key Issues”,Health Policy and Planning,2002,17(1).
    (42)王培刚、陈心广:《社会资本、社会融合与健康获得---以城市流动人口为例》,《华中科技大学学报社会科学版》2015年第3期。
    (43)Kawachi,I.and Kennedy,B.,The relationship of income inequality to mortality:does the choice of indicator matter?.Social Science&Medicine,No.45,1997,pp.1121~1127.
    (44)Wilkinson RG,Kawachi I,Kennedy BP:Mortality,the social environment,crime and violence.Social Health Illness,1998,20:578~597.
    (45)Milyo J,Mellor JM:On the importance of age-adjustment methods in ecological studies of social determinants of mortality.Health Serv Res,2003,38(6):1781~1790.
    (46)Kennelly B,Shea E,Gavey E:Social Capital,life expectancy and mortality:a cross-national examination.Soc Sci,Med 2003,56(12):2367~2377.
    (47)Siahpush M,Singh GK:Social integration and mortality in Australia.Aust N Z J Public Health,1999,23(6):571~577.
    (48)Skrabski A,Kopp M,Kawachi I:Social capital in a changing society:cross sectional associations with middle aged female and male mortality.J Epidemiol Community Health,2003,57:114~119;67.
    (49)awachi I,Kim D,Coutts A.Subramanian SV:Reconciling the three accounts of social capital.Int J Epidemiol,2004,33:682~690.
    (50)Wilkinson RG,Kawachi I,Kennedy BP:Mortality,the social environment,crime and violence.Social Health Illness,1998,20:578~597.
    (51)Rose,R.,How much does social capital add to individual health?A survey study of Russians.Social Science&Medicine,No.51,2000,pp.1421~1435.Bolin K,Lindgren B,Lindstr.M.Nystedt P:Investments in social capital-implications of social interactions for the production of health.Social Science and Medicine,2003,56(12):2379~2390.Hyyppa MT,Markku J:Individual-level relationships between social capital and self-rated health in a bilingual community.Preventive Medicine,2001,32:148~155.Lindstr M,Moghaddassi M,Merlo J:Individual self-reported health,social participation and neighborhood:a multilevel analysis in Malm,Sweden.Preventive Medicine,2004,39:135~141.
    (52)Sundquist K,Lindstr M,Malmstr M,Johansson S,Sundquist J:Social participation and coronary heart disease:a follow-up Social participation and coronary heart disease:a follow-up study of 6900 women and men in Sweden.Soc Sci Med,2004,58:615~622.
    (53)Ziersch AM,Baum FE,Macdougall C,Putland C:Neighborhood life and social capital:the implications for health.Soc Sci Med,2005,60(1):71~86.
    (54)Browning CR,Cagney KA:Collective efficacy and health:neighborhood social capital and self-rated physical functioning in an urban setting.J Health Soc Behav,2002,43.383~399.
    (55)Franzini L,Spears W:Contributions of social context to inequalities in years of life lost to heart disease in Texas,USA,SOC Sci Med,2003,57(10):1847~1861.
    (56)Lindstr M,Moghaddassi M,Merlo J:Individual selfreported health,social participation and neighborhood:a multilevel analysis in Malm,Sweden.Preventive Medicine,2004,39:135~141.
    (57)卢诅汛:《社会资本及其卫生保健功能》,《医学与社会》2000年第1期。
    (58)孙顺根、凌云:《社会资本在健康管理中的理论与实现途径》,《浙江中医药大学学报》2006年第6期。
    (59)陈迎春、崔斌:《社会资本与农村合作医疗的发展》,《中国卫生资源》2000年第3期。
    (60)邵德兴:《政府干预、社会资本与新型农村合作医疗制度的创建》,《科学社会主义》2005年第5期。
    (61)张里程、汪宏、王禄生:《社会资本对农村居民参与新型农村合作医疗支付意愿的影响》,《中国卫生经济》2004年第23期。
    (62)赵斌、刘米娜:《收入、社会资本、健康与城市居民幸福感的实证分析》,《统计与决策》2013年第20期。
    (63)Wang,H.,Schlesinger,M.,Wang,H,and William,C.H,The flip-side of social capital:The distinctive influences of trust and mistrust on health in rural China.Social Science&Medicine,No.68,2009,pp.133~142.
    (64)吴丽、杨保杰、吴次芳:《失地农民健康、幸福感与社会资本关系实证研究》,《农业经济问题》2009年第2期。
    (65)黄乾:《教育与社会资本对城市农民工健康的影响研究》,《人口与经济》2010年第2期。
    (66)薛新东、刘国恩:《社会资本决定健康状况吗---来自中国健康与养老追踪调查的证据》,《财贸经济》2012年第8期。裴晓梅、王浩伟、罗昊:《社会资本与晚年健康---老年人健康不平等的实证研究》,《广西民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版)》2014年第36期。
    (67)裴晓梅、王浩伟、罗昊:《社会资本与晚年健康---老年人健康不平等的实证研究》,《广西民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版)》2014年第36期。

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700