摘要
资产证券化是近四十年来世界金融领域最重大和发展最迅速的金融创新和金融工具。从资产证券化的运作过程和目的来看,它是把缺乏流动性但具有未来收入现金流的资产收集起来,通过结构重组,将其转变为可以在金融市场上出售和流通的证券,据以融通资金的过程。企业融资的需要,金融市场充分发展的需要,以及投资者投资的需要推动了资产证券化这一变缺乏流动性资产为流动性资产的金融衍生产品的产生。在经济高速发展的中国,其推广应用的背景也源于此。
首先,本文通过对资产证券化运作经济内涵的研究,结合我国国有企业发展的历程,找出适合国有企业集团资产证券化的运作模式。利用资产证券化这一金融工具拓宽企业集团的融资途径,同时设计出辅业分离的方案,使国有企业的发展和改革在健康、有效、稳定的环境下进行,从而实现国有企业集团做大做强,增强市场竞争力。其次,本文分析了企业集团内部关联交易所引起的资金流的特点,并指出了可能进行的资产证券化模式。企业集团内部存在大量的关联交易,母公司和子公司以及子公司与子公司之间有着密切的联系,它们之间能形成长期稳定的应收帐款,使企业集团内部现金流有可能成为一种高质量基础资产从而符合资产证券化的条件,如果对这些不同类型的应收帐款进行处理,就可以达到融资的目的。根据企业集团内部不同的关联交易产生的现金流的模式,提出了资产支持证券的价格定量分析模型。再次,根据国家“主辅分离、精干主体”的政策,利用资产证券化设计了融资和辅业分离改制的方案。国有企业集团的总体发展战略以做大做强主业为目的,很难拿出有限的资金去支持辅业做大,辅业主要以分离改制的方式另谋发展。考虑到辅业改制时国家要承担一定的改制成本,而且辅业为主业配套的产品也能产生稳定的现金流,因此辅业进行资产证券化时,以对主业支持的产品或服务产生的现金流量为基础发行证券,企业集团以对证券进行信用增级等方式间接支持辅业。这种证券并不是仅仅为了融资,而是考虑辅业改制和股份制改造,发行带有认股权证的证券,利用外部资金改善辅业的产品结构,逐渐摆脱对主业的依赖,并且引入外部投资者,达到辅业融资、改制的目的。在此,对如何设计附带认股权证的资产支持证券进行了定性分析。最后,根据资产证券化中特设目的载体(SPV)的运作原理,提出了国有企业集团参与的方式。特设目的载体(SPV)是资产证券化运作过程中的核心,本文通过分析SPV的作用和形式,结合国有企业集团参与SPV的目的,提出了在以企业集团的优质应收账款发行资产支持证券融资时,可作为SPV的股东直接参与,降低融资成本;当以辅业改制为目的时,企业集团可对资产支持证券进行信用增级,间接支持辅业,或者是参与政府主导的辅业改制基金支持辅业。
In the financial field, asset securitization is the financial innovation and financial instruments which is of greatest significance and develops the most rapidly during the past 40 years. Judging from the operation process and the goal of asset securitization, it is a process of financing which can collect the cash (lack fluidity but have the future revenue flow) and transform it to the negotiable securities which can be sold and circulated in the financial market through the structure reorganization.
The need of financing of the enterprise group, the need of full development of financial market, as well as the need of investment of the investors. It's just these three areas of need that promote the birth of asset securitization. It is financial derivatives which can changes the less-fluid asset to the fluid ones. In rapid economic development of China, the background of the asset securitization's promotion and application also stems from this.
First of all, this paper aims at discovering the asset securitization's operation pattern which is suitable to the state-owned business group through researching its economic connotation in combination with the its developing process. It uses asset securitization (financial instruments) to broaden the financing cannels of enterprise group, with a proposal of separating the auxiliary industry, causes state-owned business's development and reform in a healthy, effective and stable environment, and thus be able to strengthen and expand state-owned business group and increase the market competitiveness of the state-owned business group.
Secondly, this paper analyses the characteristics of the cash flow caused by the transaction within the enterprise group and points out the possible modes of asset securitization. There exist the massive interior affiliated transactions within the enterprise group. There is a close relationship between the parent company and the subsidiary company as well as the subsidiaries and affiliates themselves. They can form the long-term stability of the account receivables. The internal cash flow of the enterprise group could become the basis of high-quality assets so as to meet the condition of asset securitization. We may achieve the purpose of financing if we carry on processing to these different types of account receivable. We can propose the price quantitative analysis model of the asset-supported negotiable securities according to the cash flow pattern generated from the business group's interior transaction.
Thirdly, according to the policy of "main auxiliary separation, capable main body", design a proposal of financing and separating the auxiliary industry based on assets securitization. It is very difficult for the enterprise group to put out the limited fund to support the auxiliary industry development from the overall development strategy which takes strengthening and expanding its principle industry as the goal. Therefore the auxiliary industry has to seek for a way of separating and system-reforming as a main method to develop. The country must undertake certain remanufacture cost when auxiliary industry remanufactures and auxiliary industry can also produce the stable cash flow for the principal work necessary product. Considering these factors, when we carries on asset securitization of auxiliary industry, we can issue negotiable securities based on the cash flow produced by the principal work support's product or the service, and indirectly support auxiliary industry through securities credit enhancement carried out by enterprise group. These kind of negotiable securities are not only to finance merely, but also with a consideration of the reform of auxiliary industry and the shareholding reform. We can achieve auxiliary industry's financing and remanufacture goal through releasing the negotiable securities, using the outside capital to improve the auxiliary industry product mix, gradually getting rid of the dependence of the principal work, and introducing the exterior investors. Hereby we carry out a qualitative analysis on how to design an asset-backed security with cum rights.
Finally we bring out a suggestion about the way of participation of state-owned enterprise group pursuant to the working principle of special purpose vehicle (SPV) in assets securitization. Since the special purpose vehicle (SPV) is the core in working process of assets securitization, we analyze the form and function of SPV, combining the state-owned enterprise group's purpose of being involving in SPV, and then get the conclusion as following: where the asset-backed securities are issued for financing based on quality receivables of enterprise group, the group could directly participate in as a shareholder of SPV to lower the cost of financing; where the purpose is auxiliary industry reforming, the enterprise group could indirectly support auxiliary industry using credit enhancement of asset-backed securities, or support it though joining the auxiliary industry reforming fund which is dominated by government.
引文
[1]Adams,Phil.An Inroduction to the European Securitization Markets.Journal of Structured Finance,2005,11(3):33-39
[2]Adhikari,Ajay,Betancourt,Luis.Accounting for Securitizations:A Comparison of SFAS 140 and IASB 39.Journal of Inernational Financial Management &Accounting,2008,19(1):73-105
[3]Asset-Backed Alert.www.ABAlert.com.Harrison Scott Publication,2000-2008
[4]Bank of England.Examples of effects of secudtisation SPVs on monetary aggregates.Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin,2007,47(3):410-410
[5]Batlin,C.A.Hedging Mortgage-Backed Securities with Treasury Bond Futures,The Journal of Futures Markets,1987(7):675-693
[6]Berbadette Minton,Tom Poler and Sonya Stanton.Asset Secudtization among Industrial Firms,1997
[7]Boudoukh,J.,M.Richardson and R.F.Whitelaw.The Stochastic Behavior of Interest Rates,New York University working paper,1995
[8]Breeden,D.T.,M.H.Giala.Hedging Interest Rate Risk with Futures,Swaps,and Options,In Fabozzi,F.,The Handbook of Mortgage-Backed Securities(third edition).Probus Publishing,1992:847-960
[9]Breeden,D.T.,Risk.Return and Hedging of Fixed Rate Mortgages.Journal of Fixed Income,1991(1):85-107
[10]Bruski,Johannes.Germany:Securitization in Germany-evelopments and trends.International Financial Law Review,2007,26:32-33
[11]Carnahan,Scott W..Home Equity Line of Credit Securitization:Issuer Issues.Journal of Structured Finance,2005,11(3):30-32
[12]Charles Stone,Anne Zissu,Jess Lederman.Asset Securitization:Theory And Practice In Europe.Euro money Books,1991
[13]Christine A Pavel.Securitization.Chicago,1989
[14]Chunsheng Zhou.Path-dependent Option Evaluation When the Underlying Path Is Discontinuous. Federal Reserve Board, 1997, March
[15] Davidson, A. S. , M. D. Herkowitz. A comparison of Methods for Analyzing Mortgages-Backed Securities.The Handbook of Mortgage-Backed Securities (third edition), 2002: 627-718
[16] Davidson, Paul. Is the current financial distress caused by the subprime mortgage crisis a Minsky moment? or is it the result of attempting to securitize illiquid noncommercial mortgage loans? Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 2008, 30(4): 669-676
[17] De Sear, Edward. Revolving asset securitization faces regulatory reforms. International Financial Law Review, 2005,24: 104—106
[18] Donald H. Chew, Jr. The New Corporate Finance—Where Theory Meets Practice. Irwin/Graw- hill, 1999
[19] Dunn, K . B., McConnell, J . Valuation of Mortgage-Backed Securities . Journal of Finance, 1981,36:599-617
[20] Dunn, K. B. , Spatt, C. S .The Effect of Refinancing Costs and Market Imperfections on the Optimal Call Strategy and the Pricing of Debt Contracts . Working Paper, Carnegie-Mellon University, 1986
[21] Eastham, Peter. How securitization could benefit emerging Asia. International Financial Law Review, 2006,25: 7—9
[22] Fabozzi, Frank J.. The Structured Finance Market: An Investor's Perspective. Financial Analysts Journal, 2005, 61(3): 27—40
[23] F. Black , M. Scholes.The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities J. Pol .Ec ., 1973,81:637-653.
[24] Fick, Kenneth F.. Securitized Profits. Journal of Accountancy, 2008, 205 (5): 54— 60
[25] Fitch IBCA Credit Card Securitization Group. ABS of Credit Card ABS Special Report, 1998
[26] Frank J. Fabozzi. Bond Markets: Analysis and Strategies (3rd Edition)Jan.12,1996
[27] Frank J. Fabozzi. Franco Modigliani. Capital Markets Institutions and Instruments www. tup. tsinghua. edu. cn, 1998
[28] Frank J. Fabozzi. The Handbook of Fixed Income Securities. Business One Irwin, 1991
[29] Galvin, Turlough. Ireland: Ireland as a location for structured finance SPVs. International Financial Law Review, 2007,26: 37—38
[30] Galvin, Turlough. Irish SPVS to be permitted to securitise new classes of assets. International Tax Review, 2008,19(5): 76—76
[31] G. Chichilnisky, G. M. Heal, D. P Tsomocos. Option values and endogenous uncertainty in ESOPs, MBO and asset-backed loans, Economics letters 48, 1995
[32] Goodman, Laurie S., Lucas, Douglas J., Fabozzi, Frank J.. Financial Innovations and the Shaping of Capital Markets: The Case of CDOs. Journal of Alternative Investments, 2007,10(1): 62-70
[33] Ian H. Giddy. Asset Securitization in Asia: An Overview. Hill&Knowlton, 1998
[34] IMF Global Financial Stability Report Market Developments and Issues, April 2006: 51-84
[35] Jacob Boudoukh, Mattlaw Richardson and Robert F. Whitelaw. New Strategy For Dynamical Hedging MBS Working Paper, 1995
[36] Jess Lederman, Linda E. Feinne, Mark Dzialga. The commercial Loan Resale Market, Probus Publishing Company, 1991
[37] J. Norton, P. Spellman (eds.).Asset Securitization International and Financial Perspectives. Blackwell, 1991
[38] John Henderson. Asset Securitization: Current Techniques and Emerging Market Applications. Euro-money Book, 1997
[39] John Henderson and Jonathan P. Scott. Securitization. New York Institute of Finance, 1988
[40] Joseph J. Norton and Raymond M. Auerbank. International Finance in the 1990s: Challenges and Opportunities, Blackwell, 1993
[41] Kau , J. B. Keenan , D. C. Muller , III, W. J. and Epperson, J. F.A Generalized Valuation Model for Fixed-Rate Residential Mortgages . Journal of Money , Credit and Banking, 1992,24: 279—299
[42] K. S. . ABCP Investors Demand More from Conduit Administrators. Asset Securitization Report, 2008, 8(29): 14—14
[43] Langley, Paul. Financialization and the Consumer Credit Boom. Competition & Change,2008,12(2):133-147
[44]Lawrence R.Rosen.The McGraw--Hill Handbook of Interest.Yields and Returns,McGraw-Hill,Inc.,1995
[45]Leland,Hayne E..Financial Synergies and the Optimal Scope of the Firm:Implications for Mergers,Spinoffs,and Structured Finance.Journal of Finance,2007,62(2):765-80
[46]Leon T,Kendall,Michael J.Fishman.A Primer on Securitization.The MIT Press Cambridge,Massachusetts,London,England,2000
[47]Marshall J.F.,Ellis M.E.Investment Banking &Brokerage-The New Rules of the Game.McGraw-Hill,Inc.,1994
[48]McDonald,Colleen.Opportunities for U.S.Investors in the Canadian Securitization Market.Asset Securitization Report,2008,8(28):9-21
[49]McLaughlin,Shanon M..Managing Risk in the Mortgage Business.RMA Journal,2007,90(3):19-20
[50]Montgomerie,Johnna.The Financialization of the American Credit Card Industry.Competition & Change,2006,10(3):301-319
[51]Mountain,James R..Securitization Accounting:Are You Ready for the Credit Crunch Challenge? Bank Accounting & Finance,2008,21(3):3-10
[52]Moyo,Z.,Firer,C.Securitisation in South Africa:2000-2007.South African Journal of Business Management,2008,39(1):27-34
[53]Na'im,Ainun.Gadjah Mada.Special Purpose Vechicle Institutions:Their Business Natures and Accounting Implications.International Journal of Business,2006,8(1):1-19
[54]National University of Singapore.NUS Centre for Financial Engineering Seminar for the Industry on Asset Securtisation 11th May 1999
[55]OCC' s Quarterly Report on Bank Derivatives Activities,Third Quarter 2006.
[56]Philip L.Zweig,Dow Jones-Irwin.The Asset Securitization Handbook,1989
[57]Qiao,Anthony.Securitization in China:secured or not? International Financial Law Review,2005,24:51-53
[58]Ramel,Marianne.A blueprint for Chinese securitization.International Financial Law Review, 2005,24 (7): 45-47
[59] Raymond H. Rupert. The New Era of Investment Banking. Probus Publishing Company, 1993
[60] Roberts, Charles, Downey, Conor. How new structures can spur growth in CMBS. International Financial Law Review, 2005,24: 69—71
[61] Roberts, R. B. Hedging Mortgage-backed Securities : A Review of the Approaches. The Handbook of Mortgage-Backed Securities (second edition ), Probus Publishing, 2000: 855-888
[62] Ruff, Jon. Commercial Real Estate: New Paradigm or Old Story. Journal of Portfolio Management, 2007,33: 27—36
[63] Runyan, Sally A., Reuters, Thomson. Return to Functionality Will Take Time for CMBS. Asset Securitization Report, 2008, 8 (24): 16-22
[64] Sam R. hakim.Autonomous and financial Mortgage Prepayment . Journal of Real estate Research, 1997, 13 (1)
[65] Schwartz, E. S., Torous , W. N.Prepaument and the Valuation of Mortgage-Backed Securities. Journal of Finance, 1989,44: 375-392
[66] Selvam, Vijay. Recharacterisation in "True Sale" Securitisations: The "Substance over Form" Delusion. Journal of Business Law, 2006, 637—643
[67] Snil Gangwani. Deloitte and Touche L P.MBS Structuring: Concepts and Techniques. The Securitisation Conduit, 1998, 3
[68] Steven L. Schwarcz . The Universal Language of Cross-Border Finance. Working paper of Duke University School, Nov. 1999
[69] Synthetic CDO The Next Level, Eiger Capital Limited, 2006, 2007(4): 37-39
[70] Tamar Frankel. Cross-border Securitization: Without Law, But Not Lawless Working Paper of Boston University School of Law, 1998
[71] Timmis , G. C., Valuation of GNMA Mortgage-Backed Securities with Transaction Costs , Heterogeneous Households and Endogenously Generated Prepayment Rates. Working paper, Carnegie-Mellon University , 1985
[72] Uzun, Hatice. Webb, Elizabeth. Securitization and risk: empirical evidence on US banks. Journal of Risk Finance, 2007, 8 (1): 11—23
[73]Wang,Jian.What China can learn from US securitization.International Financial Law Review,2006,25(1):22-24
[74]埃兹·内尔肯,混合金融工具手册,机械工业出版社,2002
[75]陈超.企业关联交易纳税调整之准备.税收征纳,2004(7):34-35
[76]陈柳钦,周明.信托模式-我国资产证券化发展模式的现实选择.中国房地产金融,2004(7):16-20
[77]戴娟.我国租赁公司租赁资产证券化的模式.浙江金融,2004(Z1):58-60
[78]付同青,倪娜.企业资产证券化的财务结构分析.市场周刊,2008(5):68-70
[79]高保中.资产证券化演进与金融市场效率.金融教学与研究,2003(4):31-34
[80]顾晓东.集团性关联企业贷款风险防范.新金融,2004(5):35-37
[81]管同伟.美国资产证券化的最新进展及其演变趋势.国际金融研究,2007(10):10-16
[82]国务院.国务院关于推进资本市场改革开放和稳定发展的若干意见.2004.1-31
[83]何德旭.中国金融创新与发展研究.北京:经济科学出版社,2001
[84]何小锋.资产证券化:中国的模式.北京:北京大学出版社,2002
[85]何小锋,黄嵩.从资产证券化的理论体系看中国突破模式的选择.学习与探索,2002(1):66-71
[86]何小锋,刘永强.资产证券化理论及其在中国实践.学术研究,1999(2):3-8
[87]何小锋,宋芳秀.对资产证券化税收制度安排的博弈论分析.经济科学,2001(6):21-26
[88]洪艳蓉.信贷资产证券化投资者保护机制探讨.证券市场导报,2007(6):4-12
[89]胡少先.新公司法规引发的相关会计问题(二).新理财,2006(9):38-41
[90]胡旭阳.资产证券化与资本市场的均衡发展.浙江金融,2003(1):28-30
[91]黄明.债务证券化与资产托管:国有企业重组的新设想.金融与研究,1998(7):4-9
[92]江平,李国光.最新公司法疑难释解.人民法院出版社,2006
[93]姜玉梅.资产证券化中的SPV法律问题分析.天府新论,2004(1):68-70
[94]孔繁斌.资产证券化的风险与收益问题研究.华东师范大学2007届研究生论文
[95]兰莹.制度经济学视野中资产证券化的本质.上海经济研究,2002(8):51-55
[96]李传全.资产证券化的信用工程特征分析.经济与管理研究,2001(3):57-58
[97]李文海.国有及国有控股企业集团的发展现状与作用.中国统计信息网,2006(9)
[98]李湛.信贷资产证券化中的信用增级方法.农村金融研究,2007(7):29-33
[99]刘燕.我国资产证券化中SPV税收政策评析.税务研究,2007(04):6-10
[100]刘燕.资产证券化会计问题的法律视角.四川会计,2000(9):3-6
[101]覃天云,李公科.关于资产证券化中SPV的理论及法律适用探析.中国民商法律网,2004.4.8
[102]锐思管理网.我国资产证券化以往案例分析,2005.7.3
[103]沈炳熙.从投融资角度看资产证券化.中国货币市场,2007(5):4-7
[104]斯蒂文.L.西瓦兹.结构金融-资产证券化原理指南.清华大学出版社,2003
[105]宋芳秀,何小锋.我国开展资产证券化的税收问题分析.税务与经济,2002(5):15-17
[106]宋兴义.信贷资产证券化中发起人的税收政策与会计处理.税务研究,2007(11):77-80
[107]孙名扬.利用我国信托制度 推进资产证券化品种创新.理论纵横,2004(3):35-37
[108]陶涛.我国企业资产证券化信用增级模式研究.经济论坛,2008(13):108-110
[109]涂永红,刘柏荣.银行信贷资产证券化.北京:中国金融出版社,2000.134-136
[110]王安乐.贸易应收款资产证券化的收益分析.国际金融研究.2007(9):65-69
[111]王安乐.企业业务紧缩的新途径探讨.企业活力,2007(3):9-11
[112]王安乐.企业债券融资的策略探析.企业活力.2007(9):9-11
[113]王少波.资产证券化信用评级-国外模型方法及其借鉴.当代经济科学,2007(6):37-44
[114]王晓文.资产证券化试点中SPV的路径选择.企业改革与管理,2007(1):37-39
[115]王玉春,杨亚西,马创.关于资产证券化的会计确认难点与局限性.安徽商贸职业技术学院学报,2003(3):29-32
[116]许多奇.我国金融资产证券化的税收理念与税收制度.法学评论,2007(2):39-45
[117]许前川.资产证券化中SPV法律问题之探析.西南民族大学学报(人文社科版),2003(12):130-133
[118]杨亚西.资产证券化的会计确认难题及其解决方法.北方经贸,2002(12):111-112
[119]姚琦华,赵学森.企业集团中关联交易的信贷风险及对策研究.市场周刊.研究版,2005(S1):20-22
[120]尹音频,阮兵.公平与效率-资产证券化的税收政策取向.财经科学,2007(6):39-44
[121]应展宇.合成型资产证券化-创新视角的一个经济分析。数量经济技术经济研究,2007(9):77-86
[122]喻国平.资产证券化对金融系统稳定影响的理论机制.价格月刊,2007(9):29-33
[123]余坚.资产证券化带来的会计确认问题探讨.会计研究,1998(9):35-38
[124]袁立华.竞争行业国有资产证券化之路.山西高等学校社会科学学报,2002(12):51-53
[125]曾英杰,余科.资产证券化中SPV法律问题的探讨.经济师,2004(6):43-44
[126]张超英.对金融资产证券化经济学意义的再认识.财贸经济,2002(11):17-20
[127]张超英.资产证券化对货币政策实效性的影响.当代经济研究,2003(7):89-92
[128]赵丽英,方亮.资产证券化的税收问题.北方经贸,2002(11):88-89
[129]赵宇霆.资产证券SPV设立的法律思考.当代法学,2004(5):65-70
[130]周丹,王恩裕.资产证券化对我国货币政策的影响初探.金融理论与实践,2007(4):37-39
[131]周乐秀.中小企业资产证券化融资的经济分析.时代经贸,2008(3):24-26
[132]朱怀念,唐棣.试论我国推行不良资产证券化的法律环境.法学评论,2002(5):52-57
[133]祝小兵.资产证券化的基本操作原理.经济导刊,1999(2):40-45
[134]中国人民银行金融市场司编.中国资产证券化:从理论走向实践.北京:中国金融出版社,2006.