基于元胞传输模型的道路交通区域疏散应急管理研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着社会经济快速发展和城市现代化水平不断提高,城市(特别是大城市)不仅人口数量和密度大幅度增加,出现建筑、生产、财富的集中,与此同时,城市也作为灾害的巨大承载体而存在着。城市的规模越大、现代化水平越高,其潜在的灾害事件种类越多,非常规突发事件发生的频率越高,危害后果也越惊人。
     为有效应对非常规突发事件所带来的严重后果,实施大规模区域疏散越来越多地成为城市及区域应对非常规突发事件的有效途径。非常规突发事件的突发性往往要求在较短的时间内将受灾区域内的居民安全、有序的疏散到避难场所,最大限度地降低疏散总体出行时间、减少人员伤亡与财产损失。由于非常规突发事件明显的复杂性特征和潜在的次生衍生危害,以及受灾人群疏散行为的随机性与复杂性,使得区域大规模疏散问题成为应急管理研究的重点和难点。
     本文首先从国内外道路交通应急区域疏散研究现状分析入手,系统考察了疏散交通管理在灾害管理中的功能和角色,提出了区域疏散交通管理集成建模框架;其次,针对道路交通应急区域疏散交通流的时变、随机特性,开展了基于元胞传输模型的疏散交通流基础建模研究,并提出了适用于大规模路网疏散的改进元胞传输模型,形成了元胞-连接桥疏散路网模型构造的一般性方法;再次,依据元胞传输理论,构建了能够预测区域疏散交通时空分布的基础疏散动态交通配流模型,并采用逆行车道设置、分阶段疏散、交叉口冲突消除等集成管理策略,对基础交通配流模型进行修正,从而形成了集成的疏散交通管理模型;最后,针对长春市中心区局部路网进行了疏散交通管理实证分析,并结合分析结果,给出了长春市中心区规划年疏散交通管理的策略建议。
     本文立足道路交通,利用优化理论、元胞传输理论和系统科学的成果,研究了道路交通应急区域疏散交通管理理论,不仅可以弥补应急管理理论研究的不足,而且对提高道路交通管理部门的应急响应能力、危机处理能力和改善城市整体防灾减灾能力具有重要的理论意义和实践价值。
With the rapid economic development and continuously improving urban modernization, there is not only a significant increase in population size and density in cities (especially big cities), but also the concentration of construction, production and wealth. At the same time, cities also exist as a great carrier of disaster. The larger the city and the higher the level of modernization, there will be more potential types of disaster events, higher occurrence frequency of unexpected events and more alarming endanger consequences.
     To effectively deal with the serious consequences caused by unconventional emergencies, the implementation of large-scale evacuations becomes more and more an effective way to response to emergencies in urban and regional areas. Sudden emergencies often require evacuating residents in the affected region safely and orderly to shelters in a relatively short period of time, and to minimize the total evacuation duration, reduce casualties and property losses. As the obvious characteristics of complexity in the nature of sudden emergency and potential hazards of secondary derivatives, as well as evacuation of the affected population acts of randomness and complexity, making a large-scale evacuation of the regional issue has become the key and difficult problem of emergency management research.
     First of all, this paper gives a comprehensive literature review in surface transportation research field, systematically investigates the function and role of the evacuation traffic management in disaster management. An integrated regional evacuation traffic management modeling framework is presented; next, in view of the high dynamics, randomness of evacuation traffic flow, this paper conduct the analysis of basic modeling on evacuation traffic flow based on Cell Transmission Theory (CTM). Also, the classic CTM is revised to adopt the demand of large-scale evacuation modeling and solving. A formal algorithm of cell-connector evacuation road network construction is presented; next, based on CTM and R-CTM, basic evacuation traffic dynamic assignment models are presented to predict the pattern of evacuation flow in space-time dimension. Contra-flow lane, staged evacuation scheduling and elimination of intersection conflicts are imported to extend the basic traffic assignment models to form an integrated model of the evacuation traffic management; finally, an empirical analysis of evacuation traffic management in the local road network in Changchun city area is conducted. Based on the research results, the strategy proposals of evacuation traffic management in given planning year are presented.
     From the road transportation view, this paper adopts the optimization theory, CTM theory and system science to deeply study the problem of surface transportation regional evacuation traffic management. The research results not only can compensate for deficiencies in emergency management theory, but also to improve surface traffic management department emergency response capability, crisis management capacity and improve the overall urban disaster prevention and mitigation capacity, so this research has important theoretical significance and practical value.
引文
1 Y. Liu. An integrated optimal control system for emergency evacuation. University of Maryland PhD Thesis. 2007:28~29
    2 D. M. Loughlin. A framework for integrated emergency management. Public Administration Review.1985, (45):165~172
    3张钊,晏启鹏,刘澜.突发事件下应急交通疏散管理研究.铁道运输与经济.2009,31(5):85~88
    4 C. Xie, M.A. Turnquist. Lane-based evacuation network optimization: An integrated Lagrangian relaxation and tabu search approach.2010,3(5):103~109
    5 T. Urbanik. Texas Hurricane Evacuation Study. Technical Report,Texas Transportation Institute, College Station, TX, 2006, 12~14
    6 Corps of Engineers, Department of the Army, and Southwest Florida Region Planning Council. Lee County Florida Flood Emergency Evacuation Plan, 2007, 19~20
    7 D.C. Lewis. Transportation planning for hurricane evacuations. ITE Journal. 1985, 55(8): 31~35
    8 F. Southworth.Regional evacuation modeling: a state-of-the-art review. Report to ORNL/TM-11740, 1991, 45~46
    9 B. Barrett, B.Ran, R.Pillai.Developing a dynamic traffic management modeling framework for hurricane evacuation. 79th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, ,Washington, D.C.,2000: 21~30
    10 O.Franzese, D.Han. Traffic modeling framework for hurricane evacuation. 80th Annual TRB Meeting, Washington, D.C., 2001: 18~20
    11 H. X. Liu, J.X.Ban, W.T. Ma. Model reference adaptive control framework for real time traffic management under emergency evacuation. 85th annual meeting of transportation research board, Washington, D.C. ,2006: 221~230
    12 Y.Liu, X. Lai, G.L Chang, M.ASCE. Two-Level Integrated Optimization System for Planning of Emergency Evacuation. Journal of transportation engineering. 2006, 25(3):800~807
    13 M. Lahmar, T.Assavapokee, S. A. Ardekani. A Dynamic Transportation Planning Support System for Hurricane Evacuation. IEEE IntelligentTransportation Systems Conference, Toronto, 2006:17~20
    14 T.S.Glickman.A methodology for estimating time-of-day variations in the size of a population exposed to risk. Risk Analysis. 2001, (6):317~324
    15 E.Stem.A behavioural-based simulation model for urban evacuation.Power of the Regional Science Association. 2005,36(3):87~103
    16 S.B.Alam, K.G.Goulias. Dynamic emergency evacuation management system using geographic information system and spatio/temporal models of behavior. Transportation Research Record. 2007,26 (7):92~99
    17 T.Urbanik.Evacuation time estimates for nuclear power plants. Journal of Hazardous Materials. 2000, (5):165~180
    18 L.J.Dotson, J.Jones, D.Schneck, R.Sullivan. Development of evacuation time estimate studies for nuclear power plants. Technical Report, NUREG/CR-6863 (SAND2004-5900). 2005:18~20
    19 B.Mei. Development of trip generation models of hurricane evacuation. Louisiana State University Master Thesis. 2002:98~102
    20 M.D.Irwin, J.S. Hurlbert. A behavioral analysis of hurricane preparedness and evacuation in southwestern Louisiana. Technical Report, Louisiana Population Data Center.2005:15~16
    21 G.Andrienko, N.Andrienko, U.Bartling. Visual Analytics Approach to User-Controlled Evacuation Scheduling. IEEE Symposium on Visual Analytics Science and Technology, Sacramento, 2007: 43~50
    22 E.J.Baker. Hurricane Evacuation Behavior in the Middle Atlantic and Northeast States. Technical Report, Tallahassee, Florida: Hazards Management Group, Inc, 2008: 110~114
    23 Regional Development Service (RDS),Department of Sociology,and Department of Economics. Executive Summary of A Socioeconomic Hurricane Impact Analysis and A Hurricane Evacuation Impact Assessment Tool(Methodology)for Coastal North Carolina:A Case Study of Hurricane Bonnie. East Carolina University,Greenville,NC. 1999:320~324
    24 US Army Corps of Engineers.Alabama Hurricane Evacuation Study Technical Data Report: Behavioral Analysis.Final Report. 2000:32~35
    25 Post,Buckley,Schuh&Jernigan,Inc.(PBS&J). Southeast United States Hurricane Evacuation Traffic Study:Evacuation Travel Demand Forecasting System,Technical Memorandum. Final Report, Tallahassee, Florida. 2000:234~235
    26 Post,Buckley,Schuh&Jernigan,Inc.(PBS&J). Southeast United States Hurricane Evacuation Traffic Study:Behavioral Analysis,Technical Memorandum. Final Report, Tallahassee, Florida. 2000:123~134
    27 Post,Buckley,Schuh&Jernigan,Inc.(PBS&J). Hurricane Floyd Assessment: Review of Hurricane Evacuation Studies Utilization and Information Dissemination. Tallahassee, Florida.2002:11~32
    28 E.J.Baker. Predicting response to hurricane warnings:a reanalysis from four studies.Mass Emergencies. 2001,(4):9~24
    29 E.J.Baker. Evacuation in response to hurricanes Elena and Kate.Technical Report.1997:54~55
    30 R.W. Perry, M.R.Greene. Citizen ResDonse to Volcanic Eruntions. Imington Publishers,New York.1998:32~33
    31 G.O.Rogers, R.D.Sharp. Protective Action Evaluator for Chemical Emergencies. Users Manual Prepared for the Federal Emergency Management Agency by Oak Ridge National Laboratory. 1990:124~125
    32 K.Davis. Evacuation analysis of household vehicle mobilization. Natural Dsisaster. 2006,34(4):12~22
    33 Y. Xiao, D. Y.Ling, T. Qi. Highway Traffic Information Extraction from Skycam MPEG Video. IEEE 5th International Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems, Beijing, 2002:45~47
    34 J.H.Sorensen, B.M. Vogt, D.S. Mileti. Evacuation: an assessment of planning and research. Technical Report to Federal Emergency Management Agency 2007:19~30
    35 J.H.Sorensen, D.S.Mileti. Warning and evacuation: answering some basic questions.Industrial Crisis Ouarterly.2008,(2):195~209
    36 S.A.Wadoo, P.Kachroo. Feedback Control Design and Stability Analysis of Two Dimensional Evacuation System. IEEE Intelligent Transportation Systems Conference,Toronto, 2006: 1108~1113
    37 US Army Corps of Engineers.Alabama Hurricane Evacuation Study Technical Data Report: Behavioral Analysis.Final Report.2000:345~346
    38 H.J.Johnson. A model of evacuation decision making in a nuclear reactor emergency.Geographical Review .2005, (75):405~418
    39 H.J.Johnson, D.Ziegler. Modelling evacuation behavior during the Three Mile Island reactor crisis. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences.1986, (29):164~171
    40 T.Stem. A behavioral-based simulation model for urban evacuation. Papers ofthe Regional Science Association.1989, 6(6):87~103
    41 S.W.Tweedie, J.R.Rowland, S.Walsh. A methodology for estimating emergency evacuation times.The Social Science Journal.1996,31(2):189~204
    42 A.E Radwan,A.G.Hobeika, D.Sivasailarn. A computer simulation model for rural network evacuation under natural disasters. Institute for Traffic Engineering Journal.1995,(12):25~30
    43 F.Southworth, S.M.Chin. Network Evacuation Modeling For Flooding as a Result of Dam Failure.Environment and Planning.1987,12(7):1543~1558
    44 S. Ko, M. Spearpoint, A. Teo. Trial evacuation of an industrial premises and evacuation model comparison. Fire Safety Journal. 2007,42(2):91~105
    45 L.Shi, Q.Y.Xie, X.D.Cheng. Developing a database for emergency evacuation model. Building and Environment. 2009,44(8):1313~1323
    46 F.Yuan. A proposed framework for simultaneous optimization of evacuation traffic distribution and assignment, The University of Tennessee PhD. Thesis. 2005:198~199
    47 H.D.Sherali, T.B.Carter, A.G. Hobeika. A Location-Allocation Model and Algorithm for Evacuation Planning under Hurricane/Flood Conditions. Transportation Research Part B. 1991,25(6): 439~452
    48 W.M. ElDessouki. Some Developments in Transportation Network Analysis and Design with Application to Emergency Management Problems. North Carolina State University Ph.D. Thesis. 1998:45~46
    49 H.W. Hamacher, S.A.Tjandra. Mathematical modeling of evacuation problems - a state of art. ITWM technical report, 2001: 34~45
    50 C.E. Dunn, D.Newton. Optimal routes in GIS and emergency planning applications. Area. 1992, 24(3):259~267
    51 T J.Cova, J.P.Johnson. A network flow model for lane-based evacuation routing. Transportation Research Part A.2003, 37:579~604.
    52 H.Miller, S.S.Patterson.On solving quickest time problems in time-dependent, dynamic networks. Journal of Mathematical Modeling and Algorithms.2004, 3(1): 39~71
    53 P.Sattayhatewa, B.Ran. Developing a dynamic traffic management model for nuclear power plant evacuation. 79thAnnual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, 2000, Washington, D.C.:165~169
    54 G.L?mmel, D.Grether, K.Nagel. The representation and implementation of time-dependent inundation in large-scale microscopic evacuation simulations.Transportation Research Part C. 2010,18(1):84~98
    55 Y.Sheffi, H.S.Mahmassani, W.Powell. A transportation network evacuation model. Transportation Research A.1982, 16(3): 209~218
    56 M.Pidd, F.de Silva, R.Eglese. A simulation model for emergency evacuation. European Journal of Operational Research.1996, 90(3): 413~419
    57 F.de Silva, R.Eglese. Integrating simulation modeling and GIS: spatial decision support systems for evacuation planning. Journal of the Operational Research. 2000, (51): 423~430
    58 Post, Buckley, Schuh & Jernigan, Inc. (PBS&J). Southeast United States hurricane evacuation traffic study: reverse lane standards and ITS strategies. Technical Memorandum 3. Technical Report, Tallahassee, Florida, 2000:20~24
    59 H.Tuydes, A.Ziliaskopoulos. Network re-design to optimize evacuation contra-flow. 83rd Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C. 2004:1120~1125
    60 H.Tuydes. Network traffic management under disaster conditions. Northwestern University PhD Thesis, 2005:134~135
    61 H.S.Mahmassani, H.Sbayti. Optimal scheduling of contra-flow operations for network evacuation planning. The 2005 INFORMS Annual Meeting, San Francisco, 2005:1234~1239
    62 B.Wolshon.“One-way-out”: contra-flow freeway operation for hurricaneevacuation. Natural hazards review.2001,12(1):105~112
    63 B.Wolshon. Planning for the evacuation of New Orleans. ITE Journal. 2002, 72 (2): 44~49
    64 G.Theodoulou, B.Wlshon. Modeling and analyses of freeway contra-flow to improve future evacuations. 83rd Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C., 2004: 210~218
    65 E.Lim, B.Wolshon. Modeling and performance assessment of contra-flow evacuation termination points. 84th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D. C., 2005: 230~239
    66 E.Kwon, S.Pitt. Evaluation of emergency evacuation strategies for downtown event traffic using a dynamic network model. 84th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D. C., 2005:11~20
    67 X.Chen, F.B.Zhan.Agent-based modeling and simulation of urban evacuation: relative effectiveness of simultaneous and staged evacuation strategies. 83rd annual conference of Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C.,2004:223~228
    68 S.W. Mitchell, E.Radwan. Heuristic prioritization of emergency evacuation staging to reduce clearance time. 85th annual meeting of transportation research board, Washington, D.C.,2006:654~657
    69 H.Tuydes, A.Ziliaskopoulos. The network evacuation problem and solution algorithms. INFORMS Annual Meeting, San Francisco, 2005:345~353
    70 M.Chen. Traffic signal timing for urban evacuation. Maryland University Master Thesis.2005:78~83
    71 V.P. Sisiopiku, S.L.Jones, A.J.Sullivan. Regional traffic simulation for emergency preparedness. Technical report, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, The University of Alabama, 2004:35~40
    72 G.M.McHale, J.Collura. Improving emergency vehicle traffic signal priority system assessment methodologies. 82nd Annual Meeting of Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C., 2003: 12~20
    73 M.Urbanik, K.Desrosiers.CLEAR (calculated logical evacuation and response): a generic transportation network model for the calculation of evacuation time estimates. Report for the Nuclear Rgulatory Commision by Pacific Northwest Laboratory. NUREGICR-2504. Washington, D.C., 1981: 55~56
    74 R.Tweedie, R.Walsh. A methodology for estimating emergency evacuation times.The Social Science Journal .1986, 21(2):189~204
    75 S.Sinuany. A behavioural-based simulation model for urban evacuation. Regional Science Association. 1989, 6 (6):87~103
    76 A.G. Hobeika, S.Kim, R.E.Beckwith.A decision support system for developing evacuation plans around nuclear power stations. Interfaces, 1994, 24(5):22~35
    77 A.G.Hobeika,C.Kim.Comparison of traffic assignments in evacuation modeling. IEEE transactions on engineering management, 1998, 45(2):192~198
    78 Oak Ridge National Laboratory. Oak Ridge Evacuation Modeling System (OREMS). Research Report, 2004:1~2
    79 A.Z.Ren, C.Chen, Y.Luo. Simulation of Emergency Evacuation in Virtual Reality. Tsinghua Science & Technology.2008,13(5):674~680
    80 K.Uno, K.Kashiyama. Development of Simulation System for the Disaster Evacuation Based on Multi-Agent Model Using GIS. Tsinghua Science & Technology.2008,13(1):348~353
    81国内大城市应急管理系统概况(北京、大连).北京工业大学应急管理论坛网站http://trc.bjut.edu.cn/bbs/dispbbs.jsp?forumID=30&rootID=2649
    82徐高.地铁车站人员疏散的计算机仿真研究.现代隧道技术. 2003, 40(2):32~35
    83肖国清,温丽敏,陈宝智,王浩.毒气泄漏时的最佳疏散路径.东北大学学报. 2001, 22(6):674~677
    84高爱玲.公众聚集场所火灾疏散逃生与自救.现代职业安全.2010,(2):109
    85唐方勤,史文中,任爱珠.基于多层协作机制的人员疏散模拟研究.清华大学学报(自然科学版).2008,48(3):325~329
    86马嘉琪,白雁,齐茂利.基于微观仿真的同站台换乘站客流疏散研究.中国安全科学学报.2009,19(11):172~176
    87张良,吴农,马宏伟等.建筑火灾下人员疏散行为的分析与环境的仿真模拟.安防科技.2009,(11):3~7
    88王勇,夏可成.高层建筑消防安全疏散设计.武警学院学报.2009,25(12):42~44
    89宋文华,祝凌云,李庆功.城市开放场所应急疏散模型建立初探.南开大学学报(自然科学版). 2009,42(6):86~91
    90刘伟,邢志祥,任芳,刘艳.大型公共建筑人员安全疏散的模拟研究.消防科学与技术.2009,28(11):813~816
    91刘小明,胡红.应急交通疏散研究现状与展望.交通运输工程学报.2008,8(3):108~115
    92陈岳明,萧德云.路网应急疏散问题建模及其应用的进展.科学技术与工程.2008,8(17):4945~4952
    93林建新,韦献兰,海燕,张蕊.基于S-曲线的时变交通应急疏散需求预测.交通信息与安全.2009,27(3):92~96
    94安实,崔建勋,王健.基于模糊逻辑与离散选择模型的混合疏散人口估计模型.交通运输工程学报.2009,9(5):78~82
    95陈岳明,萧德云.基于动态交通分配的路网应急疏散模型.清华大学学报(自然科学版).2009,49(8):1102~1105
    96朱耀昆,汪卓.基于单安全点路网模型的区域交通疏散研究.现代交通技术.2009,6(5):58~61
    97袁媛,汪定伟,蒋忠中,盛莹.考虑路线复杂度的应急疏散双目标路径选择模型.运筹与管理.2008,17(5):73~79
    98崔建勋,安实,崔娜.基于元胞传输模型的区域疏散动态交通分配.哈尔滨工业大学学报.2010,42(1):123~127
    99高明霞,贺国光.动态系统最优的疏散路线与出发时间综合优化模型.系统工程.2009,27(6):73~77
    100韦春竹,谢元礼韦韡.基于Dial分流的陆上交通应急疏散模型的优化和实现.测绘技术装备.2009,11(4):13~15
    101高超,蒋光胜,杨孝宽,张雪.城市应急疏散策略.道路交通与安全.2007, 7(3):6~10
    102宫建.奥运应急交通疏散路径选择模型研究.北京工业大学硕士论文.2007.
    103蒋光胜.大城市突发事件交通组织与疏散对策研究.北京工业大学硕士论文. 2006.
    104 F. C. Daganzo.The cell transmission model: A dynamic representation of highway traffic consistent with the hydrodynamic theory. Transportation research Part B. 1994, 28(4): 269~287
    105贾斌等.基于元胞自动机的交通系统建模与模拟.科学出版社,2007:228~229

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700