认知模型支持下的人因可靠性分析方法研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
人为差错严重影响人机系统的可靠性和安全性,已经成为导致事故的主要原因之一,研究人为差错发生的特点及规律,并在此基础上设计人为差错的管理措施具有十分重要的意义。论文以工程实践对人因可靠性分析方法的现实需求为牵引,以推动人因可靠性分析研究的发展为导向,在人因可靠性分析的理论和方法方面开展了一系列深入的研究工作。具体的研究思路为:在已有成果的基础上,系统性地研究了人的认知行为描述、情景环境的表征、人为差错的辨识和人为差错的概率量化等4个人因可靠性分析的核心内容,提出了一系列具有规范性或创新性的方法,并通过工程应用验证了方法的工程适用性和有效性。论文的主要研究内容和成果如下:
     (1)人的认知行为描述
     通过分析比较现有的认知模型,选择SRK模型来描述人的认知行为过程,并以此作为论文后续研究的心理学基础。为了提高SRK模型的理论合理性,更新了SRK模型的解释。考虑到行为模式决定因素的状态可能存在不确定性,分别使用模糊逻辑和概率的方法,构建了静态和动态两种情景环境中行为模式的确定方法,使得行为模式的确定方法更具适用性。
     (2)情景环境的表征
     以人机交互过程为范本,分析得到了包含6个方面、3个层次、38个具体元素的行为形成因子分类,将情景环境的内涵描述得更加全面、细致和规范。根据SRK模型中3种行为模式的特点,对行为形成因子作了再分类,进一步得到了与3种行为模式对应的主要和次要行为形成因子。借鉴和适度规范了行为形成因子评分的专家判断法,有助于提高行为形成因子评分结果的有效性。通过分析人为差错数据,提出了基于关联规则挖掘的行为形成因子权重确定方法,提高了行为形成因子权重确定方法的有效性和工程适用性。最后,给出了综合评价情景环境的基本步骤,对行为形成因子的选择、评分和权重确定中所需要注意的问题,都进行了充分的讨论。
     (3)人为差错的辨识
     首先,改进和完善了外部人为差错的辨识方法。通过分析和归纳,得到了外部人为差错辨识方法的基本框架,以“执行差错基本分类”为分类框架,提出了层次性、完备性和细致性兼顾的外部人为差错分类方法,通过在分类的基础上设计“问题”,构建了基于“问题”引导的外部人为差错辨识方式。然后,创新性地着重研究了内部人为差错的辨识方法。分析构建了内部人为差错辨识方法的基本框架,分析了认知模式差错、认知功能差错和认知行为差错3者之间的关系,提出了基于SRK模型的内部人为差错分类方法,通过在分类的基础上设计“问题”,构建了基于“问题”引导的内部人为差错辨识方式,弥补了现有方法的不足。另外,通过分析行为形成因子与认知行为差错模式之间的关联关系,提出了查找认知行为差错模式成因的辅助方法。最后,将外部人为差错的辨识和内部人为差错的辨识有机结合,给出了人因可靠性工程中全面开展人为差错辨识工作的流程图。
     (4)人为差错的概率量化
     探索性地建立了人为差错概率量化的基本框架。分析了情景环境、行为模式和人为差错概率3者之间的映射关系,分别设计了静态和动态两种情景环境中人为差错概率的预测方法,提高了人为差错概率预测方法的工程适用性。分析了人为差错数据的来源,分别设计了基于Bayes基本法和基于Bayes信息融合的人为差错概率的修正方法,用于提高人为差错概率量化结果的有效性。
     (5)工程应用
     以研究成果为基础,形成了人因可靠性分析的工程方案,详细分析了汽车驾驶过程中驾驶员的认知行为描述、驾驶过程情景环境的表征、驾驶员人为差错的辨识以及驾驶员人为差错的概率量化等4个人因可靠性分析过程的主要环节。分析结果表明,所提出的方法弥补了现有方法存在的一些缺陷和不足,具有较好的工程适应性和有效性,能够为人因可靠性工程的有效开展提供帮助和指导。
Human errors have more negative effect on the reliability and safety ofhuman-machine systems than machine faults nowadays, and have been recognized asthe main cause of incidents or accidents. Therefore, it is very important to researchhuman errors in order to control them in an effective way. Driven by the requirementsfrom engineering and in order to promote the development of human reliability analysis,this dissertation researches four key contents of human reliability analysis i.e. thehuman cognitive behavior description, the scenario representation, the human erroridentification and the human error probability quantification, and therefore proposes aseries of techniques for standardization or innovation. An engineering case study isprovided, which illustrates the applicability and validity of the proposed techniques. Theoutline of research works and achievements are as follows.
     (1) Human cognitive behavior description
     The available cognitive models are collected and compared. By comparison, SRKmodel is selected as the psychological base of human cognitive behavior description inthis dissertation. The explanations of SRK (Skill, Rule and Knowledge) model areupdated to improve its theoretical rationality. Considering that there are uncertaintiesamong the states of the behavior mode determinative factors, two techniques, based onfuzzy logic system and probability respectively, are proposed to determine behaviormode in the static and the dynamic scenario.
     (2) Scenario representation
     The dissertation chooses the human-machine interaction process as the typicalparadigm. Performance shaping factors, taken as the representatives of scenario, arecategorized into six aspects, three levels and thirty-eight factors, which can describe thescenario in a more complete, delicate and normalized way. According to the propertiesof the three behavior modes in SRK model, performance shaping factors are categorizedfurther, and the dominant and subordinate ones corresponding to each behavior modeare discriminated. The technique to rate performance shaping factors by expertjudgement is employed and normalized to some extent, so that the validity of the ratingresults can be improved. By analyzing human error data, the technique based onassociation rule mining is proposed to weigh performance shaping factors, which canimprove the validity and applicability of the current techniques. Based on the proposedtechniques, the basic scheme to evaluate the whole scenario is given, and the problemsthat need be noticed when implementing the scheme are discussed in detail.
     (3) Human error identification
     First, the external human error identification is improved. By analyzing andsummarizing, the basic framework for the external human error identification is provided. Taking “the basic taxonomy of execution errors” as the taxonomic framework,the taxonomy of external human errors is provided. Base on the taxonomy, a series of“questions” are designed and the “question-answer” identification manner is proposedaccordingly. Second, the internal human error identification is researched innovativelyas the main topic. The basic framework for the internal human error identification isconstructed. The correlations of the errors of cognitive modes, cognitive functions andcognitive behaviors are analyzed, and the taxonomy of internal human errors based onSRK model is proposed. With the provision of the taxonomy, a series of “questions” aredesigned and the “question-answer” identification manner is constructed accordingly.Besides, the correlation between performance shaping factors and human cognitivebehavior error modes are analyzed, and the technique to facilitate the causes-findingprocess of human cognitive behavior error modes is proposed. At last, the external andthe internal human error identification techniques are combined, and therefore theflowchart for the full-scope application of human error identification is provided.
     (4) Human error probability quantification
     The basic framework for the human error probability quantification is provided. Asto the human error probability prediction, the correlations among scenario, behaviormode and human error probability are analyzed and constructed, and the quantificationtechniques that can be used in the static and the dynamic scenario respectively areprovided, which can improve the applicability of the current techniques. As to thehuman error probability amendment, the multiple sources of human error data areanalyzed, and two techniques based on Bayesian basic method and Bayesianinformation fusion method are proposed. They can improve the validity of the results ofthe human error probability quantification.
     (5) Engineering application
     Based on the techniques proposed in the dissertation, an engineering solution forhuman reliability analysis is formed, and it is applied in and demonstrated by the casestudy of human errors analysis on car drivers. The cognitive behavior description,scenario representation, human error identification and human error quantification ofcar drivers are analyzed in detail. The results show that the proposed techniques canovercome some shortcomings of the existed techniques and can provide betterapplicability and validity. It is a useful solution for the human reliability engineering.
引文
[1] Hollnagel E. The phenotype of erroneous actions[J]. International Journal ofMan-machine Studies,1993,39(1):1-32.
    [2] French S, Bedford T, Pollard S J T, et al. Human reliability analysis: A critiqueand review for managers[J]. Safety Science,2011,49(6):753-763.
    [3] Issac A, Shorrock S T, Kennedy R. Technical review of human performancemodels and taxonomies of human error in ATM (HERA)(HRS-002-REP-01)[R].European Air Traffic Management Programme, Brussels,2002.
    [4] USNRC. Review of finding for human performance contribution to risk inoperating events(NUREG/CR-6753)[R]. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission,Washington DC,2002.
    [5] Kariuki S G, Lowe K. Integrating human factors into process hazard analysis[J].Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2007,92(12):1764-1773.
    [6] Ren J, Jenkinson I, Wang J, et al. A methodology to model causal relationships inoffshore safety assessment focusing on human and organizational factors[J].Journal of Safety Research,2008,39(1):87-100.
    [7] Alexander H M. Error types and related error detection process in the aviationdomain[D]. Master's thesis. Urban-Champaign: University of Illinois1992.
    [8] Helmreich R L. On error management: lessons from aviation[J]. British MedicalJournal,2000,320(7237):781-783.
    [9] Wu S, Hrudey S E, French S. Human reliability analysis has a role in preventingdrinking water relations[J]. Water Research,2009,43(13):3227-3238.
    [10]高佳,黄祥瑞,沈祖培.人的可靠性分析:需要、状况和进展[J].中南工学院学报,1999,13(2):11-25.
    [11] Kohn L T, Corrigan J M, Donaldson M S. To Err is Human: Building a saferhealth system[M]. Washington DC: National Academy Press,2000.
    [12] Salmon P M, Regan M A, Johnston I. Human error and road transport: Phaseone-A framework for an error tolerant road transport system[R]. MonashUniversity Accident Research Center, Australia,2005.
    [13] Dhillon B S. Human Reliability and Error in Transportation Systems[M]. London:Springer,2007.
    [14] http://baike.baidu.com/view/317208.htm.
    [15] http://baike.baidu.com/view/48444.htm.
    [16] http://baike.baidu.com/view/3574799.html.
    [17] http://www.people.com.cn/item/dsh/home.html.
    [18] http://news.sohu.com/s2008/jiaojituogui/.
    [19] http://news.xinhuanet.com/local/2010-11/17/c_12786179.htm.
    [20] http://www.chinanews.com/gn/2011/08-04/3235166.shtml.
    [21]姜黎黎,王保国,刘淑艳等.人的可靠性研究中的定量分析方法及其评价[C].第七届人-机-系统工程学术论文集,舟山,2005.
    [22]谢红卫,孙志强,李欣欣等.典型人因可靠性分析方法评述[J].国防科技大学学报,2007,29(2):101-107.
    [23] Williams H L. Reliability evaluation of the human component in man-machinesystem[J]. Electrical Engineering,1958,12(1):78-82.
    [24] Meister D. A critical review of human performance reliability predictivemethods[J]. IEEE Transactions on Reliability,1973,22(3):116-123.
    [25] Swain A D, Guttmann H E. Handbook of human reliability analysis withemphasis on nuclear power plant applications (NUREG/CR-1278)[R]. U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington DC,1983.
    [26]童节娟,余少杰,赵军.核电站人员可靠性分析方法THERP中的班组因素[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2010,50(9):1425-1428.
    [27] Embrey D E. SLIM-MAUD: An approach to assessing human error probabilitiesusing structured expert judgment (NUREG/CR-3518)[R]. U.S. NuclearRegulatory Commission, Washington DC,1983.
    [28] Park K S, Lee J. A new method for estimating human error probabilities:AHP-SLIM[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2008,93(4):578-587.
    [29] Hanaman G W, Spurgin A J, Lukic Y. Human cognitive reliability model for PRAanalysis (NUS-4531)[R]. Electric Power Research Institute, Palo Alto,1984.
    [30] Zhang L, He X H, Dai L C, et al. The simulator experimental study on theoperator reliability of Qinshan nuclear power plant[J]. Reliability Engineeringand System Safety,2007,92(2):252-259.
    [31] Williams J C. A data-based method for assessing and reducing human error toimprove operational performance[C]. Proceedings of IEEE4th Conference onHuman Factor and Power Plants, Monterey,1988.
    [32]余建星,杨怿.潜艇火灾事故中的人因失误概率分析[J].自然灾害学报,2010,19(3):77-81.
    [33] Chadwick L, Fallon E F. Human reliability assessment of a critical nursing taskin a radiotherapy treatment process[J]. Applied Ergonomics,2012,43(1):89-97.
    [34] Kirwan B. A guide to practical human reliability assessment[M]. London: Taylor&Francis,1994.
    [35] Spurgin A J. Critique of current human reliability analysis methods[C].Proceedings of IEEE7th Human Factors and Power Plants, Arizona,2002.
    [36] Hollnagel E. Cognitive reliability and error analysis method (CREAM)[M].London: Elsevier Science Ltd.,1998.
    [37]廖可兵,刘爱群,童节娟等.人的认知失误事件定量分析法的进展及应用[J].原子能科学技术,2009,43(4):322-327.
    [38] Lee S M, Ha J S, Seong P H. CREAM-based communication error analysismethod (CEAM) for nuclear power plant operators communication[J]. Journal ofLoss Prevention in the Process Industries,2011,24(1):90-97.
    [39] USNRC. Technical basis and implementation guidelines for A Technique forHuman Event Analysis (NUREG-1624)[R]. U.S. Nuclear RegulatoryCommission, Washington DC,2000.
    [40] Forester J, Kolaczkowski A, Cooper S E. ATHEANA user's guide[R]. U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington DC,2007.
    [41] Kim J W, Jung W D, Park J K. A system approach to analysis errors ofcommission from diagnosis failure in accident progression[J]. ReliabilityEngineering and System Safety,2005,89(2):135-150.
    [42] Kim J W, Jung W D, Son Y S. The MDTA-based method for assessing diagnosisfailures and their risk impacts in nuclear power plants[J]. Reliability Engineeringand System Safety,2008,93(2):337-349.
    [43] Reer B, Dang V N, Hirschberg S. The CESA method and its application in aplant-specific pilot study on errors of commission[J]. Reliability Engineering andSystem Safety,2004,83(2):187-205.
    [44]高佳,沈祖培,何旭洪.第二代人的可靠性分析方法的进展[J].中国安全科学学报,2004,14(2):15-19.
    [45]何旭洪,高佳,黄祥瑞.人的可靠性分析方法比较[J].核动力工程,2005,26(6):627-630.
    [46] Reer B. Review of advances in human reliability analysis of errors ofcommission-Part1: EOC identification[J]. Reliability Engineering and SystemSafety,2008,93(8):1091-1104.
    [47] Reer B. Review of advances in human reliability analysis of errors ofcommission-Part2: EOC quantification[J]. Reliability Engineering and SystemSafety,2008,93(8):1105-1122.
    [48] Mosleh A, Chang Y H. Model-based human reliability analysis: prospects andrequirements[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2004,83(2):241-253.
    [49] Boring R L, Griffith C D, Joe J C. The measure of human error: direct andindirect performance shaping factors[C]. Proceedings of the8th IEEEConference on Human Factors and Power Plants and the HumanPerformance/Root Cause/Trending/Operating Experience and Self Assessment13th Annual Meeting, Monterey,2007.
    [50] Cacciabue P C, Decoris F, Drozdowicz B, et al. A cognitive simulation model ofhuman decision making and behavior in accident management of complexplant[J]. IEEE Transaction on system, man and cybernetics,1992,22(5):1058-1074.
    [51] Dang V N. Modeling operator cognition for accident sequence analysis:Development of an operator-plant simulation[D]. Master's thesis. London:Cambridge,1996.
    [52] Chang Y H J, Mosleh A. Cognitive modeling and dynamic probabilisticsimulation of operating crew response to complex system accidents, Part1-5[J].Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2007,92(8):997-1101.
    [53] Coyne K A. A predictive model of nuclear power plant crew decision-makingand performance in a dynamic simulation environment[D]. Ph.D thesis. CollegePark: University of Maryland,2009.
    [54]李鹏程,陈国华,张力等.人因可靠性分析技术的研究进展与发展趋势[J].原子能科学技术,2011,15(3):329-340.
    [55] Reason J T. Human error[M]. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1990.
    [56] Groth K M. A data-informed model of performance shaping factors for use inhuman reliability analysis[D]. Ph.D thesis. College Park: University of Maryland,2009.
    [57] Shorrock S T, Kirwan B. Development and application of a human erroridentification tool for air traffic control[J]. Applied Ergonomics,2002,33(4):319-336.
    [58] Baysari M T, Caponecchia C, McIntosh A S. A reliability and usability study ofTRACEr-RAV: the technique for the retrospective analysis of cognitive errors-forrail, Australian version[J]. Applied Ergonomics,2011,42(6):852-859.
    [59] Wiegmann D A, Shappell S A. A human error approach to aviation accidentanalysis: The human factors analysis and classification system[M]. Burlington:Ashgate Publishing Company,2003.
    [60] Patterson J M, Shappell S A. Operator error and system deficiencies: Analysis of508mining incidents and accidents from Queensland, Australia using HFACS[J].Accident Analysis&Prevention,2010,42(4):1379-1385.
    [61] Kontogiannis T. A framework for the analysis of cognitive reliability in complexsystems: a recovery centered approach[J]. Reliability Engineering and SystemSafety,1997,58(2):233-248.
    [62] Spurgin A J. Human reliability assessment theory and practice[M]. London:Taylor&Francis Group,2010.
    [63] Bell J, Holroyd J. Review of human reliability assessment methods (RR679)[R].Health and Safety Executive, Buxton,2009.
    [64] Edwards E. Man and machine: system for safety[C]. Proceedings of BritishAirline Pilots Associations Technical Symposium, London,1972.
    [65] Hawkins F H. Human factors in flight, second ed[R]. Ashgate PublishingCompany, Aldershot,1993.
    [66] Chang Y H, Wang Y C. Significant human risk factors in aircraft maintenancetechnicians[J]. Safety Science,2010,48(1):54-62.
    [67] Kim J W, Jung W D. A taxonomy of performance influence factors for humanreliability analysis of emergency tasks[J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in theProcess Industries,2003,16(1):479-495.
    [68]孙志强,史秀建,刘凤强等.人为差错成因分析方法研究[J].中国安全科学学报,2008,18(6):21-27.
    [69] Teperi A M, Leppanen A. Managers' conceptions regarding human factors in airtraffic management and in aircraft operation[J]. Safety Science,2011,49(3):438-449.
    [70]孙志强,李政仪,史秀建等.行为模式支持下的人为差错分析方法研究[J].计算技术与自动化,2008,27(4):105-110.
    [71] Zio E, Baraldi P, Librizze M, et al. A fuzzy set-based approach for modelingdependence among human errors[J]. Fuzzy Sets and System,2009,160(13):1974-1964.
    [72] Gertman D I, Blackman H S, Marble J. The SPAR-H human reliability analysismethod (NUREG/CR-6883)[R]. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission,Washington DC,2004.
    [73] DiMattia D G, Khan F I, Amyotte P R. Determination of human errorprobabilities for offshore platform musters[J]. Journal of Loss Prevention in theProcess Industries,2005,18(4-6):488-501.
    [74] Schonbeck M, Rausand M, Rouvroye J. Human and organizational factors in theoperational phase of safety instrumented systems: A new approach[J]. SafetyScience,2010,48(3):310-318.
    [75] Chang Y H, Yeh C H. Human performance interfaces in air traffic control[J].Applied Ergonomics,2010,41(1):123-129.
    [76] Park J K, Jung W D, Kim J W. The step complexity measure for emergencyoperating procedures-comparing with simulation data[J]. Reliability Engineeringand System Safety,2001,74(1):63-74.
    [77] Saaty T L. The analytic hierarchy process[M]. New York: McGraw-Hill,1980.
    [78] Zhang Y, Zhan Y L, Tan Q M. Studies on human factors in marine engineaccident[C]. Proceedings of2009Second International Symposium onKnowledge Acquisition and Modeling, Wuhan,2009.
    [79]张吉军.模糊层次分析法[J].模糊系统与数学,2000,11(2):80-88.
    [80]刘凤强,孙志强,谢红卫等.航空维修人为差错影响因素分析中的模糊层次分析法[J].中国安全科学学报,2008,18(7):43-48.
    [81]张力,廉士乾,王以群.基于模糊层次分析法的组织因素对系统安全影响度识别[J].人类工效学,2009,15(4):38-41.
    [82] Baber C, Stanton N A. Human error identification techniques applied to publictechnology: predictions compared with observed use[J]. Applied Ergonomics,1996,27(2):119-131.
    [83] Kirwan B. Human error identification techniques for risk assessment of high risksystems-Part1: review and evaluation of techniques[J]. Applied Ergonomics,1998,29(3):157-177.
    [84] Kletz T. HAZOP and HAZAN-Notes on the identification and assessment ofhazards[M]. Rurby: Institute of Chemical Engineers,1974.
    [85] Dunjo J, Fthenakis C, Vilchez J A, et al. Hazard and operability (HAZOP)analysis: A literature review[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2010,173(1-3):19-32.
    [86] Comer P J, Fitt F S, Ostebo R. A driller's HAZOP method[R]. Society ofPetroleum Engineers, Pennsylvania,1986.
    [87] Whalley S P. Minimizing the cause of human error[C]. Proceedings of10thAdvances in Reliability Technology Symposium, Libberton,1988.
    [88] Embrey D E. SHERPA: A systematic human error reduction and predictionapproach[C]. Proceedings of the International Meeting on Advances in NuclearPower Systems, Knoxville,1986.
    [89] Reason J T, Rasmussen J, Duncan K, et al. Generic error-modeling system(GEMS): A cognitive framework for locating human error forms[M]. London:John Wiley,1987.
    [90] Kirwan B, Martin B R, Rycraft H, et al. Human error data collection and datageneration[J]. International Journal of Quality and Reliability Management,1990,7(4):34-66.
    [91] Harris D, Stanton N A, Marshall A, et al. Using SHERPA to predictdesigh-induced error on the flight deck[J]. Aerospace Science and Technology,2005,9(6):525-532.
    [92] Embrey D E. Quantitative and qualitative prediction of human error in safetyassessment[C]. Proceedings of Institute of Chemical Engineerings Symposium,London,1992.
    [93] Isaac A, Shorrock S T, Kirwan B. Human error in European air trafficmanagement: the HERA project[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2002,75(2):257-272.
    [94] EATMP Human Resources Team. The Human Error in ATM Technique(HERA-JANUS)(No. HRA/HSP-002-REP-03)[R]. EuroControl, Brussels,2003.
    [95] Baysari M T, Caponecchia C, McIntosh A S, et al. Classification of errorscontributing to rail incidents and accidents: A comparison of two human erroridentification techniques[J]. Safety Science,2009,47(7):948-957.
    [96] Fleming K N, Hannaman P H, Houghton G W. HTGR accident investigation andprogression analysis status report (Vol. II) AIPA risk assessment methodology[R].General Atomic Co., San Diego,1975.
    [97] Wreathall J. Operator action trees: An approach to quantifying operator errorprobability during accident sequences (NUS-4159)[R]. NUS Corporation, SanDiego,1982.
    [98] Wei W, Hidekazu Y. A pilot study on human cognitive reliability (HCR) byhuman model simulation[C]. Proceedings of IEEE Conference on IntelligentInformation System, Los Alamitos,1997.
    [99] Kirwan B. The validation of three human reliability quantification techniques,THERP, HEART and JHEDI: Part1technique descriptions and validationissues[J]. Applied Ergonomics,1996,27(6):359-373.
    [100] Kirwan B, Kennedy R, Taylor-Adams S, et al. The validation of three humanreliability quantification techniques, THERP, HEART and JHEDI: Part II-resultsof validation exercise[J]. Applied Ergonomics,1997,28(1):17-25.
    [101] Swain A D. Accident sequence evaluation program human reliability analysisprocedure (NUREG/CR-4772)[R]. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission,Washington DC,1987.
    [102] Smith S P, Harrison M D. Augmenting descriptive scenario analysis forimprovements in human reliability design[C]. Proceedings of ACM Symposiumon Applied Computing, Madrid,2002.
    [103] Kirwan B. Nuclear action reliability assessment (NARA): A data-based tool[C].Proceeding of International7th Conference on Probabilistic Safety AssessmentManagement, Berlin,2004.
    [104] Humphreys P. Human reliability assessors guide (TRS88/95Q)[R]. Safety andReliability Directorate UKAEA (SRD), Warrington,1988.
    [105] Collier S. A simulator study of CREAM to predict cognitive errors[C].Proceedings of the International Workshop-Building the new HRA: Errors ofcommission from research to application,2003.
    [106] Kim I S. Human reliability analysis in the man-machine interface designreview[J]. Annals of Nuclear Energy,2001,28(11):1069-1081.
    [107] Fujita Y, Hollnagel E. Failures without errors: Quantification of context inHRA[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2004,83(2):145-151.
    [108] He X H, Wang Y, Shen Z P, et al. A simplified CREAM prospectivequantification process and its application[J]. Reliability Engineering and SystemSafety,2008,93(3):298-306.
    [109] Kim M C, Seong P H, Hollnagel E. A probabilistic approach for determining thecontrol mode in CREAM[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2006,91(2):191-199.
    [110] Konstandinidou M, Nivolianitou Z, Kiranoudis C. A fuzzy modeling applicationof CREAM methodology for human reliability analysis[J]. ReliabilityEngineering and System Safety,2006,91(6):706-716.
    [111] Gertman D I, Boring R L, Marble J L, et al. Mixed model usability evaluation ofthe SPAR-H human reliability analysis method[C]. Proceedings of FourthAmerican Nuclear Society International Topical Meeting on Nuclear PlantInstrumentation, Controls and Human-Machine Interface Technologies(NPIC&HMIT), Columbus,2004.
    [112]何旭洪,童节娟,黄祥瑞.低功率和停堆工况下人员可靠性分析[J].中国安全科学学报,2005,15(4):93-96.
    [113] Hanaman G W, Spurgin A J. Systematic human action reliability procedure(SHARP)(EPRI NP-3583)[R]. Electrical Power Research Institute, Palo Alto,1984.
    [114] Pyy P. An approach for assessing human decision reliability[J]. ReliabilityEngineering and System Safety,2000,68(1):17-28.
    [115] Wickens C D. Engineering psychology and human performance[M]. Columbus:Merrill,1984.
    [116] Shorrock S T. Errors of memory in air traffic control[J]. Safety Science,2005,43(8):571-588.
    [117] Shorrock S T. Errors of perception in air traffic control[J]. Safety Science,2007,45(8):890-904.
    [118] Barriere M. Technical basis and implementation guidelines for a techniques forhuman event analysis (ATHEANA)(NUREG-1624)[R]. U.S. NuclearRegulatory Commission, Washington DC,2000.
    [119]孙志强.人为差错分析方法及应用研究[D].博士论文.长沙:国防科学技术大学研究生院,2008.
    [120] Smidts C, Shen S H, Mosleh A. The IDA cognitive model for the analysis ofnuclear power plant operator response under accident conditions[J]. ReliabilityEngineering and System Safety,1997,55(1):51-71.
    [121] Rasmussen J. Information processing and human-machine interaction: Anapproach to cognitive engineer[M]. New York: North-Holland,1986.
    [122]廖可兵,张力,黄祥瑞.人的失误理论研究进展[J].中国安全科学学报,2006,16(7):45-50.
    [123] Rasmussen J. Skills, rules, and knowledge; Signals, signs and symbols, and otherdistinctions in human performance models[J]. IEEE Transactions on System,Man, and Cybernetics,1983,13(3):257-266.
    [124] Saurin T A, Guimaraes L B M, Costella M F, et al. An algorithm for classifyingerror types of front-line workers based on the SRK framework[J]. InternationalJournal of Industrial Ergonomics,2008,38(11-12):1067-1077.
    [125] Sun Z Q, Xie H W, Shi X J, et al. Engineering approach for human errorprobability quantification[J]. Journal of Systems Engineering and Electronics,2009,20(5):1144-1152.
    [126] Zadeh L. fuzzy sets[J]. Inform Control,1965,8(2):338-352.
    [127]张恩勤,施颂椒,高卫华.模糊控制系统近年来的研究与发展[J].控制理论与应用,2001,18(1):7-11.
    [128] Kempf R, Adamy J. Sequential pattern recognition employing recurrent fuzzysystems[J]. Fuzzy Sets and System,2004,146(3):451-472.
    [129] Kim M C, Seong P H. An analytic model for situation assessment of nuclearpower plant operators based on Bayesian inference[J]. Reliability Engineeringand System Safety,2006,91(3):270-282.
    [130]颜兆林,龚时雨,周经论. AHP在概率风险评价中的应用[J].工作安全与防尘,2001,27(5):33-36.
    [131] Vaurio J K. Human factors, human reliability and risk assessment in licenserenewal of a nuclear power plant[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2009,94(11):1818-1826.
    [132] Fabiano B, Curro F, Reverberi A P, et al. Port safety and the container revolution:A statistical study on human factor and occupational accidents over the longperiod[J]. Safety Science,2010,48(8):980-990.
    [133] Dougherty E M. Is human failure a stochastic process?[J]. ReliabilityEngineering and System Safety,1997,55(3):209-215.
    [134]张力,照明. WANO人因事件统计及分析[J].核动力工程,2005,26(3):291-296.
    [135]刘燕子,张力,王以群.复杂系统中人误原因因素的层次分析法[J].安全与环境学报,2005,5(5):39-42.
    [136] Steers R M, Porter L W. Motivation and work behavior[M]. New York:McGraw-Hill Professional Publishing,1979.
    [137]张力,刘燕子,王以群.人误因素树构建技术[J].人类工效学,2006,12(4):27-30.
    [138] Fagly A H, Chaiken S. The psychologies of attitudes[M]. Fort Worth: HarcourtBrace Jovanovich,1993.
    [139]蔡明悦,龚声武,李夕兵.基于层次分析法的人因失误分析技术[J].中国安全生产科学技术,2008,4(2):74-77.
    [140] Malone T B, Kirkpatrick M, Mallory K, et al. Human factors evaluation ofcontrol room design and operator performance at Three Mile Island-2(NUREG/CR-1270)[R]. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington DC,1979.
    [141] Gertman D, Hallbert B P, Parrish M W, et al. Review of findings for human errorcontribution to risk in operating events (INEEL/EXT-01-01166)[R]. IdahoNational Engineering and Environmental Laboratary, Idaho Falls,2001.
    [142] Kirwan B. The development of a nuclear chemical plant human reliabilitymanagement approach: HRMS and JHEDI[J]. Reliability Engineering andSystem Safety,1997,56(2):107-135.
    [143] John M, Hara O, Williams B. Human-system interface design reviewguideline[R]. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington DC,2002.
    [144] Strater O. Evaluation of human reliability on the basis of operational experience,in economics and social sciences[D]. Ph.D thesis. Munich: The MunichTechnical University,2000.
    [145]张力,杨大新,王以群.数字化控制室信息显示对人因可靠性的影响[J].中国安全科学学报,2010,20(9):81-85.
    [146]兰哲,戴名森.人机界面信息显示最新研究评述[J].北方交通大学学报,1998,22(3):87-91.
    [147] Kim J H, Seong P H. A quantitative approach to modeling the information flowof diagniosis tasks in nuclear power plants[J]. Reliability Engineering andSystem Safety,2003,80(1):81-94.
    [148]刘燕子,张力,王以群.人误因素树构建技术研究[J].工业安全与环保,2006,32(2):4-7.
    [149]沈祖培,王遥,高佳.人因失误的后果-前因追溯表[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2005,45(6):799-802.
    [150] Zhang Y, Li Z, Wu B, et al. A spaceflight operation complexity measure and itsexperimental validation[J]. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics,2009,39(5):756-765.
    [151] Park J, Jung W. A stuty on the validity of a task complexity measure foremergency operating procedures of nuclear power plants-Comparing taskcomplexity scores with two sets of operator response time data obtained under asimulated SGTR[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2008,93(4):557-566.
    [152]朱祖祥,葛列众,张智军等译. Wickens C D, Hollands J G著.工程心理学与人的作业[M].上海:华东师范大学出版社,2003.
    [153]李鹏程,陈国华,张力等.一种整合组织因素的人因可靠性分析方法[J].核动力工程,2010,31(4):82-86.
    [154] Schoroder-Hinrichs J U, Baldauf M, Ghirxi K T. Accident investigation reportingdeficiences related to organizational factors in machinery space fires andexplosions[J]. Accident Analysis&Prevention,2011,43(3):1187-1196.
    [155] Neal A, Grifin M A, Hart P M. The impact of organizational climate on safetyclimate and individual behavior[J]. Safety Science,2000,34(1-3):99-109.
    [156]张力,许康,戴立操等.核电厂激发事故初因的人因事件分析[J].系统工程理论与实践,2004,24(10):138-144.
    [157] Hahn S E, Murphy L R. A short scale for measuring safety climate[J]. SafetyScience,2008,46(7):1047-1066.
    [158] Ek A, Akselsson R, Arvidsson M, et al. Safety culture in Swedish air trafficcontrol[J]. Safety Science,2007,45(7):791-811.
    [159]廉士乾,张力,王以群等.人因失误机理及其原因因素研究[J].工业安全与环保,2007,33(11):46-48.
    [160] Waterson P, Kolose S L. Exploring the social and organizational aspects ofhuman factors integration: A framework and case study[J]. Safety Science,2010,48(4):482-490.
    [161] Koval D O, Floyd H L. Human element factors affecting reliability and safety[J].IEEE Transaction on Industry Applications,1998,34(2):406-414.
    [162]李鹏程,王以群,张力.人误模式与原因因素分析[J].工业工程与管理,2006(1):94-99.
    [163] Barnes V, haagensen B, Ohara J. The human performance evaluation process: aresource for reviewing the identification and resolution of human performanceproblems (NUREG/CR-6751)[R]. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission,Washington DC,2001.
    [164] Liang G F, Lin J T, Hwang S L, et al. Preventing human errors in aviationmaintenance using an on-line maintenance assistance platform[J]. InternationalJournal of Industrial Ergonomics,2010,40(2):356-367.
    [165] Tse H H, Dasborough M T, Ashkanasy N M. A multi-level analysis of teamclimate and interpersonal exchange relationships at work[J]. The LeadershipQuarterly,2008,19(2):195-211.
    [166] Chung Y H, Yoon W C, Min D. A model-based framework for the analysis ofteam communication in nuclear power plant[J]. Reliability Engineering andSystem Safety,2009,94(6):1030-1040.
    [167] Seaver D A, Stillwell W G. Procedures for using expert judgement to estimatehuman error probabilities in nuclear power plant operations(NUREG/CR-2743)[R]. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington DC,1983.
    [168] Gertman D I, Blackman H S, Haney L N. INTENT: a method for estimatinghuman error probabilities for decision-based errors[J]. Reliability Engineeringand System Safety,1992,35(2):127-136.
    [169] Toriizuka T. Application of performance shaping factor (PSF) for workimprovement in industrial plant maintenance tasks[J]. International Journal ofIndustrial Ergonomics,2001,28(3-4):225-236.
    [170]李鹏程,王以群,张力.人误原因因素灰色关联分析[J].系统工程理论与实践,2006,26(3):131-140.
    [171]罗晓利,李海燕.基于灰色关联理论的空管人误分类分析[J].中国民航大学学报,2009,27(4):26-29.
    [172]李蒙,袁策凤.核电站人因失误的动态灰色关联分析[J].核动力工程,2010,31(3):74-77.
    [173] Agrawal R, Imielinski T, Swami A. Mining association rules between sets ofitems in large databases[C]. Proceedings of1993ACM-SIGMOD InternationalConference on Management of Data, Washington DC,1993.
    [174] Na S H, Sohn S Y. Forecasting changes in Korea Composite Stock Price Index(KOSPI) using association rule[J]. Expert Systems with Application,2011,38(7):9046-9049.
    [175] Delgado M, Sanchez D, Martin-Bautista M J, et al. Mining association rules withimproved semantics in medical databases[J]. Artificial Intelligence in Medicine,2001,21(1-3):241-245.
    [176] Li T Y, Li X M. Preprocessing expert system for mining association rules intelecommunication networks[J]. Expert Systems with Application,2011,38(3):1709-1715.
    [177] Hallbert B, Gertman D, Lios E, et al. The use of empirical data sources inHRA[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2004,83(2):139-143.
    [178]张伯生.一种确定权重的新方法[J].管理工程学报,1999,13(3):67-71.
    [179]陈伟,夏建华.综合主、客观权重信息的最优组合赋权方法[J].数学的实践与认识,2007,37(1):17-22.
    [180] Yang C W, Lin C J, Tenn T C. A review of current human reliability assessmentmethods utilized in high hazard human-system interface design[C]. Proceedingsof12th International Conference on Human-Computer Interaction, Beijing,2007.
    [181] Stanton N A, Baber C. A systems approach to human error identification[J].Safety Science,1996,22(1-3):215-228.
    [182] CEI IEC61882. Hazard and operability studies (HAZOP studies)-Applicationguide[B],2001.
    [183]孙志强,史秀建,李欣欣等.基于认知模型的人为差错分类方法[J].国防科技大学学报,2008,30(1):73-77.
    [184] Kirwan B. Human error identification technique for risk assessment of high risksystem-Part1: review and evaluation of technique[J]. Applied Ergonomics,1998,29(3):157-177.
    [185] Gertman D I, Blackman H S. Human reliability and safety analysis datahandbook[M]. New York: Wiley-Interscience,1994.
    [186] Sun Z, Li Z, Gong E, et al. Estimating human error probability using a modifiedCREAM[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2012,100(1):28-32.
    [187] Moray N. Objective&Subjective estimates of human error[J]. IEEE Transactionon Reliability,1989,38(3):301-304.
    [188] Jiang Y J, Sun Z Q, Xie H W, et al. A human error probability quantificationmethod based on SRK framework[C]. Proceedings of The2010internationalConference on Information Management, Innovation Management and IndustrialEngineering, Kunming,2010.
    [189] Grabowski M, You Z Y, Zhou Z, et al. Human and organizational error datachallenges in complex, large-scale systems[J]. Safety Science,2009,47(8):1185-1194.
    [190]席永涛,陈伟炯,夏少生等.基于APJE-SLIM的海运人因失误概率的确定[J].中国安全科学学报,2011,21(3):84-89.
    [191]刘维平,曹伟国,杨立强等.装甲装备中人的可靠性统计与分析[J].兵工学报,2007,28(1):83-86.
    [192]何旭洪,黄祥瑞.工业系统中人的可靠性分析:原理、方法与应用[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2007.
    [193] Park K S, Jung K T. Considering performance shaping factors insituation-specific human error probabilities[J]. International Journal of IndustrialErgonomics,1996,18(4):325-331.
    [194] Jiang Y J, Sun Z Q, Xie H W, et al. A human error probability quantificationmethod based on CREAM+Bayes[C]. Proceedings of2010the3rd InternationalConference on Advanced Computer Theory and Engineering, Chengdu,2010.
    [195]蒋英杰,孙志强,谢红卫等.基于Bayes信息融合的人为差错概率计算方法[J].系统工程与电子技术,2011,33(4):949-953.
    [196]张金槐,唐雪梅. Bayes方法(修订版)[M].长沙:国防科技大学出版社,1993.
    [197] Hamada M S, Wilson A G, Reese C S, et al. Bayesian Reliability[M]. New York:Springer,2008.
    [198]马智博,朱建士,徐乃新.基于主观推断的可靠性评估方法[J].核科学与工程,2003,23(2):127-131.
    [199] Parry G W. Suggestions for an improved HRA method for use in probabilisticsafety assessment[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,1995,49(1):1-12.
    [200] Gertman D I, Gilmore W E, Galtean W J. Nuclear computerized library forassessing reactor reliability (NUCLARR) volume1: summary description(NUREG/CR-4639)[R]. Idaho National Engineering Laboratory, Idaho Falls,1988.
    [201] Gibson W H, Megaw E D. The implement of CORE-DATA, a computerizedhuman error probability database (HSE contract research report245/199)[R].Health and Safety Executive, Sheffield,1999.
    [202] Kirwan B, Gibson W H, Hicking B. Human error data collection as a precursorto the development of a human reliability assessment capability in air trafficmanagement[J]. Reliability Engineering and System Safety,2008,93(2):217-233.
    [203]蔡洪,张士峰,张金槐. Bayes试验分析与评估[M].长沙:国防科技大学出版社,2004.
    [204] Berger J O. Statistical Decision Theory and Bayesian Analysis (SecondEdition)[M]. New York: Springer,1985.
    [205]王玮,蔡瑞娇,焦清介.制导弹药可靠性评定方法的研究[J].兵工学报,2007,28(7):800-803.
    [206]冯静,周经论,孙权. Bayes分析中多源验前信息融合的ML-II方法[J].数学的实践与认识,2006,36(6):142-145.
    [207] http://www.stats.gov.con.
    [208] http://www.mps.gov.cn.
    [209] National Roads Authority. Road Accident Facts (Ireland,2002)[R]. NationalRoads Authority, Dublin,2002.
    [210] Stanton N A, Salmon P M. Human error taxonomies applied driving: A genericdriver error taxonomy and its implications for intelligent transport systems[J].Safety Science,2009,47(2):227-237.
    [211]段亚丽.驾驶员的驾驶素质对行车安全地影响分析[D].硕士论文.长春:吉林大学,2010.
    [212] Stephens A N, Groeger J A. Situational specificity of trait influences on drivers'evaluations and driving behaviour[J]. Transportation Research Part F,2009,12(1):29-39.
    [213] Regan M A, Hallett C, Gordon C P. Driver distraction and driver inattention:Definition, relationship and taxonomy[J]. Accident Analysis&Prevention,2011,43(5):1771-1781.
    [214] Young K L, Salmon P M. Examing the relationship between driver distractionand driving errors: A discussion of theory, studies and methods[J]. Safety Science,2012,50(2):165-174.
    [215]张磊,王建强,杨馥瑞等.驾驶员行为模式的因子分析和模糊聚类[J].交通运输工程学报,2009,9(5):121-126.
    [216]马艳丽.驾驶员驾驶特性与道路交通安全对策研究[D].博士论文.哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学,2007.
    [217] Clarke D D, Ward P, Bartle C, et al. Young driver accidents in the UK: Theinfluence of age, experience, and time of day[J]. Accident Analysis&Prevention,2006,38(5):871-878.
    [218] Bedard M, Guyatt G H, Stones M J. The independent contribution of driver,crash, and vehicle characteristics to driver fatalities[J]. Accident Analysis&Prevention,2002,34(6):717-727.
    [219]王晓原,杨新月,王凤群.基于灰色熵理论的驾驶决策影响因子研究[J].中国安全科学学报,2007,17(5):126-133.
    [220]陈雪梅,魏中华,高利.紧急情况下驾驶员行为研究[J].北京工业大学学报,2007,33(5):449-454.
    [221]王武宏,曹琦,刘东明.汽车驾驶员操作可靠性分析及评定[J].汽车工程,1994,16(4):207-213.
    [222] Fuller R, McHugh C, Pender S. Task difficulty and risk in the determination ofdriver behaviour[J]. Revue europeen of psychology application,2008,58(1):13-21.
    [223]黄荣贵.汽车驾驶员行为差错及其预防[J].人类工效学,2002,8(4):55-57.
    [224] Oz B, Ozkan T, Lajunen T. An investigation of the relationship betweenorganizational climate and professional drivers' driver behaviours[J]. SafetyScience,2010,48(10):1484-1489.
    [225]任圆圆.公路弯道路段行车危险区域及驾驶行为模型研究[D].博士论文.长春:吉林大学,2011.
    [226] Liu Y C, Wu T J. Fatigued driver's driving behavior and cognitive taskperformance: Effects of road environments and road environment changes[J].Safety Science,2009,47(8):1083-1089.
    [227] Sato T, Akamatsu M. Influence of traffic conditions on driver behavior beforemaking a right turn at an intersection: Analysis of driver behavior based onmeasured data on an actual road[J]. Transportation Research Part F,2007,10(5):397-413.
    [228] Young M S, Birrell S A, Stanton N A. Safe driving in a green world: A review ofdriver performance benchmarks and technologies to support 'smart' driving[J].Applied Ergonomics,2011,42(4):533-539.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700