针灸为主治疗风寒袭络型面瘫的疗效观察
|
摘要
目的:本研究是为了比较针刺结合药物和单纯药物治疗风寒袭络型面瘫的疗效。材料与方法:将60例面瘫患者随机分为治疗组和对照组,每组30例。两组均采用常规药物的方法治疗,此外,治疗组还介入针刺治疗。两组患者治疗3个疗程以后,采用House-Brackmann面神经功能评价分级系统及Porlmann简易评分法进行疗效评定。
结果:
1.两组及组间治疗前后House-Brackmann分级比较两组间比较治疗前HB面神经功能示治疗组和对照组无统计学差异(P>0.05),表明两组间具有可比性;治疗前后治疗组和对照组组内自身比较有显著性差异(P<0.01),表明治疗组和对照组治疗方案均对治疗风寒袭络型面瘫有很好的疗效;组间比较治疗后,两组有统计学差异(P<0.05),表明治疗组的治疗方案更能提高面神经功能。
2.两组及组间治疗前后症状评分比较治疗前两组间进行比较,治疗组和对照组无统计学差异(P>0.05),表明两组间具有可比性;治疗前后治疗组和对照组组内自身比较有显著性差异(P<0.01),表明治疗组和对照组均能有效改善面瘫症状;组间对照比较治疗后,两组症状评分有统计学差异(P<0.05),说明治疗组较对照组更能改善面瘫症状的程度。
3.疗程结束后组间临床疗效比较通过两组对照比较(P<0.05),指出治疗组疗效优于对照组。
结论:
运用针灸配合药物治疗风寒袭络型周围性面瘫明显优于单纯药物治疗,具有明确的疗效,显著改善患者的临床症状,明显提高治愈率。此法值得在临床上推广应用。
Purpose:To compare therapeutic effects of acupuncture combined with medicine and pure medicine on the facial paralysis that belong to the type of wind-cold assailing the collaterals.
Material and method:Sixty cases of facial paralysis patients were randomly divided into a treatment group and a control group,30 cases in each group. Both groups were treated with routine medication, and the treatment group was treated with acupuncture.After three therapeutic courses,the House-Brackmann facial nerve function appraisal hierarchy system and the Porlmann easy grading method were compared among the groups.
Results:
1.Contrast of the two groups in the House-Brackmann facial nerve function appraisal hierarchy system before and after treatment In between-group comparison,the treatment group and the control group were not significant different(P>0.05) before treatment,showing two methods of treatment were comparable;After treatment,the contrast was significant difference (P<0.01) for the treatment group,so was for the control group.It followed that two groups had very good effect for the peripheral facial paralysis(the type of wind-cold assailing the collaterals);After treatment,the comparison within two groups showed significant difference (P<0.05),indicating the treatment group enhanced the facial nerve function to a higher degree than control group.
2.Contrast of the two groups in the Porlmann easy grading method before and after treatment
There was no significant difference in the control group compared with the treatment group before treatment(P>0.05),indicating that two groups were comparable.There was significant difference (P<0.01)after treatment within both groups,showing that these two treatments can improve the symptom of peripheral facia1 paralysis effectively.After treatments ,The comparison between the two group was different(P<0.05),which indicated that the treatment group had improved higher than the other.
3.Contrast in clinical curative effects between the treatment group and the control group after treatment Through the comparison between the two groups(P<0.05), pointed out that the curative effect of the treatment group was better .
Conclusion:
The acupuncture and medication to treat peripheral facial paralysis (the type of wind-cold assailing the collaterals) are superior to pure medication. This method has definite effective for cure of peripheral facial paralysis, obviously improve patient's clinical symptom,and significantly improve the cure rat.It is worthy promoting in the c1inical application.
结果:
1.两组及组间治疗前后House-Brackmann分级比较两组间比较治疗前HB面神经功能示治疗组和对照组无统计学差异(P>0.05),表明两组间具有可比性;治疗前后治疗组和对照组组内自身比较有显著性差异(P<0.01),表明治疗组和对照组治疗方案均对治疗风寒袭络型面瘫有很好的疗效;组间比较治疗后,两组有统计学差异(P<0.05),表明治疗组的治疗方案更能提高面神经功能。
2.两组及组间治疗前后症状评分比较治疗前两组间进行比较,治疗组和对照组无统计学差异(P>0.05),表明两组间具有可比性;治疗前后治疗组和对照组组内自身比较有显著性差异(P<0.01),表明治疗组和对照组均能有效改善面瘫症状;组间对照比较治疗后,两组症状评分有统计学差异(P<0.05),说明治疗组较对照组更能改善面瘫症状的程度。
3.疗程结束后组间临床疗效比较通过两组对照比较(P<0.05),指出治疗组疗效优于对照组。
结论:
运用针灸配合药物治疗风寒袭络型周围性面瘫明显优于单纯药物治疗,具有明确的疗效,显著改善患者的临床症状,明显提高治愈率。此法值得在临床上推广应用。
Purpose:To compare therapeutic effects of acupuncture combined with medicine and pure medicine on the facial paralysis that belong to the type of wind-cold assailing the collaterals.
Material and method:Sixty cases of facial paralysis patients were randomly divided into a treatment group and a control group,30 cases in each group. Both groups were treated with routine medication, and the treatment group was treated with acupuncture.After three therapeutic courses,the House-Brackmann facial nerve function appraisal hierarchy system and the Porlmann easy grading method were compared among the groups.
Results:
1.Contrast of the two groups in the House-Brackmann facial nerve function appraisal hierarchy system before and after treatment In between-group comparison,the treatment group and the control group were not significant different(P>0.05) before treatment,showing two methods of treatment were comparable;After treatment,the contrast was significant difference (P<0.01) for the treatment group,so was for the control group.It followed that two groups had very good effect for the peripheral facial paralysis(the type of wind-cold assailing the collaterals);After treatment,the comparison within two groups showed significant difference (P<0.05),indicating the treatment group enhanced the facial nerve function to a higher degree than control group.
2.Contrast of the two groups in the Porlmann easy grading method before and after treatment
There was no significant difference in the control group compared with the treatment group before treatment(P>0.05),indicating that two groups were comparable.There was significant difference (P<0.01)after treatment within both groups,showing that these two treatments can improve the symptom of peripheral facia1 paralysis effectively.After treatments ,The comparison between the two group was different(P<0.05),which indicated that the treatment group had improved higher than the other.
3.Contrast in clinical curative effects between the treatment group and the control group after treatment Through the comparison between the two groups(P<0.05), pointed out that the curative effect of the treatment group was better .
Conclusion:
The acupuncture and medication to treat peripheral facial paralysis (the type of wind-cold assailing the collaterals) are superior to pure medication. This method has definite effective for cure of peripheral facial paralysis, obviously improve patient's clinical symptom,and significantly improve the cure rat.It is worthy promoting in the c1inical application.
引文
[1]朱文锋.中医内科疾病诊疗常规[M].湖南:湖南科学技术出版社,1999:225.
[2]刘长军.针卦灸治疗面瘫60例[J].湖南中医药导报.2001,7(3):114.
[3]张旭霞.针刺为主治疗周围性面瘫[J].湖北中医杂志.2004,26(6):49.
[4]林荣娇.针药结合治疗急性周围性面瘫46例[J].针灸临床杂志.2009,25 (11):16.
[5]杨龙.电针治疗周围性面瘫临床观察[J].中国伤残医学.2009,17(2):126.
[6]张青云.电针为主治疗周围性面瘫的临床观察[J].天津医科大学报.2002,6(2):22-26.
[7]刘平.“合谷刺”配合电针治疗面神经麻痹的临床观察[J].针灸临床杂志.2003,19(3):30-31.
[8]王体敏.电针断续波治疗周围性面神经麻痹临床观察[J].上海针灸杂志.2004,23(1):13-14.
[9]刘荣奇.艾条隔姜灸治疗风寒型面瘫72例[J].广西中医药.2004,27(2):48.
[10]彭建,叶萍香.艾灸治疗周围性面瘫38例[J].中医外科杂志.2006,15(5):2.
[11]张栩.隔姜灸治疗面神经麻痹[J].中国临床医药实用杂志.2004,30(15):45.
[12]秦君.风池穴温针灸治疗面瘫20例[J].JCAM.2002,18(5):24.
[13]王璞,安军明,孙科平,赵阳.多针浅刺法治疗周围性面瘫134例[J].针灸临床杂志.2008,24(11):10-11.
[14]宣益民.捻转进针浅刺法治疗面瘫220例[J].针灸临床杂志.2005,21(2):47.
[15]范郁山,姚春.温针浅刺法治疗周围型面瘫50例[J].湖北中医杂志.2002,24(12):45.
[16]郭明岐,贾志强,张志忠.多针透刺治疗周围性面瘫临床体会[J].中国实用医药.20(4):232.
[17]陈云,罗广生,赵诗磊.毫针透刺治疗周围性面瘫50例[J].中国中医急症.2005,14(8):785-786.
[18]张沛然,王建萍.补阳还五汤合牵正散辅以针灸治疗面瘫52例临床观察[J].中华新医药杂志.2004,11(1):25-26.
[19]高远丽.针药结合治疗不同时期面瘫96例临床观察[J].新中医.2009,41(8):101.
[20]杨青.针灸结合辨证用药治疗周围性面瘫[J].浙江中医学院学报.2002,26(1):49.
[21]丁明桥.针刺配合健侧穴位贴敷治疗周围性面瘫63例[J].针灸临床杂志.2008,24(9):71.
[22]李登瑞,蒋永德.针刺为主治疗面瘫846例疗效观察[J].四川中医.2007,25(3):2.
[1]贾建平,崔丽英,王伟.神经病学[M]. 6版.北京:人民卫生出版社,2008:336.
[2]王维治,罗祖明.神经病学[M]. 4版.北京:人民卫生出版社,2002:81.
[3]赵世杰,皮昕.口腔颌面部解剖学[M].北京:北京大学医学出版社,2005:122.
[4]林顺涨,孙爱英.现代面神经外科的基础和临床[M].上海:第二军医大学出版社,2002:72.
[5]Balkany T,Fradis M,Jafe BVV,al et.Intrinsic vasculature of the labyrinthine segment of the facial nerve-implications for site of lesion in Bell's palsy[J].ArchOtolaryngol Head Neck Surg.1991,104:20-23.
[6]Ikeda M,Li jima M,Kukimoto N,et al.Plasma endothelin level in the acute stage of Bell'palsy [J].ArchOtolaryngol Head Neck Surg,1996,122(8):849-852.
[7]Omori H, Ikeda M. Intravascular hypercoagulability in patients with recent Bell's palsy. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 1994,251:278-282.
[8]Burgess RC,Michaels L,Bale JF Jr,et al.Polymerase chain reaction amplification of herpes simplex viral DNA from geniculate of a patient with Bell'palsy[J].Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol.1994,103:775.
[9]Sugita T,Murakami S,Yanagihara N,et a1.Facial nerve paralysis induced by herpes simplex Virus in mice:an animal model of acute and transient facial paralysis[J].Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol.1995,104(7):574-581.
[10]Jonsson L,Larsson A,Thomander L.Immune complexes and complement components in Bell's palsy[J].Journal for Oto-Rhino-Laryngology and its Related Specialties.1987,49(6):294-301.
[11]贾建平.神经内科疾病临床诊疗规范教程[M].北京:北京大学医学出版社,2010:544.
[12]Peitersen E.Bell s palsv:the spontaneous course of 2,500 peripheral facial nerve palsies of different etiologies[J].Acta 0tolaryngol Suppl.2002,549:4.
[13]王维治.神经病学(第5版)[M].北京:人民卫生出版社,2005:33.
[14]代启彬.周围性面瘫的临床治疗研究[J].中华现代中药学杂志.2005,l(10):38-40.
[15]王燕楢.面瘫164例观察[J].中华耳鼻咽喉科杂志.1996,31(6):334.
[16]冯锦标.激素治疗贝尔面瘫临床观察[J].实用医学杂志.2001,17(7):675.
[17]杨晓燕.综合治疗面神经炎体会[J].中国中医药现代远程教育.2009,71(7):87.
[18]彭芝容.维生素B1、B12穴位注射治疗面瘫[J].中国药业.2000,9(5):46.
[19]侯群,陈眉,黄晓明等.弥可保和维生素B12治疗周围性面瘫的疗效比较[J].中国新药杂志.2000,9(12):839-841.
[20]王灿东,吴红梅,袁秀真.采用阿昔洛韦合用强的松治疗特发性面神经麻痹98例[J].山东医药.2004,44(16):41.
[21]杨运周,胡文霞,翟宏江等.更昔洛韦联合强的松急性特发性面神经麻痹临床观察[J].中国实用神经疾病杂志.2010,13(2):16-17.
[22]王景文.20%甘露醇注射液治疗周围性面瘫疗效观察[J].中国误诊学杂志.2007,7(24):5771.
[23]张垚.甘露醇联合激素治疗面神经炎50例疗效分析[J].中国实用医药.2009,30(2):119.
[24]彭亮,周君,王泽涛.脑蛋白水解物穴位注射治疗面神经炎疗效观察[J].上海针灸杂志.2006,25(2):28.
[25]张素爱,陆素琴,储旭华等.神经生长因子治疗神经炎45例的疗效观察[J],J C lin Neurol.2006,19(5):392.
[26]钟月桂,黄敏,林嘉旋,徐桂红,欧小凌.温热式低周波治疗仪治疗面神经炎的疗效观察[J].医学伦理与实践.2009,22(6):674.
[27]杨朝辉,刘莉,黄涛.毫米波治疗面神经炎疗效分析[J].中国临床康复.2005,9(1):154.
[28]王彤,赵海梅,傅如华,陈江华.激光穴位照射结合中药导入治疗面神经炎46例[J].中国实验方剂学杂志.2009,15(7):101-102.
[29]苍伟,刘玉柱,曹礼.周围神经损伤的修复[J].黑龙江医学.2002,27(2):90.
[30]陈石海.晚期面瘫治疗进展[J].广西医学.2001,23(2):303-306.
[31]李沮仁,倪国坛.高压氧医学[M].上海:上海科技出版社,1998:322-323.
[32]秦绍林.中西医结合治疗面神经炎35例临床观察[J].浙江中西医结合杂志.2002,1:35.
[33]朱志红,唐基忠.面神经炎急性期针灸治疗的疗效观察[J].中国针灸.2005,21(2):20.
[34]李绍琴.中西医结合治疗面神经瘫痪[J].职业与健康,2001,17(2):125
[35]张大千.中国针灸大辞典[M].北京:北京体育学苑出版社,1986,5:38-536.
[36]刘胜,王思广,董捷.针灸电诊断分型法治疗周围性面瘫[J].中国针灸.2002,22(7):453.
[37]薛辉,石旭星.面瘫急性期针刺治疗的可行性探讨[J].陕西中医.2003,24(9):819.
[38]裴玉新,崔勇,陈瑞平.微波加药物综合治疗带状疱疹疗效观察[J].中国麻风皮肤病杂志.2007,23(6):537.
[39]金炳旭.针灸治疗周围性面瘫研究进展[J].甘肃中医.2005,18(5):29.
[40]王竹梅.针灸治疗周围性面瘫神经电生理变化[J].山东中医药大学学报.1998,22(5):357.
[41]陈雪琴.周围性面瘫针灸治疗时机之我见[J].浙江中医学院报.2002,26(6):57.
[42]高远丽.针药结合治疗不同时期面瘫96例临床观察[J].新中医.2009,41(8):101.
[43]姚军,陈炜.滞针疗法治疗面瘫急性期50例临床观察[J].甘肃中医.2010,23(5):34-35.
[44]陈晓琴,李瑛,邙玲玲等.循证医学与贝尔面瘫针灸临床研究中不同疗法评价的研究[J].时珍国医国药.2009,20(8):1877-1800.
[45]宋宇,张小霞.双侧同穴同刺法治疗面瘫后遗症65例[J].针灸临床杂志.2007,23(3):13.
[46]王燕,杜晓燕.滞针法结合功能锻炼治疗面瘫后遗症70例[J].新疆中医药.2003,21(2):28.
[47]郑晖,李瑛,陈敏.针灸治疗周围性面瘫刺灸方法的循证评价[J].中国康复医学杂志.2009,24(1):77-78.
[48]李登瑞,蒋永德.针刺为主治疗面瘫846例疗效观察[J].四川中医.2007,25(3):100.
[49]陈玲,魏宏权,任重.失神经支配程度测试在判断面神经功能恢复中的作用[J].中国临床康复.2004,8(1):96-97.
[2]刘长军.针卦灸治疗面瘫60例[J].湖南中医药导报.2001,7(3):114.
[3]张旭霞.针刺为主治疗周围性面瘫[J].湖北中医杂志.2004,26(6):49.
[4]林荣娇.针药结合治疗急性周围性面瘫46例[J].针灸临床杂志.2009,25 (11):16.
[5]杨龙.电针治疗周围性面瘫临床观察[J].中国伤残医学.2009,17(2):126.
[6]张青云.电针为主治疗周围性面瘫的临床观察[J].天津医科大学报.2002,6(2):22-26.
[7]刘平.“合谷刺”配合电针治疗面神经麻痹的临床观察[J].针灸临床杂志.2003,19(3):30-31.
[8]王体敏.电针断续波治疗周围性面神经麻痹临床观察[J].上海针灸杂志.2004,23(1):13-14.
[9]刘荣奇.艾条隔姜灸治疗风寒型面瘫72例[J].广西中医药.2004,27(2):48.
[10]彭建,叶萍香.艾灸治疗周围性面瘫38例[J].中医外科杂志.2006,15(5):2.
[11]张栩.隔姜灸治疗面神经麻痹[J].中国临床医药实用杂志.2004,30(15):45.
[12]秦君.风池穴温针灸治疗面瘫20例[J].JCAM.2002,18(5):24.
[13]王璞,安军明,孙科平,赵阳.多针浅刺法治疗周围性面瘫134例[J].针灸临床杂志.2008,24(11):10-11.
[14]宣益民.捻转进针浅刺法治疗面瘫220例[J].针灸临床杂志.2005,21(2):47.
[15]范郁山,姚春.温针浅刺法治疗周围型面瘫50例[J].湖北中医杂志.2002,24(12):45.
[16]郭明岐,贾志强,张志忠.多针透刺治疗周围性面瘫临床体会[J].中国实用医药.20(4):232.
[17]陈云,罗广生,赵诗磊.毫针透刺治疗周围性面瘫50例[J].中国中医急症.2005,14(8):785-786.
[18]张沛然,王建萍.补阳还五汤合牵正散辅以针灸治疗面瘫52例临床观察[J].中华新医药杂志.2004,11(1):25-26.
[19]高远丽.针药结合治疗不同时期面瘫96例临床观察[J].新中医.2009,41(8):101.
[20]杨青.针灸结合辨证用药治疗周围性面瘫[J].浙江中医学院学报.2002,26(1):49.
[21]丁明桥.针刺配合健侧穴位贴敷治疗周围性面瘫63例[J].针灸临床杂志.2008,24(9):71.
[22]李登瑞,蒋永德.针刺为主治疗面瘫846例疗效观察[J].四川中医.2007,25(3):2.
[1]贾建平,崔丽英,王伟.神经病学[M]. 6版.北京:人民卫生出版社,2008:336.
[2]王维治,罗祖明.神经病学[M]. 4版.北京:人民卫生出版社,2002:81.
[3]赵世杰,皮昕.口腔颌面部解剖学[M].北京:北京大学医学出版社,2005:122.
[4]林顺涨,孙爱英.现代面神经外科的基础和临床[M].上海:第二军医大学出版社,2002:72.
[5]Balkany T,Fradis M,Jafe BVV,al et.Intrinsic vasculature of the labyrinthine segment of the facial nerve-implications for site of lesion in Bell's palsy[J].ArchOtolaryngol Head Neck Surg.1991,104:20-23.
[6]Ikeda M,Li jima M,Kukimoto N,et al.Plasma endothelin level in the acute stage of Bell'palsy [J].ArchOtolaryngol Head Neck Surg,1996,122(8):849-852.
[7]Omori H, Ikeda M. Intravascular hypercoagulability in patients with recent Bell's palsy. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 1994,251:278-282.
[8]Burgess RC,Michaels L,Bale JF Jr,et al.Polymerase chain reaction amplification of herpes simplex viral DNA from geniculate of a patient with Bell'palsy[J].Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol.1994,103:775.
[9]Sugita T,Murakami S,Yanagihara N,et a1.Facial nerve paralysis induced by herpes simplex Virus in mice:an animal model of acute and transient facial paralysis[J].Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol.1995,104(7):574-581.
[10]Jonsson L,Larsson A,Thomander L.Immune complexes and complement components in Bell's palsy[J].Journal for Oto-Rhino-Laryngology and its Related Specialties.1987,49(6):294-301.
[11]贾建平.神经内科疾病临床诊疗规范教程[M].北京:北京大学医学出版社,2010:544.
[12]Peitersen E.Bell s palsv:the spontaneous course of 2,500 peripheral facial nerve palsies of different etiologies[J].Acta 0tolaryngol Suppl.2002,549:4.
[13]王维治.神经病学(第5版)[M].北京:人民卫生出版社,2005:33.
[14]代启彬.周围性面瘫的临床治疗研究[J].中华现代中药学杂志.2005,l(10):38-40.
[15]王燕楢.面瘫164例观察[J].中华耳鼻咽喉科杂志.1996,31(6):334.
[16]冯锦标.激素治疗贝尔面瘫临床观察[J].实用医学杂志.2001,17(7):675.
[17]杨晓燕.综合治疗面神经炎体会[J].中国中医药现代远程教育.2009,71(7):87.
[18]彭芝容.维生素B1、B12穴位注射治疗面瘫[J].中国药业.2000,9(5):46.
[19]侯群,陈眉,黄晓明等.弥可保和维生素B12治疗周围性面瘫的疗效比较[J].中国新药杂志.2000,9(12):839-841.
[20]王灿东,吴红梅,袁秀真.采用阿昔洛韦合用强的松治疗特发性面神经麻痹98例[J].山东医药.2004,44(16):41.
[21]杨运周,胡文霞,翟宏江等.更昔洛韦联合强的松急性特发性面神经麻痹临床观察[J].中国实用神经疾病杂志.2010,13(2):16-17.
[22]王景文.20%甘露醇注射液治疗周围性面瘫疗效观察[J].中国误诊学杂志.2007,7(24):5771.
[23]张垚.甘露醇联合激素治疗面神经炎50例疗效分析[J].中国实用医药.2009,30(2):119.
[24]彭亮,周君,王泽涛.脑蛋白水解物穴位注射治疗面神经炎疗效观察[J].上海针灸杂志.2006,25(2):28.
[25]张素爱,陆素琴,储旭华等.神经生长因子治疗神经炎45例的疗效观察[J],J C lin Neurol.2006,19(5):392.
[26]钟月桂,黄敏,林嘉旋,徐桂红,欧小凌.温热式低周波治疗仪治疗面神经炎的疗效观察[J].医学伦理与实践.2009,22(6):674.
[27]杨朝辉,刘莉,黄涛.毫米波治疗面神经炎疗效分析[J].中国临床康复.2005,9(1):154.
[28]王彤,赵海梅,傅如华,陈江华.激光穴位照射结合中药导入治疗面神经炎46例[J].中国实验方剂学杂志.2009,15(7):101-102.
[29]苍伟,刘玉柱,曹礼.周围神经损伤的修复[J].黑龙江医学.2002,27(2):90.
[30]陈石海.晚期面瘫治疗进展[J].广西医学.2001,23(2):303-306.
[31]李沮仁,倪国坛.高压氧医学[M].上海:上海科技出版社,1998:322-323.
[32]秦绍林.中西医结合治疗面神经炎35例临床观察[J].浙江中西医结合杂志.2002,1:35.
[33]朱志红,唐基忠.面神经炎急性期针灸治疗的疗效观察[J].中国针灸.2005,21(2):20.
[34]李绍琴.中西医结合治疗面神经瘫痪[J].职业与健康,2001,17(2):125
[35]张大千.中国针灸大辞典[M].北京:北京体育学苑出版社,1986,5:38-536.
[36]刘胜,王思广,董捷.针灸电诊断分型法治疗周围性面瘫[J].中国针灸.2002,22(7):453.
[37]薛辉,石旭星.面瘫急性期针刺治疗的可行性探讨[J].陕西中医.2003,24(9):819.
[38]裴玉新,崔勇,陈瑞平.微波加药物综合治疗带状疱疹疗效观察[J].中国麻风皮肤病杂志.2007,23(6):537.
[39]金炳旭.针灸治疗周围性面瘫研究进展[J].甘肃中医.2005,18(5):29.
[40]王竹梅.针灸治疗周围性面瘫神经电生理变化[J].山东中医药大学学报.1998,22(5):357.
[41]陈雪琴.周围性面瘫针灸治疗时机之我见[J].浙江中医学院报.2002,26(6):57.
[42]高远丽.针药结合治疗不同时期面瘫96例临床观察[J].新中医.2009,41(8):101.
[43]姚军,陈炜.滞针疗法治疗面瘫急性期50例临床观察[J].甘肃中医.2010,23(5):34-35.
[44]陈晓琴,李瑛,邙玲玲等.循证医学与贝尔面瘫针灸临床研究中不同疗法评价的研究[J].时珍国医国药.2009,20(8):1877-1800.
[45]宋宇,张小霞.双侧同穴同刺法治疗面瘫后遗症65例[J].针灸临床杂志.2007,23(3):13.
[46]王燕,杜晓燕.滞针法结合功能锻炼治疗面瘫后遗症70例[J].新疆中医药.2003,21(2):28.
[47]郑晖,李瑛,陈敏.针灸治疗周围性面瘫刺灸方法的循证评价[J].中国康复医学杂志.2009,24(1):77-78.
[48]李登瑞,蒋永德.针刺为主治疗面瘫846例疗效观察[J].四川中医.2007,25(3):100.
[49]陈玲,魏宏权,任重.失神经支配程度测试在判断面神经功能恢复中的作用[J].中国临床康复.2004,8(1):96-97.