FDI对中国工业能源效率的影响研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
进入21世纪以来,中国总体经济规模及增长速度已跻身世界前列,然而,能源问题却严重制约中国经济的可持续稳定发展。在未来一段时间,因工业化和城市化进程中国能源消费量及能源消费产生的碳排放还会持续增加。中国政府已向全世界承诺到2020年将碳强度在2005年的基础上减少40%—45%,“十二五”规划也提出要将能源强度降低16%、碳强度降低17%,可见提高能源效率(能源强度的倒数)已经成为中国政府的工作重点。FDI作为国家和地区之间资金流动的主要形式之一,对东道国能源环境产生深刻的影响,尤其是对于那些迫切要求发展经济而放松环境规制吸引外资的国家,外资的进入将会导致一系列的能源环境问题。不过,外资进入东道国可能带来正向的能效技术转移和技术溢出,从而提高东道国的能源效率,作为能源经济学重要假说之一的“FDI能够降低东道国能源强度”是否在中国成立值得深入研究。
     2010年,中国实际利用外资金额达到1057.35亿美元,而在过去十年工业部门实际利用外资金额占到全国利用外资的65%左右。同时,工业部门作为中国国民经济的主要“耗能大户”(比重约为70%左右),其能源效率变动将直接影响中国总体能源效率。因此,准确把握FDI对中国工业能源效率影响的大小,传导渠道和差异,对于制定以提高能源效率为核心的外资政策、产业政策和节能减排措施具有重要的现实意义。鉴于此,本文对如下问题展开研究:
     1.测算中国内外资工业企业全要素能源效率。采用非参数数据包络分析法,对中国工业36个行业1999—2009年的全要素生产率和全要素能源效率进行测算,并进一步测算和比较28个行业内外资工业企业的全要素能源效率。测算结果表明,不管是外资企业还是内资企业,其全要素能源效率表现都不尽如人意,而且似乎与工业全要素生产率及技术进步的表现不相称。
     2.研究FDI技术效应对中国工业能源效率的影响。考虑到技术效应在许多研究中被认为具有较重要的地位,技术效应的方向和大小对于总效应的形成和变化具有较为显著的影响。因此,通过建立理论模型和计量模型,利用中国1999—2008年30个省区工业面板数据,采用静态和动态面板模型集中研究FDI技术效应(包括外资环境收益效应和外资向底线赛跑效应)对中国工业能源效率的影响,同时也对内资企业的国内自主研发、国外技术引进和国内技术购买与工业能源效率之间的关系进行实证分析。实证结果表明,FDI技术效应对中国工业能源强度影响是正面的,FDI技术效应不仅可以降低中国工业能源强度,而且能够降低中国工业能源消费量。
     3.研究FDI对中国工业能源效率的影响总效应。通过建立包含能源强度(或能源消费量)分解方程、FDI规模效应方程、FDI结构效应方程、FDI技术效应方程、FDI收入引致的技术效应方程和FDI区位选择方程的联立方程组,采用三阶段最小二乘法实证估计FDI-中国工业能源强度联立方程组,并用弹性分析法计算FDI路径下不同影响效应的大小和方向。结果表明,1999—2008年,外资进入度提高1%,导致工业行业结构高耗能化进而使工业能源强度上升0.1907%,通过直接提高技术水平和间接提高人均收入使工业能源强度分别下降0.3086%和0.0669%,总效应为工业能源强度减少0.1848%。“FDI能够降低东道国能源强度”假说得以成立。
     4.研究FDI影响中国工业能源效率的传导渠道。通过界定FDI影响中国工业能源效率的三种传导渠道——水平关联、后向关联和前向关联,以中国工业行业面板数据为研究样本,实证分析FDI影响中国工业能源效率的传导渠道。估计结果表明,外资水平关联效应显著降低工业能源强度;下游行业外资企业与上游行业中间产品供应商的联系渠道显著增加工业能源强度,而上游行业外资企业与下游行业购买商的联系渠道对工业能源强度没有产生显著影响。同时,本文还利用时间序列的脉冲响应函数研究中国工业能源效率的结构份额和效率份额在外资冲击下的传导影响。
     最后,在深入研究FDI对中国工业能源效率影响的基础上,从国家层面、区域层面和行业层面提出经济开放条件下提高能源效率的政策建议,如积极利用FDI的技术溢出效应、优化产业结构、鼓励技术创新和加大环境规制力度等。
Since twenty-first century, China's overall economic scale and growth speed havebeen among the forefront of the world, however, the energy problem has seriouslyrestricted the sustainable development of China's economy. In the foreseeable future,energy consumption and carbon emission in China will continue to increase due to theprocess of industrialization and urbanization. China announced that it would aim for a40-45%reduction in carbon intensity between2005and2020as well as a16%reduction in energy intensity and a17%cut in carbon intensity in12th five-year plan,showing that the Chinese government has aimed at improving energy efficiency (theinverse of energy intensity). As one of the main forms of capital flows amongcountries and regions, FDI has a profound impact on energy and environment of thehost country, especially for those who aspire to economic development and relaxenvironment regulation to attract foreign investment, the entry of foreign capital willlead to a series of energy and environmental issues. However, entry of foreign capitalinto the host may bring forward the technology transfers and technology spillovers,then improving the energy efficiency of the host, as one of important hypothesis inenergy economics, whether “FDI can reduce energy intensity of the host countries”hypothesis holds in China is worthy of further study.
     In2010, China's actual utilization of foreign capital is$105.735billion, andactual use of foreign capital in the industrial sector accounted for about65%of thenationwide use of foreign capital over the past decade. At the same time, change ofenergy efficiency in the industrial sector as China's “energy-hungry”(the proportion isabout70%) will directly affect China's overall energy efficiency. Therefore, anaccurate grasp of the sizes, transmission channels and differences of the impacts ofFDI on China's industrial energy efficiency, has important practical significances forthe development of effective foreign investment policy, industrial policy and energysavings and emission reduction measures at the core of improving energy efficiency.In view of this, this study is as follows:
     1.Estimating total factor energy efficiency of the industry in China. Usingnon-parametric data envelopment analysis, total factor productivity and total factorenergy efficiency of36sectors in China's industry from1999to2009are calculated,and the dissertation further estimates and compares total factor energy efficiency of domestic-funded and foreign-funded industrial enterprises in the28sectors. It turnsout that, no matter foreign or domestic enterprises, total factor energy efficiency doesnot perform well, it seems that it is not commensurate with total factor productivityand technical progress of the industry.
     2.Study on the FDI technique effect influencing China's industrial energyefficiency. Many empirical studies identify FDI is closely related to technologytransfers and technology spillovers, through the establishment of theoretical modelsand econometric models in a sample of1999-2008,30provinces, industry panel data,the dissertation studies the impacts of FDI technique effect (including theenvironmental gains from FDI and race to the bottom) on China's industrial energyefficiency using static and dynamic panel data model, but also conducts an empiricalanalysis on the relationship between R&D, foreign technology import and domesticpurchase of domestic enterprises and industrial energy efficiency. The results find thatthe impacts of FDI technique effect on China's industrial energy intensity is positive,FDI technique effect can not only reduce China's industrial energy intensity, but alsoChina's industrial energy consumption.
     3.Study on the total effect of FDI influencing China's industrial energyefficiency. Through the establishment of simultaneous equations including energyintensity (energy consumption) decomposition equation, FDI scale effect equation,FDI composition effect equation, FDI technique effect equation, FDI income-inducedtechnique effect equation and FDI selection equation, the dissertation uses three stageleast squares to empirically estimate simultaneous equations of FDI-China's industrialenergy intensity, and uses the elastic analysis to calculate the magnitude and directionof the different effect of the FDI path. The results show that in1999-2008, the degreeof foreign capital entering raises1%, resulting in heavily energy consumption of theindustrial composition and thus makes the industrial energy intensity increase by0.1907%, by directly raising the technological level and indirectly enhancing the percapita income makes the industrial energy intensity decrease by0.3086%and0.0669%respectivly, the total effect is to make industrial energy intensity decrease by0.1848%. The hypothesis “FDI can reduce the local energy intensity” is to beestablished in China.
     4.Study on the transmission channels of FDI influencing China's industrialenergy efficiency. The dissertation defines the three transmission channels of the effects of FDI on China's industrial energy efficiency—horizontal linkage, backwardlinkage and forward linkage, using a sample of Chinese industrial panel data,empirically analyzes the transmission channels of FDI influencing China's industrialenergy efficiency. The results show that significantly horizontal linkage effect of FDIreduces industrial energy intensity; the linkage channel between foreign-fundedenterprises of downstream industries and intermediate goods suppliers of the upstreamindustry significantly increases industrial energy intensity, and the linkage channelbetween foreign-funded enterprises of upstream industries and buyers of downstreamindustries does not have a significant impact on industrial energy intensity. At thesame time, the dissertation uses the impulse response function of the time series datato analyze the transmission impacts of FDI on the structure share and efficiency shareof China's industrial energy intensity.
     Finally, on the basis of in-depth study on FDI influencing China's industrialenergy efficiency, the dissertation provides policy recommendations for improvingenergy efficiency in the open economy at the national level, regional level andindustry level, such as active use of FDI technology spillovers, optimizing theindustrial structure, encouraging technological innovation and increasingenvironmental regulation and so on.
引文
[1]包群、陈媛媛、宋立刚:外商投资与东道国环境污染:存在倒U型曲线关系吗?《世界经济》2010年第1期。
    [2]蔡昉、都阳、王美艳:经济发展方式转变与节能减排内在动力,《经济研究》2008年第6期。
    [3]陈德敏、张瑞、谭志雄:全要素能源效率与中国经济增长收敛性——基于动态面板数据的实证检验,《中国人口·资源与环境》2012年第1期。
    [4]陈凌佳:FDI环境效应的新检验,《世界经济研究》2008年第9期。
    [5]陈涛涛:中国FDI行业内溢出的内在机制研究,《世界经济》2003年第9期。
    [6]陈涛涛、陈娇:行业增长因素与我国FDI行业内溢出效应,《经济研究》2006年第6期。
    [7]陈小亮、綦建红:中国工业部门外资能源效率的测算与分解,《产业经济评论》2010年第12期。
    [8]陈迎、潘家华、谢来辉:中国外贸进出口商品中的内涵能源及其政策含义,《经济研究》2008年第7期。
    [9]陈诗一:能源消耗、二氧化碳排放与中国工业的可持续发展,《经济研究》2009第4期。
    [10]陈媛媛、王海宁:FDI对省际工业能源效率的影响,《当代财经》2010年第7期。
    [11]陈媛媛、王海宁:FDI、人力资本与省际工业能源效率,《国际贸易问题》2011年第3期。
    [12]陈媛媛、李坤望:中国工业行业SO2排放强度因素分解及其影响因素,《管理世界》2010年第3期。
    [13]代迪尔、李子豪:外商直接投资的碳排放效应——基于中国工业行业数据的研究,《国际经贸探索》2011年第5期。
    [14]杜立民:中国二氧化碳排放的影响因素:基于省级面板数据的研究,《南方经济》2010第11期。
    [15]傅京燕:国际贸易中“污染避难所效应”的实证研究述评,《中国人口资源与环境》2009年第8期。
    [16]高振宇、王益:我国生产用能源消费变动的分解分析,《统计研究》2007年第3期。
    [17]耿强、孙成浩、傅坦:环境管制程度对FDI区位选择影响的实证分析,《南方经济》2010年第6期。
    [18]国家发展和改革委员会能源研究所:中国可持续发展能源暨碳排放情景分析,2003年5月。
    [19]郭红燕、韩立岩:外商直接投资、环境管制与环境污染,《国际贸易问题》2008年第8期。
    [20]杭雷鸣、屠梅曾:能源价格对能源强度的影响——以国内制造业为例,《数量经济技术经济研究》2006年第12期。
    [21]何小钢、张耀辉:中国工业碳排放影响因素与CKC重组效应——基于STIRPAT模型的分行业动态面板数据实证研究,《中国工业经济》2012第1期。
    [22]胡永泰、海闻、金毅彪:中国企业改革究竟获得了多大成功?《经济研究》1994年第9期。
    [23]黄玖立、李坤望:出口开放、地区市场规模和经济增长,《经济研究》2006年第6期。
    [24]黄肖琦、柴敏:新经济地理学视角下的FDI区位选择——基于中国省际面板数据的实证分析,《管理世界》2006年第10期。
    [25]黄莹、王良健、李桂峰:基于空间面板模型的我国环境库兹涅茨曲线的实证分析,《南方经济》2009第10期。
    [26]蒋殿春、夏良科:外商直接投资对中国高技术产业技术创新作用的经验分析,《世界经济》2005年第8期。
    [27]孔婷、孙林岩、何哲、孙荣庭:能源价格对制造业能源强度调节效应的实证研究,《管理科学》2008年第3期。
    [28]赖明勇、包群、彭水军、张新:外商直接投资与技术外溢——基于吸收能力的研究,《经济研究》2005年第8期。
    [29]李国璋、王双:中国能源强度变动的区域因素分解分析——基于LMDI分解方法,《财经研究》2008年第8期。
    [30]李京文、郑友敬、杨树庄、垄飞鸿:中国经济增长分析,《中国社会科学》1992年第1期。
    [31]李京文、钟学艺:中国生产率分析前沿,社会科学文献出版社,1998。
    [32]李锴、齐绍洲:贸易开放、经济增长与中国二氧化碳排放,《经济研究》2011年第11期。
    [33]李廉水、周勇:技术进步能提高能源效率吗,《管理世界》2006年第10期。
    [34]李未无:对外开放与能源利用效率:基于35个工业行业的实证研究,《国际贸易问题》2008年第6期。
    [35]李小平、卢现祥:国际贸易、污染产业转移与中国工业CO2排放,《经济研究》2010年第1期。
    [36]李小平、朱钟棣:中国工业行业全要素生产率的测算——基于工业行业的面板数据分析,《管理世界》2005年第4期。
    [37]林伯强、蒋竺均:中国二氧化碳的环境库兹涅茨曲线预测及影响因素分析,《管理世界》2009年第4期。
    [38]刘畅、孔宪丽、高铁梅:中国工业行业能源消耗强度变动及影响因素的实证分析,《资源科学》2008年第9期。
    [39]刘强、庄幸、姜克隽、韩文科:中国出口贸易中的载能量及碳排放量分析,《中国工业经济》2008年第8期。
    [40]陆旸:环境规制影响了污染密集型商品的贸易比较优势吗?《经济研究》2009年第4期。
    [41]罗堑:我国污染密集型工业品贸易的环境效应研究,《国际贸易问题》2007年第10期。
    [42]罗堑:中国污染密集型产品贸易的环境效应及其扭曲——兼论效应分解与估计方法的改进,《国际贸易问题》2010年第4期。
    [43]刘红玖、陶全:大中型工业企业能源密度下降的动因探析,《统计研究》2002年第9期。
    [44]刘华军、闫庆悦:贸易开放、FDI与中国CO2排放,《数量经济技术经济研究》2011年第3期。
    [45]庞瑞芝:经济转型期间中国工业增长与全要素能源效率,《中国工业经济》2009年第3期。
    [46]庞瑞芝:中国省际工业增长模式与提升路径分析——基于工业部门全要素能源效率视角,《中国地质大学学报(社会科学版)》2011年第7期。
    [47]彭水军、刘安平:中国对外贸易的环境影响效应:基于环境投入—产出模型的经验研究,《世界经济》2010年第5期。
    [48]邱斌、杨帅、辛培江:FDI技术溢出渠道与中国制造业生产率增长研究:基于面板数据的分析,《世界经济》2008年第8期。
    [49]邵军、管驰明:中国工业部门能源使用效率及其影响因素研究,《经济学家》2009年第1期。
    [50]沈坤荣、耿强:外国直接投资、技术外溢与内生经济增长,《中国社会科学》2001年第5期。
    [51]沈利生:中国对外贸易结构变化不利于节能降耗,《管理世界》2007年第10期
    [52]沈利生、唐志:对外贸易对中国污染排放的影响,《管理世界》2008年第6期。
    [53]史丹:我国经济增长过程中能源利用效率的改进,《经济研究》2002年第9期。
    [54]史丹:中国能源效率的地区差异与节能潜力分析,《中国工业经济》2006年第10期。
    [55]宋德勇、易艳春:外商直接投资与中国碳排放,《中国人口资源与环境》2011年第1期。
    [56]苏梽芳、廖迎、李颖:是什么导致了“污染天堂”:贸易还是FDI?——来自中国省级面板数据的证据,《经济评论》2011年第5期。
    [57]滕玉华:自主研发、技术引进与中国工业能源强度——基于31个行业的实证分析,《财经论丛》2009年第3期。
    [58]滕玉华:国际R&D溢出与工业能源效率——基于进口贸易的实证分析,《国际贸易问题》2010年第5期。
    [59]董利:我国能源效率变化趋势的影响因素分析,《产业经济研究》2008年第1期。
    [60]王锋等,中国经济发展中碳排放增长的驱动因素研究,《经济研究》2010年第2期。
    [61]王海宁:FDI、出口密集度与环境技术效率——基于产业数据的分位数回归方法分析,《财贸研究》2011年第4期。
    [62]王群伟、周德群:中国全要素能源效率变动的实证研究,《系统工程》2008年第7期。
    [63]王庆一:中国的能源效率及国际比较,《节能与环保》2003年第9期。
    [64]王小鲁:中国经济增长的可持续性与制度变革,《经济研究》2000年第7期。
    [65]王耀中、刘舜佳:基于前后向关联分析的外商直接投资与技术外溢,《经济评论》2005年第6期。
    [66]魏楚、沈满洪:能源效率及其影响因素:基于DEA的实证分析,《管理世界》2007年第8期。
    [67]魏楚、沈满洪:规模效率与配置效率:一个对中国能源低效的解释,《世界经济》2009年第4期。
    [68]吴巧生、成金华:中国工业化中的能源消耗强度变动及因素分析——基于分解模型的实证分析,《财经研究》2006年第6期。
    [69]吴献金、邓杰:贸易自由化、经济增长对碳排放的影响,《中国人口资源与环境》2011年第1期。
    [70]吴延兵:R&D与生产率:基于中国制造业的实证研究,《经济研究》2006年第11期。
    [71]吴延兵:自主研发、技术引进与生产率——基于中国地区工业的实证研究,《经济研究》2008年第8期。
    [72]谢千里、罗斯基、郑玉歆和王莉:所有制形式与中国工业生产率变动趋势,《数量经济技术经济研究》2001年第3期。
    [73]许和连、魏颖绮、赖明勇等:外商直接投资的后向链接溢出效应研究,《管理世界》2007年第4期。
    [74]杨博琼、陈建国:FDI对东道国环境污染影响的实证研究——基于我国省际面板数据的分析,《国际贸易问题》2011年第3期。
    [75]杨海生、贾佳、周永章、王树功:贸易、外商直接投资、经济增长与环境污染,《中国人口资源与环境》2005年第3期。
    [76]杨万平、袁晓玲:对外贸易、FDI对环境污染的影响分析——基于中国时间序列的脉冲响应函数分析:1982—2006,《世界经济研究》2008年第12期。
    [77]姚洋:非国有经济成分对我国工业企业技术效率的影响,《经济研究》1998年第12期。
    [78]姚愉芳、陈杰等:结构变化的节能潜力计算的方法论研究,《数量经济技术经济研究》2007年第4期。
    [79]叶素云、叶振宇:FDI对我国地区能源强度影响的经验研究,《国际贸易问题》2010年第9期。
    [80]尹宗成、丁日佳、江激宇:FDI、人力资本、R&D与中国能源效率,《财贸经济》2008年第9期。
    [81]应瑞瑶、周力:外商直接投资、工业污染与环境规制——基于中国数据的计量经济学分析,《财贸经济》2006年第1期。
    [82]于峰、齐建国:开放经济下环境污染的分解分析——基于1990—2003年间我国各省市的面板数据,《统计研究》2007年第1期。
    [83]于峰、齐建国、田晓林:经济发展对环境质量影响的实证分析——基于1999—2004年间各省市的面板数据,《中国工业经济》2006年第8期。
    [84]袁晓玲、张宝山、杨万平:基于环境污染的中国全要素能源效率研究,《中国工业经济》2009年第2期。
    [85]张海洋:R&D两面性、外资活动与中国工业生产率增长,《经济研究》2005年第5期。
    [86]张军、施少华:中国经济全要素生产率变动:1952—1998,《世界经济文汇》2003年第2期。
    [87]张军、吴桂英、张吉鹏:中国省际物质资本存量估算:1952—2000,《经济研究》2004年第10期。
    [88]张连众、朱坦、李慕涵、张伯伟:贸易自由化对我国环境影响的实证分析,《南开经济评论》2003年第3期。
    [89]张贤、周勇:外商直接投资对我国能源强度的空间效应分析,《数量经济技术经济研究》2007年第1期。
    [90]张友国:中国贸易增长的能源环境代价,《数量经济技术经济研究》2009年第1期。
    [91]张伟、吴文元:基于环境绩效的长三角都市圈全要素能源效率研究,《经济研究》2011年10期。
    [92]曾贤刚、庞含霜:我国各省区CO2排放状况、趋势及其减排对策,《中国软科学》2009年第9期。
    [93]赵国庆、张中元:FDI溢出效应、环境污染与全要素增长率,《世界经济文汇》2010年第4期。
    [94]赵细康:环境保护与产业国际竞争力,北京:中国社会科学出版社,2003。
    [95]郑京海、胡鞍钢:中国改革时期省级生产率增长变化的实证分析,《经济学季刊》2005年第1期。
    [96]周力、应瑞瑶:外商直接投资与工业污染,《中国人口资源与环境》2009年第4期。
    [97]周勇、李廉水:技术进步能提高能源效率吗?——基于中国工业部门的实证检验,《管理世界》2006年第10期。
    [98]周黎安:中国地方官员的晋升锦标赛模式研究,《经济研究》2007年第7期。
    [99]朱平芳、徐伟民:政府的科技激励政策对大中型工业企业R&D投入及其专利产出的影响,《经济研究》2003年第6期。
    [100]朱平芳、张征宇、姜国麟:FDI与环境规制:基于地方分权视角的实证研究,《经济研究》2011年第6期。
    [101]庄惠明、赵春明、郑伟腾:中国对外贸易的环境效应实证——基于规模、技术和结构三种效应的考察,《经济管理》2009年第5期。
    [102] Acemoglu, D., Johnson, S. and Robinson, J. A.,2005,“The Rise of Europe: Atlantic Trade,Institutional Change and Economic Growth”, American Economic Review,95(3),546-579.
    [103] Aitken, B.J. and A.E. Harrison,1999,“Do Domestic Firms Benefit from Direct ForeignInvestment? Evidence from Venezuela”, American Economic Review,89(3),605-618.
    [104] Albornoz, et al.,2009,“In Search of Environmental Spillovers,” The World Economy, Vol.32,pp.136-163.
    [105] Ang, B.W., Liu Na,2007,“Energy Decomposition Analysis: IEA Model versus otherMethods”, Energy Policy,35,1426-1432.
    [106] Ang, J.,2009,“CO2Emissions, Research and Technology Transfer in China”, EcologicalEconomics,68(10),2658-2665.
    [107] Antweiler, Werner, Brian R. Copeland, and M. Scott Taylor,2001,“Is Free Trade Good forthe Environment?” American Economic Review,91(4):877-908.
    [108] Arellano, Manuel and Bond, Stephen,1991,“Some Tests of Specification for Panel Data:Monte Carlo Evidence and an Application to Employment Equations”, Review of EconomicStudies,58(2),277-297.
    [109] Bao Qun, Chen Yuanyuan,2008,“The Environmental Consequences of Foreign DirectInvestment in China”, in China’s Dilemma: Economic Growth, the Environment and ClimateChange, Edited by Ligang Song and Wing Thye Woo, Brookings Institution Press.
    [110] Barro, R.J. and Jong-Wha, Lee,1993,“International Comparisons of EducationalAttainment”, Journal of Monetary Economics,32,361-394.
    [111] Baumol, W. and W. Oates,1998,“The Theory of Environmental Policy”,2nd edition, NewYork: Cambridge University Press.
    [112] Bhagwati, Jagdish,1993,“The Case for Free Trade”, Scientific American,269(5):18-23.
    [113] Birdsall, N. and D. Wheeler,1993,“Trade Policy and Industrial Pollution in Latin America:Where are the Pollution Havens?” Journal of Environment and Development,2(1):137-149.
    [114] Blackman, Allen&Wu, Xun,1999,“Foreign Direct Investment in China's Power Sector:Trends, Benefits and Barriers”, Energy Policy, vol.27(12),695-711.
    [115] Blundell, Richard and Bond, Stephen,1998,“Initial Conditions and Moment Restrictions inDynamic Panel Data Models”, Journal of Econometrics,87(1),115-143.
    [116] Bond, S. R., Hoeffler, A. and Temple, J.,2001,“GMM Estimation of Empirical GrowthModels”, CEPR Discussion Paper3048.
    [117] Bosetti, Valentina&Carraro, Carlo&Massetti, Emanuele&Tavoni, Massimo,2008,“International Energy R&D Spillovers and the Economics of Greenhouse Gas AtmosphericStabilization”, Energy Economics, vol.30(6),2912-2929.
    [118] Busse, M.,2004,“Trade, Environmental Regulations and the WTO—New EmpiricalEvidence”, Journal of World Trade,38(2),285-306.
    [119] Caselli, F., Esquivel G. and Lefort, F.,1996,“Reopening the Convergence Debate: A NewLook at Cross-country Growth Empirics”, Journal of Economic Growth,1(3),363-389.
    [120] Castellani, Davide&Zanfei, Antonello,2003.“Technology Gaps, Absorptive Capacity andthe Impact of Inward Investments on Productivity of European Firms”, Economics ofInnovation and New Technology, vol.12(6),555-576.
    [121] Catherine, Y.C.&J.A. List&L.D. Qui,2004,“Intellectual Property Rights, EnvironmentalRegulations, and Foreign Direct Investment”, Land Economics, vol.80(2),153-173.
    [122] Caves, R.E.,1974,“Multinational Firms, Competition and Productivity in Host-countryMarkets”, Economica,41, pp.176-193.
    [123] Caves, R.E.,1982,“Multinational Enterprises and Technology Transfer”, in Alan M. Rugman,ed., New Theories of the Multinational Enterprise.
    [124] Charnes, A., Cooper, W.W., Rhodes, E.,1978,“Measuring the Efficiency of Decision MakingUnits”, European JournaI of Operations Resarch,2,429-449.
    [125] Chen, K.; Wang, H.C.; Zheng, Y.X.; Jefferson, G.H. and Rawski, T.G.,1988,“ProductivityChange in Chinese Industry,1953-1985”, Journal of Comparative Economics,12, pp.570-591.
    [126] Chudnovsky, D. and G. Pupato,2005,“Environmental Management and Innovation inArgentine Industry: Determinants and Policy Implications”, mimeo, Buenos Aires: CENIT.
    [127] Cohen, Wesley, M. and Levinthal, Daniel, A.,1989,“Innovation and Learning: The TwoFaces of R&D”, Economic Journal, Vol.99, pp.569-596.
    [128] Coelli, T.J., D.S. Prasada Rao and G.E. Battese,1998,“An Introduction to Efficiency andProductivity Analysis”, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston.
    [129] Cole M.A.&A.J. Rayner&J.M. Bates,1998,“Trade Liberalisation and the Environment:The Case of the Uruguay Round,” The World Economy, vol.21(3),337-347.
    [130] Cole, M.A. and Elliott, R.J.R.,2003a,“Do Environmental Regulations Influence TradePatterns? Testing Old and New Trade Theories”, The World Economy, Vol.26,8,pp.1163-1186.
    [131] Cole, M.A. and Elliott, R.J.R.,2003b,“Determining the Trade–environment CompositionEffect: the Role of Capital, Labor and Environmental Regulations”, Journal of EnvironmentalEconomics and Management,46(3),363-383.
    [132] Cole, M.A., Elliott, R.J. and Shimamoto, K.,2005,“Industrial Characteristics, EnvironmentalRegulation and Air Pollution: An Analysis of the UK Manufacturing Sector”, Journal ofEnvironmental Economics and Management,50,121-143.
    [133] Cole, M.A., Elliott, R.J.&P.G. Fredriksson,2006,“Endogenous Pollution Havens: Does FDIInfluence Environmental Regulations?” Scandinavian Journal of Economics, vol.108(1),157-178.
    [134] Cole, M.A., Elliott, R.J. and Wu, S.,2008,“Industrial Activity and the Environment in China:An Industry-Level Analysis”, China Economic Review,19,393-408.
    [135] Colby, H., X. Diao and A. Somwaru,2000,“Cross Commodity Analysis of China’s GrainSector: Sources of Growth and Supply Growth”, Technical Bulletin, No.1884, EconomicResearch Service, USDA, Washington D.C.
    [136] Coondoo, D. and Dinda S.,2002,“Causality between Income and Emission: a CountryGroup Specific Econometric Analysis”, Ecological Economics,40(3),351-353.
    [137] Copeland, Brian R.&Taylor, M Scott,1994,“North-South Trade and the Environment,” TheQuarterly Journal of Economics, vol.109(3),755-87.
    [138] Copeland, Brian R.&Taylor, M. Scott,1997,“The Trade-induced Degradation Hypothesis,”Resource and Energy Economics, vol.19(4),321-344.
    [139] Copeland, Brian R.&Taylor, M. Scott,2004,“Trade, Growth, and the Environment,”Journal of Economic Literature, vol.42(1),7-71.
    [140] Copeland, Brian R.&Taylor, M. Scott,2005,“Free Trade and Global Warming: a TradeTheory View of the Kyoto Protocol,” Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,vol.49(2),205-234.
    [141] Daly, H. and R. Goodland,1994,“An Ecological Assessment of Deregulation ofInternational Commerce under GATT”, Ecological Economics,9,73-92.
    [142] Das, S.,1987,“Externalities, and Technology Transfers through Multinational Corporations:A Theoretical Analysis”, Journal of International Economics, Vol.22,171-182.
    [143] Dean, J., Mary, E. and Hua Wang,2009,“Are Foreign Investors Attracted to WeakEnvironmental Regulations? Evaluating the Evidence from China”, Journal of DevelopmentEconomics,90,1-13.
    [144] Dinda, S.,2004,“Environmental Kuznets Curve Hypothesis: A Survey”, EcologicalEconomics,49,431-455.
    [145] Djankov, Simeon&Hoekman, Bernard,2000,“Foreign Investment and Productivity Growthin Czech Enterprises”, World Bank Economic Review, vol.14(1),49-64.
    [146] Dua, A., Esty, D.C.,1997,“Sustaining the Asia Pacific Miracle: Environmental Protectionand Economic Integration,” Washington, D.C., Institute for International Economics,57-60.
    [147] Ederington, J.&Minier, J.,2003,“Is Environmental Policy a Secondary Trade Barrier? AnEmpirical Analysis”, Canadian Journal of Economics,36(1),137-154.
    [148] Eliste, Paavo, and P. G. Fredriksson,1998,“Does Open Trade Result in a Race to the Bottom?Cross Country Evidence,” mimeo, The World Bank.
    [149] Elliott, R. J. R., Shimamoto, K.,2008,“Are ASEAN Countries Havens for JapanesePollution-Intensive Industry?” World Economy,31,236-254.
    [150] Eskeland, G.S.&Harrison, A.E.,2003,“Moving to Greener Pastures? Multinationals and thePollution Haven Hypothesis”, Journal of Development Economics,70:1-23.
    [151] Esty, Daniel, and Bradford, Gentry,1997,“Foreign Investment, Globalisation and theEnvironment”, Globalization and the Environment, Edited by Tom Jones (Organization forEconomic Cooperation and Development: Paris).
    [152] Esty, D.&Geradin, D.,1997,“Market Access, Competitiveness, and Harmonization:Environmental Protection in Regional Trade Agreements”, The Harvard Environmental LawReview, Vol.21No.2, pp.265-336.
    [153] Fan Ying et al.,2007,“Changes in Carbon Intensity in China: Empirical Findings from1980-2003”, Ecological Economics,62,683-691.
    [154] Fare, R., Grosskopf, S., Norrism, et al.,1994,“Productivity Growth, Technical Progress, andEfficiency Change in Industrialized Countries”, American Economic Review,84(1),66-83.
    [155] Findlay, R.,1978,“Relative Backwardness, Direct Foreign Investment, and the Transfer ofTechnology: A Simple Dynamic Model”, Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol.92,1-16.
    [156] Fisher-Vanden K., Gary, H. Jefferson, Hongmei Liu, Quan Tao,2004,“What is DrivingChina’s Decline in Energy Intensity?” Resource and Energy Economics,26(1),77-97.
    [157] Fisher-Vanden, K. et al.,2006,“Technology Development and Energy Productivity inChina”, Energy Economics,28,690-705.
    [158] Frankel, J.A.&A.K., Rose,2005,“Is Trade Good or Bad for the Environment? Sorting Outthe Causality”, The Review of Economics and Statistics,87,85-91.
    [159] Frankel, Jeffrey and David, Romer,1999,“Does Trade Cause Growth?” American EconomicReview,89(3),379-399.
    [160] Fredriksson P.G. and Paavo Eliste,2004,“Does Trade Liberalization Cause a Race to thebottom in Environmental Policies? A Spatial Econometric Analysis”, Ch.18in Advances inSpatial Econometrics: Methodology, Tools, and Applications, edited by L. Anselin, R.J.G.M.Florax and S.J. Rey, Berlin: Springer.
    [161] Friedl, B. and M. Getzner,2003,“Determinants of CO2Emissions in a Small OpenEconomy”, Ecological Economics,45,133-148.
    [162] Galeotti, M., Lanza, A. and Pauli, F.,2006,“Reassessing the Environmental Kuznets Curvefor CO2Emissions: A Robustness Exercise”, Ecological Economics, Vol.57, pp.152-163.
    [163] Gorg, H. and D. Greenaway,2004,“Much Ado about Nothing? Do Domestic Firms ReallyBenefit from Foreign Direct Investment?” World Bank Research, Vol.19, No.2, pp.171-197.
    [164] Gorg, H. and Strobl, E.,2001,“Multinational Companies and Productivity Spillovers: A MetaAnalysis”, Economic Journal,111(473):723-739.
    [165] Griliches, Z.,1986,“Productivity, R&D and Basic Research at the Firm Level in the1970s”,American Economic Review,76(6),141-154.
    [166] Grossman, H. and Helpman, E,1991,“Quality Ladder in the Theory of Growth”, Review ofEconomic Studies,58,43-61.
    [167] Grossman, G. and Krueger, A.,1991,“Environmental Impacts of the North American FreeTrade Agreement”, NBER Working Paper, No.3914.
    [168] Grossman, G. M. and Krueger, A.,1993,“Environmental Impacts of A North American FreeTrade Agreement”, in P. Garber, ed., The US-Mexico Free Trade Agreement, Cambridge MA:MIT Press,13-56.
    [169] Grossman, G. M. and Krueger, A.,1995,“Economic Growth and Environment”, QuarterlyJournal of Economics, Vol.110,357-378.
    [170] Groves, T., Y. Hong, J. McMillan and B. Naughton,1994,“Autonomy and Incentives inChinese State Enterprises,” Quarterly Journal of Economics,109,183-209.
    [171] Haddad, M.&Harrison, A.,1993,“Are There Spillovers from Direct Foreign Investment?Evidence from Panel Data for Morocco”, Journal of Development Economics,42:51-74.
    [172] Hall, B.H. and Mairesse, J.,1995,“Exploring the Relationship between R&D andProductivity in French Manufacturing Firms”, Journal of Econometrics,65,263-293.
    [173] Hang Leiming, Tu Meizeng,2007,“The Impacts of Energy Prices on Energy Intensity:Evidence from China”, Energy Policy,35:2978-2988.
    [174] Hansen, M.W.,2004,“Foreign Direct Investment and the Environment: A Transaction CostPerspective”, Journal of Transnational Management Development,8(4),55-80.
    [175] He, Jie,2006,“Pollution Haven Hypothesis and Environmental Impacts of Foreign DirectInvestment: The Case of Industrial Emission of Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) in Chinese Provinces”,Ecological Economics, vol.60(1),228-245.
    [176] He, Jie,2008,“Foreign Direct Investment and Air Pollution In China: Evidence FromChinese Cities”, Region et Developpement, vol.28,131-150.
    [177] Heinz Welsch, and Ochsen, C.,2005,“The Determinants of Aggregate Energy Use in WestGermany: Factor Substitution, Technological Change, and Trade”, Energy Economics,27(1),93-111.
    [178] Hettige, H., Mani, M. and Wheeler, D.,2000,“Industrial Pollution in EconomicDevelopment: Kuznets Revisited”, Journal of Development Economics,62,445-476.
    [179] Hu, J. L., S.C. Wang,2006,“Total Factor Energy Efficiency of Regions in China”, EnergyPolicy,34(17),3206-3217.
    [180] Huang, J.P.,1993,“Industry Energy Use and Structural Change: a Case Study of the People’Republic of China”, Energy Economics,15,131-136.
    [181] Huang, Y. and X. Meng,1999,“China’s Industrial Growth and Efficiency: A Comparisonbetween the State and TVE Sectors”, Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy,2,101-121.
    [182] Hübler, Michael,2009,“Energy Saving Technology Diffusion via FDI and Trade: A CGEModel of China”, Kiel Working Papers, No.1479.
    [183] Hübler, Michael&Keller, Andreas,2010,“Energy Savings via FDI? Empirical Evidencefrom Developing Countries”, Environment and Development Economics, vol.15(1),59-80.
    [184] IPCC,2006,“Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories”. http://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp.
    [185] Jaffe, A.B., Peterson, S.R., Portney, P.R., Stavins, R.N.,1995,“Environmental Regulationand the Competitiveness of US Manufacturing: What Does the Evidence Tell US?” Journalof Economic Literature,33,132-163.
    [186] Javorcik, B.S.,2002,“Spillovers from Foreign Investment through Backward Linkages: DoesTechnology Gap Matter?” Mimeo, Washington, D. C., the World Bank.
    [187] Javorcik, B.S.,2004,“Does Foreign Direct Investment Increase the Productivity of Domesticfirms in Search of Spillovers through Backward Linkages?” American Economic Review,94(3), pp.605-627.
    [188] Jefferson, G.H., Rawski, T.G. and Zheng, Y.,1992,“Growth, Efficiency and Convergence inChina’s State and Collective Industry”, Economic Development and Cultural Change,40, pp.239-266.
    [189] Jin, S., J. Huang, R. Hu and S. Rozelle,2002,“The Creation and Spread of Technology andTotal Factor Productivity in China’s Agriculture”, American Journal of AgriculturalEconomics,84(4), pp.916-930.
    [190] Keller, W,2004,“International Technology Diffusion”, Journal of Economic Literature,42,752-782.
    [191] Koizumi, T. and K.J. Kopecky,1977,“Economic Growth, Capital Movements and theInternational Transfer of Technical Knowledge”, Journal of International Economics, Vol.7,45-65.
    [192] Kokko, A.,1996,“Productivity Spillovers from Competition between Local Firms andForeign Affiliates”, Journal of International Development,8(4),517-530.
    [193] Kennedy, P.W.,1994,“Equilibrium Pollution Taxes in Open Economies with ImperfectCompetiton”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, Vol.27, pp.49-63.
    [194] Lall, Sanjaya,1980,“Vertical Inter-Firm Linkage in LDCs: An Empirical Study”, OxfordBulletin of Economic and Statistics,42, pp.203-216.
    [195] Letchumanan, R. and Kodama, F.,2000,“Reconciling the Conflict between the‘Pollution-Haven’ Hypothesis and an Emerging Trajectory of International TechnologyTransfer”, Research Policy,29:59-79.
    [196] Levinson, Arik,1997,“A Note on Environmental Federalism: Interpreting SomeContradictory Results”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, vol.33(3),pp.359-366.
    [197] Liang, J. and McKitrick R.,2002,“Income Growth and Air Quality in Toronto:1973-1997”,University of Guelph, Economics Department.
    [198] Liao, H., Fan, Y. and Wei, Y.,2007,“What Induced China's Energy Intensity to Fluctuate:1997–2006?” Energy Policy,35(9):4640-4649.
    [199] List, J., McHone, W. and Millimet, D.,2004,“Effects of Environmental Regulation onForeign and Domestic Plant Births: Is There a Home Field Advantage?” Journal of UrbanEconomics,56,303-326.
    [200] Liu, Zhuomin and Lin, P.,2004,“Backward Linkages of Foreign Direct Investment:Evidence from China”, Lingnan University Workingpaper.
    [201] Liu, Z.,2008,“Foreign Direct Investment and Technology Spillovers: Theory and Evidence”,Journal of Development Economics,85(1),176-193.
    [202] Lopez, J.,2003,“NAFTA and Mexico's Manufacturing Productivity: An EmpiricalInvestigation Using Micro-level Data, Journal of LACEA,4(1), pp.55-98.
    [203] Ma, C.&Stern,2007,“China’s Carbon Emissions1971-2003”, Rensselaer Working Papersin Economics, No.0706.
    [204] Ma, Chunbo&Stern, David I.,2008,“China's Changing Energy Intensity Trend: ADecomposition Analysis”, Energy Economics, vol.30(3),1037-1053.
    [205] Mansfield, E. and A. Romeo,1980,“Technology Transfer to Overseas Subsidiaries byU.S.-based Firms”, Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol.95,737-750.
    [206] Marian, Leimbach&Lavinia, Baumstark,2010,“The Impact of Capital Trade andTechnological Spillovers on Climate Policies, Ecological Economics,69,2341-2355.
    [207] Markusen, J. R., Morey, E. and N. Oliwiler,1993,“Environmental Policy when MarketStructure and Plant Locations are Endogenous”, Journal of Environmental Economics andManagement, Vol.24, pp.69-86.
    [208] Mielnik, O. and J. Goldemberg,2002,“Foreign Direct Investment and Decoupling betweenEnergy and Gross Domestic Product in Developing Countries”, Energy Policy,30:87-89.
    [209] Mongelli, I., Tassielli, G. and Notarnicola, B.,2006,“Global Warming Agreements,International Trade and Energy-Carbon Embodiments: An Input-output Approach to theItalian Case”, Energy Policy,34,88-100.
    [210] Munksgaard, J. and Pedersen, K.,2001,“CO2Accounts for Open Economies: Producer orConsumer Responsibility?” Energy Policy,29(4), pp.327-335.
    [211] Nishimizu, M. and J.M. Page,1982,“Total Factor Productivity Growth, Technical Progressand Technical Efficiency Change: Dimensions of Productivity Change in Yugoslavia,1965~78,” The Economic Journal,92,929-936.
    [212] Nohman, A., Antrobus, G.,2005,“Trade and the Environmental Kuznets Curve: is SouthernAfrica a Pollution Heaven?” South African Journal of Economic,73,803-814.
    [213] Pakes, A. and Schankerman, M.,1984,“Rates of Obsolescence of Knowledge, ResearchGestation Lags, and the Private Rate of Return to Research Resources”, in Griliches, Z.(ed),R&D, Patents and Productivity, Chicago: University of Chicago Press,73-88.
    [214] Panayotou, T.,2000,“Globalization and Environment”, Center for InternationalDevelopment, Harvard University, CID Working Paper, No.53.
    [215] Panayotou, T.,2003,“Economic Growth and the Environment”, Economic Survey of Europe,No.2.
    [216] Patterson, M.G.,1996,“What is Energy Efficiency? Concepts, Indicators and MethodologicalIssues”, Energy Policy,24(5), pp.377-390.
    [217] Perkins, R.&Neumayer, E.,2008,“Fostering Environment Efficiency through TransnationalLinkages? Trajectories of CO2and SO2,1980–2000”, Environment and Planning A, vol.40(12),2970-2989.
    [218] Peters, G.P., E.G. Herteieh,2006,“Structural Analysis of International Trade: EnvironmentalImpacts of Norway”, Economic Systems Research, Vol.18(2),155-181.
    [219] Porter, Michael, and Claas van der Linde,1995,“Toward a New Conception of theEnvironment Competitiveness Relationship”, Journal of Economic Perspectives,9(4),97-118.
    [220] Roodman, David,2006,“How to do Xtabond2: An Introduction to Difference and SystemGMM in Stata”, Center for Global Development Working Paper, No.103.
    [221] Runge, C.,1993,“Economic Trade and Environment Protection”, In: J. Braden, H. Folmerand T. Ulen (Eds.), Environmental Policy with Economic and Polotical Integration: TheEuropean Community and the United States, Edward Elgar.
    [222] Sadayuki, Takii,2005,“Productivity Spillovers and Characteristics of Foreign MultinationalPlants in Indonesian Manufacturing1990~1995”, Journal of Development Economics,76, pp.521-542.
    [223] Savas Alpay, Ahmet Caliskan and Syed Mahmud,2001,“Environmental Policy Performance,Economic Growth and Trade Liberalization: A Cross-Country Empirical Analysis,” The2001Open Meeting of the Human Dimensions of Global Environmental Change ResearchCommunity, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, October6-8.
    [224] Schmalensee, R., Stoker, T.M., Judson, R.A.,1998,“World Carbon Dioxide Emission:1950-2050”, The Review of Economics and Statistics,80(1):85-101.
    [225] Selden, T.M.&Forrest, A.S.&Lockhart, J.E.,1999,“Analyzing the Reductions in U.S. AirPollution Emissions:1970to1990”, Land Economics, vol.75(1), pp.1-21.
    [226] Sinton, J.E. and M.D. Levine,1994,“Changing Energy Intensity in Chinese Industry,”Energy Policy,17,239-255.
    [227] Strutt, Anna&Kym, Anderson,2000,“Will Trade Liberalization Harm the Environment?The Case of Indonesia to2020”, Environmental&Resource Economics, vol.17(3),203-232.
    [228] Sun, J.W.,1998,“Changes in Energy Consumption and Energy Intensity: A completeDecomposition Mode”, Energy Economics, vol.20(1),85-100.
    [229] Swan, P.L.,1973,“The International Diffusion of an Innovation”, Journal of IndustrialEconomics, Vol.22,61-69.
    [230] Tobey, J.A.,1990,“The Effects of Domestic Environmental Policies and Patterns of WorldTrade: An Empirical Test”, Kyklos,43(2),191-209.
    [231] Verbeke, T. and M.D. Clercq,2002,“Environmental Quality and Economic Growth”, GhentUniversity, Working Paper, No.128.
    [232] Vogel, David,1995,“Trading Up: Consumer and Environmental Regulation in a GlobalEconomy”, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
    [233] Vogel, David,2001,“Is There a Race to the Bottom? The Impact of Globalization onNational Regulatory Policies?” The Tocqueville Review/La Revue Tocqueville, Vol. XXII,NO.1.
    [234] Wang et al.,2005,“Decomposition of CO2Emissions Change in China,1980-2000”, Energy,30,73-83.
    [235] Wang, H., Y. Jin,2007,“Industrial Ownership and Environmental Performance: Evidencefrom China”, Environmental and Resource Economics,3,255-273.
    [236] Wang, J.Y. and M. Blomstorm,1992,“Foreign Investment and Technology Transfer-ASimple Model”, European Economic Review,36,137-155.
    [237] Wheeler, D.,2001,“Racing to the Bottom? Foreign Investment and Air Pollution inDeveloping Countries”, Journal of Environment and Development,10(3), pp.225-245.
    [238] World Bank (WB),2000,“Is Globalization Causing A Race To The Bottom In EnvironmentalStandards?” World Bank Briefing Papers-Part4. April.
    [239] Xing, Y.&C.D. Kolstad,2002,“Do Lax Environmental Regulations Attract ForeignInvestment?” Environmental and Resource Economics,21(1),1-22.
    [240] Young, Alwyn,2003,“Gold into Base Metals: Productivity Growth in the People's Republicof China during the Reform Period”, Journal of Political Economy,111(6), pp.1220-1242.
    [241] Zarsky,1999,“Havens, Halos and Spaghetti: Untangling the Evidence about Foreign DirectInvestment and the Environment”, OECD Conference on Foreign Direct Investment and theEnvironment.
    [242] Zhang, Z.,2003,“Why did the Energy Intensity Fall in China’s Industrial Sector in the1990s?The Relative Importance of Structural Change and Intensity Change”, Energy Economics,25,625-638.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700