生态系统服务流研究进展
|
摘要
生态系统服务流是实现生态系统服务供给与人类需求耦合的重要桥梁,是当前生态系统服务研究的热点与前沿。科学理解生态系统服务从产生、传递到使用的全过程,明确区域生态系统服务供给与需求的平衡状况,对于实现区域可持续发展与提高人类福祉具有重要意义。在综合分析国内外相关研究的基础上,阐述了生态系统服务流的概念内涵,归纳总结了生态系统服务流的定量研究方法,并系统梳理了国内外生态系统服务流研究在理论探索与应用案例方面的研究进展;探讨了当前生态系统服务流研究中存在的问题和不足,包括:生态系统服务从供给区传递至需求区的空间转移规律尚不明晰、定量评估生态系统服务流的方法不成熟、面向应用的生态系统服务流的研究较为缺乏,以及人与自然耦合系统中生态系统服务流研究框架有待进一步完善。未来的研究需要重点关注复杂系统中生态系统服务流跨尺度、跨区域的传递过程,加强生态系统服务的空间流动过程与传递路径的定量分析与模拟,重视生态系统服务流的应用性研究,尤其是在生态恢复、生态补偿、城市规划等方面的应用,并完善人与自然耦合系统中生态系统服务流的研究框架,以期促进生态系统服务流研究的发展。
Ecosystem service flows have increasingly been a hot topic in recent years, as it serves as an important bridge connecting ecosystem services supply and human demand. Research on ecosystem service flows contributes to our understanding of the completed delivery processes of ecosystem services and analyzes the relationship between ecosystem services supply and demand. It has great significance for achieving regional sustainable development and improving human well-being. Based on the comprehensive analysis of relevant studies, this paper described the concept of ecosystem service flows and summarized the approaches for quantifying ecosystem service flows. Following that, the research progress from both theoretical and applied aspects was systematically reviewed. In addition, the shortcomings of recent studies were summarized. These include: 1) the ecosystem serveries delivery process from supply areas to demand areas has not been fully explored; 2) the method of quantitative assessment of ecosystem service flows needs to be improved; 3) research on integrating the concept of ecosystem service flows into practical application was relatively rare; and 4) the research framework of ecosystem service flows in the coupled human and environmental systems needs improvement. Furthermore, four research perspectives were proposed, including exploration of the ecosystem services delivery processes in the complex system, developing spatially distributed models to simulate the delivery process and delivery path of ecosystem services, applying the concept of ecosystem service flows into ecological restoration, ecological compensation, and urban planning, and improving the research framework of ecosystem service flows. These prospects and reviews were expected to serve as a reference for research of ecosystem service flows and provide a scientific foundation for regional planning and sustainable development.
Ecosystem service flows have increasingly been a hot topic in recent years, as it serves as an important bridge connecting ecosystem services supply and human demand. Research on ecosystem service flows contributes to our understanding of the completed delivery processes of ecosystem services and analyzes the relationship between ecosystem services supply and demand. It has great significance for achieving regional sustainable development and improving human well-being. Based on the comprehensive analysis of relevant studies, this paper described the concept of ecosystem service flows and summarized the approaches for quantifying ecosystem service flows. Following that, the research progress from both theoretical and applied aspects was systematically reviewed. In addition, the shortcomings of recent studies were summarized. These include: 1) the ecosystem serveries delivery process from supply areas to demand areas has not been fully explored; 2) the method of quantitative assessment of ecosystem service flows needs to be improved; 3) research on integrating the concept of ecosystem service flows into practical application was relatively rare; and 4) the research framework of ecosystem service flows in the coupled human and environmental systems needs improvement. Furthermore, four research perspectives were proposed, including exploration of the ecosystem services delivery processes in the complex system, developing spatially distributed models to simulate the delivery process and delivery path of ecosystem services, applying the concept of ecosystem service flows into ecological restoration, ecological compensation, and urban planning, and improving the research framework of ecosystem service flows. These prospects and reviews were expected to serve as a reference for research of ecosystem service flows and provide a scientific foundation for regional planning and sustainable development.
引文
[1] Costanza R,d′Arge R,de Groot R,Farber S,Grasso M,Hannon B,Limburg K,Naeem S,O′Neill R V,Paruelo J,Raskin R G,Sutton P,van den Belt M.The value of the world′s ecosystem services and natural capital.Nature,1997,387(6630):253- 260.
[2] 傅伯杰,吕一河,高光耀.中国主要陆地生态系统服务与生态安全研究的重要进展.自然杂志,2012,34(5):261- 272.
[3] 傅伯杰,周国逸,白永飞,宋长春,刘纪远,张惠远,吕一河,郑华,谢高地.中国主要陆地生态系统服务功能与生态安全.地球科学进展,2009,24(6):571- 576.
[4] 傅伯杰,张立伟.土地利用变化与生态系统服务:概念、方法与进展.地理科学进展,2014,33(4):441- 446.
[5] 白杨,王敏,李晖,黄沈发,Alatalo J M.生态系统服务供给与需求的理论与管理方法.生态学报,2017,37(17):5846- 5852.
[6] Liu S,Costanza R,Troy A,D′Aagostino J,Mates W.Valuing New Jersey′s ecosystem services and natural capital:a spatially explicit benefit transfer approach.Environmental Management,2010,45(6):1271- 1285.
[7] Maes J,Egoh B,Willemen L,Liquete C,Vihervaara P,Sch?gner J P,Grizzetti B,Drakou E G,La Notte A,Zulian G,Bouraouia F,Paracchini M L,Braat L,Bidoglio G.Mapping ecosystem services for policy support and decision making in the European Union.Ecosystem Services,2012,1(1):31- 39.
[8] Jia X Q,Fu B J,Feng X M,Hou G H,Liu Y,Wang X F.The tradeoff and synergy between ecosystem services in the Grain-for-Green areas in Northern Shaanxi,China.Ecological Indicators,2014,43:103- 113.
[9] Yahdjian L,Sala O E,Havstad K M.Rangeland ecosystem services:shifting focus from supply to reconciling supply and demand.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment,2016,13(1):44- 51.
[10] Serna-Chavez H M,Schulp C J E,van Bodegom P M,Bouten W,Verburg P H,Davidson M D.A quantitative framework for assessing spatial flows of ecosystem services.Ecological Indicators,2014,39:24- 33.
[11] Villamagna A M,Angermeier P L,Bennett E M.Capacity,pressure,demand,and flow:a conceptual framework for analyzing ecosystem service provision and delivery.Ecological Complexity,2013,15:114- 121.
[12] Castro A J,Verburg P H,Martín-López B,Garcia-Llorente M,Cabello J,Vaughn C C,López E.Ecosystem service trade-offs from supply to social demand:a landscape-scale spatial analysis.Landscape and Urban Planning,2014,132:102- 110.
[13] Burkhard B,Kroll F,Nedkov S,Müller F.Mapping ecosystem service supply,demand and budgets.Ecological Indicators,2012,21:17- 29.
[14] Nedkov S,Burkhard B.Flood regulating ecosystem services—Mapping supply and demand,in the Etropole municipality,Bulgaria.Ecological Indicators,2012,21:67- 79.
[15] 姚婧,何兴元,陈玮.生态系统服务流研究方法最新进展.应用生态学报,2018,29(1):335- 342.
[16] Bagstad K J,Johnson G W,Voigt B,Villa F.Spatial dynamics of ecosystem service flows:a comprehensive approach to quantifying actual services.Ecosystem Services,2013,4:117- 125.
[17] Schr?ter M,Barton D N,Remme R P,Hein L.Accounting for capacity and flow of ecosystem services:a conceptual model and a case study for Telemark,Norway.Ecological Indicators,2014,36:539- 551.
[18] 刘慧敏,范玉龙,丁圣彦.生态系统服务流研究进展.应用生态学报,2016,27(7):2161- 2171.
[19] 刘慧敏,刘绿怡,任嘉衍,卞子亓,丁圣彦.生态系统服务流定量化研究进展.应用生态学报,2017,28(8):2723- 2730.
[20] Syrbe R U,Walz U.Spatial indicators for the assessment of ecosystem services:Providing,benefiting and connecting areas and landscape metrics.Ecological Indicators,2012,21:80- 88.
[21] Bagstad K J,Villa F,Batker D,Harrison-Cox J,Voigt B,Johnson G W.From theoretical to actual ecosystem services:mapping beneficiaries and spatial flows in ecosystem service assessments.Ecology and Society,2014,19(2):64.
[22] Fisher B,Turner R K,Morling P.Defining and classifying ecosystem services for decision making.Ecological Economics,2009,68(3):643- 653.
[23] 李婷,李晶,王彦泽,曾莉.关中-天水经济区生态系统固碳服务空间流动及格局优化.中国农业科学,2017,50(20):3953- 3969.
[24] Li D L,Wu S Y,Liu L B,Liang Z,Li S C.Evaluating regional water security through a freshwater ecosystem service flow model:a case study in Beijing-Tianjian-Hebei region,China.Ecological Indicators,2017,81:159- 170.
[25] Xu J,Xiao Y,Xie G D,Wang Y Y,Jiang Y.How to guarantee the sustainability of the wind prevention and sand fixation service:an ecosystem service flow perspective.Sustainability,2018,10(9):2995.
[26] 肖玉,谢高地,鲁春霞,徐洁.基于供需关系的生态系统服务空间流动研究进展.生态学报,2016,36(10):3096- 3102.
[27] Palomo I,Martín-López B,Potschin M,Haines-Young R,Montes C.National Parks,buffer zones and surrounding lands:mapping ecosystem service flows.Ecosystem Services,2013,4:104- 116.
[28] Baró F,Palomo I,Zulian G,Vizcaino P,Haase D,Gómez-Baggethun E.Mapping ecosystem service capacity,flow and demand for landscape and urban planning:a case study in the Barcelona metropolitan region.Land Use Policy,2016,57:405- 417.
[29] Burkhard B,Kroll F,Müller F,Windhorst W.Landscapes′ capacities to provide ecosystem services-a concept for land-cover based assessments.Landscape Online,2009,15(1):1- 12.
[30] Owuor M A,Icely J,Newton A,Nyunja J,Otieno P,Tuda A O,Oduor N.Mapping of ecosystem services flow in Mida Creek,Kenya.Ocean & Coastal Management,2017,140:11- 21.
[31] Vrebos D,Staes J,Vandenbroucke T,D′Haeyer T,Johnston R,Muhumuza M,Kasabeke C,Meire P.Mapping ecosystem service flows with land cover scoring maps for data-scarce regions.Ecosystem Services,2015,13:28- 40.
[32] 李婧昕,杨立,杨蕾,张超,霍兆敏,陈敏豪,栾晓峰.基于熵理论的城市生态系统服务流定量评估——以北京市为例.应用生态学报,2018,29(3):987- 996.
[33] 乔旭宁,张婷,杨永菊,牛海鹏,杨德刚.渭干河流域生态系统服务的空间溢出及对居民福祉的影响.资源科学,2017,39(3):533- 544.
[34] Burkhard B,Kandziora M,Hou Y,Müller F.Ecosystem service potentials,flows and demands-concepts for spatial localisation,indication and quantification.Landscape Online,2014,34(1):1- 32.
[35] Gopal B.A conceptual framework for environmental flows assessment based on ecosystem services and their economic valuation.Ecosystem Services,2016,21:53- 58.
[36] Liu J G,Yang W,Li S X.Framing ecosystem services in the telecoupled anthropocene.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment,2016,14(1):27- 36.
[37] Felipe-Lucia M R,Martín-López B,Lavorel S,Berraquero-Díaz L,Escalera-Reyes J,Comín F A.Ecosystem services flows:why stakeholders′ power relationships matter.PLoS One,2015,10(7):e0132232.
[38] Bagstad K J,Semmens D J,Diffendorfer J E,Mattsson B J,Dubovsky J,Thogmartin W E,Wiederholt R,Loomis J,Bieri J A,Sample C,Goldstein J,López-Hoffman L.Ecosystem service flows from a migratory species:spatial subsidies of the northern pintail.Ambio,2019,48(1):61-73.
[39] Semmens D J,Diffendorfer J E,Bagstad K J,Wiederholt R,Oberhauser K,Ries L,Semmens B X,Goldstein J,Loomis J,Thogmartin W E,Mattsson B J,López-Hoffman L.Quantifying ecosystem service flows at multiple scales across the range of a long-distance migratory species.Ecosystem Services,2018,31:255- 264.
[40] Goldenberg R,Kalantari Z,Cvetkovic V,M?rtberg U,Deal B,Destouni G.Distinction,quantification and mapping of potential and realized supply-demand of flow-dependent ecosystem services.Science of the Total Environment,2017,593- 594:599- 609.
[41] Lankia T,Kopperoinen L,Pouta E,Neuvonen M.Valuing recreational ecosystem service flow in Finland.Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism,2015,10:14- 28.
[42] Egarter V L,Depellegrin D,Pereira P,De Groot R,Tappeiner U.Mapping the ecosystem service delivery chain:capacity,flow,and demand pertaining to aesthetic experiences in mountain landscapes.Science of the Total Environment,2017,574:422- 436.
[43] 赵庆建,温作民,张敏新.识别森林生态系统服务的供应与需求——基于生态系统服务流的视角.林业经济,2014,36(10):3- 7.
[44] Balzan M V,Caruana J,Zammit A.Assessing the capacity and flow of ecosystem services in multifunctional landscapes:evidence of a rural-urban gradient in a Mediterranean small island state.Land Use Policy,2018,75:711- 725.
[45] Verhagen W,Kukkala A S,Moilanen A,van Teeffelen A J A,Verburg P H.Use of demand for and spatial flow of ecosystem services to identify priority areas.Conservation Biology,2017,31(4):860- 871.
[46] 周晨,丁晓辉,李国平,汪海洲.南水北调中线工程水源区生态补偿标准研究——以生态系统服务价值为视角.资源科学,2015,37(4):792- 804.
[47] Fu Y C,Zhang J,Zhang C L,Zang W B,Guo W X,Qian Z,Liu L S,Zhao J Y,Feng J.Payments for Ecosystem Services for watershed water resource allocations.Journal of Hydrology,2018,556:689- 700;
[48] Wen C.Payments for ecosystem services of the middle route of the South-to-North Water Transfer Project in China [D].Leeds:The University of Leeds,2014.
[49] 戴尔阜,王晓莉,朱建佳,赵东升.生态系统服务权衡:方法、模型与研究框架.地理研究,2016,35(6):1005- 1016.
[50] Stürck J,Poortinga A,Verburg P H.Mapping ecosystem services:the supply and demand of flood regulation services in Europe.Ecological Indicators,2014,38:198- 211.
[51] García-Nieto A P,García-Llorente M,Iniesta-Arandia I,Martín-López B.Mapping forest ecosystem services:from providing units to beneficiaries.Ecosystem Services,2013,4:126- 138.
[52] Ninan K N,Inoue M.Valuing forest ecosystem services:case study of a forest reserve in Japan.Ecosystem Services,2013,5:78- 87.
[53] Naidoo R,Balmford A,Costanza R,Fisher B,Green R E,Lehner B,Malcolm T R,Ricketts T H.Global mapping of ecosystem services and conservation priorities.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,2008,105(28):9495- 9500.
[54] 严岩,朱捷缘,吴钢,詹云军.生态系统服务需求、供给和消费研究进展.生态学报,2017,37(8):2489- 2496.
[55] Wolff S,Schulp C J E,Verburg P H.Mapping ecosystem services demand:a review of current research and future perspectives.Ecological Indicators,2015,55:159- 171.
[56] Hou Y,Burkhard B,Müller F.Uncertainties in landscape analysis and ecosystem service assessment.Journal of Environmental Management,2013,127:S117-S131.
[57] Daily G C,Polasky S,Goldstein J,Kareiva P M,Mooney H A,Pejchar L,Ricketts T H,Salzman J,Shallenberger R.Ecosystem services in decision making:time to deliver.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment,2009,7(1):21- 28.
[58] Fang X N,Zhao W W,Fu B J,Ding J Y.Landscape service capability,landscape service flow and landscape service demand:a new framework for landscape services and its use for landscape sustainability assessment.Progress in Physical Geography:Earth and Environment,2015,39(6):817- 836.
[59] Boerema A,Rebelo A J,Bodi M B,Esler K J,Meire P.Are ecosystem services adequately quantified?Journal of Applied Ecology,2017,54(2):358- 370.
[60] 刘慧敏,刘绿怡,丁圣彦.人类活动对生态系统服务流的影响.生态学报,2017,37(10):3232- 3242.
[61] Wei H J,Fan W G,Wang X C,Lu N C,Dong X B,Zhao Y N,Ya X J,Zhao Y F.Integrating supply and social demand in ecosystem services assessment:a review.Ecosystem Services,2017,25:15- 27.
[62] Liu M C,Yang L,Min Q W.Establishment of an eco-compensation fund based on eco-services consumption.Journal of Environmental Management,2018,211:306- 312.
[63] 彭建,杨旸,谢盼,刘焱序.基于生态系统服务供需的广东省绿地生态网络建设分区.生态学报,2017,37(13):4562- 4572.
[2] 傅伯杰,吕一河,高光耀.中国主要陆地生态系统服务与生态安全研究的重要进展.自然杂志,2012,34(5):261- 272.
[3] 傅伯杰,周国逸,白永飞,宋长春,刘纪远,张惠远,吕一河,郑华,谢高地.中国主要陆地生态系统服务功能与生态安全.地球科学进展,2009,24(6):571- 576.
[4] 傅伯杰,张立伟.土地利用变化与生态系统服务:概念、方法与进展.地理科学进展,2014,33(4):441- 446.
[5] 白杨,王敏,李晖,黄沈发,Alatalo J M.生态系统服务供给与需求的理论与管理方法.生态学报,2017,37(17):5846- 5852.
[6] Liu S,Costanza R,Troy A,D′Aagostino J,Mates W.Valuing New Jersey′s ecosystem services and natural capital:a spatially explicit benefit transfer approach.Environmental Management,2010,45(6):1271- 1285.
[7] Maes J,Egoh B,Willemen L,Liquete C,Vihervaara P,Sch?gner J P,Grizzetti B,Drakou E G,La Notte A,Zulian G,Bouraouia F,Paracchini M L,Braat L,Bidoglio G.Mapping ecosystem services for policy support and decision making in the European Union.Ecosystem Services,2012,1(1):31- 39.
[8] Jia X Q,Fu B J,Feng X M,Hou G H,Liu Y,Wang X F.The tradeoff and synergy between ecosystem services in the Grain-for-Green areas in Northern Shaanxi,China.Ecological Indicators,2014,43:103- 113.
[9] Yahdjian L,Sala O E,Havstad K M.Rangeland ecosystem services:shifting focus from supply to reconciling supply and demand.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment,2016,13(1):44- 51.
[10] Serna-Chavez H M,Schulp C J E,van Bodegom P M,Bouten W,Verburg P H,Davidson M D.A quantitative framework for assessing spatial flows of ecosystem services.Ecological Indicators,2014,39:24- 33.
[11] Villamagna A M,Angermeier P L,Bennett E M.Capacity,pressure,demand,and flow:a conceptual framework for analyzing ecosystem service provision and delivery.Ecological Complexity,2013,15:114- 121.
[12] Castro A J,Verburg P H,Martín-López B,Garcia-Llorente M,Cabello J,Vaughn C C,López E.Ecosystem service trade-offs from supply to social demand:a landscape-scale spatial analysis.Landscape and Urban Planning,2014,132:102- 110.
[13] Burkhard B,Kroll F,Nedkov S,Müller F.Mapping ecosystem service supply,demand and budgets.Ecological Indicators,2012,21:17- 29.
[14] Nedkov S,Burkhard B.Flood regulating ecosystem services—Mapping supply and demand,in the Etropole municipality,Bulgaria.Ecological Indicators,2012,21:67- 79.
[15] 姚婧,何兴元,陈玮.生态系统服务流研究方法最新进展.应用生态学报,2018,29(1):335- 342.
[16] Bagstad K J,Johnson G W,Voigt B,Villa F.Spatial dynamics of ecosystem service flows:a comprehensive approach to quantifying actual services.Ecosystem Services,2013,4:117- 125.
[17] Schr?ter M,Barton D N,Remme R P,Hein L.Accounting for capacity and flow of ecosystem services:a conceptual model and a case study for Telemark,Norway.Ecological Indicators,2014,36:539- 551.
[18] 刘慧敏,范玉龙,丁圣彦.生态系统服务流研究进展.应用生态学报,2016,27(7):2161- 2171.
[19] 刘慧敏,刘绿怡,任嘉衍,卞子亓,丁圣彦.生态系统服务流定量化研究进展.应用生态学报,2017,28(8):2723- 2730.
[20] Syrbe R U,Walz U.Spatial indicators for the assessment of ecosystem services:Providing,benefiting and connecting areas and landscape metrics.Ecological Indicators,2012,21:80- 88.
[21] Bagstad K J,Villa F,Batker D,Harrison-Cox J,Voigt B,Johnson G W.From theoretical to actual ecosystem services:mapping beneficiaries and spatial flows in ecosystem service assessments.Ecology and Society,2014,19(2):64.
[22] Fisher B,Turner R K,Morling P.Defining and classifying ecosystem services for decision making.Ecological Economics,2009,68(3):643- 653.
[23] 李婷,李晶,王彦泽,曾莉.关中-天水经济区生态系统固碳服务空间流动及格局优化.中国农业科学,2017,50(20):3953- 3969.
[24] Li D L,Wu S Y,Liu L B,Liang Z,Li S C.Evaluating regional water security through a freshwater ecosystem service flow model:a case study in Beijing-Tianjian-Hebei region,China.Ecological Indicators,2017,81:159- 170.
[25] Xu J,Xiao Y,Xie G D,Wang Y Y,Jiang Y.How to guarantee the sustainability of the wind prevention and sand fixation service:an ecosystem service flow perspective.Sustainability,2018,10(9):2995.
[26] 肖玉,谢高地,鲁春霞,徐洁.基于供需关系的生态系统服务空间流动研究进展.生态学报,2016,36(10):3096- 3102.
[27] Palomo I,Martín-López B,Potschin M,Haines-Young R,Montes C.National Parks,buffer zones and surrounding lands:mapping ecosystem service flows.Ecosystem Services,2013,4:104- 116.
[28] Baró F,Palomo I,Zulian G,Vizcaino P,Haase D,Gómez-Baggethun E.Mapping ecosystem service capacity,flow and demand for landscape and urban planning:a case study in the Barcelona metropolitan region.Land Use Policy,2016,57:405- 417.
[29] Burkhard B,Kroll F,Müller F,Windhorst W.Landscapes′ capacities to provide ecosystem services-a concept for land-cover based assessments.Landscape Online,2009,15(1):1- 12.
[30] Owuor M A,Icely J,Newton A,Nyunja J,Otieno P,Tuda A O,Oduor N.Mapping of ecosystem services flow in Mida Creek,Kenya.Ocean & Coastal Management,2017,140:11- 21.
[31] Vrebos D,Staes J,Vandenbroucke T,D′Haeyer T,Johnston R,Muhumuza M,Kasabeke C,Meire P.Mapping ecosystem service flows with land cover scoring maps for data-scarce regions.Ecosystem Services,2015,13:28- 40.
[32] 李婧昕,杨立,杨蕾,张超,霍兆敏,陈敏豪,栾晓峰.基于熵理论的城市生态系统服务流定量评估——以北京市为例.应用生态学报,2018,29(3):987- 996.
[33] 乔旭宁,张婷,杨永菊,牛海鹏,杨德刚.渭干河流域生态系统服务的空间溢出及对居民福祉的影响.资源科学,2017,39(3):533- 544.
[34] Burkhard B,Kandziora M,Hou Y,Müller F.Ecosystem service potentials,flows and demands-concepts for spatial localisation,indication and quantification.Landscape Online,2014,34(1):1- 32.
[35] Gopal B.A conceptual framework for environmental flows assessment based on ecosystem services and their economic valuation.Ecosystem Services,2016,21:53- 58.
[36] Liu J G,Yang W,Li S X.Framing ecosystem services in the telecoupled anthropocene.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment,2016,14(1):27- 36.
[37] Felipe-Lucia M R,Martín-López B,Lavorel S,Berraquero-Díaz L,Escalera-Reyes J,Comín F A.Ecosystem services flows:why stakeholders′ power relationships matter.PLoS One,2015,10(7):e0132232.
[38] Bagstad K J,Semmens D J,Diffendorfer J E,Mattsson B J,Dubovsky J,Thogmartin W E,Wiederholt R,Loomis J,Bieri J A,Sample C,Goldstein J,López-Hoffman L.Ecosystem service flows from a migratory species:spatial subsidies of the northern pintail.Ambio,2019,48(1):61-73.
[39] Semmens D J,Diffendorfer J E,Bagstad K J,Wiederholt R,Oberhauser K,Ries L,Semmens B X,Goldstein J,Loomis J,Thogmartin W E,Mattsson B J,López-Hoffman L.Quantifying ecosystem service flows at multiple scales across the range of a long-distance migratory species.Ecosystem Services,2018,31:255- 264.
[40] Goldenberg R,Kalantari Z,Cvetkovic V,M?rtberg U,Deal B,Destouni G.Distinction,quantification and mapping of potential and realized supply-demand of flow-dependent ecosystem services.Science of the Total Environment,2017,593- 594:599- 609.
[41] Lankia T,Kopperoinen L,Pouta E,Neuvonen M.Valuing recreational ecosystem service flow in Finland.Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism,2015,10:14- 28.
[42] Egarter V L,Depellegrin D,Pereira P,De Groot R,Tappeiner U.Mapping the ecosystem service delivery chain:capacity,flow,and demand pertaining to aesthetic experiences in mountain landscapes.Science of the Total Environment,2017,574:422- 436.
[43] 赵庆建,温作民,张敏新.识别森林生态系统服务的供应与需求——基于生态系统服务流的视角.林业经济,2014,36(10):3- 7.
[44] Balzan M V,Caruana J,Zammit A.Assessing the capacity and flow of ecosystem services in multifunctional landscapes:evidence of a rural-urban gradient in a Mediterranean small island state.Land Use Policy,2018,75:711- 725.
[45] Verhagen W,Kukkala A S,Moilanen A,van Teeffelen A J A,Verburg P H.Use of demand for and spatial flow of ecosystem services to identify priority areas.Conservation Biology,2017,31(4):860- 871.
[46] 周晨,丁晓辉,李国平,汪海洲.南水北调中线工程水源区生态补偿标准研究——以生态系统服务价值为视角.资源科学,2015,37(4):792- 804.
[47] Fu Y C,Zhang J,Zhang C L,Zang W B,Guo W X,Qian Z,Liu L S,Zhao J Y,Feng J.Payments for Ecosystem Services for watershed water resource allocations.Journal of Hydrology,2018,556:689- 700;
[48] Wen C.Payments for ecosystem services of the middle route of the South-to-North Water Transfer Project in China [D].Leeds:The University of Leeds,2014.
[49] 戴尔阜,王晓莉,朱建佳,赵东升.生态系统服务权衡:方法、模型与研究框架.地理研究,2016,35(6):1005- 1016.
[50] Stürck J,Poortinga A,Verburg P H.Mapping ecosystem services:the supply and demand of flood regulation services in Europe.Ecological Indicators,2014,38:198- 211.
[51] García-Nieto A P,García-Llorente M,Iniesta-Arandia I,Martín-López B.Mapping forest ecosystem services:from providing units to beneficiaries.Ecosystem Services,2013,4:126- 138.
[52] Ninan K N,Inoue M.Valuing forest ecosystem services:case study of a forest reserve in Japan.Ecosystem Services,2013,5:78- 87.
[53] Naidoo R,Balmford A,Costanza R,Fisher B,Green R E,Lehner B,Malcolm T R,Ricketts T H.Global mapping of ecosystem services and conservation priorities.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,2008,105(28):9495- 9500.
[54] 严岩,朱捷缘,吴钢,詹云军.生态系统服务需求、供给和消费研究进展.生态学报,2017,37(8):2489- 2496.
[55] Wolff S,Schulp C J E,Verburg P H.Mapping ecosystem services demand:a review of current research and future perspectives.Ecological Indicators,2015,55:159- 171.
[56] Hou Y,Burkhard B,Müller F.Uncertainties in landscape analysis and ecosystem service assessment.Journal of Environmental Management,2013,127:S117-S131.
[57] Daily G C,Polasky S,Goldstein J,Kareiva P M,Mooney H A,Pejchar L,Ricketts T H,Salzman J,Shallenberger R.Ecosystem services in decision making:time to deliver.Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment,2009,7(1):21- 28.
[58] Fang X N,Zhao W W,Fu B J,Ding J Y.Landscape service capability,landscape service flow and landscape service demand:a new framework for landscape services and its use for landscape sustainability assessment.Progress in Physical Geography:Earth and Environment,2015,39(6):817- 836.
[59] Boerema A,Rebelo A J,Bodi M B,Esler K J,Meire P.Are ecosystem services adequately quantified?Journal of Applied Ecology,2017,54(2):358- 370.
[60] 刘慧敏,刘绿怡,丁圣彦.人类活动对生态系统服务流的影响.生态学报,2017,37(10):3232- 3242.
[61] Wei H J,Fan W G,Wang X C,Lu N C,Dong X B,Zhao Y N,Ya X J,Zhao Y F.Integrating supply and social demand in ecosystem services assessment:a review.Ecosystem Services,2017,25:15- 27.
[62] Liu M C,Yang L,Min Q W.Establishment of an eco-compensation fund based on eco-services consumption.Journal of Environmental Management,2018,211:306- 312.
[63] 彭建,杨旸,谢盼,刘焱序.基于生态系统服务供需的广东省绿地生态网络建设分区.生态学报,2017,37(13):4562- 4572.