基于RPYS分析的引文分析研究:起源和演化
|
摘要
文章分析已有引文分析综述存在的不足,引入新兴的文献计量方法——RPYS(参考文献出版年图谱),通过扩展RPYS研究的年限范围来探索国际引文分析领域的起源和演化过程。研究发现:R PYS识别得到的18篇文献对国际引文分析领域的起源和演化起到了不可替代的作用,证明R PYS不仅能用于学科领域的历史根源探索,也能对学科的演化和发展轨迹进行描绘,但仍然存在着局限性。
This paper analyzes the existing problems and limitations of research on citation analysis. By using a new analytical method called RPSY and expanding the time span of reference publications,the result shows that 18 documents have played an irreplaceable role in the origin and evolution of citation analysis research.
This paper analyzes the existing problems and limitations of research on citation analysis. By using a new analytical method called RPSY and expanding the time span of reference publications,the result shows that 18 documents have played an irreplaceable role in the origin and evolution of citation analysis research.
引文
[1]Nicolaisen J.Citation analysis[J].Annual R eview of Information Science&Technology,2007,41(1):609-641.
[2]Gross P L,Gross E M.College Libraries and Chemical Education[J].Bulletin of the American Association of University Professors,1927,66(1713):385-389.
[3]Burger A.Science Citation Index[M].Science citation index.Institute for Scientific Information,Inc.1961:789-790.
[4]Hirsch J E.An index to quantify an individual's scientific research output[J].Scientometrics,2010,102(3):16569-16572.
[5]杨思洛.引文分析存在的问题及其原因探究[J].中国图书馆学报,2011,37(3):108-117.
[6]Bornmann L,Marx W.The proposal of a broadening of perspective in evaluative bibliometrics by complementing the times cited with a cited reference analysis[J].Journal of Informetrics,2013,7(1):84-88.
[7]Macroberts M H,Macroberts B R.Problems of citation analysis:A critical review[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1989,40(5):342-349.
[8]苑彬成,方曙,刘清,等.国内外引文分析研究进展综述[J].情报科学,2010,28(1):147-153.
[9]万昊,谭宗颖,鲁晶晶,等.2001-2014年引文分析领域发展演化综述[J].图书情报工作,2015(6):120-136.
[10]Marx W,Bornmann L,Barth A.Detecting the Historical R oots of R esearch Fields by R eference Publication Year Spectroscopy(R PYS)[C]//F.Verlags.Proceedings of14th International Society of Scientometrics and Informetrics Conference,Stolbergasse:Facultas V,2013:493-506.
[11]Barth A,Marx W,Bornmann L,et al.O n the origins and the historical roots of the Higgs boson research from a bibliometric perspective[J].European Physical Journal Plus,2014,129(6):1-13.
[12]Leydesdorff L,Bornmann L,Marx W,et al.R eferenced Publication Years Spectroscopy applied to i Metrics:Scientometrics,Journal of Informetrics,and a relevant subset of JASIST[J].Journal of Informetrics,2013,8(1):162-174.
[13]Marx W,Bornmann L.Tracing the origin of a scientific legend by R eference Publication Year Spectroscopy(RPYS):the legend of the Darwin finches[J].Scientometrics,2014,99(3):839-844.
[14]Comins J,Hussey T.Compressing multiple scales of impact detection by R eference Publication Year Spectroscopy[J].Journal of Informetrics,2015,9(3):449-454.
[15]Elango B,Bornmann L,Kannan G.Detecting the historical roots of tribology research:a bibliometric analysis[J].Scientometrics,2016,107(1):1-9.
[16]李信,陆伟,李旭晖.一种新兴的学科领域历史根源探究方法:RPYS[J].图书情报工作,2016,60(20):70-76.
[17]刘则渊.迈向引文分析4.0时代[EB/O L].(2017-04-20)[2017-04-21].http://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-1557-1037402.Html.
[18]Jaccard P.Etude de la distribution florale dans une portion des Alpes et du Jura[J].Bulletin De La Societe Vaudoise des Sciences N aturelles,1901,37(142):547-579.
[19]Pearson,Karl.O n the theory of contingency and its relation to association and normal correlation:O n the general theory of skew correlation and non-linear regression[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1904.
[20]Cole F J,Eales N B.THE HISTO R Y O F CO MPARATIVE ANATO MY:PAR T I.-A STATISTICAL AN ALYSIS O F THE LITER ATUR E[J].Science Progress(1916-1919),1917,11(44):578-596.
[21]Gross P L,Gross E M.College Libraries and Chemical Education[J].Bulletin of the American Association of University Professors,1927,66(1713):385-389.
[22]Braddord S.C.O n the Scattering of Papers on Scientific Subjects in Scientific Periodicals[J].Engineering,1934,137(193):85-91.
[23]Zipf G K.Human behavior and the principle of least effort[M].Massachusetts:Addison-Wesley Press,1949:180-183.
[24]Garfield.E.Citation indexes for Science[J].Science,1955,122:108-111.
[25]Merton R K.Priorities in Scientific Discovery:A Chapter in the Sociology of Science[J].American Sociological R eview,1957,22(6):635-659.
[26]R.E.Burton,R.W.Kebler.The“half-life”of some scientific and technical literatures[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1960,11(1):18-22.
[27]俞培果.Burton—Kebler文献老化测度方法及其测度结果的否定[J].图书情报工作,1997(10):23-27.
[28]Kessler M M.Bibliographic coupling between scientific papers[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1963,14(1):10-25.
[29]Small H.Co-citation in the scientific literature:A new measure of the relationship between two documents[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1973,24(4):265-269.
[30]Price D.N etworks of Scientific Papers[J].Science,1965,149(3683):510-515.
[31]Gilbert G N.R eferencing as Persuasion[J].Social Studies of Science,1977,7(1):113-122.
[32]Garfield,Eugene,and R obert King Merton.Citation indexing:Its theory and application in science,technology,and humanities[M].N ew York:Wiley,1979.
[33]White H D,Griffith B C.Author cocitation:A literature measures of intellectual structure[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1981,32(3):163-171.
[34]Mccain K W.Mapping authors in intellectual space:A technical overview[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1990,41(6):433-443.
[35]Egghe L.Theory and Practice of the g-Index[J].Scientometrics,2006,69(1):131-152.
[36]Bornmann L,Daniel H D.Functional use of frequently and infrequently cited articles in citing publications.A content analysis of citations to articles with low and high citation counts[J].European Science Editing,2008,1(2):69-79.
[2]Gross P L,Gross E M.College Libraries and Chemical Education[J].Bulletin of the American Association of University Professors,1927,66(1713):385-389.
[3]Burger A.Science Citation Index[M].Science citation index.Institute for Scientific Information,Inc.1961:789-790.
[4]Hirsch J E.An index to quantify an individual's scientific research output[J].Scientometrics,2010,102(3):16569-16572.
[5]杨思洛.引文分析存在的问题及其原因探究[J].中国图书馆学报,2011,37(3):108-117.
[6]Bornmann L,Marx W.The proposal of a broadening of perspective in evaluative bibliometrics by complementing the times cited with a cited reference analysis[J].Journal of Informetrics,2013,7(1):84-88.
[7]Macroberts M H,Macroberts B R.Problems of citation analysis:A critical review[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1989,40(5):342-349.
[8]苑彬成,方曙,刘清,等.国内外引文分析研究进展综述[J].情报科学,2010,28(1):147-153.
[9]万昊,谭宗颖,鲁晶晶,等.2001-2014年引文分析领域发展演化综述[J].图书情报工作,2015(6):120-136.
[10]Marx W,Bornmann L,Barth A.Detecting the Historical R oots of R esearch Fields by R eference Publication Year Spectroscopy(R PYS)[C]//F.Verlags.Proceedings of14th International Society of Scientometrics and Informetrics Conference,Stolbergasse:Facultas V,2013:493-506.
[11]Barth A,Marx W,Bornmann L,et al.O n the origins and the historical roots of the Higgs boson research from a bibliometric perspective[J].European Physical Journal Plus,2014,129(6):1-13.
[12]Leydesdorff L,Bornmann L,Marx W,et al.R eferenced Publication Years Spectroscopy applied to i Metrics:Scientometrics,Journal of Informetrics,and a relevant subset of JASIST[J].Journal of Informetrics,2013,8(1):162-174.
[13]Marx W,Bornmann L.Tracing the origin of a scientific legend by R eference Publication Year Spectroscopy(RPYS):the legend of the Darwin finches[J].Scientometrics,2014,99(3):839-844.
[14]Comins J,Hussey T.Compressing multiple scales of impact detection by R eference Publication Year Spectroscopy[J].Journal of Informetrics,2015,9(3):449-454.
[15]Elango B,Bornmann L,Kannan G.Detecting the historical roots of tribology research:a bibliometric analysis[J].Scientometrics,2016,107(1):1-9.
[16]李信,陆伟,李旭晖.一种新兴的学科领域历史根源探究方法:RPYS[J].图书情报工作,2016,60(20):70-76.
[17]刘则渊.迈向引文分析4.0时代[EB/O L].(2017-04-20)[2017-04-21].http://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-1557-1037402.Html.
[18]Jaccard P.Etude de la distribution florale dans une portion des Alpes et du Jura[J].Bulletin De La Societe Vaudoise des Sciences N aturelles,1901,37(142):547-579.
[19]Pearson,Karl.O n the theory of contingency and its relation to association and normal correlation:O n the general theory of skew correlation and non-linear regression[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1904.
[20]Cole F J,Eales N B.THE HISTO R Y O F CO MPARATIVE ANATO MY:PAR T I.-A STATISTICAL AN ALYSIS O F THE LITER ATUR E[J].Science Progress(1916-1919),1917,11(44):578-596.
[21]Gross P L,Gross E M.College Libraries and Chemical Education[J].Bulletin of the American Association of University Professors,1927,66(1713):385-389.
[22]Braddord S.C.O n the Scattering of Papers on Scientific Subjects in Scientific Periodicals[J].Engineering,1934,137(193):85-91.
[23]Zipf G K.Human behavior and the principle of least effort[M].Massachusetts:Addison-Wesley Press,1949:180-183.
[24]Garfield.E.Citation indexes for Science[J].Science,1955,122:108-111.
[25]Merton R K.Priorities in Scientific Discovery:A Chapter in the Sociology of Science[J].American Sociological R eview,1957,22(6):635-659.
[26]R.E.Burton,R.W.Kebler.The“half-life”of some scientific and technical literatures[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1960,11(1):18-22.
[27]俞培果.Burton—Kebler文献老化测度方法及其测度结果的否定[J].图书情报工作,1997(10):23-27.
[28]Kessler M M.Bibliographic coupling between scientific papers[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1963,14(1):10-25.
[29]Small H.Co-citation in the scientific literature:A new measure of the relationship between two documents[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1973,24(4):265-269.
[30]Price D.N etworks of Scientific Papers[J].Science,1965,149(3683):510-515.
[31]Gilbert G N.R eferencing as Persuasion[J].Social Studies of Science,1977,7(1):113-122.
[32]Garfield,Eugene,and R obert King Merton.Citation indexing:Its theory and application in science,technology,and humanities[M].N ew York:Wiley,1979.
[33]White H D,Griffith B C.Author cocitation:A literature measures of intellectual structure[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1981,32(3):163-171.
[34]Mccain K W.Mapping authors in intellectual space:A technical overview[J].Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,1990,41(6):433-443.
[35]Egghe L.Theory and Practice of the g-Index[J].Scientometrics,2006,69(1):131-152.
[36]Bornmann L,Daniel H D.Functional use of frequently and infrequently cited articles in citing publications.A content analysis of citations to articles with low and high citation counts[J].European Science Editing,2008,1(2):69-79.