摘要
随着经济全球化的发展和国际竞争的日趋激烈,复杂产品研发已经成为企业、行业、国家竞争的一个核心领域。为获得持续的国际、国内优势,许多企业不断开发新的复杂产品。由于技术和制造的承接性,这些复杂产品往往并行开发,多个并行的复杂产品研发项目之间资源竞争非常激烈,这为企业层面的多项目调度提出了新的理论和实践课题。目前的研究成果多侧重于单个项目的资源配置和调度,对企业层面的多项目调度研究较少。因此,面向复杂产品研发过程,研究企业层面多项目管理中的资源配置和调度问题,从制约企业新产品研发效率的瓶颈因素角度对复杂产品研发多项目调度过程进行计划和控制,对于提高复杂产品研发企业的产能和资源利用率具有重要的理论和现实意义。
本文基于关键链项目管理方法,针对复杂产品研发企业多项目管理的现状,研究了复杂产品研发多项目调度问题,提出了基于关键链的多项目调度模型和相关决策方法。主要内容包括:构建基于关键链的复杂产品研发项目和任务绩效评估指标体系,对应用关键链方法实施调度的复杂产品研发项目的绩效进行评估;构建所有任务只使用单一类型资源的情况下基于关键链的多项目调度模型,并应用甘特图对实例进行了情景分析和说明;建立全部任务使用多种类型资源的情况下,以多项目总延迟成本最小为目标函数,基于关键链的多项目调度两层决策模型;最后根据关键链多项目调度管理系统的特征和优势,构建基于关键链项目管理方法及模型的多项目调度管理系统。
本文的主要研究内容和创新点如下:
(1)研究基于关键链的复杂产品研发项目和任务绩效评估问题。首先分析了基于关键链的多项目绩效评估问题及其对资源竞争情况下多项目调度问题的重要意义;然后基于关键链项目管理方法的特征,分别构建了项目和任务绩效评估指标体系;接着考虑复杂产品研发多项目调度决策过程中的主观不确定性、模糊性、定量和定性指标共存性等,提出将模糊层次分析法与证据理论方法相结合的评估方法;对某大型汽车制造企业的汽车整车产品研发项目绩效进行评估并产生相应的项目优先权顺序,仿真结果验证了该评估方法的合理性和有效性。
(2)研究单一类型资源模式下,基于关键链的复杂产品研发多项目调度问题。首先从复杂产品研发调度过程的特征出发,分析了项目的组织结构对多项目资源分配和调度产生的影响,提出了基于关键链方法进行多项目调度的两个基本定理;接着以上述定理为基础,建立基于瓶颈任务的多项目调度决策模型和多项目调度的组织责任模型,提出了所有任务仅使用单一类型的资源时基于关键链的多项目调度方法;然后根据项目和任务绩效评估指标体系,确定多项目中的项目优先权并进一步产生瓶颈任务的优先权顺序;应用上述基于关键链的新方法以解决汽车整车平台研发多项目调度问题,将其结果与基于项目优先权的关键链多项目调度方法进行比较,以阐明该方法的有效性和先进性。
(3)研究多类型资源模式下复杂产品研发的多项目调度问题。首先根据复杂产品研发过程中多项目调度的特征,从关系企业整体绩效的全局出发,提出基于关键链的两层决策模型,以解决任务占用多种类型资源情况下资源受限的多项目调度问题。然后综合关键链项目管理理论和两层决策方法,分别以多项目总工期最短和多项目延迟成本最小为目标,建立多类型资源模式下基于关键链的多项目调度模型;接着综合基于任务优先权规则的启发式串行调度算法和模拟退火算法,提出一种新型混合模拟退火算法并求解该模型;在某汽车企业的复杂产品研发多项目调度计划中验证和比较了上述模型和算法求解效率,同时对算法的稳定性进行了分析。
(4)研究基于关键链的多项目调度管理系统。针对复杂产品研发过程中多项目管理的特点,介绍基于关键链的多项目调度管理系统的功能特征,并比较其在汽车整车产品研发项目管理领域相对基于关键路径的项目调度系统所具有的优势;面向国内复杂产品研发行业基于关键链的多项目调度系统应用现状,根据前文提出的多项目调度理论决策模型和方法,构建基于关键链的多项目调度管理系统的总体框架并进行快速原型设计。
Along with the development of economic globalization and fierce international competition,complex product development&research(R&D) has became a core competence among enterprises,industries and nations. To acquire continuous international and domestic advantages, manyenterprises develop new complex products constantly.
Due to the succession of technology and manufacturing, these complex products often developconcurrently, which lead to intense resources competition among several parallel complex productR&D projects, thus a new theory and practice put forward for multi-project scheduling onenterprise level. The results of current research have focused on resource allocation and schedulingof a single project, whereas less studies have been put on multi-project of a whole enterprise.Therefore, we should face the R&D process of complex product and study the resource allocationand scheduling of multi-project on enterprise level. Planning and controlling the multi-projectscheduling process of complex product R&D bases on the bottleneck of new product R&Defficiency. These are important in improving the capacity and resource utilization of complexproduct R&D enterprises.
The dissertation aimed at the present situation of multi-project management of complexproduct R&D enterprises, studies the problem of complex product R&D multi-project schedulingbased on critical chain method(CCM), and presents the scheduling model and decision method ofmulti-project. Firstly, built the index system of project and task performance evaluation based onCCM and then evaluated the performance of project. Secondly, built the multi-project schedulingmodel based on CCM under the situation of a single resource used in all tasks. Scenario analysisand illustration of the example was done by Gantt Chart. Thirdly, established the bi-level decisionmodel of critical chain multi-project scheduling under the situation that all tasks using differentkinds of resources and set up the objective function as the minimum total delay cost inmulti-project. Finally, a multi-project scheduling management system based on CCM was built toassist the whole decision making process.
The main research contents and contributions in the dissertation are summarized as follows:
(1) It researched the problem of complex product R&D project and task performanceevaluation based on CCM. Firstly, analyzed the multi-project performance evaluation problembased on critical chain and the significance of multi-project scheduling under resource competition.Then, built the performance evaluation index system of project and task respectively based on thefigures of CCM. An evaluation method based on Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process(FAHP) and Evidence Reasoning(ER)was proposed in consideration of subjective uncertainty, fuzziness,co-existence of quantitative and qualitative indicators during the decision process of Complexproduct R&D multi-project scheduling. Lastly, evaluated the automotive product R&D projectperformance and the corresponding project priorities of a large automobile manufacturingenterprise. The simulation results verify the rationality and effectiveness of the evaluation method.
(2) It researched the complex product R&D multi-project scheduling base on CCM under thesituation of a single resource used in all tasks. Firstly, analyzed the impact of project organizationstructure on multi-project resource allocation starting from the characters of complex product R&Dscheduling process. Meanwhile, it proposed that there are two basic axioms of multi-projectscheduling based on CCM. Then, set up the decision and organization responsibility model basedon bottleneck task of above axioms, and presented a new scheduling method when a singleresource used in all tasks. Thirdly, confirmed the project and task priorities on the basis of projectand task performance evaluation index system. Finally, applied the above new methods based onCCM to resolve the multi-project scheduling of automobile product R&D process, and comparedthe results with which obtained from the CCM based on project priority to illustrate theeffectiveness and advancement of the new proposed method.
(3) It researched multi-project scheduling problem under the situation that all tasks usingdifferent kinds of resources. Firstly, presented a bi-level decision model based on CCM formenterprise’s overall performance to settled the Resource Constrained Multi-Project SchedulingProblem(RCMPSP) under the situation of tasks using different kinds of resources. Secondly,integrated the CCM and a bi-level decision method to build the critical chain multi-projectscheduling model under multi-resource environment with objective function as the minimum totaldelay cost and the minimum multi-project duration respectively. Then, proposed a new HybridSimulated Annealing (HSA) based on Serial Schedule Generation Scheme(SSGS) and SimulatedAnnealing (SA) and calculated the model. At last, verified and compared the above models andarithmetic in the complex product R&D multi-project scheduling plan of an automotive enterpriseand analyzed stability of the algorithm.
(4) It researched the multi-project scheduling management system of CCM. Illustrated thefunctional characteristics of above system and it’s advantage in the area of automobile productR&D project management, and compared it to project scheduling system of Critical PathMethod(CPM). Then, faced to the current application situation of Chinese complex product R&Dindustry of multi-project scheduling system based on CCM. Built the general framework ofmulti-project management system under the above decision model and method, thus conducted therapid prototyping.
引文
[1]柴旭东,李伯虎,熊光楞等.复杂产品协同仿真平台的研究与实现[J].计算机集成制造系统,2002,8(7):580-584.
[2]杨善林等.复杂产品开发——工程管理理论与方法[M].北京:科学出版社,2012.
[3]周剑.基于综合集成法的复杂产品协同设计若干关键问题研究[D].南京理工大学博士学位论文,2012.
[4]滕晓艳.复杂产品系统的模块划分方法研究[D].哈尔滨工程大学博士学位论文,2011.
[5]杨颖.复杂产品开发项目组合的动态决策方法研究[D].合肥工业大学博士学位论文,2011.
[6] Corsetti A, Ribeiro E. A, Garbi G. P., et al. Complex Systems Developed with SystemConcurrent Engineering[M].Concurrent Engineering Approaches for Sustainable ProductDevelopment in a Multi-Disciplinary Environment. Springer London,2013:1057-1068.
[7] Loureiro G. Lessons learned in12years of space systems concurrent engineering[C].61stInternational Astronautical Congress, Prague, Czech Republic.2010.
[8] Davies A, Hobday M. The business of projects: managing innovation in complex productsand systems[M]. Cambridge University Press,2005.
[9] Acha V., Davies A., Hobday M., Salter A. J. Exploring the capital goods economy: complexproduct systems in the UK[J]. Industrial and Corporate Change,2004,13(3):505–529.
[10] Hobday, M. and Laursen, K. International trade in high technology capital goods: anempirical assessment, mimeo, Complex Product System Innovation Centre, SPRU, England,2003.
[11] Davies A. Innovation in large technical systems: the case of telecommunications[J].Industrial and Corporate Change,1996,5(4):1143–1180.
[12] Davies A. The life cycle of a complex product system[J]. International Journal of InnovationManagement,1997,1(3):229–256.
[13] Abegglen J. C. Sea Change: Pacific Asia as the New World Industrial Centre[M]. New York:The Free Press,1994.
[14] Hobday M. Innovation in East Asia: The Challenge to Japan[M]. London: EdwardElgar,1995.
[15] Clark K. B., Fujimoto T. Product Development Performance[M]. Boston: Harvard BusinessSchool Press,1991.
[16] Dawson B, Fixson S. K, Whitney D. Orchestrating coordination: Reducing rework incomplex product development[J]. Babson College Digital Knowledge at Babson,2012.
[17]施国强,李伯虎,柴旭东.不确定条件下复杂产品开发项目调度模型研究[J].计算机集成制造系统,2007,13(10):1909-1913.
[18]艾明晔,齐中英. R&D项目进展评估及决策选择模型[J].控制与决策,2007,22(5):494-498.
[19]马增建.汽车设计潜在失效模式及后果分析的外部关系[J].天津汽车,2007(4):5-7.
[20]王征.新产品开发中供应商的管理问题研究[D].西安电子科技大学,2005.
[21]邓斌.一种基于关键链的项目进度计划方法[J].华中科技大学学报,2008,25(4):264-269.
[22]钱利军,李书全.关键链项目管理方法研究[J].现代管理科学,2009,8:26-28.
[23] Galbraith J. R. Designing complex organizations[M]. Addison-Wesley Longman PublishingCo., Inc.,1973.
[24] Mintzberg H. Structure in fives: Designing effective organizations[M]. Prentice-Hall, Inc,1993.
[25] Hughes T. P. Rescuing Prometheus[M]. New York: Pantheon Books,1998.
[26] Gaddis P. O. The project manager[J]. Harvard Business Review,1959,37(3):89-97.
[27] Middleton C. J. How to set up a project organization[J]. Harvard Business Review,1967,3:73–82.
[28] Morris P. W. G. The Management of Projects[M]. London: Thomas Telford,1994.
[29] Sapolsky H. M. The Polaris System Development: Bureaucratic and Programmatic Successin Government[M]. Cambridge: Harvard University Press,1972.
[30]郭庆军,赛云秀.关键链多项目进度管理分析[J].西安工业大学学报,2007,27(6):583-598.
[31]王永超,航空多型号项目计划与协调控制技术研究[D].西安:西北工业大学,2007.
[32]施国强,李伯虎,柴旭东.基于着色Petri网的复杂产品开发多项目调度建模研究[J].系统仿真学报,2007,19(17):3869一3972,3948.
[33]刘琼,林魁,张超勇等.基于关键链多项目鲁棒调度[J].计算机集成制造系统,2012,18(4):813-820.
[34]应瑛,寿涌毅.基于组合拍卖方法的资源受限多项目调度[J].计算机集成制造系统,2009,15(11):2160-2165.
[35]苏青,杨海成,敬石开等.多资源约束下航天多项目调度的启发式算法[J].中国空间科学技术,2009,29(3):64-70.
[36]马国丰,尤建新.关键链项目群进度管理的定量分析[J].系统工程理论与实践,2007,27(9):54-60.
[37]施国强,李伯虎,柴旭东.不确定条件下复杂产品开发项目调度模型研究[J].计算机集成制造系统,2007,13(10):1909-1913.
[38] Mabin Vicky,Steven Balderstone. A Review of Goldratt’ s Theory of Constraints-Lessonsfrom the International Literature[C]. Operational Research Society of New Zealand33rdAnnual Conference, Auckland.1998,205–214.
[39] Hagemann A. G. Use of the critical chain project management technique at NASA LangleyResearch Center[C]. Digital Avionics Systems2001DASC20th Conference, IEEE.2001.
[40] Feng J. C, Li L, Yang N, et al. Critical chain construction with multi-resource constraintsbased on portfolio technology in South-to-North Water Diversion Project[J]. Water Scienceand Engineering,2011,4(2):225-236.
[41] Kazem Yaghootkar, Causes and Effects of Schedule Pressure in New Product DevelopmentMulti-project Environments: An Empirical and System Dynamics Study of ProductDevelopment in a Truck Manufacturer[D] A thesis submitted to The University ofManchester for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Humanities,2010.
[42] Abdel-Hamid T K, Madnick S E. Software project dynamics: an integrated approach[M].Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall,1991.
[43] Abdel-Hamid T. K. On the utility of historical project statistics for cost and scheduleestimation: results from a simulation-based case study[J]. Journal of Systems and Software,1990,13(1):71-82.
[44] Repenning N. P. Understanding fire fighting in new product development[J]. Journal ofProduct Innovation Management,2001,18(5):285-300.
[45] Turner J. R. The Handbook of Project-based Management[M]. New York: McGraw-Hill,2008.
[46]寿涌毅.资源受限多项目调度的模型与方法[M].杭州:浙江大学出版社,2010.
[47] Lova A., Maroto C., Tormos p. A multi-criteria heuristic method to improve resourceallocation in multi-project scheduling[J]. European Journal of Operation Research,2000,127(2):408-424.
[48] Kruger D., Scholl A. A heuristic solution framework for the resource constrained (multi-)project scheduling problem with sequence-dependent transfer times[J]. European Journal ofOperational Research,2009,197(2):492-508.
[49] Pritskter A., Watters L.J., Wolfe P.M. Multi-project scheduling with limited resources: Azero-one programming approach[J]. Management Science,1969,16(1):93-108.
[50]廖仁,陈庆新,毛宁.求解模糊资源受限项目调度问题的遗传算法[J].系统工程学报,2006,21(3):323-327.
[51] Kurtulus I., Narula S.C. Multi-project scheduling: Analysis of project performance[J]. IIETransactions,1985,17(1):58-66.
[52] Lova A., Tormos P. Analysis of scheduling schemes and heuristic rules performance inresource-constrained multi-project scheduling[J]. Annals of Operations Research,2001,102(1-4):263-286.
[53] Lawrence S.R., Morton T.E. Resource-constrained multi-project scheduling with tardy costs:Comparing myopic, bottleneck, and resource pricing heuristics[J]. European Journal ofOperational Research,1993,64(2):168-187.
[54] Browning T. R, Yassine A. A. Resource-constrained multi-project scheduling: Priority ruleperformance revisited[J]. International Journal of Production Economics,2010,126(2):212-228.
[55] Chiu H.N., Tsai D.M. An efficient search procedure for the resource-constrainedmulti-project scheduling problem with discounted cash flows[J]. Construction Managementand Economics,2002,20(1):55-56.
[56] Kolisch R., Hartmann S. Experimental investigation of heuristics for resource-constrainedproject scheduling: An update[J]. European Journal of OperationalResearch,2006,174(1):23-37.
[57] Yang K.K., Sum C.C. A comparison of resource allocation and activity scheduling rules in adynamic multi-project environment[J]. Journal of Operations Management,1993,11(2):207-218.
[58]谈烨,仲伟俊,徐南荣.多种资源受限多项目排序问题的两层决策方法[J].系统工程理论与实践,2001,21(2):1-5.
[59]李春好,杜元伟.不确定环境下的两层交互式有限理性决策方法[J].系统工程理论与实践,2010,11:2003-2012.
[60]李春好,杜元伟.基于双平台协调的两层群决策方法[J].管理科学学报,2011,14(7):8-20.
[61] Goldratt E. M. Critical Chain[M]. Great Barrington: North River Press,1997.
[62] Rand G. K. Critical chain: the theory of constraints applied to project management[J].International Journal of Project Management,2000,18(3):173-177.
[63] Herroelen W, Leus R. On the merits and pitfalls of critical chain scheduling[J]. Journal ofoperations management,2001,19(5):559-577.
[64] Steyn H. Project management applications of the theory of constraints beyond critical chainscheduling[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2002,20(1):75-80.
[65] Wei C. C, Liu P. H, Tsai Y. C. Resource-constrained project management using enhancedtheory of constraint[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2002,20(7):561-567.
[66]刘士新,宋健海,唐加福.关键链——一种项目计划与调度新方法[J].控制与决策,2003,18(5):8-12.
[67] Tukel O. I., Rom W. O., Eksioglu S. D. An investigation of buffer sizing techniques incritical cha in scheduling[J]. European Journal o f Operational Research,2006,172(22):401-416.
[68]刘士新,宋健海,唐加福.资源受限项目调度中缓冲区的设定方法[J].系统工程学报,2006,21(4):381-385.
[69] Newbold R. C. Project Management in the Fast Lane applying the Theory of Constraints[M]. Boca Raton: The St. Lucie Press,1998.
[70] Radovilsky Z. D. A quantitative approach to estimate the size of the time buffer in the theoryof constraints [J]. International Journal of Production Economics,1998,55(2):113-119.
[71]彭武良,王成恩.关键链项目调度模型及遗传算法求解[J].系统工程学报,2010,25(1):123-131.
[72]别黎,崔南方.关键链多项目管理中能力约束缓冲大小研究[J].计算机集成制造系统,2011,17(7):1534-1540.
[73]凯西,施瓦尔贝. IT项目管理[M],机械工业出版社,2002
[74]项目管理知识体系指南: PMBOK [R]指南[M].电子工业出版社,2009.
[75]马国丰,屠梅曾,史占中,等.基于关键链技术的项目进度管理系统设计与实现[J].上海交通大学学报,2004,38(3):377-381.
[76]刘士新.项目优化调度理论与方法[M].机械工业出版社,2007.
[77] Leach, L.P.,2005. Critical Chain Project Management,2nd Edition. Artech House, London.
[78] Long L. D, Ohsato A. Fuzzy critical chain method for project scheduling under resourceconstraints and uncertainty[J].International Journal of Project Management,2008,26(6):688-698.
[79] Izack C., Avishai M., Avraham S. Multi-project scheduling and control: a process basedcomparative study of the critical chain methodology and some alternatives[J]. ProjectManagement Journal,2004,35(2):39-49.
[80] Yang S, Fu L. Critical chain and evidence reasoning applied to multi-project resourceschedule in automobile R&D process[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2013.
[81] Yaning W. Study on critical chain project portfolio management[C]//Management andService Science (MASS),2011International Conference on. IEEE,2011:1-4.
[82] Farhad D. Critical Chain Project Management (CCPM) at Bosch Security Systems (CCTV)Eindhoven[D]. Master thesis, University of Twenty, Netherlands,2008.
[83] Thomas G. L., Boaz R., Edward A. S. Critical chain: a new project management paradigm orold wine in new bottles[J].Engineering Management Journal,2005,17(4):45-59.
[84] Mannion M., Ehrke S. Introduction to critical chain part III.,http://www.toc-goldratt.com/toc-update/2006/08/IntroToCC3.pdf,2006.
[85]单汨源,张丽,吴娟.基于RAGA—AHP法的项目优先级评定研究[J]科技管理研究,2008,28(3):271-274.
[86]周谧.基于证据推理的多属性决策中若干问题的研究[D].合肥:合肥工业大学,2009.
[87] Bucaley J. Fuzzy hierarchical analysis [J].Fuzzy Sets System,1985,17(1):233-247.
[88] Chen, S.M., Wang, C.H. Fuzzy risk analysis based on ranking fuzzy numbers using a-cuts,belief features and signal/noise ratios[J].Expert systems with applications,2009,36(3):5576-5581.
[89] Chen S. J., Hwang C. L. Fuzzy multiple attribute decision making, methods andapplications[C]. Lecture notes in economics and mathematical systems, New York: Springer,1993:375.
[90] Mon D. L., Cheng C. H., Lin J. C. Evaluating weapon system using fuzzy analytic hierarchyprocess based on entropy weight[J]. Fuzzy Sets System,1994,62(2):127-134.
[91] Wu H. Y., Teng G. H., Chen Y. H. A fuzzy MCDM approach for evaluating bankingperformance based on Balanced Scorecard[J]. Expert systems with applications,2009,36(6):10135-10147.
[92] Yang J. B., Xu D. L. On the evidential reasoning algorithm for multiple attribute decisionanalysis under uncertainty, IEEE Transaction on system, man, and cybernetics,2002,32(3):289-304.
[93] Zhou M., Liu X.B., Yang J.B. Assessment of strategic R&D projects for car manufacturersbased on the evidential reasoning approach[J]. International Journal of ComputationalIntelligence System,2008,1(1):24-49.
[94] Zhou M., Liu X.B. A Highway Express Passenger Transportation Company EvaluationSystem Based on the Evidential Reasoning Approach[C].2009Second InternationalSymposium on Electronic Commerce and Security,2009,329-332.
[95] Zhou M., Liu X.B., Yang J.B. Evidential Reasoning Based Nonlinear Programming Model for MCDA under Fuzzy Weights and Utilities[J]. International Journal of Intelligent Systems,2010,25(1):31-58.
[96] Laslo Z., Albert G. Resource allocation under uncertainty in a multi-project matrixenvironment: is organizational conflict inevitable[J]. International Journal of ProjectManagement,2008,26:773-788.
[97] Geraldi J.G. The balance between order and chaos in multi-project firms: a conceptualmodel[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2008,26(4):348-356.
[98] Canonico P., S derlund J. Getting control of multi-project organizations: combiningcontingent control mechanisms[J]. International Journal of Project Management,2010,28:796-806.
[99] Leach L.P. Critical chain project management improve project performance[J]. ProjectManagement Journal,1999,30(2):39-51.
[100]屈翔,游四海,贾秋红.多学科优化设计及其在汽车设计中的应用[J].重庆工学院学报,2006,20(11):26-28.
[101]崔东周,刘坤,覃有为.汽车设计项目中的人员管理[J].武汉理工大学学报(信息与管理工程版),2007,1:026.
[102]付磊,杨颖,潘亚梅.基于关键链技术的项目管理软件研究[J].计算机应用研究,2009,26(2).
[103]刘士新.项目优化调度理论与方法[M].机械工业出版社,2007.
[104] Tavares L.V., Antunes Ferreira J. A., Silva Coelho J. On the optimal management ofproject risk[J]. European Journal of Operational Research,1998,107(2):451-469.
[105]滕春贤,系统工程,李智慧,等.二层规划的理论与应用[M].科学出版社,2002.
[106] Jeroslow R. G. The polynomial hierarchy and a simple model for competitive analysis[J].Mathematical programming,1985,32(2):146-164.
[107] Vicente L. N., Calamai P. H. Bilevel and multilevel programming: A bibliographyreview[J]. Journal of Global optimization,1994,5(3):291-306.
[108]安玉伟,严洪森.一类两阶段生产系统生产计划与调度的集成优化[J].计算机集成制造系统,2012,18(4):796-806.
[109]陈劲.复杂产品系统创新管理[M].北京:科学出版社,2008.
[110]程婷婷.基于关键链技术的项目进度和风险管理研究[D].武汉工程大学:计算机科学与工程学院,2006.
[111]上海普华科技发展有限公司.产品介绍—Primavera6.0[EB/OL].(2008)[2008-05-01].http://www.p3china.com/Shop/P3e/200606/1.html.
[112] Primavera P6TMproject management参考手册[K].[S.I.]:Primavera,2007.
[113] ProChain Solutions, Inc. ProChain Project Scheduling [EB/OL].2013,http://www.prochain.com
[114]杨颖,余本功.制造业项目管理软件评估与选型研究[J].项目管理技术,2007(10):22-25.
[115] Shi L., Yang S. The evaluation of software trustworthiness with FAHP and FTOPSISmethods[C]. Computational Intelligence and Software Engineering,2009. CiSE2009.International Conference on. IEEE,2009:1-5.
[116]石莉,余本功,杨颖,付磊.基于FAHP和FMCDM构建软件可信性评估模型[J].计算机应用研究,2010,27(3).
[117] Da deviren M., Yavuz S., K l n N. Weapon selection using the AHP and TOPSIS methodsunder fuzzy environment[J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2009,36(4):8143-8151.
[118] Tsaur S H, Chang T Y, Yen C H. The evaluation of airline service quality by fuzzyMCDM[J]. Tourism management,2002,23(2):107-115.
[119] Ertu rul., Karaka o lu N. Performance evaluation of Turkish cement firms with fuzzyanalytic hierarchy process and TOPSIS methods[J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2009,36(1):702-715.
[120] Naghadehi M. Z., Mikaeil R., Ataei M. The application of fuzzy analytic hierarchy process(FAHP) approach to selection of optimum underground mining method for Jajarm BauxiteMine, Iran[J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2009,36(4):8218-8226.
[121] Chang C. W., Wu C. R., Lin H. L. Applying fuzzy hierarchy multiple attributes to constructan expert decision making process[J]. Expert Systems with Applications,2009,36(4):7363-7368.
[122] Project Management Institute. A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge:PMBOK Guide[C]. Project Management Institute,2008.
[123] Wynstra F., Pierick E. Managing supplier involvement in new product development: aportfolio approach[J]. European Journal of Purchasing&Supply Management,2000,6(1):49-57.
[124]海史密斯, Highsmith J.,黄道文,等.敏捷项目管理[M].清华大学出版社,2005.
[125]张俊俊.基于Agile的项目管理软件的研究与实现[D].北京邮电大学,2010.
[126] Thompson J. L., Walsh D. P. PROJECT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM AND METHOD: U.S.Patent Application13/303,039[P].2011-11-22.