摘要
现代企业尤其是国内企业在机遇与挑战并存的竞争环境中,如何获得可持续成长,成为了企业生存与发展的焦点话题。作为特殊能动性资源的企业人力资本,是企业生存发展的核心要素。一方面以其知识与能力的内在积累构成企业能力的主要来源,另一方面需要通过人力资本各种管理实践手段以影响员工能力、动机、态度与行为来挖掘和保持其潜在价值的活力。
基于此,本文提出以高绩效工作系统实践促进企业人力资本价值增值的研究命题,在回顾与评述人力资本及其增值与高绩效工作系统的相关理论成果基础上,展开人力资本内涵、特征、价值创造、价值增值及增值效能的层层剖析,展开高绩效工作系统的内涵、特征、内容及作用效果的梳理总结,以企业绩效为纽带,解析出高绩效工作系统促进企业人力资本增值的作用路径和企业人力资本增值效能形态。并以高成长性的JZ集团为样本,提炼出与作用路径对应的JZ集团高绩效工作系统实践内容,以验证作用路径促进企业人力资本增值的可行性。
通过理论剖析,从企业人力资本边际报酬递增或递减的动态价值增值的转化过程,以能力、成本和产权的价值观视角,构建了人力资本价值增值的运营机制,即有效的投资、适度的配置和多角度激励。从高绩效工作系统的实践内容入手,构建了以员工能力、动机和参与机会为要素的高绩效工作系统作用机制。并以企业绩效与价值为结合点,形成了高绩效工作系统促进企业人力资本增值的作用路径,即从培训与开发等投资角度积累员工能力,从甄选、引进、提升与流转等配置角度形成团队协作,从薪酬、福利与奖励、职业发展、环境匹配、组织承诺与绩效约束等激励角度促进员工自我实现价值。
通过实证分析,结合JZ集团人力资本的结构特点与实施“人才战略”所形成的“留住人、凝聚人、造就人、吸引人与约束人”的高绩效工作系统实践,从JZ集团人力资本“升、降、出、增”的动态变量和下属有代表性的4家子公司的高业绩成长的数据中,总结出了企业人力资本“能力价值积累、团队协作效应与自我实现价值”的增值效能形态,由此验证了高绩效工作系统促进企业人力资本增值的有效性。
本文通过对人力资本增值内在动因的探究与JZ集团高绩效工作系统实践的梳理,形成了“能力开发、潜能激励、团队配置”的企业人力资本增值路径,实现了人力资本价值增值与企业价值增值的有效统一。
It has become a hot topic for an enterprise’s survival and development that how the modern enterprises, especially the domestic ones, can achieve sustainable development in the environment of competition with the coexistence of opportunity and challenge. The enterprise’s human capital, as a special dynamic resource, is the key element of the survival and development for an enterprise. On one hand, the main source of the enterprise’s ability is the intrinsic accumulation of knowledge and ability. On the other, it is through various means of management and practice that an employee’s ability, motivation, attitude and conduct are influenced, and that his/her vitality of intrinsic value is explored and maintained.
Grounding on the above, this thesis puts forward the researching topic of promoting the value increase of an enterprise’s human capital by the practice of high performance work system. And layer upon layer, it dissects the meaning, feature, value-creation, value-increasing and incremental validity of the human capital, and combs and sums up the meaning, feature, substance and effect of high performance work system. Taking the enterprise’s performance as the bond, this thesis also analyzes the acting route and the pattern of human capital of the high performance work system which promotes the value-increase of an enterprise’s human capital, based upon the review and commentary of the pertaining theoretical achievements regarding the value-increasing of human capital and high performance work system. Meanwhile, taking JZ group as an example of high development, it extracts the substance of practice that corresponds with the JZ group’s high performance work system, in order to inspect and verify the acting route, promoting the value-increasing feasibility of an enterprise’s human capital.
Through the theoretical analysis, based on the dynamic transformation of value-added process in which the human capital’s marginal returns reduce or increase, from the perspective of ability, cost, and the property rights, this thesis builds the human capital’s value-added operating mechanism, that is, an effective investment, appropriate configuration and multi-angle incentive. Starting from the practice of high-performance work systems, it builds a high-performance work system with staff capacity, motivation and opportunity to participate in as elements. With the corporate performance and value as the bonding point, it forms the acting path in which the high performance work system promotes the value of human capital. It accumulates the staff capacity from the perspective of investment such as training and development, forms the team collaboration from the selection, introduction, upgrading and configuration point of view, and encourages the staff to fulfill their value from the perspective of incentives such as salaries, fringe benefits and incentives, career development, the environment match, organizational commitment and performance constraints.
Through the empirical analysis, combining the structural characteristics of the human capital of JZ Group with the practice of“keeping people, uniting people, training people, attracting people and constraining people”formed by the“talent strategy”, from the dynamic variables of“up, down, out, in”of JZ Group’s human capital and the growth of high-performance data of the four representative subsidiaries, it sums up the value-added performance patterns of the human capital“accumulation of the ability value, teamwork effect and self-fulfillment”. Thus the validity of high performance work system promoting the value-increasing of enterprise’s human capital is verified.
Exploring the intrinsic motivation of the value-added route of human capital and combing the practice of JZ Group’s high performance work system, this thesis forms the a value-increasing route of an enterprise’s human capital with“exploring and accumulating ability, encouraging and arousing potential, deploying and uniting team”and achieves the effective integration of the value-increase of human capital as well as the enterprise.
引文
[1]鲁开垠.核心竞争力.北京:经济日报出版社,2001
[2] Laurie J Bassi, Jens Ludwig, Daniel P Mcmurrer, Mark Van Buren. Profiting from learning: Firm level effects of training investments and market implication. Singapore Management Review, 2002, 24(3):61-79
[3] Matthew Guthridge, Asmus B. Komm and Emily Lawson.把人才作为一项战略重点.麦肯锡季刊,2008(1)
[4]安钟利,唐冬.新兴技术企业人力资本挑战及其应对措施研究.决策咨询通讯2008(3):97-100
[5]苏中兴,曾湘泉,赖特.人力资源管理与企业绩效:国内外实证研究的评论与思考.经济理论与经济管理,2007(6):61-69
[6]王明杰,郑一山.西方人力资本理论研究综述.中国行政管理,2006(8):92-95
[7]袁建昌.高新技术企业科技型人力资本增值激励研究.吉林大学博士学位论文, 2008
[8]舒尔茨.人力资本投资.北京经济学院出版社,1990
[9]顾琴轩.国营经营者人力资本价值与收入分配.华东理工大学出版社,2004:36-37
[10]张延平,汪安佑.企业人力资本增值研究.技术经济,2003(4):9-10
[11]安妮.布鲁金著,赵浩平译.智力资本:第三资源的应用与管理.东北财经大学出版社,1998
[12]Thomas A. Stewart. Intellectual Capital: The New wealth of Organizations. Newyork: Currency Doubleday, 1997
[13]Jon younger and Kurt Sandhottz. Helping R&D professionals Build Successful Career .Research Technology management, Nov/Dec, 1997
[14]李洪涛.人力资本投资:增值及风险规避.中国劳动,2000(5):28-29
[15]于桂兰,杨富华.人力资本分享企业收益的原因与形式.中国人力资源开发,2001(12):11-12
[16]周源.人力资本:贬值与增值.人才开发,2003(3):34-35
[17]徐崇延.人力资本保值增值新论.财务通讯,2002(5):13-25
[18]张亚莉,杨乃定.论企业人力资本贬值风险.科研管理,2000(4):86-90
[19]王晨,苇宁.人力资本价值转化模型实证分析.中国工业经济,2003(5):86-91
[20]吴东,张徽燕.基于互补性资本的人力资本增值模型研究.华东经济管理,2005(11):108-110
[21]赵息,张林,商如斌.新经济中的人力资本与激励问题.津大大学报社会科学版,2001(2):161-164
[22]黄再胜.企业人力资本隐性激励刍议-兼论企业显性激励的局限性.科学·经济·社会,2003(3):27-32
[23]杨有红.试论人力资本股权奖励的运作模式.北京工商大学报(社会科学版),2003(3):52-56
[24]胡晓玉,李大为.关于人力资本价值及其有效实现的研究.求是学刊,2003(2):55-59
[25]申学武,关培兰.人力资本价值实现的制度设计.江汉论坛,2005(1):48-50
[26]付维宁.企业人力资本与企业绩效:一个理论分析模型.经济经纬,2004(2):86-88
[27]张宗益,张宁.人力资本多层次激励机制探析.经济经纬,2004(2):86-88
[28]陈淑妮.企业人力资本的三大激励机制.经济管理,2002(5):35-37
[29]王浩.论人力资本投资及其激励体制.南京农业大学学报(社科版),2003(4):48-54
[30]张晓燕.异质性人力资本与企业的长期合作-从“非流动性”角度探讨企业长期合作的激励与约束作用.经济机制改革,2004(2):76-79
[31]王鲁捷,管永桦.论异质型人力资本:二元加权股权激励.南方理工大学学报,2005(3):375-378
[32]薛乃卓,杜纲.知识型组织人力资本内涵新视角及其价值推进与实现.科学与科学技术管理,2005(3):118-121
[33]赵署明.企业家的人力资本价值.中国人力资源开发,2001(11)
[34]杨清.传统工作系统、高绩效工作系统的初步思考.长沙通信职业技术学院学报,2006(3):7-10
[35]吴慈生,孙薇.高绩效工作系统与组织绩效研究评述.现代管理科学,2007(11):84-86
[36]卿涛,罗键.西部企业高绩效工作系统实证研究.财经科学2007(6):117-124
[37]刘善仕,周巧笑.高绩效工作系统与绩效关系研究.外国经济与管理. 2004(7):19-23
[38]吴泽福,吴捷.中国企业创建高绩效工作系统的研究.企业活力,2002(7):54-56
[39]李华,李传昭,陈杨.基于高绩效工作系统的组织人力资源管理实践.生产力研究,2005(5)
[40]程德俊,赵曙明.高参与工作系统与企业绩效:人力资本专用性和环境动态性的影响.管理世界(月刊),2006(3):86-93
[41]常耀方.高参与工作系统对企业绩效的影响.华南师范大学硕士学位论文,2007:6
[42]Pfeffer J. Competitive advantage through people. Cambridge,MA: Harvard Business schoolPress Management Jourenl,1994(14):179-191
[43]刘晔.人力资本对企业能力作用的理论与实证研究.同济大学博士学位论文,2007
[44]胡大立.企业竞争力.北京:经济管理出版社,2001
[45]丁栋虹.从人力资本到异质型人力资本与同质型人力资本.理论前言,2001(5):12-14
[46]宋培林.企业经营者成长机制论.贵州人民出版社,2004(3):85
[47]刘访月,李应锋.企业人力资本分类方法探析.会计之友,2008.4(下):44-45
[48]何长全.我国企业人力资本增值管理研究.广东工业大学硕士学位论文,2006:17
[49]Lepak D. P. Snell SA. The human resource architecture:Toward a theory of human capital allocation and development. Academy of Management Review, 1999.24(1):31-48
[50]方竹兰.论人力资本及其制度分析价值.学术月刊, 2002(10):26-32
[51]Barney JB, Wright PM. On becoming a strategic partner: the role human resources in gaining competitive advantage. Human Resource Management, 1998.37(1):112-113
[52]周其仁.市场里的企业:一个人力资本与非人力资本的特别合约.经济研究,1996(6):71-79
[53]韩强.企业人力资本价值创造的战略量化研究.上海财经大学博士学位论文,2003:55
[54]Noe, R.A., Hollenbeck J.R, & Gerhart, B. et al. Fundemantals of Human Resource Management .Beijing : Tsinghua University press,2000
[55]Combs j, Liu YM, and Hall A. et al. how much do high-performance work Practice matter? A meta-analysis of their effects on organizational performance. Personnel psychology, 2006, 59(3):501-528
[56]梁荣强.人力资源高绩效工作系统特征的机制研究.浙江大学硕士学位论文,2008
[57]张冬梅.经营者人力资本与企业核心能力提升.安徽范大学学报,2006,34(1):44-47
[58]魏杰.人力资本的激励与约束机制问题.国有资产管理,2001(9)
[59]Barney J B.Looking inside for competitive advantage.Academy of Management Executive,1995,9(4):49-61
[60]贝克尔.人力资本:特别是关于教育的理论与经验分析.北京大学出版社,1987
[61]Milkovich, Boudreau . Selection and design of training programs . Human Resource Management,1991:230-251
[62]Rousseau,Greller.Human resource practices: Administrative contract marker.Human Resource Management,1994(33):385-401
[63]陈志祥,陈荣秋,马士华.论知识链与知识管理.科研管理2000,20(1):16-21
[64]Mc Gill, Slocum.Executive development in learning organizations.American Journal ofManagement Development,1995(2):23-30
[65]斯帝芬.P.罗宾斯.组织行为学(第七版).中国人民大学出版社,2003
[66]段心民,张生太.企业集团人力资本管理研究.机械工业出版,2003,6(1):164-165
[67]付亚和.绩效管理.复旦大学出版社,2008
[68]Haskins ME, Jeannel, John R. Beyond teams: Toward an ethic of collaboration. Organizational Dynamics, 1998, 126(4):34-50
[69]Huiyan-Zhang,Runtian-Jing.Value-Added of Human Capital Through Complementary Capital.. The Journal of American Academy of Business.Volume9,Number1,March2006:191-196.
[70]陆维杰.企业组织中的人力资本与非人力资本.经济研究,1998(5):67-72
[71]张正贵,何林虎,王永亮.大型企业集团适度集权的财务管控建立与实施.四川省企业管理现代化创新成果推荐材料,2007
[72]马小卉.浅谈企业人力资本增值策略.科技创业月刊,2005(1):112-113
[73]Christopher A. Bartlett and Sumantra Ghoshal ,Building competitive advantage through people. MIT Sloan Management Review, 2002(42):34-41
[74]张正贵,何林虎等.高科技企业人才兴企战略的有效实施.荣获国家级企业管理现代化创新成果奖,2004
[75]张正贵,何林虎等.军工企业成长中的和谐文化建设.荣获国家级管理创新成果二等奖,2005
[76]李仕明,唐小我.企业权利配置与经理激励.科学出版社,2003,8(1):34
[77]刘小平,王重鸣.不同文化下企业员工组织承诺概念的调查研究.科学管理研究,2004(3):85-87
[78]詹姆斯.沃克.人力资源战略.中国人民大学出版社,2001(1):110
[79]张正贵,汪晓明等.实现军民共同发展的企业技术创新管理.获第十三届全国企业管理现代化创新成果奖,2006
[80]保罗.麦耶斯主编,蒋惠工等译.知识管理与组织设计.珠海出版社1998(1):157-158
[81]杨凡.企业人力资本价值评估.广东工业大学硕士学位论文,2005