银行特许权价值和稳健性的关系研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
银行特许权价值是国家通过对银行业的市场准入、利率定价等方面设置的限制,为银行创造了垄断竞争市场,银行在这种垄断竞争的市场上通过自身的经营而获取的超额垄断利润的净现值。2006年底《中华人民共和国外资银行管理条例》的推出,标志着中国银行业已进入全面开放的新时期。外资银行的进入以后与国内银行展开全面竞争,它们通过“摘樱桃”效应吸引优质客户,导致国内银行特许权价值的降低,不利于银行体系稳健性。与国外的商业银行监管政策不同的是,中国的商业银行长期处于国家的隐性保护之下,这种保护不可避免地会增加银行的“逆向选择”和“道德风险”激励,导致商业银行长期被不良资产问题所困扰。如果忽视了强化稳健经营的动机,那么银行的竞争力与银行体系的安全性,乃至整个国家的金融系统的安全将受到严重挑战。因此,在当前的形势下对比中美两国商业银行特许权价值自律效应的不同,特别是吸取国外商业银行的经营过程中的教训,对于提高银行特许权价值,增加银行稳健性具有重大的理论和现实意义。
     围绕这个主题,根据研究目的以及独特的研究视角,本文将以特许权价值和银行稳健性的关系为主线,重点研究以下主要内容:
     (一)特许权价值和银行稳健性的度量。银行特许权价值一般包含两部分内容:一部分是政府的特许所获得市场相关的垄断收益;另一部分是由于银行自己的经营效率所获得的收益。托宾Q值不仅包含了因自身优势而导致的竞争优势租金,而且还包含了政府特许而产生的租金,可以用来度量特许权价值。影响银行稳健性的因素很多,既有制度与体制因素,又有经营环境因素,同时还有银行客户的心理与行为因素,因此衡量银行稳健性的指标应该全面反映这些因素。但是考虑指标的可得性和可行性,以及风险监管是我国银行业稳健经营的核心问题,本文从稳定性指标中选取贷款损失准备金率、不良贷款率,从健康类指标中选取净资产收益率作为衡量银行稳健性的指标。
     (二)特许权价值和银行稳健性关系的理论基础及形成机理分析。在对金融约束理论、租金激励理论、内生激励的监管理论分析的基础上,从不同角度阐述了特许权价值的自律效应的原理。同时还介绍了苑素静的“价值—危机’模型,Keeley的状态偏好模型和Park两阶段模型的内容。然后对Park两阶段模型进行改进,推导特许权价值和银行稳健性的多阶段模型,得出特许权价值长期能够促进银行稳健经营的结论。
     (三)中美商业银行特许权价值与稳健性的实证检验。通过运用14家中国上市银行2000—2009年的以及美国44家上市银行2003—2009年的面板数据,以贷款损失准备金比率、不良贷款率、净资产收益率来衡量的银行稳健性为被解释变量,用基于托宾Q值计算各上市银行的特许权价值及资产规模、财务杠杆、资本杠杆等为解释变量,对中国上市银行以政府监管、隐性保险为虚拟变量,构建多元回归模型进行实证分析,得出以下结论:中美两国商业银行特许权价值的自律作用都存在,特许权价值能够促进银行的稳健经营;中美两国的银行规模与银行稳健性存在正相关关系;中国的隐性保险制度削弱了特许权价值对银行稳健性的影响;美国商业银行比较善于利用资本杠杆和经营杠杆,提高银行的特许权价值。
     (四)基于特许权价值影响因素的银行稳健性预警。特许权价值和银行稳健性之间存在着正相关关系,银行的特许权价值越高,银行的稳健性越好。因此,根据对银行特许权价值的影响因素的分析,从市场相关硬因素和银行自身相关的软因素选取16个指标,构建商业银行稳健性评价指标体系,并基于改进BP神经网络建立商业银行稳健性预警模式。选取美国商业银行2003—2009年的数据(2003-2007年的指标数据,2009年银行稳健性的状态)作为训练样本进行模拟,然后用中国商业银行2005—2009年的数据作为检验样本进行检验,发现中国商业银行整体的稳健性较好。但是由于中国商业银行受到国家“隐性保险”照顾,稳健性较好是国家帮助的结果,而要真正做到稳健经营,必须依靠自身的经营。因此中国商业银行有必要采取措施,提高特许权价值,增加银行稳健性。
     (五)提高特许权价值,增加我国商业银行稳健性的对策建议。银行要提高自身的特许权价值,增加银行稳健性,既要注重“银行相关部分”(银行核心竞争力)各个因素的提高,又要注重“市场相关部分”(政府对银行设置的监管政策)各个因素的提高。因此应该从提升商业银行的经营效率;拓展商业银行业务范围;完善商业银行内控制度等方面提高银行的核心竞争力。还可以通过实行“渐进式”的金融自由化政策;加强对银行的有效监管;建立显性保险制度;建立以特许权价值为核心的银行稳健性预警机制来完善现有的监管制度。
     在前人研究的基础上,本文在以下几个方面进行了创新:
     (1)在Park两阶段模型基础上进行改进,推导特许权价值和银行稳健性的多阶段模型,得出特许权价值长期能够促进银行稳健经营的结论。
     (2)构建中国银行特许权价值和银行稳健性的计量经济模型,然后用2000-2009年14个中国上市商业银行的数据进行实证分析,验证特许权价值和银行稳健性的相关关系。
     (3)构建美国银行特许权价值和银行稳健性的计量经济模型,用2003-2009年44家美国商业银行的数据进行实证分析,并把结果跟中国商业银行进行比较,发现两国商业银行内部控制和外部监管的不同,为提高中国商业银行特许权价值,增加银行稳健性提供对策建议。
     (4)以特许权价值的影响因素作为预警指标,构建基于改进BP神经网络的银行稳健性预警模式。
     本文最终希望达到一个目的:通过对影响银行特许权价值的因素的分析和思考,采取各种措施提高银行特许权价值以抑制其风险动机,实现银行的稳健经营,促进我国银行业的健康规范发展,保护储户的切身利益,有效配置银行的各类资源,提高银行的经营效率,积极应对金融全球化和次贷危机的对于银行业的影响。
The state creates a monopolistic competition market by limiting banking market access and interest rate price, net present value of excess monopoly profits that the bank obtains through its own operations from such a competitive market is franchise value. Franchise value generally consists of two parts:one is market-related revenue that obtains from the government license; the other part is the revenue that obtains from their own business efficiency. From the meaning of franchise value we can see: the origin of franchise value is from external environment and internal mechanisms. Franchise value is the excess return of bank's advantages, the specific advantages include monopoly advantages, liabilities of business advantage, information advantage, transaction cost advantage and reputation advantages.
     By the end of 2006, "Regulations of foreign banks of the People's Republic of China" had been published, which means China's banking industry has entered a new opening up period. Foreign banks compete with domestic banks, they attract quality customers by "cherry effect", which resulted in lower bank franchise value, is not conducive to the stability of the banking system. Different from foreign commercial banks, in Chinese commercial banks are under long hidden the protection of the country, such protection inevitably would increase the banks' "adverse selection" and "moral hazard", which would result in non-performing loans, so the bank's stability is relatively poor. If we neglect to strengthen the motive of the stability operation, then the competitiveness of the banks, the security of the banks'and the whole finance system will be seriously challenged. Therefore, in the current situation, comparing franchise value self-regulation effect of Sino-US commercial bank is important to increase franchise value and increase the stability of the banks.
     On this theme, based on the purpose and a unique research perspective, this article will take franchise value and bank relationships as the main line, focus on the following main contents:
     (1) The measure of franchise value and bank stability. Franchise value generally consists of two parts:one is market-related revenue that obtains from the government license; the other part is the revenue that obtains from their own business efficiency. Tobin Q value includes the two parts, so it can be used to measure the franchise value. There are many factors affecting the stability of banks, such as system and institutional factors, the business environment factors, banking customers the psychological and behavioral factors, the measure of bank stability should fully reflect these factors. However, given the available and feasibility of the index, this article selects LRR, NPL and ROE to measure the bank stability.
     (2) The foundation theory of the self-regulation effect of franchise value. Basing on financial constraints theory, rent incentive theory and endogenous incentives supervision theory, this part introduces the theory of the self-regulation effect from different point of view, finds that the franchise value can lead the bank to control risks and encourage banks'stability operation. This part also introduces "value-the crisis" model, Park's two-stage model and Keeley's preference model. And then the article derive multi-stage model of franchise value and the bank stability, found that: franchise value can contribute to the long-term stable operation of banks
     (3) The Sino-US comparative analysis of the relationship between franchise value and bank stability. we construct the econometric model of franchise value and bank stability, use uses the 14 listed banks'unbalanced panel data from 2000 to 2009 and 44 listed banks panel data from 2003 to 2009 to test econometric model. Found that:commercial banks in China and the U.S. all have self-regulatory effect of franchise value; Sino-US bank size and banking stability are positively correlated; China's implicit insurance system weakened the franchise value effect of bank stability; U.S. commercial banks make better use of capital leverage and operating leverage increasing franchise value of banks.
     (4) Bank stability correcting mechanism based on the factors of franchise value. There is a positive correlation between franchise value and bank stability, the bank's franchise value higher, the better the stability of banks. Therefore, based on the affective factors of franchise value, we select 16 indexes from the market factors and the bank factors, to construct stability of the banks evaluation index system, and construct commercial banks early warning mechanism by BP neural network. And then select the data of U.S. commercial banks 2003-2009 as training samples to simulate, use commercial bank of China data from 2005-2009 as the test samples, and discovers that the stability of China's commercial banks is worse.
     (5) Suggestions of enhancing the franchise value and increase the stability of China's commercial banks. If banks want to improve their own franchise value, increase the stability of the banks, that is, not only to pay attention to "the relevant part of the bank" (Bank of core competencies), but also pay attention to "the relevant parts of the market" (the government's supervision of banks set policy). So we could increase the core competitiveness of the banks, appropriate to introduce competition mechanism to prevent excessive monopoly, introduce explicit insurance system to increase bank franchise value and enhance the stability of the banks.
     Based on previous research, this paper innovates in the following aspects:
     (1) Based on park's model, the article derive multi-stage model of franchise value and the bank stability, found that:franchise value can contribute to the long-term stable operation of banks
     (2) This article constructs the econometric of model franchise value and bank stability, then use the data of Chinese Commercial Bank from 2000-2009 to test the econometric of model, verify the positive correlation of franchise value and bank stability.
     (3) And then this article use the data of U.S. Commercial Bank from 2003-2009 to test the econometric of model, and the results were compared with commercial banks in China, found that internal control and external regulation is different from each other, which provide countermeasures to enhance the franchise value of Chinese commercial banks and increase the stability of the banks.
     (4) This article constructs improved BP neural network of early warning models of bank stability based on the franchise value of factors.
     The propose of this article is:based on the influence factors of bank franchise value analysis and reflection, take various measures to enhance the franchise value of banks in order to achieve the banking stability, and promote the health development of Chinese banking, and protect the vital interests of depositors, effectively allocate the resources of banks, improve operational efficiency of banks, actively respond to the influence of financial globalization and sub-debt crisis.
引文
[1]Aki Vehtari,Jouko Lampinen. Bayesian MLP neural networks for image analysis neural networks for image analysis. Patern Recognition Leters,2000,(21):1183-1191
    [2]Allen, F,and D. Gale,2004, Financial Intermediaries and Markets[J]. Econometrica 72: 1023-1061
    [3]Allen, F., and D. Gale,2000a, Comparing Financial Systems [J]. MTT Press, Cambridge
    [4]Allen, F., and D. Gale,2000b, Financial Contagion [J]. Journal of Poetical Economy 108: 1-33
    [5]Allen, Franklin, and Douglas Gale.2004, Competition and financial stability[J]. Journal of Money. Credit and Banking,36(3):453-480
    [6]Asli Demirg-Kunt & Enrica Detragiache,1998, Financial Liberalization and Financial Fragility[J].The world Bank:Policy Research Working Paper No.1917, May
    [7]Barth, J., G. Caprio and R, Levine,2007. Bank Regulation and Supervision (updated dataset)[J]. WB working paper series:2588
    [8]Beck, T, Demirguc-Kunt, A, and R Levine.2005, Bank concentration and fragility:Impact and mechanics[A]. in Mark Carey, and Rene Stulz(Eds.).
    [9]Beck, T., A. Demirguc-Kunt and R. Levine,2006. Bank concentration, competition, and crises:first results, Journal of Banking and Finance 30:1581-1603
    [10]Beck, T., Demirguc-Kunt, A., and R. Levine,2003, Bank Concentration and Crises, Working Paper, University of Minnesota, presented at the Conference on Bank Concentration and Competition at the World Bank
    [11]Benston G J.1983, Federal Regulation of Banking. Journal of Bank Research, (13):216-244
    [12]Berger, A.N.,1995, The Relationship Between Capital and Earnings in Banking, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,27:432-56
    [13]Berger, A.N., A. Demirguc-Kunt, R. Levine and J. Haubrich,2004, Bank concentration and competition:An evolution in the making, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 36: 433-451
    [14]Berger, A.N., R. De Young, M.J. Flannery, D. Lee, and O. Oztekin,2008, How do large banking organizations manage their capital ratios?, Federal Reserve working paper
    [15]Berger, Allen N.,1994, The Relationship Between Capital and Earnings in Banking, Finance a Economics Discussion Series Paper No.94-2, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, February
    [16]Boot, A.W.A., and A.V. Thakor,2000, Can Relationship Banking Survive Competition, Journal of Finance LV:679-713
    [17]Boyd, J. and G. De Nicolo,2005, The Theory of Bank Risk Taking Revisited, Journal of Finance 60:1329-1343
    [18]Boyd, J. G. De Nicolo, and A.M. Jalal,2006, Bank risk taking and competition revisited: New Theory and Evidence, IMF Working paper, WP/06/297
    [19]Boyd, J.H., and De Nicolo, G,2003, Bank Risk-taking and Competition Revisited, Working Paper:03-114, IMF
    [20]Boyd, J.H., De Nicolo, G., and B.D. Smith,2004, Crises in Competitive versus Monopolistic Banking System, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 36:487-506
    [21]Brewer III E,Mondschean T S,Strahan P E. The Role of Monitoring in Reducing the Moral Hazard Problem Associated With Government Guarantees:Evidence from the Life Insurance Industry. Journal of Risk and Insurance,1997:301-322
    [22]Buser S, A Chen, E Kane.1981, Federal Deposit Insurance, Regulatory Policy and Optimal Bank Capital. Journal of Finance,(36):51-60
    [23]Cao, M., and Shi, S.2000. Screening, Bidding, and the Loan Market Tightness, European Finance Review 5:34-57
    [24]Caprio and Summers,1993, The Relationship Between Capital and Earnings in Banking,Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 27:432-456
    [25]Carletti, E. and P. Hartmann,2003, Competition and Financial Stability:What's Special about Banking? In Monetary History, Exchange Rates and Financial Markets:Essays in Honour of Charles Goodhart, Vol.2, edited by P. Mizen, Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar
    [26]Carlson, M, and K Mitchener.2005, Branch banking, bank competition and financial stability[R]. Working Paper, Department of Economics, Santa Clara University
    [27]Cetorelli, N, and P. Peretto,2000, Oligopoly Banking and Capital Accumulation, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago Working Paper No.12
    [28]Cetorelli, N., and M. Gambera,2001, Banking Market Structure, Financial Dependence and Growth:International Evidence from Industry Data, The Journal of Finance 56:617-48
    [29]Chen Zhiwu,Xiong Peng. The Illiquidity Discount in China. International Center for Financial Research, Yale University,2002
    [30]Claessens, S. and L. Laeven,2004, What Drives Bank Competition? Some International Evidence, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking 36:563-583
    [31]Cordella, T.,and E.L. Yeyati,2002, Financial Opening, Deposit Insurance, and Risk in a Model of Banking Competition, European Economic Review 46:471-85
    [32]Corton.GBank Suspension of Convertibility. Journal of Monetary Economics.1995(1):77-93
    [33]Dahl, Drew and Ronald E. Shrieves,1990, The Impact of Regulation on Bank Equity Infusions, Journal of Banking and Finance,15, December:1209-1228
    [34]Daniel C Hardy.2006, Regulatory capture in banking[R].IMF Working Paper 06/34
    [35]David J.C.,MacKay. Bayesian neural networks and density networks. Nuclear Instruments and Methodsin Physics Research,1995,(354):73-80
    [36]De Nicolo, A., et al.,2003, Bank Consolidation, Conglomeration and Internationalization: Trends and Implications for Financial Risk, Working Paper:03-158, IMF
    [37]De Nicolo, G.,2000, Size, Charter Value and Risk in banking:An International Perspective, Board of Governors International Finance Discussion Paper:689
    [38]De Nicolo, Gianni and Elena Loukoianova,2006, Bank Ownership, Market Structure, and Risk, Unpublished Working Paper, International Monetary Fund, Washington, D.C
    [39]Demsetz, R., M.R. Saidenberg, and P.E. Strahan.1996, Banks with something to lose:The disciplinary role of franchise value. Federal Reserve Bank of New York Economic Policy Review. V2, no.2. (October):1-14
    [40]Diamond and Rajan,1966 and 1968, Present models that formalize a bank's franchise value and its liquidity and fragility implications, Journal of Economics and Business Vol.76: 542-593
    [41]Diamond, D.,1984, Financial Intermediation and Delegated Monitoring, Review of Economic Studies 51:393414
    [42]Diamond.Douglas.W and Philip.H.Dybvig. "Bankr uns, deposit insurance. and liquidity". Journal Political Economy.1983.(3):1-19
    [43]Djankov, S., McLiesh, C. A. Shleifer,2007, Private Credit in 129 Countries, Journal of Financial Economics 84:299-329
    [44]Djankov, S., R. La Porta, F. Lopez-de-Silanes and A. Shleifer,2003, Courts, Quarterly Journal of Economics:453-517
    [45]Douglass North.A Framework for Analyzing Economic Organization in History.Journal of Economic History,1971,(3):123-134
    [46]Dowd.K. Re-examining the Case for Government Deposit Insurance. Southern Economic Journal.1992(8):43-56
    [47]Edward I. Aliman,1968, Financial Ratios, Discriminant Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy, Journal of Finance,23(9):589-609
    [48]EtsuroHonda, Finnacial deregulation in Japan.Japan and World Economy 2003, (15):135-140
    [49]Fisher K P, Gueyie J P.2001, Charter value and Commercial Banks' Risk-taking in the NAFTA Countries. The International Journal of Finance, (13):2027-2044
    [50]Fisher. Irving, "The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depressions" Econometrical (October). 1933:337-357
    [51]Frame, W.S., and L.J. White,2007, Charter value, risk-taking incentives, and emerging competition for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking (02):83-103
    [52]Furlong F T,M C Keeley. Bank capital regulation and risk taking:A note. Journal of Banking and Finance,1989,(13):883-891
    [53]Furlong F, S Kwan.2005, Market-to-Book, Charter Value and Bank Risk-taking—A Recent Perspective. Paper presented at the Basel Committee Research Task Force Conference on Banking and Financial Stability at the Oesterreichische National bank, Vienna
    [54]Furlong F,S Kwan.2006, Sources of Bank Charter Value. Working paper, Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco
    [55]Galloway Tina M, Winson B Lee, Dianne M Roden.1997, Banks'Changing Incentives and Opportunities for Risk Taking. Journal of Banking and Finance, (21):509-527
    [56]Gary Gorton, Andrew Winton.1995, Bank Capital Regulation in General Equilibrium, NBER Working Paper:5244
    [57]Grossman(1990) and Stulz,1991, Testing For Market Discipline In The American Banking Industry, Economics Working Paper, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency
    [58]Guttenlay J, Herring R.1983, The Insolvency of Financial Institutions:Assessment and Regulatory Disposition. In Crises in the economic and financial structure, Edited by Paul Wachtel, Lexington:Lexington Books:99-126
    [59]Guttentag.Herring.D. Some Reflections on Financial Fragility in Banking and Finance. Journal of Banking and Insurance.1984(2):31-47
    [60]Haejin Ha, Michael K. Stenstrom. Identification of land use with water quality data in storm water using a neural network. Water Research,2003, (37):4222-4233
    [61]Hall, A. R.2005. Generalized Method of Moments. Oxford University Press
    [62]Hansen, L.1982. Large sample properties of generalized method of moments estimators. Econometrica,50:1029-1054
    [63]Harold Demsetz. Toword a Theory of Property Rights. American EconomicReview, 1967,(3):31-45
    [64]Hellman, J S, and D Kaufmann.2001, Confronting the challenge of state capture in transition economies[J]. Finance & Development,38 (3):34
    [65]Hellman, T., Murdock, K., and J. Stiglitz,2000, Liberalization, Moral Hazard in Banking, and Prudential Regulation:Are Capital Requirement Enough? American Economic Review 90:147-165
    [66]Hellmann Thomas, Murdock Kevin, Stiglitz Joseph. Financial Restraint:Toward a New Paradigm. In Masahiko Aoki, Hyung-KiKim, Masahiro Okuno-Fujiwara. The Role of Government in East Asian Economic Development:Comparative Institutional Analysis. New York:Oxford University Press.1996
    [67]Hellmann, K. Murdock & J.E. Stiglitz,1994, "Addressing Moral Hazard in Banking: Deposit Rate Controls VS. Capital Requirements",unpublished manuscript
    [68]Hellmann, T.F., K. Murdock and J. Stiglitz,2000, Liberalization, moral hazard in banking and prudential regulation:are capital requirements enough?, American Economic Review, 90:147-165
    [69]Hughes, Joseph P., William Lang, Lorretta J.1994, Mester and Choon-Geol Moon, Recoverin Technologies That Account for Generalized Managerial Preferences:An Application to Non-Risk-Neutral Banks, Department of Economics, Rutgers University
    [70]Jacklin.C. and Bhattacharya.S. Distinguishing Panics and Information-based Bankrupts: Welfare and Political Implication. Journal of Political Economy.1996(8):68-92
    [71]Jacques, Kevin T. and Peter J. Nigro,1995, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Economic and Policy Analysis Division, Washington, DC
    [72]James T Lindley, James R Marchand, Stewart Mounts JR. Aligning Charter Value To Default Risk:Lending Rights And the Pricing of Financial Intermediation,2004
    [73]Jensen Michael, William Meckling. The Theory of The Firm:Managerial Begavior, Agency Costand Ownership Structure. Journal of Financial Economics,1976,(12):305-360
    [74]Jensen, M., and W. Meckeng,1976, "Theory of the Finn:Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs and Ownership Structure," Journal of Financial Economics 3:305-60
    [75]Jensen, Michael,1985, Agency Costs of Free Cash Flow, Corporate Finance, and Takeovers, American Economic Review, May
    [76]Jimenez, G., J. Lopez and J. Saurina,2007, How does competition impact bank risk taking?, working paper, Banco de Espana
    [77]Jondrow, James, C.A. Knox Lovell, I. S. Materov and Peter Schmidt,1982, On Estimation of Technical Inefficiency In The Stochastic Frontier Production Function Model, Journal of Econometrics 19:233-238
    [78]Keeley, M C.1990, Deposit insurance, risk, and market power in banking[J]. American Economic Review,80(5):1183-1200
    [79]Keeley,1990, Transformation of Technology makes Declining Banking Franchise Values, We are Helpless, NBER working paper 7340:309-343
    [80]Kentaro Iwatsubo,2007, Bank capital shocks and portfolio risk:Evidence from Japan. Japan and the World Economy,19:166-186
    [81]Klaus Schaeck, Martin Cihak, and Simon Wolfe.2006, Are more competitive banking systems more stable? [R]. IMF Working Paper 06/143
    [82]Kregel J.A. "Margins of Safety and Weight of the Argument in Generating Financial Fragility".1997(3):79-83
    [83]Levine,R. Financial development and economic growth:Views and agenda, Journal of Economic Literature; Jun 1999:688-726
    [84]Linderberg E B,Ross S A. Tobin's Q Ratio and Industrial Organisation.Journal of Business,1981,(54):1-32
    [85]M.N.Hajmeer,LA. Basheer. A Bayesian-neural network approach for probabilistic modeling of bacterial growth/no-growth interface. International Journal of Food Microbiology,2003, (82):233-243
    [86]MacKayD J.C. Bayesian interpolation. Neural Computation,1992,4(3):415-447
    [87]MakcKayD J.C.A.Practical Bayesian Framework for Backprop Networks. Neural Computation,1992,4(3):448-472
    [88]Man Leung Wong, Shing Yan Lee,Kwong Sak Leung. Data mining of Bayesian networks using coperative coevolution. Decision Support Systems,2004, (8):451-472
    [89]Marcus, A.J.,1984, Deregulation and bank financial policy, Journal of Banking and Finance[J].8:557-565
    [90]Martinez-Miera, D. and R. Repullo,2007, Does competition reduce the risk of bank failure? Unpublished manuscript, CEMFI
    [91]Matutes, Carnert, and Xavier Vives.2000, Imperfect competition, risk taking and regulation in banking [J]. European Economic Review(40):1-34
    [92]Merton R C.An analytic derivation of the cost of deposit insurance and loan guarantees. Journal of Banking and Finance,1977,(1):3-11
    [93]Minsky and Reinhart," The Twin Crises:The Causes of Banking and Balance of Payments Problems", International Finance Discussion Paper.1996:544
    [94]Minsky Hyman.The Financial Fragiliy Hypothesis Capitalist Process and the Behavior of the Economy in Financial Crises. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.1982:32-58
    [95]Mishkin, Frederic.1999, Financial Consolidation; Dangers and Opportunities [J]. Journal of Banking and Finance,23:675-691
    [96]Mitchener, Kris.2004, Bank supervision, regulation, and instability during the Great Depression[R]. NBER Working Paper 10475
    [97]Murdock and Stilglitz,1994, KeyCorp's Response to the U.S. Banking Agencies' Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking Regarding New Risk-Based Bank Capital Rules, RUA working paper
    [98]Olivier De Jonghe, Rudi Vander Vennet,2008, Competition versus efficiency:What drives franchise values in European banking? Journal of Banking & Finance,32:1820-1835
    [99]Padoa-Schioppa, T.,2001, Bank Competition:A Changing Paradigm, European Finance Review 5:13-20
    [100]Pamela K. Coats and L. Franklin Fant. A Neural Network Approach to Forecasting Financial Distress. The Journal of Business Forecasting,1991-1992 winter:253-276
    [101]Park S. Risk-taking behavior of banks under regulation. Journal of Banking and Finance,1997,(2):491-507
    [102]Pemtti, Enriro C and Javier Suarez 2002, Last bank standing, What do I gain if you fail? [J]. European Economic Review,46(9):1599-1622
    [103]Peteraen, M., and R.G. Rajah.1995. The Effect of Credit Market Competition on Lending Relationships. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 110:407-43
    [104]Petersen and Rajan,1973, Money and Capital in Economic Development, Washington:Brookings Institution
    [105]R.Orre,A.Lansner, A.Bate, M.Lindquist. Bayesian Neural networks with confidence estimations Applied to data mining. Computational Statistics & Data Analysis,2000, (34): 473-493
    [106]Rafael Repullo.2002, Capital Requirements, Market Power and Risk-taking in a Dynamic Model of Bank Behaviour, Paper provided by C.E.P.R. Discussion Papers in its series CEPR Discussion Papers with number 3721
    [107]Repullo, R,2003, Capital Requirements, Market Power, and Risk-taking in Banking, Discussion Paper No.3721, CEPR
    [108]Rhoades, S., and R. Rutz,1982, Market Power and Firm Risk, Journal of Monetary Economics 9:73-85
    [109]Saez, L., and X. Shi,2004, Controlling Risk in Payment Systems, Journal of Financial Services Research 25:5-23
    [110]Salas, V., and J. Saurina,2003, Deregulation, Market Power and Risk Behavior in Spanish Banks, European Economic Review 47:1061-75
    [111]Saunders A, Wilson B.1994, Bank capital structure:An analysis of the charter value hypothesis. Working paper, New-York University, Salomon Center (14)
    [112]Saunders A, Wilson B.(1997),Bank capital and bank structure:A comparative analysis of the US,UK and Canada",Working paper, New-York University, Salomon Center.
    [113]Schaeck, K, M. Cihak, and S. Wolfe,2006, Are More Competitive Banking Systems More Stable?, Unpublished Working Paper No.143, International Monetary Fund, Washington, D.C
    [114]Shaffer, S.2004, Comments on What Drives Bank Competition:Some International Evidence:1792-1802
    [115]Shaffer, S.,1998, The Winner's Curse in Banking, Journal of Financial Intermediation 7: 359-392
    [116]Smirlock M,T Gilligan,W Marshall. Tobin's q and the Structure Performance Relationship. American Economic Review,1984, (74):1051-1060
    [117]Stephanie Stolz.2005, The Disciplining Effect of Charter Value on Risk-taking:Evidence for the EU. http://www.finprop.de/finprop_papers.htm
    [118]Steven R. Neisbrod, Howard Lee, and Liliana Rojas-Suarez,1992, Bank Risk and the Declining Franchise Value of the Banking Systems in the United States and Japan, NBER working paper 8432:673-721
    [119]Suarez J.Closure rules market power and risk-taking in a dynamic model of bank behaviour. London:London school of economics,1994:123-172
    [120]T.Veblan "Banking System Failures in Developing and Transition Countries:Diagnosis and Prediction" Working Paper No.39.Basle:Bank for International Settlements. January 1997
    [121]Terry J Ward. An Empirical Study of the Incremental Predictive Ability if Beaver's Naive Operating Flow Measure Using Four-State Ordinal Models of Financial Distress. Journal of Business Finance&Accounting,1994,21(4):152-168
    [122]Thorsten Beck. Bank Concentration and Fragility:Impact and Meehanies.2004,9
    [123]Yafeh, Y., and O. Yoaha,2001, Industrial Organization of Financial System and Strategic Use of Relationship Banking, European Finance Review 6:63-78
    [124]Yoshifusa Ito,Cidambi Srinivasan.Bayesian decision theory on three-layer neural net works. Neuro computing,2005, (63):209-228
    [125]巴曙松,刘清涛,贾蓓.基于资本充足率的银行风险监管[J].武汉金融,2004,(11):4-7
    [126]曹万林.我国股份制商业银行治理结构对银行绩效影响的实证分析[J].黑龙江对外经贸,2006,(3):84-86
    [127]查理士·恩诺克,约翰·格林.银行业的稳健与货币政策——全球经济中的一些问题及经验教训[M].北京:中国金融出版社,1999
    [128]陈华,伍志文.银行体系脆弱性:理论及基于中国的实证分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2004,(9):120-135
    [129]陈志武,熊鹏.在中国的流动性折扣[Z].国际金融研究中心,耶鲁大学,2002
    [130]戴琼.国有商业银行特许权价值的经济学分析[D].湖南大学硕士论文
    [131]丁敏.中国银行体系脆弱性实证研究及预警系统的建立[D].西南财经大学硕士论文
    [132]樊洁心.新的银行监管框架与银行创新发展[J].中山大学学报论丛,2004,(6):212-218
    [133]范洪波.国有商业银行体系脆弱性的实证分析和政策建议[J].金融论坛,2004,(7):3-9
    [134]高新宇.中国银行体系脆弱性分析[D].东北财经大学硕士论文
    [135]高新宇.银行体系脆弱性理论及中国的实证研究[D].东北财经大学博士论文
    [136]龚峰.试论银行业稳健经营指标体系的构建及现实意义[J].金融论坛,2003,(4):48-53
    [137]谷建斌,王星,张潜.对当前形势下商业银行稳健经营原则的再认识研究[J].河北金融2009,(10):39-40
    [138]韩俊.银行体系稳定性研究[M].北京:中国金融出版社,2000:36-74
    [139]韩立岩,李伟.外资银行进入与中国商业银行特许权价值[J].世界经济,2008,(10):22-32
    [140]韩立岩、李燕平.中国上市银行特许权价值与风险行为[J].金融研究,2006,(12):82-91
    [141]何光辉.民营化,国有化和中国国有银行改革[J].财贸经济,2005,(12):3-9
    [142]何韧.银行业市场结构、效率和绩效的相关性研究[J].财经研究,2005,(12),29-40
    [143]贺春临.我国银行业的市场结构与绩效研究[J].经济评论,2004,(6):96-102
    [144]贺云龙,谭剑伟.国有商业银行特许权价值与证券投资风险[J].湖南大学学报(社会科学版),2006,(11):81-84
    [145]胡祖六.东亚的银行体系与金融危机[J].国际经济评论,1998,(3):19-26
    [146]华坚,陈洁.特许权价值对我国问题银行关闭策略的影响分析[J].集团经济研究,2005,(12):108-109
    [147]华坚.多视角的银行关闭策略研究[D].河海大学商学院,2005:54-69
    [148]黄海清.商业银行价值研究——基于制度、技术视角的考察[D].西南财经大学,2003:36-40
    [149]黄金老.金融自由化与金融脆弱性[M].中国城市经济出版社,2001
    [150]贾润军.利率自由化与金融稳定:基于特许权价值视角的分析[J].农村金融研究,2006,(12):40-42
    [151]金成晓,纪明辉.我国商业银行业公司治理结构与经营绩效的实证研究[J].税务与经济,2006,(4):1-6
    [152]卡尔—约翰.林捷瑞恩.银行稳健经营与宏观经济政策[M].北京:中国金融出版社,1997
    [153]拉丰,梯若尔.政府采购与规制中的激励理论[M].石磊,王永钦泽.上海:上海三联书店,2004
    [154]黎志成,王明华.银行稳定的成本与控制问题研究[J].河南金融管理干部学院学报,2005,(5):49-53
    [155]李强.国际资本流动背景下我国银行体系稳定性研究[D].新疆财经大学硕士论文
    [156]李文宏.国有商业银行税收负担与资本充足率[J].国际金融研究,2003,(12):48-52
    [157]李兴发.影响不良贷款率下降的因素分析[J].海南金融,2005,(12):16-19
    [158]李妍娜.中国的商业银行与EVA管理[J].价值工程,2005,(12):119-121
    [159]李艳,张涤新.中国商业银行特许权价值:基于面板数据的实证研究[J].当代财经,2006,(3):40-45
    [160]李艳.中国商业银行特许权价值:1994-2003[J].上海金融,2006,(2):26-30
    [161]李燕平,韩立岩.特许权价值、隐性保险与风险承担——中国银行业的经验分析[J].金融研究,2008,(1):76-87
    [162]李元黄,岩旭,张向普.中国国有商业银行与外资银行竞争力比较研究[J].金融研究,2000,(3):47-56
    [163]梁缤尹.论银行自律及其实现[J].中南大学学报,2005,(3):378-384
    [164]凌亢.银行体系稳定性和效率关系的模型分析[J].金融研究,2000,(12):20-27
    [165]刘雯.国有商业银行体系脆弱性分析和实证研究[D].南京财经大学硕士论文
    [166]刘锡良.中国金融体系的脆弱性与道德风险[J].财贸经济,2003,(1):25-32
    [167]陆前进.银行的特许权价值分析及政策含义[J].立信会计高等专科学校学报,2002,(3):16-33
    [168]陆前进.转型经济时期的银行体系安全研究[D].复旦大学,2003
    [169]罗舜尧.论我国商业银行公司治理结构的完善[J].时代金融,2010,(1):47-49
    [170]马晓军,欧阳姝.中美两国商业银行特许权价值及影响因素的比较研究[J].金融研究,2007,(4):53-71
    [171]倪明.完善国有商业银行公司治理结构的四点政策建议[J].中国经济周刊,2008, (14):30-31
    [172]倪泽强.商业银行风险度量方法及其对我国的启示[D].硕士学位论文,安徽大学,2005
    [173]彭雷清.银行业市场营销[M].广东经济出版社,2002.7:167-200
    [174]青木昌彦.比较制度分析[M].周黎安译.上海:上海远东出版社,2001:309-326.
    [175]冉勇.激励规制理论与商业银行监管[J].财经科学,2005,(3):8-12
    [176]邵英听.银行业稳健经营与宏观经济政策[J].世界经济,1999,(5):57-67
    [177]沈铭辉,唐道毅.中国银行体系脆弱性与实体经济关系的实证分析[J].中国农业银行武汉培训学院学报,2004,(1):30-32
    [178]沈沛龙,任若恩.新的资本充足率框架与我国商业银行风险管理[J].金融研究,2001,(2):80-87
    [179]宋敏.中国银行业脆弱性、测度及效率研究[D].河海大学博士论文
    [180]孙森,袁新峰,周世进.我国有问题金融机构市场退出模式探讨[J].经济学动态,2004,(3):48-52
    [181]孙志宇,顾金宏,徐冬冬.我国上市银行特许权价值风险自律效应得研究[J].金融经济,2010,(1):51-53
    [182]唐双宁.国有商业银行股份制改革[N].中国经济周刊.2009-9-28
    [183]唐奕.建立我国的存款保险制度[J].财经界,2006,(4):133-134
    [184]佟仕富.特许权价值风险约束效应研究[D].湖南大学硕士论文
    [185]江世新.商业银行信用风险管理博弈分析[D].复旦大学,2004
    [186]王聪.公平与效率:金融税制和国有银行负税[J].中国金融年鉴,2003:683-690
    [187]王松奇,刘煜辉,欧明刚.中国商业银行竞争力评价[J].银行家,2006,(4):21-49
    [188]王小翠.我国商业银行公司治理结构的现存问题及对策[J].工业技术经济,2008,(1):159-161
    [189]王晓品.我国商业银行特许权价值与风险行为关系的研究[D].山东大学硕士论文
    [190]伍志文.我国银行体系脆弱性的理论分析及实证考察[J].金融论坛,2003,(1):2-9
    [191]伍志文.中国银行体系脆弱性状况及其成因实证分析[J].金融研究,20002,(12):21-37
    [192]肖亮.中国上市银行特许权价值和风险行为的实证研究[D].长沙理工大学硕士论文
    [193]许国新,石琴.对我国商业银行特许权价值形成要素的实证分析[J].海南金融,2007,(3):21-25
    [194]许国新.商业银行特许权价值的自律效应研究[J].上海金融,2008,(3):27-30
    [195]许国新.我国上市银行特许权价值的自律效应研究[D].湖南大学硕士学位论文,2007:11-12
    [196]杨城.商业银行风险承担的影响因素分析[D].暨南大学硕士论文,2005
    [197]姚萍.试论我国存款保险制度的建立[J].中南财经政法大学研究生学报,2006,(1):143-146
    [198]叶欣.外资银行进入对中国银行业效率影响的实证研究[J].财经问题研究,2006,(2):61-67
    [199]尤启明,尹世贵.银行体系脆弱性的理论与文献回顾[J].产业与科技论坛,2009,(1):131-133
    [200]于景莲,陈华.中国国有银行脆弱性预警模型研究[J].技术经济,2009,(1):92-97
    [201]苑素静.韩国金融危机中银行特许权价值降低的实证分析[J].现代财经,2005,(12):33-37
    [202]苑素静.中美银行特许权价值比较[J].农村金融研究,2005,(5):28-30
    [203]张红凤.西方规制经济学的变迁[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2005
    [204]张荔.论过度的金融自由化对金融休系脆弱性的助推作用[J].经济评论,2001,(1):42-49
    [205]张筱峰等.中国银行体系脆弱性的测度与实证研究[J].则经理论与实践(双月刊),2008,(1):29-33
    [206]张正平,何广文.隐性保险、市场约束与我国银行业改革[J].中国软科学,2005,(12):38-43
    [207]张志杰.稳健经营是商业银行防范风险之根本[J].经济问题,2000,(10):43-47
    [208]郑先炳.五问银行资本充足率[J].银行家,2004,(12):12-17
    [209]中国人民银行.商业银行内部控制指引[N].金融时报,2002-9-19
    [210]中国人民银行.商业银行内部控制指引[N].中国财经报,2002-11-14
    [211]周亮,曲洪建,郑建国.建筑企业供应链合作伙伴的选择[J].商业研究,2009,(10):83-87
    [212]周亮.基于神经网络的车牌识别算法研究[D].青岛科技大学硕士论文
    [213]周炜.基于金融制度理论的我国银行体系脆弱性问题研究[D].湖南大学硕士论文
    [214]周霞.商业银行人力资源管理改革对策[J].中国人力资源开发,2005,(11):91-94

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700