要素市场化与经理人市场的隐性激励
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
创造性地运用企业理论关于“企业是一系列合同的纽结”的观点来重新审视改革开放25年来的国有企业改革历程,提出生产要素市场化是国有企业改革取得成功的必要条件,而在众多生产要素的市场化过程中,企业家才能的市场化成为当前中国国企改革的“短板”。
    企业家才能市场化的载体是有序运转的经理人市场,经理人市场所内含的隐性激励与约束机制是对以业绩报酬为基础的显性激励与约束机制的重要补充。运用委托代理模型,给出了经理人市场隐性激励机制对节约企业激励成本的定量分析结论。
    在综述国内外关于经理人市场隐性激励的研究文献的基础上,全面厘清了经理人市场所内含的隐性激励机制。并运用其所提供的模型框架对中国国有企业经理人的选择机制及其弊端作了分析。
    在国企经理行政性任命制度下,提出了国企经理的多任务假说,即经营性任务、政治性任务和满足上级偏好等三项工作任务,在此基础上构造了国企经理的总效用函数,推演出了国企经理效用最大化的两个条件并作了结论分析。
    运用多任务委托代理模型分析国企经理的激励问题后得出,若多工作任务努力的激励成本之间相互独立,那么激励相容条件下的各工作任务的最优业绩报酬也是相互独立的,且最优业绩报酬是绝对风险规避度、边际激励成本变化率和可观测变量方差的递减函数;而如果多工作任务激励成本是相互依存的,那么在激励相容条件下,政治性活动和满足上级偏好的最优激励合同为“门槛型激励合同”,即只有当国企经理所创造的业绩超过一定的“门槛值”时,对其的激励才是正向的,否则将是负向的。并且定量地给出了国企经理的“门槛型激励条件”,并通过激励条件分析得出建设国企经理人市场,实现国企经理市场化选择的结论。
    最后通过一个简化的经理人流动模型对中国经理人市场的建设提出了若干政策建议,并在分析当前MBO、ESO等国企改革新问题的基础上,提出了国企及其配套改革措施在改革次序上应遵循其内在逻辑次序的观点。
After scrutinizing the reform history of China’s state-owned enterprises (SOEs) with firm theory that a firm is generally the nexus of a series of contracts, this study shows that the liberalization of production factors is the key to the further reform of the SOEs, and that managerial labor liberalization is the weakest point among all the production factors.
    An orderly managerial labor market is the carrier for the liberalization of managerial labor, whilst the implicit incentive from the managerial labor market is an important supplement to the explicit incentives which are based on the agent’s performance. By using the principal-agent model, this study draws a quantitative analytical conclusion of incentive cost saving through the implicit incentive system of the managerial labor market.
    After a literature review of the implicit incentive study, this study first clarifies the implicit incentive system, and then analyzes the SOEs’ manager selective procedure and its disadvantages based on the mathematic model provided.
    Under the superior-appointment select procedure, we present the SOE managers’ multitask hypothesis, it includes: 1) operation task, 2) political task, and 3) the superior’s preference. Then develop a total utility model for the SOE manager and get two maximal utility conditions.
    Using the multi-task principal-agent model, this study analyzes the SOE manager’s incentive issues in two aspects, the tasks are inter-independent or inter-dependent. And then comes to the conclusions that, while the tasks are inter-dependent, the incentive contract with a SOE manager is not only multi-tasked, but also threshed. That is, the incentive for a SOE manager is positive only that the SOE manager’s political performance and preference performance satisfy the threshed incentive conditions simultaneously; otherwise, it is negative. The threshed incentive conditions are thereby presented in this article. Under the incentive contract above, the SOE likely turn into a political bureaucracy, so market selection
    
    
    of SOEs’ managers, or managerial labor liberalization, is naturally the conclusion for the SOEs’ reform.
    Through a simplified model of managerial labor liberalization, this article put forward some recommendations for the construction of the Chinese managerial labor market. Moreover, based on the analysis of the present new issues of MBO and ESO, this article emphasizes that the reform of the SOEs should be implemented in its inherent logic order.
引文
Acemoglu,D.,M.Kremer and A.Mian,2001.Markets,firm and governments,draft,MIT.
    Acharya,V.,John,K.,Sundaram,R.K.,2000.On the optimality of resetting executive stock options.Journal of Financial Economics,57,65-101.
    Agrawal,A.,Knoeber,C.R,1996.Firm performance and mechanisms to control agency problems between managers and shareholders.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,31(3),377-397.
    Akerlof,G.,1970.The market for lemons:quality uncertainty and the market mechanism.Quarterly Journal of Economics,84(3),488-500.
    Anderlini,L.,Felli,L.,1998.Describability and agency problems.European Economic Review,42,35-59.
    Andersson,F.,1998. Career concerns, contracts, and work hours.JEL.working paper.
    Andersson,F.,2002.Career concerns, contracts, and effort distortions.Journal of Labor Economics,20(1),42-58.
    Axelrod, R,1984.The evolution of cooperation. Basic Books,New York.
    Barro,R.J.,1986.Reputation in model of monetary policy with incomplete information,Journal of Monetary Economics,17(1),3-20.
    Basu,K.,1995.Stackelberg equilibrium in oligopoly:An explanation based on managerial incentives.Economics Letters 49,459-464.
    Becht,M.,Bolton,P.,Roell,A.,2002.Corporate governance and control.Working paper,ECGI.
    Berle,A.A ,Means,G.G,1933.The Modern Corporation and private property.New York Macmillan.
    Bin X.,1998.A reestimation of the Evans-Jovanovic entrepreneurial choice model,Economics 58,91-95.
    Borland,J.,1992.Career concerns:incentives and endogenous learning in labour markets.Journal of Economic surveys 6(3),251-270.
    Brickley,J.A., Coles,J.L., Linck,J.S., ,1999.What happens to ceos after retire?New evidence on career concerns,horizon problems,and CEO incentives.Journal of Financial Economics,52,341-377.
    Brookfield,D.,Ormrod,P.,2000.Executive stock options-volatility,managerial decisions and agency costs.Journal of Multinational Financial Management,10,275-295.
    Cannella,A.A.,Donald,R.J,Scott,L.D.,1995.Firm failure and managerial labor markets evidence from Texas banking.Journal of Financial Economics,38,185-210.
    
    
    Cauley,J., Sandler,T.,2001.Agent cost and the crisis of China's SOEs:A comment and further observations. Working paper.
    Casson,Mark,1982.The entrepreneur: an economic theory, Martin Robertson,Oxford.
    CCFR, FBE,UHK,2002.Corporate governance and protection of the rights of minority shareholders in China.Working paper.
    Cheung,S.N.S.,1983. The contractual nature of the firm,Journal of Law and Economics,26(1),1-21.
    Chevalier,J., Ellison,G., 1999. Career concerns of mutual fund managers. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 114(2), 389-432.
    Choe,C., Yin,X.,2000.Contract management responsibility sysytem and profit incentives in china's state-owned enterprised.China Ecomomic Review 11,98-112.
    Coase, R.H., 1937. The Nature of the Firm, Economica , 4. 386-405.
    Cremer,J.,1986.Cooperation in on-going organizations.Quarterly Journal of Economics,101,33-49.
    Dewatripont,M.,Jewitt,I.,Tirole,J.,1997.Information structure and career concerns.Mimeo,11,ECARE,University of Bristol,and IDEI.
    Dewatripont,M.,Jewitt,I.,Tirole,J.,1999.The economics of career concerns. Part 1:Comparing information structure.Review of Economic Studies 66:183-98. part 2:Application to missions and accountability of government agencies.Review of Economic Studies 66:199-217.
    Dewatripont,M.,Jewitt,I.,Tirole,J.,2000.Multitask agency problems-Focus and task clustering.European Ecomomic Review,44,869-877.
    Dewatripont,M.,Roland,G.,1999.Soft budget constraints, transition and financial systems.Working paper,ECARE.
    Diamond, D. W., 1989.Reputation acquisition in debt markets.Journal of Political Economy, 97(4), 828--862.
    Douglas,A.V.,2002,Capital structure and the control of managerial incentives. Journal of Corporate Finance 8,287-311.
    Dow,G.K.,1993. Why capital hires labour:a bargaining perspective,American Economic Review,83(1),118-134.
    Dyck,A.J.,1997.Privatization in eastern Germany:Management selection and economic transition.The American Economic Review,87(4),565-597.
    Eewatripont,M.,Jewitt,I.,Tirole,J.,1999.The ecomomics of career concerns,part 1:comparing information structures.Review of Ecomomic Studies,66,183-198.
    Eewatripont,M.,Jewitt,I.,Tirole,J.,1999.The economics of career concerns,part 2:application to missions and accountability of government agencies.Review of Ecomomic Studies,66,199-217.
    
    
    Eriksson,T.,Lausten,M.,2000.Managerial pay and firm performance-Danish evidence.Scandinavian Journal of Management,16,269-286.
    Fama,E.F.,1980.Agency problems and the theory of the firm.Journal of Political Economy,88(2),288-307.
    Fee,C.E.,Hadlock,C.J.,2001.Raids, rewards, and reputations in the market for CEO talent.Working paper,AFA 2002 Atlanta Meetings.
    Fenn,G.W., Liang,N.,2001.Corporate payout policy and managerial stock incentives.Journal of Financial Ecomomics 60 45-72.
    Friedman, J. W., 1985, Cooperative equilibria in finite horizon non cooperative super games.” Journal of Economic Theory, 35, 390-398.
    Fudenberg,D., E.Maskin,1986. The folk theorem in repeated games with discounting or with incomplete information. Econometrica 54,533-554.
    Fudenberg,D.,Tirole,J.,1986.A sigal-jamming theory of predation.Rand Journal of Economics,17(3),366-376.
    Gamble,J.E.,2000.Management commitment to innovation and ESOP stock concentration.Journal of Business Venturing,15,433-447.
    Gibbons,R.,Murphy,K.,1992.Optimal incentive contracts in the presence of career concerns:theory and evidence.Journal of Political Economy,100(3),468-505.
    Goel,A.M.,Nanda,V., Narayanan,M.P.,2002. Career concerns and resource allocation in conglomerates. JEL.Working paper.
    Grossman,S.,Hart,O.,1983.An analysis of the principal-agent problem,Econometrica,51(1),7-45.
    Groves T., Hong Y., McMillan J. and Naughton B. ,1995. China's Evolving Managerial Labor Market, Journal of Political Economy, 103, 873-892.
    Harris,M.raviv,A.,1979.Optimal incentive contracts with imperfect information.Journal of Economic Theory,20(2),231-259.
    Hart,O., and B., Holmstrom, 1987. Theory of contracts, in Advances in economic theory: fifth world congress, edited by T. Bewley. Cambridge University Press.
    Holmstrom,B.,1982.Managerial incentive problems:A dynamic perspective.In:Essays in economics and management in honor of Lars Wahlbeck,pp.209-230.Helsinki:Swedish School of Economics and Business Administration.
    Holmstrom,B.,Costa,J.R.,1986.Managerial incentives and capital management. Quarterly Journal of Economics,101(4),835-860.
    Holmstrom,B.,P.Milgrom,1991,Multi-task principal-agent analyses:incentive contracts,asset ownership and job design.Journl of Law,Economics and Organization 7,24-52.
    
    
    
    Holmstrom,B.,Tirole,J.,The theory of the firm.in Richard Schmalensee and Robert D.Willig, eds., Handbook of Industrial Organization, Vol. 1, Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1989.
    Jensen,M.C.,1986.Agency cost of free cash flow,corporate finance and takeovers.American Economic Review,76,323-339.
    Jensen,M.C.,Murphy,K.J.,1990.Performance pay and top-management incentives.Journal of Political Economy,98,225-264.
    Jeon,S.,1996.Moral hazard and reputational concerns in teams-implicatons for organizational choice.International Journal of Industrial Organization,14,297-315.
    Jeon,S.,1998.Reputational concerns and managerial incentives in investment decisions.European Ecomomic Review,42,1203-1219.
    Johannes Horner, 2002. Reputation and competition.American Economic Review, 92(3), 644-663.
    Jones,D.C.,Dato,T.,1995.Awramov,S.,Managerial labour markets in transitional economies-evidence from Bulgaria.International Journal of Manpower,16(10),14-24.
    Kandori,M.,1992.Repeated games played by overlapping generations of players.Review of Exomomic Studies,59,81-92.
    Kanodia,C.,Bushman,R.,Dickhaut,J.,1989.Escalation errors and the sunk cost effect:an explanation based on reputation and information asymmetries.Jorunal of Accounting Research,27(1),59-77.
    Khanna,A.,1999. Agency problems and incentive contracts: The case of the English east India company. Working paper.
    Kirzner,I.M.,1979.Perception,opportunity and profit, Chicago University Press,Chicago.
    Klein, Benjamin, and Keith B. Leffler (1981). “The Role of Market Forces in Assessing Contractual Performance,” Journal of Political Economy, 89, August, 615-641.
    Kolodko,G.W.,2000.Transition to a market and entrepreneurship:the systemic factors and policy options.Communist and Post-Communist Studies,33,271-293.
    Kreps,D.M.,1990.Corporate culture and ecomomic theory.In Perspecives on Positive Political Economy:edited by James Alt and Kenneth Shepsle.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1990,90-143.
    Kreps,D. and R.Wilson,1982. Sequential equilibrium. Econometrica 50,863-94.
    Kreps,D., P.Milgrom, J.Roberts and R.wilson, 1982. Rational cooperation in the finitely repeated prisoners’ dilemma. Journal of Economic Theory 27,245-52.
    Li,Xi,2002,Career concerns of equity analysts-compensation,termination,and performance.JEL.Working paper.
    Luce, R.D. and H. Raifa, 1957. Games and decisions. Wiley, New York.
    
    
    Mailath,G.J.and Samuelson,L.,2001.Who wants a good reputation?The Review of Economic Studies,68(2),415-441.
    Maug,E.,1996.Corporate control and the market for managerial labour:On the decision to go public.European Economic Review 40,1049-1056.
    Medoff and Abraham,1981. Are Those Paid More Really MoreProductive? The case of experience.Journal of Labor Resources 16 (Spring), 186-216.
    Meyer,M.,Vickers,J.,1997.Performance comparisons and dynamic incentives.Journal of Political Economy, 105(3).547-581.
    Milbourn,T.T.,Shockldy,R.L.,Thakor,A.V.,2001.Managerial career cincerns and investments in information.Rand Jorunal of Ecomomics,32(2),334-351.
    Milbourn,T.T.,Shockley,R.L.,Anjan,V.,2001.ThakorManagerial career concerns and investments in information.Rand Journal of Economics,32(2),pp.334.
    Milgrom,P.,Roberts,J.,1982.Limit pricing and entry under incomplete information:an equilibrium analysis. Econometrica 40,433-59.
    Milgrom,P.,Roberts,J.,1988.An ecomomic approach to influence activeties.American Journa of Sociology,94,Supplement,154-179.
    Mirrlees,J.,1976.The optimal structure of incentives and authority within an organization.The Bell Journal of Economics,7(1),105-131.
    Narayanan,M.P.,1985.Managerial incentives for short-term results.Journal of Finance,40(5),1469-1484.
    Nelson, P., 1970. Information and Consumer Behavior. Journal of Political Economy, 78, 311-329.
    Neyman, A.,1985, Bounded complexity justifies cooperation in the finitely repeated prisoner’s dilemma.” Economics Letters, 19,227-229.
    Nohel,T. Todd,S.,2001.Stock options and managerial incentives to invest.EFMA 2002 London Meetings.
    Nohel,T. Todd,S.,2002.Compensation for managers with career concerns-the role of stock option in optimal contracts,JEL.Working paper.
    Ortega,J.Porer in the firm and managerial career concerns.Journal of Economics and Management Strategy,Forthcoming,www.ssrn.com.
    Padilla,A.,Property economics of agency problems,JEL. Working paper.
    Peiperl,M.,Estrin,S.,1998.Managerial markets in transition in Central and Eastern Europe:A field study and implications.The International Journal of Human Resource Management 9(1),58-78.
    Puelz,R.,Snow,A.,1997.Optimal incentive contracting with ex ante and ex post moral hazards: theory and evidence.Mathematics and Ecomomics,20(3),pp264.
    Radner,R.,1981.Monitoring cooperative agreements in a repeated principal-agent relationship.Econometrica,49(5),1127-1148.
    
    Raviv,A.1985.Managerial compensation and the managerial labor market:an overview.Journal of Accounting and Economics,7,239-245.
    Rawski,T.,G.,1997.Chian's state enterprises reforms-an overseas view.China Ecomomic Review,8(1),89-98.
    Roland, G. 2001.Corporate Governance Systems and Restructuring:The Lessons from the Transition Experience, in: Annual Bank Conference on Development Economics 2000, World Bank, Washington DC, 331-352.
     Roland,G.,Sekkat,K.,2000.Managerial career concerns,privatization and restructuring in transition economies.European Economic Review,44,1857-1872.
    Rubinstein,A.,1981.An optinal conviction policy for offenses that may have been committed by accident.in Applied Game Theory,Brahms,Schotter and Schwodiauer(Eds.).Wein:Physica Verlag.
    Schumpeter,J.A.,1936.The theory of ecomomic development, Havard University Press,Cambridge,Mass.
    Schumpeter,J.A.,1943.Capitalism,socialism and democracy,Unwis University Books,London.
    Senbongi,S.,Harrington,J.E.,1995.Managerial reputation and the competitiveness of an industry.International Journal of Industrial Organization,13,95-110.
    Smith,L.,1992.Folk theorems in overlapping generations games.Games and Ecomomic Behavior 4,426-449.
    Sonnenfeld,J.A.,Peiperl,M.A.,Kotter,J.P.,1988.Strategic determinants of managerial labor markets:a systems view.Human Resource Management,27,369-388.
    Sridhar,S.,S., & Balachandran,B.,V,1999.Choice of an information structure versus a production environment:A managerial control perspective.Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, 18,193-227.
    Swank,O.,2000.Policy advice, secrecy, and reputational concerns.European Journal of Political Ecomomy,16,257-271.
    Tadelis,S.,2002.The market for reputations as an incentive mechanism.Journal of Political Economy,110,157-183.
    Tirole,J.,1988. The Theory of Industrial Organization. The MIT Press, Cambridge.
    Vancil,R.F.,1987.Passing the baton:managing the process of CEO succession.Boston:Harvard Business School Press.
    Vickers,J.,1986.Signalling in a model of monetary policy with incomplete information.Oxford Economic Papers,38,443-55.
    White,M.D.,2001.Managerial incentives and the decision to hire managers in markets with public and private firms.European Journal of Political Economy,17,877-896.
    
    Williamson,O.E.,1975.Markets and hierarchies:analysis and antitrust implications. New York:The Free Press.
    Williamson,O.E.,1979.Transaction cost economics:the governance of contractual relations,ournal of law and economics,22,233-261.
    Williamson O.E.,1986.The economics of governance:framework and implications.Langlois,12-26.
    Wynarczyk,P.,Watson,R.,Storey,D.,eta.,1993.Managerial Labour Markets in Small and Medium-sized Enterprises.London and New York:Routledge.267pp.
    Zabojnik,J.,2001.On the efficiency of markets for managers.Ecomomic Theory,18,701-710.
    Zanzi,A.,Arthur,M.B.,Shamir,B.,1991.The relationships between career concerns and political tactics in organizations.Journal of Organizational Behavior,12(3),219-233.
    Zemel, E., 1989. Small talk and cooperation: a note on bounded rationality. Journal of Economic Theory, 49(1), 1-9.
    Zwiebel,J.,1995.Corporate conservation and relative compensation,Journal of Political Economy 103,1-25.
    Zhou,M., Wang,X.,2000.Agency cost and the crisis of China's SOE.China Economic Review,11,297-317.
    Zhou,M.,Wang,X.,2000.Agency cost and the crisis of China's SOE.Chian Ecomomic Review,11 297-317.
    Zhou,X.,1999.Executive compensation and managerial incentives-a comparison between canada and the united states.Journal of Corporate Finance,5,277-301.
    Zhou,X.,2001.Understanding the determinants of managerial ownership and the link between ownership and performance:comment.Journal of Financial Economics, 62,559-571.
    白仲光,张维,陶华,公司管理层股权激励方案的成本研究,天津大学学报,
     2002,5:589-592。
    曹元坤,企业败德行为及伦理化趋势的经济学分析,当代财经,2002,12:58-61。
    程鹏,吴冲峰,李为冰,信贷风险控制中的显性与隐性激励机制分析,预测,2001,1:58-60。
    邓宏图,周立群,经理人市场:供求与交易关系研究--从交易的角度解析经理报酬(定价),江苏社会科学,2001,10:44-51。
    邓宏图,周立群,企业家流动研究:体制、企业家能力分布、人力资本与市场资源配置,经济评论,2001,6:14-17。
    丁宇澄,程伟庆,激励设计的一个模型分析,经济管理-新管理,2002,22:34-36。
    
    
    方世建,范育涛,经理人市场的逆向选择与国有企业重组,经济纵横,2001,3:23-24。
    费方域,代理问题,经理人市场和经营者激励-法马的企业理论评介,经济学动态,96,5:27-30。
    国家体改委,中国经济体制改革年鉴(1992),改革出版社,1992年版。
    洪功翔,政府任命国企经理人员的弊端及其治理,经济问题探索,2001,11:35-36。
    侯光明,甘仞初,隐蔽行为的约束机制研究,北京理工大学学报,1999,2:122-126。
    胡鞍钢,过勇,从垄断市场到竞争市场-深刻的社会变革,改革,2002,1: 17-28。
    黄培清,祝足,经理人市场与产品市场,上海交通大学学报,1998,12:124-127。
    黄群慧 李春琦,报酬、声誉与经营者长期化行为的激励,中国工业经济,2001,1:58-93。
    黄群慧,企业家激励约束与国有企业改革,北京,中国人民大学出版社,2000年版。
    黄群慧,张凡,国企经理:行为如何长期化,经济管理,1999,10:28-30。
    江伟,国有企业经理激励悖论,改革,2002,3:31-34。
    康均,经营者股票期权的理论基础与环境建设,经济管理-新管理,2001,10:50-54。
    李春琦,国外企业激励理论述评,经济学动态,2001,6:61-66。
    李军林,声誉、控制权与博弈均衡——一个关于国有企业经营绩效的博弈分析,上海财经大学学报,2002,8:38-45。
    李敏,张春法,经理人市场的建立运作,江苏评论,2000,12:16-20。
    李新春 丘海雄等,企业家精神、企业家能力与企业成长--“企业家理论与企业成长国际研讨会”综述,经济研究,2002,1:89-92。
    李新春,企业家过程与国有企业的准企业家模型,经济研究,2000,6:51-57。
    李新春,我国经理人市场发育成长的特征和问题,商业经济与管理,1997,4:13-17。
    李垣,孙恺,企业家激励机制对分配性行为的治理分析,管理科学学报,2000,9:82-88。
    连建辉,融资制度与企业家筛选机制,改革,2002,3:18-24。
    林毅夫等,中国的奇迹:发展战略与经济改革,上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,1994年版,128-132。
    刘兵,康凯,企业经营者的动态激励机制设计,系统工程学报,2001,2:50-54。
    
    
    刘兵,罗宜美,论企业管理的崭新阶段-声誉管理,中国软科学,2000,5:96-98。
    刘鸿雁,张维,孔峰,电力行业国企经营者激励数学模型研究,华北电力大学学报,2002,10:69-72。
    刘芍佳,李骥,超产权论与企业业绩,经济研究,1998,8。
    刘芍佳,李骥,什么是最理想企业-谈企业治理机制,企业管理,1998,8:28-29。
    刘卫江,动态不一致性及政府声誉与通货膨胀防范,现代财经,2002,1:35-38。
    刘迎军,王坤秀,我国企业经理股票期权制度的实践评析,上海金融,2001,1:14-15。
    彭建刚,博弈论与西方经济学的发展,经济学动态,1998,5:57-60。
    彭尚平,国有企业经营者选择中的识别风险及其规避,四川大学学报,2001,2:46-50。
    钱颖一,理解现代经济学,经济社会体制比较,2002,2。
    钱颖一,《企业理论》 载汤敏等编《现代经济学前沿专题》第一章,商务印书馆,1989年版,第5页。
    青木昌彦,钱颖一,转轨经济中的公司治理结构,北京,中国经济出版社,1995。
    邱显平,构建经理人市场体系的思考,江西社会科学,2001,1:33-34。
    芮明杰,赵春明,外部经理人市场对国有企业的影响及应有的对策,上海经济研究,2000,3:13-18。
    盛宇明,论公有制企业的政治性及双层代理结构,经济学动态,2002,1:43-47。
    泰勒尔(法Jeon,Tirole),产业组织理论(The Theory of Industrial Organization),北京:中国人民大学出版社,1997年8月版。
    石磊,经济市场化面临的制度瓶颈,10-15。
    汪贤裕,钟胜,李康,一类多期委托代理关系的模型研究,系统工程理论与实践,2001,11:167-123。
    王红领,委托人“政府化”与“非政府化”对企业治理结构的影响,经济研究,2000,7:56-62。
    王娟,杨凤林,基于现金流的现代资本结构研究的最新进展,外国经济与管理,2002,1:27-30。
    王珺,双重博弈中的激励与行为——对转轨时期国有企业经理激励不足的一种新解释,经济研究,2001,8:71-78。
    王云平,关于建立经理人市场之探讨,当代财经,1997,5:61-62。
    翁君奕,企业信誉体系的动态博弈分析,经济学家,1996,1:76-82。
    
    
    吴宏洛,实施期权激励亟待解决的几个问题,福建师范大学学报(哲社版),2001,4:9-13。
    吴敬琏,大中型企业改革:建立现代企业制度,天津人民出版社,1993年版, 145-157。
    吴延兵,人力资源管理中的道德风险与激励机制设计,贵州财经学院学报,2002,3:37-40。
    肖艳,石磊,隐性激励与国有企业经营者激励机制重构,当代财经,2002,3:64-67。
    谢德仁,企业剩余索取权:分享安排与剩余计量,上海三联出版社,2001年。
    徐强,产品市场化与要素市场化不同步的负面影响透析,求是学刊,2002,5:69-72。
    严建苗,万建军,国有企业间经理人市场的声誉机制分析,数量经济技术经济研究,2002,3:36-39。
    杨继国,“进入权”-企业理论发展前沿,经济学动态,2001,10:73-77。
    杨其静,合同与企业理论前沿综述,经济研究,2002,1:80-88。
    杨伟文,刘梦雨,经理人市场的隐性激励约束效应分析及对策,中南工业大学学报(社科版),2001,12:309-312。
    叶建亮,经济学视野里的信用:一个文献回顾,2002,工作稿,www.wxhf.net。
    易宪容,激励过度是贪心,企业管理,2002,5:112-113。
    约瑟夫·熊彼特(美),《经济发展理论——对于利润、资本、信贷、利息和经济周期的考察》,北京:商务印书馆,1990年版。
    张春霖,国家融资与国有企业的领导班子问题,经济社会体制比较,1997,3。
    张进,李文,王海燕,公司股权结构、经理人市场与管理层激励,东南大学学报(哲社版),2001,2:62-64。
    张君立,职业经理人市场的建立和运行机制,现代企业管理,2002,5:30-32。
    张维迎,博奕论与信息经济学[M],北京,上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,1996。
    张维迎,企业的企业家---契约理论,上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,1995年9月第1版,19-25。
    张维迎,产权安排与企业内部的权利斗争,经济研究,2000,6。
    张维迎,法律制度的信誉基础,经济研究.2002,1:3-13。
    张维迎,企业理论与中国企业改革,北京大学出版社,1999。
    郑红亮,公司治理理论与中国国有企业改革,经济研究,1998,10:20-27。
    郑志刚,声誉制度理论及其实践评述,经济学动态,2002,5:73-77。
    中国企业家调查系统,管理世界,1993-2003各期。又见www.ceoinchina.com。
    周立群,陈晓东,我国企业经营者的演变轨迹与职业企业家队伍的培育,南开学报,2000,3:10-15。
    
    周立群,韩亮,实施股票期权有待探讨的几个问题,中国工业经济,2000,6:55-58。
    周其仁,公司制企业的性质,经济研究,2000,11。
    周其仁,控制权回报和企业家控制的企业,经济研究,1997,5。
    周其仁,市场里的企业:一个人力资本与非人力资本的特别合约,经济研究,1996,1:71-80。

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700