上海股市过度反应的实证研究及原因分析
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
传统的金融学理论认为金融产品的价格中已经包含了所有的信息,因此,在任何时候,都可以将价格视为真实的投资价值。但是大量的实验研究表明,股票市场的异常现象无法用传统金融理论来解释,过度反应成为了其中的一个研究热点,涌现了许多理论和实证结果。
     本文依据国内外相关的研究成果,采用Debont和Thaler的研究方法,选取2006年1月至2010年6月上海股票的交易数据,对是否存在过度反应进行实证检验。实证结果表明,检验期输家组合的超额收益率超过了赢家组合,确实存在着过度反应,并且期限越长,收益的反转程度越弱。对原因的研究中发现,赢输家组合的风险差异不能很好的解释过度反应,而投资者的认知偏差以及中国股票市场的制度背景等约束性条件是造成中国股市过度反应的主要原因。
     本文从五个部分展开研究:
     第一部分,研究的背景。解释了研究过度反应的必要性并且提出了研究方法;并且对行为金融学产生的背景、发展历史进行了综述,同时对行为金融学的基本内容进行了阐述。
     第二部分,国内外文献综述。回顾了国内外大量学者对过度反应现象的实证研究以及原因分析。
     第三部分,过度反应实证分析。选取2006年1月至2010年6月上海股票的交易数据,采用Debont和Thaler的经典研究方法,对是否存在过度反应进行实证检验。实证结果表明,其结果显示了上海股票市场的确存在过度反应,即在形成期表现最好的股票在检验期表现弱于市场平均水平,而在形成期表现最差的股票在检验期表现强于市场水平。
     第四部分,过度反应的理论解释。国外的行为金融学的相关研究认为是因为证券投资者自身的认知偏差与风险因素。但如果只是研究心理原因和风险因素,并不能完全解释中国股票市场上的过度反应现象,所以还应该考虑中国股市具体的拘束条件,制度背景和市场结构等。
     第五部分,总结了全文的结论,提出了相应的投资策略。
Traditional financial theory suggests that the price of financial products has already contains all the information,so it could be regarded as the true value of the investment price at any time.But lots of experimental studies indicated that the abnormal phenomena in the stock market could not be explained by the traditional financial theory,and overreaction became the research hotspot, emerging many theoretical and empirical results.
     This text is based on domestic and foreign research results, use the research methods of Debont and Thaler, select the trading data from January 2006 to June 2010 in the Shanghai stock market.Test whether there is overreaction in the stock market. The empirical result shows that the test of the loser portfolio excess return more than the winner portfolio, confirms there is exist over-reaction, and with the term longer, income is less. The study found that the portfolio risk of winner and loser could not explained well for overreaction, and cognitive biases of investors and the institutional background of China's stock market conditions and other constraints is the main reason which caused by the Chinese stock market overreaction.
     This paper has divided five part:
     (1)The study backgroung. It explains the necessity of the research in over reaction and proposed methods;and reviewed the behavioral finance background, development history, and described the basic content of behavioral finance.
     (2)Literature reviewed. Recalling the large number of scholars from domestic and abroad for overreaction and analysis of empirical research.
     (3)The overreaction of empirical ananlysis. Select transaction data from January 2006 to June 2010 in Shanghai stock, and use the classic research methods of Debont and Thaler, test the existence of overreaction on the empirical. The empirical results shows that the results of the Shanghai stock market does exist overreaction,in other words the formation of the best performing stock on the test performance was weaker than that of the average market level, the worst in the formation of the stock to outperform in the test market level.
     (4)The explain of the overreaction.Foreign behavioral financial research shows that it is because of the securities investors own cognitive bias and risk factors. However, if only research psychological causes and risk factors, couled not fully explain China's stock market overreaction, it should also be bound to consider the specific conditions of China's stock market, institutional background and market structure.
     (5) Summarizes the full text of the conclusions, and propose the investment strategy.
引文
[1]DeBondt,W.F.M.,and R.H.Thaler,Does the stock market overreact:Journal of Fi nance[J],1985,40:793-808.
    [2]Robert G.Bowman,David Iverson.Short-run overreaction in the New Zealand stock market,Pacific-Basin Finance Journal[J],1998,6:475-491.
    [3]Kryzanowiski,L&H Zhang.The contrarian investment strategy does not work in Canadian markets.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis[J],1992,9:383-394.
    [4]Brailsford,T..A test for the winner-loser anomaly in the Australian equity marke t:1958-1987.Journal of Business Finance and Accounting[J],1992,19:225-241.
    [5]安德瑞.史莱佛著,赵英军译.并非有效的市场一行为金融学导论[M],2003,中国人民大学出版社.
    [6]刘力.行为金融理论对效率市场假说的挑战[J].经济科学,1999,3,63-71.
    [7]饶育蕾,刘达锋.行为金融学[M].上海::上海财经大学出版社,2003,05.
    [8]Andrei Shleifer. Inefficient Markets—An Introduction to Behavioral Finance [M]. Oxford University press,2000.
    [9]戴国强、吴林祥、金胜.市场徽观结构理论[M].上海财经大学出版社,1999:38-54.
    [10]宋瑞莉.浅谈投资与行为金融学[M].现代商业,2008:14.
    [11]金晓斌、何旭强.投资者行为、市场风险收益特征与交易策略有效性深圳证券交易所第五届会员、基金管理公司研究成果:2003.
    [12]Odean,T.Do investors trade too much[J].American Economic Review,1999,89: 1279-1298
    [13]Slovic,P.(eds.).From Shakespeare to Simon:Speculations and some evidence abo ut man's ability to process information[J].Oregon Research Institute Monogra ph:1972.
    [14]梁冰.中国证券市场过度反应行为研究一理论·实证·应用[D].上海:上海交通大学,2005.
    [15]DeBondt,W.EM.R.H.Thaler.Further Evidence on Investor Overreaction and Sto-ck Market Seasonality[J] Joumal of Finance,1987,42:557-580.
    [16]骆艳,曾勇,唐小我.证券市场过度反应理论研究评介[J].预测2003,3:72-75
    [17]Fama,E.E,K.R.Freneh.Conmmon Factors in Serial Correlation of Stock Return [Z].Working Paper:Graduate School of Business,Univ.of Chicago,1986.
    [18]Jegadeesh,N.Evidence of Predietable Behavior of Seeurity Returns[J].Jounalof Finance,1990,45:881-898.
    [19]Zarowin,P.Does the Stoek Market Overreaet to Corporate Earnings Information [J].Joumal Of Finance,1989,44:1385-1399.
    [20]Zarowin,P.Size,Seasonality,and Stoek Market overreaetion[J].Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1990,25:113—125.
    [21]Clare,A·D.,S.H.Thomas.The Overreaction Hypothesis and The UK Stock Mark-et[J] Jounal of Basiness Finaneial,1995,22:961-973.
    [22]Lehmann,B.Fads.Martingales,and Market Efficiency[J].Quarterly Journal of Eco-nomics,1990,105:1-28
    [23]Lo Andrew W,A.Craig MacKinlay.Data-Snooping Biases in Tests of Financial Asset Pricing Models[J].The Review of Financial Studies,1990,3:431-467.
    [24]Chopra,N.J.Lakonishok,J.R.Ritter.Messuring Abnormal Performance:Do Stocks overreact[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1992,31:235-268.
    [25]K.Geert Rouwenhorst.International Momentum Strategies[J].Journal of Finance, 1998,53:267-284.
    [26]张人骥,朱平芳,王怀芳.上海证券市场过度反应的实证检验[J].经济研究,1998,(5):58-64.
    [27]沈艺峰,吴世农.中国证券市场过度反应了吗?[J].经济研究,1999,(2):21—26.
    [28]朱少醒.2000,行为金融理论框架下的金融市场微观结构研究[D].上海:上海交通大学,2000.
    [29]王永宏、赵学军.中国股市“惯性策略”和“反转策略”的实证分析[J].经济研究,2001,(6):56—61.
    [30]周琳杰.中国股票市场动量策略赢利性研究[J].《世界经济》,2002(1)
    [31]邹小凡、钱英.我国股票市场的中长期回报率的过度反应[J].数理统计与管理,2003,(11):9-13.
    [32]王春峰、李双成、康莉.中国股市的过度反应与“政策市”现象实证研究[J]. 西北农林科技大学学报,2003,4:20-24.
    [33]梁冰,顾海英.中国股票市场过度反应行为:完整牛市和熊市周期中的实证[J].东北林业大学学报,2004,(5):80—82.
    [34]肖军、徐信忠.中国股市价值反转投资策略有效性实证研究[J].经济研究,2004,3:55-64.
    [35]李诗林、李扬.沪深股票市场过度反应效应研究[J].管理评论,2003,6.
    [36]克罗吉,乔志峰.中国股市存在“反应过度”吗?[J].统计与决策,2005,(5):108-111.
    [37]宋献中、汤胜.中国股市“过度反应”与“规模效应”的实证分析—基于中国上海A股股票市场的检验[J].暨南学报,2006,03:74-78.
    [38]蔡路咖、朱昊.我国证券市场过度反应的实证研究[J].经济社会体制比较,2006,2.
    [39]雷辉、李小晓、王书华.股权分置改革中的反应过度问题[J].中国统汁,2006.
    [40]陈国进、范长平.我国股票市场的过度反应现象及其成因分析[J].南开经济研究,2006,3.
    [41]曹广辰.中国股票市场过度反应实证研究[J].商业文化,2007,9.
    [42]杨春鹏.基于展望理论的证券市场反应过度和反应不足研究[J].运筹与管理,2007,6.
    [43]廖理,伍毅惠.中国股票市场风险溢价研究[J].金融研究,2003,(4):54-61.
    [44]Fama,E.F.Efficient Capital Markets Ⅱ[J].Journal of Finance,1970,46 (5):1575-1617.
    [45]Fama,Eugene. Efficient Capital Markets:A Review of Theory and Empirical Work[J] Journal of Finance,1970,2;383-417.
    [46]Jegadeesh,N.,Titlnan,S..Returns to buying winners and selling losers:implica tions for stock market efficiency[J].Journal of Finance,1993,48:65-91.
    [47]Kahneman,D,and A.Tversky.On the psychology of prediction[J].Psychological Review,1973,80:237-251.
    [48]Kahneman, D, and A.Tversky. Judgment inder uncertainty:Heuristice and Biase s[J].New York:Russell Sage Foundation.
    [49]Shefrin,H. and Meir Staman.Behavioral Capital Asset Pricing Theory[J].Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysts,1993,29(3)323-349.
    [50]刘树成,沈沛.中国资本市场前沿理论研究文集.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2000:40-52.
    [51]Barberis N,Shleifer A,Vishny R.A model of investor sentiment.Journal of Finan-cial Economics[J],1998,49(3):307343.
    [52]Kahneman D,Tversky A.Prospect theory An analysis of decision under risk. Econm-etrica[J],1979,47(2)263-292.
    [53]Grundy B D,J S Martin.Understanding the nature of the risks and the source of the rewards to momentum investing[J].Review of Financial Studies,2001,(14): 29-78
    [54]Daniel K D,Hirshleifer D,Subrahmanyam A.Investor psychology and security marketunder-and overreactions. Journal of Finance,1998,53(6):1839-1885.
    [55]Vermanelen T,Verstringe M.Do Belgians overreact?Working paper[J],University of Louvain,Belgiun,1986,6.
    [56]Alonso A,Rubio GOverreaction in the Spanish equity market. Journal of Banking and Finance[J],1990,14(3):469 481.
    [57]Costa D N.Overreaction in the Brazilian stock market.Journal of Banking and Finance[J],1994,18(4):633642.
    [58]刘玉珍,刘维琪,谢政能.台湾股票市场过度反应研究.科学发展月刊[J],1990,19(1):34-47.
    [59]刘力,陈兴珠.中国股市过度反应研究.研究报告,北京大学光华管理学院,2001.
    [60]Mitchell R,Ricardo L.Evidence of short-term price reversals following large one day movements in the emerging markets of Latin America and Asia.Working paper[J],Rider University,1998,2.
    [61]Atkins A B,Dyl E A.Price reversals,bid-ask spreads,and market efficiency.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis[J],1990,25(12):535547.
    [62]French K R,Schwert G W,Stambaugh R F.Expected stock returns and volat ility. Journal of Financial Economics[J],1987,19(9):3 29.
    [63]Bowman R G,Iverson D.Short run overreaction in the New Zealand stock mar ket.Pacific Basin Finance Journal[J],1998,6(5):475 491.
    [64]Conrad J, Kaul G. Longterm market overreaction or biased in computed ret urns[J].Journal of Finance,1993,48 (3):39-63.
    [65]Conrad J, Kaul G. Mean reversion in short2horizon expected return[J].Review of Financial Studies,1989,2(2):225-240.
    [66]Loughran T,Ritter J R. Longterm market overreaction:the effect of lowpriced stocks[J].Journal of Finance,1996,72 (5):1959-1970.
    [67]Hong H,Stein J. A Unified Theory of Underreaction,Momentum Tradingand Over reaction in Asset Markets [J].Journal of Finance,1999,(54):84-143
    [68]Ball R,Kothari S P. Nonstationary expected returns:implications for tests of market efficiency and serial correlation in returns [J].Journal of Financial Economics,1989,25 (6):51-74.
    [69]Ball R,Kothari S P.Security returns around earnings announcements[J].The Acco unting Review,1991,66(11):718-738.
    [70]Chan K C. Can tax-loss selling explain the January seasonal instockreturns [J]. Journal of Finance,1986,41(5):1115-1128.
    [71]Chan K C.On the contrarian investment strategy[J].Journal of Business,198 8,61,(2):147-164
    [72]约翰·凯恩斯.就业利息和货币通论[M].徐毓楠译.北京:商务印书馆,1983.
    [73]Keim D B,Stambaugh R F. Predicting returns in thestock and bond markets [J]. Journal of Financial Eco2nomics,1986,17 (2):357-390.
    [74]Black F,Jensen M C.The capital asset pricing model:some empirical tests [M],N ew York:Praeger Publishers,1972.
    [75]Miller M H,Scholes M. Studies in the theory of capital markets[M].New Yor k:Praeger Publishers,1972.
    [76]Jegadeesh N. Does market risk explain size effect[J]. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,1992,27 (3):337-351.
    [77]Fama E G, Macbeth J D. Risk, return,and equilibrium:empirical tests [J]. Journal of Political Economy,1973,81 (3):607-636.
    [78]薛薇.SPSS统计分析方法及应用[M],电子工业出版社,2004.
    [79]Shiller,Robert,1981, "Do Stock Prices Move Too Much to Be Justified by Subsequent Changes in Dividends",American Economic Reviews,Vol.71, No. 3(June):421-436.
    [80]Palmer,R.,Arthur,W.B.,Holland,J.H.,LeBaron,B.&Tayler,P.,Artificial economic li fe:A simple model of a stock market,Physica,1994,D 75:264-274
    [81]Otchere I, Chan J. Short term overreaction in the Hong Kong stock market:can a contrarian trading strategy beat the market[R]. Working Paper, The University of Melbourne Parkville,1999.
    [82]Banz R W. The relationship between return and market value of common stocks [J].Journal of Financial Economics,1981,9 (3):3-18.
    [83]Reinganum M R. A direct test of Roll's conjecture on the firm size effect [J]. Journal of Finance,1982,37(1):27-35.
    [84]Campell J Y, Lo A W, Mackinlay A C. The econometrics of financial markets [M]. New Jersey:Princeton University Press,1997.
    [85]Amihud Y,Mendelson H. Asset pricing and the bid-ask spread [J].Journal of Financial Economics,1986,17(2):223-249.
    [86]Akhigbe A T,Harikumar T. Winners and losers on NYSE:a reexamination using daily closing bidaskspreads[J]. Journal of Financial Research,1998,21(3):53-64.
    [87]Conrad J,Kaul G. Mean reversion in short horizon expected return[J].Review of Financial Studies,1989,2(2):225-240.
    [88]Barberis,N.,Shleifer,A.,and R.Vishny.A model of investor sentimen[J].Journal of Financial Economics,1998,49:307-343..
    [89]Hong,harrison and stein.Bad News Travels Slowly:Size,Analyst Coverage and the Profit ability of Momentum Strategies [J].Journal of Finance,1999, forth comi-ng.
    [90]黄俊,陈平.我国股市反应过度与反应不足的实证研究[J].理论与实践,2009,6:91-94.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700