摘要
在全球化日益竞争激烈的时代,企业要永续经营下去,必须向其掌握的人力资源寻求解决之道。而新生代员工作为职场的有生力量,己成为主力军。然而,与高速发展的经济相伴的却是新生代员工的组织忠诚度降到历史新低。频繁的离职、心猿意马的工作心态,给社会、企业和员工个人都带来困扰,因此研究新生代员工的组织忠诚度的问题成为当下关注的热点。本论文试图在借鉴该领域国内外已有的研究成果的基础上,通过实地访谈、问卷调研,得出一手资料来分析新生代员工组织忠诚度下降的原因、影响、应对措施等相关问题。
本论文从新生代员工的特征着手,结合新生代员工成长的时代背景和生长环境,归纳出其五方面的独特个性:视野开阔、思维活跃,极具创造力和想象力,具有很强的创新思维;在“蜜罐”中长大,不易委曲求全,有很大的不稳定性,同时肩负着较大的经济压力;有良好的教育基础,渴望在工作中学到更多的技能和知识,保持终身的就业能力;沟通和交流方式发生重大变革,“虚拟交流”成为重要的渠道;普遍心智较为单纯,渴望简单的人际工作环境;同时喜欢公平、公正、民主的氛围。在对新生代员工个性特征充分了解的基础上,调研影响新生代员工组织忠诚度的原因等,重点从社会、组织、工作、个人四个维度来分析影响新生代员工组织忠诚度的原因,同时检验不同行业、从事不同岗位、处于不同企业性质以及80后、85后和90后组织忠诚度原因的差异,建构出影响新生代员工组织忠诚度的综合模型。为了更深刻地分析新生代员工离职行为,本文引入博弈模型分析方法,建构新生代员工离职的策略影响公式,得出留任核心员工的价值。在此基础上,从外部环境影响、企业层面以及员工个人三方面系统分析了影响员工忠诚度的因素。接下来从高低忠诚度两个维度来分析新生代员工忠诚度对社会、组织和个人的影响。最后通过新生代员工组织忠诚度形成路径着手分析,从管理者转变理念和角色、战略性的人才培养体系、人力资源具体实践,同时引入风险管控、知识管理和回聘制度等方面着眼,建构系统地新生代员工组织忠诚度形成机制模型。
If the enterprises want to own sustainable business, it must find a solution to human resources in the era of globalization increasingly competitive. The new generation of employees has become the main force as the effective strength of the workplace. Accompanied with the rapid development, the new generation of employees' organizational loyalty drops a record low. Due to frequent turnover, distracted work mentality, it has brought trouble to the community, businesses and individual, so this kind of research has become hot issues. This paper attempts to learn from at home and abroad in the field of existing research results, then it obtained first-hand information on the basis of field interviews and questionnaire survey to analyze the problem of organizational loyalty about the new generation of employees.
In this thesis, it summarized its five unique personalities by being proceed from the characteristics of the new generation of employees and being combined with the background of the times and growing environment for the growth of the new generation of employees. Their unique personality as follows:Vision, thinking, active, highly creative and imaginative and highly innovative thinking; Growing up in a "honeypot" is not easy to make compromises, there is a lot of instability, while shouldering greater economic pressure; Good educational foundation, eager to more skills and knowledge learned on the job to maintain life-long employability; Communication and exchange of significant change,"virtual exchange" has become an important channel; Universal mind is more pure, simple desire people work environment; Like a fair, just, democratic atmosphere. Research on the basis of personality characteristics of the new generation of employees, it can fully understand the current situation of separation and the reasons for the new generation of employee turnover. It focuses on four dimensions such as social, organizational, work and personal. At the same time, it tests reasons for leaving difference about different industries, different positions, different companies as well as different times of birth (e.g.80,85and90).In order to gain a deeper analysis of the new generation of employee turnover behavior, we introduce the game model analysis method to construct new generation of employees turnover strategies affect the formula obtained remain in the value of key employees. From the external environment, the enterprise level, and individual employees find out why the new generation of employee turnover, systematic analysis of the factors affecting employee loyalty. Next, from the two dimensions of the level of loyalty, it analyzes impact of the new generation of employee loyalty to society, organizations and individuals. At the last step, On the basis of the path formed by the new generation of Organizational loyalty, We analyze the vision and role of the manager changes, strategic personnel training system, human resources practices, while introducing the method of discussion of risk management and control, knowledge management and back Engagement System, and then construct new generation of organizational loyalty formation mechanism model.
引文
[1]姜育新.人力资源是第一资源[J].经济师.2002(6):30-35.
[2]周青.新生代,管理因你而变[J].中国人力资源开发.2007(2):26-29.
[3]孔梅英,万华.“80后”知识型员工的个性特征与激励模式[J].企业活力.2010(7):54-57.
[4]周石.80后员工“职业观”分析.管理世界[J].管理世界.2009(4):184-185.
[5]王丽霞,钱士茹.从社会认知角度解析新生代知识型员工的管理[J].中国石油大学学报(社会科学版)[J].2012(6):26-32.
[6]Bob Voylesi. Are satisfied employees loyal employees?[J].Potentials.1999(9): 69-701.
[7]刘聚梅,陈步峰.强化使命责任,培育员工忠诚[J].杭州金融研修学院学报.2003(4):5-61.
[8]郑艳.从顾客忠诚到员工忠诚[J].企业研究.2001(9):24-25.
[9]周亚越,俞海山.员工忠诚的三维因素分析[J].理论月刊.2003(3):121-124.
[10]赵瑞美,李桂云.企业员工忠诚度下降的原因与对策分析[J].聊城大学学报社会科学版.2003(4):36-38.
[11]Albert O. Hirschman.Exit, Voice, and Loyalty[M].Cambridge, Mass.:Harvard University Press.1970(1).
[12]Getchell E.H. Factors Affecting Employee Loyalty[D].The Thesis For The Degree of Master of Science At The Massachusetts Institute of Technology.1975(6).
[13]Fredrick F Reichheld. Satisfaction:The False Path to Employee Loyalty[J]. Harvard Management Update Article.2001 (10):10-11.
[14]Richard Coughlan. Employee Loyalty as Adherence to Shared Moral Values[J]. Journal of Managerial Issues, Spring 2005(17):43.
[15]Getchell E.H. Factors Affecting Employee Loyalty[D].The Thesis For The Degree of Master of Science At The Massachusetts Institute of Technology.1975(6).
[16]Fredrick F Reichheld. Satisfaction:The False Path to Employee Loyalty[J]. Harvard Management Update Article.2001 (10):10-11.
[17]Allen N J and J.P. Meyer. The Measurement and Antecedents of Affective Continuance and Normative Commitment to the Organization Journal of OccupationalPsychology.1990(63):1-18.
[18]Meyer J P.D.J Stanley L Herscovitch L Topohytsky Affective Continuance and Normative Commitment to the Organization A Meta-analysis of Antecedents Correlates and Consequences Journal of Vocational Behavior.2002(6):20-52.
[19]邓劲松.知识型企业的组织认同与员工忠诚[J].计划与市场.2002(2):15-17.
[20]刘小平.组织承诺研究综述[J].心理学动态.1999(4):31-37.
[21]许小东,孟晓斌.基于心理契约的组织成员忠诚度培育[J].经济管理.2003(14):49-53.
[22]刘颖.影响员工忠诚度的心理动因分析[J].中国邮政.2003(4):18-19.
[23]周亚越,俞海山.员工忠诚的三维因素分析[J].理论月刊.2003(3):121-124.
[24]张晓光.影响组织与员工双向忠诚的因素[J].中国人力资源开发.2005(7):18-22.
[25]赵瑞美,李桂云.企业员工忠诚度下降的原因与对策分析[J].聊城大学学报(社会科学版).2003(4).
[26]陈云娟.知识型员工激励模式新探[J].经营与管理.2004(3):6-8.
[27]李星敏,唐孝云.论员工忠诚度的培养[J].重庆大学学报(社会科学版).2004(4):30-35.
[28]蒋建华,扬延钫.员工忠诚度下降的原因与对策[J].江苏商论.2004(3):35-38.
[29]陈萍.基于心理契约的员工忠诚度及风险分析[J].西北民族大学学报(社会科学版).2004(1):42-47.
[30]杨帆,郎福臣.“员工忠诚”内涵的五个层次解析[J].人才资源开发.2005.(6):30-31.
[31]包立杰.企业员工忠诚度研究[J]内蒙古民族大学学报.2006(9):35-37.
[32]蒲清平,龚丽,刁黎.企业管理人员工作价值观、组织忠诚度现状及相关性研究[J].重庆大学学报(社会科学版).2007(6):50-53.
[33]刘敏,李小平,庄伟.员工忠诚度研究的新视角[J].山东工商学院学报.2010(1):51-54.
[34]Allen D G,Shore L M,Griffth R W.The Role of Perceived Organizational Support and Support and Supportive Human Resource Pracices in the Turnover Process[J]. Journal of Management.2003,29(1):99.
[35]SAKS A M, ASHFORTH B. A Longitudinal Investigation of the Relationships Between Job Information Sources, Applicant Percept ions of Fit, and Work Outcomes[J]. Personnel Psychology,1997,50(6):395-426.
[36]LAU VER K J, KRISTOF B A. Distinguishing Between employees' Perceptions of Person-Job and Person-Organization Fit [J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior,2002,59(3):454-470.
[37]Kirkman B L, Rosen B. A Model of Work Team Empowerment [J]. Research in Organizational Change and Development,1997(10):131-167.
[38]McEvoy L K. Ethical Decision Making in Organizations:A Person situation Integrationist Model [J]. Academy of Management Review,1986,11(3):601-617.
[39]David G Allen Kelly P Weeks, Karen R Moffitt. Turnover intentions and voluntary turnover:the moderating roles of self-monitoring, locus of control, proactive personality, and risk aversion [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2005 (5):980-990.
[40]Spector, Paul E. Behavior in organizations as a function of employee's locus of control[J]. Psychological Bulletin,1982,91 (3):482-497.
[41]Porter L W,Steers R M, Mowday R T, Boulian P V. Organizational Commitment, Job Satisfaction and Turnover among Psychiatric Technicians[J] Journal of Applied Psychology,1974,59:603-609.
[42]Mobley, W. H. Intermediate linkages in the relationship between job and satisfaction and employee and turnover[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,1977, 62(2):237-240.
[43]Price J L. Reflections of the determinants of voluntary turnover[J]. Journal of International Manpower,2001,22(7):600-624.
[44]王忠民,陈继祥,续洁丽.影响员工离职的九大因素[J].人才开发.2002(2):22-24.
[45]张勉,张德,李树茁.IT企业技术员工离职意图路径模型实证研究[J].南开管理评论.2003(4):12-20.
[46]李坚强.浅议企业员工离职原因及对策[J].江南大学学报(人文社会科学 版).2003(4):62-64.
[47]熊明良.组织认同在员工离职倾向决定中的调节效应研究[J].软科学.2008(7):64-69.
[48]王忠,张琳.个人-组织匹配、工作满意度与员工离职意向关系的实证研究[J].管理学报.2010(3):379-385.
[49]黄攸立,周琴.人格特质在员工离职倾向决定中的调节效应研究[J].北京理工大学学报(社会科学版).2010(4).
[50]孙跃,胡蓓.成就动机在产业集群员工离职意愿决定中的调节效应研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2009(2):154-159.
[51]陈璧辉.组织承诺和职务投入对技术人员行为的影响[J].应用心理学.2001(3):33-37.
[52]郑美群,张宁.组织政治行为对员工离职的影响分析[J].中国人力资源开发.2009(6):54-57.
[53]张一弛,梁钧平,刘鹏,邓建修.个体价值观在员工离职倾向决定中的调节效应研究[J].中国地质大学学报(社会科学版).2005(3):10-16.
[54]李倩,王艳平,刘效广.员工对高管的信任与员工离职倾向的关系-组织承诺的中介效应研究[J].软科学.2009(12):108-112.
[55]何惠,张新安,冯任重.员工离职-工作控制感与金钱动力角度的解释[J].经济理论与经济管理.2011(6):77-84.
[56]韩翼,廖建桥.员工离职因素的实证研究[J].经济管理.2007(11):60-65.
[57]夏功成,胡斌,张金隆.基于定性模拟的员工离职行为预测[J].管理科学学报.2006(4):81-94.
[58]Marc Prensky. Capturing The Value of "Generation Tech" Employees[J]. Strategy & Business Magazine.2004(3).
[59]HaeJung Kim, Dee K. Knight, Christy Crutsinger. Generation Y employees' retail work experience:The mediating effect of job characteristics [J]. Journal of Business Research.2009(5).
[60]Peter Haynes,Jack Vowles, Peter Boxall. Explaining the Younger-Older Worker Union Density Gap:Evidence from New Zealand[J]. British Journal of Industrial Relations.2005(3).
[61]Paul N.Gooderham,Odd Nordhaug.International management:cross-boundary challenges[M].Blackwell Publishing.2003.
[62]Jay A. Conger, Beth Benjamin. Building Leaders:How Successful Companies Develop The Next Generation[M].Jossey-Bass.2003.
[63]彼得.卡佩利著,朱飞,欧阳杰,李凤(译).员工管理新变革-管理受市场驱动的员工队伍[M].北京:商务印书馆,2006.
[64]李芝山.“新新人类”的工作特性及管理策略[J].中国人力资源开发.2007(2):18-23.
[65]姚月娟.新生代员工的多元化激励[J].生产力研究.2008(10):16-19.
[66]刘维政.新生代员工培训模式构建的研究[J].成人教育.2009(4):25-27.
[67]吴晓燕,姜汝祥.管理因Y一代而变[N].中国经营报.2005(2):4-5.
[68]柯健.基于CAS理论的“新新员工”特色化管理[J].中国人力资源开发.2007(2):25-32.
[69]李军.环境造就人才—塑造优秀员工,成就卓越的管理者[M].北京:北京工业大学出版社,2007:6.
[70]邱静.当60后领导遭遇80后员工[J].人力资源.2010(5):17-20.
[71]赵西萍,刘玲,张长征.员工离职倾向影响因素的多变量分析[J].中国软科学.2003(3):15-19.
[72]陈瑜,何波.关于企业员工离职管理的问题思考[J].科技管理研究.2005(2):27-34.
[73]李向民,任宇石.当代企业员工离职及影响因素探析[J].中央财经大学学报.2007(4):19-24.
[74]苏华,肖坤梅.论“80后”员工的工作特点及管理[J].当代青年研究.2008(4):54-58.
[75]刘玥,李东坡.我国企业新员工离职流失问题分析及对策[J].西南民族大学学报(自然科学版).2010(1):20-23.
[76]刘维政.“新生代”员工培训模式构建的研究.成人教育.2009(4):11-12.
[77]董克用.人力资源管理理论[M].中国人民大学出版社.2009(1):146-147.
[78]Davenport,Thomas&Ceantrell,2002)(DavenPort,T.H.,Thomas,R.J.& Cantrell,5.T heMysteriousArtandSeienee of Knowledge Worker Performance[J].MIT Sloan Management Review,2002,44(1):23-30.
[79]斯蒂芬-罗宾斯,玛丽-库尔特.管理学[M1.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2004:453-459.
[80]Herzberg, E Manser,B.& Snyderman,B.The Motivation to Work, New York: JohnWiley,& Sons Inc,1959.
[81]MUCHINSKY PM,MONAHANCJ. What Is Person-Environment Congruence? Supplementary Versus Complementary Models of Fit [J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior.1987,31(7):268-277.
[82]MITCHELL T R, LEE T W. The unfolding model of voluntary turnover and job embeddedness:Foundations for a comprehensive theory of attachment [J]. Research in Organizational Behavior.2001,23(2):198-246.
[83]MEYER, ALLEN. The measurement and antecedents of affective, Continuance and normative commitment to the organization [J]. Journal of Occupational Psychology.1990,63(3):1-18.
[84]凌文辁,张治灿.中国职工组织承诺的结构模型研究[J].管理科学学报.2000(6):76-81.
[85]周石.80后员工“职业观”分析[J].管理世界.2009(4):184-185.
[86]韩振燕,方焕廷.对80后员工的多元化激励[J].中国人力资源开发.2011(5):41-43.
[87]高建华.笑着离开惠普[M].北京:商务印书馆.2005:2.
[88]何晓宁.对Y代员工激励方式的思考[J].Pioneering With Science and Technology.2007(8):111-113.
[89]吴爱华,葛文雷.员工主动离职管理:从专用性投资视角的研究[J].中国人力资源开发.2010(4):17-20.