我国小企业融资困境与对策研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
无论是发达国家还是发展中国家,小企业在国民经济中的地位和作用越来越重要,成为促进经济增长、科技创新、创造就业、促进经济转型的重要力量,引起全球范围内政府、学术和产业界的广泛关注、探讨和研究。尽管我国一直高度重视小企业融资的问题,国家有关部门也采取了一系列的措施办法,然而,这些方案往往没有触及深层次原因,治标不治本,融资难的问题一直未能得到有效解决,而且在宏观政策收紧的时候有加剧的趋势。
     本文在整合国内外文献的基础上,建立了逻辑清晰的关于小企业融资难成因和对策的系统分析框架,充分体现了理论和研究方法的创新性,同时进一步完善和补充这一研究领域。根据研究的需要,本文综合运用各种有效的经济分析方法,比如比较分析方法、经济理论模型分析方法等。在具体研究过程中,采用理论分析与实证分析相结合的方法。在实证分析中,则注重定性分析与定量分析相结合,描述性统计与计量分析相结合的方法,力求分析的全面性和深入性。
     本文共设七章:
     第1章绪论。论述了本文的选题背景及研究意义、研究方法,归纳总结了国内外相关理论文献,提出本文的创新点及进一步的研究方向。
     第2章小企业融资方式及供求动态博弈分析。首先,分析了小企业主要的融资方式及融资次序,对不同发展阶段和不同行业小企业的融资特点进行研究;其次,对微型企业融资的特殊性梳理分析;再次,对小企业资金供给渠道进行划分,比较不同渠道的交易费用和资金的可得性;最后,运用博弈理论对商业银行和小企业的信贷行为进行理论分析,在完全资本市场和非完全资本市场两种条件下透析小企业资金供求错配的原因。
     第3章我国小企业融资状况及制约因素分析。首先对小企业融资政策环境及融资总体情况进行分析,其次,运用因素分析法分别从小企业自身、金融体系的角度阐述小企业融资的制约因素,最后对大连市小企业融资状况进行调查和实证研究以佐证上述判断。
     第4章小企业融资支持体系的国别和地区比较与借鉴。以美国、日本、我国台湾地区等国家和地区为代表,对小企业融资市场体系和政策扶持体系的特点进行比较分析。首先分析了美国小企业融资市场体系和政策扶持体系的特点;其次分析了日本小企业融资市场体系和政策扶持体系的特点;再次其他国家和地区小企业融资市场体系和政策扶持体系的特点;最后是借鉴与启示。
     第5章我国金融机构对小企业支持的案例分析——以大连市为例。本章以五家政策性银行、国有商业银行、股份制银行、区域性银行和小型城市商业银行为例,分析了各家银行支持小型企业融资的举措和办法,通过对五家银行的分析评述,说明各家银行在支持小企业融资上的特点,丰富了小企业融资支持的研究内容。
     第6章多渠道完善小企业融资支持体系。首先提出改善小企业融资制度环境的建议,其次在分析完善小企业间接融资体系的基础上,进一步提出构建我国小企业直接融资体系的建议,通过规范和引导民间融资,发挥融资担保机构作用,以及推动适合小企业的融资方式和融资工具的发展等方式改进小企业融资支持体系,有效缓解小企业融资难的状况。
     第7章结论。归纳了全文的主要研究结论,并对微型企业研究结论进行总结。
     通过分析研究,本文可能取得以下三点创新:
     一是提出引导和规范民间融资,对接小企业融资需求的建议。通过分析和比较,本文认为缓解目前我国小微企业融资难的办法是在增加正规渠道融资的情况下,适度放开民间融资,更好的满足小企业,特别是微型企业的融资需求。同时看到,随着我国私有制经济的发展和资本积累的增加,大量民间资金迫切需要寻找运用渠道,因此,小微企业融资的“活水”来源于民间资金,将小微企业资金需求与民间资金投资需求对接,不仅是必要的而且是可行的。
     二是提出了破解我国小企业融资困境的系统性、渐进性方案和措施,并取得多处理论创新,如本文提出:从长远看,大中型银行的小企业信贷专营机构应该逐步转变为独立的地方性小企业法人银行;我国的小企业信用担保体系应由政府担保机构为主体的政策型向商业担保和互助担保为主、政策性担保为辅的市场型转变。
     三是在整合国内外有关研究文献的基础上,建立了我国小企业融资困境成因的系统分析框架,对小企业信贷进行分层次研究,并取得多处理论创新。如在第一层次的研究中,分析小企业特征、信息和法治环境对单一“商业性”银行信贷行为的影响;在第二层次的研究中,引入金融管理体制、银行业结构等制度变量,放松商业银行“商业性”和市场结构“竞争性”的假设,分析金融管理体制、银行业结构等制度变量约束下的小企业信贷行为。
     本文的不足之处主要在于对小企业融资现状、成因和对策的实证分析尚不充分,有的观点和结论需要数据支撑。在今后的研究中,需要加强数据收集和整理,使分析结论更加可靠。
Small enterprises play more and more important role in the, economy for both developed and developing countries. Small enterprises serve as an important force in promoting economic growth, technological innovation, job creation, and economic restructuring, which causes global and widespread concern from government, academic and industrial field. China has always attached great importance to small business financing, and national authorities have taken a series of measures and methods to deal with it. However, these programs often do not reach the deeper reason, and only exist as temporary solution. The issue of small business financing has not been effectively addressed, and in time of tightening of macroeconomic policies the issue becomes more serious.
     Based on the integration of literature, this paper establishes a logic systematic analyzing framework on the causes of small business financing and countermeasures, which fully reflects innovative theories and research methods while further improves and supplements this research. This paper comprehensive uses various effective methods of economic analysis, such as comparative analysis, theoretical models of economic analysis methods according to research. In specific study, theoretical analysis and empirical analysis are used in a combination. In the empirical analysis, the paper focus on the combination of qualitative analysis and the combination of descriptive statistics and econometric analysis method, which seeks to analyze the issue with great comprehensiveness and depth.
     This paper composes seven chapters:
     Chapter 1 is Introduction. This chapter discusses the background, significance of study topics, and research methods, summarizes the theory of literature at home and abroad, and comes up with the innovation of this paper and further research.
     Chapter 2 is small business financing and supply and demand dynamic game analysis. First, the chapter analyses modes of small business financing and financing major order, the different stages of development and different characteristics of small business financing in various industry; Secondly, the chapter analyses special nature of micro business financing; thirdly, the chapter analyses the money supply channel for small businesses, and compare different sources of transaction costs and funding availability; Finally, the chapter uses game theory to analyze credit behavior of commercial banks and small business theoretically and analyze mismatch reasons of capital supply and demand under both perfect capital markets and non-perfect capital markets conditions.
     Chapter 3 is China's small business financing conditions and constraints analysis. First, the chapter analyses the policy environment for small business financing and of the analysis of the overall situation of financing. Secondly, factor analysis is used to analyze the small business financing constraints from small businesses perspective and the financial system's perspective. Third, the chapter investigates the financing situation of small enterprises in Dalian and does relevant empirical research in order to support the result above.
     Chapter 4 is the comparison of small business financing support system between different countries and regions of the country and regional comparison. This chapter chooses the United States, Japan, Taiwan, China and other countries and regions as typical market and compares characteristics of financing system and policy support system for small business. First, the chapter analyses the U.S. small business financing market system and policy support system; Second, the chapter analyses the Japanese financial market system and small business policy support system features; third, the chapter analyses financing market system and policy support system in other countries and regions. The last part is the comparison and policy implications.
     Chapter 5 is case studies of Dalian City's financial institutions supporting small business. This chapter selects five typical banks as example, i.e. policy banks, state-owned commercial banks, joint-stock banks, regional banks and small city commercial banks. This chapter analyses initiatives and measures how each bank supports small business. Through the analysis of the five banks reviewed, the paper indicates the characteristics of each bank in supporting small business financing, which enriches the research content.
     Chapter 6 puts forwards multi-channel supporting system for small business financing. First, the chapter proposes to improve the institutional environment of small business financing. Second, on the analysis of completing indirect financing system for small business, the paper further proposes to build our system of direct financing for small business through regulating and guiding private financing, boosting the roles of guarantee institutions, and promoting financing tools for small business development and improving the support system for small business financing to alleviate the situation effectively.
     Chapter 7 is conclusions. The chapter summarizes the main findings of the full text, and makes conclusions of the study on micro-enterprises specifically.
     Through analysis, this paper may obtain the following three innovations:
     First, let private funds meet financing plight of small enterprises while guide and regulate it. Through analysis and comparison, the paper has proposed that one way to solve China's small and micro enterprises financing plight is to increase the formal channels of financing and to liberalize private financing moderately, so as to better meet the small cnterprises, especially micro-enterprise financing needs. It is noticed that large amount of private funds seek for investment channels urgently as China's economic development and private ownership of capital accumulation increases. In this trend, small and micro enterprise financing could be solved by private funds as a sort of "flowing water". It is not only necessary but also feasible to make the interaction between the need of small and micro-enterprise financing and the demand of private funds investment channels.
     Second, the paper proposes progressive programs and measures for the plight of small business financing in China systemically, and made many new theories. For example, the paper proposed that in the long term, small business credit franchisees of medium-sized bank should be gradually transformed into an independent local small business corporate bank, and that China's credit guarantee system for small businesses should reform from government guarantee oriented to commercial-based, and mutual -based security, supplemented by policy guarantee.
     Third, on the integration of domestic and foreign literature, this paper establishes systematic analysis framework for causes of the plight of China's small business financing, researches on small business credit in multiple level, and made many theoretical innovation. For example, in the first level of study, the paper analysis small business features and how information and legal environment affects a single "commercial" bank credit behavior. In the second level of study, the paper introduces financial management system, banking system structure as variables, relaxed the hypothesis of commercial banks''commercialese' and market structure's "competitiveness", and analyses small business credit behavior under the constraint of financial management systems, banking systems and other systems.
     The inadequacies of this paper is that the analysis on small business financing situation, causes and countermeasures of the empirical analysis is not sufficient, and that some arguments and conclusions requires further support data. In future's research, the paper needs to strengthen data collection and collation, which will make analysis of the conclusions more reliable.
引文
①刘杉:中小企业融资研究理论综述,南开经济研究,2005年第2期
    ①张广宁: 破解中国中小企业融资困境的对策研究,辽宁大学博士论文,2009年
    ①刘杉,中小企业融资研究理论综述,南开经济研究,2005年第2期
    ①所谓的金融抑制主要是指一国政府通过对金融活动和金融体系的种种管制抑制了金融体系的发展,其主要表现在对利率的控制、信贷限额或信贷指标配给、金融机构业务经营范围的限制等方面。
    ②尹丹莉:我国中小企业融资问题研究,天津财经大学博士论文,2009年
    ①张广宁:破解中国中小企业融资困境的对策研究,辽宁大学博士论文,2009年
    ①刘曼红:中国中小企业融资问题研究,12页,中国人民大学出版社,2003
    ①高正平:中小企业融资新论,66页,中国金融出版社,2004
    ②高正平:中小企业融资新论,72页,中国金融出版社,2004
    ① Berger, A. N. and Udell,G.F.,1998,"The Economics of Small Business Finance:The Roles of Private Equity and Debt Markets in the Financial Growth Cycle", Journal of Banking and Finance 22,pp187-243
    ②宋智慧:企业生命周期理论,知识经济,2010年24期
    ①此处借鉴李镇西《小企业金融服务研究》一书的分类方法,见该书21页,中国金融出版社,2011
    ②戴理慧:基于企业生命周期理论的中小企业融资问题探讨,科技信息,2009年19期
    ①张杰、刘东;微型企业融资困境与金融机构行为选择问题研究,生产力研究,2007年1期
    ①杨波:资本经营,63页,中央广播电视大学出版社,2002
    ②王铁军:中国中小企业融资28种模式,84页,中国金融出版社,2004
    ③曹啸:内生交易费用的金融发展理论与中国金融发展,59页,财贸经济,2002年1期
    ①黄少安,张岗:中国上市公司股权融资偏好分析,经济研究,2001年11期
    ①《证券法》第十四条规定
    ②《企业债券管理条例》第十二条规定
    ①《首次公开发行股票并上市管理办法》第三十三条规定
    ②《首次公开发行股票并在创业板上市管理暂行办法》第十条规定
    ③《首次公开发行股票并在创业板上市管理暂行办法》第十条规定
    ①林毅夫、李永军:中小金融机构发展与中小企业融资,经济研究,2001年1期
    ①徐东明:现行中小企业集合票据融资现状及对策建议,金融经济,2011年8期
    ②郭薇:融资租赁在企业融资中的优势分析,管理观察,2009年11期
    ①蒋琳,邢增艺,戴鸿广:发展中小企业融资租赁的思考,经济研究导刊,2009年27期
    ①吴建勇,祝有溪:优化信贷结构推进信贷转型——关于加快贸易融资业务发展的建议,中国城市经济,2009年3期
    ②陈诗礼,徐雷,吴丹:加快国内贸易融资业务发展若干问题的思考,金融管理与研究,2009年9期
    [1]Adizes, I.,1999, Managing Corporate Lifecycles, Prentice Hall
    [2]Berger, A. N. and Gregory F.Udell.1998, "The economics of small business finance: The role of private equity and debt markets in financial grow cycle". Journal of Bankingand finance. Vol22,pp187-243.
    [3]Farrar,D.and Russell T.1967, "Impefect information.uncertainy and credit rationing".Quarterly Journal of Economics.90:651-66.
    [4]Greiner, L.,1972. "Evolution and Revolution as Organizations Growth". Harvard Business Review,50,37-46
    [5]Galbis,V.1997. "Financial internation and economic growth in less-developed countries:A theoretical approach".Journal of Development Studies. vol.13.No.2.pp76-84
    [6]Harris,M.and Raviv,A.1991, "The theory of capital structure".Journal of Finance.56, No1:pp297-355
    [7]Myers,S.1984,Capital structure puzzle.NBER Working Paper.No.393
    [8]International Finance Corporation (IFC).2000.China private enterprise study(A draft report)
    [9]Shavell,A.G.Modern banking in theory and practice.John Wiley & Sons Ltd.New York.1966
    [10]Sohl,J. Angel investment activity:Funding high technology innovations.US Figures.2002
    [11]Steinfeld S.Forging reform in China:The fate of state-owned industry.Cambridge University Press.1998
    [12]Stiglitz,J.and Andew Weiss.Credit rationing in markets with imperfect information.American Economic Review.1981,June:414-477.
    [13]Stulz,R.Managerial control of voting rights:Financing policies and the market for corporate control.Journal of Economics.1988,Vol.20:721-746.
    [14]Strakan,F.and Weston.Small business lending and bank consolidation:Is there cause for concern/current issues in Economics and Financial 2,Federal ReserveBank of New York.1999:1-6.
    [15]Simon,W.N.The growth of small enterprises.Proceeding of International Forum for some Development.2001.11.
    [16]Stepnen D.W.Costly monitoring,financial intermediation and equilibrium credit rationing,Journal of Monetary Economics.1986,Vol 18:841-870
    [17]Shaffer,S.Competition,economics of scale,and diversity of firm sizes.Economica, 1985,17:467-476.Qian Y.and Roland.G.The soft budget constraint in China.Japan and the World Economy.1996,10:207-223.
    [18]Ramakrishman.and Thakor. Information reliability and a theory of financial intermediation.Review of Economic Studies.1991,51:415-432.
    [19]Rajn,R.G.and Zingals,L.Financial dependence and growth.American Economic Review.1998,88(3):559-586.
    [20]Robichek,A.Problems in the theory of optimal capital structure. Journal of Financial and quantitative analysis.1967,1:756-823
    [21]Robichek,A.and S.Myers.Some estimates of the cost of capital to the electric utility industry,1954-57,comment.The American Economic Review. 1967,57:1277-1288,
    [22]Ross,S.A.The interrelations of finance and economics:Theoretical perspectives. American Economic Review.Papers and Proceedings.1987.77:29-34.
    [23]Rubinmstein,M.Corporate financial policy in segmented securities markets.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis.1973a.8,No 5:749-761.
    [24]Rubinmstein,M.A mean variance synthesis of corporate financial theory.Journal of Finance.1973b.28,No 1:167-182.
    [25]Scott,T.An analysis of the turnaround strategy in commercial banking.Journal of Management Studies.1976,12:165-208.
    [26]Shavell,A.G.Modern banking in theory and practice.John Wiley&Sons Ltd,New York.1966
    [27]Sohl,J.Angel investment activity:Funding high technology innovations.US Figures.2002
    [28]Steinfeld S.Forging reform in China:The fate of state-owned industry.Cambridge University Press.1998
    [29]Stiglitz,J.and Andew Weiss.Credit rationing in markets with imperfect information.American Economic Review.1981,June:414-477.
    [30]Strakan.F.and Weston.Small business lending and bank consolidation:Is there cause for concern/current issues in Economics and Financial 2.Federal Reserve Bank of New York.1999:1-6.
    [31]Simon,W.N.The growth of small enterprises.Proceeding of International Forum for some Development.2001.11.
    [32]Stepnen D.W.Costly monitoring,financial intermediation and equilibrium credit rationing.Journal of Monetary Economics.1986.Vol 18:841-870
    [33]Shaffer.S.Competition,economics of scale,and diversity of firm sizes.Economica,1985. 17:467-476.
    [34]吴建勇,祝有溪.优化信贷结构推进信贷转型——关于加快贸易融资业务发展的建议[J].中国城市金融,2009,(3):35-37.
    [35]郭薇.融资租赁在企业融资中的优势分析[J].管理观察,2009,(11):16-18
    [36]陈诗礼,徐雷,吴丹.加快国内贸易融资业务发展若干问题的思考[J].金融管理与研究,2009,(9):23-28.
    [37]蒋琳,邢增艺,戴鸿广.发展中小企业融资租赁的思考[J].经济研究导刊,2009(27):66-67.
    [38]徐东明.现行中小企业集合票据融资现状及对策建议[J].金融经济,2011,(8):118-119
    [39]高正平.中小企业融资新论[M],第1版.中国金融出版社,2004
    [40]高正平等.中小企业融资实务[M],第1版.中国金融出版社,2006
    [41]中国人民银行研究局、日本国际协力机构(JICA)中国中小企业金融制度报告[R],第1版,中信出版社,2005
    [42]王铁军.中国中小企业融资28种模式[M],第1版,中国金融出版社,2004
    [43]杨波.资本经营[M],第1版,中央广播电视大学出版社,2002
    [44]黄少安,张岗.中国上市公司股权融资偏好分析[J],经济研究,2001,(11):12-20
    [45]张杰、刘东.微型企业融资困境与金融机构行为选择问题研究[J],生产力研究,2007,(1),32-33
    [46]黄丽华.结构矛盾与机制改良:对九江市微型企业融资的个案研究[J],金融研究(实务版),2007,(2),165-172
    [47]王磊、匡桦.民间金融与法定金融:高利率的融资成本解释[J],西安电子科技大 学学报,2010,(9),51-57
    [48]屈国俊、曹啸.内生交易费用金融发展理论分析框架的思考[J],河南金融管理干部学院学报,2006,(1),71-72
    [49]任彦峰、王传东.基于交易费用的中小企业信贷融资问题分析[J],沈阳大学学报,2010, (12),90-92
    [50]林毅夫、李永军.中小金融机构发展与中小企业融资[J],经济研究.2001,(1),10-18
    [51]刘曼红.中国中小企业融资问题研究[M],第1版,中国人民大学出版社,2003
    [52]黄孟复.中国小企业融资状况调查[M],第1版,中国财政经济出版社,2010
    [53]程剑鸣、孙晓岭.中小企业融资[M],第1版,清华大学出版社,2006
    [54]曹啸.内生交易费用的金融发展理论与中国金融发展[J],财贸经济,2002.(1),58-60
    [55]戴理慧.基于企业生命周期理论的中小企业融资问题探讨[J],科技信息,2009.(19),306-307
    [56]宋智慧.企业生命周期理论[J],知识经济,2010.(24),105
    [57]罗丹阳.中小企业民间融资[M].第1版.北京:中国金融出版社,2009.19-30.
    [58]谭浩俊.微型企业要“名”更要“份”[J].中国中小企业,2011,(8):13.
    [59]梅沁芳.微型企业与商业银行关系的现状、成因与新型关系的构建[J].浙江金融,2011,(7):79-80.
    [60]刘洋、刘韬.后金融危机时期中小企业融资的新出路[J].中国商贸,2011,(23):107-108.
    [61]杜亚涛、赵锦.中小企业民间融资困境与法律对策[J].合作经济与科技,2011,(9):127-128.
    [62]袁增霆、蔡真.小企业融资政策研究综述[J].金融评论,2010,(6):99-123.
    [63]王川.国内外解决中小企业融资服务的政策措施、经验做法和启示[J].中外企业家,2009, (8): 210-211.
    [64]袁满.中小企业财务管理的发展与创新[J].中国商贸,2011,(23):73-74.
    [65]王伟.浅议中小企业财务管理存在的问题及对策分析[J].时代金融,2011,(6):116-117.
    [66]李长强.我国信用担保业发展问题研究[J].投资研究,2010,(12):23-27.
    [67]马国建、张冬华.中小企业信用再担保制度研究[J].时代金融,2011,(6):72-80.
    [68]王家辉.中小企业贷款难的银行视角[J].经济论坛,2011,(5):142-144.
    [69]苏汝勤.中小企业贷款风险表现及其审计方法[J].学术论坛,2011,(5):131-139.
    [70]宗和.破解中小企业融资难[J].中国中小企业,2011,(8):16-22.
    [71]蒋倩华.我国中小企业融资难的原因及对策分析[J].中国商贸,2011,(24):113-114.
    [72]曾荣华、曾鑫.我国中小企业融资难的问题及对策探析[J].时代金融,2011,(6):141-142.
    [73]陈代莹.中小企业融资与民间资本的合法化进程[J].中国证券期货,2011,(7):187-4-185
    [74]林毅夫、孙希芳.信息、非正规金融与中小企业融资[J].经济研究,2005,(7):35-44
    [75]林汉川、魏中奇.中小企业的界定与评价[J].中国工业经济,2000,(7):12-17
    [76]任志华.中小企业融资行为与商业银行制度和业务创新[D].天津大学博士学位论文,2003
    [77]陈莉.中小企业融资的特点,难点及解决对策[J].武汉金融,2006,(4):22-24
    [78]陈连江.德国中小企业生存环境及对我国中小企业的启示[J].乡镇企业研究,2004,(3):63-64
    [79]陈明玉:宏观调控下中小企业的融资结构——苍南县221家中小企业融资情况的调查[J].浙江经济,2005,(18):26-28
    [80]陈荣富.《台湾之合会事业》,台湾银行期刊,1953,5(4)
    [81]陈晓红,郭声琨,中小企业的融资[M].经济科学出版社,2000
    [82]陈晓红,刘剑.我国中小企业融资结构与融资方式演进研究[J].中国软科学,2005,(12): 61-67
    [83]傅汉清.美国小企业研究[M].中国财政经济出版社,2000
    [84]葛兆强、廖梅桂.国有银行不良债权的经济学分析[J].人大复印报刊资料:金融与保险,1999(3)
    [85]郭斌、刘曼路.民间金融与中小企业发展:对温州的实证分析[J].经济研,2002(10):40-46
    [86][美]拉迪·R·尼古拉斯:《中国未完成的经济改革》[M].隆国强,李桐连等译,中国发展出版社1999
    [87]赖婧华.运用税收杠杆促进科技型中小企业发展[J].科技创业月刊,2006,(10):43-44
    [88]乐强毅.我国未上市公司股权交易市场研究[M].上海财经大学出版社,2008。
    [89]李建军.民间金融:不可替代的内生需求[N].中国经营报,2010.2.14。
    [90]卢福财.企业融资效率分析[M].经济管理出版社,2001
    [91]李扬、杨思群.中小企业融资与银行[M].上海财经大学出版社,2001。
    [92]陈艳;张明悦.金融危机背景下我国中小企业融资问题的实证研究[J].东北财经大学学报,2011,(3):22-29
    [93]胡小平.中小企业融资[M].经济管理出版社,2001。
    [94]沈炳熙、高圣智.日本的中小企业金融政策[J].金融研究,2002,(9):53-60
    [95]史巧玉.中小企业界定标准及行业分布研究[J].兰州商学院学报,2004,20(1):47-54
    [96][美]斯蒂格勒.产业组织和政府管制[M].上海人民出版社,三联书店,1996
    [97][日]太田一郎.现代中小企业的活力与新生[M].西安电子科技大学出版社,1991
    [98]万解秋.企业融资结构研究[M].复旦大学出版社,2001
    [99]王正耀、年四五:.中小企业民间融资:形成机理与规范对策[J].河南金融管理干部学院学报,2006,(1):118-120
    [100]王霄,张捷.银行信贷配给与中小企业融资[J].经济研究,2003(7):36-40
    [101]徐金才.对“萧山模式”信用担保公司持续发展现象的调查与思考[J].浙江金融,2007, (5): 43-44
    [102]张杰.民营经济的金融困境与融资次序[J].经济研究,2000,(4):3-10
    [103]张令柏、张乐善.产权交易市场非上市公司股票交易问题研究[J].财会研究,2007,(3): 50-53
    [104]祝孔海.我国中小企业融资问题实证研究[J].金融理论与实践,2005,(3):39-42

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700