新型农村合作医疗健康体检的模式研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
目的
     本文旨在通过对新型农村合作医疗健康体检的内涵、利益相关主体、存在问题分析,以及四种不同健康体检模式的设计、实施效果和优缺点比较,探讨不同目的下适宜的健康体检模式,并提出相应的对策与建议,以促进新型农村合作医疗健康体检的持续发展。
     方法
     本文运用公共管理学、卫生事业管理学、卫生经济学、卫生统计学等理论和方法,通过理论分析、现场调查和人员访谈,对新型农村合作医疗健康体检的内涵、存在问题、利益相关主体、及不同目的下的适宜体检模式进行了分析。主要方法包括:(1)文献研究法;(2)现场调查法;(3)人员访谈法;(4)问卷调查;(5)卫生统计学方法。
     结果
     (1)新型农村合作医疗健康体检是指政府统一领导,卫生部门(主要是新型农村合作医疗管理部门)牵头,有关部门协作,以农民所在地的乡镇卫生院作为主要经办机构,为参合农民提供的健康体检。
     (2)新型农村合作医疗的目的:①在合作医疗初期主要是扩大参合农民补偿受益面和缓解基金结余压力;②在合作医疗深入发展时期主要是通过疾病预防和健康教育对农民进行健康管理。
     (3)新型农村合作医疗健康体检模式的主要内容:①体检的设计理念;②体检经费来源渠道与拨付标准;③体检经费拨付方式;④体检对象的界定;⑤体检项目的设置;⑥体检机构及医生的要求;⑦体检时间、地点安排及开展方式;⑧体检过程中的角色界定;⑨体检质量的监管与结果应用。
     (4)新型农村合作医疗健康体检四种主要模式:①A模式:体检对象由“未获补偿”参合家庭推荐一人,“菜单式”检查项目设置,农民按需选择,从家庭账户基金中支付体检经费;②B模式:政府单列体检基金,体检标准分类设置,体检对象由“未补偿”参合居民调整到全体参合居民;③C模式:广覆盖面下的一般体格体检,从住院基金中支付体检基金;④D模式:针对性强的“两步走”体检,体检对象为“未获住院补偿”的参合农民,从合作医疗基金支付体检经费。
     (5)新型农村合作医疗健康体检存在的主要问题:①体检设计理念不一致;②从合作医疗基金中提取体检基金的作法与合作医疗主旨及家庭账户补偿模式之间的矛盾;③体检对象确定现行健康体检政策之间的矛盾;④体检项目设置与有限经费和农民高期望值之间的矛盾;⑤部分地区体检资金使用效率低;⑥部分体检体检机构服务能力较低,医生水平有限;⑦体检政策宣传不到位,部分农民健康意识不高;⑧)体检标准不统一,组织方式与监管力度有待完善和加强;⑨体检结果应用不足。
     结论
     (1)明确政府(新型农村合作医疗管理部门为主)、体检机构(乡镇卫生院为主)、参合农民三方利益主体在健康体检过程中的责、权、利;(2)因地制宜,依据不同的体检目的设置相应的新型农村合作医疗健康体检模式。(3)从法律和政策上对农民健康体检予以明确,现行新型农村合作医疗健康体检的政策应保持一定时期内的稳定性;(4)新型农村合作医疗健康体检应逐步过渡到农村公共卫生范畴,由政府担当筹资责任主体,并整合农村地区不同领域的体检资源,以保证其发展的持续性;(5)建立相对统一的体检标准,以规范体检质量:(6)加强信息网络化技术在体检资料管理和分析中的应用;(7)建立健全新型农村合作医疗健康体检组织开展方式及监管体系;(8)加强乡镇卫生院服务能力建设,提高体检医生的水平。
Objective According to the analysis on connotation, stakeholders and problems of health examination in the New Cooperative Medical System(NCMS) and comparison of designing,effection, advantages and disadvantages among different models of health examination,the thesis discusses the appropriate models of health examination under different objectives,and raises reasonable countermeasures and proposals,which can promote health examination in the NCMS smoothly.
     Methods Through theoretical analysis, field survey and interview,the connotation, stakeholders,problems and appropriate models under different objectives were analyzed by applying theories and methods of public management,health management,health economics,biostatistics and so on. The main methods include literature study, field survey, interview, questionnaire survey and biostatistics.
     Results
     1) Health examination in NCMS is provided for the farmers who have been in the NCMS for a period of time.It is under the unified leadership of government,and requests the health sectors to take the lead in collaboration with other related departments. Township hospitals are the main implementing agencies.
     2) Objectives of health examination in NCMS:①In the beginning of NCMS,the main objective is to expand the compensation benefit of farmers joining in NCMS and ease pressure on the fund balances;②In-depth development of NCMS,the main objectivs is to manage farmers’health by disease prevention and health education.
     3)Main contents of health examination in NCMS:①The designing of health examination;②Channel and payment of funds;③Methods of paying funds;④Defining the farmers of health examination;⑤Setting the items and contents of health examination;⑥Standards of township hospitals and doctors;⑦Arrangements of time,place and organization;⑧ Stakeholders’role in health examination;⑨Monitoring and using.
     4) Typical models of health examination in NCMS:①A:Limited range of farmers and menu-set items;②B: Funds from Public health expenditure and different standards;③C:Wide coverage and simple examination;④D:Two-step and targeted examination.
     5) Main problems of health examination in the NCMS:①Different concept of designing;②Funds of health examination from NCMS is questionable;③Methods of determining physical objects is questionable;④Contradictions among items,funds and farmers’expectations;⑤The use of funds is low efficiency in somg areas;⑥Service capacity of some towns hospitals is limited;⑦Policy advocacy and health awareness among farmers should be further strengthened;⑧Different standards is not conducive to control the quality;⑨The use of health examination is not enough.
     Conclusion
     1)Clear the duties,rights,and benefit among government, institutions and farmers;2) According to different objectives,appropriate models of health examination must meet with local conditions and the development of NCMS;3) The current policy of health examination in the NCMS should keep its stability and continuity for a certain period of time and be defined by law;4) For the further development,health examination in the NCMS should be integrated with other health examination in rural areas and put into the range of Public Health, in which government plays a dominant role;5)The uniform standards of health eaamination must be established to control guality;6)Healthy information should be collected, collated and used timely by building and applying the network and information technology;7) The organizations and monitoring system of health examination must be established and improved;8)Promte the quality of health examination by strengthening capacity-building and doctors’ability of township hospital. In this process,county-level medical institutions play a guiding role.
引文
[1] http://www.shgzw.gov.cn/gb/gzw/shgz/node572/node575/userobject1ai53756.html
    [2]沈利英,叶志弘,秦建芬等.在健康体检中开展健康促进工作.中华护理杂志, 2006,41(9):821-822.
    [3]张成琪,孟庆跃,冯建,等.健康体检发展与健康管理的模式探讨.中国卫生事业管理,2007,8:510-513.
    [4]中国健康体检网.
    [5] Chii - Jun Chion ,M·S·and Hsing- Yi Chang, Dr·PH·Do the elderly benefit from Annual Physical Examination? [J]·Preven-tive Medicine ,2002(35):264~270.
    [6]Nakannshi N, Tatara,Takashima Y, FujiwaraH, Takamori Y, Takabayashi H,et al·The as-sociation of health management with the health of elderly people [J]·Age Ageing , 1995;(24):334~340.
    [7]Nakannshi N, Tatara K, Tatatorige, Muraka-mi S, Shinsho F·Effects of preventive health service on survival of the elderly living in a community in Osaka, Japan [J]·Epidemiol Commun Health ,1997;(51):199~204.
    [8]Vetter N·J, Jones DA ,Victor CR·Effects of health vistors working with elderly patients in general practice :a randomized controlled trial[J]·Br Med J ,1984;(289):1522~1524.
    [9]World Bank (1993) World Development Re-port ,Investing in Health[D]·New York :Ox-ford University Press ,1994.
    [10]刘翠娥,孙玉兰,王丹妮.浅谈健康体检的必要性.青岛医药卫生,2005,37(6):473.
    [11]Baberg HT, Uzun D, de Zeeuw J. Health promotion and inpatient rehabili-tation.Herz,2005, 30(8):754-760.
    [12]王永娟,孙一文.健康体检是实施健康管理的最佳时机.现代医药卫生,2005,21(13):1762-1763.
    [13]P.Puska,et al. The Norh Karelia Project:20Year Results and Experiences [M].Helsinki University Printing House,1995:359-363.
    [14]金彩虹.芬兰健康管理模式的经验.中国卫生资源,2007,10(6):312-313.
    [15]P.Puska.Successful prevention of non-communicable diseases: 25year experiences with North Karelia Project in Finland[J].Public Health Medicine2002,4(1):5-7.
    [16] Krouse HJ. Video modeling to educate patients.J Adv Nurs,2001,33(6):748-757.
    [17] Hwalla N,Koleilat M.Dietetic practice:the past,present and future.East Mediter Health J,2004,10(6):716-730.
    [18]卫生部、财政部、农业部《关于建立新型农村合作医疗制度的意见》(国办发[2003]3号).
    [19]《中共中央、国务院关于进一步加强农村卫生工作的决定》(中发[2002]13号),2002年10月19日.
    [20]卫生部、财政部、国家中医药管理局《关于完善新型农村合作医疗统筹补偿方案的指导意见》(卫农卫发[2007]253号).
    [21]刘军安,卢祖洵,田怀谷等.新型农村合作医疗支持体系功能要素分析.中国卫生经济,2007,26(10):44-46.
    [22]王延中,冯立果,崔红志,等.社会主义新农村建设背景下农村卫生事业发展的思路和对策.中国卫生经济,2007,26(8):11-14.
    [23]石丁.基于可持续发展的新型农村合作医疗制度改革初探.卫生经济研究,2007,8:35-36.
    [24]欧佩芳.体检过程中健康教育的人文关怀.南方护理学报,2003,10(6):63-64.
    [25]刘瑛,郭建丽.利用健康体检进行健康教育初探[J].中国健康教育,2004,20(1):56—57.
    [26]孙乃强.健康体检从没病找病开始[J].中国卫生产业,2005, 9: 36-37.
    [27]张建华,滕文杰.论社会公共卫生服务与政府职责.中国卫生质量管理, 2005,12(2):47-49.
    [28]方茹,刘君燕.职业医学教育应加强学生健康教育能力的培养.卫生职业教育,2004,6:28.
    [29]董冬.中国健康管理模式研究.科学之友,2007年11月:73-74.
    [30]李鲁.主编.社会医学.第2版,北京:人民卫生出版社,2003.8.
    [31]Martin R,Riehle D,Buschmann F,程序设计的模式语言,北京:清华大学出版社,2005.82.
    [32]王惠军,王炳丽.SARS过后新掘金产业借势萌芽-健康体检产业发展展望[J].医药世界,2003;(9):14~23.
    [33]王召平,张爱莉.日本健康体检医学的现状.上海预防医学杂志, 2002,14(3):123-125.
    [34] http://www.kyncenter.com/InfoCenter/default.asp?ID=6.
    [35]林淑周.重视新型农村合作医疗实施中的利益关系及其协调.福州党校学报,2005,6:36-39.
    [36]杨俊.农村公共卫生事业管理的探讨.中国卫生事业管理,2005,8:490-491.
    [37]赖瑞南,俞容容,周旭东.按人头付费在新型农村合作医疗中的应用探讨.中国卫生事业管理, 2006, 22(3): 178-188.
    [38]沈清,刘钟明,陈定湾,等.浙江省农民健康体检实施情况分析.卫生经济研究,2007,8:45-46.
    [39]樊放,买买提·胡加合买提.健康体检应制定统一的国家标准.中医药管理杂志,2005,3:58-59.
    [40]Winslow C-EA.The untilled fields of public health[J].Science,New Series,1920,51(1306): 23-33.
    [41]Dorthy P.,The history of public health:current themes and ap-proaches Hygiea Internationalist.1999,(1):9~21.
    [42]Institute of medicine.The future of public health National Academies Press,Washington DC.1988.
    [43]Beaglehole R,Bonita R,Horton R,et al.Public health in the newera:improving health through collective action[J].Lancet,2004,363(9426):2084-2086.
    [44]Institure of medicine.The future of public health in 21stcentury.The National Academies Press,Washington DC.2003.
    [45]伍晓霞.安徽省新农合可持续发展关键因素分析及对策.中国农村卫生事业管理.2007,27(11):812-813.
    [46]王延清,高惠珍,张鲁春,等.优化健康体检流程提高服务质量和效率.社区医学杂志,2006,4(3)
    [1]中共中央、国务院关于进一步加强农村卫生工作的决定
    [2]郑小华.新型农村合作医疗补偿方案研究[J].医院领导决策参考,2004,(3):7-10.
    [3]邵海亚.对新型农村合作医疗属性、目标及评价的思考.卫生软科学,2006,24(2):99-101.
    [4]刘明慧,陈军晖.社会保障理论与改革探索[M].沈阳:东北财经大学出版社,1998.
    [5]冯晓明.农民健康体检的一些常识.乐清日报,2006年10月.
    [6]沈利英,叶志弘,秦建芬等.在健康体检中开展健康促进工作.中华护理杂志, 2006,41(9):821-822.
    [7]睢党臣.我国新型农村合作医疗制度发展初探.宁夏社会科学,2006,2:70-73.
    [8]张宜民,庄红平,张金齐等.论新型农村合作医疗制度的可持续发展.中国初级卫健, 2004,18(18):18-20.
    [9]王宏艳,王洪曼.从现代公共卫生内涵探寻我国公共卫生建设之路.中国公共卫生管理.2005,6:455-457
    [10]卫生部关于新型农村合作医疗的新闻发布会,2006年9月27日
    [11]刘翠娥,孙玉兰,王丹妮.浅谈健康体检的必要性.青岛医药卫生,2005,37(6):473.
    [12]王翠玲,吴建民.从卫生经济学角度看投资农村卫生的重要意义.中国初级卫生保健,2005,19(11):31-32.
    [13]韩萍.从健康体检看健康教育的重要性.中国中医药:46-48
    [14]王永娟,孙一文.健康体检是实施健康管理的最佳时机.现代医药卫生,2005,21(13):1762-1763.
    [15]王俊华.中国农村公共卫生:问题、出路与政府责任.江苏社会科学,2003,4:30-34.
    [16]王小丽,谢玉红.新型农村合作医疗制度的缺陷分析.中国初级卫生保健,2006,20(1):10-11.
    [17]马雪彬,曹建新.逆向选择:新型农村合作医疗制度的内在脆弱性探析.贵州社会科学,2005,6:26-29.
    [18]丁少群,尹中立.农村医疗保障:新型农村合作医疗该向何处去.中国卫生经济.2005,24(3):20-23.
    [19]冯永惠.健康体检的发展.现代护理.2005,11(9):690-691.
    [20]孙乃强.健康体检从没病找病开始[J].中国卫生产业,2005,9:36-37.
    [21]沈利英,叶志弘,秦建芬等.在健康体检中开展健康促进工作.中华护理杂志, 2006,41(9):821-822.
    [22]韩萍.从健康体检看健康教育的重要性.中国中医药:46-48
    [23]袁红,毛精华,饶定虎,等.我院实施健康体检套餐的做法.中华医院管理杂志,2003,19(11):700.
    [24]陶力超.行业健康体检费用支出的几种方式探讨.上海预防医学杂志,2002,14(5):221.
    [25]冯永惠.对健康体检病种的调查分析.中国疗养医学.2005,14(4):246-247.
    [26]任冬莉,姜萍,孙奎兰,等.重视健康体检强化慢性病的防治.农垦医学, 2004,26(6):428-429.
    [27]李英年,李晓华,王桂玲.浅述健康体检的管理.医学研究生学报,2006,19(1):95-96.
    [28]谢青.食品从业人员健康体检的质量控制管理.职业与健康,2002,18(8):54.
    [29]樊放,买买提·胡加合买提.健康体检应制定统一的国家标准.中医药管理杂志, 2005,13(3):58-59.
    [30]冯晓明.农民健康体检的一些常识.乐清日报,2006年10月.
    [31]王靖元,徐德斌,徐文彦.赣榆县新型农村合作医疗免费体检的做法与分析.中国农村卫生事业管理,2006,26(3):26-27.
    [32]范玉改,姚建红.澳大利亚的农村公共卫生.中华全科医学杂志,2006,5(7):419-420.
    [33]Australia government department of health and ageing. General Practice in Australia: Canberra ACT: National Capital Printing,2005.131-132.
    [34]Wilkinson D, Blue I. The new rural health. South Melboure: Oxford University Press,2004.100.
    [35]Krouse HJ.Video modeling to educate patients.J Adv Nurs,2001,33(6):748-757.
    [36]Hwalla N,Koleilat M.Dietetic practice:the past,present and future.East Mediter Health J,2004,10(6):716-730.
    [37]Baberg HT,Uzun D,de Zeeuw J.Health promotion and inpatient rehabilitation. Herz,2005,30(8):754-760.
    [38]石裕东.国外农村医疗保险制度对我国农村医疗保障制度的启示.当代经理人, 2006.2:146-147.
    [39]王召平,张爱莉.日本健康体检医学的现状.上海预防医学杂志, 2002,14(3):123-125.
    [40]柴传英,陈宝海,丁玲.健康体检面临的问题及对策.实用医药杂志.2006,23(8):1017.
    [41]王靖元,徐德斌,徐文彦.赣榆县新型农村合作医疗免费体检的做法与分析.中国农村卫生事业管理,2006,26(3):26-27.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700