摘要
民用建筑节能是建设资源节约型、环境友好型和生态文明社会的必然选择和重要内容,现阶段建设资金来源渠道单一、有效资金供给不足已成为制约我国民用节能建筑市场发展的主要障碍。本文立足于我国民用节能建筑市场资金融通难这一关键问题,以增量投融资为研究对象,通过对我国民用节能建筑市场增量投融资现状进行广泛调查研究,采用计算机模拟、统计分析、模型推理和实证研究的方法,综合运用投资经济学、公共物品理论、公共财政理论、公共选择理论、博弈论、行为经济学和复杂系统理论知识,在民用节能建筑市场增量投资产生过程、多参与主体行为建模及影响因素、增量投融资政策改善路径设计、政策对增量投融资的作用机理以及投融资模式建议等方面进行了深入研究。
针对民用节能建筑市场增量投融资缺乏规范性定义的现状,本文首先提出了概念框架,实现对民用节能建筑市场及增量投融资不同阶段特征的系统认识。通过定义民用节能建筑、民用节能建筑市场和增量投融资的基本概念,进一步界定本文的研究范围与内容;从外部性、竞争性和排他性角度分析民用节能建筑的公共物品和准公共物品属性,指出需要由政府或政府委托私人部门进行生产和提供;但由于民用节能建筑市场存在市场失灵和政府失灵,在私人生产领域需要加强政府的干预和引导作用,在政府管理领域则需要加强监督机制和管理模式的创新;由于现阶段民用节能建筑市场增量投融资处于金融成长周期的创建期和发展期的交汇阶段,需要充分发挥政府对投融资的引导作用,实行以政府引导为主市场行为为辅的投融资模式。
其次,通过建立全生命周期内民用节能建筑市场增量投资产生过程的三维模型,实现对增量投资产生内外部动力的动态分析。增量投资产生于民用节能建筑的全生命周期内,由于增加节能技术要求使各阶段内容丰富,从而实现民用节能建筑市场的闭合管理;在确定分析原则的基础上,指出现有基于技术和基于过程的增量投资产生分析方法的局限性;建立包含增量动因产生维、生命周期维和能源消耗维的三维模型,挖掘增量投资产生的内部动力;通过增量投资成本效益帕累托寻优过程分析增量投资产生的外部动力。
再次,为确定增量投融资的影响因素,构建民用节能建筑市场增量投融资多参与主体行为网络化模型。通过对市场各参与主体包括投资方、融资方和代理方行为特征和属性的界定,建立多参与主体行为的网络化概念模型;进而定义系统属性及各主体之间的作用关系及偏好,利用动态参与者网络分析平台进行演算和模拟,并选择效用、满意度和失效率三个评价指标,结合统计结果与实际调研数据识别出增量投融资的影响因素包括:经济激励政策、节能建筑公共管理方式、建筑节能服务体系和建筑节能知识扩散形式。
第四,通过建立民用节能建筑市场增量投融资过程中政府和其他投资者基于Stackelberg的两阶段主从博弈模型,证明政府参与程度和方式对市场投资效率具有重要影响作用,并对改善增量投融资影响因素的政策路径进行设计。博弈均衡结果显示政府通过制订相应政策参与增量投融资对其他投资者具有显著影响;进而利用经济数学模型分析命令控制型和经济激励型两种常用政策类型对增量投融资的影响,通过静态比较分析得出针对不同类型建筑需要制订不同的政策模式;结合我国民用节能建筑市场特点设计了经济激励型、命令控制型和市场规范型三种政策路径模式;并分析不同类型政策对增量投融资的作用机理,结果表明其不仅能对增量投融资起到较好的引导作用,还能促进市场化融资方式的形成。
最后,结合上述研究内容及成果对北京市民用节能建筑市场增量投融资进行了实证分析,通过确定北京市民用节能建筑市场增量投融资政策优化变量,重新构建政策优化后的多参与主体行为概念模型,并利用动态参与者网络分析平台进行计算模拟,统计结果显示投融资状况改善明显。根据实证分析结果与全文研究内容提出适合我国现阶段的增量投融资模式建议:市场准入与能效标识相结合的增量投融资模式、基于既有居住建筑节能改造模式的增量投融资模式和节能监管框架下的增量投融资模式。
通过对民用节能建筑市场增量投融资的研究,可有效解决我国民用节能建筑市场发展初期的资金“瓶颈”问题,培育节能建筑市场的供给主体和需求主体,调整建筑业的能源使用结构,为政府制订民用节能建筑领域的投融资政策提供相应的建议。伴随我国民用节能建筑市场的发展与成熟,本文的研究成果将具有广阔的应用前景。
Civil building energy efficiency is inevitable selection and important contents of establishing resource-preserving, environment-friendly and ecological civilization society. In this stage, development barriers of civil building energy efficient market (CBEEM) in China mainly centralize on unitary construction capital source channel and deficient effective capital supply. To the key problems of capital financing in CBEEM, the study takes the incremental investment and financing (IIF) as research object. Through extensive market investigations to the condition of IIF for CBEEM, adopt the methodology of computer simulation, statistical analysis, model consequence and demonstration research, synthetically utilize the knowledge of investment economy, public goods theory, public financing theory, public choice theory, game theory, behavior economy and complex system theory. Deeply research on emerging process and drive of incremental investment (II), establishing multi-participant behavior model and influence factor analysis, policy improvement path, inducting mechanism of policy to IIF and IIF mode selection.
According to absence of canonical definition of CBEEM, the research firstly put forward to the concept scheme for CBEEM so as to systematically recognize the different stage characteristics of IIF for CBEEM. Through defining civil energy efficient building (CEEB), CBEEM and IIF, furtherly limit research scope and content. Analyze the public goods and quasi-public goods characteristics of CEEB from the view of externality, competitiveness and exclusiveness, prove that it can be produced and supplied by government or government consigning private department. Because of market failure and government failure in CBEEM, it needs strengthen government’s inducting and intervening function in the field of private production and innovate government supervising mechanism and management mode in the field of government management. Because IIF of CBEEM is located in the intersection stage of start-up and grow-up, it also needs play the inducting role of government and executing the financing mode of government inducting as priority and market behavior as supplement.
Secondly, complete the dynamic analysis on interior and exterior drive on II emerging through establishing three-dimension model for emerging process of II for CBEEM in whole life cycle. II is emerged from the whole life cycle of CEEB. For the requirement of adding energy efficient technique, enrich the different stage contents and form the close management of CBEEM. On the basis of analyzing limitations of II emerging method of existing methods based on process and technique, confirm the analysis principle and method. Establish three-dimension model including incremental reason emerging dimension, life cycle dimension and energy consumption dimension, fully dig the interior drive of IIF emerging. Through Pareto optimization process of II benefit-cost, analyze the exterior drive of II emerging.
Thirdly, in order to confirm on influence factors of IIF, established behavior network model of multi-participants for CBEEM. Through defining the behavior characteristics and attributes of participants including investment participant, financing participant and agent participant, establish network behavior concept model of multi-participants in market. Respectively define the system attribute, influence relationship and preference of different agents. Take calculations and simulation through Dynamic Actor Network Analysis (DANA) and select three appraisal indexes including market utility, satisfaction degree and frustration degree. Combining with statistic result and practical investigation data, identify the influence factors on IIF. They include economic incentive policy, energy efficient building public management mode, building energy efficient (BEE) service system and BEE knowledge diffusion form.
Fourthly, established two-stage leader-followers game model based on Stackelberg with government and other investors during the course of IIF for CBEEM, proved that government’s participant degree and mode have important influence on market investment efficiency and proposed policy path improving IIF influence factors. Game equilibrium results show that the policy established by government has obvious influence on other investors. Furtherly, analyze the economic influence on IIF of Command and Control (CAC) and Market-based Instruments (MBI). The results show that it can be concluded that different buildings need to establish different policy mode after static comparison. According to the characteristics of CBEEM, propose three types of policy path including CAC, MBI and market standardization policy type (MSP) based on CBEEM. Analyzed the influence mechanism on IIF. The results show that it not only inducting IIF but also propelling to form market financing mode.
Lastly, according to the following research contents accomplished the empirical analysis of IIF for CBEEM in Beijing. Through confirming on optimization policy variable, reconstruct participant behavior concept model after policy improvement, calculate and simulate utilizing DANA. The statistic result shows that the investment and financing condition is obviously improved. On the basis of empirical analysis result and research contents of whole study, propose three IIF modes suit for this stage, which include IIF mode combining market admittance and energy efficient label, IIF mode based on existing residential building energy efficient retrofit mode and IIF mode under energy efficient supervision framework.
Through the research on IIF for CBEEM, it can effectively settle the capital bottleneck problem in the grow-up stage of CBEEM, cultivate with the supply and demand agents, propel the progress of energy efficient technique, promote the development of energy efficient building engineering practice and adjust the structure of energy utilization in construction industry. At the same time, it can offer some suggestions on government establishing investment and financing policy in the field of energy efficient building. With the development of CBEEM, the research fruits will have the wide application foreground.
引文
1 Jing Liang, Baizhan Li, Yong Wu, Runming Yao. An Investigation of the Existing Situation and Trends in Building Energy Efficiency Management in China. Energy and Buildings. 2007, (1): 1~9
2武涌.我国建筑节能的目标任务措施.住宅产业. 2007, (12): 18~20
3江亿.我国建筑能耗趋势与节能重点.建设科技. 2006, (7): 10~15
4鲍德威威迪逊.公共部门经济学.中国人民大学出版社. 2000,(6): 20~30
5 Lee Schipper, Stephen Meyers. Energy Efficiency and Human Activity: Past Trends and Future Prospects. Cambridge University Press. 1992: 210~223
6 Dennis L Meadows.增长的极限.商务印书馆, 2006, (6): 130~175
7 Lorna A. Greening, David L. Greene, Carmen Difiglio. Energy Efficiency and Consumption-the Rebound Effect-A Survey. Energy policy. 2000, 28(6):389~401
8 Sinton JE, Levine MD, Wang QY. Energy Efficiency in China: Accomplishments and Challeges. Energy Policy. 1998, 126(11): 813~829
9武涌,刘长滨,刘应宗,屈宏乐.中国建筑节能管理制度创新研究.中国建筑工业出版社. 2007,(4): 238~239
10 Gred Hauser. Arrangements for an Increase of Energy Efficiency of Buildings in German and Europe. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Building Energy Efficiency Policy. 2006, (3):25~41
11 Kraus felicitas. Policy and Stategy of Energy Efficiency. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Building Energy Efficiency Policy. 2006, (3):111~131
12 Gasals X G. Analysis of Building Energy Regulation and Certification in Europe: Their Role, Limitations and Differences. Energy and Buildings. 2006,(38):381~392
13 Banerjee A, Solomon B D. Eco-labeling for Energy Efficiency and Sustainability: a Meta-evaluation of US Programs. Energy Policy. 2003, (31):109~123
14 Mahlia T M I. Methodology for Predicting Market Transformation Due to Implementation of Energy Efficiency Standards and Labels. EnergyConversion and Management. 2004, (45):1785~1793
15 Palo Bertoldi, Silvia Rezessy, Edward Vine. Energy Service Companies in European Countries: Current Status and a Strategy to Foster Their Development. Energy Policy. 2006, (34):1818~1832
16 Goldman Charles A., Osborn Julie G., Hopper Nicole C., Singer Terry E.. Market Trends in the U.S. ESCO Industry: Results from the NAESCO Database Project. Report of Ernest Orlando Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory of California University. 2002,(3): 23~26
17 Silvia Rezessy, Konstantin Dimitrov, Diana Urge-Vorsatz, Seth Baruch. Municipalities and Energy Efficiency in Countries in Transition Review of Factors that Determine Municipal Involvement in the Markets for Energy Service and Energy Efficient Equipment, or How to Argument the Role of Municipalities as Market Players. Energy Policy. 2006, (34):2323~2327
18 Steve Sorrel. The Economics of Energy Service Contracts. Energy Policy. 2006, (34):127~145
19 Philip C.H. Yu, W.K. Chow. A Discussion on Potentials of Saving Energy Use for Commercial Buildings in Hong Kong. Energy. 2006, (3):1~12
20 M. Bennett, M. Newborough. Auditing Energy Use in Cities. Energy Policy. 2001, (29): 125~134
21 Tahsin Engin, Vedat Ari. Energy Auditing and Recovery for Dry Type Cement Rotary Kiln Systems: A Case Study. Energy Conversion and Management. 2005, (46):551~562
22王清勤.国际建筑节能经验对我国建筑节能发展的启示.节能.2006, (1):8~10
23 Peter K. Clark, Alan Greenspan, Stephen M. Goldfeld, Peter Clark. Investment in the 1970s: Theory, Performance, and Prediction. Economic Activity. 1979, 1(1): 73~124
24 W.L Lee, F.W.H Yik. Regulatory and Voluntary Approaches for Enhancing Building Energy Efficiency. Progress in Energy and Combustion Science. 2004,30(5): 477~499
25 Robert Topel, Sherwin Rosen. Housing Investment in the United States. The Journal of Political Economy. 1988,96(4):718~740
26吴大华.中国循环经济的政府引导及激励政策.管理现代化.2007,(4):50~52
27占松林,韩青苗,刘长滨.关于建立建筑节能奖励制度的思考.建筑经济.2008,(1):90~93
28钱坤,高平.浅析我国发展节能省地型住宅与公共建筑的法律保障体系建设.建筑经济.2006,(8):84~85
29原国家经贸委资源司赴美节能培训班.美国及加州建筑节能工作的开展.节能与环保. 2003,(11):21
30吴丹红.日本节约能源的经验与启示.郑州大学学报(哲学社会科学版). 2007,40(1):74~78
31陈伟.美国和加拿大的住宅节能激励政策.住宅产业. 2006,(11):119~121
32施骞,徐莉燕.绿色建筑评价体系分析.同济大学学报(社会科学版).2007, 18(4):112~118
33 McDonald R., Siegel D.R.. The Value of Waiting to Invest. Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1986, 101(4):707~727
34 Dixit A.K., Pindyck R.S..朱勇等译.不确定条件下的投资.中国人民大学出版社.2002: 23~25
35范必.企业投资行为的基本特征及外部环境评价.中国投资.1994(7):41~44
36萧楠,孙向东.地方政府投融资行为研究.经济经纬. 2000,(4):44~46
37刘丽芹,马亚军.中国上市公司担保与借款人非理性投融资行为分析.财经论坛.统计与决策. 2007,(20): 107~108
38姜秀珍,陈俊芳.现金流量投融资行为与企业价值研究.价格理论与实践. 2003,(3): 57~58
39祝锡萍,谢莉,端木青.投融资行为的收益-成本平衡点分析.工业技术经济. 2005,6(12): 144~147
40李菁,马彦琳,梁晓群.既有建筑节能改造的融资障碍及对策研究.建筑经济. 2007,(12): 37~40
41 Carlsmith R.S., McMahon J.E., Chandler W.U., Santini, D.J.. Energy Efficiency: How Far Can We Go? Proceedings of 1990 Energy Conversation Engineering Conference. 1990, 4(8): 74~77
42 William H. Golove, Joseph H. Eto. Market Barriers to Energy Efficient: A Critical Reappraisal of the Rationale for Public Policy to Promote Energy Efficiency. Reoport of Energy & Environment Division of Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, University of California, 1996, (3):15~18
43 Andy Frank. Possible and Profitable: Energy Efficiency Investments in the Building Sector. Reports of Mckinsey Global Institute. 2003:33~37
44李忠富,周佳.生态住宅与传统住宅全生命周期成本对比分析.建设科技.2007,(15~16):76~77
45 Fisher Anthony C., Rothkopf, Michael H.. Market Failure and Energy Policy. Energy Policy, 1989,17(4):397~406
46 Sanjay Kumar, S. Sinha, T. Kojima, H. Yoshida. Development of Parameter based Fault Detection and Diagnosis Technique for Energy Efficient Building Management System. Energy Conversion and Management. 2001,7(5):833~854
47 Cameron T. A Nested Logit Model of Energy Conservation Activities by Owners of Existing Single Family Dwellings. Review of Economics and Statistics. 1985,6(2):205~211
48 Long J. An Econometric Analysis of Residential Expenditures on Energy Conservation and Renewable Energy Sources. Energy Economics. 1993,15(4):232~238
49 Torleif Haugland. Social Benefits of Financial Investment Support in Energy Conservation Policy, Energy Journal. 1996, 17(2): 79~102
50 Stein J.R., Meier A.. Accuracy of Home Energy Rating Systems. Energy. 2000, 25(4):339~354
51 Howarth, Richard B Sanstad, Alan H. Discount Rates and Energy Efficiency. Journal Contemporary Economic Policy. 1995, 13(3):101~109
52 Levine M.D, Koomey J.G., McMahon J.E, Sanstad A.H. Energy Efficiency, Market Failures, and Government Policy. Energy and Envrionment, 1994,1(3):3~7
53 Rivers, Nic,Jaccard, Mark. Choice of environmental policy in the presence of learning by doing. Energy Economics. 2006, 28(3): 223~242
54丹尼尔史普博.管制与市场.上海人民出版社. 2005,(12): 30~33
55 Yasuhiro Hamada,Makoto Nakamura. Development of a Database of Low Energy Homes Around the World and Analyses of Their Trends. Renewable Energy. 2003(28):321~328
56 Decanio S.I. Barriers within Firms to Energy-Efficient Investments. Energy Policy. 1993(21): 906~914
57 Henri L.F de Groot, Erik T. Verhoef and Peter Nijkamp. Energy Saving byFirms: Decision-Making, Barriers and Policies. Energy Economics, 2001(23):717~740
58 Andrew J. Friedland, Tillman U. Gerngross and Richard B.Howarth. Personal Decisions and Their Impacts on Energy Use and the Environment. Environmental Science&Policy, 2003,6(2): 175~179
59 Robert W. Hahn, Robert N. Stavins. Economic Incentives for Environmental Protection: Integrating Theory and Practice. The American Economic Review. 1992,(3): 464~468
60 Effrey A. Drezner. Designing Effective Incentives for Energy Conservation in the Public Sector. California: Doctor Dissertation of The Claremont Graduate University,1999:23~34
61 N.W.A. Lidula, N. Mithulananthan, W. Ongsakul, C. Widjaya, R. Henson. ASEAN Towards Clean and Sustainable Energy: Potentials, Utilization and Barriers. Renewable Energy, 2006, (6):1~11
62 Jorgen Sjodin. Modelling the Impact of Energy Taxation. International Journal of Energy Research. 2002, 26(5):475~494
63 Klevas, Valentinas, Minkstimas, Renatas. The Guidelines for State Policy of Energy Efficiency in Lithuania. Energy Policy. 2004, 32(2):309~320
64 Joseph C. Lam. Energy Analysis of Commercial Buildings in Subtropical Climates. Building and Environment. 2000,35(6):19~26
65 Korhonen, P.J., Syrjanen, M.J. Evaluation of Cost Efficiency in Finnish Electricity Distribution. Annals of Operations Research. 2003,121(1–4):105~122
66 Pearce, David. The Political Economy of an Energy Tax: The United Kingdom's Climate Change Levy. Energy Economics. 2006, 28(3): 149~158
67 Wu KT, Lu WC, Lee HT. Current Status and Development of Biomass Energy and Its Application. Solar Energy New Energy. 2003, 8(2): 27~30
68 Vaninsky, Alexander. Efficiency of Electric Power Generation in the United States: Analysis and Forecast Based on Data Envelopment Analysis. Energy Economics. 2006, 28(5): 326~338
69李峥嵘,于雅泽,黄俊鹏.浅析建筑节能政策.上海节能. 2004, (4):2~4
70王华.完善建筑节能经济政策的思考.建筑. 2006, (11): 15~16
71苏明,傅志华,牟岩.支持节能的财政税收政策建议.经济研究参考. 2006, (14): 42~52
72涂逢样.建筑节能.中国建筑工业出版社, 2003, (6): 20-24
73 DENA.中国建筑节能资金筹措形式.建设科技. 2007,(18): 66~67
74 Joe Huang. Incentive Programs to Go Beyond Building Energy Standards. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Building Energy Efficiency Policy. 2006, (3): 80~114
75 Edward Vine. An International Survey of the Energy Service Company Industry. Energy Policy. 2005,33(3): 691~704
76 Klaus-Peter Pischke. KfW-Approach to Promotion of Energy Efficiency in the Housing Sector in Germany KfW. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Building Energy Efficiency Policy. 2006, (3): 140~154
77崔新明,廖春波.国内外建筑节能的比较与经验.建设科技. 2006, (9): 94~95
78王景文.欧盟成员国实施建筑节能新措施.全球科技经济瞭望. 2006, (1): 51
79 J.P. Painuly, H. Park, M.K. Lee, J. Noh. Promoting Energy Efficiency Financing and ESCOs in Developing Countries: Mechanisms and Barriers. Journal of Cleaner Production. 2003, (11): 659~665
80龙惟定.建筑能耗比例与建筑节能目标.中国能源. 2005,27(10):23~27
81郎四维.建筑节能设计标准剖析.住宅产业. 2006(6):47~49
82 George S. Day. Strategic Market Analysis and Denefinition: An Integrated Approach. Strategic Management Journal. 1981,2(3):281~299
83 Michael Bromwich, Chelokyu Hong. Activity-Based Costing Sytems and Incremental Costs. Management Accounting Research. 1999,10(3):39~60
84 D. Copper Smith, G. B. Sorkin. On the Expected Incremental Cost of A Minimum Assignment. Mathematical Studies. 2002, (10): 277~288
85黄秀清,司先秀.长期增量成本在实际应用中的难点分析.北京邮电大学学报(社会科学版). 2006,8(1):33~37
86 Victoria Chick. Investment Finance in Economic Development. Routledge. 1995: 12~23
87 Paul A.Samulson. The Pure Theory of Public Expenditure. Review of Economic and Statistics. 1954,(36):387~389
88 James M. Buchanan. An Economic Theory of Clubs. Economics. 1965,32(12):1~14
89 Buchanan JM, Stubblebine WE. Externality. Economic.1962,29(11):371.
90威廉J鲍莫尔,华莱士E奥茨.环境经济理论与政策设计.经济科学出版社, 2003:45~47
91 Francis M. Bator. The Anatomy of Market Failure. The Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1958,3(8): 351~379
92 Joe Wallis, Brian Dollery, Charlie Weir. Market Failure, Government Failure, Leadership and Public Policy. The Economic Journal. 2000, 110: 762~764
93刘玲玲.公共财政学.中国发展出版社. 2003,(10): 23~27
94丹尼斯C.缪勒.公共选择理论.中国社会科学出版社. 1999: 34~39
95喻小军,金希.中美中小企业金融成长周期的融资结构比较.武汉理工大学学报. 2005,(6):107~109
96 Weston J Fred, Euquene F. Brigham. Managerial Finance. Dryden Press. 1978: 16~20
97 Allen N. Berger, Gregory F. Udell. The Economics of Small Business Finance: the Roles of Private Equity and Debt Markets in the Financial Growth Cycle. Journal of Banking and Financing, 1998,(22): 3~7
98 National Research Council. Pay Now or Pay Later. Press of Building Research Board. 1991:13~14
99 Eva Sterner. Green Procurement of Buildings Estamation of Environmental Impact and Life Cycle Cost. Doctoral Thesis of Lulea Tekniska University. 2002,(9): 34~37
100 Hugh Hawk. Bridge Life-Cycle Cost Analysis. Transportation Research Board of The National Academy. 2003:12~14
101董士波.全生命周期工程造价管理研究.哈尔滨工程大学博士学位论文. 2003,(12):65~66
102黄明星,顾道金.建筑节能的全生命周期研究.华中建筑. 2006,(8):70~71
103 Joshua Aizenman. Endogenous Pricing to Market and Financing Costs. Journal of Monetary Economics. 2004,4(5):691~712
104建设部,科技部.绿色建筑技术导则.中国建筑工业出版社. 2005,(10):7~10
105 Paul A. Gompers. Institutional Investors and Equity Prices. The Quarterly Journal of Economics. 2001,1(2):229~259
106 Chris Riedy, Mark Diesendorf. Financial Subsidies to the Australian Fossil Fuel Industry. Energy Policy. 2003, 2(1):125~137
107 Preter Bots. Dynamic Actor Network Analysis: Introduction and Overview in Presentation for the Institute for Resource Flow Management. Universitat Osnabruck. 2003:14~16
108 L.M. Hermans. Dynamic Actor Network Analysis for diffuse Pollution in the Province of North-Holland. Water Science and Technology. 2004,49(3):205~212
109 Proefschrift. Policy Analysis in Multi-actor Policy Settings. Eburon Publishers. 2004:30~37
110 Ethjel Tolsma. Actor Analysis among rural development and health organizations in Ouagadougou, Diebougou and rural farmers in Bapla. Larenstein University of Professional Education. 2004: 41~45
111 Ethjel Tolsma. Actor Analysis among rural development and health organizations in Ouagadougou, Diebougou and rural farmers in Bapla. Larenstein University of Professional Education. 2004: 41~45
112 Bots, P. W.G., Van Twist, M.J.W., Van Duin J.H.R. Automatic Pattern Detection in Stakeholder Network. Proceedings 33rd Hawaii International Conference on System Science. 2000: 1340~1347
113郝斌,刘幼农,刘军民,孙海燕.大力培育建筑节能服务体系.建设科技. 2007,(10):6
114 R.B. Myerson. Game Theory: Analysis of Conflict. Harvard University Press. 1997:23~26
115 Gerchak Y, Parlar M. Allocating Resources to Research and Development Projects in a Competitive Envrionment. Transaction. 1999,31(9):827~834
116 Samaddar S, Kadiyala S. An Analysis of Interorganizational Resource Sharing Decision in Collaborative Knowledge Creation. European Journal of Operatioinal Research. 2005,32(6):483~491
117 G. P. Papavassilopoulous. Solution of Some Stochastic Quadratic Nash and Leader-Follower Games. Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics. 1981,19(5):651~666
118常良峰,黄小原.一类供应链的Stackelberg主从对策问题研究.中国管理科学. 2002,10(6):48~52
119 Bialas W.F.. Cooperative N-person Stackelberg Games. Proceedings of 28th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control. 1989,(12): 12~17
120 Jong-Shi Pang, Masao Fukushima. Quasi-Variational Inequalities, Generalized Nash Equilibria, and Multi-Leader-Follower Games. Computational Management Science. 2005,2(11):21~56
121吕周洋,吴广谋,何建敏.相关性评价中合谋现象的主从博弈模型及其改进.数量经济技术经济研究. 2004,(4):104~109
122聂国卿.环境政策选择的经济学分析——兼论我国转型时期的环境治理.复旦大学博士学位论文. 2003,(4):15
123 Paul R. Portney, Robert N. Stavins. Market-Based Environmental Policies. Resources for the Future Environmental Policy. 2000: 123~134
124 Richard M. Huber, Jack Ruitenbeek, Ronaldo Seroa Da Motta. Market-Based Instruments for Environmental PolicyMaking in Latin America and the Caribbean. World Bank Publications. 1998: 23~26
125 Ole Langniss, Barbara Praetorius. How Much Market Do Market-Based Instruments Create? An Analysis for the Case of White Certificates. Energy Policy. 2006,2(1):200~211
126赵哲身.公共建筑空调能耗分析和节能.建设科技. 2007,(7):18~19
127 Samuel Tung, Stella Chol. Determinants of Regional Investment Decisions in China: An Econometric Model of Tax Incentive Policy. Review of Quantitative Fiancing and Accounting. 2004,(10):167~185
128 M.J. Gordon. Optimal Investment and Financing Policy. The Journal of Finance. 1963,2(5):264~272
129 G. David Haushalter. Financing Policy, Basis Risk, and Corporate Hedging: Evidence From Oil And Gas Producers. The Journal of Finance. 2000,1(2):107~152
130尹波.建筑能效标识管理研究.天津大学博士学位论文. 2006,(6):93~95
131 Jin Minghong, Li Aixian. China Energy Label System. China Energy. 2005,(5): 34~40
132 Stephen Wiel, James Mcmahon. Energy-Efficiency Labels and Standards: A Guidebook for Applicances, Equipment and Lighting. ClASP. 2002:235~239
133陈淑琴,李念平.公共建筑能耗统计方法的研究.煤气与热力. 2006,26(11): 71~74
134 A Study on Thermal Environment and Energy Consumption of Urban Residential Buildings in Hot Summer and Cold Winter Climate of China. Environmental Informatics Archives. 2005,(3):379~386
135 Cao Zhidong, Liu Chunhong, Yu Ziyou. Game Analysis of Rational FRS on Market Admittance. Journal of Donghua University. 2001,(12):23~28
136吕石磊,武涌.北方采暖地区既有居住建筑节能改造工作的目标识别和障碍分析.暖通空调. 2007,(9):20~24
137林常青,吴萍.德国既有住宅改造模式与经验.建设科技. 2006,(7):94~97
138涂逢祥,徐宗威,汪又兰,方修睦.波兰丹麦建筑供暖计量收费情况考察报告.暖通空调. 2000,30(1):25~28
139古春晓,徐向辉.中国既有建筑节能改造——唐山样本.建设科技. 2007,(20):36
140 Moncef Krarti. Energy Audit of Building Systems: An Engineering Approach. CRC Press. 2000: 211~215
141 Pantelis N.Botsaris, Spyridon Prebezanos. A Methodology for a Thermal Energy Building Audit. Building and Environment. 2004,2(2):195~199
142 M. Bennett, M. Newborough. Auditing Energy Use in Cities. Energy Policy. 2001,2(1):125~134
143唐捷,胡秀珍,任震,蔡泽祥,李勇,高志华.峰谷分时电价定价模型研究.电力需求侧管理.2007,9(5):112~115
144刘承水,乞建勋.配网时电价实用预测模型研究.中国管理科学.2006,14(2):117~121
145李伟,施家芳.自愿性信息披露的动因与监管.事业财会. 2007,(6):45~47
146杨振宇.金融组织强制性信息披露问题研究.中央财经大学学报. 2007,(11):28~33
147 Vito Tanzi, Howell Zee. Tax Policy for Developing Countries. Economic Issues. 2001,27(3): 37~48
148 Robert E. Hall, Dale W. Jorgenson. Tax Policy and Investment Behavior. MIT Press. 1996:98~105
149彭梦月.美国能源管理项目融资机制—ESPC.建设科技. 2007,(24):54~57
150郑照宁,潘韬,刘德顺.清洁发展机制的项目融资方式.商业研究.2005,(2):116~119
151秦克. CDM项目开发流程与实施模式的选择.现代管理科学. 2007,(12):99~100
152 IPPC. Climate Change 2001: Mitigation. Cambridge University Press. 2001:34~36
153 Axel Michaelowa, Frank Jotaob. Transaction Costs, Institutional Rigidities and the Size of the Clean Development Mechansim. Energy Policy. 2005,33:511~523
154 Ryuji Matsuhashi, Sei Fujisawa, Wataru Mitamura. Clean Development Mechanism Projects and Portfolio Risks. Energy Policy. 2004,29(7~8):1579~1588
155 N. Duic, L. M. Alves, F. Chen, M. Dagrac. Potential of Kyoto Protocol Clean Development Mechanism in Transfer of Clean Energy Technologes to Small Island Developing States: Case Study of Cape Verde. Renewable and Sustainable Enery Reviews. 2003,(7):83~98
156鲍海君.土地开发整理的BOT项目融资研究——特许权期决策与项目运行监督的博弈分析.浙江大学博士学位论文.2005,(5):20~27
157江亿,薛志峰.北京市建筑用能现状与节能途径分析.暖通空调. 2004,(10):13~16
158田桂清,唐艳芬,杨瑾,尤克强.北京既有非节能住宅建筑节能改造浅析.节能与环保. 2006,(2):26~29